Skip to content

"Them With a Heart of Who" (w/ Bobby Finger + Lindsey Weber)

Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang

1h 47m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang welcome fellow podcast hosts and authors Bobby Finger and Lindsey Weber to discuss their pop-culture book exploring the modern binary of celebrities categorized as "thems" versus "who's." The group examines how media landscapes, tabloid origins, and the attention economy shape fame, from the disappearance of the celebrity middle class to the complexities of crossing over from a who into a them. They unpack the paradoxes of public perception, the performative nature of press, and why certain cultural figures like Rita Ora manage to maintain a blissful freedom by bypassing traditional celebrity constraints.

  • Understand the tabloid industry's historical roots and how shame has evolved around celebrity media consumption. 14:57
  • Recognize that becoming a "them" often means being reduced to a single lane in the public eye. 26:01
  • Observe how long-form free-form podcasting serves as a rare space for unscripted celebrity insights. 1:22:50

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Sponsored Ads

    The episode opens with a brief introduction and multiple sponsor messages, setting the tone for the show.

  2. 0:52
    Matt & Bowen’s Banter on Reality TV

    Matt and Bowen riff on the deceptive nature of reality shows and the pitfalls of online platforms, establishing their playful dynamic.

  3. 7:08
    Transition to Guest Segment

    The hosts announce the arrival of guests, signaling a shift from casual banter to a structured interview.

  4. 8:00
    Introduction of Bobby Finger & Lindsey Weber

    Bobby Finger and Lindsey Weber join the conversation, bringing fresh perspectives on identity and fame.

  5. 12:00
    Exploring the ‘Them’ vs. ‘Who’ Framework

    The group delves into the cultural taxonomy of ‘them’ and ‘who’, discussing how celebrities navigate these identities.

  6. 18:00
    Case Studies: Meghan Markle and Celebrity Trajectories

    They analyze Meghan Markle’s rise and the broader shift from cover stars to ‘them’ status in modern media.

  7. 25:00
    Closing Reflections on Fame and Authenticity

    The episode concludes with musings on the balance between public persona and personal authenticity in the age of social media.

  8. 38:43
    Rita Ora as the Ultimate ‘Them’ Example

    The hosts celebrate Rita Ora’s career, illustrating the pinnacle of being a ‘them’ with a heart of ‘who’ and its cultural impact.

  9. 45:11
    Podcast Origins and Early Challenges

    Matt and Bowen discuss how they launched their podcast in 2016 amid a crowded market, reflecting on initial doubts and the evolution of their brand.

  10. 46:02
    Book Release and Cultural Coverage

    The hosts talk about the recent book release, its modern references, and the tight timeline for edits, highlighting the importance of staying current.

  11. 48:00
    Podcast Growth and Media Expansion

    Matt and Bowen reflect on how their podcast grew from niche to mainstream, the impact of media coverage, and the decision to pivot to video and TV.

  12. 49:44
    Navigating Celebrity Interviews and Guest Selection

    The conversation shifts to the challenges of booking high-profile guests, maintaining authenticity, and the importance of cultural relevance in interviews.

  13. 59:35
    Advertising Segments and Product Placement

    A series of ad reads for Depop, Venmo, Wayfair, and Virgin Voyages are interspersed, showcasing the show's sponsorship strategy.

  14. 1:02:18
    Wayfair Home‑Shopping Segment

    Matt and Bowen showcase Wayfair products, sharing personal picks and tips for home décor.

  15. 1:10:38
    Cultural Reflections and Personal Stories

    Matt and Bowen share personal anecdotes about influential pop culture moments, from Waterworld to Jennifer Garner, illustrating how media shapes identity.

Highlights

  • 9:10

    Defining Thems And Who'sstrategy

    Bobby Finger and Lindsey Weber explain their celebrity taxonomy using a 2001 Hudson News grocery store metaphor, where recognizable cover stars are thems and unfamiliar prominent figures are who's.

  • 12:50

    Unintended Tabloid Headlinesstory

    Matt Rogers shares the embarrassment of a casual podcast remark about an audition for a movie getting turned into a sensational People Magazine headline.

  • 14:09

    The Death of the Entertainment Middle Classinsight

    Bowen Yang points out that the binary index of thems and who's reflects the vanishing middle class in the entertainment industry.

  • 1:04:01

    Rita Ora as the Ultimate Whoinsight

    The guests celebrate Rita Ora as the patron saint of their podcast, praising her ability to enjoy a prolific career while completely ignoring the traps of modern fame.

  • 1:09:39

    Waterworld Box Office Origin Storystory

    Bobby Finger explains how his childhood obsession with the financial logistics and budget of the film Waterworld sparked his lifelong media criticism habits.

Quotes

  • “Hotels.com, it's all in the name.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:44
  • “The only thing better is being a them with a heart of who.”
    Unnamed speaker · 13:55
  • “If you have a heart of who, I think that that's like, still very.”
    Unnamed speaker · 14:03
  • “People have to have a preconceived notion of who you are.”
    Unnamed speaker · 32:24
  • “The moment you are a them, it's sort of like this weird paradox, because then you are reduced to like one thing.”
    Unnamed speaker · 38:21
  • “And now it's like, you get a sense that there's like a little bit of paralysis in there, which she is like, really sort of like,”
    Unnamed speaker · 45:14
  • “We have a TV show now. That's, that's, that's what it is.”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:10
  • “We don't have to be fastidious about the way food is presented unless you're at this gorgeously curated dining experience.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:38:30
  • “The best thing about writing a book about celebrities is that the people we talk about, I hope that maybe some of them will read it and be like, useful.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:36:55
  • ViiV Healthcare 0:04–0:25
  • ViiV Healthcare 26:27–28:14
  • Depop 59:40–1:00:32
  • ViiV Healthcare 1:00:33–1:01:28
  • Wayfair 1:02:18–1:03:40
  • Virgin Voyages 1:03:46–1:04:49
  • ViiV Healthcare 1:29:45–1:30:35
  • Venmo 1:30:14–1:31:23
  • Wayfair 1:31:30–1:32:47
  • Virgin Voyages 1:32:58–1:33:55
  • Matt Rogers 2:02:03–2:02:09
  • ViiV Healthcare 2:02:29–2:02:51
  • O'Reilly Veriscan 2:03:00–2:03:13

About this episode

Who? Them? With us? Yes! It’s the podcasting event of the century for a very specific type of person as the hosts of the iconic and hilarious Who Weekly? — Bobby Finger and Lindsey Weber — finally join Matt + Bowen to talk about their fantastic new book I Want To Be Famous: When Everybody and Nobody is a Celebrity. The group discuss what it feels like to have started their podcasting at the same time ten years ago and arrive wherever we all are now, the concept of “Who-dom” and “Them-dom” and why both are important in a pop culture eco-system, and Rita Ora. Also, VH1, “I Love the 80’s” and its equally formative spinoffs, and Lacey Chabert. All this, Waterworld, the Girls revival, and Bethenny Frankel. You MUST get this book. Reader? We mean it. Xo! See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
1:47:28

25,092 words · 7 speakers

Topics

  • Quince
  • Hotels.com

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated