Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the complicated and sometimes unsettling realities of secret identities through three distinct stories. The program begins at a California roadside attraction where a giant Paul Bunyan statue hides a physical space inside its torso where operators talk to visitors. Next, the show examines the strange case of a young man who convinced a group of robbers they were working undercover for the government, driven by a rare psychological condition called delusional disorder. Finally, the episode looks at a high school mascot who uses a tiger costume to shed her shyness and find confidence, alongside a report on a vigilante in Juarez targeting bus drivers amid systemic violence.
- Delusional disorder features beliefs that are entirely plausible, unlike the more fantastic hallucinations associated with schizophrenia. 20:56
- The only workable approach to managing delusional disorder in relationships often involves a compromise where the person accepts the delusion's practical limits without agreeing it is false. 29:20
- A costume or alter ego can allow someone to overcome intense personal shyness and perform actions they could never do as themselves. 43:13
- Decades of unsolved violence against women in Juarez created an environment where some residents expressed tacit support for a vigilante killer. 50:05
Chapters
- 0:00Ad Read: Midi Health Hormonal Care
An introductory ad promoting Midi Health’s virtual hormonal care services.
- 0:55Behind the Mask of Paul Bunyan
Ira discovers the secret behind the statue’s voice and the family running the attraction.
- 4:59Inside Paul Bunyan’s Body
Ira explores the hidden mechanical interior of the statue, revealing its hydraulic systems.
- 8:34Act One: Secret Identities Explained
Ira introduces the theme of secret identities and previews the episode’s segments.
- 19:37Delusional Disorder and Josh Brady
Exploration of Josh Brady’s mental illness and how it led to a fabricated covert operation.
- 33:25Act Two: Navy the Mascot
The life of Navy Baker, a high school mascot who balances her secret identity with everyday school life.
- 44:31Act Three: The Blonde Avenger of Juárez
A harrowing account of women in Juárez seeking vengeance against bus drivers, highlighting systemic injustice.
- 56:42Bus Description and Condition
The narrator describes the noisy, old buses that are clean yet decaying.
- 57:40Myth of Diana the Hunter
The story of Diana the Hunter, a goddess associated with women and childbirth, and her connection to the shootings.
- 58:41Commissioning Bus Artwork
Yuri Herrera commissions artwork of Diana the Hunter for the bus, involving artist Alice Leora Briggs.
- 59:21Production Credits and Thanks
The hosts list the production team, research helpers, and special thanks for the episode.
- 1:00:04Sponsor Ad – Rosetta Stone
A commercial for Rosetta Stone’s new Sapphire app, highlighting its language learning approach.
Highlights
- 2:30
Paul Bunyan's Fuzzy Employment Statusinsight
The owner of Trees of Mystery explains that Paul Bunyan has a fuzzy employment status because he is too big to control and occasionally steps on cars.
- 5:34
Inside Paul Bunyan's Torsostory
The host climbs inside the Paul Bunyan statue and discovers an eight-to-ten-foot oval space with soundproofing tiles, pressure gauges, and a sink.
- 11:45
Recruited for Fake Government Operationsstory
A 21-year-old worker gets a text message from an old friend offering twenty-five thousand dollars to rob banks as part of a government security test.
- 20:44
Plausibility of Delusional Disorderinsight
A court psychologist explains that unlike schizophrenia, delusional disorder involves false beliefs that could actually happen in real life.
- 38:10
Secret Mascot Transforms Into Performerstory
An eighth-grade girl sneaks into a football game in a tiger costume and instantly transforms into an energetic, swaggering crowd favorite.
- 41:59
Costume Enables Physical Capabilitiesinsight
Out of costume, a teenager is unable to perform a cartwheel, but inside the tiger suit, she executes one easily because her face is hidden.
- 46:47
Vigilante Targets Bus Driversdata
An email to a news website signed by Diana claims responsibility for murdering bus drivers in Juarez to avenge sexual violence against women.
Quotes
“I have to say, this is better than not knowing.”
Ira Glass · 6:27 “The bottom line, Ira, is that would you pull the mask off Mickey Mouse?”
Unnamed speaker · 3:17 “They are noisy, old buses, reasonably clean but in a state of decay that everyone accepts.”
Unnamed speaker · 56:42 “I wonder if the guy driving my bus was scared at all, nervous.”
Unnamed speaker · 57:00 “Diana the Hunter is the goddess of women and childbirth, who, like many other Roman gods, acts out of basic human feelings, like rage and revenge.”
Unnamed speaker · 57:40 “She’s muscular, strong, holding a bow with her arms stretched back, about to shoot.”
Unnamed speaker · 58:04
Sponsored segments
- Midi Health 0:00–0:15
- Capital One 7:20–8:02
- Avalara Aviator 8:02–8:38
- Capital One 32:15–33:10
- Carvana 32:30–32:44
- Legacy Box 32:44–33:18
- This American Life 1:00:09–1:01:29
- Rosetta Stone 1:02:33–1:02:59
About this episode
A bank robber on an undercover mission. A teenage girl with the powers of a tiger. A vigilante seeking vengeance in Ciudad Juárez. All have secret identities — but not all of them chose those identities for themselves. Start a Life Partners free trial https://thisamericanlife.supercast.com/?coupon=VIDEO?utm_id=lifepartners&utm_source=rss&utm_medium=shownotes to watch our new video, A Night of Stories and Improv. (00:00:00) Prologue: Ira attempts to solve perhaps the most unsolvable mystery at the Trees of Mystery in California: Who is the voice of Paul Bunyan? (7 minutes) (00:07:23) Act One: If you ever think about assuming a secret identity, you may want to take a little time to consider the possible consequences. Jon Ronson tells the tale of a bank robber who absolutely does not take that advice. (22 minutes) (00:31:33) Act Two: Elna Baker shares a story about her teenage cousin, Navey Baker, who maintains a secret identity while being a public figure: she's the school mascot, a tiger, at her high school. (11 minutes) (00:41:28) Act Three: While we were putting together this week's show, we heard about a real-life Avenger with a secret identity in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico. Writer Yuri Herrera lived on the border for several years and spent a lot of time in Juarez. He went back there to see what effect this secret Avenger has had on the city. (13 minutes) Transcripts are available at thisamericanlife.org https://www.thisamericanlife.org/506/transcript / This American Life privacy policy https://www.thisamericanlife.org/page/privacy-policy. / Learn more about sponsor message choices https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices.
Transcript
9,885 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Juarez
- Trees of Mystery
- Gilbert High
- Highway 101
- Redwood Forest
- Sky Trail
- Bus Route 4A
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated