Skip to content

506: Secret Identity

This American Life

Hosted by Ira Glass

1h 2m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the complicated and sometimes unsettling realities of secret identities through three distinct stories. The program begins at a California roadside attraction where a giant Paul Bunyan statue hides a physical space inside its torso where operators talk to visitors. Next, the show examines the strange case of a young man who convinced a group of robbers they were working undercover for the government, driven by a rare psychological condition called delusional disorder. Finally, the episode looks at a high school mascot who uses a tiger costume to shed her shyness and find confidence, alongside a report on a vigilante in Juarez targeting bus drivers amid systemic violence.

  • Delusional disorder features beliefs that are entirely plausible, unlike the more fantastic hallucinations associated with schizophrenia. 20:56
  • The only workable approach to managing delusional disorder in relationships often involves a compromise where the person accepts the delusion's practical limits without agreeing it is false. 29:20
  • A costume or alter ego can allow someone to overcome intense personal shyness and perform actions they could never do as themselves. 43:13
  • Decades of unsolved violence against women in Juarez created an environment where some residents expressed tacit support for a vigilante killer. 50:05

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Ad Read: Midi Health Hormonal Care

    An introductory ad promoting Midi Health’s virtual hormonal care services.

  2. 0:55
    Behind the Mask of Paul Bunyan

    Ira discovers the secret behind the statue’s voice and the family running the attraction.

  3. 4:59
    Inside Paul Bunyan’s Body

    Ira explores the hidden mechanical interior of the statue, revealing its hydraulic systems.

  4. 8:34
    Act One: Secret Identities Explained

    Ira introduces the theme of secret identities and previews the episode’s segments.

  5. 19:37
    Delusional Disorder and Josh Brady

    Exploration of Josh Brady’s mental illness and how it led to a fabricated covert operation.

  6. 33:25
    Act Two: Navy the Mascot

    The life of Navy Baker, a high school mascot who balances her secret identity with everyday school life.

  7. 44:31
    Act Three: The Blonde Avenger of Juárez

    A harrowing account of women in Juárez seeking vengeance against bus drivers, highlighting systemic injustice.

  8. 56:42
    Bus Description and Condition

    The narrator describes the noisy, old buses that are clean yet decaying.

  9. 57:40
    Myth of Diana the Hunter

    The story of Diana the Hunter, a goddess associated with women and childbirth, and her connection to the shootings.

  10. 58:41
    Commissioning Bus Artwork

    Yuri Herrera commissions artwork of Diana the Hunter for the bus, involving artist Alice Leora Briggs.

  11. 59:21
    Production Credits and Thanks

    The hosts list the production team, research helpers, and special thanks for the episode.

  12. 1:00:04
    Sponsor Ad – Rosetta Stone

    A commercial for Rosetta Stone’s new Sapphire app, highlighting its language learning approach.

Highlights

Quotes

  • “I have to say, this is better than not knowing.”
    Ira Glass · 6:27
  • “The bottom line, Ira, is that would you pull the mask off Mickey Mouse?”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:17
  • “They are noisy, old buses, reasonably clean but in a state of decay that everyone accepts.”
    Unnamed speaker · 56:42
  • “I wonder if the guy driving my bus was scared at all, nervous.”
    Unnamed speaker · 57:00
  • “Diana the Hunter is the goddess of women and childbirth, who, like many other Roman gods, acts out of basic human feelings, like rage and revenge.”
    Unnamed speaker · 57:40
  • “She’s muscular, strong, holding a bow with her arms stretched back, about to shoot.”
    Unnamed speaker · 58:04
  • Midi Health 0:00–0:15
  • Capital One 7:20–8:02
  • Avalara Aviator 8:02–8:38
  • Capital One 32:15–33:10
  • Carvana 32:30–32:44
  • Legacy Box 32:44–33:18
  • This American Life 1:00:09–1:01:29
  • Rosetta Stone 1:02:33–1:02:59

About this episode

A bank robber on an undercover mission. A teenage girl with the powers of a tiger. A vigilante seeking vengeance in Ciudad Juárez. All have secret identities — but not all of them chose those identities for themselves. Start a Life Partners free trial https://thisamericanlife.supercast.com/?coupon=VIDEO?utm_id=lifepartners&utm_source=rss&utm_medium=shownotes to watch our new video, A Night of Stories and Improv. (00:00:00) Prologue: Ira attempts to solve perhaps the most unsolvable mystery at the Trees of Mystery in California: Who is the voice of Paul Bunyan? (7 minutes) (00:07:23) Act One: If you ever think about assuming a secret identity, you may want to take a little time to consider the possible consequences. Jon Ronson tells the tale of a bank robber who absolutely does not take that advice. (22 minutes) (00:31:33) Act Two: Elna Baker shares a story about her teenage cousin, Navey Baker, who maintains a secret identity while being a public figure: she's the school mascot, a tiger, at her high school. (11 minutes) (00:41:28) Act Three: While we were putting together this week's show, we heard about a real-life Avenger with a secret identity in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico. Writer Yuri Herrera lived on the border for several years and spent a lot of time in Juarez. He went back there to see what effect this secret Avenger has had on the city. (13 minutes) Transcripts are available at thisamericanlife.org https://www.thisamericanlife.org/506/transcript / This American Life privacy policy https://www.thisamericanlife.org/page/privacy-policy. / Learn more about sponsor message choices https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices.

Transcript

0:00
1:02:07

9,885 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Juarez
  • Trees of Mystery
  • Gilbert High
  • Highway 101
  • Redwood Forest
  • Sky Trail
  • Bus Route 4A

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated