Skip to content

Travelling Back In Time To Kill The Wrong Baby Hitler (with Gianmarco Soresi!) | Prohibition (Part 2)

Fin vs History

59m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the history and cultural fallout of American Prohibition with guest Gianmarco Soresi. The hosts and guest trace how the Volstead Act transformed American nightlife, pushed women into public drinking spaces, birthed jazz and cocktail culture, and inadvertently catalyzed organized crime while failing to stop citizens from drinking. They examine how systemic corruption flourished when enforcement agents went unpaid, and how bootlegging operations paved the way for modern stock car racing. The discussion also touches on presidential hypocrisy, the tragic reality of government-poisoned industrial alcohol, and the chaotic legislative path that ultimately ended the dry era in 1933.

Along the way, the conversation drifts into comedic tangents about musical theatre, bizarre time-travel movie pitches involving Adolf Hitler, and contrasting British and American drinking habits. The hosts argue that Prohibition was driven by a conservative, puritanical minority whose overreach fundamentally altered the nation's relationship with alcohol, leaving a lasting legacy on legal drinking ages and underground economies.

  • Prohibition failed to stop public drinking and instead created a massive underground economy of speakeasies and bootlegging. 12:10
  • The government deliberately added dangerous chemicals to industrial alcohol diverted by bootleggers, resulting in thousands of deaths. 27:05
  • FDR won the 1932 election in a landslide largely by promising to legalize beer. 50:42
  • Illegal moonshine runners modifying cars to outrun the police directly evolved into NASCAR. 52:57

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Ad Read

    The hosts open the episode with a brief introduction and a commercial break from Nordstrom Rack.

  2. 0:47
    Welcome and Guest Introduction

    Fin and Horatio welcome Gianmarco Sarezi, discussing his Italian heritage and musical theatre interests.

  3. 2:01
    Family History and Italian Roots

    Gianmarco shares details about his Sicilian ancestry and family connections to historical figures like Mussolini.

  4. 5:51
    Bootlegging, Moonshining, and Government Response

    The hosts explain bootlegging practices, bathtub gin, and government attempts to poison illicit alcohol.

  5. 11:00
    Closing Remarks and Final Thoughts

    Fin and Horatio wrap up the episode, summarizing key points and teasing future discussions.

  6. 15:50
    Musical Theatre and Cultural Reflection

    The hosts discuss how musical theatre, especially Chicago the Musical, reflects and critiques Prohibition-era society.

  7. 20:19
    Mafia, Organized Crime, and Prohibition

    A deep dive into how Prohibition enabled the rise of organized crime, focusing on figures like Lucky Luciano and Al Capone.

  8. 41:57
    Domestic Violence and Social Consequences

    The conversation turns to the effects of Prohibition on domestic violence, flappers, and moral reformers.

  9. 43:01
    Revisiting Prohibition’s Moral Debate

    The hosts reflect on how prohibition was framed as a moral victory rather than a legal enforcement issue.

  10. 46:59
    Cultural Legacy of the 21‑Year Drinking Age

    The conversation turns to how prohibition shaped the modern legal drinking age and its cultural implications.

  11. 50:03
    Prohibition’s Economic Impact and the Great Depression

    Discussion on how prohibition’s failure led to economic pressures that ultimately influenced its repeal during the Depression.

  12. 50:50
    The Rise of NASCAR from Moonshine

    Exploration of how illegal moonshining during prohibition evolved into the sport of NASCAR.

Highlights

  • 1:56

    Family ties to Mussolinistory

    Gianmarco shares that his great-grandfather Luigi Soresi managed a boxer and has photographs dining with Benito Mussolini.

  • 5:51

    The birth of modern nightlifeinsight

    The hosts explain how Prohibition destroyed traditional male-only saloons, unintentionally bringing women and jazz music into underground nightlife.

  • 27:05

    Government poisoning civiliansdata

    The panel discusses how the U.S. government poisoned industrial alcohol to deter consumption, leading to the deaths of roughly 10,000 people.

  • 37:55

    St. Valentine's Day massacrestory

    Al Capone's gang eliminated rivals by dressing as police officers during a supposed alcohol deal in a Chicago garage.

  • 40:00

    A bootlegger pleads insanitystory

    George Remus, a massively successful bootlegger, caught his wife having an affair with an agent, shot her, and successfully defended himself in court.

  • 50:42

    FDR legalizes beerstrategy

    Franklin D. Roosevelt secured a landslide presidential victory in 1932 by campaigning heavily on the promise to legalize beer.

  • 52:57

    The origins of NASCARinsight

    Stock car racing originated from bootleggers modifying standard vehicles to outrun law enforcement while transporting illegal Canadian whiskey.

Quotes

  • “The wheel had roads. Electricity had the grid. Innovation needs infrastructure.”
    Unnamed speaker · 11:49
  • “Prohibition was, was invented, because to stop that.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:57
  • “The unintended consequence of banning alcohol is to create this huge underground economy and a nightlife.”
    Unnamed speaker · 16:14
  • “So they're making bathtub gin. It's called moon shining because people would make it under the cover of the moonlight, uh, in night.”
    Unnamed speaker · 26:30
  • “I would have been a moralizer. I would have been drinking moralizer.”
    Unnamed speaker · 43:17
  • “The thing, the thing about this though is that once, when everyone realizes it's not enforced, cause again, it's not a moral victory.”
    Unnamed speaker · 43:41
  • “The sales for non-alcoholic drinks, it's, it's huge.”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:00
  • “This is my favorite thing about the whole story, is that FDR wins the 1932 election and his main policy is, I will legalize beer.”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:37
  • “NASCAR is started by people driving whisky from Canada illegally.”
    Unnamed speaker · 52:57
  • Nordstrom Rack 0:00–0:16
  • Plaid 0:23–0:31
  • Nordstrom Rack 11:24–11:29
  • Surfshark 12:31–12:51
  • Plaid 29:34–30:17

About this episode

.. with Gianmarco Soresi! Let’s talk about the birth of modern nightlife. Prohibition (Part 2) The show for people who like history but don't care what actually happened. For weekly bonus episodes, ad-free listening and early access to series, become a Truther and sign up to the Patreon ⁠patreon.com/fintaylor This episode of Fin vs History is brought to you by Surfshark. Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code FVH for an extra 4 months at surfshark.com/fvh Chapters: 00:00 - Mussolini The Musical 03:38 - The Wrong Hitler 10:58 - 10 Gooning Street 14:39 - Click Or Snap? 19:05 - Interactive Theatre Experiences 28:03 - Gays Drive Nightlife? 30:04 - Everybody Becomes Cool 34:32 - What A Shame 37:34 - Men’s Mental Health 42:35 - The Sandro Introduction 47:48 - Really Andy? 50:01 - Sparkly McGee Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
59:48

12,315 words · 7 speakers

Topics

  • NASCAR
  • Chicago the Musical
  • Vince
  • Kohan
  • Hunter
  • Ugg
  • Volstead Act
  • Cullen Harrison Act
  • Magna Carta
  • Bill of Rights

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated