Skip to content

Stalingrad Of The Adriatic: The Gully (Part 3)

WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk

1h 0m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode of We Have Ways of Making You Talk covers the grueling battle for The Gully and the advance toward Ortona on the Italian front in December 1943. Hosts Al Murray and James Holland detail the relentless attrition faced by Allied infantry, particularly Canadian units fighting through horrific winter weather, mud, and entrenched German defenses. Through personal accounts from soldiers like Lieutenant Farley Moat and German corporal Werner Mork, the podcast illustrates the psychological toll of static warfare, incessant shelling, and tactical deadlocks.

Throughout the episode, the hosts examine the high-level command decisions driving the carnage, contrasting the aggressive pushes ordered by Allied commanders like General Chris Vokes with the rigid, micromanaged defense dictated by Hitler and executed by generals like Jörg Lemelson. Despite staggering casualties and units being reduced to fractions of their original strength, both sides are compelled to keep fighting. The episode highlights the grim reality of the Italian campaign, where strategic goals were overshadowed by relentless grinding combat and mounting human cost.

  • Keep infantry units from being completely decimated by rotating troops out of the front line, maintaining a 10% reserve. 40:10
  • Conduct thorough reconnaissance and patrolling before launching attacks to avoid running into unknown machine gun nests. 36:46
  • Recognize that severe combat stress and psychological breaking points are common among soldiers subjected to intense artillery barrages. 10:39

Chapters

  1. 0:02
    Podcast Intro and Advertisements

    Hosts introduce the episode and run a brief commercial break.

  2. 2:29
    Setting the Stage: The Gully and Ortona

    Hosts explain the strategic context of the Gully and the approach to Ortona.

  3. 3:43
    Farley Moat’s Descent into the Meat Grinder

    Moat’s nervousness and the brutal reality of infantry combat are highlighted.

  4. 4:23
    The Bridgehead and Counterattacks

    The Hasty Peas hold a fragile bridgehead while facing repeated German counterattacks.

  5. 15:00
    The Gully’s Geography and Defensive Advantage

    The unique terrain of the Gully gives German defenders a strong defensive position.

  6. 26:43
    German Command and the Loss of Initiative

    German leadership struggles under Hitler’s micromanagement, leading to costly attrition.

  7. 30:00
    Allied Assaults and Attritional Stalemate

    Allied forces launch multiple attacks, suffering heavy casualties while slowly advancing.

  8. 40:00
    The Final Push to Cider Crossroads

    After weeks of fighting, the Allies finally capture the key crossroads at the end of the Gully.

  9. 47:49
    Debriefing the 90th Panzer Grenadier

    Discussion of the 90th Panzer Grenadier’s dissolution and replacement by the 65th Infantry, highlighting war diary entries and the challenges of maintaining force cohesion.

  10. 48:29
    Strategic Motives Behind German Counter‑Thrusts

    Analysis of Lemelson’s planned counter‑thrust in the Autona sector, the use of small units, and the unrealistic expectations of German commanders.

  11. 49:11
    Assessing German Training and Manpower Shortages

    Examination of the rapid training of German troops, the reliance on teenagers and foreign conscripts, and the impact on combat effectiveness in Italy.

  12. 52:02
    Survival Story of Werner Mork

    Narrative of Mork’s escape from a foxhole, his stealthy escape, and eventual return to friendly lines.

Highlights

  • 6:47

    Pigs feeding on battle corpsesstory

    Lieutenant Farley Moat observes two huge pigs eating the bloated corpse of a mule from his battalion headquarters, capturing the grim desolation of the battlefield.

  • 10:39

    A soldier breaks in the mudstory

    After a salvo of shells crashes nearby, Farley Moat falls in the mud and suffers a psychological break, turning back and running away from the front line.

  • 20:57

    Agony of a dying soldierstory

    German corporal Werner Mork and his comrades listen to the prolonged, agonizing screams of a popular NCO with a severe stomach wound who cannot be rescued during daylight.

  • 29:06

    Catastrophic unit casualty ratesdata

    Units suffering 30 to 35 percent casualties are typically considered inoperable, yet units in this sector are operating at only 10 to 20 percent strength.

  • 41:24

    Heavy tank losses in New Zealand attackdata

    The New Zealand 21st Battalion suffers 40 percent casualties and loses 25 tanks knocked out in just a single day of fighting at Orsonia.

  • 52:07

    Insane German counter-thrust plansinsight

    With German divisions virtually annihilated and lacking air power or adequate forces, General Lemelson issues orders for an absurd counter-thrust.

Quotes

  • “The wheel was brilliant, but the road made it iconic. Electricity was powerful, but the grid brought it to every home.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:06
  • “It's a meat grinder. If you're in the situation that the British find, the Allies find themselves in, if you can't use all your elements, if you can't, if the weather doesn't play ball, you can't bring all your fantastic elements to bear that you have at your disposal, things are difficult.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:51
  • “The Germans are predisposed to always counterattack. So you do have opportunities to wear them down. It's not just sort of, you know, hurling over shells and mortars and hoping one will land in a foxhole.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:05
  • “The advantage of defending is you haven't got, you really haven't got, you've got to divide up what you're gonna do, but you haven't got to decide where, what, decide, make, take the initiative, right? But that does mean you have to sit there and wait.”
    Unnamed speaker · 24:10
  • “And this goes back to what we were saying earlier on about Lemelson and Kasserang and, uh, and so on.”
    Unnamed speaker · 47:49
  • “But, but, but also the 1st Falschmäger have become the kind of, you know, the go-to, the elites in inverted commas, the kind of”
    Unnamed speaker · 48:29
  • “People are being brought, brought forward much, much quicker.”
    Unnamed speaker · 49:23
  • “And by men like Lemelson, you know.”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:49
  • “And they decide, actually, they are going to make a run for it, but they figure out their chances would be better if they, if they each try alone.”
    Unnamed speaker · 57:44
  • Patreon 0:02–0:19
  • Apple Sports 0:24–0:46
  • Nordstrom Rack 0:48–1:05
  • Plaid 1:18–2:14
  • Nordstrom Rack 25:00–25:33
  • Plaid 25:41–25:54
  • Stonefire Naan 25:47–26:07
  • Patreon 59:23–59:57
  • Plaid 1:00:21–1:00:34
  • Gates Foundation 1:01:10–1:01:33

About this episode

What was the reaction of Nazi leadership to Allied attacks at Ortona? Why did Germans always counter-attack? When did Kesselring take full control of German forces in Italy? Join James Holland and Al Murray for part 3, as they explore the terrible Italian battle known as the 'Stalingrad Of The Adriatic'. Start your free trial at ⁠patreon.com/wehaveways⁠ and unlock exclusive content and more. Enjoy livestreams, early access, ad-free listening, bonus episodes, and a weekly newsletter packed with book deals and behind-the-scenes insights. Get your WHW Merch here! A Goalhanger Production Produced by James Regan Editor: Oli Ortega Assistant Producer: Alfie Norris Exec Producer: Tony Pastor Social: @WeHaveWaysPod Social Producer: Harry Balden Email: [email protected] Membership Club: patreon.com/wehaveways Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
1:00:29

11,708 words · 7 speakers

Topics

  • Italy
  • Stonefire
  • Autona
  • Rome
  • AI
  • Orsonia
  • Adriatic
  • Pescara
  • Hermann Göring division
  • Balkans

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated