08 Lies in Lismore | BONUS Inquest insider speaks
- 17m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This bonus episode of Lies in Lismore features host Richard Baker interviewing Philip Strickland, the counsel assisting the 2024 coronial inquest into the killing of Simone Strobel. They examine why the 2007 and 2024 inquests reached starkly different conclusions despite examining much of the same core evidence. Strickland explains how Tobias Moran's early falsehoods about drug use, alcohol, and relationship conflict distorted the original police investigation and created tunnel vision. They also discuss the challenges of interpreting lies in criminal cases, the impact of the findings on the Strobel family, and the inadequate early forensic investigation into alternative suspects.
- Investigators must distinguish between credibility lies and consciousness of guilt lies before assuming a suspect's dishonesty proves homicide. 5:05
- Coroners rely heavily on the evidence and assistance provided by counsel assisting teams, which can shape final findings. 9:21
- Unmatched DNA profiles and hair samples left on physical evidence like Simone Strobel's black top and barbed wire remain potential clues. 11:51
- Anyone with information about the killing should contact Crime Stoppers to help provide answers for the victim's family. 14:56
Chapters
- 0:01Podcast Introduction and Host Overview
The episode opens with the host introducing the podcast and setting the context for the bonus interview.
- 0:38Introduction to Philip Strickland and the Simone Strobel Inquest
The host welcomes Philip Strickland and explains his role as counsel assisting in the 2024 inquest.
- 2:12Comparing the 2007 and 2024 Inquests
The discussion turns to why two inquests reached different conclusions despite similar evidence.
- 7:23Family Reactions and Counsel Responsibilities
The host asks about the emotional toll on the victim’s family and how Philip balanced duty with empathy.
- 8:55Oversights in the First Inquest and Police Investigation
Philip admits there were oversights and limited exploration of other suspects in the initial inquiry.
- 13:12Forensic Evidence and Unsolved Clues
The conversation focuses on remaining forensic leads and their potential to solve the case.
- 14:44Closing Remarks and Call to Action
The host thanks Philip, encourages listeners to contact Crime Stoppers, and provides additional context about the inquest process.
Highlights
- 2:12
Conflicting Inquest Conclusions Explainedinsight
The guest explains that while both the 2007 and 2024 inquests reviewed similar evidence, different interpretations of Tobias Moran's lies led to contrasting views on the case.
- 4:44
Distorted Police Investigationinsight
The guest argues that Tobias Moran's unwise lies caused police to focus heavily on him to the potential exclusion of other viable suspects.
- 5:05
Two Types of Criminal Liesstrategy
The guest breaks down the critical legal distinction between lies told to damage credibility versus consciousness of guilt lies meant to conceal a crime.
- 7:23
Balancing Family Distress and Evidencestory
The guest reflects on the difficulty of reaching findings that upset the victim's family, stressing that barristers must follow the evidence rather than shape outcomes for families.
- 9:21
The Role of Coroners and Counselinsight
The guest notes that a coroner's ultimate findings depend heavily on the evidence presented and the assistance provided by the legal team.
- 11:51
Unmatched Forensic Evidencedata
The guest highlights that unknown male DNA on Simone Strobel's black top and hair samples near a fence were never matched to anyone in the investigation.
- 12:11
Validity of Tunnel Vision Claimdebate
The guest agrees that Tobias Moran's claim of police tunnel vision has validity due to the lack of early, thorough investigation into other suspects.
Quotes
“I think one of the answers is that people do look at evidence, people interpret evidence differently all the time.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:49 “You can use a lie basically in two ways.”
Unnamed speaker · 5:11 “And I think that there wasn't adequate attention given to other suspects.”
Unnamed speaker · 10:31 “I don't think even at the second inquest, all the information that people know was revealed.”
Unnamed speaker · 13:41
About this episode
Key inquest lawyer says other suspects weren't adequately investigated by police. Philip Strickland SC acted as counsel assisting the coroner for the recent inquest into the death of Simone Strobel. He tells Richard Baker that there's "some validity" to Tobias Moran's claim that police got tunnel vision. He says the "extremely unwise" lies told by Tobias Moran distorted the investigation. Credits Host and reporter: Richard BakerProducer and fact checker: Romy SherSupervising producer: Alicia BridgesSpecial thanks: Chiara Holzhaeuser; Joanne Shoebridge and everyone at ABC North CoastAdditional reporting: Cath AdamsTheme composition and additional music: Martin Peralta and Ashley CadellSound design: Tim SymondsExecutive Producers: Tim Roxburgh, Eric GeorgeHead of Audio on Demand: Jessica Radburn
Transcript
2,313 words · 5 speakers
Topics
- ABC Listen
- New South Wales
- Sydney
- Cairns
- Canberra
- New South Wales Coroner's Court
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated