Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Tia Levings Escaped A Trad Wife Cult About this episode Tia Levings was raised within the same strict Christian fundamentalist ideology as the infamous Duggar family from 19 Kids And Counting. By the time she was 19 years old, Tia found herself in an abusive marriage where the violence was sanctioned by the church.
In this must-listen episode of No Filter, Tia tells Mia Freedman about the ways she was groomed to be a Trad Wife, and the moment she knew she had to run for her life. This is a story of indoctrination and survival, of reinvention and strength…but it is also about the thousands of other women who haven’t escaped the Trad Wife movement, and the new ones who are joining every day.
You can hear the second half of Mia's conversation with Tia here. https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/no-filter/tia-levings-part-two/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=nofilter
You can find out more about Tia and her book, A Well Trained Wife, here https://tialevings.com/.
You can follow her on Instagram here. https://www.instagram.com/tialevingswriter/?hl=en
And if you need to talk to someone, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.
THE END BITS:
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=nofilter
Listen to more No Filter interviews here https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/no-filter/ and follow us on Instagram here. https://www.instagram.com/nofiltermamamia/
Discovermore Mamamia podcasts here https://www.mamamia.com.au/podcasts/.
Feedback: [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
Share your story, feedback, or dilemma! Send us a voice message https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960, and one of our Podcast Producers will come back to you ASAP.
Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review.
CREDITS:
Host: Mia Freedman
You can find Mia onInstagram here https://www.instagram.com/miafreedman/?hl=en and get hernewsletter here. https://miafreedman.substack.com/
Executive Producer: Naima Brown
Audio Producer: Leah PorgesMamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on. Hey, I'm Gemma Buff, host of True Crime Conversations. And did you know that the team at Mamma Mia is bringing you over 100 hours of the best content from your award winning podcasts for the hot pod summer of your dreams? Well, we are. Here at True Crime Conversations, we've handpicked some of the most chilling and thought provoking episodes from our feed, including gripping cult stories, powerful interviews with crime victims, and in-depth accounts from women who have been incarcerated, sharing the journeys that led them to that place. And that's just the beginning. Today, I'm bringing you the story of Tia Levings from No Filter, another amazing podcast on the Mamma Mia network hosted by Mia Freedman.
0:50 Speaker 01 In this episode, Mia chats with Tia, who grew up in a strict Christian fundamentalist community. By the time she was 19, she found herself in an abusive marriage, with the violence actually being supported by the church. Here's the original episode. Have a listen and we'd love to hear what you think.
1:08 Speaker 02 I heard a voice in my head, in my mind, in my heart that said, run. And he had gone to his office to get his gun. So if I had stayed, we wouldn't be having this conversation right now. And we drove away.
1:20 Speaker 01 From Mamma Mia, you're listening to No Filter and I'm Mia Freedman.
1:26 Speaker 01 When I was a teenage girl, I was kissing boys and dating and I was hanging with my friends. I was working at Woolies and I was desperately trying to get a fake ID so that I could sneak into clubs. All the usual teenage behaviour. But I was also dreaming about my future, thinking about who I wanted to be when I grew up, what I wanted to do, what adventures I wanted to have out in the world when I left school.
1:50 Speaker 03 When Tia Levings was a teenage girl, she was preparing to serve a husband that she hadn't even met yet. Because Tia was brought up as a Christian fundamentalist, where being a trad wife was the only option for girls. A marriage with strict, old fashioned gender roles, where the man was the boss and the woman served him. And that's exactly what she did. Around the time Tia got married, in the early 2000s, the whole trad wife lifestyle, although it wasn't called that then, it was being glorified on TV around the world by a show called 19 Kids and Counting. You might remember it. It was about the Duggar family, the parents, Michelle and Jim Bob. They were also Christian fundamentalists like Tia and the community where she grew up.
2:35 Speaker 03 They wore old fashioned clothes and they chopped their own wood and they home schooled all their children. They had so many children. It was kind of fascinating to watch. But what we've since learned is that there were some really dark things going on in that house, among the Duggars, and Tia experienced similar things in her own trad wife marriage. She barely escaped from that marriage with her life. She had to grab her children and flee in the middle of the night. Tia's story is a story about survival, indoctrination, fundamentalism, but it's also a story about marketing and how trad wives aren't just a quirky trend on Instagram or a funny reality show.
3:19 Speaker 03 This is why Tia has written a book about her trad life and why she wants you to hear her story as the former trad wife who got away.
3:29 Speaker 03 Tia, welcome.
3:30 Speaker 02 Thank you so much for having me.
3:32 Speaker 03 You start your story in 1984 when your family moved from Michigan to Florida. Talk to me about your early years and the way that your family changed when you made that move to Florida.
3:44 Speaker 02 When I was 10, we moved to Jacksonville, Florida, and my parents wanted to give us a good childhood, a protected childhood, a happy one. And in Jacksonville, the message was all over the city that the best way to do that was to join the biggest church in town. So it was a Southern Baptist megachurch. We had 3,500 members at that time, and then it quickly grew to 10,000 and then 20,000. And by the time I graduated high school, our sanctuary sat over 10,000 people. I was there six days a week. It was a lot of fun. I would not have pointed to a lot of it as being particularly traumatic or problematic. I was being systematically groomed and conditioned to self-subjugate and self-gaslight and cooperate
4:26 Speaker 02 with an authoritarian model. But I didn't know that. I knew that I was just having this Christian evangelical experience that had a lot of money and privilege attached to it, and I didn't know any different. I talk about this sometimes, like a culture within a culture, and it's based on the verse in the Bible that says, be in the world, but not of it. And so we really were practicing a parallel Christian culture in the world, but not engaging with the world, not informing our worldviews, not growing into adults. We were growing to prepare to be Christian wives and mothers, and that is all. That was my second 10 years. I got married at 19.
5:05 Speaker 03 You call it a cult without walls?
5:07 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
5:08 Speaker 03 Which is really interesting, because by that, I assume you mean it's hiding in plain sight. You talked about it's a megachurch, so it's not just like a fringe few kind of people meeting in a basement. It is like literally tens of thousands of people.
5:25 Speaker 02 Yes.
5:26 Speaker 03 What is the IBLP? Is it Gothard or Gotard?
5:29 Speaker 02 Well, Gothard is how we say it, but it's spelled Gotard, which is just so funny to me. Bill Gothard started the Institute of Basic Life Principles, the IBLP for short. There's a headquarters in Australia, there's a headquarters in America. His model of growth crossed denominational lines in that he taught biblical principles. So Christians from churches all over would come, and then they would be sent back out to their churches to To proselytize within their congregations for this stricter form of Christianity. If you're familiar with the Duggar family on TLC's Nineteen Kids and Counting, that's the most visible family of the Gothard system. I was in Shiny Happy People last year and that did a big expose on the IBLP
6:12 Speaker 02 and how it works and how it has gone into, because of its agenda, it's gone into every branch of government and the entire evangelical movement. That's why I call it the cult without walls because we were part of this high control group with very strict criteria that meets all of the cult definition, but it doesn't have a building. And so people identify with cults as like it's a place you go and it's a single person you follow. And that is not how high control religion works. I believe it does meet all of the cult criteria. And if you listen to survivors, you hear from multiple backgrounds, all kinds of different evangelical sects and denominations with very similar experiences.
6:54 Speaker 03 What's the role of the Duggars in the IBLP and Gothard, you know, as the leader of that church?
7:02 Speaker 02 They were kind of reputation ambassadors. They had some influence and sway, but they were one of the star families because of the number of children that they had and their high visibility and their political involvement. But really their role was lifestyle evangelism. So their purpose was to show the world what a great lifestyle this is so that people will feel attracted to it and choose it. And it worked in a big influential way in America. Plenty of people watched that show just to watch the car accident and the crazies. But plenty more thought it was an enviable way to live. And the trad lifestyle that we find ourselves in today is in large part influenced by fundamentalism on TV.
7:43 Speaker 03 So while you were preparing for womanhood, talk to me about your teenage years and what influence the IBLP and Gothard had on you.
7:52 Speaker 02 So it was an invisible influence for me in my high school years because I didn't know about him. His people were around me and I was observing them and I was learning all their special rules. And I was observing that there was this way in our church to be a special kind of Christian, a holier Christian, somebody who was more devout and more sold out and serious in their faith. And that it had a lifestyle projection in that they wore different clothes and they had lots of children and they decided to homeschool their children. And so we had a lot of respect and reverence for them. Not everyone wanted to live that way, but it seemed very much like an option you could take. It wasn't a serious pursuit of mine until I was married and very quickly a young mother. And I was in abuse and I needed to keep my baby quiet at night.
8:36 Speaker 02 And I turned to an older mother in that system to teach me how to help my baby sleep, but also keep the home. It's called keepers of the home. And so I wanted to be a godly Proverbs 31 woman and be good, you know, what I was trying to be, which was just a Christian wife and mother.
8:53 Speaker 03 You talk about in your book that at 14, when most young girls are at the mall and shopping and maybe getting on Instagram and posting selfies, your job was to prepare at age 14 to be a Christian wife and mother within the church. What did that preparation actually look like?
9:13 Speaker 02 Oh, that's a great question because we weren't actually preparing to be wives. And if they had been teaching us, here's what you might practically face as a wife, I might have had some more tools under my belt. Instead, it was looked like a lot of what you don't do. Very heavily focused on purity culture and remaining a virgin, not tempting men.
9:33 Speaker 03 What's purity culture for someone who's not familiar with purity culture?
9:37 Speaker 02 Purity culture is an entire culture that's built around keeping you sexually pure. So it includes modesty so that you're learning how to dress in a very modest manner that won't tempt men. It also includes your behavior, your speech, being modest in all ways. We call it purity culture here because this is the idea that your behavior can make you impure and that you're trying to stay pure so that you can be an undefiled bride for your husband.
10:05 Speaker 03 I want to ask about modesty because What does modesty actually mean in this context? Because for most people, modesty means you don't go around perhaps big noting yourself, you have humility. But that's not what this kind of modesty in religious fundamentalism means. Can you explain what it is?
10:24 Speaker 02 That's the big irony is that modesty, especially in scriptures, has a lot to do with your bearing and behaviour. But what it's become in evangelical culture is a hyper fixation on the length of a girl's skirt and whether or not her bra strap is showing. Or Bill Gothard has a teaching called eye traps. So these are the way clothing is designed to draw your eye to, say, a slender waistline or cleavage, or something that might attract a man's attention. And that is ruled as immodest clothing. Your behaviour can be immodest in that you can be loud or laugh too loud, stand out in any way, you know, that can become a thing, but it's all external.
11:03 Speaker 03 Is it about sexuality? Because it's at an age, you know, a 14 year old girl, she's growing breasts, she's menstruating, she's suddenly aware that men are looking at her in a different way. She's maybe feeling hormones, she's maybe feeling things. In fact, she no doubt is all of the things. How were you taught to interpret that? That all of that was dangerous and that it was sinful and that it was your job to protect men from the sin of you?
11:30 Speaker 02 Yes, it's completely internalised. The actual scripture says that if a man lusts, he should pluck his eyes out. It never mentions what the girl is doing. But we flipped it. The evangelical culture flipped it. It was all focused on first how we were dressing and being, but then eventually our very worth was sinful, distracting, dangerous, tempting. I interpreted the things I was feeling as a sexualised young person. Those were my temptations to sin and step out of the will of God. So constantly suppressing any urges or attractions or desires so that I wouldn't feel them. It's very important to not feel them so that you can remain pure. And then it's supposed to magically turn on when you're married, which we know now it doesn't for a lot of women.
12:15 Speaker 02 Sexual dysfunction is very, very High because our nervous system does not acclimate that way. That's not how the human body works.
12:22 Speaker 03 Did you have sex before your wedding at nineteen?
12:24 Speaker 02 I had an early sexual assault when I was thirteen that I interpreted as maybe my first kiss. I wasn't really sure. I didn't have anybody to talk to about that. And I had one kiss with a boyfriend otherwise, but no, did not have any real experience before my wedding night.
12:41 Speaker 03 After this break, Tia gets married at nineteen and her life is about to change dramatically. And then she realizes she was in danger really from the first night of that marriage.
13:02 Speaker 03 How did you meet your husband?
13:03 Speaker 02 Yeah, so this big mega church I go to or went to is Jacksonville's a port city. So we have a naval port and he was a sailor that came in on a ship and attended our Navy ministry. We had this big military ministry to reach the sailors for Christ. They come in for, you know, community and to meet girls. So that's what happened. I went to a hayride and he was there and we met at a mixer near Christmas time. About four weeks later, we were engaged. I didn't really know him, but he had decided I was the girl he wanted to marry. And I was in pursuit of a husband at that time. I was very open to this is the only thing I can do with my life is to be a Christian wife and mother. So I need a husband to do that. I was primed and ready to receive whoever said they were God's will for my life.
13:47 Speaker 03 Did having a job or a career ever occur to you? Or was that ever presented to you as a possibility when you were a teenage girl?
13:55 Speaker 02 It's a grief, you know, I share in the book how I learned to split myself. I had dreams and desires and opportunities and talents and I, and I had to learn to suppress them and stuff them down. They were not in accordance with what I was being told was the only acceptable outcome for my life. And I was unbearable to feel the loss of them. So I learned to stuff them away. And there was a season where I tried to, I wanted to be an artist and I, I thought, oh, if I'm an artist for God, I can do it. That's how I'll get through this. And that didn't work because I was chosen for marriage first and it just didn't work.
14:31 Speaker 03 You talk about being chosen. Did you want to marry this guy? Was he nice? Did you like him?
14:36 Speaker 02 I didn't really know him. I did not feel attracted to him. I know in hindsight that if we had given it natural time, you know, to unfold, he would have shown his true character. He had behavior tendencies that were masked, carefully masked under charm, and that charm would have fallen away if we had given it more time, which he knew, and that's why he needed to secure me so quickly. So I was locked in very quickly and did not feel like I really had a choice. By that point, you don't believe you can say no to a man or to God, and they are one and the same.
15:09 Speaker 03 So when he decided that he wanted to marry you, was it an option to say no? Or you were like, yeah, I need a husband. Like, why not?
15:17 Speaker 02 It's a great question because I just feel for little nineteen year old me who
15:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:22 Speaker 02 really didn't spend that much time thinking that. I think I project onto her that she wanted to say no, but I think that she actually didn't spend that much time deliberating. She'd been taught that you were going to say yes, and that's how you're going to know it's right. If you're asked, then you know it's right. And I was very practiced at shutting down my signals, my arguments, any resistance I had, and I instead funneled that energy into talking myself into it.
15:50 Speaker 03 Tell me about your wedding day. Did you like it?
15:53 Speaker 02 It was magical. I did love it. My parents went all out. My mom's a seamstress. She spent so many hours on my dresses and my bridesmaids dresses, and we had a very traditional wedding, and it was near Christmas time the following year. And so it was just, I took advantage of the whole season feeling festive, and we had a horse-drawn carriage, and I had a cape, and it was romantic and candlelit and really beautiful. I mean, it was not smooth and without issue, but I was overwhelmingly really happy, and I felt like I was celebrating this launch into the rest of my life.
16:29 Speaker 03 You say you had a very traditional wedding. Before you walked down the aisle, your dad was like, are you ready? And you said, I can't see.
16:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. My veil was heavy chiffon. I wanted it to drape differently than the bridal tool. Bridal tool is very puffy, and I wanted a romantic drape. So I picked this fabric. It looked gorgeous in photos, and it looked gorgeous by day, but we were standing in candlelight. And so when we flipped it over my head, I couldn't see anything. It was a shrouded woman, and I had to walk the aisle blind.
16:58 Speaker 03 Which was very symbolic, wasn't it?
17:00 Speaker 02 It ended up being quite metaphorical, yes.
17:04 Speaker 03 Your wedding night, what did you know going into it about what was going to happen on your wedding night?
17:10 Speaker 02 I knew that we would have sex. I did not fully understand what sex was. I knew there would be insertion of anatomy and that it would hurt, but that it would be romantic and loving and God-designed, and so it would be okay, that I would be held in caress and cared for. We had a book by Ed Wheat, it was called Intended for Pleasure. And then also, like, this is what they tell young fiancés. We had been in an engaged class and had premarital counselling through the church. And so there was no real sex education or instruction or transparency, but they did, you know, set us up. We also read Elizabeth Elliot's Passion and Purity, which talks a lot about remaining pure until your wedding night so that you can give yourself as a spotless woman to
17:55 Speaker 02 your husband and you will be rewarded with great pleasure and married passion. And it will be beautiful and procreative and song of solemn and level joy. That's a book in the Bible that talks about sexual pleasure.
18:09 Speaker 03 Sounds awesome. Is that how it went down?
18:12 Speaker 02 Just that's not how it went down. What actually happened is that I had three sexual assaults on my wedding night and no language to describe that or a way to ask for help or explain. And a week later, I ended up with a raging infection and a doctor who shed light on the fact that there had been battery involved and violence, but I really did not understand what happened on my wedding night until a good 14 years later, when I was finally given language for marital rape and what consent means.
18:43 Speaker 03 I'm so sorry that that happened to you. It's shocking. And when you talk about it in the book, it is so shocking. I don't want to make you relive it. But was there a part of you that thought, oh, this doesn't seem right? It sounds like maybe there, there was no consent because you were his property as well. Consent wasn't something you even knew about, was it?
19:02 Speaker 02 Not at all. That is not a word I knew until I was out of this marriage. Part of that is just culturally, we didn't have very much of a conversation around consent. The therapeutic language that we have available to us today has evolved because survivors and because of researchers and therapists. At this point, we're in 1996 in the story. I did not have that.
19:23 Speaker 03 What does the term quiverful mean?
19:26 Speaker 02 Okay, so this is based on a verse in the Bible. It's relating children to weapons. And if you're going into war, you want lots of weapons. So the verse says, "Weapons in the hand of a warrior are children unto the Lord. Happy is the man that has his quiver full of them." And so that is metaphor, that child is an arrow and you want a quiver full of arrows for your culture war against the West and against secularism and democracy, everything that the Christian nationalists and the dominionists are against. In the Bible, of course, this was the psalmist. So there was an actual war that they were talking about with the weaponry that they had available in Bible times. The quiverful mindset in the evangelical movement was promoted through Bill Gothard's institute.
20:10 Speaker 02 He did not author that. This is just what they latched on to because dominionism is their underlying theology. They want to dominate the world's government through population. So they want to have as many babies as possible without stop.
20:26 Speaker 03 Which was turned into such a kind of a funny quirky joke on 15 and counting or 16 and counting with the Duggars. But from what you say, there's something a lot more insidious about it. It's literally repopulating the world with a particular type of fundamental religious belief.
20:47 Speaker 02 They want white Christian babies. They want to dominate elections and population with an ideology that is not pro-democracy. It is not equality or freedom. It objectifies children because it reduces them to a number. And there is a host of lifestyle accommodations that come with that kind of backwardness that modern society would ordinarily reject.
21:12 Speaker 03 You were careful to say in your book that your world was not fringe. It was very mainstream and that's how it thrives. Can you tell me more about that?
21:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, and the Duggars again are going to serve as a really good example. This is a lifestyle, when we talk about it, the tendency is to say that it was fringe and extreme, except TLC put it on TV and it had, you know, many years. Seasons and lots of money and millions of viewers. They promote themselves as a innocence and a wholesome aesthetic that's very appealing and attractive. Because who doesn't love rows and rows of beautiful obedient children and sweet babies? And the women involved want motherhood. I always say fundamentalism exploits the thing you wanted for yourself. I wanted motherhood. The mothers I knew all wanted motherhood. And it's the very vehicle that they are reduced by until sometimes the point of death.
22:03 Speaker 03 You say sometimes until the point of death. Do you mean that they are encouraged to keep having pregnancies? Because I thought this for a long time, actually, about Michelle Duggar. I'm like, it's not safe. She'd had Caesarians, she'd had complications. She was still trying to get pregnant and pregnant and have more and more and more babies. Are women really just seen as baby factories, essentially? Is that the role of women within this system?
22:25 Speaker 02 Women are seen as breeding cows and they're interchangeable. And they die from things like ongoing uterine issues, prolapsed uteruses, early cancer diagnosis, exhaustion, depression, lack of resources. And then they're replaced with a younger model who will continue having babies. That happened again and again. We would see a mother die in her 30s, early 40s, from essentially exhaustion-related causes. And then replaced with a younger, a younger woman and she'd continue having babies for that man.
22:56 Speaker 03 It's interesting what you say about also, you've written about how the wives have to talk in a very quiet voice. I mean, anyone who's heard Michelle Duggar and watched that TV show. It is so unthreatening and soft. And you write, it's on purpose, like the trained childlike voice, fundy women, fundamentalist women, are trained to adore their men by offering their rapt attention, even if he's an idiot, even if he's not saying much at all, even if you have an intelligent point to make. He's your head, he's a conduit of Jesus, he's amazing. And of course, you're also his consumable resource. So don't be surprised if he's up in your business, undresses you with his eyes, wants to devour you, invades your space.
23:41 Speaker 03 Is that what your life was like? How did that play out?
23:43 Speaker 02 Well, in my case, I don't know if we can say fortunate or not. My husband really hated physical contact and sex. So in my particular case, he was not in my business very often. It is a miracle that I had the number of pregnancies that I had.
23:57 Speaker 03 Because when you say in your business, to be clear, you mean sexual assault and rape by husbands of their wives?
24:05 Speaker 02 Right, I do. But I feel entitled to women's bodies and they're raised from childhood to believe that. Most cases, most of the survivors I talked to, frequent assault is just the norm and they don't know any different. And they don't even know to call it that. Again, not vocabulary available to us. It would never dawn on us to say no, because we haven't been able to say no about anything else. And they've never heard something like, if you can't say no, then you're not free to say yes. It's just, they got married. Their marriage was consent, period. That's the world.
24:36 Speaker 03 Did you ever step out of line? Did you raise your voice, talk to him in a way that wasn't adoring and approving? Because these women are also humans. So did that ever happen to you?
24:47 Speaker 02 This is part of my self-preservation. Yes, it happened to me. My parents actually, you know, they're just, they just took us to church. They weren't high control people themselves. I was a spirited child. I was raised to run and play and explore and do things like that. So being married to this did not come naturally to me. I was constantly at war with my expression. And I was also getting in trouble for things that weren't really wrong. So I was always trying to suss out where the line was. What is small enough for you? Because sometimes just my breathing could make him angry or an expression, an opinion at the table. You know, you're not supposed to have an opinion. But I'm somebody who is a lot. I am a lot of person. I am a lot of expression.
25:29 Speaker 02 And I have ideas and dreams and thoughts and opinions. And I was also the more mentally capable parent for my children. So a lot of times I didn't agree with what was going on and I would push back for their sake to be protective. And that usually would get me in some serious trouble and consequences. So yeah, I think that was descriptive of most of my years with him, that there's this stance happening between us.
25:54 Speaker 03 How soon after your wedding night did you have your first child?
25:58 Speaker 02 I had a miscarriage three months after our wedding and then I had my first baby. I was pregnant three months after that, six months after the wedding. So he was born the next year.
26:08 Speaker 03 How did having a baby and becoming a mother, which was clearly your job description and your purpose, how did that change the dynamic within your family and how did it change your life?
26:19 Speaker 02 It was also my dream. And so, again, I split in this way because I loved being a mom and I loved having my babies. And I wanted every single one of them. And it was always a tension within me because I, just because I wanted them doesn't mean I wanted one a year. I wanted to give my body a break. I wanted to give us as a newlywed couple that was struggling, some time and space to find our feet. I thought I had sound arguments for using contraception and I did use contraception on the sly, even though I was heavily trained not to. I was really trying for our health to not do that. And it also just really upped the stakes because now there's a child involved and then children involved.
27:03 Speaker 02 And it's not just me anymore that's going to pay the consequences. And I so badly wanted to give my children a happy childhood in a secure home. So it just made me dig in harder. You know, it didn't have any way out. So there was not a lot of time spent dreaming of escape. I dreamt of salvation. I wanted someone to come save me and make it better, but I didn't dream of escaping because divorce is absolutely forbidden. They would probably rather you commit suicide than divorce, but of course they don't say that. But in general, if you die, it's a little bit nicer than if you get a divorce in that circle. So I didn't want to do either. I didn't want to die and I didn't have access to a divorce.
27:40 Speaker 03 Because women in the church was so consumed and are the ones that are still there, of course, looking after, you know, up to a dozen children, sometimes more. But many children very close together, which puts an enormous amount of pressure. And often these women are very, very young when they become mothers. What did the church and the IBLP tell you about motherhood and parenting? There was a list of things that you could skip, wasn't there? How did that work and what was on that list?
28:10 Speaker 02 So in my work today, I have a list. I started compiling that list and I call the series Things My Gothard Fundy Mentors Said I Could Skip To Have Equivalent, because there was a whole long list of ordinary things that I took for granted that were part of child rearing that they just didn't do so that they could have more babies. If you did that thing and it interfered with your decision to have more children, then you stopped doing that thing.
28:35 Speaker 03 Can you read that list to me?
28:36 Speaker 02 These were forbidden and I just like warn you, the list is jaw dropping. Well child visits and paediatricians, academics, haircuts, shopping, playdates, socialisation, extended family gatherings, birth control, rest, mom friends, a second income, the entire concept of being a teenager, toys, snacks, education for girls, gynaecological visits, consent, sleepless nights, privacy,
29:13 Speaker 02 the dentist, separate bedrooms, baby food, pants, voting, therapy, art and debt.
29:24 Speaker 03 What do all of those things have in common?
29:27 Speaker 02 Oh, they have many things in common. One of the largest is mandatory reporters.
29:31 Speaker 03 So to keep you away from anyone who could alert authorities to what was going on?
29:36 Speaker 02 Exactly. Agency and ideas that you might have options. That's a big piece of the why you would not have academics in your home school. We weren't allowed to go to the library. We weren't allowed to educate our daughters, you know, because why do they need college? They're going to be just wives and mothers. So their education really stops around sixth, seventh grade. And then they become just little mothers, paramothers, to prepare to be a wife and mother. And then they're skilled at being keepers of the home. We don't want our daughters knowing consent. We don't want our boys to feel like they need to ask for consent. The list all has a very subtle sales process. I was like, shouldn't I take my child to the pediatrician? I'm, I should get them their vaccines.
30:20 Speaker 02 No, you don't need to do vaccines and you don't need to do well child visits because the pediatrician will pressure you to use Western medicine. And we don't use that. We don't use doctors.
30:31 Speaker 03 You don't use doctors?
30:32 Speaker 02 Only in case of emergency.
30:35 Speaker 03 After this short break, how one of the greatest losses of T's life was also her greatest gift and ultimately the key to her freedom.
30:52 Speaker 03 You had four children very quickly. You actually had five children very quickly. But one of your daughters Clara died at nine and a half weeks old.
31:01 Speaker 02 Yes.
31:02 Speaker 03 I'm so sorry for the loss of Clara. That must have been impossibly difficult. How did that thrust you into the world outside the church? Just because of hospitals and doctors? She was born with a heart condition, wasn't she?
31:18 Speaker 02 Yes, hypoplastic left heart syndrome, which is where just half of the heart develops. After she was born, we traveled out of state to have surgery. And so I was immediately immersed into a world where women could be doctors. Women had jobs, women used childcare. I was alone and apart from my husband. I was apart from my babies and my mentors. We were in a completely different environment and believed that we were on the way to wellness. You know, it was definitely with that mindset that we were going to get better and go home. And I include her story in the book the way that I do because the entire experience of Clara absolutely broke me open. It broke the spell of mind control. I had never lost anyone before I lost my daughter.
32:02 Speaker 02 So it was just jarring and shocking all by itself, all for the reasons that anyone can imagine. And when you lose a child, but the experience was so complex and it was impossible to box myself back up after. I could not be the person I had been. And there was a great demand on me to become that again. When I got back home, there was so much pressure on me to not grieve too long. You know, don't make people uncomfortable with your grief. Get back to business quickly, have another child, give God all the glory. And I just couldn't box myself into that anymore. She made that impossible.
32:35 Speaker 03 And there was no therapy?
32:36 Speaker 02 No.
32:36 Speaker 03 In that list that you recited, mum friends.
32:40 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
32:41 Speaker 03 You couldn't even talk to other women.
32:43 Speaker 02 No. And if I did, the only women I would have been speaking to were my mentors, who would have been schooling me to more practical activity and husband obedience. Like, there's no compassion, empathy, friendship.
32:57 Speaker 03 Tia, it's the Handmaid's Tale.
32:59 Speaker 02 Well, I call my story the prequel, the real life prequel to The Handmaid's Tale. And it's important to note that Atwood used real Christian fundamentalist groups as her model. Like, she didn't make that up. Everything in her books already happened.
33:11 Speaker 03 What did the church teach you about discipline and obedience?
33:15 Speaker 02 Oh.
33:16 Speaker 03 Both of your children and of yourself?
33:19 Speaker 02 High control, it has to have a method. So one of the things that's true in patriarchy is it's very fear-based. And they're terrified. Like, these fundamentalists are not evil, crazy people that want something different than the rest of us. They are just like you and me, and they want comforting answers. They want reassuring binaries. They want organization in times of chaos. And they want happy families and successful children. And so they're convinced that if there aren't this high-control model, their children will go bad and that they will lose them and to a lake of fire. The stakes couldn't be higher because it's an eternity in hell. And so all of that convinces parents to do whatever their authority tells them they need to do.
34:01 Speaker 02 And there's no shortage in patriarchy of resources encouraging parents to treat their strong-willed child, you know, with a rod of correction. This environment that I was in and that is just so alive and well today, one teacher really does lead to another and one book leads to another. And so the ideas in one book will build off of that and take you to the next level of extremity. And while everyone may not achieve that. Far and extreme, where in my story, it includes disciplining wives as if they're children and wife spanking. Maybe not everyone experiences that. A lot of them experience a lot of harsh corporal punishment of children. And on the very beginning of the spectrum,
34:43 Speaker 02 babies, because Michael Pearl's books talk about switching through blanket training, which begins at four months old.
34:49 Speaker 03 What's blanket training? Can you explain what blanket training is?
34:52 Speaker 02 Yes. Blanket training is a behavior modification practice that begins in infancy. So as soon as the baby starts to move, put them on a blanket and every time they try to crawl off of the blanket through a normal child development of exploration, you stop them and swat them and tell them no.
35:09 Speaker 03 When you say swat, does that mean hit?
35:11 Speaker 02 Yes, you hit them with a, any kind of switch, approved switch. So they recommended a twig, a stick, a twig, a piece of plumbing, PVC plumbing pipe, glue sticks, flexible craft glue sticks. There's a number of implements they recommend, but you start as a baby and you teach that baby to not move unless you've given it permission.
35:33 Speaker 03 My god.
35:35 Speaker 02 It's barbaric.
35:36 Speaker 03 It sounds illegal. Is it not illegal?
35:39 Speaker 02 It should be. Oh, it should be. In America, spanking children is legal and children have died from it, but they are still publishing and they are still practicing. And this movement fights very hard in court to protect parent rights over children's rights. So in the Christian patriarchy, children have no rights, neither do women. And so that's not the mindset they're operating from.
36:04 Speaker 03 You mentioned wife spanking.
36:07 Speaker 02 Hmm.
36:07 Speaker 03 Did that actually happen to you?
36:09 Speaker 02 It did. It's a practice called Christian domestic discipline. I said in Shiny Happy People, like a careful read of these books on discipline, Michael Pearl's To Train Up A Child being an example of many, they don't have an age limit on when you should stop spanking your child. So if you listen to survivors of these movements, you will hear Older daughters spanked by their fathers into their young adulthood. And you will hear wives who have been spanked. It is tied up in the theology that tells a man that he's responsible for everything that happens in his home. And he's answerable to God for the all of the behavior. And so that's how it's sold, that you need to hold her accountable and train her because
36:52 Speaker 02 her choices are going to reflect on you on judgment day.
36:56 Speaker 03 Women can't vote, can they? They're not allowed to vote.
36:58 Speaker 02 It's not as clean cut as that. I was not allowed to vote and they don't prefer women to vote, but they will utilize the female vote if the popular numbers are close. And in American elections lately, they've been very close. And so women are allowed to vote, but they're expected to vote in compliance with their head of household.
37:17 Speaker 03 So their husband tells them who to vote for?
37:19 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:20 Speaker 03 You mentioned how Clara and losing her cracked you open. Was there a definitive moment when you decided that enough was enough?
37:29 Speaker 02 It took me seven more years to reach that point. I really came home from the hospital with this endeavor to be the best Christian wife and mother I could be. I felt emboldened in my faith. I felt empowered by Christ. I felt like I'd seen an example of strength and power and that I could color inside the lines, so to speak. And that really did work to a point. I had two more children after Clara and four more pregnancies. It was life, you know, I did not realize that there was not a entertaining, again, of getting out. It's till death do you part, even if it's at his hands. And it did come down to that. I think one of the traits that I have is a Christian girl groomed to people please and fawn.
38:14 Speaker 02 I tend to stay in environments longer than I should. I can see the writing on the wall and then I lack the courage to save myself and take myself out of that. It's a life discipline I'm working on. And this is the biggest example of it. I had to get to a place where he was about to kill us. I had to realize I was grooming the next generation of abusers in order to put my foot down and say enough is enough. And then when, when you try to leave an abusive person, it becomes much more dangerous and violent. And that's what happened, the violence escalated.
38:44 Speaker 03 You wrote in the book that as you began to find your power, your husband reacted very badly. And you wrote, balance was a delusion. As I became more independent and healthy, high control religion and domestic abuse tightened their grip. My husband became more erratic and dangerous. In October of 2007, things came to a violent head and I narrowly escaped with my children in the middle of the night. What happened on that night, if it's not too distressing to recount?
39:11 Speaker 02 Sure, I'm gonna give you like the high level version. I knew that I had to leave and I had been making arrangements to leave the next day with my children while he was at work. We had gone trick or treating, which was the first time our children had participated in Halloween. It was part of a kind of new progressive community that we were in. And I felt like excited that they could do that. You know, I didn't want to take that from them prematurely. So we had gone trick or treating and after we got home, he had some sort of psychotic break. I really don't have good language for what happened to him inside of him, other than that he snapped. He held me hostage for four hours with the length of firewood, threatening to kill me and kill the children. And then he suddenly left and I,
39:56 Speaker 02 I heard a voice in my head, in my mind, in my heart that said, run. So I packed us up, grabbed the laundry and the children and my laptop and I left. And he had gone to his office to get his gun. So if I had stayed, we wouldn't be having this conversation right now. We drove away.
40:13 Speaker 03 Oh my God. How old were your children then?
40:16 Speaker 02 Ten and down, ten to two and a half.
40:18 Speaker 03 How old were you?
40:19 Speaker 02 Thirty-three.
40:21 Speaker 03 And you mentioned grabbing your laptop. There was a group of, an online group of women, who became your lifeline and really showed you the door and the possibility that there was a way out. How did you come upon them and, and how did they play a role before that night happened?
40:39 Speaker 02 Way back, if we go back into the timeline to when Clara died, just after that, my oldest was old enough for homeschooling. And I had stumbled on the homeschooling forums that had just formed. The internet was brand new, you know, we were all pioneers in this new technology. I had a way to connect the outside world from home and it is a big, big through line of how I survived this mentally, how I educated myself and the connections that I made that were outside of the religious groups that we were in. And they were other Christian women going through very similar dynamics with different expressions, like none of them were like in as much high control as I was, but they had toxicity in their marriages and they had family dynamics where we could relate to one another and talk in a real way about what kinds of things we were facing.
41:23 Speaker 02 And I had also started a business by the time I left, a blogging business and I had a successful website at that time. So I grabbed my laptop because I knew my livelihood was in it and all of my contacts and those women helped me hide. They sheltered me and took me in and I do believe, I know that we're seeing this again, there's underground railroads forming of women connecting to women, helping one another out of danger situations and in America, you know, helping women get abortions, helping women find healthcare and, and resources and get out of domestic violence. So they saved my life, they really did and they kept my children's world somewhat balanced during that time.
42:02 Speaker 03 Was there a moment where you thought, okay, I've done it, I've left and I can't return to that life?
42:08 Speaker 02 It was that night. Yeah, that was done. It was a complete severance.
42:12 Speaker 03 And what happened after that? What was the next 12 months like for you and your kids?
42:17 Speaker 02 We had to go into hiding. We started divorce proceedings, which had to be separated from the custody proceedings because those required forensic investigations. Violence continued and it was about a 10-year process of all of that. You don't get divorced cleanly from someone like that and easily. But I was also going through trauma therapy through those years and putting my life back together. I mean, I really did set to healing, raising my kids, securing my employment, getting on my feet. And I had it in this context that this bad marriage happened to us. It wasn't till years later in therapy when I had to start like reversing my decision-making process and exploring what made me make those choices in the first place.
43:01 Speaker 02 What made me go along and comply? And that's what led me to the religious trauma and understanding the grooming and conditioning I'd been part of as a younger woman.
43:10 Speaker 03 How do you un-brainwash yourself? Because essentially you'd been brainwashed since the age of 10 about even how you think. One of the things that struck me so much in your book, you told me, you told me you wrote that you couldn't even write a journal because you didn't even have any privacy of thought. You were worried that God would see it or that your husband might find it because you had no right to say, no, I don't want you to read this. How do you undo that?
43:40 Speaker 02 It's a mixture of big, binge-y growth spurts and then a lot of careful day-to-day retraining, rediscovery. I prefer like to emphasize curiosity and question asking and meditation. I have come up with my own steps of recovery and my own process of healing. And I've had breakthroughs along the way that I'm writing about now. But there were also giant moments, like when Clara died, that was a giant moment where a lot of the spell was broken in my mind and I was curious and, and wanted to learn. And then there were harder times where I, I have deeply embedded patterns of fawning and people pleasing and cooperation.
44:21 Speaker 02 And I have to really work on situation by situation and carefully with a therapist. So it's a little mixture of both, but I did not accept that I wouldn't heal. Like I want that for my life.
44:35 Speaker 03 Well, this is not the end of Tia's story, not by a long shot, because it takes a lot more than leaving a marriage to leave a cult. How do you un-brainwash yourself? How do you trust again? Find love again? And learn how to be a grown woman in a world that you'd been kept apart from for so long? And what does Tia think about trad wives like Hannah Neillman and Ballerina Farm, who were trying to sell this life to a whole new generation of women? There's so much more of this incredible conversation, more than we could share in one episode here. So if you're not already a Mamma Mia subscriber, let this be the episode that makes you one. I'll put a link in the show notes and I'll see you in part two.
45:17 Speaker 01 If you're looking for something else to listen to, like and follow all of our Mamma Mia! podcasts, which are currently bringing you Hot Pod Summer. 100 hours of summer listens, from spicy conversations to incredible stories, fashion, beauty and more.
Previous Inside One Of Australia’s Longest Running Cults [fresh episode] Next A Doomsday Cult And Two Missing Kids Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated