Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Inside One Of Australia’s Longest Running Cults [fresh episode] About this episode The Geelong Revival Centre, one of Australia’s longest-running cults, has been hiding in plain sight for years. Led by Pastor Noel Hollins until his death in 2024, the ultra-conservative church controls every aspect of its followers' lives.
For the past two years, investigative journalist Richard Baker has collected disturbing audio recordings from Hollins and testimonies from survivors. They’ve told him stories of alleged physical and sexual abuse, emotional stories of families being torn apart by strict rules and disturbing allegations of medicine being banned.
Due to legal constraints, he’s been unable to share it… until now. You can listen to Richard's podcast Secrets We Keep: Pray Harder here https://play.listnr.com/podcast/secrets-we-keep.
THE END BITS
Subscribe to Mamamia https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe/?utm_source=shownotes&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=tcc
CREDITS
Guest: Richard Baker https://www.linkedin.com/in/richard-baker-b8ba7a10?originalSubdomain=au
Host: Gemma Bath https://www.linkedin.com/in/gemmabath/overlay/photo/
Producer: Tahli Blackman
Audio Producer: Jacob Round
GET IN TOUCH
Feedback? We’re listening! Email us at [email protected]
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
Mamamia acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast.
0:04 Speaker 01 Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters this podcast was recorded on.
0:11 Speaker 01 Growing up in an ultra-conservative Pentecostal church in the suburbs of Geelong, Stacey remembers feeling like royalty. She was related to the all-powerful pastor Noel Hollands, the man whose word everyone followed as gospel. She got VIP access to lunch on Sundays and life was good. She'd been born into the church and she didn't know any other way. If you were part of the Geelong Revival Centre, you didn't question the Lord and you certainly didn't question Pastor Noel, no matter how troubling his rules became.
0:43 Speaker 02 But those who've got a hunger for the Lord, that word will register and the sheep will come. It's not going to stop the Lord's work at all, to all the people said.
0:54 Speaker 01 For Stacey, everything was fine until it wasn't. At the age of 18, Stacey says she was raped by a male friend. The pastor found out and told her she had to marry him and that she had to be excommunicated, kicked out of the church for a year as punishment for having sex before marriage. She was cut off from everyone, left completely on her own to deal with not only what had happened to her, but the future she was being forced into. For Stacey, that time in exile was the start of the end. It gave her time to question the church. Why were they forcing her to marry someone she'd accused of raping her? Why was that her fault? Why did she believe the preachings of this church so holy
1:38 Speaker 01 when the rules and ramifications hurt so deeply? What if, she thought, the man on the platform, her relative, her pastor, was wrong?
1:58 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. 2024 has been a big year for the Geelong Revival Centre, an ultra-conservative church based in the suburbs of a Victorian city an hour and a half from Melbourne. In April, the controversial, long-time leader of the church, Pastor Noel Hollands, died at the age of 93. Then in August, a man named Todd Hubers, who was a senior leader at the church, pled guilty to the persistent sexual abuse of multiple children. It's understood the crimes took place between 2016 and 2023 at various locations across the Geelong region,
2:41 Speaker 01 and the victims were boys aged between 6 and 12. Hubers is still awaiting sentencing, that will happen in early 2025. But this is far from the only criminal, confronting, and deeply troubling revelation that's emerged from the shadowy depths of the cult-like church, a church that thousands of Australians have been a part of over the decades, a place where alcohol, friends outside of church, medicine, and even team sport are banned, a place where the pastor is in charge of your dating life, where movie-style kissing is banned, and church brothers get to choose the women they marry whether she wants to or not, a place where young girls and women are forced to reveal intricate details of their sex lives,
3:24 Speaker 01 things like positions and timing, even if those experiences came as the result of alleged rape. For two years, Richard has been investigating the Geelong Revival Centre, collecting audio from Noel Hollands and stories from cult survivors. For legal reasons, he's been unable to share it, until now. Here's Richard.
3:49 Speaker 01 Richard, tell me how you came across this story and just how long you've been working on it.
3:55 Speaker 03 I came across Pray Harder, or the story that I've called Pray Harder. In the middle of 2022, I was contacted by a guy who was an ex-member of this extreme Pentecostal church headquartered in Geelong. And it turned out actually that he and I were at primary school in a coastal town near to Geelong together in the mid 1980s. It just felt like, you know, that was meant to be that I was going to do this story. And I've been working on it ever since then. And through this guy, Ryan, I was introduced to a number of other former members of the church. And it kind of just snowballed and spiralled from there.
4:39 Speaker 03 My first couple of meetings with people, I couldn't believe some of the things I was being told. And, you know, as much as you want to hear extreme or shocking things or whatever, you know, as part of you as a journalist is going, oh, that can't be that bad. Or, you know, is that a stretch or whatever? Took a few months and a number of meetings with, you know, quite a few people from that church to realise, no, what I'm being told is 100%. And then I really knew I had to commit to it.
5:08 Speaker 01 So you grew up in the area we're talking about, around Geelong in Victoria. Do you remember hearing about the church or did you know about the church growing up?
5:16 Speaker 03 I didn't know per se about this particular one. What I did know in Geelong is that at that time, there was quite a strong presence of, I guess you would call Pentecostal styled churches where they were quite insular communities and very popular. I remember some really big churches. My dad, after my parents separated, got involved with one of those more popular churches. And I remember going to a few of the services and the singing and people speaking in tongues and things like that, that you associate with those things. And yeah, I just thought they were all one and the same as a kid, you know, you wouldn't distinguish.
6:01 Speaker 03 But yes, certainly that style of religion was a, I had a small insight into it as a kid for a window where my dad was. Looking for something, you know, after her mum separated.
6:13 Speaker 01 I know you've been working on this story since 2022. The leader of the church, Pastor Noel Hollands, he died in early 2024. While you're in the midst of this investigation, was that a turning point?
6:27 Speaker 03 He carried a lot of fear with him in everyone who grew up under him. So Pastor Noel Hollands was basically the founder and leader of this Geelong Revival Centre, which is the main church, but it oversees a network of about 17 assemblies across Australia, in Queensland, South Wales, Tasmania, South Australia and WA. He'd been running it since, I think, like 1958. Even though people have been out 10 years or so, still could hear his voice. And if you listen, you know, people listening to the podcast will hear that it is a very unique and quite, I guess, intimidating voice. And certainly the force of his message has kind of left an imprint on their heads.
7:12 Speaker 03 So, yeah, even when people were speaking about him, part of them at times, they would say, I feel guilty or I feel like I'm doing wrong or my soul is in trouble because of what I'm about to tell you about this place. He's big on secrets and really big on him having total control over everyone and everything.
7:31 Speaker 01 So what's Pastor Noel's background? Had he come from a strictly religious world himself? Or is it something he came to later in life?
7:39 Speaker 03 He was born into quite a well-off family in Hawthorn in Melbourne. And his father was actually a member of parliament in Victoria and served as a minister in some governments, you know, back in the 30s or 40s. And they were raised a sort of strict Methodist church people. And it wasn't until a couple of years after, at the end of World War Two, that the Hollands family got introduced to this new brand of worship and new brand, I guess, of Christianity called the Revival Crusade. And it came out of America.
8:18 Speaker 03 A couple of its, you know, key points were, you know, total acceptance of like every word in the Bible is literal and true. And you have to abide by all those things. There's no room for kind of interpretation or. You know, seeing things as, you know, metaphoric or whatever, it was very literal. And the other big impression on their family was a concept called British Israelism. And what that boils down to is a belief that the people of Great Britain and the United States, that is, the white people, are the descendants of what's called the ten lost tribes of Israel.
9:00 Speaker 03 And they are basically God's chosen people and kind of a buff of other races and other, other religions. And the Hollands family was visited by a guy called Tom Foster, who was a massive proponent of British Israelism in the post-World War Two years. And what Noel Hollands did was kind of fuse the revival beliefs and style of worship and inject that British Israel message into his teachings. And that became the cornerstone of his doctrine, that you wanna be a part of this church, you have to find salvation through speaking in tongues. So you've got to show that you can receive the Holy Spirit by speaking in tongues.
9:44 Speaker 03 Baptism by full immersion in a water tank and then believe this British Israel message, which is basically that the Anglo-Saxon or Anglo-Celtic people have a special place and are God's chosen people.
9:59 Speaker 01 So it's racist, in other words?
10:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, it is. I mean, if you do a deep dive into British Israelism, it's been embraced by some KKK leaders in the States and is still a cornerstone principle of that muscular nationalist, Christian fundamentalist movement in America, which is quite powerful and has some political power. Yeah.
10:25 Speaker 03 Of course, they'll accept people in the church from other backgrounds and other other races. This church, the one that Noel Hollands founded and expanded, has branches in Singapore and India and the Philippines, Colombia, Sierra Leone. So they're not scared to or afraid of mixing with other people. But one thing he wanted to make clear was that brothers in the church, that's what they call the men, who were sent out to kind of establish and run these overseas assemblies are not to marry a local girl because they will not be welcomed back.
11:01 Speaker 01 It's mind boggling that these other countries accept that.
11:04 Speaker 03 Well, they don't know. I mean, they go there, they don't, you know, go through the normal channels of, you know, getting approval from government or things like that. They just go out, they set up a thing and they promise salvation. And so it's a very seductive message that they have is basically, come to us, we've got a way that will solve all your problems in your current life, because all you've got to do is pray harder, do what we say, things will be okay. And then that this life is only temporary anyway, that the end of the world is fast approaching. By being part of this church, you will earn eternal life. So, you know, that for
11:48 Speaker 03 people who've got a lot of problems or whatever, this is a quick fix with a promise of something everlasting. And all you've got to do is just do what they say.
11:57 Speaker 01 Doing what they say comes with a lot of rules under Pastor Noel. Can you take us through some of those? Because they were very strict in all facets of life, in what you were and weren't allowed to do.
12:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, extremely strict. I've never seen anything quite like it. For example, extremely patriarchal in that Noel is the head of the church, he has a senior group of elders under him. Then the man is the head of the household and a woman is basically there to support her husband and have kids and make sure her kids don't step out of line and only speak when they're spoken to. People are encouraged to report on each other. So there's a lot of spying and judgment going on and report to pastor. Teenagers aren't allowed to associate with others outside of schools. So there's no sleepovers or play dates or, you know, doing things with non-church people. So it's
12:52 Speaker 03 very, very cloistered. Relationships between, you know, teenage boys and girls, for example, are kind of forbidden. And when people turn eighteen, if they want to pair off, in the pastor's words, that has to be approved by pastor. And then they are subject to things like only seeing each other once or twice a week, limited phone time. There was one famous rule, there they had no movie style kissing. And of course, if you happen to grow up and realise that you're gay, then you've got a massive problem, because that's about the worst thing anyone can be in that place. And that's going to lead to your expulsion from the church and your family are going to be
13:37 Speaker 03 forced to cut you loose, to have nothing to do with you. So that's what happens if someone decides to leave, their families are instructed to sever all ties and leave someone without a support network on the outside. So that's a very grave fear of, one, being kicked out because you lose your salvation if you're not in church and you're being told the world's about to end. You think you're going to go to hell. And two, you lose your family and your friends, you know. So it's really very, very, very controlling. And for women in particular, too, they can't initiate a relationship. So they basically are sitting on the shelf, waiting for a man in the
14:20 Speaker 03 church, and it could be from one of the other churches around Australia that are affiliated with them to go, hmm, I like you, I want to start a relationship with you. And then basically. That's like a factory farm.
14:32 Speaker 01 It's like an arranged marriage kind of thing. You don't get a choice.
14:35 Speaker 03 No, because you're just brought up to believe that your role is to hopefully be chosen to be married. And, you know, I've had females, you know, young women in in the podcast say you don't even care who it is or even you just want them to be nice and to treat you nice. But that's the main goal. Because that's all your your role in life is, is to bear children and support your husband.
15:01 Speaker 01 So you're not allowed to work at all.
15:03 Speaker 03 There's not a hard and fast rule, but the type of job you can do is is restricted. And if your husband doesn't want you to work, it won't work. And also the pastor says where you live, you can't choose to move. And even your holidays are truncated. Like, if you go on holidays, you have to go to a place where there's another affiliated assembly so you can receive prayer and communion and fasting. And for the kids, you know, there's obviously a lot of problems in this too, because the other thing they encourage is corporal punishment of children. Although corporal punishment is still legal when it's, you know, just a smack or a lot of people choose not to do it and think there are better ways now.
15:45 Speaker 03 What that did, that constant messaging, one thing that they people said they heard over and over was spare the rod, spoil the child. Well, that was literal in terms of people got caned, belted, hit with fists, choked. So they described some terrifying encounters growing up as children. And also there was always a spectre, an undercurrent of sexual abuse and, you know, another scary thing for kids to face.
16:13 Speaker 01 Which I want to get into in a minute, but focusing on that more physical abuse of children and how accepted it was. It wasn't just the man in your household, so your dad, anyone, any man could discipline children, couldn't they?
16:27 Speaker 03 Yes, if the children were within your orbit and you felt that they needed correction. So the other name for that policy was the rod of correction. Yeah, they they could dish out a punishment without any consequence. And women who were perhaps single mothers or stuff in there would find themselves having a married brother in the church, kind of appoint himself as to be the overseer of her house. And that would entail him disciplining her children when he saw fit.
17:00 Speaker 01 This is criminal, isn't it? The physical abuse of children at this kind of extent.
17:04 Speaker 03 I would argue that, yeah, from what I was told and what the podcast has, there are clear-cut examples of criminal abuse within the place, going back, in some cases, decades.
17:16 Speaker 01 And then there's the allegations of sexual assault and abuse against children. You were told, not just like one or two, you were told numerous stories about this, weren't you?
17:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, and that, you know, maybe it has something to do with the extreme rules and the strictness put on those relationships, on the ability to actually have a physical relationship with somebody else as you're growing up, and that's how we learn along the way in the outside world or the normal world. Maybe that's a factor in there being this kind of undercurrent of abusive, sexual abuse in there with children because people aren't formed in their relationships, or they just have opportunity and access, I don't know. But yeah, it's certainly a factor in the stories, again, what I've been told that we put out in the podcast.
18:06 Speaker 03 And not all of these things were immediately or ever reported to police. Certainly, the pastor, Pastor Noel, made it clear that he was the authority in every matter, and he was the first port of call, rather than any external or secular authorities when it came to anything that happened within the church. It was his realm.
18:28 Speaker 01 So a lot of these people you've spoken to with these allegations, they say that Pastor Noel knew about the abuse?
18:35 Speaker 03 Yep, they do. Basically, he was dismissive of it unless there was an admission from a perpetrator that something had taken place. But yeah, I mean, I've had people tell me in the podcast and tell me outside of that, that basically his response was that sort of stuff doesn't happen here.
18:55 Speaker 01 I want to give listeners an example so they know the kinds of stories we're talking about. Can you tell us a little bit about Robert and what happened to him?
19:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, so Robert is one of the oldest sort of people, I guess, in the podcast. He'd be in his 50s. So he was describing his sort of teenage years in the 80s. At one summer camp, he tells a story of... Basically been groomed by a young male in the church who was probably, you know, 10 or so years his senior in that they'd spend a bit of time together, they'd go surfing. Then this guy sort of introduced him to, you know, some soft porn mags and then yeah, started doing things to Robert and encouraging Robert to do things to him to say, this is what you do, this will make you feel nice and stuff. And yeah, Robert told his
19:47 Speaker 03 parents and they really didn't believe him and then it found its way to the pastor and he didn't believe it either. So this poor kid in Robert is left to feel abandoned and unsupported and that no one believed him. I know the guy he's referring to, I've heard accounts of, you know, Robert not being the only one to suffer at the hands of this, this man back then. Robert left the church not that long after and, and that meant the rest of his life, he's been excommunicated by his family. His mother won't recognise him.
20:22 Speaker 01 Because of that, because of what happened to him?
20:25 Speaker 03 Because he left, yeah. But the reason he left was their failure to believe him or accept that what he was telling them was true. It was just, no, this doesn't happen. You're making it up.
20:41 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with journalist and podcaster, Richard Baker, about the Geelong Revival Centre cult. Up next, we talk about Stacey's story and how she managed to escape the church.
21:02 Speaker 01 Probably one of the most shocking stories in your podcast involves a woman you called Stacey, who was actually a relative of Pastor Noel.
21:12 Speaker 01 And she claims that she was raped and that Pastor Noel knew about it and told her she had to marry him. That is a huge statement to make. That's harrowing.
21:24 Speaker 03 It is. It's hard to comprehend. I mean, I sat across from Stacey when I was interviewing her and when she got to this part of her story, I honestly could see a physical change come over her. And I don't even know if, you know, she was aware of that or not. But as she recounted her alleged rape and then the pastor, who was her, you know, senior male relative in her family, his response to it, her bottom lip was trembling. So, you know, it clearly has had a visceral effect on, on her recounting it to me. So basically, she was 18 and again,
22:04 Speaker 03 you know, growing up in this extremely strict and controlled environment where the expectations placed on a young woman were very, very extreme and constant. You were being watched for your behaviour all the time. Look, she struck up a relationship with a young guy in the Geelong area and that turned out to be an abusive relationship. And, you know, the story of their first, I guess, I'm talking in inverted commas here, you know, sexual interaction, they got outed. She actually revealed how that took place, which was, is an alleged rape. She had to go and confront pastor with this because putting yourself in that situation, if you're
22:45 Speaker 03 a woman, or finding yourself in that situation is a breach of the rules and you're to blame. And she was to be punished and she knew she was going to be put out of fellowship. According to their beliefs, if the world ends while you're out, you go to hell and also you're separated from your family. Now, the other thing he said, according to her, was that the only way we can half make this right. Is for you to marry this guy. That was the only way. She was still going to be punished for a bit, but it wouldn't be as severe. But that was how to fix this problem. The guy you claim raped you and, you know, took your virginity and all that away from you is gonna be your husband.
23:29 Speaker 01 Did she do it? Did she marry him?
23:31 Speaker 03 No, that ended her relationship with the church. Caused tremendous upheaval in her family group because her dad had to stick up for her and cross swords with with Noel, who he was related to. You know, the battle scars from all that, they still wear that to this day. But he had to stand up for his daughter because she was going to be forced to marry her abuser.
23:58 Speaker 01 This story, Stacey's story of being excommunicated or being kicked out, it felt like a common theme throughout your investigation of these families. Being torn apart, often for things like this that were not their fault. You mentioned before, people who are gay, that also warrants you an excommunication from the church. Is that something that you've found over and over again, that families were just being forced to kind of kick members out?
24:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, to me, that's the biggest tragedy of a place like this is the destruction of families, generation after generation, you know, because this has been around for seventy years, this network of churches. The ripple effects of that, you know, we've got families that have had suicides and stuff because of the trauma of being split apart from your your children or your brothers and sisters and ex-wives, whatever. You know, people have taken their own lives and then they're made an example of by the leaders of the churches to say, well, this is what happens if you leave. Without looking at the reasons why something happens, you know, in terms of the forced separation of family.
25:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, I just found that the biggest, most kind of, I guess, emotional response I had was it just hits you over the head when you hear it time and time again and you look at it and you look at the damage done and equate that with your own life and how important family is for most of us to have that denied just because you've made a life decision for yourself. You know, I, I think that's criminal.
25:35 Speaker 01 It's probably also a good time to bring in the term backslider because that's different to being excommunicated. Can you talk us through the difference?
25:42 Speaker 03 So you could be excommunicated for a while as punishment, right? But then a lot of people who get that work very hard to correct themselves so that we welcome back in. Backslider is also shunned, cut off from their family, but a backslider is someone who leaves by choice. And that's the word that is given to those people and they are the lowest of the low. They are described frequently as being lower than a dog returning to its own vomit. And that backsliders, you have to have nothing to do with them because they, you know, they're going to bring you on a pathway to hell and cost you your salvation.
26:18 Speaker 01 So you could leave, it just cost you your entire world, your entire life, your family, your friends?
26:24 Speaker 03 Yeah. One guy, Gary, he decided to leave after a lifetime, you know, half a lifetime. He's in his 40s. In the church, he could no longer do it. He tried to take his, one of his daughters who were teens then to, to come with him. They wouldn't. They've stayed in. His ex-wife is remarried in there. And he's not, has seen his daughters now, I think, for six years. And they live eight kilometres away from him, have nothing to do with him. They've been, you know, married off or will be married off or whatever to someone in the church and, and so it continues.
27:00 Speaker 01 One case we can talk about that has been through the court system is Todd Hubers. Can you touch on him and who he was within the church? He has pled guilty to 16 charges, including the sexual penetration and touching of boys, young boys.
27:16 Speaker 03 For his plea hearing, you know, the court was told in, you know, really explicit terms, the depravity of of what he did. So Todd Hubers was a a man born into a church family, raised in this setting, in this really restrictive environment, talented musician, taught music to a number of the kids in the church. And he admitted in court to having a lifelong or twenty five year addiction to child pornography. And he started in twenty sixteen to abuse young boys in the Geelong region, now suggesting that those victims are from the church there, but certainly young boys from the Geelong
28:01 Speaker 03 region who he came into contact with. And yeah, he operated this thing he called Boys Club. He built a loft in his garage, a mezzanine sort of loft. Abuse took place there on trips to swimming pools and and things there. And when we're talking abuse here, I don't want to downgrade any form of abuse, but the stuff that he has admitted to doing to boys aged between six and twelve is at the extreme end of offending. What was interesting was that in January twenty twenty three, Hubers went to see Pastor Noel Hollands
28:43 Speaker 03 and made some partial admissions to him about what he'd been up to. Hollands said, well, you'd better turn yourself in to police. And Hollands himself didn't contact police about what a member of his church had had confessed to him about for perhaps a day, day and a half later from hearing that information. And Hubers took four days to hand himself in. And during the course of that time, he admitted to deleting perhaps terabytes of child pornography from his devices that police cyber experts have not been able
29:23 Speaker 03 to fully recover because he was a skilled I T professional. And as we know, obviously having and watching and downloading that material is a really serious crime. And to have that amount, you just multiply, you know, the abuse of children that would be contained in that. And that was part of Boys Club too, some of the. You know, things he did with the boys there was make them watch that kind of material. You know, the court heard that it might have perhaps been a couple of early warning signs back in 2016 that his addiction was getting worse and his behaviour more risky and criminal.
30:06 Speaker 03 But he was able to explain a couple of things away and was given the benefit of the doubt by those close to him. You know, this emboldened him and enabled him to, you know, go about grooming young boys in the Geelong region, introducing them to his so-called boys' club.
30:25 Speaker 01 Well, as you said, he came from this world, this church world, where men ruled over everyone, women and children primarily. And they were allowed to get away with a lot of things, not saying this, but that's the world he grew up in.
30:37 Speaker 03 Your values and your relationships, I think, aren't fully formed in a place where there are such tight controls and guidelines on everything that you do and who you can talk to, when you can, how you talk. It just doesn't create a normal setting for it. And a warped sense of morality, because if you think about it, when you're growing up in a place where the ultimate arbiter of right and wrong is your pastor, your sense of morality and your moral settings aren't the same as wider society, because you remember this is a church that does not like wider society. And frequently, members are told, we're at war with the outside world, and they don't
31:22 Speaker 03 understand this.
31:25 Speaker 01 After the break, I asked Richard about the church banning medicine and how that ended up causing severe illness and even death among its followers.
31:40 Speaker 01 The other area you explore in detail is the pastor and the church's rejection of medicine. Can you expand on that a bit? Because the ramifications of a rule like that which you explore are horrible, to say the least.
31:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, the rule or the expectation of, you know, putting prayer ahead of medicine was definitely right throughout this network of churches. Some pastors, you know, had stricter interpretations or expectations around the use of medicine. What people described was that, yeah, members were discouraged from relying on the medical community and science. Because this is a place that rejects a lot of science too, you know, the theory of evolution according to personal is just garbage. And yeah, people suffering life threatening illnesses like cancer and different things often denied themselves or were discouraged or believed
32:37 Speaker 03 that they were not right with God if they went and sought treatment because they'd been told that if they were walking in the spirit and with the Lord, then they'd be healed. And so families and people who had serious medical issues either didn't seek treatment, delayed treatment, had infrequent treatment. And then when, you know, they weren't healed or the problem didn't go away or someone died, they were made to feel guilty that this happened. They had a spiritual problem. There was something not right with them. So the psychological effect was also profound, let alone just the physical effect of perhaps
33:18 Speaker 03 not having, you know, the best of medical treatment for whatever was afflicting them. There's a story going for, or a case going through the courts in Brisbane now involving the death of an eight-year-old girl called Elizabeth Struths, who was in Toowoomba. And her family were part of a really strict church that practised many of these same beliefs. She was diabetic and they denied her, her insulin in the belief that prayer would heal. She died weighing twenty two kilos on a mattress in her house and, and her parents and the other members of the church prayed around her body for thirty six hours, believing she'd be resurrected. These things, as unbelievable as they sound to most of us, are happening in Australia in places like this church.
34:04 Speaker 01 And are happening in, you know, twenty twenty four still.
34:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:07 Speaker 01 Do we go as far as calling this Geelong Revival Centre and its affiliates? Is it a cult?
34:13 Speaker 03 I think it meets the definitions. If your liberties and your freedoms are taken away from you in the belief that you have to behave and think a certain way and basically give over all autonomy to one man. That to me suggests it's a cult. I guess the most important thing in answering that question, perhaps it's not for me to say, but what former members say, what do they think they were in, you know? When they look back on their decades of living this way, most of them think it, it meets the definition of a cult or a cult-like group. And there are lots of them in Australia.
34:52 Speaker 03 It's hard because politicians don't like, and for good reason sometimes, crossing over and putting barriers on religious freedom. But to have religious freedom also, I think, comes with responsibility to ensure people aren't harmed and particularly when you say people, for me, it's children who have no choice. An adult can choose to subject themselves to this kind of life. And then, yeah, perhaps once they're in, you know, it changes into something that I didn't think it would be, but it's too hard to get out. That's one thing, but for me, the biggest problem and where society and the authorities perhaps need to do more and keep. A closer eye on places like this is on the welfare of the kids.
35:37 Speaker 03 Because they don't have a choice if they're born into that.
35:40 Speaker 01 We've talked about numerous things that deserve criminal proceedings. They need to be investigated and we haven't even touched on. You have found examples of people within the church allegedly bashing men in Geelong that they knew were gay. Because they were gay. And then there's all of the financially dubious stuff you've uncovered about. The church's finances itself and the fact that they say that they're tax exempt, but. You kind of uncovered that that's a bit wishy washy.
36:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, the finances are a real mystery because of, you know, one area I think this shines a bit of a light on in Australia is um. The tax exemptions given to what's called a basic religious charity. So if you and I, we can set up our own religious group and we could get tax exemption if we set up a charity. And run our books through that. All we need to say is we're a charity and what do we do? Oh, we're advancing the cause of religion and that's all you need to do to qualify. And what that means is if you're registered as a basic religious charity, which is the trust at the centre of this church. Is one of those you don't have to submit financial reports. So members have no clarity on where their money and remember.
36:54 Speaker 03 Everyone who's part of this church is expected to give a tithing and make offerings. And if you've got more money, the more money you're expected to commit. You can't see how that's being used. These basic religious charities aren't subject to the same governance guidelines and rules. That other non-religious charities are.
37:14 Speaker 01 What's happened since you put your podcast and your investigation out into the world? Do you think that authorities are going to start looking more closely at this church?
37:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think so. I think that plus the combination of how a guy like Todd Hubers was moulded or created. In this place and how the church handled. Or how the pastor at the time handled his admissions and then, you know, the delay in notifying police would be something of, something of interest there. And I'm certainly doing my best to bring it to the attention of relevant authorities. It's up to individuals, obviously, if they want to report things to police. I know a number of people from Geelong but from other places have made some historic abuse allegations, either physical or sexual, that they say they experienced when they were children. There are some other prosecutions going on in other assemblies
38:08 Speaker 03 connected to this church in Australia that I'm not going to say where because I don't want to impact any trials or things coming up there. There's enough there, I think, in what's out there through the podcast and these ex-members' stories, plus what's happening just in, in our court system and other things, to say places like this need to be put under the microscope some more. And maybe, you know, the relevant authorities that are responsible for things like child protection or child safety, actually go in and have a look at what do they have in place here? Do they have working with children's checks on people who are minding children or supervising activities at their camps and things like that? And also question the leaders around these
38:53 Speaker 03 policies that allow people other than parents of children to dish out quite, you know, physical and sometimes violent punishments on other people's kids.
39:04 Speaker 01 Do we know if anything's changed since Pastor Noel died?
39:08 Speaker 03 Well, there's a new leader of the church who was, I guess, an acolyte of Pastor Noel. I don't think anything's changed. I think if anything, they've got more, from what I'm hearing, more repressive, more secretive, building up the walls around them because they perceive what I've done as an attack on them.
39:27 Speaker 01 Hmm.
39:27 Speaker 03 It's not that people, you know, can have the right to worship who and how they like, but society has a job to do, the media has a job to do, when that's at the expense of other people's physical or emotional wellbeing.
39:42 Speaker 01 Is there life on the other side? A lot of these now adults that were children that grew up in this church, have they been able to? Create better lives for themselves despite all of the trauma and the ripping apart of their families that they've endured?
39:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, and that's the silver lining. Like, a lot of what we've talked about is heavy, you know, and
40:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:02 Speaker 03 hard to take content. The good thing is, and the podcast does have an element of that, there is hope. And people who have transitioned out of such places have found the outside world's pretty good. And their kids are happy and they're living really good lives as productive and involved members of the wider community. And they're loving it. And the good thing is for people on the inside of places like that is these guys are connected through social media and different networks now that you go out and, you know, you did this 20 years ago. You were literally on your own. Now you've got a group of people who understand exactly what you're going through. Who can relate to what you're feeling and the challenges you might be facing.
40:46 Speaker 03 And they're there to help you and guide you through it. You know, in Geelong, I know, you know, there was one just last Saturday where a group of the ex-members all caught up and had a beer and enjoyed some time together. And, you know, they were never allowed to drink inside the church or anything like that. But just, you know, be normal and enjoy other people's company.
41:08 Speaker 01 So even the fact we're talking about it, the fact that you've done this investigation, the fact that there's Facebook groups, you know, for the people still inside, there are options for them.
41:17 Speaker 03 Totally, yeah. I guess you've got living proof when you see how happy they are. There must be something right about it, something good about it.
41:25 Speaker 01 Richard, am I right in saying that this isn't over for you?
41:27 Speaker 03 No, there's a lot more work to do. I mean, since releasing the podcast nearly a month ago. Yeah, I've had at least another 45 people that I didn't know when I released it contact me with all sorts of information. And this is from around Australia and overseas. And also in some other churches that are not part of this group, but operate in a very similar fashion. Yeah, I don't know exactly where it's all going to go, but I'm certainly, my lines of inquiry are many. I'd say, you know, I'm hoping next year to expand upon this story and really.
42:08 Speaker 03 Really drill into a part of Australian life that most of us don't know about, but that is happening every day, just quietly out there in the suburbs and in our, you know, regional towns and that. There are people living in a way that is not healthy for a large proportion of members, but particularly for young people in there. That the things that are being taught and the things that are being told about the world aren't true, are bullshit. It sets them on a path for a life that no one would really want, I think.
42:43 Speaker 01 Thanks to Richard for helping us to tell this story. We'll leave a link to Richard's podcast, Secrets We Keep, Pray Harder, in the show notes. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous The Baby Doll Serial Killer: America’s Most Unsuspecting Murderer Next Tia Levings Escaped A Trad Wife Cult Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated