Pod Insights True Crime Conversations Meet Heston Russell: The Veteran Falsely Accused Of War Crimes About this episode Heston Russell has lived a life most of us couldn’t imagine. A former special forces commander, he’s been shot at, dropped out of helicopters, and led troops through the chaos of Afghanistan and Iraq.
But it wasn’t until he came home that he faced his toughest fight yet — not against an enemy overseas, but against his own country. Heston and his men were accused of war crimes, and suddenly, he was battling to defend their names against the weight of national headlines and public judgment.
In this episode, we dive into Heston’s intense defamation case against the ABC, but we go deeper, too, into what it’s like to be a soldier at war and what you do when you’re wrongly accused of a crime you didn’t commit.
You can listen to The ABC’s of Heston Russell podcast here https://shows.acast.com/the-abcs-of-heston-russell.
CREDITS
Guest: Heston Russell https://www.instagram.com/hestonrussell/?hl=en
Host: Claire Murphy https://www.linkedin.com/in/claire-murphy-52121979/?originalSubdomain=au
Producer: Tahli Blackman https://www.linkedin.com/in/tahli-blackman-205a891b7/?originalSubdomain=au
Audio Producer: Jacob Round https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacobroundsound/?originalSubdomain=au
GET IN TOUCH
Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960to give us feedback or suggest a case for the podcast.
Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review. You can also leave a comment for us on Spotify.
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,408 words · 2 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 True Crime Conversations acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast was recorded on.
0:08 Speaker 00 Us average Aussie civilians can't ever truly know what it's like to go to war. To be on the ground when the enemy is upon you, guns and IEDs ready to kill and maim. Your life or theirs, a constant battle. For Heston Russell, a special forces combat veteran, it was his job to navigate that on a daily basis when he and his November platoon colleagues landed in Afghanistan. Amongst the dust and the wreckage of years of fighting, Heston had to make decisions that none of us would ever hope to be responsible for. Do I pull the trigger? Do I send my men into that building?
0:52 Speaker 00 Do I continue to engage with the enemy or help retrieve the pieces of my fallen soldier? All of these very important decisions have to also be weighed up against the rule of war that the Australian Defence Force are bound by when on the battlefield. But what if you were accused of breaching those rules? What if the media then ran stories linking your name to the words 'war crimes' without there ever having been a trial?
1:26 Speaker 00 I'm Claire Murphy and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. Heston Russell's been through more than many of us can imagine. He's been shot at, dropped from helicopters, survived tours of Afghanistan and Iraq. He's led his men into uncertain territory, relying on intelligence to point them in the right direction when the enemy looks all too similar to civilians. But it was when he was back home that he faced the challenge that would become his life's purpose. How do you defend yourself when you and your men are accused of war crimes?
2:09 Speaker 00 Even when you have the evidence that the story being told doesn't match up to the reality, but no one will listen? How do you do that when those who had your back 100% while you were in battle, all of a sudden leave you in the dust? Heston sat down with us to discuss his life in uniform and the fight for his and his men's reputations.
2:34 Speaker 00 Heston, thank you so much for agreeing to sit down and have a chat with us today. We've got decades of things to discuss with you today, so we're going to try our best to get through it with you. But I wanted to start kind of back at the beginning because you grew up, when we say in a military family, normally it means like mum or dad served and you become like an army brat and you move around the country a lot. But your type of military family is like grandparents and great grandparents. And we're talking about, you know, a relative who served on the Western Front in World War One. Like you've got a very long family history of military service. So for you as a kid, was there ever an idea that you were going to do anything else other than serve in the military?
3:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm a fifth generation veteran, even my brother served as well. But growing up, you know, dad was in the military and we moved around. And we knew that mum's dad and mum had been in the military, but it wasn't spoken of a lot. It's only been these last few years, going through all these trials and tribulations and media and all the rest, that my ancestral heritage going back five generations has become the topic of conversation. But no, I mean, growing up, going through school, there were all the different machinations of, you know, everything from an astronaut through to Superman, or sorry, Batman at some stage I was going to be.
3:52 Speaker 00 Oh, Batman, got to get that correct.
3:53 Speaker 01 Absolutely, that was my favourite t-shirt. I wouldn't let mum wash it, apparently I'd sneak out at night as a four-year-old and get it from the washing hamper. Being brought up around dad and his mates and their sons and all the aspirational men in my life, particularly as I went through a phase of being overweight and unpopular at high school, it's sort of, I kind of saw myself self-actualised, or at least the most aspirational version of men in my life, being those in the military. And that was more so the influence to me, as opposed to a, you know, desirement to fulfil a family legacy.
4:25 Speaker 00 Let's talk about that struggle. When I've read comments from you or listened to the podcast that you've done, you talk about high school like it was a real trauma time in your life for you. And you talk about, you know, you describe yourself as, you know, the fat, uncool kid, which I know will resonate with so many people listening to this right now. What was that like for you? And I know that you were also the target of bullying. How do you think that shaped, you think, who you've ended up becoming?
4:54 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, I hated it. I just came from a place of not knowing who I was and so readily looking to change myself to fit in. And it's interesting because being where I am now and the experience I've had since, it's actually kind of the personality profile that kind of thrives for Defence Force recruitment. We call it the lost boys, the Peter Pan lost boys syndrome, where, yeah, it's actually really easy to then go on and see a life in the military as, you know, this opportunity, this journey that provides the structure to help you develop an identity. And yeah, it was a really confusing time for me, even on a sexual perspective.
5:34 Speaker 01 Like, I never had a girlfriend. I tried to have a girlfriend. I guess I started to find guys attractive, but more so in an aspirational way. I wanted to be fit like them. I didn't want to be romantic with them. But yeah, and at the same time, it was, you know, parents divorce, all that good stuff. And I just really struggled not having, I guess, a good friend or a good friendship group and mentoring within that that helped me to get through what was a pretty, pretty crazy stage. And I also didn't want to bring that, those troubles home. So I really dealt with them a lot on my own and didn't really tell my parents a lot about what was going on.
6:07 Speaker 00 Was that choice because you knew that your mum and dad's relationship was struggling too? That you didn't want to add to that? Because they did, as you mentioned, separate when you were younger too. Was that part of that decision not to want to bring that to them?
6:19 Speaker 01 I think it was more so about not wanting to, just seeing it as failure and not wanting to, you know, just further, I guess, own up that I was struggling, that I wasn't achieving as high as I expected me to be, or they expected me to be, or more so they wanted me to be happy and all the rest. So I've, I've developed along my life, a good skill of being able to, I guess, gloss over things so as others don't worry about me, essentially.
6:45 Speaker 00 We are gonna bring up your sexuality as it pertains to your actual defamation case later on.
6:52 Speaker 00 In your case, it does become interesting when you factor in that you are in the military
6:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:57 Speaker 00 at that point where you're still trying to figure yourself out.
7:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:01 Speaker 00 What was it like for you to be in that really hyper masculine environment around men who, and I know you've kind of said that there's a little bit of a lost boys perspective there, but you know, the perspective we see of military men are like these tough, sometimes homophobic, like real straight man's man kind of environment. How was that for you when you're trying to figure out who you are when you're in that hyper masculine environment?
7:25 Speaker 01 I think context is key. In particular, I joined the military in two thousand and three, so very different time. And I then joined into the special forces in two thousand and ten.
7:37 Speaker 00 Which is like a whole nother level again, right? Because SAS have got a real expectation on who that man is.
7:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, so SAS in commandos, I joined the commandos in Sydney. And yeah, very hyper masculine, even going through the selection corps. So everyone has a callsign, what you call each other on the radio. So you don't use your names to protect people's identities and.
7:58 Speaker 00 Is this like Maverick and Goose on Top Gun?
8:00 Speaker 01 Kind of, kind of, but more, more structured, more phonetical. Those are, those jet pilots get to make up their own. As the commander, I was an officer and I became a commander, so a platoon commander of forty people in the commandos. Your callsign was always Alpha. So the commander's callsign was Alpha and then my platoon was November. So I was November Alpha. And even throughout your training, it's like, you know, you're the Alpha, you need to be the Alpha male, so on and so forth. And fast forward to the end of my career, I actually coined the phrase alphabetical male because you just need to be as the leader adaptable to achieve the purpose and not get into these personal confrontations with people. But you know, the unit was four hundred men, qualified commandos, plus another, you know,
8:41 Speaker 01 five or six hundred support staff and not one single openly gay person. But again, this was two thousand and ten onwards. And the fascinating part is, you know, like to call someone gay and all the rest was still, you know, derogatory, but in like a jovial way, but. The hard part is explaining to those on the outside that military culture and that hyper operationally focused special forces culture where it really did not matter what you did in your personal life, as long as it did not impact on your ability to deploy at a moment's notice to achieve a mission. You know, we, you know, deployed on a dime to Afghanistan, Iraq, to other theatres of war, to other conflicts, to other emergencies, to help out the government.
9:24 Speaker 01 And it really came down to how good you were at your job and how well you worked together as a team. And that being said, by the time in two thousand and fifteen, when I finally decided and accepted that I was gay, after spending many years trying to literally change the way in which I saw my sexuality, seeing it as a choice, I can tell anyone out there, I went through my own conversion therapy and all the rest, and it definitely is not. But then at that point in time, you know, again, there wasn't another openly gay person in special forces, let alone as an officer, at that time I was a major. And I just made the decision that I didn't need that self affirmation, or that public affirmation of accepting my sexuality within a workplace where I saw it only potentially
10:09 Speaker 01 being something that brought uncertainty into what needed to be a certain environment, which needed to be mission focused and team focused, where I didn't need to have, you know, stigmas or shame that people naturally have through their upbringings, worrying is the boss checking me out in the showers and all the rest. And I didn't need, you know, that entitlement, because my love and my passion was my job. And me accepting myself made me better at my job. And I just accepted that's a part of service, that's a part of putting the mission and team before yourself. But the hardest part in particular was just not having someone like me that I could look forward to. People call it jokingly, that I was like, you know, a bit of a unicorn.
10:51 Speaker 01 You know, Australia's only ever special forces officer who was gay, that we know of. And.
10:57 Speaker 00 They say that about footballers too. There's like, you know, one that actually comes out, who knows how many there actually are.
11:04 Speaker 01 Absolutely. And not having someone that I could see a part of myself in, in front of me as a mentor was really difficult, but it just made me. At an early age, I guess, learn that lesson of self-acceptance, which I know many people struggle with, but coming to that self-acceptance, telling my mum and sister and just those that I wanted to, and just appreciating that so much more of my identity was simply, was more than simply my sexuality. That's a lesson I got to learn very young, well, very young in my growth, as it would be, anyway.
11:36 Speaker 00 I'd love to know how you made it through Adfa, which is the officer training
11:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:40 Speaker 00 facility, because I've known a few people who've gone through that and done true, and they described to me a culture which I have not known to exist in any other training facility.
11:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:53 Speaker 00 There are lots of hazing rituals, there's lots of interesting opinions towards women, and there is essentially a body count for sexual partners for a lot of the officers that I have known in that time. And I don't know if that culture has changed since then, but I, like I say, young man still trying to identify who you are in the world, like, how did you find officer training?
12:19 Speaker 01 When I marched into Adfa in January two thousand and three, I had just turned seventeen, November beforehand, being in school.
12:25 Speaker 00 Such a baby.
12:26 Speaker 01 Being in school from Queensland, so I had a fake ID my whole first year, but um, and that was my first introduction to drinking and to everything. I, I loved Adfa. I loved the military college the year after even more, but I never encountered a lot of that, what you speak of, and I'm interested if they went through Adfa before or after me, because straight from the outset, you're in communal living, you know, there's forty of you living in a building and you live in sort of section hallways, four this end, four that side, each sharing a bathroom and a laundry. And for us, it was four boys this side, four ladies that side, and you were just integrated and everything was mixed from the day dot. And you really had to work together in that communal environment. And it was really enjoyable because you kind of got, you know, sisters and cousins and you
13:09 Speaker 01 were all going through. I loved Adfa because unlike high school, where there was kind of social rankings based off how you looked and popularity and all the rest, we were all at Adfa together, all at a common starting line. And there was just such a fire hose of information, both in academics, but particularly in military training, that we all were going through for the first time together. And one thing that I was very good at was learning things very quickly and a very practical, hands-on learner, and most of the stuff was very practical, hands-on. So it was really enjoyable where you might bring in some high school stigmas of social constructs and all the rest. And but very rapidly, people were exposed based on their competence level and again, how you operated with others in a communal environment. And the fat unpopular kid from high school was very good at doing things practically,
13:54 Speaker 01 learning things quickly. And others were forced to be my friend, including living with me as well. So it was fantastic.
14:00 Speaker 00 And there was such a focus on physical fitness as well.
14:04 Speaker 01 Everything was so really focused on physical fitness and such a great structure and all the resources and gyms and food and everything. So it was really, it really was a great environment. And I'm very lucky I went to Adfa as the little shit of a seventeen-year-old I was before, you know, marching out four years later to become an officer in charge of soldiers.
14:22 Speaker 00 So when you come out of Adfa, you are.
14:24 Speaker 01 I go up to the normal army first.
14:26 Speaker 00 Normal army first?
14:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I go up to the normal army in Townsville for three years and then I try out for the special forces in two thousand and ten.
14:34 Speaker 00 Okay, so it's after special forces training, commando training, that you come out as the commander for November platoon.
14:40 Speaker 01 Correct.
14:41 Speaker 00 You're still quite a young man and the people that you are leading, they have already done tours. They've already been to Afghanistan. Like, these are experienced team members that you're now in charge of. You haven't been deployed to Afghanistan yet by this stage.
14:57 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:58 Speaker 00 What was that like for you to try and come in and lead people who essentially have a lot more experience than you? Is that a tough gig from the get-go?
15:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, really. Impostor syndrome, you know, and inferiority complex and all the rest. The commando selection course was six weeks and then you'd go on for the whole year's worth of training, doing all sorts of specialist courses from fast roping, demolitions, weapons, you know, parachuting and all the rest. And most of your instructors throughout that year's worth of training come from the unit that you're going to go into. And so I'd already got experience to some of these, you know, some of these people that I was going to be in charge of had been instructing me to get my qualifications throughout that whole year. And also, two thousand and ten, you're right, I was twenty-five. And November Platoon was in Afghanistan for part of that time. And they suffered a helicopter crash that killed three members.
15:50 Speaker 01 Tim Appleton, Ben Chuck and Scott Palmer and injured a bunch more. So then when I took over November Platoon, it was off the back of that, off the back of, like you say, I was the youngest person in the platoon. A platoon full of warriors who had deployed multiple times beforehand and who had just recently on their last deployment encountered one of the greatest, you know, tragic incidents and losses of life. So it was really, really difficult from a on paper, holy cow, I'm not good enough for this. And as I talk about when I do a lot of my public speaking in the book and in the podcast I've done, it was one of the greatest lessons I've learned in leadership where it just comes down to being competent in your craft, being good at your job. My job as a platoon commander was to be an expert in leadership and planning.
16:35 Speaker 01 And as a part of that leadership, it's to bring in the experience of those in my team to collaborate as we communicate and plan, ultimately be the person to decide and accept the responsibility for the plan, whether it's good or bad, whatever the results are. And then, you know, go through the process of forming, norming and storming and bringing people together. But first and foremost, like being proficient at your job with that group of people, it didn't matter how much of a good bloke you were. You can come in there and try and make friends with everyone. They don't care. They've seen commanders come and go and they've, you know, experienced the tip of the spear stuff that no matter how good a bloke you are, you know, you can still suffer tragedies overseas on operations. So if my job was to be the best I could be at my job,
17:18 Speaker 01 earn their respect through doing my job and then from there, looking for the opportunities to draw on their collective knowledge and provide the best outcomes for the missions that were our ultimate purpose together.
17:30 Speaker 00 Can I ask you a bit about the training that you've kind of touched on a bit there? I know it's a part of your training to become desensitized to killing human beings. Now that is just a fact of being in the military, even if you find it abhorrent as, you know, a citizen. It's just part of what you have to learn. Can you talk me through a little bit about how how you become desensitized to killing another human being? It seems such a foreign idea for us.
17:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's not so much overt, like you're not sat down in front of PowerPoint presentations and videos, you know, watching people die and all the rest. It's kind of ingrained from even basic training entering into the military. You have to go to the range and learn how to shoot the rifle and the targets you shoot at, have, you know, sort of the outlines of people, like an armed person running at you, through to just so much of the training that you do, whether it's blank fire training and scenarios, you know, you're shooting at people, you're shooting at each other, you're playing, dressing up, playing the enemy against each other.
18:29 Speaker 00 When you say dressing up like the enemy, is it the enemy of the year time? Like, is it, because I'm presuming at some stage it would have been German soldiers in our history and now it seems, you know, still Middle Eastern people who aren't wearing uniforms. Like, are we talking about dressing up like that?
18:45 Speaker 01 Great question. So throughout basic training, so throughout my Adfa days and even in my time in the normal infantry up in Townsville. So the military has developed this doctrinal enemy called the Missourians that have their own uniforms, their own weapons, their own equipment. We basically designed a whole doctrinal enemy force that are per like the conventional land on land, air on air, sea on sea battle. Then when you go into specific training for deployments and operations like in the special forces, that's indeed when we adapted it to the specific role players and outfits and all the rest that we encountered within where we were going in the Middle East or where we were going in Iraq.
19:25 Speaker 00 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Claire Murphy. I'm speaking with Heston Russell, the Australian Special Forces veteran who won a defamation case against the ABC over false war crime allegations. Up next, Heston tells me about his first deployment to Afghanistan.
19:49 Speaker 00 So I love that your first deployment to Afghanistan wasn't like the standard military deployment, because you got to escort then Prime Minister Julia Gillard to Afghanistan. Can you tell me what that was like?
20:04 Speaker 01 Yes, I was her personal security officer. So for ease of explanation, I was her personal one-on-one bodyguard. And yeah, you're right. Again, I've been chomping at the bit to deploy to Afghanistan. This is November 2011. But my first job was manning the counterterrorism, which is, you know, the critical response requirement in Australia. And these trips come up and we need to provide protective security detachments. And given that she is the Prime Minister, she had to attend all these very high-level security meetings. And also the great diplomatic opportunity there is, being with her and having the conversations that are needed, you know, to help our own equities and others. You know, it was put forward that I should be her personal security officer. Apparently, I was a quite jovial, good-looking person in uniform as well.
20:49 Speaker 00 You're an affable guy, yes.
20:52 Speaker 01 And you can imagine straight away, I just went straight back into that inferiority complex and that imposter syndrome. It's like, holy cow, like, this is our nation's leader. I haven't been to Afghanistan beforehand, you know, surely I should have some deployments and experience. But again, it comes down to what are the specific skills and drills you require for that? I'm one person within a protective team and then a whole security architecture around that. My job is just to be an expert in my job, focusing on her and doing what's required there. And it was really incredible. I left that deployment with an excellent impression of Julia Gillard. Whereas previously, just watching on TV and all the politics, I did not. I saw very prepared speeches. I saw so much politics
21:37 Speaker 01 and segues and all the rest. And I got to really spend some personal one-on-one time with her. And the conversations she openly had with me as well, really helped me to see so much of the natural leadership potential she had, or the leadership potential, be it natural or not. And it also made me quite, you know, sympathetic to the fact that she wasn't able To show a lot of that, just given the nature of politics. And I personally think that is one of the saddest revelations is that, you know, someone like her was not able to truly shine with all the skills that I have seen. And I say that now, coming from someone who's been responsible for selecting and training special forces, soldiers and officers. Um, you know, there's something wrong with our system where, you know, politics takes precedence over real leadership.
22:22 Speaker 00 Can you take me to your first tour of Afghanistan, not as Julia Gillard's personal bodyguard, but when you do go with November Platoon and you are in Afghanistan?
22:31 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
22:32 Speaker 00 What is that like on the ground? When I envision what it's like, I'm only piecing together things that I've seen in news footage or from movies. And, you know, it feels very scary and very dusty. And the enemy can also look like a civilian and the civilian can look like the enemy. Like, it seems like a really confusing place. And, you know, when you're talking about an enemy that is not organised in the way that a traditional enemy is organised too. So you're not fighting on a front. Essentially, it could be around any corner. Tell me what that's like to step into that for the first time.
23:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, surreal, very surreal is the best explanation I can give. Uh, you do so much training and preparation. And particularly in the role of special forces over there, you know, we went out hunting bad people. We were watching them with assets in the sky and working with all sorts of three-letter agencies to track them from mobile phones through the satellites, through all the rest. So you really had a great picture of who you were going after and why you were going after them and what their likely reactions or actions may be. But in particular, Claire, there was, you know, that threat of IEDs, improvised explosive devices, about, you know, the enemy beneath the ground that could, you know, be activated by a child, you know, that could be detonated by someone's phone, that we couldn't detect them all
23:54 Speaker 01 because they're removing metal from the press switches and. Yeah, it's, you know, living with this sense of paranoia, wherever you step, like wherever you step, um, you know, could be an explosion. And in particular, I guess our mindset was not wanting to harm others and making sure you're doing right by your own skills and drills. And then at the same time, you know, going after these targets that were also happily putting themselves right in the middle of villages filled with women and children and all the rest. And you just have to be so on the ball, you know, even shooting your personal weapon system, you would only shoot in those close proximities when you literally had the sight on someone and knew if the bullet went through them, where it would hit behind to make sure
24:38 Speaker 01 it didn't injure someone else, a civilian or whatnot. It just brought on this hyper sense of vigilance. You know, we talk about hyper vigilance as a, as a military thing, but it was pretty incredible, particularly from a mental health perspective with hindsight, looking back, living in the moment. I've never lived so much in the moment in my life. Hmm. And it's a pretty incredible place to be from your own mental capabilities and physical capabilities, to be so physically, mentally and emotionally focused into that moment and on such a rapid repetition through all the missions that we conducted. And while those first missions were extremely surreal, uh, you kind of warm up into it pretty quickly
25:21 Speaker 01 because you're also there, you're not there alone, you're there with a lot of people. And I particularly remember that first mission, again, just so afraid that I was going to stumble over and look like an idiot in front of my guys or whatever. You kind of, you kind of draw strength from that team. You just know that you've trained and prepared together so well, and you truly trust these people with your life. It's, again, I have great conversations with my psychologist these days. Some of the biggest struggles in transitioning are realizing that there's not a lot of people out there who are willing to have your back as much as someone like me is willing to have theirs. And the extreme comfort and confidence that comes from having that trust that these people you're with will just have your back to the
26:04 Speaker 01 point of giving up their life if they need to, and you the same. Just allowing you to then bring all that presence forward into what you need to do. And being so well skilled, drilled, equipped and supported in what we were doing. You know, I talk about Maslow's hierarchy of needs being that self actualisation and I call it that state of flow. I've never felt so aligned in what I've been doing and so present brought on by the stresses of those and unique circumstances of those situations.
26:31 Speaker 00 You talk quite a bit about mental health these days and not just of your own, but of your fellow members who have served, but I'd really like to just touch on a couple of points that I wonder what your mental health is like in the aftermath of. And the first is losing a colleague while you're serving. So you've spoken about one of your men who stepped on an IED in a doorway in a village and you go into like a fair bit of detail about how he essentially exploded into a thousand pieces in front of you. And it's like, what, like, how do you, how do you even compartmentalise or even process that?
27:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a really great question because like I said before this, I've been writing my own book the last four years. And one of those chapters, I go into great detail about the death of Scott James Smith, who died on the 21st of October, 2012. And it was in writing that chapter where I go into just such granular detail about, you know, he was killed, he was blown up into a thousand pieces over 300 metres. And, you know, at that same time, the enemy attacked because this giant plume of dust went up and, you know, there were the burliest alpha male commandos up there fighting to keep the enemy back while the other half were on their hands and knees, with the most tender hands, picking up every little piece of Scott from, you know, a limb to a little five cent
27:58 Speaker 01 piece of coin size. And I gave that chapter to his mother, Katrina, and asked her permission to publish it. And she got back to me and she said, thank you, this has helped me to heal. They told me, you know, that Scott died instantly and, you know, he didn't feel anything. But I've always wanted to ask more. But I've always been too afraid to ask any of you that were there because I never wanted to re-traumatise you.
28:20 Speaker 00 Hmm.
28:20 Speaker 01 And she's like, this has helped me to heal. And so many other Australians need to read this. Because we too easily don't glorify, but perhaps romanticise or gloss over the loss of life. But it's devastating. It's it's incredible to just see what can be done to a person that does not deserve to die that way. But at the same time, it's so incredible to also be so inspired by someone that it has happened to in the line of service, doing what they wanted to do with the people they wanted to do for a purpose they so believed in. And also just reflecting on the incredible emotions.
28:59 Speaker 01 I mean, I remember when Scott died, I felt angry and then immediately I felt failure because I was his commander, you know? I was meant to bring him home, even if we were around the same age and all the rest, you know, it's. And I carried that for me such a long time. And it's only through friends and family and again, staying close to and linking in with Scott's family that I've been able to heal that myself.
29:22 Speaker 00 Then of course, there's the flip side to that too, because whilst you are all putting your lives on the line, there are Afghani people who are doing exactly the same. First of all, like, how do you, in that moment, especially the first time, make that decision to take somebody's life? And then secondly, I'd really like to know, and this is something I think a lot of us civilians don't understand, is the accountability of that.
29:49 Speaker 01 For sure. I guess, you know, one thing about going up against people, and like you said, the Afghans, you know, feeling like they're defending their lands as well. I mean, very specifically, we were targeting insurgents and terrorist networks there as a special forces. But you would definitely encounter perhaps some locals who were trying to defend themselves. But in particular, we go into places where Taliban or insurgents had gone in and were actually kind of not holding the locals hostage, but pretty much, you know, dictating to them what could or couldn't be done. And particularly when we would go on target, we'd always go on target with our Afghan partner force. So we had to go on every mission with a group of Afghan special police. And straight away, they were the incredible ones who could speak to locals and the locals straight away would be giving up who's not meant to be here
30:33 Speaker 01 and where they are and where all their equipment is. So. It's really, there's so much of this narrative that the public doesn't get to hear about, but part of the storytelling is part of that process. And then it's this battle of wills. Like you said, we're there to do a job. And even the insurgents and terrorists and all that, they are fully ideological into that they are doing the right thing. At the end of the day, it's a contest of wills. And you just have to be so focused on your mission. And when it comes to the taking of life, nine times out of 10, the focus wasn't to go in there and kill them, unless it was a specific job, but it was to achieve the mission. And the taking of life came from a circumstance of protecting life, protecting each other, protecting your own.
31:14 Speaker 01 You know, we were really restricted, to be honest, in our rules of engagement to the point of, I remember the first time I had to kill someone, I probably let it go a bit for longer, to a point where he started pointing his weapon at some of our friendly forces. And so as I was fully legally justified in pulling the trigger and taking his life. And again, that was just part of the mission. So it's really fascinating because there are so many elements to doubt and hesitate throughout combat. It's not, while you think you're out there, you know, it's so easy to potentially take everyone's life. There are assets and drones and satellites all overhead filming everything that we're doing, through to helmet cameras and everything else in between.
31:55 Speaker 01 Then there's just the whole moral and ethical part of the training and preparation that goes into us before we deploy. Probably quite different for me, but I got to see it very viscerally on the ground, where most of my soldiers had family, let's say at least half, if not two thirds of my soldiers were married. Most of them, half of them had kids of their own and really felt and attached themselves to the fact that these were other human beings, other families as well. I remember in particular, there was one engagement we had where an American tank went through this building and knocked down all the rubble. And this mother was screaming because her child was under there.
32:36 Speaker 01 And straight away, I just watched my guys drop their equipment, completely lose their own, you know, safety posture and get in there and dig out this child. And so fortunately, he was just sitting there under this gap in the rubble, smiling up, no worries at all. But I just really got to see, and then straight away, I'm like, no, what are you doing with a job to do? But straight away, like they were dads and just seeing this, you know. Seeing this human side of them cut through all this super hard conditioning, special forces training, you know, it could have been a trap, you know, we, there were all sorts of things that people had played on us beforehand. The building could have had an IED in it, who knows? They didn't care. They cared more about that child than they did for their own safety. And that's the sort of people you deployed with.
33:17 Speaker 00 You spent sixteen years serving and you've served in Afghanistan and in Iraq, but you do decide in twenty nineteen to retire. Like, what brought you to that decision? And what was that like for you to transition back to civilian life?
33:31 Speaker 01 For sure. Well, twenty sixteen, seventeen, I deployed to Iraq. That was my last deployment in our fight against ISIS. And most of the public doesn't even know we deployed special forces personnel to that. But that was incredible. We were fighting evil people who were doing terrible things to children and just, just evil. I never felt so justified in war against a group of people in my life. At the same time, I was over there with someone who was going to come back and be the future leader of our special forces, who I just saw as being narcissistic, arrogant and an absolutely toxic leader. And I got to work very closely with him. And on that deployment, I was actually dating, and I was actually, I had a boyfriend, Blake, back in L A. And unlike every other deployment I'd been on,
34:16 Speaker 01 I was in love with someone back home. And while I felt very accomplished in what we were doing, I became disillusioned in my senior leadership. I became very disillusioned in the Australian leadership because I was primarily operating under the US leadership and got to see just how much more confident they were in backing their people on the ground and removing politics from what needed to be done. And I decided to come back and take my long service leave, spend time with Blake and really wanted to instead pivot my life to focus on love and focus on building us a life outside of the uncertainty of the military.
34:51 Speaker 00 I love that. As much as it's like a big transition for you, I love that love was the catalyst. That's gorgeous.
34:57 Speaker 01 But it was, yeah, it was an interesting transition in that. Identity and failing to understand identity. And we touched on this at the start, going from being a lost teenager to having my identity indoctrinated into the military where it puts service and team before yourself. So then accepting my sexuality and then jumping into my first ever public relationship and then bringing a brand called Barry's Bootcamp and being very public in the media and that to Sydney. I immediately traded this secret identity of being a special forces officer and commando and military service and the values of selflessness, responsibility, courage
35:41 Speaker 01 for a society which rapidly became about selfishness and entitlement. And you know, you've got to represent yourself first or people, you know, will pass you over. Through to defining myself by the job that I did and the relationship I was with. And not appreciating that while I was emotionally intelligent, I wasn't emotionally mature. I never had to deal with emotions like jealousy. I never had to deal with having to have vulnerable conversations about emotions that I saw as weakness as opposed to growth opportunities, you know?
36:15 Speaker 00 Now you just had to be like one of us.
36:17 Speaker 01 Oh, well, I was so used to being the master of my universe in life or death, combat situations and everything else in between. And so used to being seen as being an inspirational leader and being seen, you know, as being, you know, a leader and all the rest by my soldiers. And I put myself on a pedestal and I wasn't ready to remove myself from that and face the realities of life that do not comply with the extremes of life and death.
36:49 Speaker 00 After the break, I asked Keston what he was doing on the day the ABC article about his alleged war crimes was published and what the impact was.
37:02 Speaker 00 It's 2020, pandemic is upon us, but you wake up one morning and your phone is blowing up.
37:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:09 Speaker 00 Talk me through the day the ABC story dropped.
37:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, so it was the exact day, the eighth anniversary of the day we lost Scott, the 21st of October 2020. Now, when we got back from overseas, we, as a group, met with Scott's mum, Scott's sister, went down and spread his ashes down there at the lake where he used to ski as a kid. But we hadn't really seen Scott's family since then. And on that day, we'd all planned to meet up again with his mum Katrina at the North Bondi RSL to all have dinner that night. And it was that exact morning that I woke up to, yeah, my phone just buzzing off the table. And it was messages from all my guys sending me this link to this article where this journalist, Mark Willis, and his mates had published that this whole story, that essentially this marine
37:57 Speaker 01 had heard a pop, which meant that we had, and it literally said November Platoon, had executed this bound prisoner that we had because it wouldn't fit on a helicopter. And it was just incredible because you might hear about a generic story about a unit or someone in the military or whatnot, but this had specifically, for the first time in our nation's history, named a platoon, November Platoon. And that could only be 30 or 40 people, that specific platoon in 2012, and that was us. And I was the commander, there was no one above me, I was November Alpha. So it was so surreal and on that day, you just could imagine the emotions that flew through.
38:40 Speaker 01 So I just set about, I called the APC, left two messages with them, and I just started reaching out to some of my former commanders and waiting to hear from someone from the Defence Public Affairs or someone to jump onto this, but. No one got back to me. And that night, yeah, when I went and met with the guys and met with Katrina Scott's mum, there were so many emotions, so many tears, so many people just like, what do we do about this? By this time, the Burton Report and Inquiry had been dragging on and it really caused a lot of damage, bringing some of us who had been out back in to show us some pretty graphic stuff and try and interrogate us. And yeah, a lot of people were really emotionally bruised and damaged. And that was kind of when I got given my new mission. You know, by this time, I'd broken up with Blake at the very start
39:25 Speaker 01 of the pandemic and I was a bit isolated and alone. And next thing this fight came about, they were targeting my guys. And if there's one thing you can't do, it's target them without dealing with me. So that set me off on the next five years.
39:39 Speaker 00 So this unnamed marine who claims to have heard the pop, because the way it's supposedly unfolded, so there's a radio conversation where your guys on the ground say, we've got seven prisoners who require transport. This unnamed person said there was only room for six on the helicopter. And then he claims that he heard a pop. And then the next radio transmission was now we have six prisoners in to transport. And so his summation was that Australian soldiers had just murdered a prisoner in order for that to happen. But I'm really interested to know, did you, first of all, did you recognise this unnamed marine? Because he eventually would do interviews with his face on show. And I presume that
40:24 Speaker 00 you would have maybe got into that helicopter with him. Did you know who this person was?
40:27 Speaker 01 It was so incredible. Surely afterwards, the guys and I got together and we wrote this 10 page letter to the ABC that just went line by line, how impossible this is. And if everyone wants to see it, hestonrussell.com slash ABC. I've literally made a page where I've kept a running blog of this whole thing.
40:44 Speaker 00 Just to give some idea, it's basically like, in order for that to happen, someone's radio had to have been like, on at the exact moment for it to be transmitted. And that just wouldn't have happened that way. And the prisoners wouldn't have been near the radio. Like, there's a lot of, like, reasoning as to why that would have happened.
40:58 Speaker 01 The only people who talk to the helicopters to come in are either Me, my signaler or my JTAC, we all stay together. We are never anywhere near prisoners because you don't want them hearing what you're saying. Right the way through to this guy said that he just watched us tackle and hogtie them. It was a nighttime operation, Helmand Province, he said, he was in a gunship, which means they never land. So he's flying around at a couple of thousand feet. How did he physically see that? You can't carry someone once you've hogtied them, like there's just all these impracticalities to it. And then the kicker for me was, you know, this was now twenty twenty when the article was being published. So some eight years later, he had decided that that pop was us executing someone. And then he's decided to come forward.
41:39 Speaker 01 And the crazy part for me was that the media was allowed to publish this as one person's ear witness account, ear witness, without having it met any form of criminal level of evidence or investigation. Like it should have been something, there was literally this inspector general inquiry underway. It's something that should have been turned over, investigated before just so freely naming an entire platoon right there on that day. And if they'd even done their research, like Scott Smith was a member of November Platoon. You know, if they'd done any of their research, they would realise, hey, we're publishing this once in a lifetime accusation on the anniversary of the death of the one guy from that platoon during that deployment. It was just absolutely mind boggling.
42:24 Speaker 01 And as far as like my brain snapping, you could just imagine the internal conflict I was going through.
42:31 Speaker 00 Tell me about that trauma of having that story go live. Because we are very aware about the sometimes fragile mental health of veterans who have served and that the suicide rate for veterans is abysmally high. What does that do to your team, to your men, when allegations like that are printed? Like, what's the immediate aftermath of that for them?
42:56 Speaker 01 It was devastating. It was like a bomb went off within our group where our entire career, that entire deployment is all done outside of public knowledge. You know, you're not even allowed to have a social media account in your name. We have protected identity status. We do all these things in the silence because it needs to be done. And part of what we do is also saving people from knowing some of the bad things that need to be done in order to keep the world that we enjoy safe. And all of a sudden, for the only public record about your platoon and your service to be. The allegation that you're a war criminal, you know, and as it gained more and more media traction, you know, I had soldiers saying to me, hey, my daughters came home from school, where this was discussed by her teacher and others.
43:39 Speaker 01 And she said that that's my daddy's platoon and little kids were calling her dad a war criminal. You know, children were having these conversations in schools. That's the flow-on effect, right the way through to, you know, even some of my guys are applying for jobs in the unstable life that often is the transition of a veteran. And, you know, they chose to remove their military service or service in the special forces from being on their resume. They've never been charged, although convicted as war criminals, but in the court of public opinion, some journalist has callously published an ear witness account of one person as fact without even interviewing a single one of us who were there on the mission. You know, it just sent these shockwaves where some people just did not want to be associated
44:21 Speaker 01 with our service because the only public record was that we were war criminals.
44:26 Speaker 00 He's mentioned that you wrote to the ABC, you also reached out to the ABC, but they weren't the only people you, you know, you reached out to, in the Department of Veteran Affairs, the Defence Department, you wrote to Peter Dutton, who was the Defence Minister at the time. So you've reached out to lots of people in the aftermath of this. Did anyone step up and support you in that moment?
44:46 Speaker 01 Oh, I submitted two complaints through their proper processes. We stepped up a petition, they got 27,000 signatures through the Parliament. As far as anyone stepping up, Ben Fordham in the media stepped up for me massively and some other members in the media, but none quite like Ben did. And it wasn't until finally I decided to take the ABC to court for defamation, where I received some affidavits from a few people, but unfortunately, others, including the likes of Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott, who I'd had on my podcast beforehand, through to my former military commanders who won distinguished service medals for those same deployments, when none of them were there, when I asked for help going into that fight.
45:31 Speaker 01 I was to rapidly learn a really heavy lesson that in Australia to take on the media is a fight too far for so many, just given how much of a um strong platform they have, you know, if they decide to turn on you, they can so easily destroy your life, which was so fascinating for me because, you know, I'd lived through combat, I lived through real life and death. And even particularly for me, it was my old military commanders who I'd turn to and to see them worried more about their careers and their families back home. So afraid to enter into this fight. It was just so fascinating for me how it was actually more dangerous for, you know, the life I wanted to live back home to take up this fight than it was to fight in actual combat as they accused us of doing, yeah.
46:17 Speaker 01 It was just imagine, just imagine that from, if you can, from what you've heard from me beforehand. The just incredible juxtaposition and, you know, brain crack of these circumstances.
46:27 Speaker 00 You're fighting for your life in such a different way.
46:30 Speaker 01 And in combat, I was so supported and so aligned and had such a team and, you know. And then all of a sudden, you know, to have none of those support anywhere when you need it the most, it was really, you know, sense of abandonment, talk to my psychologist about my sense of abandonment is pretty big.
46:49 Speaker 00 That is still something to laugh at, but that is funny.
46:52 Speaker 01 If you can't laugh at yourself, what can you laugh at? But it's all stuff I really, I really had to work through. And look, it's incredible where situations like this kind of declutter your life as well, potentially to, you know, help you be more efficient in your energy. But yeah, wow, it was a very demoralising, humbling and lonely time, yeah.
47:12 Speaker 00 The reason you actually reached out to Peter Dutton was really quite significant because you had realised that in some of the reporting about this alleged war crime, that the facts were actually quite incorrect and you could prove that if you could get some documents released by the Defence Department about your diplomat. Can you talk me through when you realised that things were not adding up?
47:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, I, I pushed every time the ABC released something, we got into this bit of a back and forward. And every time they released something trying to double down on their story, I was able to pick it apart. And this one time they overstepped, they overstepped so far and they said that they had put a request into the Defence Force for a Freedom of Information um request for the dates between June and July two thousand and twelve, quote, when this incident occurred. And straight away, I dug up my old deployment record, which showed that I didn't deploy with my platoon until July. We didn't commence operations until August, and we didn't go into Helmand Province, where it was said this incident occurred, until September. And straight away, I jumped on this and I wrote to Peter Dutton and all I just said, you know, can you please
48:19 Speaker 01 make my deployment order public for once and for all? We can prove, you know, how wrong they are. And yeah, 30 days later, as per the ministerial requirement, he wrote back to me with a lovely hand saluted letter saying, you know, I've always thought our veterans deserve more respect. And if you need help, including mental health or welfare support, here's the welfare hotline. So instead, I took to my social media and very quickly, the ABC changed their article and said during 2012 and wrote a little footnote that was a complete lie to the public. And that was a point where I was like, wow, this isn't about facts. This isn't about truth. This is about winning this now public argument.
49:00 Speaker 01 And the person who is the minister responsible for me and my soldiers, who could have helped end this in a single stroke of a pen, is not even willing to enter into this fray.
49:10 Speaker 00 Talk me through some of the allegations that were put up against you. One, which was very easily refuted after you showed extra footage from a helmet cam.
49:22 Speaker 01 Oh.
49:22 Speaker 00 And another, which included men under your charge who supposedly murdered prisoners. Can you just tell me through those allegations and, and why you were able to show that they were not true?
49:36 Speaker 01 Absolutely. So during my court case, the ABC quickly published this follow on story that said they had footage of a commander shooting at unarmed civilians out of a helicopter. And it was from 15 seconds worth of footage they received from an end of trip video. Now, because it was during my court case, I had to sit on it, but my legal team wrote to them and said, hey, one, well, they said it was me. So they said, one, it's not our client. Two, they're not unarmed civilians. And three, why have you edited this footage to add extra gunshot noises at this time and this time where they weren't beforehand? And the ABC never got back to us, but they decided to drop their truth defence, which relied on that piece of evidence. So then, two years later, Channel Seven Spotlight worked with me to do a whole episode,
50:18 Speaker 01 breaking down, you know, how they had professionally added this extra noise. And I'd actually given the ABC the full five minutes' worth of helmet cam footage that I had from that deployment, that showed the entire sequence of us following these enemy, the guy turning, and there's me in the camera. Us, me ordering him to shoot, because over the radio, we'd heard this person had picked up a weapon, and we were flying in a helicopter above, very, very vulnerable. And then, at the very end of the video, it showed me ordering the helicopter to land, the two of us getting out, and the two of us going after these enemy, only to get into an ambush. And in the footage, you see us getting shot at, you hear the bullet zipping past, and us to fire back.
51:01 Speaker 01 And all of that has never been produced by the ABC. All of that went under the carpet, and instead, they took down the video once we publicly exposed that they'd added extra gunshots. And the whole narrative has been about that. So we provided them with all the real footage, and I sat there and offered to do an interview and talk through it all with them. But again, it's just been doubling down, doubling down, and no matter how many times we bring real evidence from those on the ground, the narrative has been to try and defend this story and to attack me for being, for daring to step up and take it on.
51:33 Speaker 00 Well, what is so interesting is, by the time this actually reaches court, like, the drama continues, because there is like a pre-trial hearing where we decide whether it's going to go to trial or not, and that all seems to go well and good, and then the ABC has a truth defence in place. But then, because you've refuted so many of these claims, they have to drop the truth defence and go with public interest. And then, eventually, they also drop that one. And so, we think, oh, okay, the trial's now not going to go ahead, they're going to have to apologise to you and potentially pay you out for defamation. But then Ben Fordham finds this unnamed marine.
52:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, Josh.
52:13 Speaker 00 Talk to me about what happened.
52:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:15 Speaker 00 Josh, the unnamed marine, talk to me about what happened after that.
52:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, so when the ABC originally published this article, this marine who heard a pop, they gave him the pseudonym Josh. But they still published his name, his unit and all these details about him. And for a long time.
52:28 Speaker 00 And his face too, like we saw his face unobstructed, right? Yeah.
52:32 Speaker 01 So, so when it came to the part where after they dropped their truth defence and the ABC said, hey, we're going to drop our public interest defence and drop it completely because we don't want to break the ethical line of journalism and have to reveal our source. That's when, you know, Ben Fordham and my legal team come out like, hey, we actually know who Josh is and we've tracked him down just based off the information you've made public. And he's actually, his name's Dean and he's a salesperson here and I won't say anything more, but. Then we got to the part where ABC's like, well, okay, if you already know who he is, then let's have this defence out and see what happens. It was just, I remember the, the judge, Justice Lee, said this is turning into an absolute farce. And it really was, all at taxpayers' expense.
53:17 Speaker 00 So eventually it does land in your favour and you do get a payout from this. But then in all of the correspondence I have seen in the public since then, is the ABC saying that they have apologised to you several times. Um, and that they have made it very clear on articles that they are, you know, misleading or incorrect. And again, they've apologised to you.
53:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
53:40 Speaker 00 Have you received an apology or at least one that you feel is significant enough to cover you for the fact that you've been fighting this for so long?
53:47 Speaker 01 Well, this is the issue and this is where Brian does a great job in the podcast, the ABCs of Heston Russell, to really break down this gaslighting campaign of theirs about the apology. So when I won my defamation case, the defamation case found the ABC and the two journalists, Josh Robertson and Mark Willissey, liable for defamation, but, and to, to pay damages, but the ABC pays for all their personal damages. And then because we originally entered into the, uh, case, just asking for them to apologise and to take the stories down. They then had to pay all of my legal costs. So it was a multimillion dollar bill I had to pay on top. They then went on to, one, refused to apologise to me, uh, post the defamation case. And then only after we exposed their adding of gunshots to the footage.
54:32 Speaker 01 Did they release apology that was generic to all the members of the Second Commander Regiment? And then when I took it even further and I had to conduct this internal review by one of their own staff members, former staff members, they issued an apology saying, hey, while Heston Russell wasn't named in this, he has taken offence to it and we apologise to him for that.
54:51 Speaker 00 Because you've taken offence to it?
54:52 Speaker 01 Isn't that, yeah, you can apologise for the action or you can apologise for the effect. And as opposed to apologising for their actions, they're apologising that I took offence, which is pretty insulting, to be honest.
55:03 Speaker 00 I'm sorry that you're offended.
55:04 Speaker 01 Ah, that's it, that's it. Isn't it incredible? And this is, this is the incredible part for me, Claire, like, we're in 2025 with the national broadcaster that every taxpayer funds over a billion dollars a year, asking for adults to apologise, whether they were errors or otherwise, but have since been proven in the federal court to have been wrong. And for me, where does that stand as far as the morals and ethics we accept in society where we're not even willing to apologise? Even like the, the head of the ABC who wasn't personally responsible for publishing the article. And I've written to them, when particularly with the new managing director and saying, hey, let me spell this out for you. In the federal court proceedings, you submitted on record that you had footage of me
55:47 Speaker 01 shooting from a helicopter at unarmed civilians and that I could be liable of to being, you know, breaking the rules of war or committing a war crime. You need to apologise for that because that is still on the public record. The Guardian published it as a front page piece and it's still online if you search for Heston Russell shooting at unarmed civilians. And they still refuse to, they're saying, no, we have apologised, like, no, you haven't. So we're in 2025 arguing over an apology.
56:11 Speaker 00 What I do want to land on here finally, though, Heston, is that we have seen other Australian soldiers
56:20 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
56:20 Speaker 00 who whilst have not been criminally charged with war crimes, they have been in other cases where they have been found to have committed war crimes. So we as the Australian people are concerned that There's kind of this two arguments here. We need journalists to tell us the truth about what our soldiers are doing on the ground to make sure that they are accountable for what happens, you know, on the field of war. On the other hand, we don't want our defence force to be unfairly accused of things that they have not done. How do we find the line here? Because we're being told that, yes, these things are happening, but at the same time we hear your story and we're like, we don't want that to happen to anyone ever again.
57:01 Speaker 01 Absolutely. It's called due process and the actual court system. So the issue is that people like myself have had to go through civil defamation proceedings. And the issue here that most people don't understand is the difference between civil and criminal prosecution. You know, if journalists were truly focused on justice, then they would take such accusations like a marine hearing a pop and saying that we'd killed someone to the authorities. There was specifically, you know, the Office of the Special Investigator that is costing the taxpayer fifty eight million dollars a year that's been set up by the government to investigate any accusations of war crimes from Afghanistan, to take it to them and have them gather evidence to meet the thresholds of charging someone criminally, to then be
57:45 Speaker 01 tested beyond reasonable doubt in a criminal court by a jury. What is happening is we're caught up in this place where journalists can publish whatever they want, as long as they can justify in civil proceedings that it meets the balance of probabilities for public interest, because it is now such a public interest case. And this has been my frustrations. We developed this Veterans Protection Act and tried to get both parties to agree to it before this election, is that as a society, we absolutely need to hold our veterans accountable for all of our actions, particularly in combat. We've now had a royal commission of events and veteran suicide, all the rest, and the examples from my story and the impact this has.
58:27 Speaker 01 Can we not simply agree to afford those who've been in combat, the presumption of innocence and due process to have any evidence brought before a criminal court and not be played out in civil proceedings? To be allowed to defend ourselves in a court and not have to pay out of our own pockets to launch a defamation case to clear our names? That's the simple ask. And it's just simply reinforcing the legal process, not the media process. Not chasing stories that, under the provise of public interest. But public interest is about, you know, true justice, you know, about truly determining if there were war crimes and to truly holding people accountable, not a lot of the circus that's been played out publicly.
59:11 Speaker 01 So that's, that's my answer to your question.
59:15 Speaker 00 Thank you to Heston for sharing his story with us. You can listen to all seven episodes of the ABCs of Heston Russell podcast now. You'll find a link to that in our show notes. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted by me, Claire Murphy, and produced by Tali Blackman, with audio design by Jacob Round. Thank you so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous Escaping One Of Australia's Most Secretive Cults [re-release] Next "I Had to Kill Him": The Woman Who Survived Dirty John Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated