Pod Insights True Crime Conversations "I Had to Kill Him": The Woman Who Survived Dirty John About this episode "Dirty John" Meehan, a serial con artist and violent criminal, was Terra Newell's stepfather. He had married her mother and spent years manipulating and abusing her until she finally left him. Enraged by her departure, he sought revenge.
One day, after finishing her shift at work, Terra was walking to her car when John suddenly grabbed her from behind, wrapping his arm around her waist and trying to abduct her.
In a desperate attempt to escape, she bit him. But his response was brutal—he began stabbing her repeatedly with a large knife.
With every ounce of strength she had, Terra fought for her life. In a fierce struggle, she managed to knock the knife from his hand. Realising the only way to survive was to stop him for good, she knew she had to act fast.
This is the story of Dirty John’s demise, told by the woman who lived through it.
CREDITS
Guest: Terra Newell https://www.instagram.com/terranewell/?hl=en
Host: Gemma Bath
https://www.linkedin.com/in/claire-murphy-52121979/?originalSubdomain=auProducer: Tahli Blackman https://www.linkedin.com/in/tahli-blackman-205a891b7/?originalSubdomain=au
Audio Producer: Jacob Round https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacobroundsound/?originalSubdomain=au
GET IN TOUCH
Email us at [email protected] mailto:[email protected] or send us a voice note https://help.mamamia.com.au/en-US/send-a-podcast-voice-note-467960to give us feedback or suggest a case for the podcast.
Rate or review us on Apple by clicking on the three dots in the top right-hand corner, click Go To Show then scroll down to the bottom of the page, click on the stars at the bottom and write a review. You can also leave a comment for us on Spotify.
If any of the contents in this episode have caused distress, know that there is help available via Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636.
We acknowledge the Traditional Owners of the Land we have recorded this podcast on, the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation. We pay our respects to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures.
Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 True Crime Conversations acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast was recorded on.
0:07 Speaker 01 It's a Saturday afternoon in August 2016, and Terra Newell has finished up her shift at Rebel Run, a dog kennel in Newport Beach. She has exciting plans tonight. She's off to see one of her favourite country stars perform with a friend. Cash, her miniature Australian shepherd, jumps into the backseat of her Toyota Prius for the five-kilometre drive home. As she pulls into her car park, she notices an unfamiliar car. Her dog starts growling as they spot a man fidgeting in the back. Maybe he's homeless, she thinks, living in his car? As she hops out of the driver's seat and makes towards the exit, the man grabs her
0:49 Speaker 01 around the waist, looking her straight in the eye as he says, "Do you remember me?" It's John Meehan, her mother's estranged husband, a man she and her sisters discovered and unveiled as a serial con man and criminal, a man she has feared for a long, long time. She struggles, but he's bigger, stronger. He covers her mouth, she bites him. He starts stabbing her with a large knife, again and again and again. Tara fights for her life. As the seconds drag by, she finds herself on the floor, kicking up at John with sturdy work boots. She manages to knock the knife out of his hand. It lands right by her.
1:33 Speaker 02 I didn't give it a second thought and I just started whiling on him and stabbing him. Because I know that if I didn't fight back and wound him, he would continue to try to hurt me and possibly kill me.
2:00 Speaker 01 I'm Gemma Buff and this is True Crime Conversations, a Mamma Mia podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. Terra Newell fatally stabbed John Meehan 13 times in total. Her last blow went straight through his eye. Of all of Deborah Newell's four children, Tara was seen as the most softly spoken, the least competitive, the sweet one who would never hurt a fly. But at the age of 25, she killed a man who tried to take her life in an act of self-defence. Orange County prosecutor Matt Murphy once told us on this very podcast...
2:44 Speaker 03 That's one of the few cases that truly, you know, when you work homicides, you see a lot of really sad things and that was the happiest ending I encountered in almost two decades doing that work.
2:56 Speaker 01 This was a man who had a kidnap kit waiting for her in that car, complete with duct tape, weapons and cable ties. A man who had a detailed, terrifying criminal past, which was only further revealed after his death. A man who sold himself to her mother as a successful anaesthetiologist, who'd worked with Doctors Without Borders, a devoted Christian and a dedicated father. In reality, he was a nurse, not a doctor, who'd had his licence permanently revoked and had strained relationships with his children. Today, we're going to hear from Tara, nearly a decade on from stopping Dirty John, which is the name of the podcast that first made this story go viral. But first, a bit of background on Meehan.
3:41 Speaker 01 His first bout in prison was for stealing drugs. His first wife discovered he'd been using his job as a nurse to steal them from hospitals to get high. After their divorce in 2001, he started stalking and extorting another woman he started dating and went to prison for a few months in 2014 for crimes against her. Once out, he turned his sights on Deborah Newell, a successful and wealthy interior designer looking for love after four failed marriages. Her daughter Tara joins us now.
4:14 Speaker 01 Tara, this all happened to you and your family in your early twenties. You're now in your thirties. How do you feel about it, reflecting on it now, all these years later?
4:28 Speaker 02 It's interesting because true crime, the story is never over in a sense. And I'm still learning stuff to this day. And it's interesting also because at first, when I went through my story, it was slightly triggering but very cathartic. And now I'm to the point where me just going through my attack and going through the hospital, it doesn't benefit my mental health anymore. It just triggers me further instead of helping like it used to.
5:04 Speaker 01 But have you found that over the years, you've learnt where those boundaries are? Perhaps you've tested them a bit more, saying more than you want and then realised, oh, I need to peel back. Has that been a bit of a journey for you?
5:16 Speaker 02 It has a little bit, but now it's interesting because I still have things that come up when I talk about the attack. I'll slightly remember, oh, something else. And it's interesting because I'm still piecing together that memory because trauma, the brain likes to block out the trauma that happens. So I can't see it fully as if someone who was watching it might see it. But that person also might block things from their memory too, because that's a witness witnessing a trauma. So that's a trauma itself.
5:59 Speaker 01 Hmm, that's so interesting, how the brain protects you as well.
6:03 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:05 Speaker 01 I wanna go back to the start. Do you remember the first time you heard about John?
6:11 Speaker 02 Yes, I was on the phone with my sister, actually, Jacqueline, and she was talking about how mom met someone new. She doesn't really like him. And then it's funny because then I talked to my mom and then my mom's telling me, oh, I met someone new. I really like him. Jacqueline doesn't like him.
6:34 Speaker 02 And it's just like sisters and mom going back and forth and talking about like, oh, like I met this guy. And then my sister never liked anyone. And so I took what she was saying with a grain of salt, but I also didn't expect for him to be the real greatest guy.
6:58 Speaker 01 Right. They met on an online dating site?
7:02 Speaker 02 Yes.
7:03 Speaker 01 How did you feel about her finding love online? I, I assume what you're alluding to there is she had a bit of a history with men and dating and you guys had always kind of like watched on from the sidelines.
7:17 Speaker 02 Yes, well, we were, well, not from the sidelines in a sense. I say sometimes we were involved with giving our opinion to my mom, involved with, why is he doing this? Why is he doing that? He shouldn't be doing that.
7:35 Speaker 02 And just being uber opinionated.
7:39 Speaker 01 Walk me through your family. You've mentioned your sister. Where were you and your siblings at in 2014? And how close were you to your mum?
7:49 Speaker 02 So during this time, I was working at a dog kennel. I think I was also maybe working at like a pet store during this time. But I think I left because then you started to gain awareness about pet stores and how the ethical nature of them and selling dogs and.
8:15 Speaker 02 I didn't really care for the standards that the dogs were living in. So I was either working or in transition during that time. I ended up moving to Vegas with my boyfriend at the time. And then, so we were like newly in Vegas, working in the TV and film industry. And then I was also working as a dog groomer. And then my sister was in a relationship at the time, still in that relationship. And then my other siblings, they were, they probably had kids around like eight to like six to like
8:56 Speaker 02 eight or 10, like those ranges.
8:59 Speaker 01 So everyone was kind of living busy, separate lives?
9:03 Speaker 02 Yes, like everyone was just living their own life. And so my mom was really alone. She was really not having as much family time as she was used to. And so she needed to also create her own life for herself.
9:20 Speaker 01 So your sister Jacqueline was the first one of the siblings to kind of have some strange interactions with him.
9:27 Speaker 02 Yes.
9:27 Speaker 01 Can you explain some of those?
9:29 Speaker 02 Yes, so my sister, she met him the first night that they went on a date, actually. And he showed up to the apartment. She didn't really prefer his look. She said that he was wearing khakis and that he just presented himself in a different way. He was also looking around, scoping out the apartment. And to her, she just noticed that he seemed uber interested in her safe. And also just like the penthouse and just asking her maybe a little too many questions.
10:10 Speaker 01 So your mum and John moved in together after dating for about two-ish months. And initially they tried to keep that a bit of a secret. Can you tell me about your trip to visit them for Thanksgiving?
10:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I actually had a trip the week prior and that's the week that I helped them move into their apartment with my boyfriend Jimmy at the time. And then our dogs and we stayed there. It seemed like John was moving in. My mom denied it at the time, however, I don't even know if she knew he was moving in. And because he had so little stuff, he had like a box and then his grooming bag. And then he had a few clothing items. So I don't think in her head she even thought he was moving in. I think she just thought he was staying all
11:07 Speaker 02 there all the time, that it was okay because it's a new relationship. She didn't wanna go to Indio and he told her that he lived in Indio, so she thought, oh, he could stay out here and I get to get away from my daughter because Jacqueline was having an issue with them being in the apartment together. She wanted her space and her privacy. And she also wanted to create boundaries with my sister, which is considered healthy and normal, you know?
11:40 Speaker 01 Because your sister was living with your mom during that period?
11:44 Speaker 02 Yes, so she moved away to create these boundaries with my sister. And he essentially moved in, but I kept on saying things to my mom, like, oh, are you sure he's not moving in? And she kept denying it to me. And then
12:05 Speaker 02 the next week, we came back, me and my boyfriend and our dogs. We came back to celebrate Thanksgiving. And so the day prior, I went and did all the grocery shopping. I got all the groceries. Then John came back with my mom because John was at the hospital. And also I was at my sister's hairdresser and she also was my hairdresser and my mom's. And then she did John's hair as well. And John said a lot of interesting things to her. He just didn't seem.
12:51 Speaker 02 Like a great guy to her. And so we were kind of gossiping about that and talking about my mom's relationship and how we just didn't like him. And we were questioning, why was he using my mom's cars? Why is he basically moving in? We just had all these questions and also where was all his stuff? If he said he was a doctor and an anesthesiologist and all these things. So we just had questions. I went back to the house and then my mom comes home from the hospital with John.
13:33 Speaker 02 And then they kind of peek in the doorway. Me and John have some words, my mom has some words. And basically I end up leaving and I go to my sisters and I'm disinvited to Thanksgiving.
13:50 Speaker 01 What kind of language was he using with you that really upset you or or made you kind of think twice?
13:58 Speaker 02 I was having a conversation with my mom and then he came up behind her and then just started accusing me of wanting my mom all to myself. And then there was a lot of effues and stuff thrown around from both parts. And it just, my boyfriend at the time was even asked a few questions as well from my mom and we essentially just left because it didn't seem like we were welcome there anymore. And then it was, it was honestly a very traumatic memory for me in that time because it created a trauma around Thanksgiving essentially forever.
14:43 Speaker 01 Right.
14:45 Speaker 01 What do you think your mum saw in him? Because obviously you and your siblings weren't in love with him. You were on the like outside, so you could see all of this stuff happening. But she was in love with him. What do you think she saw in him?
14:58 Speaker 02 He was rather good looking, I guess, for her.
15:07 Speaker 02 It's hard to say that because I, he is not my type. I've never seen him. I am, how can I be attracted to my mum's man? I don't know. I, I mean, I guess I could think like, oh, like he is a good looking man, like George Clooney. He's a good looking man.
15:27 Speaker 01 He obviously treated her well. Do you think he, he even love bombed her? Like he just kind of doted on her so much that she didn't see the bad sides?
15:36 Speaker 02 Oh, yes. No, he definitely love bombed her. He would give her coffee drinks every morning. He would just give her all this praise and affection. And when you're getting that hit of dopamine and oxytocin, then you're just kind of glued at first and you're thinking, oh, my gosh, this person's going to be a great partner. So he was love bombing her and doing all the things that a guy should do in a relationship at first.
16:16 Speaker 01 Things kind of kept spiraling after Thanksgiving. You know, then we go into Christmas and he was really trying to poison yours and your sister's relationship with your mum, wasn't he?
16:29 Speaker 02 Yes, no, he was starting to isolate my mum away from her family because that was one of the steps of trauma bonding her, is getting her isolated and away from her family. So then he's going to start to bring up problems about the kids, be like, oh, the kids are like this. And also he was saying that the kids wanted your money and this and that. And also he would take my mum's gift cards and stuff and then just blame it on us, which is funny because we weren't around, so.
17:08 Speaker 02 How is that possible? But John was so good at convincing someone that their reality was a different reality. You know, he was so good at gaslighting.
17:21 Speaker 01 They ended up getting married quite quickly as well. Do you remember when you found out about that? Because they also tried to keep that a bit of a secret for a while.
17:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, when we hired the private investigator, we ended up finding out that my mom was married to him and we knew then that it was gonna be so much harder for her to leave this relationship. And that was a little, that was like about a week after the incident with Thanksgiving.
17:52 Speaker 01 That's when they got married?
17:54 Speaker 02 Uh, yes, about a week after Thanksgiving.
17:57 Speaker 01 Wow. Tell me about hiring that private investigator. That's a big next step to be like, I don't like my mom's boyfriend to, right, let's get an expert in here. Let's find some dirt.
18:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, so my brother-in-law, he actually hired the private investigator. And my sister was also gathering information, help, not helping the private investigator, but just kind of doing her own research alongside him. And so my mom ended up marrying him. And so we brought the stuff to her after that, but we didn't really let her know that we knew she was married. We kept that as a secret as well. And then all this stuff was given to her. She ended up leaving him,
18:51 Speaker 02 living with my sister and her children for a while, and then my brother-in-law. And then he was actually able to convince her that all these things that we found were different John Mee hands. And it's actually crazy because there, there is a lot of John Mee hands out there.
19:14 Speaker 01 Can we talk a little bit about what you uncovered? Because it wasn't just a few misdemeanors. It was an extensive criminal history. Drug charges, multiple prison stays, a history of scamming women, stalking, harassment, restraining orders, theft. Like, I could keep going. There was so. It was such a long list of kind of charges and allegations. How did you feel when all of that kind of came to light? And how did it come to light?
19:48 Speaker 02 I think for me, I didn't realise the extent of it. But I knew he was bad. I had a bad feeling about him. I was living on the edge of just being in fear and feeling like someone was going to come after me all the time. And so it really just confirmed everything that we were feeling and feeling like we were crazy thinking. Because at first, my family, my other family members, my brother-in-law and my sister, well, my, I have a couple of sisters. But my other sister, whose husband hired a private investigator,
20:32 Speaker 02 they just didn't believe my sister and I for a minute. So it was really, I hate to say great, but it was, you're not crazy with how you're feeling right now.
20:47 Speaker 01 Well, it's validating, isn't it?
20:49 Speaker 02 Yes.
20:49 Speaker 01 You have fact.
20:51 Speaker 02 Yes, and scary too, super scary.
20:55 Speaker 01 Did you have to sit your mum down and kind of lay this all out?
20:59 Speaker 02 So I was living in Vegas at the time. And so I didn't sit her down. My brother-in-law did. And I think my sister Jacqueline was there. And they showed her everything. And then, well, I think it was actually more so my sister Nicole. She, they kind of had a conversation with my mum. And then my mum learns about everything. Because I really wasn't there for that moment because of just living in a different state.
21:35 Speaker 01 And what was the plan? Like, your mum was shocked, obviously, when she saw all of this.
21:44 Speaker 01 And there was kind of a bit of a right, well, we need to get you out, we need to extricate you. What was that plan? What did that look like?
21:51 Speaker 02 So it looked like
21:55 Speaker 02 they had to get the stuff out of the Balboa place because he was now living there and they had to move him out as well. So one of the days, my mom just kind of packed everything, I got her stuff out of there. And then my dad ended up helping her rent out the place to one of his friends. So his friend moved in there instead. And then my mom went, lived with my sister for a moment. So that he could also not be around. You know, with the street that they live on, it's a cul-de-sac, everyone knows each other.
22:37 Speaker 02 And so it was also a sense of safety for her to be there, especially given everything that she found out. And so
22:48 Speaker 02 she just kind of
22:51 Speaker 02 went about her life, but just tried to stay a little bit more safe. Because he didn't really threaten her or anything quite yet. I mean, he would say stuff to her and be mean to her and put her down. But he didn't come out with the threats quite yet, other than saying stuff about my sister. And saying that he would shoot my sister with a sniper rifle and stuff. But he didn't make direct threats to my mom quite yet. It was just more so about my sister.
23:34 Speaker 01 Did you ever imagine a scenario where she would go back to him? Given what you found out and given the way he reacted, saying stuff like that about your sister?
23:46 Speaker 02 Yes, I did because I was in a toxic relationship before. And I was with someone that wasn't a great person. And you just wanna see the best in them. And, you know, it takes an average time of a woman to leave an abusive relationship seven times. And I know so many more women that have literally, it's taken them 20 times. And, you know, there's still women that are with their abusers. So it's not easy to leave at all, you know?
24:23 Speaker 01 I think it's really easy for people to judge something like that from the outside if they haven't experienced it.
24:29 Speaker 02 Yes, I agree.
24:31 Speaker 01 The coercion that's involved, the love bombing that comes in, ultimately their emotions at the end of the day.
24:39 Speaker 02 Right, yes, and I agree. There's even women that I come across that are in a coercive controlled relationship. And they are the ones also judging these women. So I think it's more just nuanced than that because it's a lot of people also in denial. Like, oh, that person's not a bad person, that person can't be abusive. You know, how many celebrities do we even see that are abusers? And because they have this celebrity status and they create this familiarity with their brain, with people. And people cannot think that, say, Armie Hammer is an abuser.
25:25 Speaker 01 How did you feel, though, when you heard that she'd gone back?
25:29 Speaker 02 I honestly was just like.
25:33 Speaker 02 Okay, because there were signs.
25:35 Speaker 01 Right.
25:36 Speaker 02 And we didn't find out right away that she just went back, you know? There was little sneaking around. There was like, oh, I'm not available at this time. I'm like, okay, why are you not available?
25:49 Speaker 01 Did you have much to do with your mum? Because she kind of went back and it was like another nine or so months that she was with him. Did you see them much? Were you involved?
26:00 Speaker 02 So she was like with him for five months.
26:04 Speaker 01 A lot?
26:05 Speaker 02 So five months, what she was like originally with him. And then she left him, found all, all the stuff about him. Because she literally met him in like September. And then like November, so you might be right with like the six weeks meeting him. Um, September and then like a week or two later, they get married after Thanksgiving. And then, um, she leaves him March 7th. And then they get back together, but I think it takes like a couple of months.
26:50 Speaker 02 And then literally she leaves him again on March 7th the next year.
26:58 Speaker 01 You're listening to True Crime Conversations with me, Gemma Bath. I'm speaking with Terra Newell, who fatally stabbed her mother's estranged husband in 2016 in an act of self-defense. Up next, Tara tells us about the second time her mother decided to leave John. This time for good.
27:19 Speaker 01 So they'd been together for, you know, over a year by then with a break in between. The second time your mum left, though, she was quite scared, wasn't she?
27:30 Speaker 02 Yes. No, we found out more information because by this time, we're finding out more so his rap sheet and everything is true. Because before he took her to a lawyer and the lawyer explained like, oh, these are different John Mee hands as well. So he had a lawyer in his pocket because John's favorite thing to do was get lawyers disbarred. He just loved to like threaten them, saying I'm gonna do this. And he was very successful at getting several lawyers disbarred as well.
28:04 Speaker 01 So he would use that to kind of coerce your mum and I'm assuming other women into thinking he was a quote unquote good guy?
28:13 Speaker 02 Oh, yes. Oh, yes.
28:15 Speaker 01 So your mum left for that second time. How did he react then? Was that when the threats started coming in?
28:21 Speaker 02 Yes, that's when the threats really started coming in because he even said to my mom, hit me, hit me. And then basically telling her if she hit him, she would never get up again. And but he wanted her to hit him, you know? She left and she left with like one shoe and a bag full of stuff. And by this time, they got a dog together and now they're living at the Irvine Spectrum. And they also have a house in Vegas as well together. And so this time, my mom went and met up with my sister Jacqueline. And they drove straight to Vegas to go get the stuff. They called up my mom's workers.
29:04 Speaker 02 And my mom's workers were great and just there for her as well. And they go to Vegas, my sister films everything, and then they pack up the house. And so I, um.
29:21 Speaker 02 I'm just getting phone calls and hearing like, okay, mom got her stuff. Jaclyn's more so calling me and being like, we got all the stuff. I filmed everything so that John doesn't have evidence or think that we ruined everything. Everything was kind of calculated at this point because we knew that he was a bad person and that he could literally screw us over. And so we wanted to be very careful and just document everything. And then my mom ended up living with my sister up until he came after me.
30:02 Speaker 02 And then, well, like, we were still living together even after John came after me.
30:08 Speaker 01 Did she involve the police at this stage?
30:13 Speaker 02 Yes. No, my mom was trying to get restraining orders. John had also lit her Jaguar in fire in Irvine. And there was a police report and a detective was working on that as well. And so there was lots of reports, but... And I even made a report about John too as well because now I was back in Newport. I broke, um, my ex broke up with me. And so I was just, we were all kind of in the same area now. And the police just wouldn't take us seriously, even though this guy had a rap sheet.
30:58 Speaker 02 And then I remember my sister called the police, Jaclyn, and we were living in the same apartment complex at this time. And I just remember the cop coming and telling us basically that you needed three harassment suits in order to get a restraining order against someone here in the States or in California.
31:18 Speaker 01 Three?
31:19 Speaker 02 Yes.
31:20 Speaker 01 So someone can do it one time, they can do it a second time, a third time is when they'll act?
31:26 Speaker 02 Yes.
31:27 Speaker 01 That's wild, isn't it?
31:29 Speaker 02 Uh huh. Yeah. No, but it's, it's interesting because the perpetrators here are more protected than anything. You know, if you're a victim...
31:45 Speaker 02 You're basically questioned about everything.
31:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:50 Speaker 02 You're not believed, like you have to prove that this happened to you.
31:57 Speaker 01 Do you remember feeling worried about your safety during this time? Or was your assumption that if something were to happen, it was going to happen to your mum? Or say Jacqueline, because really you were the one that he hated the most. Like he, he was kind of, Jacqueline was up in his grill a lot more. Even your other sister was a lot more. You were kind of not as antagonistic with him.
32:24 Speaker 02 See, well, my other sister didn't really have anything. She just kind of did the work, pointed out to my mom and then tried to put boundaries with my mom. But Jacqueline and him would just get into it. They would text each other things. They would literally like Jacqueline would send the shit emoji to him. He would send her a picture of her birth certificate with spit on it. And then I, I was trying to be like, oh, I would love to have a conversation with him. I would love to work things out with him. Just to also show that I was willing to work on things, however, he was not.
33:07 Speaker 01 I wanted to kind of touch on, you know, coming into August of 2016, your sister caught John watching the house. Or, so it started to get a little bit more kind of scary at that point. And your sister was really monitoring it.
33:23 Speaker 02 Yes, no, and this was literally just a day or two prior. And then she chased him down with her friend on the freeway. Or like he got onto the freeway and then they lost him.
33:39 Speaker 01 So it was days later that you found yourself face to face with him?
33:45 Speaker 02 Yes, or just like a day or two, yes. Cause my sister had that happen, saw John, and then she came to my apartment right afterwards. Did kind of a little scan and was like, okay, Tara has work in the morning, I'm not gonna bother her. Cause I worked at seven AM the next day.
34:09 Speaker 01 Wow. I know that at the start you said that you find it hard to think about the details of that time. Does it creep up on you? Do you still dream about it? Is it, is it something that kind of catches you off guard still? Or, or have you been able to move on?
34:25 Speaker 02 There are times if I'm going through a hard moment, it's funny because relationships just love to bring up your trauma.
34:36 Speaker 01 Yep.
34:37 Speaker 02 And I, if something happens with my relationship, well, I'm not in a relationship at the moment, but I was with another survivor. And when he broke up with me, I remember seeing. I remember that I had blood in my hair for three day, or like two days or whatever. Because I was in the hospital for a couple of days. And I didn't take a shower or anything in the hospital. So when I came home, there was a white, I had a white marble shower at the time. And I just remember seeing the blood go down the drain. And it's interesting too, because now, since like the breakup,
35:22 Speaker 02 I, if I see a show or anything where that happens, it just brings me back to that moment. And then I think also the breakup kind of,
35:37 Speaker 02 I can't go to these certain moments anymore because.
35:43 Speaker 02 It did really affect my relationships at times.
35:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
35:47 Speaker 02 And I was living in fight mode and I would just be on edge and not be working on my trauma as much or just be likely, um. I told someone to fuck off at a festival before and then all their followers came after me. And so it just, it doesn't benefit me to live in that trauma anymore. And I definitely don't wanna be telling someone to fuck off at a festival.
36:15 Speaker 01 Were you telling them to fuck off because they asked about it?
36:18 Speaker 02 No, they were literally arguing with my boyfriend at the time and so I just wanted them to stop arguing.
36:26 Speaker 01 You said that you were in a relationship with someone that was also a survivor. At the start, was that a comfort being with someone that had also been through something that was traumatic? Or did it make things harder?
36:39 Speaker 02 Absolutely. Like, it was amazing and it still is great to have him as a friend in that friendship because at the end of the day, it's funny because I feel like no matter who I'm with, that person's not going to understand that part and that's like in dating before him, that was always my struggle with finding someone is that you just, that person just didn't get that trauma fully.
37:10 Speaker 01 Hmm.
37:11 Speaker 02 And I'm sure like the guys I dated, like could have empathy for it, but Collier really got sharing our stories.
37:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
37:23 Speaker 02 You know? And then I think, you know, that relationship could have worked out if we were in a different spot or whatever, but I think that I'm definitely, I only wanna speak for myself because, you know, I appreciate him. He's an amazing person just, you know, and I wanna respect his privacy in it, but for me, I definitely need to work on my trauma and get myself to a better homeostasis.
37:53 Speaker 01 Well, Collier was also your co-host and you were working together.
38:00 Speaker 01 Talking to other people about their trauma. So, you know, that's a lot to take on also, like dealing with your own, dealing with other people's trauma. Or was it helpful hearing other people's stories?
38:12 Speaker 02 It was honestly so, so great. I mean, at times you do have to take a mental health break, you know, stop. I mean, we were really great about recording episodes because we would take pockets. We would record for a time period and then we would take a break. And then we were able to also just focus on our own mental health, but also be able to be in that spot to hear the story and also relate with everyone else. And it really actually made me at least feel like I wasn't alone in my trauma. Because for so long, I kind of thought I was the only
38:57 Speaker 02 survivor or only person with a true crime story. And then you go and you meet other people and you realise you're not so special.
39:09 Speaker 01 Well, you are special, but I guess it makes you, the emotions you're feeling, and even like that, that visual that you recalled earlier about seeing the blood. And I'm sure there are other people that have visceral memories like that, that they're like, why is that the thing that kind of comes back to me? It's not even the moment from, but it's like something that happened after. And I'm sure you were able to relate, like strange things that your brain does after trauma with these people.
39:38 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah, no. So, and it's just crazy because you're like, oh, that happened to you, that happened to me. And you're just able to relate and honestly create a survivor squad. And
39:53 Speaker 01 Which is the name of your podcast?
39:55 Speaker 02 Yes, which is the name. And just have a community where you guys can not feel so alone, you know, like Brené Brown says, when you're vulnerable and you share your vulnerability is like, it doesn't make it so lonely anymore.
40:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. I want to rewind a little bit because there is one aspect I want to talk to you about, which is how on earth you learnt self-defence? Because I find this fascinating. And it's something I think we all Think about, but you actually put it into action. You learnt how to defend yourself from watching TV.
40:34 Speaker 02 Yes, I am a huge TV nerd. I love The Walking Dead. And so that is where I learned to zombie kill John. I'm sorry, it's hard to say that without laughing sometimes.
40:52 Speaker 01 It's not like you pr- you would have practised this stuff. Like, I'm assuming you would have watched the show. And it just sticks in your head?
41:02 Speaker 02 I mean, there is a few times where my, not my last ex call year, but my ex Jimmy and I would go and literally get like watermelons. And you know that scene in Step Brothers where they're just like cutting watermelon?
41:21 Speaker 01 Yes.
41:23 Speaker 02 We wanted to do that. So there was a few times where we did that. And I had a lot of knives because I was always preparing for a zombie apocalypse.
41:36 Speaker 01 But I do, I, I do think that's fascinating that you were able to rely on. It's not like some, this is something you studied. You didn't go to a self-defense class. You learnt it from a, a TV show about zombies.
41:50 Speaker 02 Yes, yes. Well, I just watched The Walking Dead so much. I would watch the episode when it came out. Then I would watch the episode after and then I would watch The Talking Dead. And then I would watch the episode one more time again that night.
42:05 Speaker 01 Well, good on you. My gosh.
42:08 Speaker 01 What did healing look like? We've touched on what it's looked like for you. But what does it look like for your family? Because really, you know, your mum would have had her own journey. But also your family unit had a lot of healing to do.
42:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I think that it really made us look at the generational trauma, even in our family. Because there was a murder before.
42:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:33 Speaker 02 My aunt was murdered by her husband. And it's interesting to, because.
42:41 Speaker 02 Like, my cousins were about the same age as Collier even, and it's interesting just see how family dynamics even affect. Like, I don't think it was helpful for my grandma to take in my cousins and then for their dad to also get custody of them after he got out of jail. I don't think that that was helpful to them. And it just shows a difference even how Collier was put into foster home. And so it shows even that, um, because I think
43:25 Speaker 02 Collier has a better view about his situation, or is able to cope a little bit better.
43:31 Speaker 01 Because for listeners that don't know, Collier had a similar situation happen to your aunt in that his dad killed his mum.
43:40 Speaker 02 Yes.
43:41 Speaker 01 So it's a similar dynamic that he was dealing with.
43:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, so, you know, seeing the two similarities, I think that there are a lot of dynamics in my family where maybe the men have been doted on and praised upon, and the women had to appease to everything and kind of just look over what was toxic.
44:12 Speaker 01 So do you think that your generation now, and even your mum as well, like, can learn from that because it has been blasted in such a big way?
44:25 Speaker 01 Is that helpful? Is that a hu- a helpful outcome to, to actually focus on?
44:30 Speaker 02 Yes, no, I think so a hundred percent because my mom and I have been able to have so many great conversations. And my grandma even passed away this year. And, you know, she was a lovely lady, but she wasn't perfect. And especially in the sense of her testifying for my aunt, her daughter's abuser, um, who murdered her. And so I think that my mom has really been able to also Take a step back and also say like that was wrong and my mom to do that.
45:10 Speaker 02 I mean, I still love her as a person, but I don't necessarily agree with her doing that and forgiving my sister's killer. So I think that those conversations have been great to have. And then just realizing, because my mom is a big appeaser.
45:32 Speaker 02 I'm a big appeaser and just pointing that out and noticing how we're breaking those generational curses and trauma.
45:42 Speaker 01 Your story and your mum's story blew up on a podcast called Dirty John and then a, you know, a TV series where you've got, you know, Julia Garner playing you. And it became internationally, like it was just everywhere. I don't think I know someone who wouldn't know the name or the phrase Dirty John. What was that like for you, living amongst that kind of hype when it's something so hectic that happened to you?
46:16 Speaker 02 I mean, it's very interesting because working in the TV and film industry to begin with, you're always hoping that a project is gonna get picked up and you're, you're just hoping and praying for that. So when it got picked up about my life, I was so excited. Well, at first I wanted to have everything under wraps. We had lawyers on everything, looking out for our names in the news and ready to put gag orders on everything. And so, you know, the LA Times came to us. We really had to give it some thought because it is so personal and it is such a huge trauma. And we thought that it would just help other people.
47:00 Speaker 02 And so that was really our goal. And so we never expected it to be a TV show. We didn't really even know what a podcast was whatsoever, to be honest. And so.
47:14 Speaker 02 It was a huge shock when everything came out because you're listening to it and you're not thinking it's gonna be as big as it is. You're thinking it's gonna be like maybe a few hundred listens. Uh, but now it's over like one hundred and seventy million listens and now they added like another series on top of it. It's a shock. And it's just crazy how so many people have opinions about your trauma.
47:44 Speaker 01 Hmm.
47:46 Speaker 02 It's also interesting how Dirty John has been coined like a term now.
47:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
47:54 Speaker 02 And it's funny because people will tell me, no, that's always been a term. I'm like, no, like Dirty Harry has, but.
48:03 Speaker 01 People will now come to you and say, I dated a Dirty John and that sits kind of weirdly with you?
48:10 Speaker 02 Yes, because to me Dirty John was the person that I had to kill. I will always live with that. And I will, like, watching someone die is not something you ever wanna do. If you've ever watched someone die from cancer, anything, it's sad. It's so sad. And to take someone's life personally, I don't wish that upon anyone. I wish I didn't have to do that. And unfortunately, I was put into a situation where if I didn't take his life, I would have been gone from this planet.
48:53 Speaker 02 And so I had to do what I had to do, but it's not an easy thing to live with the trauma of everything. And
49:04 Speaker 02 I just hope people get that when they say the term Dirty John, like, the media really
49:14 Speaker 02 coined that term, like really just made it.
49:20 Speaker 02 Into kind of, not a fad, but like.
49:24 Speaker 01 Well, they lightened it almost into the dating side of things when really this story is so much darker than that.
49:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, you know how the Colleen Hoover, there's all the drama with the Colleen Hoover movie and it ends with this drama? And how in the PR scheme, they didn't want to talk about how dark and dreary domestic violence is, or really talk about how like it was about domestic violence. It's about that. It's about creating a nice PR package.
49:57 Speaker 01 Yep.
49:58 Speaker 02 For something. And, you know, the Dirty John, it's so catching. And it's really Tanya created the term from filthy John Meehan. And then it turns into Dirty John. And so it's just this transition of how you kind of promote stuff. And then it, like, people are able to relate to, well, I'm happy that people are able to relate to it in the aspect that they had someone that was abusive and they saw similarities.
50:36 Speaker 02 But I would prefer for them to say, I dated a dirty Harry, a dirty whatever.
50:45 Speaker 01 Insert name here.
50:47 Speaker 02 Yes. And, you know, because I have so many women that also tell me, they go, I dated a Dirty John. And I'm like, oh, did they date John Meehan? And that gets me confused, even though, because now I'm like, I wish to connect with all the survivors.
51:04 Speaker 01 And I know we just did a whole interview about it, but are you hopeful that one day you won't be asked as many questions about John Meehan, that that part of your life will be able to stay in the past?
51:17 Speaker 02 Yes, I want to be a mom one day. And I don't want my kids coming up to me and being like, what were you talking about about John Meehan?
51:30 Speaker 02 And so I definitely am looking forward to putting this story in the past real soon.
51:40 Speaker 01 Thanks to Tara for telling us her story. True Crime Conversations is a Mamma Mia podcast hosted and produced by me, Gemma Bath, and Tali Blackman, with audio design by Jacob Brown. Thanks so much for listening. Claire Murphy will be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Previous Meet Heston Russell: The Veteran Falsely Accused Of War Crimes Next Tortured & Brainwashed: How Ben Shenton Survived Australia’s Most Disturbing Cult Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated