Is it time for a Luddite Renaissance?

Calling someone a "Luddite" is usually an insult – shorthand for someone who is behind the times. But the real Luddites weren't just afraid of change; they were a labor movement fighting to save their jobs from being replaced by machines. Today, with the rise of AI, many feel the same kind of existential threat and some are even pushing for a Luddite Renaissance. In this episode, Throughline takes on a listener's question to explore what the 19th-century Luddite rebellion can teach us about technology and human agency. Guests: Katrina Navickas, history professor at the University of Hertfordshire and author of the book Protest and the politics of space and place, 1789–1848 Support public media with NPR+ and enjoy perks for over 25 podcasts like this one. This show’s perks include sponsor-free listening. Learn more at plus.npr.org http://plus.npr.org/. See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences. NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy

• 0:00Speaker 00

  This message comes from Capital One. With the Spark Cash Plus card, you earn unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase for your business. Find out more at capitalone.com/sparkcashplus. Terms apply.

• 0:13Speaker 01

  The American people have not provided their consent to the complete takeover of our interpersonal relationships by artificial intelligence. What is happening? Why is this happening so fast? Why didn't I get a say in this?

• 0:27Speaker 02

  It's cognitive offloading. It's dangerous and it takes away thought and it takes away analysis.

• 0:32Speaker 03

  I feel like I'm living in a nightmare.

• 0:35Speaker 04

  What's happening with AI right now is exactly why the Luddites smashed the cannibal. They're calling it the summer of Ludd, inspired by the first Luddites.

• 0:44Speaker 05

  If this was a disease, the cure is human connection.

• 0:51Speaker 06

  A lot of us are worried right now about how AI is changing the way we work and live. And sure, it isn't the first time in history that a new technology has upended society. But something about this moment feels more existential, like the very core of who we are as human beings is under threat, challenging the way we think, communicate, connect. Meanwhile, data centers are popping up in cities across the country, prompting pushback from local communities, which is probably why some people are now calling themselves new Luddites and trying to spark a Luddite renaissance. Now, I've heard that word thrown around a lot. I've even been accused of being a Luddite myself on occasion. And I know that it generally means people who are antiquated

• 1:36Speaker 06

  or resistant to change or new technology. But who were they really? And what was their movement actually about? That's what one Throughline listener, Drew Barrett, wrote to us wanting to know. Hi, very nice to meet you.

• 1:51Speaker 07

  Hi, nice to meet you, too.

• 1:53Speaker 06

  Drew talked to me from his home in Colorado.

• 1:56Speaker 07

  I live in Golden, but largely I'm in Denver.

• 1:59Speaker 06

  Drew considers himself a modern Luddite.

• 2:02Speaker 07

  Thinking about them now, I think Luddite is synonymous with Neanderthal or something like that, where it's a term that's used as disparaging. But it feels more like it was almost a labor movement.

• 2:18Speaker 06

  Labor activists or Neanderthals? Heroes or villains? On this episode of Throughline, we're taking on Drew's question and digging into the story of the original Luddites. That's coming up.

• 2:44Speaker 00

  Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn Ads. Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first but didn't live up to the hype? For marketers, that's impressions. When ads don't create revenue, that's a tough conversation with the CFO. Instead, invest in results your CFO will love. LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. So advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 and get a $250 credit. Just go to LinkedIn.com/NPRPod. Terms and conditions apply.

• 3:22Speaker 08

  This message comes from NPR sponsor A24, presenting You Can See Everything. 34 days before she's set to begin her prison sentence, Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes invites Nathan Fielder and a camera crew to move in with her family and document their every move. This jaw-dropping, once-in-a-generation theatrical event demands to be seen on the big screen. You Can See Everything, now playing in theaters.

• 3:47Speaker 08

  This message comes from Midi Health. Most women never get real answers about their hormonal health. Midi is changing that with virtual care covered by most major insurances. Understand your hormones. Visit joinmidi.com to book your first visit today.

• 4:04Speaker 06

  I'm curious, when did you first hear the word Luddite?

• 4:09Speaker 09

  I'm from near Manchester in the northwest of England. That's one of the areas that the Luddites were active. So yeah, very much from childhood, really.

• 4:19Speaker 06

  This is Katrina Navickas, a history professor at the University of Hertfordshire in the UK.

• 4:25Speaker 09

  And my new book is Contested Commons: A History of Protest in Public Space in England.

• 4:30Speaker 06

  Katrina thinks the OG Luddites get a bad rap.

• 4:34Speaker 09

  Hopefully, I'm going to convince you that Luddite is a good word and it's a positive word because it represents a lot more than just being opposed to technology. But it's become this shorthand, I think, that perhaps is we need to correct.

• 4:48Speaker 06

  Hmm, I like this. You've now set up a wager for us here. Can you convince me and also the listener that Luddite is actually a good word?

• 5:07Speaker 06

  OK, now imagine we're traveling back in time to Katrina's hometown near Manchester, England, early 1800s. The country is at war with Napoleon's France. There's widespread poverty. Food is hard to come by. Life is hard for a lot of people. And these new, odd-looking machines start popping up all over the place. This is the Industrial Revolution, and it's where the story of the Luddites begins.

• 5:37Speaker 09

  It's a time when employers are starting to introduce large factories. Skilled workers, usually skilled men, are being replaced by machinery increasingly powered by steam, the great inventions of the Industrial Revolution.

• 5:54Speaker 06

  Big cities like Manchester, Leeds, Birmingham were booming. More and more people were flocking to them, and massive factories transformed what these cities looked like.

• 6:04Speaker 09

  Almost brutalist buildings with mechanized processes, with set hours that you have to go in and clock in and clock out, heavily polluted air, heavily polluted rivers.

• 6:16Speaker 06

  A lot of these factories were producing textiles. And the workers in these textile factories were getting more and more worried about how this new technology was impacting the way they worked, how much money they could make, and the quality of life they and their families had. Eventually, it reached a boiling point.

• 6:38Speaker 09

  And the first attack that we know of happened on the 11th of March, 1811, in a village called Arnold in the stocking industry.

• 6:49Speaker 09

  Framework knitters, they gather outside the local exchange, where the cloth is sold, and then go around attacking the new machinery. That seems to set off a wave of attacks across the East Midlands in 1811. And then it spreads to West Yorkshire, where the woolen mills are attacked by local woolen croppers, as they're called.

• 7:14Speaker 06

  Not people, they're attacking only the machines.

• 7:16Speaker 09

  Yeah, they're attacking the machines. And then it escalates from there.

• 7:23Speaker 09

  People had broken machines before. What's unique about them is that they all start calling themselves Luddites.

• 7:29Speaker 06

  For the most part, the Luddites were an anonymous group, except for their leader, General Ned Ludd. Only one known image exists of him. It's a cartoon drawing of him in a dress, standing in front of an angry mob with a factory on fire in the background. This was all the authorities had to go on. But he seemed to be everywhere.

• 7:51Speaker 09

  The Luddites produced lots of written material. So they wrote threatening letters to their employers saying, if you do not take down your machinery, we will attack your factory. Signed, General Ludd.

• 8:07Speaker 09

  So in April, 1812, the local employer who runs West Horton Mill speaks with the magistrate, who's a guy called Colonel Ralph Fletcher, who has a whole network of spies. This magistrate is employing spies to go into the pubs, listen to what the workers are saying, and then try and stir them up into attacking the mill.

• 8:32Speaker 09

  So on the 24th of April, West Horton Mill, which has 200 of these cotton looms, 50 people start gathering outside it. And then there's further processions from the local villages all around. So this is hill country. People are coming down from the hills, little villages where these small workshops are, and they converge on West Horton Mill. And from about 5:00 PM onwards, they start breaking the windows. They start throwing, burning wood into the mill to try and set fire to the machinery there. They get into the mill and start breaking the machinery. The Luddites are well-known for having what's called Enoch, which is a big hammer. So a huge mallet thing.

• 9:16Speaker 09

  These machines are very large and require a lot of manpower, literally, to break them. And the riots basically go on all night.

• 9:27Speaker 06

  About 45 minutes after the riots started, the military arrived. Several people were later arrested.

• 9:34Speaker 09

  The government then clamps down hard on this.

• 9:38Speaker 06

  Over the next few years, the Luddites and the government played a cat and mouse game. There were major battles with hundreds of Luddites raining onto manufacturing plants where the main goal was to take down the machines. There were also high-profile murders of company owners, like William Horstfall, who had a cannon installed at his mill to prevent Luddite attacks. Horstfall would be ambushed by four Luddites who were hiding along the road.

• 10:06Speaker 06

  But the government also fought back.

• 10:09Speaker 09

  The government passes the Frame Breaking Act in 1812, which makes frame breaking a capital offense, so you can get hanged for doing it.

• 10:18Speaker 06

  Some of the Luddites are caught and made an example out of.

• 10:22Speaker 09

  There were kind of show trials after these big attacks.

• 10:27Speaker 06

  Several executions followed. And during these years, when the Luddites were squaring off against the machines in government courts, they were also waging a PR battle in the Court of Public Opinion. The Luddites would create what was essentially propaganda to market their movement.

• 10:44Speaker 09

  So after a big attack, you'll see celebratory poetry written, songs written.

• 10:52Speaker 09

  It's part of folk culture, keeping the memory alive, passing the memory on to different groups of people.

• 10:58Speaker 06

  And many of these messages would include their leader, General Lud.

• 11:02Speaker 07

  Shant no more of your old rhymes about bold Robin Hood. His feats I but little admire. I will sing the achievements of General Lud, now the hero of Nottinghamshire.

• 11:14Speaker 09

  The Derby is true, and Nottingham too. Poor men to the jail they have been taking. They say that Ned Lud, as I understood, a thousand wide frames has been breaking. Foul de Ralph. Foul de Ralph.

• 11:27Speaker 06

  What's foul de Ralph?

• 11:28Speaker 09

  I think it's just a kind of, you know, like doo-doo-doo.

• 11:30Speaker 06

  Oh, foul de Ralph.

• 11:32Speaker 09

  Yeah, something like that.

• 11:34Speaker 06

  Got it.

• 11:37Speaker 06

  This whole time, the British authorities could not find any leads on General Lud.

• 11:42Speaker 09

  They don't know who General Lud is. They're still looking for him.

• 11:45Speaker 06

  But they'd never find him. Because, and this blew my mind when Katrina told me about it, Ned Lud, the guy they sang songs about, who the authorities were hell-bent on tracking down, well, it turns out, more than likely, he wasn't even real.

• 12:00Speaker 09

  I think it's a myth. No one could pin him down. But perhaps there was someone called Ned Lud. And that name seemed to stick with the reputation of breaking machinery that your employer is bringing in that will reduce your wages and reduce your skill level.

• 12:19Speaker 06

  She says there was a power in that mythology, an almost prophetic quality to him.

• 12:24Speaker 09

  And then General Lud then creates his own extended universe. I'd like to see him as a kind of superhero with all the different characters involved in the extended universe. So he has a solicitor. He has lieutenants underneath him. All these characters appear as signatories to these anonymous letters. Because obviously, people don't want to sign their own names, because then they'll get caught.

• 12:49Speaker 06

  They're chasing a ghost.

• 12:50Speaker 09

  Yeah.

• 12:51Speaker 06

  Did people perceive the Luddites as like, what we would call today rogue terrorists, you know, going around destroying things? Or did they have a different view of them?

• 13:03Speaker 09

  Certainly, most of people in power, local gentry, aristocracy, authorities are completely opposed to Luddites. But in local communities, I think opinion's a lot more mixed, because local communities support these skilled workers who are making their livelihood in small workshops. And there is this idea that, yes, you should have control over your working conditions.

• 13:33Speaker 06

  What was the goal? Were they just like, we want to destroy the technology and go back to the way things were?

• 13:40Speaker 09

  Basically, yes. They want to go back to their original working conditions, which is working in small workshops using hand-powered machinery that they could use with skill. Their argument is that the machines produce less good-quality cloth. So by mass production, it's cheapening the quality of their products, which then cheapens their reputation. They want to retain their higher wages. They're paid by pieces of cloth.

• 14:07Speaker 06

  Whereas in factories, they were paid weekly wages.

• 14:11Speaker 09

  They're worried about women and children being involved in working conditions, not just from a humanitarian position, but also from a wages position that women and children automatically paid less than men. So it's also a defense of skilled male labor.

• 14:31Speaker 06

  In a lot of ways, what you've described is a very sympathetic movement, right? I can relate to the fear that it sounds like motivated a lot of them. On the other hand, you've described real acts of violence, right? There was at least a few people who were murdered by the Luddites. So if, going back to the wager, we are to think of them as good, how do we square those two things?

• 15:03Speaker 09

  As a historian, I'd say the Luddites in 1812 had no choice. The options were very limited. Violence was one of the only options available to them. Today, we've got a lot more choice and agency. We have the vote. Adult men in Britain at that point didn't have democracy, and they didn't have the vote. So this, again, was another way in which they were expressing their anger. Today, we've got a lot more options for political organization and to express what we want to say. We've got much more freedom of expression in many respects than the Luddites had in 1812. So I'm not condoning the violence or the murders.

• 15:46Speaker 09

  But actually, my contention that we should think about Luddite in a positive way is related to that kind of defense of your working conditions, your skill, your worth as an individual, against a system that seems to be removing that skill and that independence.

• 16:06Speaker 06

  A lot of what you're saying feels really resonant to today. You can see why there is a "Luddite Renaissance," quote unquote, that has emerged. Because when we think about AI, which arguably there's never been any technology, I mean, if they thought the steam engine was threatening, I mean, what would they think of AI, right? Like, it is truly an existential, it feels existential to not just work, but who we are as human beings.

• 16:32Speaker 09

  Yeah, so the Luddites, you've got it in one, are about being human. And machinery that takes away that sense of human agency is what they were opposing. Just as today, AI takes out the human from the machine. So I think that's the similarity with the fight around the unlimited or unrestrained use of AI.

• 16:57Speaker 06

  Yeah, forcing people to think more carefully about, even if we're going to have the technology and it's here to stay, how do we incorporate into our lives, rather than force humans to reshape themselves to fit the technology?

• 17:12Speaker 09

  Yeah, yeah. That's exactly what the Luddites were talking about, or singing about.

• 17:20Speaker 06

  That's Katrina Navickas, a history professor at the University of Hertfordshire in the UK. She has a new book called Contested Commons: A History of Protests and Public Space in England. Thank you to our listener Drew Barrett, who asked us to look into the history of the Luddites. And that's it for today's show. Throughline was created by me and Ramtin Adebroui. This episode was produced by me and...

• 17:46Speaker 08

  Devin Kadyama.

• 17:47Speaker 06

  Molly Marcelo.

• 17:48Speaker 02

  Leanna Simstrom. Jasmine Romero. Sarah Wyman. Julia Redpath. Amy Padula. Irene Noguchi.

• 17:56Speaker 06

  This episode was fact-checked by Nicolette Khan and mixed by Robert Rodriguez. Music by Ramtin Adebroui and his band, Drop Electric. Thanks also to Johannes Durki. I'm Randa Abdelfattah. Thanks for listening.

• 18:17Speaker 00

  Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

• 18:22Speaker 08

  This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace, without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu.

• 18:36Speaker 00

  This message comes from Bombas. Whether you're outdoors or just lounging around the house, cool weather calls for cozier footwear. Bombas makes the perfect slippers and shoes, built with smooth, premium suede, plush sherpa, and warm sheepskin shearling, all with layers of cloud-like cushioning. Perfect for staying in, stepping out, and keeping things cozy all season long. Visit B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash NPR and use code NPR for 20% off your first purchase.