Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 179 Fluoride 2: Fighting tooth and nail About this episode In last week’s episode, we traced the history of fluoridation (and the anti-fluoridation movement) to its roots in the early 20th century, but we left you wondering whether there’s anything to back up the health claims that anti-fluoridationists make. Today, we get deep into the weeds of the fluoride literature, explaining how this mineral works, the difference between topical and systemic fluoride, and whether fluoridation has been linked to any health issues. The details matter, and don’t you worry - we’ve got plenty of nitty gritty for you to feast on.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,262 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:06 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
0:51 Speaker 01 Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company dot com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
1:03 Speaker 02 Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:35 Speaker 03 Ouch! It's 1964, and I'm at the fight of the century, and I just lost. I got my tooth pulled. And why did I lose my tooth? I didn't really know then, but I do now. It was bacteria versus fluoride, and I didn't have any.
1:56 Speaker 03 It was bacteria poop, to be exact, acid. I'm eating candy, my mom doesn't really know how much. I'm eating cereal that's called Sugar Smacks or Frosted Flakes with a sugar bowl that we got to use sugar. Because my mom was sleeping and we didn't want to wake her because we were five kids. And my mom needed her sleep in the morning. So hiding in plain sight in 1964 was fluoride. It had just entered the water in New York City. And it was in some toothpaste. Lord knows if I brushed my teeth, I can't remember, we probably did. But we certainly didn't have fluoride treatments at the dentist. And so why did I lose my teeth at that time? Because it's not one thing.
2:41 Speaker 03 It's not one quantity of one thing. It's an approach to health. Reasonable amounts of sugar. Fluoride in the water to build the teeth strong. And I know that. And why do I know that? Well, I don't remember if I said this is Raphael and it is, but this is Dr. Sontore also. In 1974, about 10 years after I got my tooth pulled, I went to dental school. And I learned a lot about how to fix broken teeth. I didn't learn as much how to keep them from getting broken, how to keep them from getting decayed. That came with time and maturity. And after 45 years, I have a lot of stories.
3:24 Speaker 03 But I only want to tell you one or two. So what happened in 1980? I was treating patients. And I was finished with all my residencies and things. And I noticed that I would fix teeth that had cavities on top of the fillings, on top of the teeth that just had cavities. Boy, that lactic acid and all those things that bacteria produce and they erode teeth were working really hard against me. And I started to see a change in the late 80s. And in 1987, Willbrook closed. And that is where we saw lots of patients who came to the hospital I worked at,
4:08 Speaker 03 where I did anesthesia and taught pediatric residents how to do dentistry and how to think about healthcare for the handicapped. And we saw over about 10 years before Willbrook closed. And even after, while we were treating the handicapped in the larger New York area, mostly Brooklyn, but larger New York area, that the kids were getting less cavities. We started speaking to the parents and we start looking at the data. And we realized that there was a revolution, that the bacteria was starting to lose the battle. And we weren't quite sure why. It seemed common sense that people brush their teeth, but it had to be more than that.
4:51 Speaker 03 Because the handicapped kids could not brush their teeth well. Their parents were always exhausted caring for them. And it was a difficult environment. In about 1991, varnishes came out that we dentists could use in the teeth. And before we put the restorations in them. And in 1996, my son, my firstborn son was six years old. And he had no cavities. And I noticed, because I treated the kids in his class, that they had no cavities. And I started to put together the relationship between good healthcare and systemic fluoride, as well as topical fluoride. And they do different things.
5:36 Speaker 03 And we argue to this day about which one is better, and they are both important. But the thing about systemic fluoride is it's the quiet giant that works behind the scenes. And that's what I came to realize as a dentist, in the trenches, so to speak, trying to prevent teeth from being destroyed. In the year 2025, I can tell you without a doubt, from treating different communities with different advantages and access, that fluoride, in all its forms, properly used, is a gift to children.
6:19 Speaker 03 And I share that with every parent that comes in. And I show them x-rays, I have so many x-rays, that show such a long history, that we went from decay and fillings to very little decay, or almost none, and no fillings.
6:38 Speaker 03 And I thank you for listening to this. And I hope you heard a simple message with all the honesty that I meant for you to have and to hear. Thank you.
7:35 Speaker 04 I love that.
7:36 Speaker 01 It's so good.
7:37 Speaker 04 Ray, thank you so, so much for sharing that with us.
7:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, thank you so much.
7:43 Speaker 04 You're the best, the best. A man who goes by many names. Raphael, Dr. Sontore, Uncle Ray, my husband's Uncle Ray. So, but I really did appreciate that perspective of like, here is a noticeable difference. You know, I feel like sometimes big public health measures, we don't see the impact right away, or we only see the impact when they're taken away. But I love that with that additional fluoride to the water, it was like, here is a very clear night and day difference.
8:16 Speaker 01 Right. We can really see the effects. And from someone who's on literally the front line of it, right? Seeing teeth day in and day out.
8:24 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, we really appreciate it.
8:27 Speaker 04 Super, super appreciate it. Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
8:31 Speaker 01 And I'm Erin Allman Updike.
8:33 Speaker 04 And this is, this podcast will kill you.
8:35 Speaker 01 Part two of fluoride.
8:37 Speaker 04 Part two. Yeah.
8:39 Speaker 01 It's on me today.
8:41 Speaker 04 I am just thinking how weird it is and like, I don't know if I, I don't know if it's like nice if I'm like comfortable not having anything to say.
8:50 Speaker 01 You have nothing to hold and to be like, reference.
8:53 Speaker 04 I mean, it's, I get to just like, sit back and relax mostly.
8:56 Speaker 01 I liked it last week. I would love to do more of those. Very nervous about this week. But so last week, if you missed it, we went through, Erin Welsh went through the history of fluoride. How we figured out what it does, when we started putting it in our water slash when it was always there.
9:14 Speaker 04 When we, yeah, when we stopped putting it in our water in some places. Yeah.
9:18 Speaker 01 And the history, yes, of the anti-fluoridation movement.
9:21 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
9:22 Speaker 01 So today I am going to talk to us about, honestly Erin, this is going to be just a very long-winded episode for me to end with essentially the same conclusion that you stated last week.
9:36 Speaker 01 That as of right now, there, there is no data of harm to our health from drinking water with fluoride added to it at the specific concentrations that we add to it.
9:48 Speaker 04 Right.
9:49 Speaker 01 So that's the TLDR.
9:51 Speaker 04 TLDL.
9:52 Speaker 01 TLD, listen. Yep, there you go.
9:56 Speaker 01 But let me tell you, it took me a very long time, quite a lot of research and a real emotional journey to get to that conclusion. So.
10:04 Speaker 04 Okay. I'm curious about the emotions, number one. Number two, I think that that illustrates how challenging it can be.
10:13 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:13 Speaker 04 If you have questions to get to the bottom of those questions.
10:18 Speaker 01 A hundred percent, a hundred percent.
10:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
10:20 Speaker 01 But we will do our best to do that today with first going into some detail on like what a carry or a cavity, like we talked about last week really is, how it forms.
10:29 Speaker 04 Quick question, is it a carries?
10:31 Speaker 01 I don't know, Erin. I still don't know. And I'm probably just going to call it cavity because that's my word.
10:37 Speaker 04 Okay, I'm fine with that.
10:38 Speaker 01 A carries seems so weird.
10:40 Speaker 04 I know. I kept, I kept trying to like, adjust the verb noun agreement.
10:45 Speaker 01 Dental carries. Okay. How dental carries form? How about that?
10:50 Speaker 04 How dental carries forms.
10:52 Speaker 01 What?
10:53 Speaker 04 But then is there a plural of carries?
10:54 Speaker 01 No, no, carries is.
10:55 Speaker 04 What's the singular of carries?
10:58 Speaker 01 Right, help us out.
11:00 Speaker 04 Yeah, we need, we clearly do. I think it's like deer and deer.
11:04 Speaker 01 No, that, I can't accept that.
11:07 Speaker 04 I think it might be.
11:08 Speaker 01 On the end, but carries is plural.
11:12 Speaker 04 And singular.
11:13 Speaker 01 Whatever, Erin, listen, is we're gonna talk about how they form, how fluoride actually works to protect against the formation of dental carries, where we're getting that fluoride from, and then, of course, all of the controversies, if that is the right word, about the supposed or possible negative health effects of fluoride. Okay.
11:34 Speaker 04 Okay.
11:34 Speaker 01 That's what we're gonna talk about today, but first.
11:37 Speaker 04 But first.
11:38 Speaker 01 It's quarantiney.
11:39 Speaker 04 It's quarantiney time. We're drinking the same thing we did last week, and that is pulling teeth.
11:44 Speaker 01 Pulling teeth.
11:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
11:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
11:47 Speaker 04 It's, um, we don't quite remember the ingredients, but that's okay, because you know what?
11:54 Speaker 04 It would've been so easily accessible, it's in my notes.
11:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:57 Speaker 04 But that's okay, because you know where you can find that.
12:00 Speaker 01 On our website.
12:01 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:02 Speaker 01 ThisPodcastWillKillYou.com.
12:04 Speaker 04 And all of our social media channels.
12:05 Speaker 01 We're there. Instagram, ThisPodcastWillKillYou, Blue Sky. I don't remember our handle.
12:11 Speaker 04 Either TPWKY or ThisPodcastWillKillYou.
12:13 Speaker 01 Facebook, we still exist there. TikTok also, you know what I mean?
12:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:19 Speaker 01 Just follow us.
12:20 Speaker 04 Check it, check it out.
12:21 Speaker 01 There's mint in it, there's elderflower, it's like, it's delicious.
12:26 Speaker 04 Let's, let's do a website spiel.
12:29 Speaker 01 Okay, good, do it.
12:30 Speaker 04 We've got transcripts, we've got sources, because I know that you're gonna wanna read up more on fluoride.
12:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, you are.
12:38 Speaker 04 We've got some, we've got some sources, we've got a link to where you can submit your firsthand account, we've got links to the books that we feature on these episodes and our book club episodes, and more things. Those terrible website spiel.
12:53 Speaker 01 You did your best.
12:54 Speaker 04 Thank you. That's all I, that's all I can do, that's all I can hope for.
12:58 Speaker 01 Rate, review, and subscribe on your favorite podcatcher.
13:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, we're on YouTube.
13:04 Speaker 01 YouTube.
13:06 Speaker 01 The end.
13:06 Speaker 04 Let's go. Let's go.
13:09 Speaker 01 Okay, after a break, we'll do it. What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do.
13:53 Speaker 01 So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long. Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
14:10 Speaker 02 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. So you're helping Will.i.am write hooks. What made "Ordinary People" become the one song from Little Soundcheck's "You Knew You Had to Make Your Own"?
14:38 Speaker 05 I was just writing for the Black Eyed Peas. I wasn't expecting to write something for myself in that session, but I wrote the hook for "Ordinary People," and I recorded a demo, and I'm like, I would rather keep "Ordinary People" for myself. This station in Chicago, WGCI, they start playing it before we're promoting it. The song spoke for itself. It became the defining song for my first album. I knew it was special, but you never know how special it's going to be and how much impact it's going to have in people's lives. And you never believe that you're going to actually change people's lives with a song.
15:07 Speaker 02 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
15:32 Speaker 01 I just want to also set the stage really quick.
15:35 Speaker 04 Okay.
15:36 Speaker 01 And remind us of what a global public health problem dental caries are. I'm gonna use them as a plural.
15:44 Speaker 04 They are, it's both a plural and a singular, so you're, you're in the clear.
15:47 Speaker 01 Okay, I cannot get it wrong. So, the World Health Organization estimates, and this is a little bit old data, but it's still what is cited, that 2.4 billion people across the globe have untreated dental caries in their permanent teeth, and 621 million kiddos have untreated dental caries in their primary teeth.
16:11 Speaker 01 So, this is a huge public health problem. There was a really great Nature Review, Nature Reviews Disease Primers paper from 2017 that I used heavily for the caries section, and it estimates that 60 to 90% of children and the vast majority of adults are affected by dental caries at some point in their life, and they're actually considered the single most common chronic childhood disease. Like, what?
16:35 Speaker 04 I mean, I'm not, I'm not surprised.
16:36 Speaker 01 I know. And, like many chronic and infectious diseases, we do see disparities in prevalence as well as access to care with children of color and children in lower-income areas having significantly higher prevalence and difficulties in access to care. Although globally, it is still the case, though this is changing due to dietary changes, higher-income countries actually tend to have slightly more caries than lower-income countries. So, it's largely dietary differences and how much sugar we eat.
17:07 Speaker 01 Okay? And that's the end that I'm gonna say about sugar, because today is about fluoride. Okay, let's talk about how dental caries form. There's two main components that exist for the formation of dental caries. First is issues with the enamel itself, and the second is the components of the oral microbiome. So, let's start there. Our oral microbiome is just...
17:32 Speaker 01 So varied. We have so many different things that live in our mouth. We've got bacteria, yeast, viruses, protozoa, even archaea. Did you know that?
17:41 Speaker 04 I did not know that.
17:42 Speaker 01 Me neither.
17:43 Speaker 04 How did they get there?
17:44 Speaker 01 How did they get there? Many of these organisms are commensals or even beneficial to our mouth and to our health, but some are what we call karyogenic. And all of these helpful and unhelpful organisms, because I can't just say bacteria, it's more than just bacteria, they live together and they grow and form this very complex biofilm on our teeth's surface that we call plaque.
18:12 Speaker 04 Plaque.
18:13 Speaker 01 And each surface of each one of our teeth is its own little microenvironment with its own little microbiome.
18:23 Speaker 04 So there's like
18:24 Speaker 01 There's like your whole mouth and then there's like each little surface of its tooth, it's going to be a little bit different.
18:30 Speaker 04 Yeah.
18:31 Speaker 01 Isn't that great to think about?
18:33 Speaker 04 I am very curious. Okay. And, and so I assume that there's like a fairly, there's, that there's a gradient from front to back too. Like if you're closer to the back of your mouth, what's going on there?
18:44 Speaker 01 I have no idea. What a fun. We should do a whole episode on the oral microbiome.
18:49 Speaker 04 Really, we should though.
18:50 Speaker 01 We should.
18:50 Speaker 04 And like flossing?
18:53 Speaker 01 Listen.
18:53 Speaker 04 We should talk about floss.
18:54 Speaker 01 You know that we've talked a lot about floss, you and I.
18:57 Speaker 04 We, you and I have talked a lot about, more than you would expect.
19:00 Speaker 01 I know. Okay. But listen, we're, let's get back to the oral microbiome in the context of
19:05 Speaker 04 Teeth, individual teeth, et cetera. Yeah.
19:07 Speaker 01 So under certain environmental conditions, for example, high concentrations of fermentable carbohydrates, like sugar, or conditions like, say, a reduction in saliva, we can see a shift in this microbiome to favor certain bacteria, including various species that are more either acid producing, so they make more acid from these fermentable carbohydrates, or they're just very tolerant of this acid. And it's not just like one or two species of bacteria. We used to think it was just like Maybe a couple different species that were the main like causes of dental caries. It's not. It's this whole ecological community that shifts to favor acid production.
19:52 Speaker 01 And that is the first step in the formation of dental caries is this shift in the oral microbiome to favor acid production. And we most often see this due to things like regular exposure to sugars.
20:04 Speaker 04 Okay, so we've got this, the first thing like the inciting incident is the sugar. And then that just sort of selects for this ecosystem that is acid happy.
20:14 Speaker 01 More cariogenic.
20:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
20:15 Speaker 01 Then we have the hard stuff, our enamel. So as the acid production from these bacteria starts to build up in our mouth, the pH of course is going to drop. Acid has a low pH. And that drops the pH at the surface of our enamel, which is the outermost part of our teeth that surrounds the dentine, right? Enamel is mostly made of a substance called hydroxyapatite, which is basically just a compound of calcium and phosphate and hydroxyl, which is like oxygen and hydrogen. And in the presence of acid, what happens is that this becomes soluble. So if there's a partial demineralization of this outer surface of the tooth.
20:58 Speaker 01 And as this hydroxyapatite starts to demineralize, then you have an increase in porosity, right? So then this acid can diffuse even deeper and cause further demineralization, releasing more calcium and more phosphate from this enamel, right? And this process, don't ask questions yet, Erin.
21:21 Speaker 04 I can see you take a breath. See me teeing up, yeah.
21:23 Speaker 01 This process and the fact that like we have saliva in our mouth, which serves as a buffer, eventually we're going to wash out some of this acid. Eventually, you will have re-mineralization, right? Because the calcium and phosphate are being released, your saliva is coming into buffer, and eventually things even out to where the calcium and phosphate are going to redeposit, and you can re-mineralize this. Unless you can't, because if you continue to have acid production, if you don't have enough saliva, etc., then this demineralization process can continue until you end up damaging the pulp of the tooth, which can then damage the canal, the root canal, and then you end up needing a root canal or an extraction.
22:09 Speaker 01 But this process, demineralization and then remineralization, mineralization, it's hard for me to say, this is happening in our mouth all the time. I think that we think of our teeth as like static, right? They're just like little bones sitting in our mouth, but they're not. They're alive and they are constantly changing in response to the environment of our mouth.
22:30 Speaker 04 Um, okay. Can you tell me about why low saliva is bad?
22:35 Speaker 01 Saliva is a buffer in our, in that acid base system. And so without the saliva, then you don't have that buffer. Yeah.
22:44 Speaker 04 And then why?
22:45 Speaker 01 There's probably more also, but that's the short answer.
22:48 Speaker 04 Why acid? Like, why do these microbes produce acid? Is it like a competition thing with other microbes? Just to kind of like stake out more space and claim?
22:59 Speaker 01 That's a deeper dive. I don't know. Is it just that that's like a byproduct of the production of sugars?
23:03 Speaker 04 Right.
23:04 Speaker 01 That's what it seems like. It's like they produce mostly lactic acid as a result of the production or the digestion of sugars. So it's just like, they're poop.
23:12 Speaker 04 Right, right.
23:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. Okay. But that's just like, all of that was just dental carries. That's just what's happening in our mouth. Where the heck does fluoride come in? I haven't even said the word fluoride yet.
23:22 Speaker 04 It's just lurking in the background.
23:23 Speaker 01 It is. It is, Erin. So it is, like you said last week, Erin, you kind of went into this fluoride is, it's just a mineral salt that's present in our environment. Like all of us are being exposed to fluoride through various sources. Fluoride is like the ion form of fluorine, the, the element, which is, I learned, the 13th most abundant element in our earth's crust. Like, it's just there. It's around.
23:51 Speaker 04 It's there. Yeah.
23:52 Speaker 01 It's in a lot of different mineral compounds and it's absorbed very well via our GI tract when we are exposed to it. But how does it work in our teeth to protect them from dental carries? There are several mechanisms that we know of now, how fluoride works. First is that it delays that initial demineralization process. Basically fluoride itself, you can think of as acting like a buffer. It, because of when fluoride precipitates versus becomes soluble compared to calcium phosphate that's, and the hydroxyl groups that's in hydroxyapatate.
24:32 Speaker 01 In the presence of fluoride, you have to have a lower pH, a more acidic environment before that demineralization starts. Does that make sense?
24:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah. It like lowers or it raises the bar.
24:44 Speaker 01 Yes.
24:45 Speaker 04 For like, you gotta be even more acidic if you want to do damage here.
24:48 Speaker 01 Exactly, exactly.
24:49 Speaker 04 Okay.
24:50 Speaker 01 And then on top of that, again, because of the chemical properties, it also hastens that process of re-mineralization. It returns that neutral pH faster to favor re-mineralization, right? So you're like less demineralizing and more re-mineralizing.
25:09 Speaker 04 Wow, okay. So it's like a twofold. It protects you and it also helps to repair faster.
25:15 Speaker 01 Exactly, yeah. And there are more mechanisms too. It also can interfere with like the bacteria themselves that form this biofilm. They can, fluoride can interfere with glycolysis. So some of the specific like metabolic processes in that bacteria that live in our mouths, especially those carcinogenic ones, so that they're just not as efficient. It's thought that this is probably not like the most important mechanism, but it is yet another mechanism by which fluoride is helping the oral microbiome of our teeth, which is cool. And all of these events happen even at very low levels of fluoride in our mouths, like less than one part per million.
25:57 Speaker 01 At high levels of fluoride, it can also penetrate through the plaque and then be incorporated into our enamel itself. So instead of that hydroxyapatite, you can have fluoride there instead of the OH group. So it's called fluorapatite. Did you know that shark enamel is made almost entirely of fluorapatite?
26:19 Speaker 04 All shark, like what?
26:22 Speaker 01 Don't ask me more details, Erin.
26:24 Speaker 04 It's like, is there a lot of fluoride in saltwater in the oceans?
26:27 Speaker 01 There's like one to 1.5 parts per million in saltwater, so nah, not really. I mean, there's some.
26:32 Speaker 04 Amazing, okay.
26:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, so that's some of the other ways. And like we talked about last week, Erin, if we are ingesting fluoride systemically in our water, in our food, whatever, pre-eruption, i.e. when we are little, before our first teeth pop out, it also has been shown to make our enamel more resistant to the development. of carries later on, especially the deep craggly bits of our teeth that aren't ever going to be exposed to topical fluoride.
27:03 Speaker 04 Ah, okay. And this is both for baby teeth and permanent teeth?
27:09 Speaker 01 All these mechanisms? Yes. Yes. Hundred percent. And I want to actually stop here for a second and take a pause because this already, what I have said is one of the points that many of the papers and the rhetoric that pushes back against the idea of community water fluoridation really tends to stick on. Because it is true, and we talked a little bit about this last week, we know now that the primary mechanism of action of fluoride is actually topical. So it is what is happening in, on, and around our teeth, in our saliva, in this dental plaque,
27:47 Speaker 01 etc. There are, though, these so-called systemic effects in that there is data, pretty clear data, that there's a preeruptive benefit to having exposure to fluoride before your teeth even form. But the primary way that it works thereafter is by existing in our mouths and around our teeth.
28:09 Speaker 04 Right.
28:10 Speaker 01 But when you really then think about all of the different ways that we could be then exposing people to fluoride, that fact that it is topical, that it is low levels, that it is a constant exposure, actually favors water fluoridation because we're drinking it multiple times a day, every day, compared to, say, milk or salt fluoridation, which are other more targeted strategies that other countries use for like, large-scale fluoride distribution, right? Because drinking it in our water is this constant low-concentration flow, plus then anything that's absorbed systemically is then going to be re-screeded into our saliva, although at even lower levels, right?
28:53 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm. Right, right. I mean, it's that the fact that if you're drinking it, then you have the systemic fluoride in your saliva, bathing your teeth
29:03 Speaker 01 Right.
29:03 Speaker 04 in fluoride.
29:04 Speaker 01 Right. It's also when that water is in your mouth. So it's not just like having to be absorbed by your GI tract. It's also every single time, I've been swishing my water a lot more since reading about this. It's probably ridiculous, but really.
29:17 Speaker 04 Yeah. Okay, so. I have a question about the development of teeth.
29:22 Speaker 01 Oh, gosh.
29:25 Speaker 01 Oh, no, Erin.
29:27 Speaker 04 Yeah.
29:27 Speaker 01 Don't ask me questions about things I didn't research. Okay, go ahead.
29:30 Speaker 04 I mean, take it away. Like, when do teeth develop?
29:34 Speaker 01 I mean.
29:41 Speaker 01 I pass.
29:43 Speaker 04 Okay.
29:45 Speaker 04 I'm sorry.
29:48 Speaker 04 I was just thinking, like, at what level? When is exposure to systemic fluoride?
29:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:55 Speaker 04 For tooth development? Like, really, what is that critical time period?
29:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't know.
30:00 Speaker 04 Okay.
30:00 Speaker 01 And I didn't see the specific data on that. They all just say, like, preeruptive.
30:05 Speaker 04 Preeruptive.
30:06 Speaker 01 Because I think, like, by the time, so, like, six months to 12 months is when your first baby teeth usually start to appear. And then the, obviously, adult teeth, you start to lose your baby teeth usually by six years old is, like, the earliest, sometimes a little bit earlier. So it's sometime in that timeframe, like, before the eruption of, especially your adult teeth. But, yeah, I don't, I don't have an answer to that, Erin.
30:30 Speaker 04 Okay.
30:33 Speaker 01 Okay. Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather, and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non-greasy, and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to okeefescompany.com to get yours today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
31:29 Speaker 06 Everything about us, everything we do is temporary. And I just got terrified of that. You know, what we do with our time and how I feel like the way the world is today and how fast paced it is and how much we don't even acknowledge anything around us. How I felt temporary to the people around me and how that made me scared and how much I wanted to last and make an impact on people. And I guess to change the way I looked at things and to change myself and to change how I guess I approached everything in my life. It's important that things are impermanent because nothing would feel special. Right. And enjoying, you know, learning to love with knowing it's not going to last.
32:03 Speaker 02 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
32:23 Speaker 01 But so what are the different ways that we have used this knowledge that we now have about how effective fluoride is and the ways that it's effective to prevent dental caries? What are the different ways that we've been using this to improve public health? And you kind of set the stage for us for this a lot last week, Erin. In the US, community water fluoridation is the way that we, as a society, I guess, I don't know, as a, what's the word?
32:52 Speaker 04 Nation?
32:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, country is the word I was looking for.
32:55 Speaker 04 Okay.
32:56 Speaker 01 It is the way that we, as a country, have decided to do oral health, right? Is community water fluoridation. We've been doing it for almost 80 years. It's had tremendous and very measurable public health impacts. And it is not just the US. Countries around the globe have been using widely administered fluoride for the prevention of dental caries for a really long time. Some countries, instead of using it in the water, have decided to use milk supplementation, the way that we fortify milk with vitamin D in the US. Other countries have used salt, like the way that we fortify salt with iodine here in the US. Are we sensing a theme here?
33:35 Speaker 04 Yeah.
33:35 Speaker 01 And then, community water fluoridation, or CWF, is the most widespread. It's covered an estimated 400 million people in 25 different countries worldwide.
33:45 Speaker 04 It's actually less than I thought, fewer than I thought.
33:48 Speaker 01 Okay.
33:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
33:49 Speaker 01 I mean, that doesn't account for everyone who just gets it from naturally fluoridated sources, which we'll talk about.
33:53 Speaker 04 Yeah.
33:54 Speaker 01 But I also just want to do a plug real quick here, and I have a paper to back this up, that our water fluoridation systems are very, very impressively good at keeping the concentrations at that 0.7 parts per million or milligrams per liter that they are expected to. Like, better than I expected, honestly. Like, very, very good at it.
34:15 Speaker 04 And I think that's a talking point of some anti-fluoridationists where they're like, they're not really measuring the water. It's just like a ballpark.
34:22 Speaker 01 They actually do a very good job of it.
34:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:26 Speaker 01 The US Public Health Service and the ADA report their estimate is that drinking fluoridated water at the level that they recommend, which again, I'm going to say this a million times, 0.7 milligrams per liter, which is the same as parts per million, reduces dental carries by 25% in children and adults. And that number already is now contentious because recently, some papers that have tried to look at like, what is the benefit just of fluoridating our water specifically?
35:02 Speaker 01 In more recent years, since the advent of other dental hygiene options, like we didn't used to have fluoridated toothpaste, we didn't used to have fluoride sealants, et cetera. So some papers that have tried to look just at more recent data estimate a lower benefit, maybe like a 3% to 4% reduction in carries. And this is based on a Cochrane review that came out last year, as well as a paper out of the UK that looked at like 10 years of UK data. But at the same time, other recent papers, including one out of Australia from 2017 and one out of Brazil. Brazil in 2021 actually had much higher carry reduction estimates from their water fluoridation.
35:42 Speaker 01 So we don't know the exact amount, but the data is clear across the board that there is a reduction in dental carries and every paper that has looked at the financial impacts consistently finds that community water fluoridation is a cost effective intervention, even when its impacts are less. Okay.
36:03 Speaker 04 Okay, so I just, I really want to understand why there are such discrepancies. And so like historically, those numbers were much higher even than 25%.
36:13 Speaker 01 Right. I mean, even the Brazil paper from 2021 like was a 50% reduction. So.
36:18 Speaker 04 Right. Yeah. So what, what can account for that three to 4%?
36:22 Speaker 01 I don't know. In all honesty, Erin, I mean, is it just that we have so many other options that are doing a very good job. And so we've seen, I don't know, because it's not like we've seen reductions in carries, like carries are, if anything, on the rise. So I don't know. I don't have a good answer for you. I just can tell you that that is what the data shows.
36:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:44 Speaker 01 So we, we grains of salt all of this. Okay.
36:46 Speaker 04 Okay.
36:47 Speaker 01 But consistently a reduction. And like, what level of reduction in carries prevalence do we have to hit for this to be considered important if we know that it's cost effective? That is like so far beyond my expertise, right? This is like, these are the big questions.
37:03 Speaker 04 I mean, it's still, it's still to me comes down to the fact that like, this is a community public health approach versus you have to go then go to the store and buy mouthwash and buy the right toothpaste and go to the dentist and all of the things that cost a lot of money. Whereas fluoridated water, it's just, yeah.
37:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And I will say.
37:23 Speaker 04 A reasonable solution.
37:25 Speaker 01 Doesn't it? And so that's what we've decided. Okay. So now we have to get into what I know that everyone probably really wants to know is there's a lot of people talking about that fluoride is actually quite harmful to us. So what does the data show? What are the risks, if any, of having fluoride in our water?
37:45 Speaker 01 There are only two potential harms that are worth talking about in detail today. So that's what I'm going to focus on. But I do just want to point out that there are an endless array of things that fluoride has been blamed for and continues to be blamed for.
38:01 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
38:02 Speaker 01 Kidney dysfunction, kidney stones, bladder cancer, all cancers, sex hormone disruption, ADHD, diabetes, liver dysfunction, infertility, musculoskeletal pain. Throw a dart at your pathophysiology textbook. Someone has made a claim that fluoride has caused it.
38:16 Speaker 04 I mean, what last week, what did I say? Undo financial distress or something like that?
38:20 Speaker 01 There's actually data that fluoride in the water. People work more and they they have better income and stuff. There's some papers that say that, which is so interesting.
38:30 Speaker 04 I mean, yeah, you're not having to go to the dentist to like for emergency dental carries repair all the time.
38:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:38 Speaker 04 Whatever.
38:39 Speaker 01 What does the data show? Okay, let's let's look at this.
38:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:43 Speaker 01 There are some things that we know for sure. There is very consistent evidence of absolutely no association between fluoride exposure and cancer.
38:55 Speaker 04 Right.
38:55 Speaker 01 Or cancer related mortality, or bone cancer specifically, or hip fracture, or Down syndrome, or kidney stones. So that we can say definitely no association.
39:07 Speaker 04 No association.
39:08 Speaker 01 Thyroid dysfunction is another thing that people say is caused by fluoride. There is really limited evidence for any association one way or another. There are papers, some of which show an association, some of which do not show an association. At this point, we cannot make any solid conclusion for thyroid dysfunction. And most of the rest of these claims, there is simply no data to even evaluate these associations, which just means that anyone who says that these associations exist is lying. It does not mean that for sure, there's absolutely no way that this could ever be related, but there there is literally no data to support these ideas. Okay.
39:46 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
39:47 Speaker 01 But there are two outcomes that are worth digging into a little bit more because of the Wealth of information that we have on the subject and all of the controversies that exist right now. And those two are skeletal fluorosis.
40:00 Speaker 04 Okay.
40:01 Speaker 01 And impacts on intelligence as measured by IQ, but which is often conflated as just this blanket idea of neurotoxicity.
40:11 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
40:12 Speaker 01 So let's get into these two, shall we?
40:14 Speaker 04 I'm very excited for this. Yeah.
40:15 Speaker 01 Yeah. Excited is not the word I would use.
40:18 Speaker 04 I am. Yeah.
40:20 Speaker 01 It's fine. We're excited. Listen. Skeletal fluorosis. Okay. Erin, you talked to us a lot last week about dental fluorosis. And that is when we're exposed to a lot of fluoride and then our teeth get modeled enamel from it because of the fluoride actually accumulating in our teeth. So much like fluoride can accumulate in our teeth if we're exposed at high levels, it can also accumulate in our bones. And this can lead to deficient mineralization, essentially because fluoride is getting taken up in our bones instead of the other minerals that would normally get taken up in our bones.
40:56 Speaker 04 Okay.
40:56 Speaker 01 So then you just have a change in your bone structure and potentially weaker bones. Now, remember that we have very strong data that there's no association between community water fluoridation and hip fractures, which was one of our main metrics to look at like the strength of bones. Okay. But skeletal fluorosis is something that definitely can happen and does happen. It generally happens at long term intakes of six to 14 milligrams of fluoride or more per day.
41:27 Speaker 04 Okay. So what is that in terms of parts per million?
41:30 Speaker 01 Should we? Should we err in math a little bit?
41:32 Speaker 04 Yes, we should.
41:33 Speaker 01 We can't wait. Okay.
41:36 Speaker 01 If you, this is erring math trademark. I could be wrong, but I did the math. Okay. If you got all of your fluoride from drinking water in the US from optimally fluoridated sources, then you would be drinking water that was 0.7 milligrams per liter or parts per million.
41:54 Speaker 04 Okay.
41:55 Speaker 01 You would have to drink eight and a half liters of water per day. If you got all of your fluoride from water, you would have to drink eight and a half liters of water per day just to get six milligrams. Fluoride in your diet. I don't know about you, but I can't even get myself to drink two liters. Eight and a half liters of water per day, that would not be a healthy amount to drink. Okay?
42:16 Speaker 04 Right. And so that just remind me again, the range that leads to that is suggested to lead to skeletal fluorosis.
42:22 Speaker 01 So six to 14 milligrams per day puts you at higher risk of skeletal fluorosis. It does not mean that you will have it. But ingestion of six milligrams or more per day puts like at a population level, some people are going to end up with skeletal fluorosis.
42:38 Speaker 04 Okay.
42:38 Speaker 01 Now, no one is getting 100% of their daily fluoride from water. It's estimated that in the U. S. We get like 40 to 70% of our daily fluoride intake from our water. And the rest from other bottled beverages, food, black tea has so much fluoride in it.
42:57 Speaker 04 Really?
42:58 Speaker 01 Yeah. Um, and you know, toothpaste, especially our kids who are just like chugging that stuff.
43:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
43:06 Speaker 01 So annoying that they do that.
43:09 Speaker 01 Personal.
43:09 Speaker 04 Delicious though, right?
43:10 Speaker 01 Yeah. Why do they make it so delicious?
43:12 Speaker 04 Is it delicious?
43:13 Speaker 01 No, but they think it is. It's like bubblegum flavored and it's so gross. Anyways.
43:19 Speaker 04 Bubblegum flavored toothpaste grosses me out.
43:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, dude, same, but I buy it. If you assume then on the low end that you get 40% of your fluoride from water. We can air and math this as well. In order to get to that six milligrams a day, you'd have to still be drinking like three and a half liters of water. 3.4 liters of water and somehow getting another 2.6 milligrams from somewhere else. And you'd be hard pressed to get that from your other dietary sources. Eating a lot of toothpaste, I guess, might get you there. So the math just does not work out. And there are some pretty large meta-analyses that have estimated like, what does water have to be at for someone to have an increased risk of skeletal fluorosis?
44:06 Speaker 01 From their drinking water.
44:07 Speaker 04 From just daily drinking.
44:08 Speaker 01 Right. You've got to be looking at higher than 3.7 to 3.8 parts per million.
44:13 Speaker 04 Which is if you were getting something from like a deep well that has not been evaluated for.
44:19 Speaker 01 Definitely could be drinking that. So realistically, bottom line, skeletal fluorosis is not something that is a concern from drinking water at the levels that we see in optimally fluoridated water systems.
44:32 Speaker 04 Question.
44:33 Speaker 01 Yes.
44:34 Speaker 04 How is skeletal fluorosis diagnosed?
44:37 Speaker 01 Oh, that's a really good question. I don't actually know the full answer to that.
44:42 Speaker 04 Okay.
44:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:43 Speaker 04 So do we know the prevalence of skeletal fluorosis?
44:46 Speaker 01 No, in areas that like the highest prevalence in areas that have like really high levels of water fluoridation. I've seen like maybe 10 or 11, 12%, but like across the globe, it's pretty low. But it certainly is a risk in areas that have really high fluoride levels. And I think there are probably some populations somewhere that have much higher levels than that. But I don't have like global estimates or anything.
45:08 Speaker 04 And so this would be like in areas where you see higher, like maybe there are geographic areas with higher hip fractures. Then you might suspect that there's higher levels of fluoride in the drinking water, something like that.
45:19 Speaker 01 I don't know that I would even go that far, honestly.
45:22 Speaker 04 Okay.
45:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't think that we have any data to support those kinds of estimates. No.
45:26 Speaker 04 Okay.
45:27 Speaker 01 Yeah. Now, on the other hand, mild dental fluorosis, which again, dental fluorosis you get from having higher levels of fluoride in your water. We do still see some degree of mild dental fluorosis, which is it's considered mild if it's not enough to cause significant cosmetic concerns. But like a dentist would see it on your teeth.
45:47 Speaker 04 Right.
45:48 Speaker 01 Depending on the study, there's some estimates of like 10 to 12% of the population in areas that are like optimally fluoridating their water can still have a mild dental fluorosis. So that is real. But that's, it's not real for skeletal fluorosis at the levels
46:05 Speaker 04 Right.
46:06 Speaker 01 of optimally fluoridated water.
46:08 Speaker 04 It's not like having a health impact.
46:10 Speaker 01 Correct.
46:10 Speaker 04 It's having teeth, like the, the appearance of teeth.
46:14 Speaker 01 Correct.
46:14 Speaker 04 Of your teeth.
46:15 Speaker 01 And only in a small proportion of the population.
46:17 Speaker 04 Right, right, right.
46:18 Speaker 01 Correct.
46:21 Speaker 01 So now a very quick diversion, a little bit more numbers before we get into the possible neurotoxic effects of fluoride. Because these numbers are going to get really important because surprise, surprise, we need a little bit of nuance here. Okay?
46:38 Speaker 01 I've said 100 times already, the US Public Health Service recommends that if communities are going to add fluoride to their water, they do so at a level of 0.7 milligrams per liter, or parts per million.
46:49 Speaker 04 Parts per million, yeah.
46:50 Speaker 01 Now, the EPA, which is the body who is in charge of regulating and enforcing standards for things like our drinking water. Their standard for the maximum amount of fluoride that should be in our drinking water is 4 milligrams per liter. That is the level at which they can actually enforce something. Their recommended maximum is 2 milligrams per liter, but it's not actually enforceable. So if a community, for example, has fluoride naturally occurring in their water between 2 and 4, the EPA can be like, hey, listen, that's a little high, but they cannot do anything about it unless it's above 4.
47:32 Speaker 04 Okay, this, this brings to mind a question about the fluoridation laws that are currently being, or anti-fluoridation laws that are currently being discussed or have already been passed, like in Utah and Florida. If there is naturally occurring fluoride, and this is maybe, this is like a question that maybe you can't answer.
47:53 Speaker 01 I can't, but it is the question, Erin.
47:55 Speaker 04 It is, it is the question. If there is naturally occurring fluoride in one of these states where you're not allowed to add fluoride to your water, is there anything done to reduce the fluoride in that water?
48:09 Speaker 01 That, that is the question, because it also is who is checking it and who is enforcing those regulations, right? Because the EPA is in charge of detecting this and of enforcing these regulations. What teeth do they have to be able to enforce those regulations? The more that we defund the EPA, what ability do they even have to be doing the water testing that they need to be doing to make sure that our fluoride is at a safe level, especially in places with naturally occurring fluoride?
48:37 Speaker 04 I'm sure a corporation would love to, you know, hop in and charge a great deal of money for that.
48:42 Speaker 01 That's a great idea, Erin.
48:43 Speaker 04 Privatization, yeah.
48:44 Speaker 01 So listen, for what it's worth, the World Health Organization... recommends that drinking water should have no more than 1.5 milligrams per liter. That's their maximum that should be allowed in drinking water. And they say that for any place who is adding fluoride for community water fluoridation, they should do so at a level between 0.5 and 1 milligrams per liter.
49:05 Speaker 04 Okay.
49:06 Speaker 01 And these numbers, especially that World Health Organization recommendation of no more than 1.5 milligrams per liter, that number is important. So keep that in your brain. Okay?
49:15 Speaker 04 Okay. Yep.
49:16 Speaker 01 Back in 2015, so like a decade ago now, the recommendation in the US for optimally fluoridated water was a little bit different. It was like a range. You could go anywhere from 0.7 to 1.2.
49:29 Speaker 04 Okay.
49:30 Speaker 01 But then because of the incidence of dental fluorosis being higher at levels above 1, they decided to lower it to 0.7 back in 2015.
49:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
49:42 Speaker 01 That same year is when they established a task force through the NIH, actually, not the CDC, but through the National Toxicology Program to look into the effects of fluoride on neurodevelopment and specifically on IQ.
50:00 Speaker 04 Okay.
50:00 Speaker 01 The results of that have now been published just this year.
50:06 Speaker 04 10 years. Okay.
50:07 Speaker 01 There was a monograph by the National Toxicology Program that came out in August 2024. And then in January of this year, a like subsequent, like an additional meta-analysis that was published in JAMA Pediatrics.
50:20 Speaker 04 Okay.
50:21 Speaker 01 So I'm going to tell you the conclusions of this study, Erin.
50:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
50:25 Speaker 01 There is a dose-response relationship between exposure to high levels of fluoridated water and lower IQ scores in children. Plain English.
50:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
50:39 Speaker 01 Kids who are drinking water that has higher levels of fluoride, specifically kids who are drinking water with more than 1.5 milligrams per liter of fluoride may have slightly lower IQs than kids who are drinking water with less fluoride. And it's like, it goes up with the amount of fluoride above 1.5 milligrams per liter.
51:04 Speaker 04 Above 1.5 and there's a, like, the more fluoride, the higher the reduction in IQ, which as we maybe know is not a, the best metric for things, but it is a metric. Yeah.
51:22 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
51:22 Speaker 04 You have thought, do you have?
51:23 Speaker 01 There's so, there's so much that I am bursting to say and it's, it's hard. Okay?
51:30 Speaker 04 Yeah.
51:30 Speaker 01 Um, and I cannot get too in-depth on the exact effect size of this because we don't have those exact numbers from drinking water itself. Like, what is, what are we talking about? How much of a reduction in IQ?
51:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
51:43 Speaker 01 They didn't actually estimate those numbers from drinking water, but they also looked in this meta-analysis at urinary fluoride.
51:51 Speaker 01 Which is, it's a little bit problematic to use because we excrete most of the fluoride that we drink in our urine, but the like concentrations are going to vary depending on the time and how much water you drink and blah, blah, blah. But in any case, for every one milligram per liter increase in urinary fluoride, we saw in this meta-analysis, a 1.63 points decline in IQ.
52:16 Speaker 04 Okay.
52:17 Speaker 01 Okay.
52:17 Speaker 04 Just again, to like set, just so that I understand, this is in, okay. Maybe I'll phrase it this way.
52:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:26 Speaker 04 Which communities in the US have water that's higher than 1.5 parts per million?
52:31 Speaker 01 Before I can even get into that, Erin, none of the studies that were in this meta-analysis were in the US. None of them. Almost every single study that was included in this meta-analysis were done in places that had naturally high levels of fluoridation. None of them were in places that were adding fluoride to the water at optimum fluoride concentrations. A lot of the studies that were, a lot of the studies that had, you know, like low fluoride versus high fluoride, their low fluoride concentrations were Actually at levels that are consistent with what we consider fluoridated water. Right? Because like across the board, everyone's got higher fluoride. So high fluoride was like
53:13 Speaker 01 above two and low fluoride was like point five to point eight. Okay?
53:19 Speaker 01 I know this is so, it's too much.
53:21 Speaker 04 No, no, no, no. Okay. So, so this, this, this review, this meta analysis, I guess this, this task force.
53:28 Speaker 01 Yes.
53:28 Speaker 04 That was established in the US.
53:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, part of the National Toxicology Program. Yeah. I guess I don't know if it was a task force feels official, but yeah.
53:36 Speaker 04 Okay, okay.
53:37 Speaker 01 Okay.
53:37 Speaker 04 But there was not a single study that it was included that was done, that was based in the US.
53:43 Speaker 01 No.
53:44 Speaker 04 Looking at water that is community fluoridated in the US.
53:48 Speaker 01 No. Another meta-analysis from a couple of years ago, published in 2023, which one could argue might be more relevant to the question of like, is fluoridating our water 2.7 parts per million potentially harmful? Found no reduction in IQ between un-fluoridated water, which had an average fluoride concentration of 0.2 parts per million and optimally fluoridated water, which was at 0.7 parts per million. And if you look at this, that is actually entirely consistent with this newer meta-analysis from 2025 because all of the data in this meta-analysis showed that there was a potential for reduction in IQ at levels higher than 1.5. There was no association seen
54:34 Speaker 01 for IQ at lower levels than 1.5 milligrams per liter. That association broke down and fell apart. There was no data to support it in this large meta-analysis.
54:46 Speaker 04 So if you're looking at a graph of this, maybe this is a terrible thing to do on a podcast, but hey, we're video now. But not, I'm just gonna use my hands.
54:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:56 Speaker 04 But if you're looking at a graph of this, and on the x-axis, the bottom is fluoride levels in the water. And it's, and the, on the y-axis is like reduction in IQ or something. Yeah.
55:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:09 Speaker 04 It's a straight level from zero, from like no fluoride in the water, all the way past where the 0.7 optimally fluoridated water. Keep going, still straight line until you get to like, what, 1.5?
55:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, above 1.5.
55:24 Speaker 04 And then it starts to, you know, change.
55:27 Speaker 01 Exactly.
55:29 Speaker 04 Okay.
55:32 Speaker 01 That's the conclusion, Erin.
55:35 Speaker 04 So.
55:37 Speaker 01 You asked, sorry, you asked earlier, how much, how many people are getting more than 1.5?
55:47 Speaker 04 Yeah.
55:48 Speaker 01 Okay. In the US, it's estimated that 2.9 million people are served by groundwater or private wells that have concentrations greater than 1.5, and several hundred thousand having concentrations higher than 2.0, which is again, the EPA non-inforceable maximum recommended, or even some above 4.0, which is above what is even supposed to be enforceable by the EPA. Globally, it's estimated that 57 million people at least receive water that is naturally fluoridated, which means who heckin' knows what the concentration of fluoride is, right?
56:27 Speaker 04 Right, right.
56:29 Speaker 04 Fascinating.
56:30 Speaker 01 Compared to 200 million people in the US who are estimated to get their water from optimally fluoridated community water fluoridation sources at .7 parts per million.
56:41 Speaker 04 I mean, this just to me speaks even further to that the, the point of the anti-fluoridation movement is not to actually like protect health. It's just to deregulate and be anti-expert. Because I really, I really do want to know whether these states that are introducing these anti-fluoride bans, or these fluoride bans are doing anything in the communities that are served by naturally fluoridated water at levels that are shown to have any sort of health impact.
57:17 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I also want to point out a big difference that I noticed, because again,
57:25 Speaker 01 There are so many papers on this and there are so many papers that have a very clear bent to them, right? Because I mean, even scientists, like, we all have our own biases, right?
57:35 Speaker 04 Totally.
57:36 Speaker 01 And, and some of them have a very clear bent, some of them, it's maybe less clear. And, and I mean, in both directions, right? Like, some are very clearly, like, pro-fluoride, and some are very clearly anti-fluoride, and a lot are somewhere in between. But, from the scientific side, and not from like, the social media side, or the political side, or the like, we, like, it is a neurotoxin, it's killing us side, right?
57:57 Speaker 04 Right.
57:58 Speaker 01 All of the papers, even the ones that are very concerned about fluoride in their water, the main concern that I took away from those is the potential effect of maternal ingestion of high levels of fluoride?
58:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
58:10 Speaker 01 Or infant ingestion of high levels of fluoride, especially in the context, which I will say I had not thought about before, of formula use. Like, if babies are not breastfed and are fed by formula, because some formulas actually have relatively higher levels of fluoride. So then, if you are also using fluoridated water, whether naturally fluoridated or optimally fluoridated, because infants are so tiny, could you potentially be getting too much in those tiny humans? But even on those points, there has been very mixed results from even, like, long-term studies. There was a paper from 2019 in JAMA Pediatrics that got a
58:49 Speaker 01 lot of press, and it seems was very controversial, that showed a, for, looking specifically at maternal ingestion of fluoridated water in Canada, where they optimally fluoridate their water.
59:03 Speaker 04 Okay.
59:04 Speaker 01 They showed a reduction in IQ in those babies born to people who are drinking fluoridated water, but only in boys. And that was not true in girls, and it was not true if you looked at all babies. So that was a little bit like, we don't understand how that could be. And then, another analysis on, I don't know if it was the exact same cohort, or, but like, using that same study, because it's like, this really huge study in Canada, that came out a couple of years later, actually did not show any difference in IQ, once they accounted for exposure after birth. So even kids who are drinking fluoride in their water did not have lower IQ than those who were not drinking fluoridated water.
59:47 Speaker 01 So again, the data is still a little bit messy. Like, there's not a clear, there's not a clear association there at optimally fluoridated levels.
59:54 Speaker 04 Right, okay. I, I think I'm just confused by tho- those studies are like what they're, what the conclusions are. I mean, basically, it sounds like it's noisy and a mess.
1:00:05 Speaker 01 It's noisy and a mess, and there's still not, like, there is not the conclusion that optimally fluoridated water has an impact on IQ.
1:00:14 Speaker 04 And I think that's, that's the message that gets lost.
1:00:18 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:00:18 Speaker 04 Because people will just say fluoride.
1:00:20 Speaker 01 Right.
1:00:21 Speaker 04 And there is a big difference between fluoride and, and optimally, like naturally fluoridated.
1:00:28 Speaker 01 Right.
1:00:28 Speaker 04 And optimally fluoridated, or like managed fluoride levels.
1:00:31 Speaker 01 Managed fluoride levels. And just, just to make this, drive this point home, with regards to any of the other so-called neurotoxic effects, because sometimes fluoride just gets labeled as like a neurotoxin, there is not any data to back up any of the other claims. Headaches, insomnia, lethargy, autism, ADHD, there's no data whatsoever that positively associates fluoride in our water with any of those other neurologic effects. Only IQ, and only at levels that are higher than the World Health Organization maximum recommended level, twice as high as what we see in community water fluoridation.
1:01:10 Speaker 04 Twice as high, yeah.
1:01:12 Speaker 01 So, for me, what I, one of the main conclusions that I come to, when we look at this debate on fluoride, is that there is always going to be a certain degree of uncertainty in science, right?
1:01:28 Speaker 04 We preach it in our, yeah.
1:01:30 Speaker 01 And that can sometimes feel really scary. But the nature of the scientific process and scientific inquiry is to keep asking questions. Could we do this better? Can we make this safer? Can we improve on our processes?
1:01:43 Speaker 04 Right.
1:01:44 Speaker 01 What changes do we need to make? What studies do we need to do to gather more data?
1:01:48 Speaker 04 I mean, it's why we revised the the optimally fluoridated level to point seven.
1:01:53 Speaker 01 That's exactly why we revised it, right?
1:01:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:01:56 Speaker 01 At the same time, we have to function as a society, our governments, our regulatory bodies, they have to make the best decisions that they can based on the data that we have. And that is exactly what has happened and continues to be happening when it comes to fluoride. No one is not looking at this problem. There is so much data now that we have that at the levels of fluoride that exist in some of the naturally fluoridated areas, we need to figure out how to lower fluoride levels in those communities because we could potentially be causing harm.
1:02:29 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:02:29 Speaker 01 And there is data that at the level of point seven milligrams per liter at less than 1.5, there is a significant improvement in our dental health and no adverse effects other than a slight increase in mild dental fluorosis.
1:02:45 Speaker 04 I mean, and some of this stuff, like, I think it's hard because, and we talked about this a little last week, we've been fluoridating water for 80 years. And things have, and we've learned a lot in that time, and we've made adjustments accordingly in that time. And we've been open, I do think, I think there's sometimes an accusation from certain individuals or people with certain agendas to say that science just barges ahead without thinking of the consequences.
1:03:16 Speaker 01 And sometimes we do.
1:03:17 Speaker 04 Sometimes we do. There, I mean, there's, this is, this podcast will kill you. We've talked about a lot of instances where that's happened.
1:03:23 Speaker 01 Exactly.
1:03:24 Speaker 04 But I think when it comes to fluoride, like, just like you said, that the questions, the fact that there are still some unanswered questions is not, cannot erase the fact that we have answered many, many, many questions about fluoride and optimally fluoridated water.
1:03:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. I do think it's It's not, this is not the end of the fluoride story. There's going to be more data, more studies that keeping done, especially at like trying to pull apart the nuances. Should we go from point seven to point five, to point six, to point six five? I don't know. Can we keep doing better?
1:03:59 Speaker 04 And I think some of the data will come from these states that are choosing to stop fluoridating.
1:04:06 Speaker 01 We already have data. You mentioned last week, Erin, in Calgary in Canada, where they took fluoride out of the water. There was a 10-year analysis that has looked so far and has seen a slight, not like a huge, but a slight increase in dental carries there compared to Edmonton, which still has fluoridated water. There's also a few other studies that I cite that are looking at exactly the same thing. So in places where they've taken fluoride out of the water, what do we see? We see worse dental health. The other thing I think that for me, this really points out is like the importance of our federal regulatory bodies and how essential they are in keeping our drinking water safe.
1:04:48 Speaker 01 Because if we're talking about, oh, my gosh, we're looking at this potentially extremely harmful chemical and all of these effects, then, and like our community water systems are actually poisoning us. First of all, we got to look at the data. So we need some scientists to actually look at the data and explore all of this nuance, which they've done. And then we need our regulatory agencies to be able to identify what the limits should be and enforce those limits. So who is going to fund that?
1:05:19 Speaker 04 Right. These jobs should exist and some of them no longer do.
1:05:24 Speaker 01 Exactly. They're already being taken away.
1:05:26 Speaker 04 Right. What pathogens are in milk?
1:05:27 Speaker 01 Right.
1:05:28 Speaker 04 Like what bird flu in milk? You know, it's just, there's so much.
1:05:31 Speaker 01 That's the thing that's so, I think, frustrating about the discourse surrounding fluoride right now is it's like, we'll take this out of our water, when it's like, what, then who, what, like, first of all, who is going to do that? Second of all, who, who is going to enforce this? What about all the places that already have it there? Like, the politics of it are just so different from what the science shows right now.
1:05:56 Speaker 04 Oh, and I think that's the whole point, right?
1:05:57 Speaker 01 I know.
1:05:58 Speaker 04 Fluoride is a tool to, you know, again deregulate and privatize and change who the experts are.
1:06:06 Speaker 01 I know. Well, if you want to become an expert on this, let me tell you where to read, okay?
1:06:12 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:06:12 Speaker 01 Uh, I already mentioned there was a great nature of used disease primers paper just about dental carries. It was called Dental Carries from 2017. A couple of other great papers that I had on the mechanism of action of fluoride. Actually, Erin, did you read this one from the Journal of Dental Research in 2019? It was called Fluoride Mode of Action: Once There Was An Observant Dentist?
1:06:32 Speaker 04 Uh, no, I didn't.
1:06:33 Speaker 01 It was really fun. It was like quite historical, but it was really, really fun. Um, then when we get into the, you know, the meat of what people want, the paper from 2025 from JAMA Pediatrics was by Taylor et al. Fluoride Exposure and Children's IQ Scores: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. The one from a couple of years earlier that looked at more relevant fluoride levels was by Kumar et al. in the Journal of Public Health. That was titled Association Between Low Fluoride Exposure and Children's Intelligence: A Meta-Analysis Relevant to Community Water Fluoridation. There was another one I actually loved. Sorry, I'm giving shout outs longer than I usually do, but this one was super great from 2024 by Tayher et al.
1:07:16 Speaker 01 I'm sorry if I'm pronouncing that wrong, in Critical Reviews in Toxicology. This paper looked not just at IQ, but this one looked at every claim that people have made about fluoride. What is the evidence epidemiologically? What is the toxological evidence? Um, what is the evidence in animals, in vitro? And it came up with this really comprehensive table to look at all of these. And so that is a really great paper. You can check out the list of sources from this episode and every single one of our episodes on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com. There's so many more.
1:07:51 Speaker 04 There's so many more. Thank you again so much to Dr. Santore for sharing that story with us.
1:07:58 Speaker 01 Thank you so much.
1:07:59 Speaker 04 We appreciate you so much.
1:08:00 Speaker 01 We really do. Thank you also to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes.
1:08:06 Speaker 04 All of them. Thank you to Tom and Leanna and Pete and Brent and Jess and everyone at Exactly Right who helps this to happen, helps this to happen, helps us make this happen. Yeah, here we go. We'll go with that.
1:08:20 Speaker 01 And thank you to all of you for listening. For watching, for joining us on this journey. We're done with fluoride for now.
1:08:26 Speaker 04 It's the journey for now, but we're not done with teeth.
1:08:29 Speaker 01 No.
1:08:30 Speaker 04 Or gums, or flossing, or whatever.
1:08:33 Speaker 01 Can't wait.
1:08:33 Speaker 04 Anyway, thank you also to our wonderful patrons. We appreciate your support so very much.
1:08:39 Speaker 01 We do. Thank you.
1:08:41 Speaker 04 Well, until next time, brush your teeth.
1:08:47 Speaker 01 You filthy animals.
1:08:49 Speaker 04 And wash your hands.
1:08:50 Speaker 01 Both.
1:09:12 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day, but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue. So you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
1:09:57 Speaker 01 Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works. With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans, develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a prioritized schedule. So you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at chatgpt.com. This is Shirley Strawberry from the Steve Harvey Morning Show.
1:10:41 Speaker 01 Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features and tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at trade-in, get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
Previous Ep 178 Fluoride 1: The real tooth fairy Next Special Episode: Professor Steven Mithen & The Language Puzzle Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated