Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 178 Fluoride 1: The real tooth fairy About this episode Is it just us, or does it seem like every other week there’s a new headline about some state or town banning water fluoridation? As it turns out, this has been going on for decades, basically since fluoride was first introduced. Why are some people opposed to fluoride? Is there any basis to their fears? What does fluoride actually do? And how the heck did we find out about it? This week and next, we’re deep diving into our first dental discussion about this revolutionary mineral. In the first of these episodes, we explore the origins of fluoridation and the outcry against it - how did tuberculosis, a gold rush town, and a dentist with an insatiable curiosity set the stage for one of the greatest public health achievements of the 20th century? And why has there been pushback against it since its inception? Tune in to find out.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,160 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is Exactly Right.
0:06 Speaker 01 Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather, and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non-gracey, and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to O'Keefe'sCompany.com to get yours today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company dot com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
0:38 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
0:46 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
0:54 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
0:57 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking. One less thing to figure out. Learn more at BofA.com/simplebanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
1:08 Speaker 00 Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln Original Series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:39 Speaker 04 It is now 25 years since the late, trendly dean and I journeyed by train from Washington DC to Grand Rapids, Michigan, to be joined by Philip J. for a meeting with the mayor to gain his approval for a water fluoridation experiment. There were no signs of apprehension, of daring, or of pioneering. There was no suggestion that we were being foolhardy in subjecting a population of 160,000 people to a procedure which might have either short- or long-range hazards. We were merely replicating nature's best, based on an extensive background of study data in nature's laboratory.
2:20 Speaker 04 In the United States alone, some 7 million people in 1,900 communities had, throughout life, used drinking water which was naturally fluoridated with a fluoride concentration of 0.7 parts per million or more. We knew what too much fluoride did. We knew what too little did. We knew what the optimum amount was, and we had reassurance that one part per million fluoride in the drinking water had the same biological effect, whether it got there from flowing over rocks or from a feeding machine. 25 years ago, there were no anti-fluoridationists to becloud the issue or distort our efforts.
3:04 Speaker 04 The opponents of fluoridation act collectively as merchants of fear and doubt, implicating fluoride as either causing or exacerbating virtually every disease and biologic malfunction known to mankind. They discovered early that the public referendum method afforded them excellent opportunities to exploit fear and doubt while posing as protectors of human rights and religious freedom. The anti-fluoridationists sought opportunities to engage us in debate on the platform, on radio, and on television. In retrospect, it is clear that it took us much too long to learn that these public
3:44 Speaker 04 debates, these confrontation dialogues, increased confusion rather than understanding, and thereby helped serve the cause of the anti-fluoridationists. On July 27, 1969, the Assembly of the World Health Organization, at its annual meeting in Boston, endorsed water fluoridation. This endorsement adds another asset of great potential use. That potential will not be activated, however, unless it engenders commitment and political action by the proponents of water fluoridation. It has been said that only a fool learns from his own mistakes. You are invited to escape that classification by learning from the mistakes committed by me
4:29 Speaker 04 and my colleagues during the past 25 years.
5:18 Speaker 01 Erin.
5:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
5:20 Speaker 01 That's very interesting.
5:22 Speaker 04 Isn't it? Yeah. So that is a, like a reflection article about fluoridation after 25 years by one of the people who like led the charge, John Knutson. And that paper was published in 1970.
5:35 Speaker 01 Oh, wow.
5:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
5:37 Speaker 01 Long time.
5:38 Speaker 04 It's just, it's fascinating to me. I think also the reflection of like, we made mistakes. We made mistakes by not being, by, by just assuming that the public would accept facts and science. Right?
5:54 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:56 Speaker 04 Like, yeah, we have science on our side, but that doesn't really do much.
6:00 Speaker 01 Doesn't mean all that much. Yeah.
6:01 Speaker 04 So it's so, it was really interesting. The whole, the whole paper is very interesting to read.
6:06 Speaker 01 I also, I love that I tell my five-year-old that all the time. I'm like, you could learn from our mistake. We're just trying for you to learn from our mistakes so that you don't have to make the same one.
6:15 Speaker 04 I know.
6:16 Speaker 01 It doesn't work with the five-year-olds. I don't know if it works with grownups either.
6:19 Speaker 04 No, certainly not. Rarely.
6:25 Speaker 04 Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
6:26 Speaker 01 And I'm Erin Allman Updike.
6:28 Speaker 04 And this is, this podcast will kill you.
6:30 Speaker 01 Welcome to episode one of two on fluoride.
6:35 Speaker 04 Fluoride. There's a lot there. We wanted to get it all, you know, out in the open. Full story.
6:44 Speaker 01 I am really excited about this. We split this episode into two episodes, this series. We're making a series out of it, very much like we did with raw milk. So today I just get to listen. So excited about that. I mean, well, you tell us all about the history of fluoridation and how we got to where we are today. And then next week I'll go through what the heck is a cavity anyways?
7:12 Speaker 04 What it, yeah.
7:14 Speaker 01 And what do we know about the like biological effects of fluoride?
7:17 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:18 Speaker 01 I can't wait.
7:19 Speaker 04 I, I am really excited. I mean, like, it's, it's very funny to me because when I was doing this, and I'll tell you more about this, like in the actual episode.
7:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:29 Speaker 04 But the parallels between raw milk and fluoride are just off the charts. Where I'm like,
7:35 Speaker 01 I expect nothing less.
7:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:37 Speaker 01 It feels also very anti-vaxy, too. Like, it's all the same. It's all the same playbook, like we've talked about, you and I, a lot.
7:45 Speaker 04 Yes, the playbook. That's what I think, reading that paper, it's funny because like, we talk about this in our, in our presentations where we're like, this is how disinformation spreaders, this is, these are the strategies they use.
7:56 Speaker 01 Yes.
7:56 Speaker 04 Debate equal side or equal time to both sides. And I'm like, oh, my gosh. There were so many other things, just like fear and doubt. And then I think the other thing.
8:06 Speaker 01 Maverick scientist.
8:07 Speaker 04 Yep. The other thing being inaction, that like, people don't feel well informed enough about fluoride, because it is a really complex scientific topic to vote at all. So then, even if they might be pro fluoridation, they're like, but it feels safer to not vote. It feels safer to not vaccinate, despite what we know. Anyway, it's, there's so much.
8:26 Speaker 01 Because it feels like not doing something is like not taking a side.
8:31 Speaker 04 Yes.
8:31 Speaker 01 When in fact, it is still taking a side. So yeah, it's, ah.
8:36 Speaker 04 And getting people to like, be pro fluoride and not just like, you know, indifferent is really like pulling teeth.
8:47 Speaker 01 Is it, Erin?
8:47 Speaker 04 Did you like that?
8:49 Speaker 01 That was really good. Your face was so straight when you said it.
8:54 Speaker 04 I was trying to find the best transition to quarantine time.
8:57 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, it's quarantine time.
8:58 Speaker 04 Quarantine time. We're drinking pulling teeth.
9:05 Speaker 01 I love it.
9:07 Speaker 04 I'm glad.
9:07 Speaker 01 Pulling teeth.
9:08 Speaker 04 Pulling teeth. It is.
9:09 Speaker 01 What's in it?
9:10 Speaker 04 It's delicious. It is, um, it's got elderflower liqueur, mint, prosecco, mint because like, you know, freshness, prosecco.
9:20 Speaker 01 Toothpaste.
9:21 Speaker 04 Soda water. Yeah.
9:21 Speaker 01 Toothpaste. Bring a little toothpaste.
9:23 Speaker 04 Don't, don't consume toothpaste. Do not.
9:26 Speaker 01 No, it has too much fluoride.
9:27 Speaker 04 Too much fluoride.
9:30 Speaker 04 It's a great little summery, refreshing bev and we'll post the full Quarantini recipe as well as the non-alcoholic placebo Rita on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com as well as on all of our social media channels, which if you're not following us on those, you should be.
9:45 Speaker 01 Check it out. We're there.
9:47 Speaker 04 We are.
9:48 Speaker 01 Also, if you haven't yet rated, reviewed and subscribed on whatever platform that you love to listen, uh, where you're listening right now, do so. We'd love it. It would appreciate, we would appreciate it. Um, if you're not already subscribed to the Exactly Right YouTube channel, you could do that as well, too. Um, we're there.
10:08 Speaker 04 We're there. We're also, we have a website, but you've listened to episodes before. You know what's there. Let's just get started.
10:15 Speaker 01 Thispodcastwillkillyou.com. Goodbye.
10:17 Speaker 04 Goodbye. Goodbye and hello. We'll, um,
10:23 Speaker 04 we'll get started, uh, just after this short break.
10:27 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day, but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue. So you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling
11:10 Speaker 01 comfortable all season long. Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
11:25 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
11:33 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
11:41 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
11:44 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at B of A dot com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
11:55 Speaker 00 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. How does music actually enter your mind?
12:17 Speaker 05 I'm not sure why or how the music comes to me, but I think people who love music and write music, our brains are just filled with music. Like, we have listened to so much music, we've been a part of so much music. I think of the story that I want to tell, the mood that I want to create with the music, start playing chords, see where they lead me.
12:39 Speaker 00 Sometimes I'm just not even thinking about music, right? And I hear this little thing and I go, oh, that could be this.
12:49 Speaker 05 You know, you just have to be ready for when the inspiration hits.
12:52 Speaker 00 Yeah. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
13:14 Speaker 04 Born in 1874, Frederick McKay had spent his childhood, like many others, in his hometown of Milford, Massachusetts. He worked in his father's dry goods store, he played in bands, he went to school. But when he turned 16, he noticed that something felt off. Maybe it was a lingering cough, maybe it was night sweats, persistent fever. The diagnosis, tuberculosis. Like many others at this time, I mean tuberculosis was rampant. He sought to cure his disease with a better climate, dry air. So he traveled to Colorado Springs where he recuperated for a while until he felt well enough to move back to Massachusetts.
13:59 Speaker 04 Upon returning to the Northeast, he decided on a life of dentistry. And just as he was completing his education, McKay's tuberculosis flared up again, driving him back west where he set up his dental practice in Colorado Springs in 1901. I think he was like, there's no point in me, like I should just stay out west forever.
14:18 Speaker 01 Okay.
14:19 Speaker 04 And before long, after his arrival there, he began to notice an unusual pattern in the teeth of some of his patients. And even just like talking to people around town, he noticed this, something on their teeth. And this was not anything that he had come across in his dental training. Their teeth were streaky with brown or yellow spots, something that he called mottled enamel and that the locals called Colorado stain or Colorado brown stain, which was a term not entirely welcomed by city officials who were trying to get people to come to the Springs, not repel them. And so McKay got kind of obsessed with the mystery of mottled enamel, like what the heck was causing it?
15:04 Speaker 04 And why did no one know about it? Why was this not in any dental textbook that he had come across? Other local dentists knew about it and they weren't all that interested. And they just kind of figured, well, specific to the Colorado region, it was kind of like, yeah, we've seen it before.
15:18 Speaker 01 How interesting to not, to just be like, yeah, this is how it is here. But I guess if you have no other frame of reference, so it makes sense, he like trained in one place, came to somewhere else and was like, this is different.
15:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, exactly. So he was like, what do you mean? This is not like, this is not what people, this is not what teeth look like.
15:36 Speaker 01 This is not just everywhere.
15:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:39 Speaker 04 And but when he so he briefly moved McKay briefly moved to St. Louis and that's when he would like confirmed for him, okay, this is not like a nationwide issue. This is something that is specific to the Colorado region. And so when he moved back to Colorado, again tuberculosis driven, he was like, okay, someone's got to get to the bottom of this. I guess it has to be me. I think secretly he was like, oh, my gosh, I really want to know what's happening here. Yeah. And so the first steps to solving this puzzle were raising awareness, which he did by attending various regional and state dental meetings, sometimes with a patient in tow to be like, Colorado Brown's name, open up. Yeah.
16:22 Speaker 04 And also just by getting a sense of the incidence and the geographical scope of the issue, which he did by examining children in Colorado Springs Public Schools. Eighty seven point five percent of the kids had mottled teeth. Wow, okay. Huge. Yeah. That's a huge proportion. Yeah. McKay's efforts made it clear that there was a real issue here that was worth looking into. It wasn't just like a local curiosity. This was affecting a great number of people's lives. And as McKay cast a wider net, traveling around the state to look for more cases and receiving help from dentists across the country, he realized that the Colorado stain was not at all limited to Colorado or even the US.
17:06 Speaker 04 I think there was like another term for it. I wish I'd written this down in Texas. It was like, maybe like Texas teeth or something like that. Because there were some communities that had mottled teeth. Yeah. Yeah, or mottled enamel. And so this this finding that it was like much more widespread and he was like, okay, there's got to be what is driving this led him to team up with a the dean of Northwestern University's dental school, whose name was Dr. Green Black, which is hilarious to me that it's yeah. And he they wanted to partner to systematically study like what was happening with the stain at the tissue level. You know, what what is the stain coming? Where's it coming from? Right. What is it in there? Yeah. And then try to find its root cause. Okay.
17:49 Speaker 04 As they collected more samples and more data on where and how the staining occurred, one thing stuck out to them. Even though the enamel on modeled teeth was rough and uneven, that didn't seem to make the teeth more susceptible to decay, which is what they would have predicted. In fact, what they noticed after examining thousands of patients was that decay was much lower in people with modeled enamel than it was in other populations. I mean, this could be huge. Like, this finding had huge implications. Right. Except they still didn't know what caused the modeling. Okay. But they had a suspicion. Okay. It was in the water. Hmm. Yeah.
18:34 Speaker 04 In his investigations, McKay had seen that children who lived elsewhere for the first two to three years of their life before moving to a modeled teeth area were not affected. Okay. So he also noticed that basically all members of a community, regardless of their diet, whether they were rich or poor, where their house was, they all had modeled teeth. He added stronger evidence to the water hypothesis when he visited a dentist in South Dakota who had reached out, asking for McKay's advice on the modeling that he saw in his own town. And it turned out that the town had switched their water supply 18 years prior. And you could draw a sharp line between those born before the switch, no modeling, and those born after, lots of modeling.
19:19 Speaker 04 Ooh. Right? Like, really compelling. And so, over the next 15 years, McKay continued his search for the answer and had, by the late 1920s, accumulated ample evidence that the water held the key. Okay. The final piece of the puzzle fell into place when McKay was sent by the US Public Health Service to a small town in Arkansas called Bauxite. And this is a mining community built for employees of the Aluminum Company of America, ALCOA.
19:52 Speaker 04 In 1909, Bauxite had switched their water from shallow wells to a deep well. And kids born after the switch had extremely mottled enamel. Okay. This was not welcome news for Alcoa, the company, the aluminum company, who was already under fire from claims that their aluminum cookware was toxic. And so they were like, this is going to be used as evidence that we're poisoning the water too now. Like, everyone's going to hate us even more.
20:21 Speaker 04 And so the chief chemist of Alcoa examined the water for rare elements using sophisticated tech not readily available. Okay. And he wrote to McKay about what he had found. Quote, "We have discovered the presence of hitherto unsuspected constituents in this water. The high fluorine content was so unexpected that a new sample was taken with extreme precautions. And again, the test showed fluorine in the water. They detected fluorine at a level of 13.7 parts per million." That's very high. Very high. Yeah. For context, the recommendation today is 0.7 parts per million. And it used to be 1, but then it was revised downward.
21:05 Speaker 04 And so that 0.7 recommendation is enough to protect against decay, but too low to cause fluorosis. Right. Yeah.
21:14 Speaker 04 13.7. That's quite, quite a lot higher. Very, very high. Yeah. So, but this was also, this was not necessarily, it's kind of interesting. I came across this later, but this is not necessarily the first time that fluorine had been linked to this. But for some reason McKay either like missed, like missed the memo on those or just like didn't, it didn't seem as compelling as this example here. Okay. And so then McKay, like this really was like, whoa, this seems, like this seems pretty, uh, strong. Right. At least like suggestive, right? Right, right, right. Like, we should look into this. Look into this. And so that's, that's what he did.
21:55 Speaker 04 He sent additional samples from other endemic areas where there's a lot of mottled enamel. And yes, the results were like, okay, this, every single one of these places where there is high teeth, like high modeling. Um, fluorine levels are high. Either, you know, ranged from two parts per million in Colorado Springs to 12 in Kidder, South Dakota.
22:19 Speaker 01 Okay.
22:20 Speaker 04 The US Public Health Service was pretty excited and worried about these results, which like historically, they were not, they didn't seem that interested in it.
22:28 Speaker 01 Okay.
22:29 Speaker 04 But now this was finally like, okay, we have, we have something to go on here.
22:33 Speaker 01 Right, right, right. We have some data here and not just like observational stuff.
22:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
22:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:38 Speaker 04 And so they sent a young dental officer, Dr. H. Trendley Dean, to get a clearer picture of the relationship between fluoride and modeling. And in his investigation, he found that not only was there a clear relationship between the degree of modeling and fluorine concentration, which was like in kind of like a dose, like there was like a continuous relationship essentially.
23:02 Speaker 01 Okay.
23:02 Speaker 04 He also observed the striking connection between fluorine and dental carries. In children who lived where the water supply had 0.6 to 1.5 parts per million, only 4% to 5% were carries free.
23:17 Speaker 01 Okay.
23:17 Speaker 04 Whereas in areas where the water was 1.7 to 2.5 parts per million, 22% were carries free. So like five times.
23:27 Speaker 01 Got it.
23:27 Speaker 04 More carries.
23:28 Speaker 01 So the higher the concentration of fluorine, then the more kids had no cavities whatsoever.
23:36 Speaker 04 Right. The higher the protective ability. Yeah.
23:38 Speaker 01 Okay.
23:39 Speaker 04 And then there was a study of 21 cities that showed that children aged 12 to 14 that had grown up in a city with 0.5 parts per million or less, had on average, more than seven decayed, missing and filled permanent teeth. These are kids aged 12 to 14.
23:56 Speaker 01 Wow.
23:56 Speaker 04 Yeah. Further studies showed that the carries protection provided by fluoride plateaued around one part per million, which was a level that only led to, quote, "sporadic instances of the mildest forms of dental fluorosis of no practical aesthetic significance." So it was like, okay, we don't need to add more and we're not going to add, we're not going to get more protection if we add more. If we add more, we're just going to get dental staining.
24:21 Speaker 01 Got it.
24:22 Speaker 04 And so Dean concluded in 1938, quote, "Inasmuch as it appears that the mineral composition of the drinking water may have an important bearing on the incidence of dental caries in a community, the possibility of partially controlling dental caries through the domestic water supply warrants thorough epidemiological chemical study."
24:44 Speaker 01 Okay.
24:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
24:46 Speaker 01 I'm on board.
24:47 Speaker 04 So nearly four decades after a tuberculosis flare-up sent Dr. Frederick McKay back west, where he embarked on unraveling the mystery of mottled teeth, dentistry in the US and around the globe was about to undergo a massive transition, where prevention now occurred alongside restoration as the primary goal. Previously, it wasn't really possible, like there wasn't enough known about what causes tooth decay to
25:17 Speaker 01 Interesting.
25:18 Speaker 04 to enact any sort of preventative measures.
25:20 Speaker 01 So this also, like this finding also allowed for just like preventive dentistry, period.
25:26 Speaker 04 Period.
25:27 Speaker 01 Yeah. Which is now like the cornerstone of dentistry.
25:30 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
25:30 Speaker 01 Yeah. Ha.
25:32 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. But as we'll see, not everyone welcomed this change and some actively fought against it.
25:39 Speaker 01 Classic.
25:40 Speaker 04 Classic. So next week, Erin, you're going to take us through more of the nitty gritty biology of how dental caries forms and what fluoride does to reduce decay.
25:52 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:52 Speaker 04 But I want to take some time here to talk about dental caries over history because what else am I going to get to do this? And plus, like any opportunity to talk about paleopathology, even the littlest bit is fun. So humans and many other species have been impacted by dental caries since well before we were humans, of course. Fish, hundreds of millions of years ago, dinosaurs, tens of millions of years ago.
26:17 Speaker 01 Stop it. Wait, wait, wait, wait.
26:18 Speaker 04 Yes.
26:18 Speaker 01 Do we have like fossil dinosaur teeth with cavities?
26:21 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
26:25 Speaker 01 Oh, I love that.
26:26 Speaker 04 I know, I know. Uh, also, are hominid relatives and ancestors wild animals today? Like bears get, get caries? Are domestic animals like dogs? I mean, caries for all.
26:38 Speaker 01 Right.
26:39 Speaker 04 So, let me just take a second here to define what caries is. Essentially, it's tooth decay. So, the hard enamel on the surface of a tooth begins to wear down and the inner soft dentin gets exposed and slowly decays, sometimes reaching the pulp cavity. The initial hit, that enamel loss, is helped along by bacteria in our mouth producing acid. Fluoride, by the way, acts to help strengthen that enamel and so that's how it protects us from caries. And a cavity, just to distinguish, because I was like, what is the difference?
27:10 Speaker 01 Cavity versus carry? I'm glad you're doing this. I don't have to next week.
27:13 Speaker 04 Okay. I mean, the cavity is essentially when that tooth decay turns into a hole. So, that's it. Like, it's like-
27:20 Speaker 01 So, like, caries is like the first initial bit? And then cavity?
27:24 Speaker 04 Caries is, well, okay, now I'm not entirely sure if it's like more of a general term or just like, like, caries is tooth decay and cavities is specific to when there's like, uh, tissue loss, maybe? Or like when there's a hole formed? Yeah.
27:39 Speaker 01 Okay.
27:39 Speaker 04 Yeah. And so, given that caries affects teeth and teeth stick around for a long time after we die, we can make some judgments on how the prevalence of caries has changed over human history.
27:52 Speaker 01 Okay.
27:52 Speaker 04 And it certainly has, uh, in ways you can probably predict. So, in general, dental caries increased as humans moved from a hunter-gatherer lifestyle to agriculture. And you can see this with different, um, groups, like, in the same region or era, right? So, as some groups, let's say you have like a similar region in the same time period, some groups are still mostly hunter-gathering and some are, um, farming. You can see within those groups even changes.
28:27 Speaker 01 Interesting.
28:27 Speaker 04 Yeah. And so, yeah, those that incorporated more farming and carbohydrates into their lifestyle had more caries.
28:34 Speaker 01 Okay, because of the foods they were eating.
28:35 Speaker 04 Exactly, yeah.
28:36 Speaker 01 Okay.
28:36 Speaker 04 Specifically, uh, carbohydrates, like cereals and potatoes and so on.
28:42 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yum.
28:43 Speaker 04 Yeah. And, I mean, things that I love so much.
28:48 Speaker 04 And this pattern continues today. As groups adopt quote unquote, "Western diets," their rates of caries increase.
28:54 Speaker 01 Okay.
28:55 Speaker 04 So let's put some numbers to this. If we look at the percentage of individuals within a population that have caries, so let's say like Europe, we can go back to around 4,500 BCE, which is post agricultural revolution. So rates are already higher than historically. And around that time, we see around 29% of adults impacted.
29:18 Speaker 01 Okay.
29:18 Speaker 04 This percentage rises and falls. So goes up to like 36% around 1,500 BCE, back down to the upper twenties percentages, closer to the first century CE. We see another rise in the seventh century to 56%, which is when refined sugar became a commercial product, apparently.
29:39 Speaker 01 Interesting.
29:40 Speaker 04 And today, global values are over 95%.
29:45 Speaker 01 I was gonna say 20%. That sounds so low.
29:48 Speaker 04 I know.
29:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:50 Speaker 04 Wow.
29:50 Speaker 01 Yeah. What is one thing many of us deal with every single day, but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue. So you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do.
30:32 Speaker 01 So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long. Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
30:49 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
30:57 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
31:05 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
31:09 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at BofA.com/simplbanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
31:19 Speaker 00 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. So you're helping Will.i.am write hooks. What made "Ordinary People" become the one song from those sound checks you knew you had to make your own?
31:47 Speaker 05 I was just writing for the Black Eyed Peas. I wasn't expecting to write something for myself in that session. But I wrote the hook for "Ordinary People," and I recorded a demo. And I'm like, I would rather keep "Ordinary People" for myself. This station in Chicago, WCCI, they start playing it before we're promoting it. The song spoke for itself. It became the defining song for my first album. I knew it was special, but you never know how special it's going to be and how much impact it's going to have in people's lives. And you never believe that you're going to actually change people's lives with a song.
32:17 Speaker 00 Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeartRadio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
32:41 Speaker 04 We know that it's diet causing this, but how? Okay, so I'm just gonna read you a quote, because this does it better than I could do it. It's from a book chapter, quote, "A cariogenic diet," as in one that produces Produces more caries. "has been defined by the following features: frequent intake of meals with a high content of carbohydrates, quickly fermentable, mainly sucrose, with retentive and sticky consistence that produces repetitive lowering of pH values and changes in the ecology of dental plaque," end quote. "More sugar, more carbs, like potatoes and cereals, equals more lesions and faster development of lesions." Right, and different microbiome in your mouth.
33:24 Speaker 04 Different microbiome in your mouth, totally. And so, since the advent of agriculture to the mid 20th century, it's like we were hurtling towards the state where caries was omnipresent and unavoidable. For centuries, caries and other dental woes had featured in medical texts, along with some creative treatments, including the Evers papyrus, but dentists were largely powerless to prevent the development of tooth decay. And so their efforts focused on restoration and keeping things from getting worse. Okay. Even after germ theory helped to make the connection between acid-producing bacteria and tooth decay, and also diet and acid-producing bacteria, there wasn't much that they could
34:09 Speaker 04 do to prevent caries, just treat it when it happened. Also, I've never thought about germ theory in the context of dental care and like, knowledge about cavities, right? Isn't that wild? Yeah. Love it. Me too. Yeah, and so, so there, it was mostly dental care was focused on, was focused on restoration, or even like, maybe detection, or measuring the rate of progress through like, x-ray technology, which was new as of the, you know, early 20th century, late 1800s. And that was the case until fluoride, specifically water fluoridation. Huh.
34:51 Speaker 04 Also, Erin, there are like, so many more topics that we should do in dentistry that I, like, I want to do like, gum health and certain diseases, you've, I like, I feel like I've seen that a lot, braces, grinding your teeth at night, hello, I mean, like, there's just like-
35:09 Speaker 04 There's like so much that we could do. So that's just my petition for more dental episodes.
35:13 Speaker 01 Okay. I mean, you don't have to work hard to convince me. Although I always like doing these episodes, I get it's so, so interesting. How? We don't learn any of this in medical school.
35:27 Speaker 04 Well, that's, that's another thing I would love to learn about when dentistry became a field.
35:33 Speaker 01 Right. And like, why is it so separate from quote unquote, medicine, like the rest of your body medicine? It's like eyes and teeth. We got to pull them out and they're going to be totally separate.
35:42 Speaker 04 We get separate insurances for eyes and teeth. They're a part of our bodies. Yeah.
35:46 Speaker 01 Why? They're part of our overall health, too. Like oral health is part of your health.
35:51 Speaker 04 100%.
35:52 Speaker 01 Then people come in with like a mouth complaint and I'm like, uh oh.
35:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, we should definitely, we should definitely do that.
36:02 Speaker 01 Right. The history of dentistry. I would love it.
36:04 Speaker 04 Yes. Okay. But that was just the briefest detour.
36:08 Speaker 01 Sorry, tangent.
36:08 Speaker 04 Through, no, through the history of, of carries. And so we left off before this little detour in the late 1930s with the knowledge that certain levels of fluoride in the water seemed to protect against tooth decay.
36:22 Speaker 01 Right.
36:22 Speaker 04 So the obvious next step would be to implement that knowledge.
36:26 Speaker 01 That's what I would think happens next.
36:28 Speaker 04 Yeah, it is what happens next. So in 1942, the US Public Health Service began talks with two cities in Michigan, Grand Rapids and Muskegon, to conduct an experiment with artificially fluoridating the water to one part per million, with Grand Rapids getting the fluoride and Muskegon acting as the control.
36:49 Speaker 01 Okay.
36:50 Speaker 04 The experiment was set to begin on January 1st, 1945. And within a few days, foreshadowing what was to come in later decades, the complaints started rolling in. Rashes, rapid weight gain, headaches, tumors. I mean, fluoride was blamed for a wide variety of health issues of the residents in the residents of Grand Rapids.
37:12 Speaker 01 Okay.
37:13 Speaker 04 The thing was fluoridation hadn't actually started yet.
37:20 Speaker 01 But it was like they knew, so okay.
37:22 Speaker 04 They knew it was coming, yeah.
37:23 Speaker 01 The residents, did the residents like agree to this?
37:26 Speaker 04 I don't think so. I think it was like a, like agreed upon by the city officials.
37:33 Speaker 01 Okay, so they didn't, they didn't necessarily agree, but they, they knew that this was coming. And they had maybe like a start date or something on their calendars and then they started having complaints about things. But they didn't actually, they hadn't actually started yet.
37:46 Speaker 04 Right. There was, there was like an unexpected delay in the shipment or like the delivery of fluoride. And so it didn't get added to the water until January 25th. But even before then, people had started to blame fluoride for things.
38:00 Speaker 01 And complain about things.
38:01 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:03 Speaker 01 Interesting.
38:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:04 Speaker 01 Please keep going.
38:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, so there was no, no evidence, of course, for fluoride causing these complaints because fluoride wasn't in the water yet. And in fact, what the evidence did show was that fluoride was a safe and effective way to drastically reduce tooth decay in a population. I mean, like the firsthand account said, there were seven million people who were getting their water from naturally fluoridated sources, right? And there had been a lot of studies, I don't know all of the studies, examining the, the different communities with and their health, you know, aspects. Those who were in fluoridated water, those who did not have fluoridated water and found pretty much that one of the, the only difference was the cavity protection.
38:49 Speaker 01 The teeth.
38:49 Speaker 04 Or carry protection.
38:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
38:50 Speaker 04 Yeah. Okay, so how did this experiment go? Fifteen years after water fluoridation was introduced to Grand Rapids, the rate of decayed, missing and filled teeth in 15 year old children had dropped 50%. Huge.
39:07 Speaker 01 Fifteen years also, like they're studying this 15 years. So that's a long, this is a very long term.
39:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:13 Speaker 01 Thing.
39:13 Speaker 04 They wanted to make sure that it was actually worth implementing. The other thing too is that. And I don't know if I mentioned this or not, but systemic fluoride, in order to like, when your teeth, and I know you'll get more into like this part of it,
39:25 Speaker 01 Right.
39:26 Speaker 04 but it is important in development when your teeth are developing. And so it would have taken a long time to see the benefits of that because these kids had to be born and then, yeah.
39:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, although we'll talk more later, it's also topical, so it's like in your mouth.
39:40 Speaker 04 Yes.
39:40 Speaker 01 Too, but yes, especially for kids.
39:43 Speaker 04 Systemic, and then if it's in your saliva, it's washing over your teeth.
39:45 Speaker 01 Exactly.
39:46 Speaker 04 Helping with enamel, but like for developing kids, to see those big effects in the reduction of caries was, yeah.
39:52 Speaker 01 Especially because we're talking about very, very low levels. It's not the same as like the sealants that your dentist might be putting on your teeth, right?
39:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
40:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:01 Speaker 04 Yep, and also just to kind of like bolster this, these findings, the data show that the tooth decay rates in fluoridated Grand Rapids were similar to other regions with naturally fluoridated water. So it was like this, even though we are putting fluoride into this water, the effect is the same as places that have naturally fluoridated water.
40:25 Speaker 01 And we're doing it at this lower level than most of these natural sources at one part per million.
40:31 Speaker 04 Right, optimized level.
40:33 Speaker 01 Okay.
40:35 Speaker 04 And so the cause and effect relationship, because before these, I mean, these were highly suggestive correlative studies, results, like where it was like, okay, caries rates lower in areas with higher fluoridation, but this actually showed like a cause and effect relationship.
40:53 Speaker 01 You're doing a randomized controlled trial.
40:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
40:55 Speaker 01 Rather than just an epidemiological observational study.
40:58 Speaker 04 Yes, 100%.
40:59 Speaker 01 It's beautiful, it's science in action.
41:02 Speaker 04 And this was also happening in other fluoridation experiments in cities in the US, in Canada, in the UK, in New Zealand, and elsewhere around the world. Other communities were fluoridating their water.
41:13 Speaker 01 Okay.
41:13 Speaker 04 And many cities and towns began fluoridating their water even before the results from Grand Rapids were out because they felt that the safety and efficacy of fluoridation had already been proven.
41:23 Speaker 01 Okay.
41:24 Speaker 04 In 1958, the WHO released a report concluding that fluoride was an effective and feasible public health measure to reduce dental caries. And they followed that up a few years later with an expert panel tasked with reviewing the safety data of fluoridation.
41:42 Speaker 04 I'm going to read you a quote from their conclusion.
41:45 Speaker 01 Okay.
41:45 Speaker 04 The results have shown that for the climatic nutritional and environmental conditions under which the surveys have been carried out, a level of approximately one part per million fluoride in temperate climates has no harmful effects on the community. The margin of safety is such that it will cover any individual variation of intake to be found in such areas, end quote. So it's like someone's drinking a lot of water, they're still going to be fine. Someone's drinking not very much, they're still going to be fine.
42:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:15 Speaker 04 Yeah. Yep. And so, starting in the 1960s with these promising results, cities and towns across the US and the rest of the world began fluoridating their water. Some states issued like a blanket fluoridation mandate while others allowed communities to exempt themselves by popular vote. In 1989, 135 million Americans, so 62.1% of the population, were getting fluoridated water from public systems at optimized levels. There were some more that were getting fluoride from, or fluoridated water from naturally fluoridated, but I don't know if it was like controlled or optimized.
42:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
42:56 Speaker 04 The goal, so that was 1989, 62.1%. The goal for 1990 was to get 95% of the population on optimally fluoridated water. Obviously, this was not achieved. And the new goal was revised down to 75% by 2000.
43:11 Speaker 01 Okay.
43:11 Speaker 04 We're still not quite there, but we are close, although we'll see what happens because of stuff that's been happening, yeah.
43:20 Speaker 01 Because they're trying to take it all away.
43:22 Speaker 04 They're trying to take it all away. In the nearly eight decades since water fluoridation began, the health benefits have become clear. An average drop of 35 to 50% in carries rates in fluoridated communities. This translates also to economic benefits. Less money spent on restorative dental care in communities with fluoridated water, less time missed from work, having to go to dental appointments, not to mention like, I know you'll get into some of these like bigger picture, how dental health is health and how it like, there are so many other systemic effects of that. And then there's like the self-esteem and so on, like to have dental repair, yeah.
44:04 Speaker 04 And I know that next week, you're also going to get into more of like the, some of the... Claims that people are making.
44:13 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:13 Speaker 04 But from my reading, water fluoridation at the recommended level has not been linked with data to any negative health outcome. Of course, overconsumption of fluoride can occur, which can be harmful. But at the recommended level, like what it is in our water, it is safe and effective. So why has there been such a strong and sustained opposition movement to fluoride?
44:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:39 Speaker 04 Let's get into it.
44:40 Speaker 01 I also, I don't think that I knew that it was, I mean, it's this podcast, We Kill You. I'm not surprised that there's been like opposition from the get go and like, you know, like so strong and whatever, but I, I, it's, it's the same thing as so many other things that we're hearing so much more about today. We're like, I never thought about it for so long and now I can't stop hearing about it everywhere.
45:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. And it's not just like, like people are actually talking about it more. I mean, yeah, like RFK is talking about it more.
45:14 Speaker 01 So you can't, you can't not talk about it.
45:16 Speaker 04 Automatic red flag.
45:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, literally like on the news from the, the people who are the highest up making the decisions about our health in this country.
45:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. Yeah. And I mean, and like those other things, like vaccines, like pasteurization, water fluoridation has long had its fair share of detractors and which have also, like raw milk and vaccines, have been growing in number as of late.
45:43 Speaker 04 And the Venn diagram of these three groups is like a circle, basically. It's just boop.
45:50 Speaker 04 So we can trace the origins of the anti-fluoridation movement to Wisconsin in the 1940s.
45:56 Speaker 01 Okay.
45:57 Speaker 04 The Grand Rapids Muskegon Experiment was on the horizon, but there was one outspoken Wisconsin dentist, Dr. John Frisch, who didn't want to wait 15 years for his communities to start fluoridating. He had followed the work of McKay and Dean and concluded that fluoride at an appropriate level was safe and effective and they should get started right away because he was a dentist and he cared about his patients and wanted them to not have cavities and carries, right? Like, he's like, we can, we can prevent this.
46:26 Speaker 01 Right. Which is also.
46:29 Speaker 04 Oh, I know. Are you gonna talk about like big fluoride?
46:31 Speaker 01 Right. Well, it's, it's interesting to think about in the context of like, in the context of a profession where at the time their main source of business was restorative dentistry.
46:43 Speaker 04 Right.
46:43 Speaker 01 You might think that a dentist would want less fluoride because then their patients would have more cavities and they would have more business.
46:52 Speaker 04 It's like somebody coming in to, it's like a, a family med doctor being like, ooh, my patients have diabetes and kidney disease and heart disease. This is great for me. And it's like, no, it's not.
47:04 Speaker 01 No, it's not. Exactly. And that, and that's the point, right? It's like the people who go into these fields do it because they want to help people because they care about people's health, because they want for their patients to, to be better, to have healthy teeth. Like, so, but I.
47:20 Speaker 04 But big fluoride, Erin.
47:21 Speaker 01 Big fluoride.
47:24 Speaker 01 Raking in that dough.
47:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, I honestly, it's, I mean, it's, it's baffling, but not surprising. Yeah.
47:30 Speaker 01 I know. Okay.
47:31 Speaker 04 There's no logic, but there wasn't ever any to begin with. Yeah. So this dentist was like, I'm hyped about fluoride. Let's do this. Like, let's, we don't need to wait for that. We've already, we have had decades of people collecting data that show that this is like a good thing to do.
47:46 Speaker 01 Okay.
47:46 Speaker 04 And so he started this like very active and enthusiastic campaign for water fluoridation across the state.
47:54 Speaker 01 Okay.
47:54 Speaker 04 And within a few years, many communities had started adding fluoride to their water after this because, you know, he was like gung ho. And so when in 1950, the US Public Health Service approved fluoridation for all communities in the US, Frisch declared victory in a letter that he wrote to McKay. "Cease firing. The war is over." Direct quote from that. Yeah. Which turned out to be a bit of a premature celebration. Frisch's very vocal campaign won many over to the side of fluoridation and raised awareness overall, but it also attracted some critics, especially the very outspoken Alexander Wallace,
48:34 Speaker 04 who was a resident of Stevens Point, Wisconsin and self-appointed watchdog of the public treasury, local poet and author of many letters to the editor.
48:47 Speaker 04 Notice how I didn't mention any scientific or dental training because I don't believe there was any, right?
48:51 Speaker 01 I also just can picture.
48:54 Speaker 04 A 100%. I mean, basically, I'm picturing like Parks and Rec and like someone who goes to one of the town halls. Yeah.
49:01 Speaker 01 I'm picturing my parents' neighbor who lives not too far away. I will not mention names, but has run for the board multiple times, etc.
49:09 Speaker 04 On platform of anti-floride?
49:11 Speaker 01 No, just on the platform of anti-fun, mostly.
49:15 Speaker 04 Oh, got it. Okay.
49:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, don't like the swim team and they don't like the anything. Anyways.
49:22 Speaker 04 Letters to the editor.
49:23 Speaker 01 Yeah. Letters to the editor.
49:25 Speaker 04 There we go.
49:26 Speaker 01 Well, they're important. Okay.
49:28 Speaker 04 They are. Love them sometimes. But yeah, his stance, this guy, Alexander Wallace, his stance was that fluoride was poison.
49:37 Speaker 01 Okay.
49:38 Speaker 04 He, you know, and his evidence ranged from the misused, like for instance, the US Public Health Service at the time, still classified fluoride as experimental and then it did not stay. But he said it was totally untested, right?
49:55 Speaker 01 Classic. That's a classic thing to say.
49:58 Speaker 04 It's a classic thing. Yeah.
50:00 Speaker 01 Yeah. Covid vaccines, totally untested.
50:02 Speaker 04 Uh huh. Exactly. mRNA, forget it. And then a lot of the time, he just manufactured evidence, right? Like he said fluoride is rat poison and will cause irreparable harm.
50:11 Speaker 01 Oh, he should listen to Stricknig.
50:12 Speaker 04 That's what I was gonna say. I'm like, Stricknig is rat poison. We don't put that in the water.
50:16 Speaker 01 Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
50:19 Speaker 04 And so despite not having any scientific evidence to support his claims and the fact that existing evidence refuted them, in fact, his opposition was highly publicized and ultimately successful.
50:30 Speaker 01 Okay.
50:31 Speaker 04 He set the precedent for this debate to be held in kind of a public forum with him on one side and the data on the other.
50:40 Speaker 01 So interesting, Erin.
50:41 Speaker 04 So classic Erin.
50:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:43 Speaker 04 Naturally, this equal viewpoint representation confused the general public, who were led to believe that Wallace had as much data supporting his side as the scientist did, as the dentist did.
50:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:56 Speaker 04 In September 1950, the citizens of Stevens Point rejected fluoridation, the first to do so in a monument to anti-science, anti-expert. This proved to not be a one-off, as pro-fluoridationists had hoped. The outcome was plastered across national headlines and served as encouragement to other opponents of fluoridation. The message was, who needs science and facts when you've got fear and doubt? They realized it was a heck of a lot easier to instill doubt and fear than dispel it. The anti-fluoridationists of the 1950s were a motley crew, mostly quote-unquote independent
51:35 Speaker 04 thinkers like Wallace, alternative medicine advocates, supplement brands, really supplement brands, not surprising, but also just like...
51:45 Speaker 01 Like, could you be more basic?
51:47 Speaker 04 You know, it's like predictable.
51:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
51:51 Speaker 04 Then there were chiropractors and groups like the John Birch Society, which, if you haven't heard of it, is a right-wing libertarian conspiracy theory anti-communist group that is also an inspiration to the current administration, and the Ku Klux Klan. The KKK was big in the anti-fluoride movement in the early decades.
52:14 Speaker 01 I, uh, I could see that. I could see that.
52:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
52:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:19 Speaker 04 Um, I was very like, wait, what?
52:24 Speaker 01 It's one of those where you go, wah? And then when you think about it...
52:27 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
52:28 Speaker 01 Because this is something that's working on the public health, and so it's going to be helping everyone.
52:34 Speaker 04 Everyone, yeah.
52:35 Speaker 01 Right? Including people, quote-unquote, undesirables.
52:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
52:39 Speaker 01 And in fact, maybe more so, we'll talk more about that next week, for sure.
52:43 Speaker 04 For sure, yeah. Yes.
52:45 Speaker 01 Okay.
52:45 Speaker 04 That is, I mean, and that is like a big, I think, part of the, like, the point is also cruelty.
52:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:54 Speaker 04 Yeah.
52:54 Speaker 01 We should withhold this...
52:55 Speaker 04 Withholding, yeah.
52:56 Speaker 01 From people who don't deserve it, because if you can afford it, you can just buy fluoridated toothpaste. If you can afford it, you can just go get fluoride sealants.
53:05 Speaker 04 Right.
53:06 Speaker 01 If you can afford it...
53:09 Speaker 04 Yep. Okay. And so that is, that is one big motivator for why people were and are anti-fluoride. But there were many other reasons as well. And so, you know, just like raw milk, this, these groups are not a monolith, or like this anti-fluoride movement is not a monolith. And there's a mix of people who have been preyed upon and those who are doing the praying. Looking into the perpetrators or originators of this misinformation, the reasons they give for why fluoride is bad have evolved over time. And they can generally be split into three categories, sometimes overlapping. All right, you've got number one, fraudulent health claims.
53:50 Speaker 04 Number two, feelings of personal freedom violations slash conspiracy theories. And number three, claims that fluoride doesn't work slash economics. Yeah. Yeah. So the first concrete fraudulent health claim that proved to be quite sticky was that fluoride causes cancer. And I think this is still touted today occasionally. This misconception originated from leaked preliminary results of an animal study out of the University of Texas that was specifically looking at this question. And early results seemed to suggest that mice that drank fluoridated water developed cancer earlier than those that did not. And the press ate that story up. Of course. They ran with it before any closer examination. I mean, these were preliminary, preliminary results.
54:36 Speaker 04 Yeah. It didn't matter, right? And then, once, once the researcher who was involved in this did like a closer examination, it was revealed that the experiment was totally invalid. All of the mice, both the experimental and control groups, were being fed chow that had a fluoride level of 42 parts per million.
54:59 Speaker 04 Wait, all of them? All of them. Both the experimental and the, so it was like, whatever they were drinking didn't matter. Yeah. Yeah.
55:09 Speaker 04 But it was too late. Like this, this correction was too late. This, the follow up was not nearly as widely publicized as the initial results. And even if people came across the correction, the association between cancer and fluoride would be in their minds already. Where it's like, I'm not saying that fluoride causes cancer. You know what I mean? Or they, they would be like, I read a news story about fluoride and cancer, but I can't remember what it was. Isn't that the thing that, yeah, right, totally. And you're like, I'm not sure what it was. So I'm just gonna err on the side of caution. Caution. Yeah. Yeah. Um, and then reputable studies, so like since then, since those, that experiment and that news story, reputable studies, there have been so many of them because the fear was so high. Yeah.
55:52 Speaker 04 That examined cancer and fluoride have found no association. But that didn't stop the anti-fluoridationists claiming that fluoride causes cancer. And again, we're talking about the levels that are the optimized levels in public drinking water. And cancer was far from alone in being blamed, or fluoride was far from alone. Cancer was one of the, one of many things. There we go. One of many ill health effects. Yes. That was blamed on fluoride. Oh, so many. And I know that you're gonna go into more next week, but like vaccines, fluoride has been held responsible for whatever health threat preoccupied the general public at a certain time. You know, like at one point, it was Alzheimer's. Another time it was blamed
56:33 Speaker 04 for AIDS. IQ, infertility, brittle bones, take your pick. The more fringe ones were oily sweat, undue financial anxiety, and nymphomania.
56:48 Speaker 04 Okay. Isn't that bizarre? Yeah. All of it's bizarre, Erin. I know, I know. Uh, I just saw undue financial anxieties. Yeah. I live with that on a daily. Just kidding. I was gonna say like undue. Undue? Is it undue? Is it undue? Right.
57:05 Speaker 04 And occasionally, they've entered into the more conspiracy side of things, especially with the anti-communism fears so widespread during the 1950s and 1960s. And I think that's also where the KKK got involved, where it was like, we don't, like, this is communism, essentially. This is socialized medicine, and we don't, we don't do that here.
57:22 Speaker 01 They're forcing it on us. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay.
57:25 Speaker 04 Some people genuinely believed that it was like a Soviet plot designed to harm the American public. And this belief was parodied in the 1964 movie, Doctor Strange Love. Or it was a strategy, one person claimed, and I'm sure this was not just one person's opinion, that it was a strategy to, quote unquote, weaken the Aryan race.
57:46 Speaker 04 Again, the parallels with raw milk are astonishing, but not surprising.
57:51 Speaker 01 So interesting, Erin.
57:53 Speaker 04 And so this is kind of where these health concerns bleed over into the personal freedom conspiracy side of things. So from the beginning of fluoridation, one of the leading complaints was that fluoridation, that fluoridation in water represented a violation of personal freedoms, that parents should be able to choose what to feed their children, and that fluoride was mass medication, starting us on a slippery slope where the government could put whatever they wanted into the water without our knowledge or consent. Or just that it represented a deadly step towards socialized medicine, where people could, you know, where health is a right, right? Or healthcare is a right.
58:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:30 Speaker 04 And this seems
58:31 Speaker 01 How dare we?
58:32 Speaker 04 Dare we even imagine that possibility? This seems to be a consistent sentiment motivating people at the ballot box 70 years ago, as well as today. Like, these are all things that are still around. The mass medication complaint arose and gained traction at a time where things like DDT or asbestos were found to be highly toxic after decades of use and like, being freely used and everyone being, you know, reassuring that, no, it's fine, it's fine, it's fine.
58:59 Speaker 01 Right.
58:59 Speaker 04 Where thalidomide slipped through the cracks and where a, quote unquote, back-to-the-soil, natural movement was taking hold. And so, to some, fluoride represented yet another chemical we're adding to our bodies without enough research. And I think What I find truly fascinating about that is that fluoride is in so many sources of water naturally.
59:24 Speaker 01 Right.
59:25 Speaker 04 It's in water.
59:26 Speaker 01 It's interesting to look at it in that way, like, oh, this is something that we're adding.
59:30 Speaker 04 Right.
59:31 Speaker 01 This is something that is naturally, quote unquote, naturally found in so many sources. Sometimes at such a high level that it is causing potential ill effects.
59:44 Speaker 01 But then putting it into our water at lower levels is seen as potentially harmful when it's really just trying to replicate something that exists in nature.
59:53 Speaker 04 Yes. Yeah.
59:55 Speaker 01 And it, and it's, and it is valid that we have done things.
59:58 Speaker 04 100%.
59:59 Speaker 01 Without a lot of data, right?
1:00:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:00:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's, we have done things that are quite harmful. So it makes sense to, I don't know, it's so complicated, Erin.
1:00:09 Speaker 04 Well, and I think the other facet of that too, is that, you know, going back to naturally fluoridated sources of water is that, that have been shown, that have been linked to, you know, whether it's teeth modeling or something else. Anti-fluoridationists don't make any effort to reduce the fluoride that occurs naturally. If they think that fluoride is such a big problem.
1:00:28 Speaker 01 Really?
1:00:29 Speaker 04 Then they don't really seem.
1:00:30 Speaker 01 I shouldn't be surprised.
1:00:31 Speaker 04 Concerned with helping to remove or limit fluoride in communities with naturally overfluoridated water. Yeah, they're just like, it's only, don't put fluoride in my water.
1:00:40 Speaker 01 Don't put it in my water. But if you move to Colorado Springs, you're on your own.
1:00:44 Speaker 04 Well, I think, I think, I think they, they take it out of work.
1:00:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm sure they do. Not to hate on Colorado Springs. I'm sure they're doing fine. Yeah, no, that is, it is interesting. And I think that that just kind of points out, it's like, who, I think what it, what it shows is like, who is it that is the one perpetuating these claims? And what is the intent behind what they are doing it for?
1:01:08 Speaker 04 Right.
1:01:09 Speaker 01 Are they using any data that may or may not be legitimate? Maybe, but what is the intention behind that? And is it just to discredit science? Because that's what it often comes down to.
1:01:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, and it also, like, again, I think it, it comes back to those who are hearing this information and buying into it. And those who are originating it and perpetuating it. So there are different motivators, I think, for that.
1:01:35 Speaker 04 And so the final argument against fluoride was that it doesn't work, or that the benefits of fluoride can be achieved solely through fluoride-containing products, such as toothpaste and mouthwashes, topical fluoride.
1:01:47 Speaker 01 Right.
1:01:48 Speaker 04 Following that, the argument goes that water fluoridation is wasteful, since only a small proportion is actually ingested, as opposed to being used to like wash dishes or shower.
1:01:58 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:01:58 Speaker 04 And I know you'll get more into the details of systemic versus topical fluoride, but systemic fluoridation does make a difference, as we discussed, in the prevention of tooth decay. And in fact, Calgary in Canada had previously voted to stop fluoridation around 10 years ago, and then recently voted to put it back in, since the rate of tooth decay in children increased.
1:02:20 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:02:20 Speaker 04 It seems like, from where I'm standing, that the trend has been more often than not in the other direction, with states like Utah banning fluoride in the water, which means that even if a community wanted to fluoridate, they couldn't. And so now, if you want systemic fluoride in Utah, you have to get a prescription. And so, of course, yes, you have to get a prescription.
1:02:43 Speaker 01 From whom?
1:02:44 Speaker 04 Uh, you can go to the dentist. I think you can get one from a pharmacist.
1:02:48 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:02:49 Speaker 04 Your doctor. And so, of course, just like with every other personal freedom medical issue, this disproportionately impacts those who are the most disadvantaged, who lack access to a dentist or can't afford supplements. But that rarely concerns anti-fluoride activists, who are more than happy to sell you their purification systems or their book outlining how to eliminate fluoride from your diet. When it comes to fluoride, it's more of the same with what we see for raw milk and vaccines. A focus on deregulation, on privatization, and redefining expertise. And this debate over fluoride has continued because it has been framed as a debate.
1:03:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:03:29 Speaker 04 With science and evidence on one side and sentiment on the other. And, again, like, we get it, right? We, the historical opposition especially, I'm not sure just how many health outcomes were evaluated in naturally fluoridated versus unfluoridated communities before they started artificially fluoridating.
1:03:48 Speaker 01 Right. Did they look at every possible outcome?
1:03:51 Speaker 04 Right.
1:03:52 Speaker 01 Or not?
1:03:52 Speaker 04 Probably not, yeah. But at that time, no, it has been 80 years, 80 years since water was, since fluoridated water was started in Grand Rapids, Michigan. And that means that over those 80 years, we have collected a wealth of data that would allow us to detect an association between fluoride and so many things. And we haven't really found those associations and people are still looking, people are still continuously evaluating because that is what science does, that is how it works. But when you've got TikToks and forums claiming that fluoride is harmful for your kid or it's giving you cancer, it's hard to shake those fears, that doubt, especially when the pro-fluoride movement is much quieter.
1:04:36 Speaker 04 I mean, like, I knew so little about how fluoride worked before we picked this as a topic. I didn't know that it was like in a development. I just thought it was like, oh, mouthwash, that's fine, right? And I can't help but think that the lack of awareness and understanding is contributing to the gains that the anti-fluoridationists have made in the past few years. Despite being named as one of the top public health achievements of the 20th century, the top 10, it's in the top 10.
1:05:04 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:05:05 Speaker 04 Fluoride does not have enough hype people talking about how many teeth have been saved, how much less people have had to spend, all thanks to a relatively straightforward and inexpensive solution.
1:05:17 Speaker 01 Hmm.
1:05:18 Speaker 04 Fluoride, man.
1:05:19 Speaker 01 Fluoride.
1:05:20 Speaker 04 Tell you what.
1:05:22 Speaker 01 Tell you what?
1:05:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:05:24 Speaker 01 You're right, Erin, I don't really hear any fluoride hype people.
1:05:28 Speaker 04 I know.
1:05:29 Speaker 01 I can't remember a fluoride hype person.
1:05:30 Speaker 04 Me either. And I think that it's because like on an individual level, um, you know, you go to the dentist and you, you get fluoride, like where is the political activism from pro-fluoridation? It's just a really interesting thing and I think that fluoride doesn't really get the attention it deserves in the public health arena as like a way to prevent, okay, it's like, okay, dental carries. Because actually, the, the significance of that is much bigger than we think it is.
1:05:57 Speaker 01 Well, it's also like.
1:06:00 Speaker 01 Like we've said many times on this podcast, Erin, when public health is working well, you don't know that it's working at all.
1:06:06 Speaker 04 You don't know that it's working.
1:06:07 Speaker 01 Right? When we're preventing caries with, you didn't even know that your water was fluoridated and you have less caries than a community that doesn't have fluoridated water, you don't think about it, right? And then if you start hearing that something is bad, that's when you then start questioning.
1:06:25 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:06:26 Speaker 01 What are you doing to me without my knowledge, without my consent? Who made this decision? What data are you using?
1:06:33 Speaker 04 We've been doing this for 80 years and it's, but it really seems like gains are being made for the anti-floridationists.
1:06:40 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
1:06:41 Speaker 04 Ah, yeah.
1:06:43 Speaker 01 And there's a lot more to say, Erin, about what we know about the effects of fluoride, positive, negative, neutral. How is it working? What's up with caries?
1:06:58 Speaker 04 What's up with caries?
1:06:59 Speaker 01 Yeah. And we're going to get into all of that next week and I cannot wait.
1:07:05 Speaker 04 Oh, my gosh. Me, I am really excited. I, I feel like this was just a teaser to be like, now we have fluoride.
1:07:12 Speaker 01 But it's so good to set the stage of like, this is how, you know what I mean? Especially as we talk about like, what is the evidence? Now we can also look at like, this is how long things have been going on for.
1:07:22 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:07:23 Speaker 01 So.
1:07:24 Speaker 04 Well, in the meantime, if you would like to read more.
1:07:28 Speaker 01 I do.
1:07:28 Speaker 04 I've got some sources.
1:07:30 Speaker 01 Excellent.
1:07:31 Speaker 04 Um, okay, so there was a book called Fluoride and Caries Prevention by John Murray, published in 1982, maybe? A paper by Ripa from 1993, A Half Century of Community Water Fluoridation in the United States. A great paper by McNeil, 1985, America's Longest War, The Fight Over Fluoridation.
1:07:53 Speaker 04 And if you want to learn more about just like carries in generally and over a time, Caselets 1998, Carries: Ancient Plague of Humankind.
1:08:02 Speaker 01 Ancient plague.
1:08:03 Speaker 04 And I've got so many more, honestly, but those are the ones that I'm going to shout out. So yeah, take a look at our website if you want to see all the sources for this episode and all of our episodes.
1:08:14 Speaker 01 ThisPodcastMoculie.com.
1:08:15 Speaker 04 Yeah. Thank you to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes.
1:08:21 Speaker 01 Thank you to Tom and Leanna and Brent and Pete and Mike and all of Exactly Right, Jess. Thank you all. We have so many people that help out with this and we really appreciate it.
1:08:33 Speaker 04 Yeah, we do. Thank you also to our listeners. We hope that you enjoyed this episode. Did it answer some of your questions?
1:08:41 Speaker 01 Any of your questions? Do you have more questions?
1:08:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:08:43 Speaker 01 We'll answer them next week, maybe?
1:08:47 Speaker 01 And as always, a special shout out to our patrons. Thank you so much for your support. It really does mean the world to us.
1:08:54 Speaker 04 It does. Well, until next time, wash your hands.
1:08:59 Speaker 01 You filthy animals.
1:09:27 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding Or everyday wear and tear. O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
1:10:12 Speaker 01 Visit O'Keefe'sCompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands, yeah, it works.
1:10:26 Speaker 02 Wait, I came in for two things. How is this $47?
1:10:31 Speaker 06 All right, we're gonna need a plan here.
1:10:33 Speaker 03 Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft ATM fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25.
1:10:42 Speaker 02 Oh, that's actually really simple.
1:10:45 Speaker 03 Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at BofA.com/simplebanking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
Previous Special Episode: Dr. Wendy Kline & Exposed Next Ep 179 Fluoride 2: Fighting tooth and nail Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated