Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 164 Rift Valley Fever: Ruminating on ruminants About this episode Hemorrhagic virus? Check. Deadly disease? Check. Mosquito-borne? Check. Affected by animal movement, human activity, and environmental change? Check. Rift Valley Fever has all the markings of a classic TPWKY episode. This week, we’re doing a deep dive on this deadly virus, taking a One Health approach to explore the intricate relationships between animals, humans, and the environment to understand how this virus moves across the landscape. We trace the various paths this virus takes: through the organisms it infects, across the globe as it spreads, and over time as it appears to be evolving to be deadlier. Tune in to learn more about Rift Valley fever and what we might see with this pathogen in the years to come.
Transcript 12,884 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:06 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
0:51 Speaker 01 Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company dot com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
1:03 Speaker 02 This is Jason Timp from Hoops Tonight with Jason Timp. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which can mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
1:36 Speaker 03 Your team is on a deadline, but moving all your enterprise data will take time your business simply doesn't have. IBM technology lets AI work with your data where it already lives with an open hybrid cloud approach designed to build on your existing investments. It's another way IBM helps you put your data to work. Let's create smarter business. IBM. Visit ibm.com to learn more.
2:05 Speaker 01 A pathologist, R.S., aged 30 years, had been working with Rift Valley Fever virus for several weeks before the onset of his illness. On the evening of December 22, 1932, he felt chilly while walking home and complained that his eyes and the calves of his legs ached. During the night, his rest was disturbed by general malaise and pains, especially around the knees and hips. On awakening, the second day of illness, his temperature was 101 Fahrenheit. He attempted to continue his work, but had several chills during the day and felt so miserable that he took to bed. He complained at this time of a vague soreness over his abdomen, constant dull headache, and pain behind the eyes associated with slight photophobia.
2:49 Speaker 01 There was no sore throat, rhinitis, nausea, or vomiting. He was admitted to the hospital of the Rockefeller Institute 24 hours after the onset of symptoms. On admission, the temperature was 102.6 Fahrenheit, pulse 140, respirations 24. The patient was definitely prostrated by his illness, but rational and cooperative. The throat culture was negative for hemolytic streptococci and influenza bacilli, and blood cultures in infusion broth remained sterile. A tentative diagnosis of Rift Valley Fever or influenza was made. In an attempt to confirm the tentative diagnosis of Rift Valley Fever, 6 cc's of the patient's blood was injected into 6 mice.
3:33 Speaker 01 All of the mice died within 48 hours. Almost immediately after admission, the patient began to improve. The temperature, which reached a peak of 103.8 Fahrenheit on the night of admission, fell promptly to normal within 24 hours. The symptoms, however, abated somewhat less rapidly. By the 12th day of illness, the patient had improved to such an extent that he was allowed to sit in a chair for a short time, and on the following day was permitted to walk a short distance. On the evening of the 16th day, however, he complained of pain in the left leg. The patient was returned to bed and the leg was immobilized in an elevated position. Four days later, 20th day of illness, the patient awakened with pain in the right chest,
4:15 Speaker 01 which was more pronounced during deep inspiration or exhalation. In the x-ray photograph made at this time, there was a distinct shadow at the base of the right lung. On several occasions, blood was expectorated in small amounts. On the 38th day of illness, recovery seemed to be proceeding uneventfully. On the morning of the 45th day of illness, however, the patient suddenly collapsed and died within a few minutes. Death was apparently due to a large embolus in the pulmonary vessels.
5:31 Speaker 01 Oof, that's a tough, tough story, Erin.
5:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, and what a roller coaster, too.
5:37 Speaker 01 Really is. Like, you have no idea where it's going to go until you're there.
5:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, I don't know anything about the pathophysiology of Rift Valley Fever, so I'm very curious to know how well this fits in with the clinical picture that has been seen.
5:53 Speaker 01 You know, not super well, but...
5:56 Speaker 00 Interesting.
5:58 Speaker 01 But I can, I can see how these things ended up happening. So we can, when we talk about the pathology, we can kind of tie back into it.
6:07 Speaker 00 Okay, so that firsthand account was from a paper by Schwenker and Rivers from 1934 titled "Rift Valley Fever in Man: Report of a Fatal Laboratory Infection Complicated by Thrombophlebitis." And this actually is the first recorded death due to Rift Valley Fever.
6:29 Speaker 01 Oh, interesting.
6:30 Speaker 00 I mean, likely not the first death in humans, but the first recorded human death.
6:35 Speaker 01 Detailed, recorded, huh.
6:37 Speaker 00 Yeah. Hi, I'm Erin Welsh.
6:40 Speaker 01 And I'm Erin Allman Updike.
6:41 Speaker 00 And this is This Podcast Will Kill You.
6:44 Speaker 01 And today, we're talking about Rift Valley Fever. We've had a lot of requests for this one, which I feel like is surprising because I knew almost nothing about it, except I had heard there is Rift Valley Fever. Like, I knew that it existed. I knew it was mosquito borne. That's all I knew.
6:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, I, same. I was like, oh, this is a dangerous virus. But I didn't really know much more than that. And I was kind of shocked when I got into the history of outbreaks.
7:13 Speaker 01 I am shocked at how little I knew, considering like that we were deep in disease ecology for so long.
7:22 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. I mean, I still, I would like flip through parasite books for fun.
7:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
7:27 Speaker 00 But somehow, just goes to show that there is no limit to the number of diseases and viruses and pathogens and parasites and fungi out there.
7:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's true. So Rift Valley Fever is the one we're talking about today. But before we can tell you all about it and all the things that we learned, it's quarantine time.
7:48 Speaker 00 It is. Erin, what are we drinking this week?
7:51 Speaker 01 We're drinking wolf in sheep's clothing. It'll make sense.
7:56 Speaker 00 It'll make sense. Sheep are involved. The wolf is the virus. Love to over explain a joke. It's how I do it.
8:04 Speaker 01 We went back and forth by text on is the wolf, the wolf is the virus? The virus is the wolf? Yes, okay. It's a great name.
8:12 Speaker 01 What's in a wolf in sheep's clothing?
8:14 Speaker 00 A wolf in sheep's clothing is your basic concoction of mezcal, grapefruit juice, a lemon lime soda of your choice, and you know, maybe a squirt of lime or something.
8:28 Speaker 01 And some jalapenos, right? A little spicy mezcal paloma.
8:32 Speaker 00 Yes.
8:32 Speaker 01 Situation.
8:33 Speaker 00 Crucial, the crucial muddled jalapenos.
8:36 Speaker 01 And we'll post the full recipe for that quarantini, as well as the non-alcoholic, equally delicious pussy burrito on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com, and all of our socials. So if you're not already following us, you should, because the pics are delicious.
8:50 Speaker 00 On our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com, you can find all manner of things. You know, there's transcripts for all of our episodes. You can find links to our bookshop.org affiliate account, our Goodreads list, music by Blood Mobile, cool merch. We've got great merch.
9:07 Speaker 01 We do.
9:07 Speaker 00 Links to Patreon, links to a submit your first hand account form, links to a contact us form. There's more there, too.
9:15 Speaker 01 There's so much. Thispodcastwillkillyou.com, check it out.
9:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:19 Speaker 01 If you haven't already, please check your podcatcher, make sure you're subscribed. If you haven't left us a review or a rating and you'd like to, now's your opportunity. You can do that right now. And we would so appreciate it. We would really love it. It really helps the show. So thank you.
9:34 Speaker 00 She's not lying. She's, she's totally right. We, we appreciate it and it helps us.
9:41 Speaker 01 Well, then, shall we get into this virus?
9:46 Speaker 00 Let's do it. Let's take a quick break and begin. The holidays are coming up, and the best gifts are usually the ones that become part of someone's everyday life. Their new favorite sweater, a bag they carry everywhere, gold jewelry they keep reaching for. For gifts that last, there's Quince. Quince specializes in effortless, high-quality essentials like ultra-soft organic cotton and premium Mongolian cashmere sweaters. They're beautifully tailored, built to last, and transition seamlessly from morning meetings to dinner. Quince also has gifts that keep giving all season long, like their high-quality down outerwear and cozy cashmere gloves and scarves. And Quince has a lot more than clothing. Think leather bags, hotel-quality bedding, chef-grade cookware, and five-star luggage.
10:31 Speaker 00 So there is something special for everyone on your list. I am so excited about my latest Quince purchase, 100%. Australian Schilling earmuffs, which are so soft and fluffy and keep my ears super warm on those extra cold days. Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns, now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was this podcast will kill you. It's the best way to support the show.
11:05 Speaker 01 Dry hands can be uncomfortable and frustrating, especially when frequent hand washing, changing weather and everyday wear and tear take their toll. O'Keefe's Working Hands is here to help keep dry hands feeling hydrated and comfortable. O'Keefe's Working Hands creates a soothing barrier on the skin that locks in moisture and prevents further dryness. It's concentrated and non greasy and you start to feel relief in one use. Go to okeefescompany.com to get yours today. That's O K E E F F E S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
12:00 Speaker 01 I think part of what surprised me about how little I knew about Rift Valley Fever is how much of a classic TPWKY story it really is.
12:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:11 Speaker 01 I know that we are getting back to the roots of this podcast when I can go on the World Health Organization's website and find so much of the information that I'm looking for. And even more so when there's a page on the World Organization for Animal Health website. So buckle up. This is a really classic piece of TPWKY content. So Rift Valley Fever is a disease that's caused by a virus called Rift Valley Fever virus. It's not very creative. And this is an RNA virus in the genus Flebo virus. I think that's how you say it. And I think that the phylogeny of this group of viruses has changed relatively recently.
12:54 Speaker 01 But in any case, it's in the order Bunya viralis, which is the same group that includes hantavirus and loss of fever virus and some others that we haven't yet covered.
13:05 Speaker 00 Have we done loss of fever, Erin?
13:07 Speaker 01 No, we haven't done loss of fever, but maybe people have heard of loss of fever.
13:11 Speaker 00 I know, we haven't done it.
13:12 Speaker 01 Wow, okay. There's, Erin, there's so many that we haven't done yet.
13:16 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:17 Speaker 01 But hantavirus is, we have. And with the exception really of the hantavirus and loss of fever and other arena viruses, most all of the other viruses in this order Bunya viralis are transmitted primarily by arthropod vectors like ticks and mosquitoes and Rift Valley fever virus is no exception. Asterisk, but let's talk about it. So Rift Valley fever in humans is really considered a zoonotic disease, which means that primarily it's not affecting humans, it's infecting animals. And it's generally considered to be only these spillover events that end up causing disease in humans. So there has to generally be some kind of animal outbreak, which we call an epizootic,
14:02 Speaker 01 before there is then a human outbreak. And this virus infects a pretty wide variety of animals. And the ones that end up being most important for us as humans are our livestock. So this virus infects cattle, sheep, goats and other small ruminants and camels. And sheep and goats tend to be the most severely affected. And it's transmitted to these livestock primarily by mosquitoes. But not just any one mosquito. No, no, no. Whole bunches of mosquitoes in multiple different genera. Mostly transmitted by 80s mosquitoes of dengue fever, yellow fever, chikungunya, like
14:47 Speaker 01 all the viruses, 80s mosquitoes, as well as Culex mosquitoes of like West Nile virus and Japanese encephalitis virus fame.
14:56 Speaker 00 It's so strange because usually viruses are so hyper-adapted to their mosquito vector hosts, like that specific species.
15:08 Speaker 00 But this isn't. So what, what's how?
15:10 Speaker 01 I have so many questions, Erin, about the pathophysiology or the like, the life cycle of this virus in mosquitoes because it, it doesn't, we don't have as much information as I expect. Okay. And it's really interesting. So there's at least like 50 different species of mosquito that have been found to harbor this virus. And the transmission is like, usually when we picture like a transmission cycle among, let's say, you know, vector, host, maybe there's a secondary host, it's like a circle, right? The transmission of
15:53 Speaker 01 this virus, when you look at this site, it's not a circle. It's like a circle with a line and another line and like two other branches. It's, it's a mess.
16:02 Speaker 00 Creative geometry.
16:04 Speaker 01 Yeah. So how does it go? Really? Usually when we're covering a vector borne disease on this podcast, I can start like this, and I'll start like this for this episode. Ready? A female mosquito, it's always a female mosquito, takes a blood meal from a host. Let's call it a sheep for accuracy. It drinks up some of the virus in that blood meal because the sheep is infected. And after some amount of time in the mosquito and varying amounts of this virus moving through the mosquito, it maybe makes it to the salivary glands or something like that. And then that mosquito takes another blood meal, spits the virus
16:46 Speaker 01 into the host, and boom, now you've completed the transmission cycle. And that cycle can happen in Rift Valley fever. But how long does it have to exist in the mosquito? How long does this virus have to be there? I don't know. What does it do inside this mosquito? I don't know. Where does it go? Does it travel to the salivary glands? Or does it not? I don't know. I don't know, Erin.
17:14 Speaker 00 Okay. And I anticipate that the answer to this question is, I don't know. But are different mosquito species differently capable of harboring, transmitting the virus?
17:27 Speaker 01 Almost certainly, yes. Which ones more likely than less? I don't know.
17:34 Speaker 01 Here's where we can add another layer of complication. In addition to that transmission cycle, this virus can also be and is known to be transmitted from female mosquitoes into their eggs. This is called vertical transmission. And we know this happens at least in some species of 80s mosquitoes, but maybe not in all species. We're not sure.
17:57 Speaker 00 Which has huge implications for the distribution of this virus in the landscape and the potential for outbreaks to happen in subsequent years, even outside of like big outbreaks, like the intra epidemic years or whatever.
18:09 Speaker 01 It sure does, Erin. You're 100% right because it means that mosquito babies are essentially born infected. So they can inject virus into their host with the very first blood meal that they take. So not only can this virus potentially persist like among different seasons without necessarily needing to have reservoir hosts that are infected, you also can then have viral transmission, even if mosquitoes aren't living long enough to transmit from animal to animal to animal. Because the very first blood meal that they take, they can potentially transmit this virus.
18:43 Speaker 00 Okay, so here's another question, though. It's not just the mosquito.
18:47 Speaker 01 It's not just the mosquitoes.
18:50 Speaker 00 It's not a question, but you know where I'm going with that.
18:53 Speaker 01 There's, let's keep going, shall we? I said that this was a web. So we shall continue along this transmission web. Once an animal host is infected, and again, mostly in this case, we're talking about livestock, ruminants, sheep, cattle, goats, camels. All of these animals also have vertical transmission themselves. So if a pregnant animal gets infected from a mosquito, it will almost inevitably pass that virus through the placenta to their offspring. And this almost always causes spontaneous abortion or pregnancy loss. This virus can also be transmitted from mosquitoes to other wildlife. And we don't fully understand the whole wildlife cycle. That's just like a black box.
19:37 Speaker 01 We know that it happens, but we don't know what hosts are important. Are they amplifying hosts or are they not, etc.?
19:44 Speaker 00 Are they maintenance hosts? Yeah.
19:46 Speaker 01 But then we get to humans. How do we get infected in this tangled web? Well, it could be the same way that our animal friends are getting infected via these mosquitoes. But what's far more common is that humans are infected from our infected animal friends themselves. Either from direct contact with something like their blood, their raw milk, or other bodily fluids, directly getting into our eyes, mouth, or other mucous membranes, or through breaks in our skin in the process of caring for or slaughtering these animals, or from inhaling aerosolized bodily fluids.
20:26 Speaker 01 So it's usually a kind of more direct transmission from animal to humans that ends up causing disease in humans. And then we as humans can also pass this virus through the placenta and potentially cause infection in a fetus. The only good thing thus far is that horizontal, meaning human-to-human transmission, has yet to be documented. And the same is true for direct transmission from animals to animals, like among a herd. So then why is it that humans can get infected from animals? We don't know. Is it just because of the ways that we happen to be interacting with and handling their tissues and bodily fluids? I don't know.
21:08 Speaker 01 But that is the like, good news that I can say about the transmission of this virus.
21:13 Speaker 00 Okay. I mean, that makes sense because it's not like the animals are doing the slaughtering and inhaling the blood. It's, it's, yeah, humans are doing that. Okay. How many viral particles?
21:25 Speaker 01 Ooh, no idea. Great question, though.
21:27 Speaker 00 Okay, okay. And it's, it is through the aerosolization. Like, is it also contaminated surfaces? Is there, what's the durability of this virus in the environment?
21:37 Speaker 01 There's so many other questions I could have tried to go down rabbit holes to answer that I don't have the answers for, Erin. Yes, so there's differential virulence, and that's likely due to like, like you asked, how many viral particles does it take? And things like that. People get more or less sick depending on what route they were more likely exposed to. And aerosol transmission seems to be the most virulent. So most likely to cause really severe disease is when it's you're inhaling it and it's going into your mucous membranes that way. The other common way that people get infected, and this could be from contaminated surfaces, but it's through contact with like broken skin. So like you have an injury and blood or something like that gets into your bloodstream from that.
22:22 Speaker 01 So those are kind of the two most common ways. There have been some cases of things like raw milk, which means that that could be potentially an oral or a GI exposure, but we have just less data on that overall.
22:33 Speaker 00 Interesting.
22:34 Speaker 01 Okay.
22:35 Speaker 00 Yes. The holidays are coming up and the best gifts are usually the ones that become part of someone's everyday life. Their new favorite sweater, a bag they carry everywhere, gold jewelry they keep reaching for. For gifts that last, there's Quince. Quince specializes in effortless, high-quality essentials like ultra-soft organic cotton and premium Mongolian cashmere sweaters. They're beautifully tailored, built to last, and transition seamlessly from morning meetings to dinner. Quince also has gifts that keep giving all season long, like their high-quality down outerwear and cozy cashmere gloves and scarves. And Quince has a lot more than clothing. Think leather bags, hotel-quality bedding, chef-grade cookware, and five-star luggage. So there is something special for everyone on your list.
23:20 Speaker 00 I am so excited about my latest Quince purchase, 100% Australian shearling earmuffs, which are so soft and fluffy and keep my ears super warm on those extra cold days. Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was this podcast will kill you. It's the best way to support the show.
23:51 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day, but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue. So you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling comfortable all season long.
24:36 Speaker 01 Visit O'Keefe'sCompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S Company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
24:48 Speaker 04 Hi, this is Mauro Lopez from All Mauro Lopez Daily Podcast. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel drive Camry Corolla Cross or a Corolla sedan with the latest features in tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at traded. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. ShopToyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
25:38 Speaker 00 This is maybe jumping ahead a little bit, but in an outbreak where it's not just livestock impacted, but also humans, is there any known breakdown between how people have gotten exposed? Like what proportion is mosquito versus direct contact? That kind of thing.
25:55 Speaker 01 Of all the outbreaks that we have good data on, primarily are happening from direct contact with animal fluids.
26:04 Speaker 01 It is very likely that mosquito borne transmission absolutely plays a role in some outbreaks, but it seems that overall, across the board, it is animal to human transmission that causes the vast majority of human cases.
26:17 Speaker 00 Okay.
26:18 Speaker 01 Which means that the people at highest risk are people who work in industries where they are coming into contact with animals.
26:24 Speaker 00 Okay.
26:25 Speaker 01 But, as I'm sure you know, and we'll probably talk about, some of the historic outbreaks have been very large, which means that certainly there's other things that are going on. And why in those cases did the outbreaks get so big? There presumably must have been also mosquito borne transmission happening. So yes, it definitely can happen. But does it also just depend on like, are mosquitoes more likely to bite humans or to bite animals? And what mosquito species are circulating in those regions? Because again, this is so many different mosquito species. So yeah, there's a lot, there's a lot of layers. And we don't have great data on a lot of details on a lot of these outbreaks.
27:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
27:08 Speaker 01 I wish that we had more data. I wish that we had more data.
27:10 Speaker 00 I mean, don't we all?
27:12 Speaker 01 Don't we? Yes. We do know some more about like, what does this disease do? Like, what, what does it look like if, if an animal or if a person gets rifali fever? Unsurprisingly, given that this is a virus that infects so many different species, it presents very differently across different animals, but even within humans, it can present very differently. Across the board, though, we know that there's two main cell types in mammalian bodies that this virus is predominantly infecting. And everyone who listens to this show is well aware at this point that a virus has to infect a host cell in order to use our machinery
27:53 Speaker 01 to replicate. So which cells it's infecting tend to be really important in what kind of symptoms and what kind of disease we see. So in the case of rifali fever, the two main cell types that this virus is infecting are liver cells. So we'll talk about what that ends up doing. And then monocytes, which are a type of white blood cell. And so especially in severe cases, the liver is one of the main sites of damage. So what does that end up actually looking like? If we look at animals, again, the symptoms will vary depending on the type of animal that's infected, as well as how old that animal is, because universally, young animals,
28:38 Speaker 01 so fetuses as well as newborn animals are much more severely affected than older animals. But in general, in almost all animals that are infected, all of these livestock animals, we see things like fever, we'll see the animal stop eating, they stop like moving about, they don't really like walk around or get up and go around. They become really like listless and lethargic. Especially in sheep, you might start to see like evidence of GI inflammation, abdominal pain, bloody diarrhea, and these animals are like visibly in pain and uncomfortable. But the way that this virus ends up wiping out entire populations of livestock
29:22 Speaker 01 is because it passes through the placenta and then causes spontaneous abortions in pregnant animals, and then has massive mortality rates in newborn and young animals. So in these livestock herds, especially in lambs and kids, which are baby goats, the mortality rate can be as high as 70 to 100%. It's devastating. It's devastating. And even in adult sheep and things like baby cows or calves and adult cattle, the mortality rates can be as high as 20 to 70%. So this is a very lethal infection for livestock animals.
30:01 Speaker 01 When it comes to humans, there is a really wide range of how this disease can present. Most papers across the board estimate that about 50% of people who are infected are essentially asymptomatic, like don't really show any symptoms whatsoever. And most people who do have symptoms will have a relatively mild disease, and only a small percentage, and most papers say maybe 1 to 2%, develop severe symptoms, and we'll talk about what those severe symptoms look like.
30:39 Speaker 01 But I want to caveat early on those numbers because A, it seems like maybe that 1 to 2% is an underestimate for recent outbreaks or more modern outbreaks.
30:53 Speaker 01 And some papers cite this number, instead of saying 1 to 2% of all cases, they'll say it's like 8 to 10% of symptomatic cases. Okay. And I feel like looking at it that way really changes your perspective on this disease. Because as we'll go through some of these symptoms, this can be incredibly terrifying and really severe. And so I think trying to understand like how big are these outbreaks that we're talking about and how many people are affected are really, really important. So let's talk about what it ends up looking like. If somebody is going to show symptoms of Rift Valley fever, symptoms usually start between two to six days after exposure. And it usually starts, as the name suggests, with a fever. Mm hmm.
31:36 Speaker 01 Along with a headache, you'll have muscle or joint pains. Very often, we see some like neurologic symptoms like vertigo or like in the first hand account, that photophobia, like it hurts to look at light. Yeah. You might have nausea or vomiting. And then if it remains a mild case, then this might last anywhere from like a few days, like four days to a week or so. And then often that person will get better. Sometimes, it's not uncommon that people will have like a biphasic illness, which means they'll get better and then a couple of days later, their fever will spike again and they'll get sick for another few days before they improve for good. But there are several ways, three different ways really,
32:21 Speaker 01 that this can cause a much more severe illness. Here's the three ways. It can infect your eye. It can infect your brain and spinal cord.
32:31 Speaker 00 Uh huh.
32:31 Speaker 01 Or it can destroy your liver and then you have a hemorrhagic illness. So let's go through those.
32:37 Speaker 00 And these are not mutually exclusive.
32:40 Speaker 01 They're not mutually exclusive, but they're very different. And so I don't know how often they happen all together.
32:47 Speaker 00 Okay.
32:48 Speaker 01 So in some people, this virus seems to infect the eye, the back of the eye. And it can infect like a whole variety of parts of that. It could be the retina itself. It could be your nerve in your eye. It could be the macula, a whole bunch of different parts. And in those cases, that person might have had the same mild illness that I already described, get better. And then a week or several weeks later, they'll start to have blurry vision or decreased vision. And then this can last a few months or it can end up causing permanent damage, depending on which part of the eye ends up being infected with this virus.
33:30 Speaker 00 Why the eye?
33:31 Speaker 01 Why the eye? I don't know.
33:33 Speaker 00 Okay.
33:33 Speaker 01 Is it just an easy target? There's good blood supply there. Is it just that that's where the virus was close to? I have no idea. Also, why is it so long after the initial infection? I don't know. The like specific pathophysiology of what's going on.
33:51 Speaker 01 But that's not the only way that you can see this delayed response. Another way that it could go is that, again, a few weeks or even months after an initial infection, somebody might come down with a severe headache and signs of brain inflammation. That might look like confusion, disorientation, vertigo, even things like hallucinations or loss of memory. And this can progress to seizures, coma, and potentially death. And this is all a meningoencephalitis. So inflammation that's happening in the brain and the spinal cord as a result of Rift Valley fever.
34:30 Speaker 00 Okay. And so this is like a consequence. This isn't the virus attacking those things necessarily. It's like a consequence of our immune responses reaction to the virus.
34:42 Speaker 01 I don't know, Erin.
34:44 Speaker 00 Okay.
34:45 Speaker 01 Because we know a lot, and I'll link to a bunch of specific papers that look at like the like gross anatomic pathology that's happening in these cases. We know that it's a lot of inflammation. Is it that virus is laying latent and then reactivating and causing this? Or is it that you're having delayed immune reaction to the virus? I am not 100% sure from all of my reading. And it could be that I'm not interpreting the reading correctly. Given the delay, it seems more likely that it's an inflammatory reaction, like an immune response. But it's a little bit unclear to me from all of the reading that I did.
35:24 Speaker 00 Well, and I will say too, in that firsthand account, they talked about how as this person, you know, seemed to get better and then got worse and worse and then got better again and then worse. Later on, they retested, they retook blood and reinjected it into mice to see, is this still Rift Valley fever? And the mice were fine.
35:42 Speaker 01 Okay, interesting. So then it suggests that it's more immune mediated.
35:47 Speaker 00 I mean, the paper's from 1934, like, who knows? But still, but still.
35:51 Speaker 01 And just timing wise, that's sort of what it, what it seems like, right?
35:54 Speaker 00 Right.
35:56 Speaker 01 This kind of neurologic disease, when it happens, can cause like long-term neurologic complications. And some sources suggest that it doesn't tend to cause death, but there was an outbreak in Saudi Arabia in the early 2000s, which like 50% of people that ended up having neurologic complications died from that. So I don't think it's entirely accurate to say that you would never have death as a result of this type of neurologic manifestation of Rift Valley fever.
36:25 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:26 Speaker 01 But it's less common than the final manifestation, which is the most severe. And that is when this virus causes a hemorrhagic disease. And it does this because of damage to the liver. So the way that this might present is that during that acute illness, so during that time when someone is sick with a fever, et cetera, someone might then start to appear jaundice. So their skin or their nails or their eyes are starting to turn yellow. And that's a sign of liver damage because that yellowness is caused by something called bilirubin building up in your skin or your eyes because your liver can't break it down into the form that you can excrete.
37:07 Speaker 01 And as your liver gets damaged, because your liver is also in charge of making most all of our clotting factors, now, all of a sudden, your blood can't clot the way that it should. So you start to have signs of bleeding, and this could be things like large bruises or purpura, which are these like big, dark, purple splotches on the skin that are essentially just signs of bleeding underneath the skin.
37:30 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
37:31 Speaker 01 You might see bleeding from mucous membranes, like your nose or your gums. You'll see bloody vomiting or diarrhea, really heavy menstrual bleeding. If this person is already hospitalized and getting poked for things like blood draws or IVs, they'll start to have bleeding from these sites of venipuncture. And this form of hemorrhagic disease is the most severe form. About 50% of people who develop hemorrhagic disease from Riffali fever will usually die within three to six days of the first sign of these hemorrhagic symptoms.
38:03 Speaker 00 Do we know what factors make someone more likely to develop the hemorrhagic form, or the ocular form, or the neurological form, or be completely asymptomatic?
38:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's such a good question. It's probably similar to different species of animals that we see. It likely depends on host factors, right? So like who you are and what your immune system does in response to this virus. But also things like the route of transmission. So overall, like I said, the intranasal or airborne transmission seems to be more likely to cause severe disease than in animal models where we've like injected this virus into animals. But beyond that, there's like a lot that we don't know and don't understand. And again, I have several papers that go really deep into detail on what we do know,
38:56 Speaker 01 which is a lot about like viral receptors and the histopathology of like what's happening in your liver and what's happening in where in your brain is there inflammation. But like, how does this actually happen? Why are some people so severely affected and others are not? I don't have a good answer to that question.
39:16 Speaker 00 Hmm, okay.
39:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:19 Speaker 00 And you mentioned that the virus can also be transmitted from pregnant person to fetus.
39:26 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
39:26 Speaker 00 What does the infection look like in that situation?
39:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, it depends. And we don't have a lot of data on this because there haven't been that many well documented cases. There's been enough to show that it is very likely that this virus can cross the placenta and infect a fetus. It can cause potentially like it does in animals spontaneous abortion. But again, we haven't seen like significant increased rates of spontaneous abortion in areas where there have been outbreaks, which is good news. But certainly, it can also then cause infection in a newborn. And because newborns have very little immune system, that infection is likely more likely to be severe. So there have been cases of neonatal deaths from this virus.
40:08 Speaker 00 And where do we stand on treatment?
40:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, we don't stand.
40:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay.
40:14 Speaker 01 There are no treatments that are specific for this virus, which means that there's a lot of things that we have to do to try and prevent it. So mosquito control is an important part of that. Vaccines, and there are a couple of different vaccines for livestock. No vaccines for humans. But there are both like live attenuated vaccines and there are inactivated or killed virus vaccines. Pros and cons to both of those. But they both exist and they both can be used both like on a regular basis in endemic areas in livestock as well as in the case of outbreaks, at least the inactivated form. But yeah, that's
40:54 Speaker 01 that's Rift Valley fever. It is, it can be a really severe infection. And we'll talk more in detail about recent outbreaks that have happened. Like, why is it so severe sometimes? Or is it getting more severe? I don't, I don't know, Erin.
41:11 Speaker 00 That is a great question.
41:13 Speaker 01 It is. I still have a question. So Erin, when did we first find out about this virus? When did it spill over from animals to humans? What do we know about it?
41:25 Speaker 00 Uh, let me see what I can answer right after this break.
41:57 Speaker 00 On the surface, history and disease ecology seem like two entirely different fields. History, of course, deals with past events, especially from a human perspective, while disease ecology examines the relationship between a pathogen or pathogens, its host or hosts, and the environment. Like, what would you learn in a history class that would be repeated in a class on disease ecology, besides the discovery of one disease or another? Not a lot, Erin. That's why I love our podcast. Me too, Erin. But as I was reading about Rift Valley Fever, the first described outbreaks, the potential impact of climate change and land use change on future outbreaks,
42:42 Speaker 00 I realized how similar the approach that these two fields take really is. Because it all comes down to understanding the context. Why did this happen, when it did? And what can the past tell us about the future? Ooh, love that. Yeah, I know. This is my, like, hyper nerd. I was like, whoa, disease ecology and history are the same thing. I finally get why I love this. And finally, it all makes sense. It all makes sense. But let's start with the first part of that, the why did this happen when it did? Getting at the earliest known emergence of Rift Valley Fever. In August of 1913, the Department of Agriculture of, quote unquote,
43:26 Speaker 00 "British East Africa" published its annual report. On the whole, it's some pretty dry reading. Crop counts, detailed descriptions of personnel vacations, the number of in-going and outgoing letters for each sub-department. Like, do you want to know how many letters the veterinary department received and wrote in 1913?
43:48 Speaker 01 I actually do.
43:50 Speaker 00 It's 6,800.
43:52 Speaker 01 Wow.
43:53 Speaker 00 It's more than I thought.
43:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, that seems like a lot.
43:56 Speaker 00 I know.
43:56 Speaker 01 They didn't have email. Think about how many emails they probably send now, but.
44:00 Speaker 00 I know. It's kind of, I was like, wow, that's, that's, that's a lot.
44:04 Speaker 01 It's a lot. That's a lot of letters.
44:06 Speaker 00 And these reports also included casual mentions of land theft and forceful removal under the guise of manifest destiny.
44:14 Speaker 01 Ah, yeah.
44:15 Speaker 00 Right? So, quote, "In June 1912, the removal of the Maasai and their stock from Lai Kipia was commenced and was brought to a successful conclusion on the 27th of March, 1913," end quote.
44:28 Speaker 01 Wow. Imagine just talking about, like, decimating human populations and forcibly removing human beings from their home that way. Cool.
44:36 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yep. I mean, success definitely in the eye of the beholder in that successful conclusion. Because just for a little bit of extra context, this removal broke the 1904 promise that the British had made to the Maasai to stop taking their land, which they ultimately stole about 70% of, to make space for the incoming settlers. And they were like, oh, the Lai Kipia Plateau being at higher elevation, it's going to be more hospitable to the Europeans that are coming. Like, it's, it's just all part of it. Yeah.
45:10 Speaker 00 But if you keep scrolling past this detached reporting of, you know, land theft and so on, you'll eventually come to a mention of a devastating disease impacting sheep. Quote, "A mortality of 90% was recorded among the lambs at government farm Nai Vasha. Other farms in the Rift Valley also suffered considerable loss. In some cases, the symptoms were very acute and death occurred within a few hours. In others, the disease ran a more subacute or chronic course. In the acute form, the only symptoms shown were dullness, rapid respirations, collapse, and death within four hours. In postmortem, the liver was found to be soft and friable, and the kidneys congested.
45:54 Speaker 00 In the subacute or chronic form, the umbilicus was incompletely closed and swelling of the joints occurred. Investigation pointed to the disease resulting from infection gaining entrance through the umbilicus," end quote.
46:07 Speaker 01 Hmm.
46:08 Speaker 00 Yeah. The sheep that were primarily impacted by this disease were merino, which were introduced for their wool. Hmm. But there didn't seem to be much follow up or concern about this particular disease, perhaps because, quote, "The setback was only a temporary one," end quote. Hmm. So this brief mention from 1912, buried in pages upon pages of bureaucratic minutia, stands out as the first description of what was likely rift valley fever. Yeah. Why then? Why 1912? Right? Just because you brought all them sheeps there? Um, I mean, that's part of it, but it also does seem to impact the native species there as well.
46:54 Speaker 00 So maybe it's just visibility, like these merino sheep were more susceptible. That's part of it. But I think there are some other things going on too. So later genetic analyses would place the origin of the rift valley fever virus as recently as the 1880s to 1890s. What? Yeah. So it could have just been that this was one of the earliest outbreaks that this virus caused. Interesting. So where did this virus come from? Great question. I don't know. Because also viruses do this thing where one strain tends to dominate in an outbreak and it replaces all the other strains and kind of makes it look like it's the only one. And so this could underestimate how old the virus truly is.
47:39 Speaker 00 So maybe it is a lot older, but it's just sort of doing this whole strain replacement type of thing. But regardless of when the virus evolved, it likely had caused infections prior to 1912. And the reason, though, that it was first described then is probably because of colonization, right? Importing a merino sheep, which might be more susceptible to the virus, as we talked about. But also there's the looking for it. Right. In these agricultural reports, the British were monitoring their investments, seeing how well the introduced crops and livestock, like merino sheep, did on the lands that they stole and noting what diseases posed a threat to their income, like rift valley fever.
48:25 Speaker 00 This is the reason that tropical medicine was founded as a field of study. Right. Yep. To better understand, prevent and treat the diseases that were prevalent in an area undergoing colonization. Mm hmm. The chief veterinary officer who made the initial report, R.J. Stordi, wasn't noting this sheep disease out of academic curiosity, but out of a, oh, this might be something we have to look out for as settlers set up their farms here type of a thing.
48:53 Speaker 01 Right.
48:55 Speaker 00 R.E. Montgomery, the veterinary pathologist at the time, even signed off his report with, quote, "In conclusion, I may add that only such diseases as appeared to me possess considerable interest to the stock owner have been dealt with in this report. There have been a considerable number of others, which are, as yet fortunately, of minor importance. I consider it our duty so far as possible to undertake the preliminary investigation of all diseases which come within our knowledge, and by doing so, to be in some measure prepared for eventualities." End quote. Science and the questions that we ask in science have always been guided by certain values or principles or interests.
49:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
49:37 Speaker 00 And I just, I feel like it's, that part doesn't really get highlighted a whole lot in
49:43 Speaker 01 Oh, no.
49:44 Speaker 00 This type of research, yeah.
49:45 Speaker 01 Stories of like discovery for discovery's sake, or like, this is so cool and interesting and then was used. But yeah, no, I mean,
49:54 Speaker 01 much of the time, specific things were being studied at the bottom line for money.
50:01 Speaker 00 Yeah. I mean, then the chief veterinary officer for the Department of Agriculture wasn't just like screening sheep left and right. The more interested in diseases affecting sheep than the diseases affecting wildlife, because sheep was where the money was, not wildlife.
50:16 Speaker 01 A hundred percent.
50:17 Speaker 00 Okay, but what happens next, right? Like, what happens after 1912? Well, nearly 20 years would pass before the disease appeared in another scientific publication, one that would give it its name and identify the causative agent. In 1931, Dobney and Hudson, from the Division of Veterinary Research Kenya Colony, described a devastating outbreak of unknown cause in sheep, merino sheep, on a farm in the Rift Valley. The disease primarily impacted newborn lambs or pregnant sheep. At the start of the outbreak, 60 of the 80 lambs born died within a matter of weeks. The authors noted that the farm manager chose July and August as the lambing
50:59 Speaker 00 season that year, which was somewhat unusual. Normally, it was May or October to November. Right? So you choose like when the lambs are born. You, sorry, how do you choose that? You put the sheep together at a certain time. Oh, wow. Yeah. I didn't know.
51:16 Speaker 00 Well, and you do this so that you can time it with like when Rainfall. Rainfall, when grass is available, grazing lands, et cetera. Interesting. Okay. So why July and August of that year? Well, it turns out that in that same year, the area had received an unusually large amount of rainfall, over forty-five inches compared to the annual average of twenty-five, which is a ton. So this meant more grazing habitat during the dry season. And so the manager figured it would be safe to lamb in July and August, especially if the heavy rains in the beginning of the year were repeated in November, which would make it harder on the lambs that were born then. So you're kind of just like
51:57 Speaker 00 hedging your bets, like, well, things are looking good right now. Let's lamb right now. Or like, you know, however many months from now. And the rainfall and mosquitoes. The excess rainfall, yep, also meant more habitat for other critters like midges, which can transmit a virus that causes the livestock disease, bluetongue, which I also saw a peak in that year, and mosquitoes, which of course carry the rift valley fever virus. Those sixty lamb deaths in early July turned out to be only the tip of the iceberg as the disease tore through the flock, killing lambs and ewes within hours of the first
52:39 Speaker 00 symptoms appearing. By August 10, 1930, about a month after the outbreak began, quote, "The total mortality in lambs had reached approximately thirty-five hundred and upwards of twelve hundred ewes had died." Wow. I think it was a mortality of ninety-five percent. Oh, my God. Yeah.
53:00 Speaker 00 The farm manager was desperate to save the surviving sheep. And so he transported them to another farm higher up, around 7,000 to 8,500 feet in altitude, which is 2,100 to 2,600 meters. The other farm, the original farm, was about 5,500 to 6,000 feet, 1,700 to 1,800 meters. After arriving there, higher up, the deaths continued for a few days, but eventually stopped.
53:26 Speaker 01 Okay.
53:27 Speaker 00 But the disease continued on in on the original farm for months after. And so this could be because there aren't as many mosquitoes at higher elevations. Maybe like the temperatures keep it down or the humidity or whatever it is. Or the mosquitoes that carry the virus don't live at higher elevations, even if there are other mosquitoes there. Or the mosquitoes at those higher altitudes just weren't infected. And so to try to answer this, I did a little bit of digging and found a 2016 paper that noted that the risk of rift valley fever tended to go down as altitude went up. But it doesn't seem like there's been extensive research about the altitudinal range of the vector mosquitoes. Or, you know, like, all of these questions that are like, are mosquitoes capable of transmitting the virus
54:12 Speaker 00 existing or living at higher altitudes?
54:14 Speaker 01 Right. Well, and it's hard because there's so many species, Erin. Like, which one do you pick?
54:18 Speaker 00 So many species, right?
54:19 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:20 Speaker 00 And then, like, if higher altitude means less likely infection, will that change as the climate changes?
54:26 Speaker 01 Probably.
54:28 Speaker 00 But I'm getting ahead of myself. Dobney and Hudson, the authors of this 1931 paper, got to the farm and began their susceptibility tests, their postmortems, their analyses. And they isolated a virus that they named the rift valley fever virus, found that it caused the highest mortality in sheep, but that goats and cattle could also be infected, as could humans. Quote, "During the course of the investigation, all the four Europeans engaged developed a dengue-like fever, which we now know to have been due to infection with the virus." "The first person to be attacked was Mr. F. Lyons, the laboratory assistant in charge of the exposure experiment on the farm where the disease first appeared."
55:10 Speaker 00 Mr. EJ Hall, who assisted in the laboratory investigation, was next attacked. A few days later, both writers developed symptoms within a few hours of each other. In every case, the onset of the attack was characterized by a very brief period of general malaise, followed rapidly by sharp rigors and headache. The temperature rose to about 103 degrees Fahrenheit and the face was brightly flushed. In from three to six hours after the rigors had passed off, pains developed in or near the joints extending from the base of the skull to the extremities. Fever persisted for a period of from 12 to 36 hours and the pains gradually disappeared within about four days. Hmm. And then they would go on to say that every "native" that was herding sheep during
55:55 Speaker 00 the attack also got sick with fever and aches and pains, and that the manager just chalked it up to eating "the somewhat decomposed carcasses of dead sheep." End quote. Great, great. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, just some casual racism thrown into that paper. Not surprising at all. Nope, nope. This 1931 paper clearly described this newly recognized disease, the responsible virus, the symptoms it caused, and its association with wet years, even noting that "the dengue-like fever in man would in all probability fail to attract serious attention in view of the fact that in such years the incidence of malaria would be unusually high." End quote. Yeah. So they're like obscured.
56:40 Speaker 00 Right, it's here, but it's not as big of a deal as the other stuff, so no one's looking at it. Right, and it's also like everyone's getting sick from these other things, and so it kind of flies under the radar. Right, right, right. Okay, makes sense. And so, but with that similarity to malaria pointed out, they made an educated guess that the rift valley fever virus was transmitted like malaria by mosquitoes. Love that. Yeah. But it was also clear that mosquitoes were not the only way you could get exposed to the virus. First you had the four who worked on the virus, including Dobney and Hudson, get sick, along with so many people who worked with sheep in the field, presumably from handling samples or directly interacting with the sheep themselves.
57:21 Speaker 00 But then the disease started to crop up in laboratory researchers a long way from Kenya, especially those who performed necropsies on the lambs. And the first known death from rift valley fever in humans was recorded in 1933 or 1932 from our firsthand account. Okay. This death, though, would stand out as somewhat of an anomaly for the four or so decades that followed the publication of Dobney and Hudson's paper. From the 1930s to the 1970s, Rift Valley Fever caused nearly two dozen epizootics throughout Africa, first spreading from East Africa to South Africa, and infections seemed limited to livestock only.
58:05 Speaker 00 Few human cases were noted and no deaths. And these weren't necessarily small outbreaks. One epizootic in Kenya from 1950 to 1951 led to 500,000 sheep infections and 100,000 deaths. Wow. Yeah. That's like, I feel like when you hear numbers like that, like, it's just so hard to imagine that much death and devastation, honestly. It is. And like livelihoods ruined. Absolutely ruined, yeah. Was it possible that in an epizootic like this, just no one was looking for human cases and they were just mild or asymptomatic?
58:48 Speaker 00 I mean, potentially, likely, but researchers screened some of the people that were handling animals during the outbreaks and found really low levels of antibodies to the Rift Valley Fever virus, suggesting that they weren't getting infected at all. I have so many questions, Erin. I know. Because this isn't the way things stayed. Yeah. Right? Like, this epizootic happening every few years, causing a few mild human infections, if any, but lots and lots of animal infections and deaths? Mm-hmm. That was gonna be a thing of the past. The first signal that something changed came in 1974 and 1976, when South Africa saw
59:30 Speaker 00 half a million animal infections and the first human deaths due to Rift Valley Fever virus in South Africa, this time not from laboratory workers, and more human infections than had ever been reported. 110 lab-diagnosed cases and seven deaths. Wow. But this outbreak would quickly be overshadowed by another, resulting in a total paradigm shift for this disease that would shape our understanding of the virus and its relevance in public health. Between 1977 and 1979, Rift Valley Fever ripped through Egypt, which had never seen a case before. In fact, no cases outside of Sub-Saharan Africa had been seen before this.
1:00:13 Speaker 00 Officials estimated that half of all susceptible animals in the country were infected.
1:00:19 Speaker 01 Whoa.
1:00:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, which absolutely devastated the Egyptian economy. As if that wasn't bad enough, the disease also caused extensive morbidity and mortality in humans, with an estimated 200,000 human infections and 600 deaths.
1:00:39 Speaker 01 Yeah. I mean, so different than these early outbreaks that you're discussing.
1:00:44 Speaker 00 So different. And even in the past outbreaks, when there had been some human infection, they were mild.
1:00:50 Speaker 01 Right, and small comparatively.
1:00:53 Speaker 00 Small numbers, yeah. But this outbreak in Egypt, there was hemorrhagic disease, there was encephalitis, there was ocular disease, all of these extreme manifestations of the virus that you described. And with this outbreak came the realization that this was more than a potentially devastating disease for livestock. Rift Valley Fever also posed a serious threat to humans. This became more and more apparent over the following decades. First in 1997 to 1998, with a devastating episodic epidemic in Kenya after rainfall exceeded 60 to 100 times the normal amount,
1:01:29 Speaker 01 Wow.
1:01:30 Speaker 00 resulting in livestock losses up to 70% on some farms, and an estimated 89,000 infections and 478 deaths in humans.
1:01:41 Speaker 00 Then Rift Valley Fever continued to expand its geographic range, with the first cases of Rift Valley Fever outside of Africa happening in Saudi Arabia and Yemen in 2000, where it caused 880 lab-confirmed cases, the real number is likely much, much higher, and 123 deaths. Since then, Rift Valley Fever has settled into this new pattern, causing occasional epizootics and epidemics after periods of unusually heavy rainfall, often resulting in hundreds, if not thousands, or tens of thousands of human cases and deaths, as well as severe economic losses due to livestock mortality. And so circling back to those two questions that I asked at the start of this,
1:02:25 Speaker 00 why did Rift Valley Fever become deadlier and cause larger outbreaks over the past 50 years or so? And what can that tell us about future outbreaks? The answer to those questions is complicated because we've got so many interconnected factors at play. Right? We've got the virus itself. How likely it is to mutate, or reassort, or recombine? How often it gets an opportunity to become more virulent? We've got the vectors. How abundant they are? Which species are in which areas? Whether different species are equally good at transmitting the virus? Whether different species tend to bite humans or livestock more readily? How often they feed? How long their eggs, which could potentially contain the virus,
1:03:09 Speaker 00 last between epizootics in the environment? We've got the hosts. How many sheep are in a certain area? How controlled their movements are? How susceptible they are? Whether the animals have been vaccinated? When lambing happens? Importation of animals from affected regions to ones where the virus has never appeared? How many humans live or work near outbreak areas? Whether they have access to protective equipment when handling infected animals? Whether this region has the resources to monitor outbreaks and take steps to prevent or control the disease if it appears? I'm not done.
1:03:41 Speaker 01 There's more, I know.
1:03:42 Speaker 00 Because then there's the environment.
1:03:44 Speaker 01 Right.
1:03:45 Speaker 00 Rainfall amount, humidity, temperatures, soil type. Some soils retain water better than others, which in turn has an effect on mosquito habitat, the propensity of certain areas to flood, vegetation density and type, which also affects mosquito breeding habitats and grazing, deforestation, irrigation, dams, El Nino events, wind, and so many other factors.
1:04:08 Speaker 01 Well, wildlife?
1:04:10 Speaker 00 Wildlife, yes.
1:04:11 Speaker 01 Right?
1:04:12 Speaker 00 What potential hosts are-
1:04:13 Speaker 01 What other hosts are around besides your livestock?
1:04:16 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:04:16 Speaker 01 And what kind of density and what kind of environments, what kind of mixing? What species of mosquito are biting them versus you versus your livestock? There, it is an unbelievably complicated... This is why we don't have predictive models, that's the-
1:04:31 Speaker 00 Well, but we do. That's the kind of cool thing. I mean, no, but like, we do and we don't, right? Do we have perfect models? There's no such thing.
1:04:40 Speaker 01 Right.
1:04:40 Speaker 00 We're never gonna have the amount of data. Ecology is just too noisy. There's, there's too much going on, it's too difficult to collect, things are changing too much. Drawing a straight line from cause to effect is impossible.
1:04:52 Speaker 01 Doesn't exist, yeah.
1:04:54 Speaker 00 I mean, yeah.
1:04:55 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:04:56 Speaker 00 Just not really a feasibility. But even with all of these moving parts, there are some ways that we are able to see what the future might look like. And it also might help us to answer some questions about the past. Why Rift Valley Fever became more deadly and more likely to cause human deaths about 50 years ago? It's, it's, I mean, it's probably a mix of those moving parts, maybe mutations or reassortments of the virus, increased rainfall events because of climate instability, increasing herd sizes, and crucially, movement of infected animals across large geographic areas, especially from endemic to naive areas.
1:05:40 Speaker 00 More virus equals more infections equals more opportunities to become deadlier.
1:05:45 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
1:05:45 Speaker 00 We don't have a perfect roadmap for how this happened. But putting together the drivers of these past outbreaks, or some factors associated with these past outbreaks, can give us clues about the future. So there's a cool paper from 2024 by Chemisen et al. That talks about how they created a model using climate data to see if they could accurately predict past rift valley fever outbreaks across Africa.
1:06:12 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:06:12 Speaker 00 And it is just like primarily climate data.
1:06:15 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:06:15 Speaker 00 But their model did a pretty good job, which is exciting in itself. But what this also means is that you could tell this model, okay, this is what the climate is projected to look like in the next 10 years for this region or that region, or even the next year or the next five years, whatever you want. And you could see how those different climate scenarios or climate change scenarios could impact the risk of rift valley fever outbreaks.
1:06:40 Speaker 01 Right.
1:06:40 Speaker 00 Broad strokes right now seems to be that things will get wetter in affected regions, which means more outbreaks potentially.
1:06:47 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
1:06:48 Speaker 00 And so you could say, okay, next year, what is it going to look like potentially for rainfall? And you could place higher alert. And so then if an outbreak does start to happen, are there things that you can do to cut that outbreak short?
1:07:01 Speaker 01 Right. What are the plans that you put in place, knowing that this is going to be a wetter year, knowing that that's going to increase the risk of transmission? How do you then deal with it?
1:07:08 Speaker 00 Right, right. And so these models are not perfect.
1:07:11 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
1:07:12 Speaker 00 But they can help to create early warnings, to focus resources during certain areas at certain times in places where resources typically are often very limited, to see where rift valley fever might spread as the climate changes. Like you'll see some papers that are like rift valley fever in Europe? Is this where it's going to be now? And these models can be updated as we learn more about this virus, about the climate, about the hosts, about all of, about the mosquitoes, about everything.
1:07:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:07:44 Speaker 00 They are a really important part of our toolkit, but they're not the only thing. So, speaking of which, Erin, I was hoping that you could tell me where we are with Rift Valley Fever today and whether there's maybe a human vaccine in the works? We'll talk about it right after this break.
1:08:37 Speaker 01 So like you mentioned, Erin, when you were talking about where we first saw this virus and how it has spread, this is a virus that's endemic at this point in animals and/or mosquitoes across Eastern Africa, all the way into Southern Africa, honestly, across the entire continent into Western Africa, and has gone north into Egypt and caused a few outbreaks on the Arabian Peninsula.
1:09:06 Speaker 01 Looking at the World Health Organization's outbreak reports, because they have disease outbreak news reports, and this is absolutely one of the viruses that gets reported on if there are any human cases, the most recent outbreaks that they reported were actually a couple of years ago, which I was a little bit surprised about. There haven't been any that they reported thus far, as of the time of recording, in 2023 or 2024. The most recent outbreak that the World Health Organization reported on was in Mauritania in 2022. And in this outbreak, there were 47 cases confirmed in humans. Almost all of them were people who worked with animals of some kind, many animal breeders.
1:09:50 Speaker 01 But of those 47 cases, 23 people died.
1:09:56 Speaker 00 Wow.
1:09:57 Speaker 01 Which is a case fatality rate of 49%.
1:10:02 Speaker 01 In this outbreak of the animals that they tested, there were nearly 300 animals that were positive for Rift Valley fever virus. 24% of those animals died. And these were a mix of cattle, camels, and small ruminants.
1:10:17 Speaker 01 If we look back at past outbreaks, in 2021, there was an outbreak in Kenya that had 32 confirmed human cases and 11 deaths, which is a case fatality rate of 34%. There was an even larger outbreak in Mauritania in 2020 with at least 75 people confirmed positive. Over 200 people were suspected to be infected and at least 25 deaths. And what I was thinking in looking through all of these individual outbreaks, and again, you can link to all of these on the World Health Organization website. There's a number more dating back to like the 2010s,
1:10:59 Speaker 01 that these are very high case fatality rates. Yeah. Very high compared to what we have seen in the past and very high compared to what all of the sources that I read would lead you to expect. When we talk about 1% to 2% of cases, or even 8% to 10% of symptomatic cases being severe, and 50% of hemorrhagic cases ending in death, right? That's the numbers that I cited earlier. Yeah. So what is going on here? Like, does this mean that in these outbreaks,
1:11:42 Speaker 01 the cases that we are able to report, that the World Health Organization is reporting, are those cases only the tip of the iceberg? Probably. In a case, yeah, that's possible. I did some errand math to try and get a handle on what that would mean.
1:12:01 Speaker 01 So if we look at the outbreak in Mauritania in 2022, we had 47 people that were confirmed to be infected and 23 people who died.
1:12:11 Speaker 01 If we think that that means that those cases were only the people who had severe infection, if we tried to err in math that outbreak, then we would estimate that that outbreak could have been as large as like 4,700 people who were infected. If we were expecting that only 1 to 2% of all people who were infected had severe symptoms and 50% of people with severe symptoms, that would be those 47 people, 50% of those people would end up dying. That's, that's my err in math of the situation. Does that make sense?
1:12:52 Speaker 00 Yes.
1:12:53 Speaker 01 We don't have any data to suggest that that is what happened, at least that that has been reported that I have seen. So I'm not trying to say that these cases are actually, these outbreaks are actually thousands more than we think, but that is one possibility. The other possibility is that case fatality rates are indicative of much more severe illness than we have seen in the past. And if so, why? Is that because the virus is changing? Is that because something was happening with hosts who were infected at the time? I don't know, but there was a paper from PLOS neglected tropical disease that was a systematic review and meta-analysis of all the case reports from the last few decades. They looked at like
1:13:37 Speaker 01 32 different studies and they found an overall 21% fatality rate among those who had symptoms of disease. So it seems like the mortality rate may be on the rise from Rift Valley Fever. And we don't, as far as I read, understand what exactly might be driving that.
1:13:59 Speaker 00 Which is very interesting because as we talked about, the virus is not directly transmitted human to human.
1:14:08 Speaker 01 Exactly. It is not. And there still has been no evidence that that has started.
1:14:12 Speaker 00 And so what is going on? In the environment, like it must be something that is happening to increase the virulence. Is there a corresponding increase in virulence in the affected animal species?
1:14:26 Speaker 01 And it's hard because it's already so virulent. So.
1:14:29 Speaker 00 Right. How could you go up from 90%?
1:14:32 Speaker 01 Right. Yeah. So, no, and I haven't seen data that suggests that it's killing more animals. It's certainly still killing hundreds, tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands in many outbreaks.
1:14:46 Speaker 01 But, yeah, so it's, it's very interesting. It's going to be important, I think, to watch what is actually happening. And I think too, I'm sure that especially for these last few years of outbreaks, there will be more papers coming out that maybe look at a larger swath of the population where these outbreaks occurred to try and get a sense of like, what is the seroprevalence in that population? How big were these outbreaks really? In some studies that have looked across like endemic areas, there have been seroprevalent studies that have estimated anywhere from like six to eight percent of humans and eight to 12% of livestock
1:15:27 Speaker 01 show evidence of prior infection. So this virus is out there circulating, even when we're not necessarily seeing it cause epizootics or outbreaks in humans. So what do we do about it all?
1:15:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was just about to say, is there a vaccine in the works?
1:15:44 Speaker 01 There, there are many. So there are two already, at least two, and there might be multiple like versions, but there are two that exist for animals, for livestock. Neither of them are perfect. The live vaccine is very effective. A single dose of the live vaccine is very effective, but it has a lot of drawbacks. It tends to cause spontaneous abortion in animals if they are pregnant because it is a live vaccine, even though it's less virulent. You also can't give that vaccine during an outbreak because it can actually end up amplifying the outbreak.
1:16:21 Speaker 00 Right.
1:16:22 Speaker 01 And there's always a risk because it's a live vaccine that it would then kind of mutate back closer to the wild type and then cause disease outbreaks amongst animals or humans. So those are the big drawbacks of the live vaccine. There is also an inactivated vaccine. They require multiple doses, I think at least three doses, which makes them more difficult to implement in a lot of areas. And they just don't provide quite as long lasting of protection, but they also don't have the drawbacks that the live vaccine has. So unsurprisingly, this is one of the main areas of research is developing a vaccine, especially one that could be used for both livestock and humans.
1:17:06 Speaker 01 There's at least one that's being studied right now in both the UK and in Uganda, or at least when this paper was published in 2022, it was being studied in these areas in both livestock and humans that was using a viral vector, very similar to some of the COVID vaccines that we saw that use like a viral vector as a vaccine. But there's also like a whole bunch of different vaccine candidates that people are studying. We don't have any that I saw that are super close to being ready for use in humans.
1:17:41 Speaker 00 Okay, that's disappointing.
1:17:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, but maybe by the time this episode comes out, there will be a new paper that changes that because I mean, as of a couple of years ago, they were definitely studying it. And I think that with all of the advancements that we've seen in vaccine platforms since COVID, I think that we are very likely to see the development of vaccines for viruses like Rift Valley fever because of what a huge impact it has on livestock, on economics, and on human health and public health. So there is a vaccine that some veterinary and laboratory personnel have gotten. Like there is a vaccine that people have gotten when they're at very high risk for infection, but it's an animal vaccine that has never been licensed or approved for use in any country.
1:18:28 Speaker 00 Interesting. Okay.
1:18:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:18:31 Speaker 01 Like someone's like, I've been vaccinated. That's very cool. It's not approved.
1:18:38 Speaker 01 So yeah, that's Rift Valley Fever. I um, I feel like it is one that should get more press than it has gotten, perhaps. Like, it made me more nervous than I-
1:18:50 Speaker 00 Absolutely. I feel like, yes, it is a scary and potentially very impactful disease in a public health context, but also just as a livestock disease. It's so economically devastating and traumatizing.
1:19:08 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:19:09 Speaker 00 Because like, I just, again, from one day to the next, or like, one week to the next, you could lose your entire herd, your entire livelihood.
1:19:17 Speaker 01 It's, I mean, absolutely devastating. The size of some of these outbreaks, and we'll link to some papers that have kind of details on all of the dozens of outbreaks that have happened over even just the past 20 years. I mean, some of them have been hundreds of thousands-
1:19:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:19:33 Speaker 01 -of livestock. It's just, I mean, horrific.
1:19:35 Speaker 00 Unfathomable. Yeah.
1:19:37 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:19:38 Speaker 00 Well, speaking of sources, shall we share some sources?
1:19:42 Speaker 01 Let's share, so you can read some more.
1:19:43 Speaker 00 Okay. I'm gonna shout out three in particular. By Baba et al. from 2016, "Has Rift Valley Fever Virus Evolved With Increasing Severity In Human Populations In East Africa?" By McMillan and Hartman from 2018, "Rift Valley Fever In Animals And Humans: Current Perspectives." And that modeling paper that I mentioned in "The Last Bit Of The History" by Chemison et al. from 2024, "Ability Of A Dynamical Climate-Sensitive Model To Reproduce Historical Rift Valley Fever Outbreaks Over Africa."
1:20:17 Speaker 01 I have a number of papers, a couple that I wanted to give a shout out to. One was that PLOS Neglected Tropical Disease Paper. It was from 2022. It was titled "Clinical Manifestations Of Rift Valley Fever In Humans: Systematic Review And Meta-Analysis." Another was from the Journal of Veterinary Research from 2021, called "Rift Valley Fever: A Growing Threat To Humans And Animals." And there was a number of other ones. So we will post the list of all of our sources from this episode. And every single one of our episodes, you can get so deep on the neuropathophysiology on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com, under the Episodes tab.
1:20:56 Speaker 00 Thank you to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes.
1:21:01 Speaker 01 Thank you to Tom Bryfogle and Leona Scolacci for the audio mixing.
1:21:05 Speaker 00 Thank you to everyone at Exactly Right.
1:21:08 Speaker 01 And thank you to you, listeners. I hope that you enjoyed this episode.
1:21:13 Speaker 00 Yeah. I hope you learned something new. That's always my hope. I certainly did.
1:21:19 Speaker 01 It's our favorite thing is to learn new things.
1:21:21 Speaker 00 It truly, truly is.
1:21:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:21:24 Speaker 00 And a special thank you to our wonderful patrons. We appreciate your support so, so very much. It really means a lot to us.
1:21:32 Speaker 01 It really does. Thank you.
1:21:33 Speaker 00 Well, until next time, wash your hands.
1:21:36 Speaker 01 You filthy animals.
1:22:06 Speaker 01 What is one thing many of us deal with every single day but rarely talk about? Dry hands. Whether you frequently wash your hands or deal with harsh weather, your hands can be left feeling dry, rough, cracked, and even uncomfortable. That's where O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream comes in to help. The fast-absorbing formula goes on smoothly and it won't leave behind a greasy residue, so you can get back to your busy day without ever missing a beat. And because a little will go a long way, O'Keefe's Working Hands Hand Cream is effective, dependable, and economical, too. Whether you're dealing with harsh weather outside, demanding work, or everyday wear and tear, O'Keefe's Working Hands works just as hard as you do. So keep your hands hydrated, smooth, and feeling
1:22:49 Speaker 01 comfortable all season long. Visit okeefescompany.com today. That's O-K-E-E-F-F-E-S company.com for guaranteed relief. O'Keefe's Working Hands. Yeah, it works.
1:23:03 Speaker 05 Hey, it's Lunchbox from the Bobby Bones Show. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features in tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or an adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops, while Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at trade-in. Get a deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
1:23:41 Speaker 06 With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans. Develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a prioritized schedule. So you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at chatgpt.com.
Previous Ep 163 Circadian Rhythm: Live from Perth, Australia Next Ep 165 Fish Tongue Parasite: Parasite Appreciation Hour Page updated November 4, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated