Pod Insights This Podcast Will Kill You Ep 163 Circadian Rhythm: Live from Perth, Australia About this episode We are coming at you with our very first live episode from Perth, Australia! Here at the 2024 Australian Institute of Occupational Hygienists Annual Scientific Conference and Exhibition, occupational hazards and exposures get top billing. And one of the most ubiquitous hazards, experienced by nearly every industry is fatigue, specifically fatigue caused by circadian rhythm disruption. In this very special episode, we explore how our circadian rhythms work and some of the consequences that can emerge when we work against those rhythms, whether that’s because we’re traveling across many time zones or switching to night shift work.
Transcript 13,875 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:06 Speaker 01 Hey, it's Lunchbox from the Bobby Bones Show. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features in tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or an adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops, while Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at trade-in. Get a deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
0:44 Speaker 00 Morning, Carmen.
0:44 Speaker 02 Good morning.
0:45 Speaker 00 Quick question.
0:46 Speaker 02 Just one second.
0:46 Speaker 03 Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything.
0:54 Speaker 04 Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account?
0:57 Speaker 03 Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ.
1:03 Speaker 02 Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023?
1:09 Speaker 03 Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on.
1:14 Speaker 05 Network freedom and flexibility, that's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to bill Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
1:44 Speaker 06 Good morning, Arians. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for the invitation to come and share a story that I went through in my career. In 2012, I was an intern back in Dublin in a large teaching hospital. I was six months after finishing my intern year, aged 23. And I was working in a busy surgical unit. It was January and I was waking, woken up about 6am to go and start my journey to work. As I've gone to work, bear in mind it's a Thursday, I've already undertaken about 36 hours of work within this work week from Monday. And I'm about to go and start on another Thursday.
2:24 Speaker 06 I feel I'm relatively well rested, but I know that I'm not feeling particularly good going in to start a very large shift, which I'm going to elaborate on a little bit now. At 6.30, I arrive into work and I undertake results checking. We look at all the results of our patients from the day before, recent blood tests, recent scan results, and ultimately to prepare for the ward round when our surgeons, the consultants and the senior doctors will start undertaking, looking at every patient on their list. At 7 o'clock, we start sharp and we finish about 8 o'clock. And at 8 o'clock, those senior surgeons will head off to surgery and us as the junior doctors will then undertake the tasks of the day.
3:06 Speaker 06 We'll look at organising consultations, we'll be writing letters, discharging patients, admitting new ones, and then deal with problems as they occur on the wards. It's fast paced, it's a busy unit, but it's something that I thrive. I enjoy the challenges as they present. I really am passionate about the work and I'm very happy to work in such a busy environment, even though you might only be getting 20 minutes for a quick lunch break. You feel very valued, you feel wanted and a key cog in that machine of the hospital. But there's very much a drive, you have to have the work done and it has to be done correctly, it's got to be done with precision because at the end of the day, patient care depends on it.
3:51 Speaker 06 As the day continues, we tick over to about quarter to six in the evening. And then the surgeons are starting to come out of theatre and then we start doing a further round through the hospital again of all the patients that have been under the lists of the surgeons whom have operated and those who are still waiting after their operations. These rounds then can finish about quarter past seven. So bear in mind, I've been in the hospital since six thirty and it's now quarter past seven at night. I then start the next part of my shift. And back in 2012, we were routinely rostered to do twenty-four hours. So I will then move from my day job to then providing night cover in the tertiary hospital, of which there are only four interns.
4:31 Speaker 06 All of us have only done six months prior and we're all fresh out of college, maybe twenty-three, twenty-four, twenty-five. We each cover in the region about a hundred and eighty patients each with one senior doctor to call upon for assistance as we go through the night. Now, usually you would get a scattering of sleep here or there of a few hours and maybe hold each other's pagers. This particular night in question, that was not going to be one of those cases. We were dealing with sick patients across the hospital and in my particular area that I was looking after, I know offhand I was dealing with a patient who was having an acute stroke on the middle of the ward, as well as a patient who was bleeding post-operatively
5:14 Speaker 06 on the ward and trying to get them back to theatre for emergency surgery. Jobs kept creeping up as we went through the night and they did not stop. But then we were getting to six thirty in the morning and I was then starting to get set for the next ward round which my team were getting prepared for. And it's at that point that I'd been notified that we have a sick doctor on and I'm going to be required to stay. And my boss has asked me to stay and conduct surgery with him. Now, bear in mind, I'm not a surgeon and I'm working under complete supervision of very senior surgeons at the time. I'm not putting any patient within risk because I'm simply holding a retractor. I'm not doing anything that's going to be compromising them.
5:57 Speaker 06 It is simply to be able to hold something in theatre and provide that extra bit of support so the surgeon and their assistant can do their work, under full supervision at that time. I finish and wrapped up about eleven thirty in the morning, I'm excused, at which point I've probably been awake for about twenty nine hours and scatterings of sleep here or there. I make the decision to drive home and nobody forced me to make this decision, I took that completely on myself. And as I'm driving down the Grand Canal in Dublin, I fall asleep at the wheel and I wake up with a jolt and I've put my car into the back of a large Dublin bus.
6:37 Speaker 06 I get out of the car, I'm looking at the smashed windscreen, completely obliterated bonnet and smoke coming off the engine, I'm shaking. I'm uninjured but really fraught with anxiety and just fear of what's happened. I call my dad, who's been a fantastic wealth of, uh, wealth of advice and support for me over the years, who helps me to navigate the situation in relation to getting insurance, calling retrieval authorities etcetera to get cars off the road. Um, he slowly makes his way to come and see me on the Grand Canal dock and as traffic starts to move on, we get the, um, the daggered looks of the frustrated drivers whose days
7:19 Speaker 06 have been interrupted by my, um, my accident. Um, but my dad has said he'd been a wealth of advice over the years, says to me, he's like, this has been a very valuable learning curve for you and you've gone through it without anybody being injured. And for me, that was what was really interesting was because now as I reflect back on that, my life could have taken a very different turn. Um, not only was I uninjured, but I did not injure anybody else. And it's something that, it really does strike fear in me that I didn't only put myself in a position of danger, but I put others in danger. And it only cost me the price of my car, not the cost of someone's life or my own
7:59 Speaker 06 life and leaving a family, potentially having an injured family member or even my own family, um, where they would have to deal with my death because of a decision I made. But in reality, I was far too fatigued to make that decision correctly. And as I said, no one forced me to do this, this was something that I did on my own. And it's something I reflect on every day as I go to work, whether I'm making sure that I am not in a position where I can make an error like that again.
9:12 Speaker 00 That is just a terrifying and very relatable story. And I'm glad that you were OK. I'm glad everything turned out OK. And just thank you very much for sharing this story with us. Yeah, thank you. We're so glad, like you said, that the accident wasn't worse than it was. And we really appreciate you sharing it with everybody here today. I think it's something that unfortunately a lot of us can probably relate to. So thank you so much.
9:35 Speaker 06 Thank you for having me. Thank you all.
9:41 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Erin Welsh. And I'm Erin Omen Upday. And this is This Podcast Will Kill You. And we are coming to you live with our very first recorded live episode from Perth, Australia, the lovely Perth. And we're here at the 2024 AIOH Annual Scientific Conference and Exhibition. And we are just thrilled to be here. We really are. Thank you all so much for having us. A huge thank you to Zach and Kelly and David and everybody who helped organize this conference. We are truly honored to be up here today, speaking with you all. Really? And in light of the fact that we are at the annual meeting of the Australian Institute of Occupational Hygienists, and we just flew across 1 million time zones to get here, not an exaggeration,
10:26 Speaker 00 we decided to focus on a topic that is of central importance to pretty much every industry, and that is fatigue, specifically fatigue caused by disruption in our circadian rhythms in the context of shift work. And because that...
10:41 Speaker 07 That alone is such a huge topic that there is no way that we could fit it all into a 90-minute plenary. We're not going to make you sit here for 100 hours, don't worry. We're going to take you through just a few parts of that. So first, I'm going to focus on what do we mean by fatigue? How do we define that and what does that actually mean? How are circadian rhythms actually work? And how disruption in circadian rhythms can lead to symptoms like fatigue, excessive daytime sleepiness, and so many other chronic health conditions.
11:11 Speaker 00 And then I'll get into how our understanding of circadian rhythms has evolved over time, the changes that led to shift work becoming as widespread as it is today, and how we came to recognize those negative effects of shift work. And then, we're going to bring on a subject matter expert, Dr. Ian Duneckin, who will share some of the current exciting research that's going on on circadian rhythms, and how to combat the negative effects of things like shift work and jet lag.
11:39 Speaker 07 Yes. But first, no episode of our podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, would be complete without a beverage that we call a Quarantini, or in our case, a Placebarita, because we don't have any alcoholic spirits in it.
11:52 Speaker 00 Nope.
11:53 Speaker 07 But we are drinking one today. Erin, what are we drinking today?
11:57 Speaker 00 We're drinking Tik Tok You Don't Stop.
12:00 Speaker 07 Get it?
12:01 Speaker 00 Because it's like a clock.
12:02 Speaker 07 Yeah. It'll be funny eventually.
12:05 Speaker 00 We love to explain jokes so that they're not funny anymore.
12:07 Speaker 07 But what is in Tik Tok You Don't Stop, Erin?
12:11 Speaker 00 It's a delicious beverage consisting of one ingredient, which is Australian ginger beer, so.
12:17 Speaker 07 Thank you.
12:18 Speaker 00 It's delicious. And also easily modified. You can add whatever spirit you would like, or just leave it with a little bit of lime in there. Delicious.
12:26 Speaker 07 Yeah, sorry. We should have really had the foresight to make a drink for everyone, like, under your seats, you can find.
12:31 Speaker 00 Oh, my gosh. That would have been really fun.
12:32 Speaker 07 Very Oprah of us.
12:33 Speaker 00 Cheers.
12:34 Speaker 07 Cheers.
12:36 Speaker 07 To you all. Okay. Now, drinks are drunk. Shall we? We'll get into the biology of our circadian rhythm? I can't wait. Yeah, tell me all about it. It's gonna be fun.
12:48 Speaker 01 This is Jason Timp from Hoops Tonight with Jason Timp. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which can mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
13:20 Speaker 03 So, everyone on board? Yeah, I think so. You can't see it, but everyone in this room is nodding. They all agree the launch plan's perfect, but Julie has an idea how it can be even better. So she asks Copilot Cowork to help her overnight.
13:30 Speaker 00 Hey, Copilot. Gather the past three months of retail sales reports, surface key insights, and build a deck outlining a partner strategy by tomorrow morning.
13:42 Speaker 00 Morning, team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check Slide 4.
13:45 Speaker 03 Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot, work lives on.
13:50 Speaker 05 Network freedom and flexibility, that's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to bill Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
14:31 Speaker 07 So we decided to do this talk today on fatigue, because it's kind of this universal experience that also happens to be an occupational hazard in so many different industries. Everyone has, at some point, been fatigued, experienced fatigue. But when we talk about this idea, what do we actually mean? Like, how do we define fatigue?
14:53 Speaker 00 Right, it's super easy to define, right?
14:55 Speaker 07 Yeah, right. There's not a definition. There is not a single definition of fatigue, but there are a lot of different definitions. Most of them use a lot of synonyms, things like tiredness or exhaustion. Most of the definitions include something like the decreased ability to function at your normal capacity, or some kind of decreased capacity for mental or physical work.
15:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
15:19 Speaker 07 So, overall, we're looking at fatigue as this generalized lack of energy that overall has some kind of impairment on your ability to function, be that your physical function or your cognitive function.
15:30 Speaker 00 All right.
15:30 Speaker 07 Makes sense?
15:31 Speaker 00 Okay, I'm following.
15:32 Speaker 07 But in that definition, what's important about it is that we then have to intentionally separate fatigue from sleepiness.
15:38 Speaker 00 Right.
15:39 Speaker 07 Right?
15:39 Speaker 00 And how does one do that?
15:41 Speaker 07 How does one do that? By defining sleepiness.
15:44 Speaker 00 Okay, more definitions.
15:46 Speaker 07 More definitions. So we can do this by defining sleepiness as directly related to the physiologic phenomenon that is the act of falling asleep.
15:54 Speaker 00 Okay.
15:55 Speaker 07 Because that means that it's something that we can measure, okay? At least to a better degree than we can fatigue, which is so nebulous.
16:02 Speaker 00 Right.
16:03 Speaker 07 And we do this, we can measure sleepiness with a couple of different tests. There's one called the Multiple Sleep Latency Test, which is, I'm gonna put you in a dark room and you're gonna lay down and fall asleep. How long does it take you?
16:14 Speaker 00 Wow, okay.
16:15 Speaker 07 Sounds not stressful at all, right?
16:18 Speaker 07 And then there's also the maintenance of wakefulness test, which is how long can you stay awake if we sit you in a dark room and ask you to not sleep?
16:26 Speaker 00 Sit you, we have to be sitting for this one?
16:27 Speaker 07 Just sitting with your thoughts in a dark room.
16:30 Speaker 00 No, I don't like that idea.
16:32 Speaker 07 Now, sleepiness itself, like falling asleep, it's not a bad thing inherently. We have to sleep. It is required of all humans. And as humans are diurnal species, we have evolved to sleep at night when it is dark and be awake when it is light. So being sleepy at nighttime itself is not a bad thing. But if that sleepiness is happening when we shouldn't be asleep, then it can lead to what's called excessive daytime sleepiness, or this inability to stay awake during hours when you should be awake. And that can be bad, or as we heard in our firsthand account, even downright dangerous.
17:07 Speaker 00 Yep.
17:08 Speaker 07 Both excessive sleepiness and fatigue, though they are different and these definitions are important, they're also kind of two halves of a story. And they both contribute to the kinds of accidents and workplace events like we heard about in our firsthand account. And while circadian rhythm disruptions themselves are by no means the only things that can cause excessive daytime sleepiness or fatigue, these are two of the most immediate consequences that we see from circadian dysfunction. So having a basic understanding of what our circadian rhythms are and how they work can go a really long way to understanding what happens if they get pushed out of sync. Which then can lead us to better anticipate the hazards
17:53 Speaker 07 that might be inherent to some professions, or recognize these symptoms when they start to crop up during certain phases of life. Hello newborns. Gotta love them. And then evaluating and understanding these consequences of this type of circadian disruption can help us to actually implement strategies in the future.
18:11 Speaker 00 To help mitigate some of these?
18:13 Speaker 07 Hopefully. We'll get there.
18:14 Speaker 00 Yeah. Can it be done?
18:16 Speaker 07 Can it? So then first we have to start with what really is circadian rhythm. And I think most people probably have a sense of what this means in their mind, right? It comes from the Latin circa means about, and dias or diem means day.
18:31 Speaker 00 Stole my line.
18:32 Speaker 07 Thank you.
18:34 Speaker 07 So when we talk about a circadian rhythm, we're talking about cycles that are happening in our bodies on an about 24-hour timeframe. And Erin, I know later you're going to talk about why we have these rhythms.
18:46 Speaker 00 Yeah.
18:47 Speaker 07 Like, from an evolutionary perspective.
18:49 Speaker 00 Yep.
18:49 Speaker 07 What are they doing for us?
18:50 Speaker 00 Important, so they're important.
18:51 Speaker 07 Are they?
18:52 Speaker 00 Let's find out.
18:53 Speaker 07 Yeah. But I'm going to focus first on how they actually work. And everyone is probably most familiar with a circadian rhythm in the context of sleep and our sleep-wake cycle. Because our sleep-wake cycle is one of the most classic examples of our circadian rhythm in action. So we can see a few different things that oscillate in our sleep-wake cycles. One of them is something like melatonin secretion. So our melatonin peaks in the couple of hours before we go to sleep, and then we'll go to sleep. Our cortisol levels will peak in the morning, right about the time that we tend to wake up. We also see oscillations in our body temperature with the lowest body temperature happening in the wee hours of the night while you're still asleep.
19:37 Speaker 00 I just want to ask why for each one of these.
19:40 Speaker 07 I don't have great answers. But I can tell you that what these, like, the why is that these processes together are what are driving our drive for wakefulness.
19:51 Speaker 00 Okay.
19:52 Speaker 07 And our pressure for sleep.
19:54 Speaker 00 Okay.
19:54 Speaker 07 So these three things, they're not the only things that are involved in what's literally keeping us awake during the day and telling our bodies we need to go to sleep at night. But these are three of the big drivers of that drive for wakefulness that happens during the day.
20:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
20:07 Speaker 07 And that pressure for sleep that happens through, like, towards the night.
20:10 Speaker 00 But what's the deal with temperature?
20:12 Speaker 07 Oh, I don't know, Erin.
20:13 Speaker 00 And also, what is that? So the body temperature changes, by how many degrees?
20:18 Speaker 07 I knew you were going to ask that, and I meant to, like, look it up again to try and get a... I don't know. I don't know the answer to that.
20:24 Speaker 00 Not like 20, it's just a few.
20:26 Speaker 07 No, yes. Like, proportions of a degree.
20:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, okay, okay.
20:30 Speaker 07 Little changes. But it's enough that it sort of, in that period when we're close to waking up, that drop in temperature is what helps our bodies stay asleep, essentially.
20:40 Speaker 00 Ah, okay.
20:41 Speaker 07 Like, it's colder, stay asleep, etc., right?
20:43 Speaker 00 Okay, all right. Explains why I don't sleep well when I have that heavy cough.
20:47 Speaker 07 If it's too hot, yeah. We're going off track.
20:49 Speaker 00 Yep.
20:49 Speaker 07 So as humans, because we're diurnal, we see these particular cycles, again, on this 24-hour clock, where sleep is happening at dark and awake time is happening during the light.
20:59 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
21:00 Speaker 07 So this is what we all think of when we think of circadian rhythm. But it is not just this. Our circadian rhythm, like literally every single function and process in our bodies, from the cellular level, like the genes that are controlling which cells are going to divide when, the genes that are controlling DNA repair, does it happen, in what cells, and when? Things like our immune system, our metabolism, our hunger cues, our bowel movements, our libidos. Every function in our body is controlled, to one degree or another, by circadian processes.
21:35 Speaker 00 It's like the ultimate, "But wait, there's more." It's not just sleep-wake. It's everything.
21:40 Speaker 07 Everything. And these all are our circadian rhythms. It's not just sleep, but sleep is a big part of our circadian rhythm. And these circadian rhythms are recognized internally in our bodies by what's called an intrinsic circadian clock. But not just one clock. We have multiple clocks. We have a main clock in the part of our brain that's called the suprachiasmatic nucleus.
22:06 Speaker 00 I'm really glad that you pronounce this, because I just wrote "SCN" over and over again. I don't even know if I talk about "SCN," but no.
22:13 Speaker 07 Now you know.
22:14 Speaker 00 Now I know how to pronounce it.
22:15 Speaker 07 The "SCN," or the suprachiasmatic nucleus. And this region in our brain functions as like a master regulator of our internal clock. But all of our peripheral cells and tissues, they all have clocks of their own. And together, all these clocks drive our many, many circadian rhythms, in large part by the buildup and then the breakdown of specific proteins whose literal job it is to be made, build up, and then break down on a 24-hour cycle, to keep these clocks all in sync with each other.
22:49 Speaker 00 Okay.
22:50 Speaker 07 Does that make sense?
22:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:51 Speaker 07 It's like, pretty basic, right?
22:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's super easy. I'm sure it took no time at all to figure that out.
22:56 Speaker 07 No, no, no. So that's how these circadian clocks are working on like a cellular level. And I said that these are intrinsic. And we know that these are intrinsic because these cycles will persist on an about 24-hour basis. In humans, it's a little long. We tend to run about 24 hours and 10 minutes.
23:17 Speaker 00 I got 11 in here, 11 minutes.
23:19 Speaker 07 11 minutes. 9 to 11 is what the literature says. We can have a range.
23:24 Speaker 00 Anywhere from 9 to 11 minutes.
23:26 Speaker 07 And our clocks.
23:27 Speaker 00 And 24 hours.
23:27 Speaker 07 And 24 hours. And 11 minutes. 9 to 11. And our clocks keep doing this even if we put someone in a dark room with absolutely no external environmental cues. Like, in absence of the environment, our clocks still run. However, these environmental cues are, in fact, an essential part of our circadian rhythm. Because a lot like clocks, old-timey clocks, not new-fangled watches which work by magic is how my I watch works.
23:57 Speaker 00 Okay.
23:58 Speaker 07 Old-timey clocks, mechanical ones, you used to have to wind in order for them to keep correct time. Our circadian clocks also have to be wound in order to keep them on as close to a 24-hour cycle as possible. And this happens through a process called entrainment. And the environmental cues that we use for entrainment in our circadian clocks are called Zeitgäber, which is my attempt at German. And that is German for "time giver."
24:27 Speaker 00 How'd she do? Did I, anyone speak German?
24:30 Speaker 07 Not, not great, I can tell. I tried really hard. Zeitgäber. In humans, it is light, predominantly light from the sun, that acts as our number-one Zeitgäber, or time giver. And the sun, light from the sun, is detected by these specialized cells in the back of our eyeballs that project directly to that SCN, the suprachiasmatic nucleus. And that part of our brain, again, is this pacemaker that coordinates the cycles in all of the rest of our body. And they do this, they coordinate the timing of like so many different processes, right? Through direct and indirect pathways to keep us on this 24-hour cycle
25:15 Speaker 07 in sync with the sun or the light around us. Now, light is by no means our only zeitgaber. Food can be a powerful one.
25:24 Speaker 00 Okay.
25:25 Speaker 07 Especially for other mammals other than humans. We also can see exercise, social activity, other things can serve as zeitgapers. But, light is by far the primary one that our particular clocks use. Which means that although these rhythms are generated internally, they do require entrainment, mostly via light, in order for so many of our biological processes to match our environment. So, when our environment changes, like when we travel across exactly nine time zones, I counted, between California and Western Australia to come to a conference.
26:00 Speaker 00 Ten for me.
26:02 Speaker 07 Suffice to say, our internal clock no longer matches our external environment.
26:06 Speaker 00 I'm feeling okay, though, I will say.
26:08 Speaker 07 Thank you, caffeine.
26:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a big part of it.
26:11 Speaker 07 Right. And we all know this particular phenomenon very well. This is jet lag. And with jet lag, because of this discrepancy between your external environment, the timing of light exposure, and where your internal circadian clock was set before you left, you end up feeling pretty terrible, right?
26:30 Speaker 00 Not myself.
26:31 Speaker 07 Not today, right now. We feel great. But, you can end up feeling pretty terrible. You might have symptoms like a really hard time falling asleep when it's time to fall asleep. Or maybe you simply cannot keep your eyes open for like an afternoon meeting when you get to where you're going. And because, again, this maladjusted timing is affecting every body system that we have, not just sleep. It's not just being fatigued or being excessively sleepy. You might also have GI upset, mood changes, brain fog, and so much more. Now, in addition to regular old jet lag, there's also a phenomenon called social jet lag.
27:13 Speaker 07 We'll separate it.
27:14 Speaker 00 All right.
27:14 Speaker 07 And social jet lag is basically this idea that we all, as like a society at large, not us in this room here, we have all decided that our day starts at like 8:00 a.m., right? Or whatever.
27:27 Speaker 00 Sure, yeah.
27:27 Speaker 07 We can say 8. And that is when the day is supposed to start for everyone across the board. But a lot of us maybe end up relying on like our alarm clocks to wake us up on the weekdays to be able to get ready for work on time.
27:40 Speaker 00 A lot of us.
27:41 Speaker 07 A lot of us.
27:41 Speaker 00 I mean, who doesn't? That would be, that sounds amazing.
27:44 Speaker 07 Impressive. And then, when that happens, many of us might perhaps, on weekends, when our schedule permits it, sleep in later, go to bed later, stay up later. So we have this shift in what our schedule looks like between weekdays and weekends. And it turns out that different people might feel differently. Some of you might be like, "Oh yeah, I do that." And others are like, "Nah, dude, 6:00 a.m., I'm ready to go." That's because we all have different chronotypes. And a chronotype is like different natural tendencies to either sleep early or sleep late, like early bird, night owl. It's a real thing.
28:18 Speaker 00 Which are you?
28:19 Speaker 07 I'm an early bird.
28:20 Speaker 00 You're an early bird.
28:21 Speaker 07 Very early bird.
28:21 Speaker 00 And like, so what is the threshold?
28:23 Speaker 07 Oh, what a fun question.
28:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:25 Speaker 07 I don't know. I don't know.
28:27 Speaker 00 Okay.
28:27 Speaker 07 I don't know if there's like a specific thing.
28:29 Speaker 00 And can you be neither? Or can you be like a light early bird?
28:31 Speaker 07 You can be neither. You can be whatever you want to be.
28:34 Speaker 00 Okay.
28:34 Speaker 07 Are you an early bird or a night owl?
28:36 Speaker 00 I think I'm a mild early bird.
28:37 Speaker 07 A mild early bird.
28:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:38 Speaker 07 Like a not-too-early bird.
28:40 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:41 Speaker 07 I don't want the first one.
28:42 Speaker 00 No, I want like the second or third.
28:43 Speaker 07 The third one would be fine.
28:44 Speaker 00 Gloves are still left at the buffet.
28:46 Speaker 07 They should let them all gone.
28:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:49 Speaker 07 I love that. I'm an early.
28:51 Speaker 00 Like that first. Like very early?
28:52 Speaker 07 No, no, probably not.
28:54 Speaker 00 Okay.
28:54 Speaker 07 That's being moderate. Maybe I wish I was that early.
28:56 Speaker 00 Yeah.
28:56 Speaker 07 It's too much. But for people especially who veer more night owl, then they might have an especially hard time waking up for that 8:00 a.m. start every day, right? This is especially true for teenagers, and that's not just a stereotype. Teenagers, actually, we see shifts in their intrinsic circadian clocks during the teen years.
29:14 Speaker 00 And like, most teenagers, at least in the U.S., start their days at like before 7:00.
29:19 Speaker 07 Right.
29:19 Speaker 00 Which is, why do we do that? It was miserable.
29:22 Speaker 07 It wasn't my idea. And so this system of forcing these early wakings on some days and then maybe seeing a shift in what your patterns are like on the weekends, it can end up causing chronic sleep deprivation. And so that's what we see in this phenomenon of social jet lag. And that's something that a lot of us have probably experienced to one degree or another. But we also then have even more severe or persistent disruptions in our circadian cycle that can result from a more chronic forced mismatch between our environmental cues and our intrinsic clocks. And this is what we can see in shift work. So across the globe, it's estimated that anywhere between 10 and 30% of all adults in industrialized countries, which is a lot.
30:05 Speaker 00 That's a lot.
30:06 Speaker 07 Work in shift work. And often, if you work in shift work, then you might end up working outside of a traditional 8 to 5 of like a regular old job. And that might mean you're working night shifts. And night shifts, of course, are going to require a complete flip of your circadian cycle where you have to adapt to working entirely during the dark hours and being asleep during the light hours, right? But it might not just be night shift. It can also mean rotating shifts.
30:33 Speaker 00 Right.
30:34 Speaker 07 It can mean late afternoon shifts that bleed into nighttime. Or it can mean early, early morning shifts that require you to start your day before the dawn.
30:42 Speaker 00 My mom was an afternoon night shift worker, or an afternoon worker as a nurse, but she loved it because she would just lay out at the pool until 3:00 PM.
30:50 Speaker 07 Oh my god, that's hilarious.
30:51 Speaker 00 That's what she said. She was like, "I loved it." And then I would go home and have a drink at the bar.
30:54 Speaker 07 Is she a night owl?
30:55 Speaker 00 Not anymore.
30:56 Speaker 07 Maybe she was.
30:57 Speaker 00 She goes back at like 7:30, yeah.
30:58 Speaker 07 Because that would track.
31:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:01 Speaker 07 But, so, all of these scenarios, any of these scenarios can serve to end up disrupting our circadian clock because they're disrupting the typical timing of our light/dark exposure. In a lot of cases, it might be exposing our eyes and thus our brains to light essentially 24 hours a day. And while sometimes people can adjust the timing of when they're asleep and when they're awake, like, maybe they sleep just fine during the day. They like sleeping in late and then laying out in the sun, or whatever. What we do see is that the vast majority of shift workers do not show a complete shift in all of their circadian rhythms. Meaning, things like their melatonin secretion, as an example, will still happen at nighttime.
31:46 Speaker 07 And in some cases, can be up to 12 hours out of phase from when they're actually sleeping.
31:51 Speaker 00 Wow, okay, yeah.
31:53 Speaker 07 There was one paper I read that estimated that only about 25% of people who work night shift long-term actually show evidence of having a lot of these circadian rhythms actually being shifted in line with their real life.
32:06 Speaker 00 Wow.
32:07 Speaker 07 Right? It's a pretty low percentage.
32:09 Speaker 00 Okay. And this is like, continuous night shift work, not like, rotating shift work?
32:12 Speaker 07 Right.
32:13 Speaker 00 Or like, two weeks on, two weeks off?
32:14 Speaker 07 Exactly. This was in people who were like, night shift for the long-term.
32:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
32:18 Speaker 07 And so, this can, unsurprisingly, result in what's called shift work disorder. Which is a disorder that can be characterized by things like insomnia, which is difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep. Or, it might be excessive sleepiness, like falling asleep when you shouldn't be at work, or micro-napping. But it can also lead to increased irritability, it can lead to mood changes like depression or anxiety, and it overall can lead to this mental fog that can lead to increases in mistakes because of all of this fatigue and sleepiness. So, some studies suggest that working during the night alone increases the risk of workplace accidents by 40 to 100%.
32:57 Speaker 00 Whoa.
32:58 Speaker 07 Which is huge. It's a huge range, also. But it's also huge, like, very significant. And, shift work disorder alone is not that uncommon. Some papers estimate up to 27% of shift workers meet the formal definition of shift work, shift work disorder.
33:15 Speaker 00 Okay.
33:16 Speaker 07 But on a practical level, everyone who has worked shift work has probably experienced to one degree or another, this negative effects of this circadian disruption.
33:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
33:24 Speaker 07 But again, it's not just fatigue and sleepiness, at work or outside of work. Because, especially what we see with time spent working night shifts, having really significant impacts on long-term health.
33:37 Speaker 07 Shift workers are at about a 20 to 35% increased risk of breast cancer, prostate cancer, colorectal cancers, but also type 2 diabetes, coronary artery disease, and depression, and many other chronic health conditions as well.
33:53 Speaker 00 Erin, but like, what is the mechanism for that? Like, why?
33:57 Speaker 07 Yeah.
33:57 Speaker 00 What do we know about that?
33:58 Speaker 07 We don't know everything. Which is a classic one. And I will say that there has, in the literature, been some like pushback as to like, how causal is this relationship? Because a lot of these disorders also have a lot of other lifestyle factors that influence them as well.
34:16 Speaker 00 Okay.
34:16 Speaker 07 And so sometimes you might see difference in lifestyle between people who work shift work, or night shift work specifically, compared to day shift workers and things like that. But the evidence, especially for cancers in animal studies, is so significant that circadian rhythm disruption in animal studies leads to cancer formation, tumor growth. And it is such overwhelming evidence that the International Agency for Research on Cancer named night shift work a probable carcinogen all the way back in 2007.
34:48 Speaker 00 Wow.
34:48 Speaker 07 This isn't new information.
34:50 Speaker 00 No.
34:50 Speaker 07 But then if we dig even deeper on like, what is the mechanisms? We know that our circadian rhythms are affecting so much of our overall body functions. And what we see is that dis-synchrony of our sleep-wake cycles and our endogenous circadian rhythms ends up leading to things like increases in blood pressure, reduced insulin sensitivity, elevated lipid concentrations. And so all of these might put us at risk for things like diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease. There's also some evidence between like, timing of and amount of melatonin secretion and the effects on oncogenesis or cancer formation.
35:29 Speaker 00 That's interesting.
35:30 Speaker 07 Exactly. So at like a basic level, what it's thought to be is that all of these increases in risk are a result of the fact that so many of us working night shifts, our endogenous circadian rhythms do not adapt to this forced pattern of being awake at night and being asleep during the day. So it's a mismatch between our internal cycles and the environment. So that's the best answer I've got.
35:54 Speaker 00 I mean, I think that's a pretty good answer. A lot of moving parts.
35:57 Speaker 07 It is. And probably a lot of specific mechanisms that go into each of the different disorders and things like that. But on the whole, I think I've convinced you all that it's abundantly clear that our circadian rhythms are very, very integral, not just in our sleeping and our weakness and our alertness or fatigue, but also in so much of our health. So circadian rhythms are an important thing to consider in the context of a lot of our stages of life, a lot of our professions. So I have a question for you, Erin.
36:27 Speaker 00 Uh huh. Ask. Go ahead.
36:29 Speaker 07 If this thing, these things, these circadian rhythms, that seem today to be, it's so easy for us to disrupt them, to get them messed up. You just hop on a plane, just change your clocks back.
36:41 Speaker 00 Just go into a grocery store at night.
36:42 Speaker 07 Right. If it's so easy for them to get disrupted, and when they get disrupted, they can cause so much trouble, why do we have them? What do they do for us as humans or creatures? And when did we, how did we know all of this? Tell me everything.
36:58 Speaker 00 Okay. I'll tell you as much as I can tell you. Maybe not everything.
37:05 Speaker 01 This is Jonas Knox from Two Pros and a Cup of Joe. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota Ford Ability, and it starts with a great deal on an off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
37:42 Speaker 04 Morning, Carmen.
37:42 Speaker 02 Good morning.
37:43 Speaker 04 Quick question.
37:44 Speaker 02 Just one second.
37:45 Speaker 03 Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything.
37:52 Speaker 04 Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account?
37:55 Speaker 03 Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ.
38:01 Speaker 02 Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023?
38:07 Speaker 03 Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on.
38:12 Speaker 05 Network freedom and flexibility, that's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to bill Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
38:56 Speaker 00 Wherever you are, whether you're here in this room in Perth, Australia, at this conference, or you're tuning in from across the world, I want you to imagine yourself as a dot on the globe, as a pin on the map. I've marked Perth here.
39:14 Speaker 00 Now, let's rewind time. Let's say 200 million years or so, keeping that pin in its original coordinates. And I want you to picture a time lapse of the continents shifting, colliding, separating, oceans expanding and shrinking, mountains forming and crumbling. What is your pin witnessing in all of this? Has it mostly been adrift in a vast ocean? Or has it been at the center of continental action, witness to collisions and separations? Or maybe your pin has seen it all? As our time lapse comes to an end, eventually, and the continents have settled into their familiar positions,
39:57 Speaker 00 let's take a minute to marvel at the incredible dynamic changes that our planet has seen over those 200 million years, which is just a fraction of the Earth's 4.5 billion-year existence. Grasslands turned to deserts, rainforests turned to freshwater lakes, and temperature, rainfall, and atmospheric composition shifting tremendously over these millennia. Life on Earth has had to deal with a lot of change, even just over those 200 million years. But throughout those transformations, there has remained one near constant: the sun always rises and the sun always sets.
40:37 Speaker 07 I love that, so profound.
40:40 Speaker 00 And while the time between sunrise and sunset varies across latitudes and seasons, the existence of a day has always been a feature of life on Earth. So let's go back to your pin in the map, the 200 million years ago. The day you'd experience, outside of having to fight and hide from dinosaurs, is nearly identical to the one that you'll experience today, just about an hour shorter, thanks to the Earth's gradual slowdown. In a world filled with so much uncertainty, it can be reassuring to have that one constant. And this sentiment is shared across much of life on Earth. Most organisms have evolved to anticipate these daily changes.
41:22 Speaker 00 Plants, animals, fungi, algae, even cyanobacteria all possess internal clocks that control the timing of biological, physiological, and behavioral responses.
41:34 Speaker 07 I love that we see it even in bacteria. Like, it's unbelievably fascinating.
41:39 Speaker 00 It's so cool. I also love that someone looked for that.
41:41 Speaker 07 Right? They're like, "We've got to find it here." "It's not just us."
41:45 Speaker 00 It's not just us, it's everyone. Or is it?
41:49 Speaker 07 Is it?
41:50 Speaker 00 That I don't know.
41:54 Speaker 00 Rhetorical question. But these behavioral responses, or these biological responses, things like sleep, like the release of certain hormones, or like feeding that occurs at certain times of day or night. And we call these rhythms that are these responses that repeat over a roughly 24-hour period, of course, are circadian rhythms. The ubiquity of these rhythms across all, or almost all, of life, I guess I don't know what's going on in like the worms that live in the deep sea vents. Oh yeah, the vents. Whether they have circadian rhythms. They always mess things up. I don't know, they could have. They probably still do somehow. They could have something, yeah. So we'll find out. Yeah, we'll look into it. But it just speaks to how important these rhythms are. But why?
42:37 Speaker 00 Why would it be so crucial to partition our activity or our physiology across a 24-hour period? That's my question. Why does it matter? Yeah. In a word, optimization. Our external environment changes in many ways every day. Food availability, predator activity, temperature, when other members of your species are also out and about. You want to spend your energy where it counts. If you're a bird who relies on color vision for foraging, for berries, you probably want to do that during the day, when the light actually helps you pick out those colorful berries. You can see them. You can actually see them. It helps. But if you're a small prey mammal species, like this flying squirrel, maybe running
43:21 Speaker 00 around at night is your best bet to escape predators, or flying around. You also don't want to be active all the time. That would be exhausting. Our sleep is incredibly important for housekeeping tasks that our body can't do while we're running around. And circadian rhythms help us optimize how we spend our energy and when it's safe to get the rest that we need to recuperate. Anyone who has pulled an all-nighter, or who has had to run on a few stolen hours of sleep after welcoming a newborn, knows the pain of being out of sync with the world. But for the most part, we can easily recover from these one-time or short-term disruptions. But what happens when there is a constant mismatch between your Internal clock and the external environment.
44:05 Speaker 00 Well, we know from what you just told us, Erin, that it's really not great. Not good for humans at the least, not good for most, if not all, of the animals we've studied.
44:14 Speaker 07 Yeah.
44:15 Speaker 00 And decades of research have shown that it's not great for really anything. So let's take a minute to get into the story of how we came to understand these rhythms of our lives and the consequences of their disruption. Humans have recognized circadian rhythms in ourselves and other creatures for millennia. Aristotle in the 4th century BCE noted that bees slept.
44:37 Speaker 07 Bees.
44:38 Speaker 00 Bees slept.
44:39 Speaker 07 In the 4th century BCE.
44:40 Speaker 00 How cute is that?
44:41 Speaker 07 I love that. They're just cutting open hives, being like, "Oh, that one's asleep."
44:45 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, I'm sure.
44:46 Speaker 07 "Sorry for disturbing you."
44:47 Speaker 00 Tucked up like this. It's very cute.
44:49 Speaker 07 Oh, it's so cute.
44:52 Speaker 00 And around the same time, Androsphanes observed the leaves of the tamarind tree curling and uncurling over a day. The famous ancient Greek and Roman physicians Hippocrates and Galen described fevers that peaked at certain times of day. What do we think that might be?
45:07 Speaker 07 I love this. It's malaria.
45:09 Speaker 00 It's malaria.
45:10 Speaker 07 It's my favorite.
45:11 Speaker 00 Yeah. And one of the leading hypotheses for why these cyclic fevers exist is that the parasites match the circadian rhythm of their host or their mosquito vector for more likely transmission. Like, do they go into the bloodstream at certain times of day so that that's when the mosquitoes are biting? It's really fascinating.
45:28 Speaker 07 That's the part that's my favorite. Not malaria, it's horrible.
45:30 Speaker 00 Yeah. To clarify.
45:33 Speaker 07 But the fact that the parasites are like going to be active at certain times to maximize transmission, that's mind blowing.
45:40 Speaker 00 Evolution, man, it's pretty cool. But for centuries, all of these observations remained just that, observations. No one attempted to answer the question of why until the 1720s, when a French scientist by the name of Desmairan decided to take a closer look at a plant, specifically Mimosa pudica, which also goes by the adorable common name of sensitive plant.
46:06 Speaker 07 Or shy plant.
46:07 Speaker 00 Or shy plant.
46:08 Speaker 07 That's what they used to call it.
46:09 Speaker 00 And anyone who has interacted with this plant can see where it got its nickname. When you touch its delicate leaves, they fold in on themselves, like, "Ah, don't touch me." And then a few minutes later, they'll open back up, they calm back down. But it turns out that the plants also do this folding and unfolding routine throughout the day, folding up at night. De Mauroy, observing this, thought to himself, "What if?" the two words at the heart of every scientist. "What if they aren't exposed to light? Then what happens?" And so he plopped the plant into a dark cupboard and saw that it still opened and closed its leaves over that 24-hour period, even in complete darkness. And so if light wasn't driving this pattern, what was?
46:54 Speaker 00 In 1832, about 100 years after De Mauroy's experiments, Swiss botanist Auguste de Kende took this question further, placing mimosa plants under continuous light. Initially, the plants still showed their daily leaf movements, but as the days went on, de Kende watched as this pattern grew out of sync with day and night. Something internal, like an internal clock perhaps, seemed to be driving these movements, governed by a cycle slightly shorter than a day, around 22 hours compared to 24. De Kende's experiment was the first to demonstrate the concept of a free-running rhythm, where an organism's internal clock is slightly longer or shorter than a full 24-hour day,
47:39 Speaker 00 and in the absence of external cues, their rhythms will eventually decouple from that 24-hour cycle and instead be guided by their internal ones. Humans, for instance, 24 and...
47:50 Speaker 07 10 hours and 9 to 11 minutes. 9 to 11 minutes.
47:54 Speaker 00 But as it often goes, de Kende's conclusion that organisms are guided by an internal clock as opposed to responding solely due to external stimuli was not immediately embraced.
48:05 Speaker 07 Shock.
48:05 Speaker 00 Imagine that.
48:06 Speaker 07 You learn something new and not everyone believes you.
48:10 Speaker 00 The debate on whether these daily patterns were directed by internal or external forces continued basically up to the middle of the 20th century, coinciding with the peak of the nature versus nurture debate. But while nature versus nurture seemed to be only increasing in contentiousness, research on rats, plants, birds, bees, even humans demonstrated clear evidence for an internal clock.
48:36 Speaker 00 Cut off from external cues, mice and rats kept running on their wheel or sleeping right on schedule. Chickens who had been incubated at constant conditions still hatched with an innate biological rhythm. Bees demonstrated a keen sense of time and an ability to communicate that time. Bees are just an amazing example of circadian rhythms.
48:57 Speaker 07 They're so cute. And their flower timing, they're really good at it.
49:00 Speaker 00 I know, they have to like, schedule, like, have a little scheduled calendar for, oh, I need to visit this flower then, because that's when it's producing nectar.
49:06 Speaker 07 Right, they have it all in a little notebook.
49:08 Speaker 00 I just imagine getting there a little early and they're like, oh my gosh, wait, this is, where's the nectar?
49:13 Speaker 07 Yeah.
49:14 Speaker 00 Got places to be.
49:16 Speaker 07 Next one opens in five!
49:19 Speaker 00 And humans turned out to be no exception to this, as a series of cave, arctic, and underground bunker experiments demonstrated. The first of these took place in 1938, when physiologist Nathaniel Kleitman called his graduate student Bruce Richardson into his office one day, at least this is how I'm imagining how it went, and said, "Hey Bruce, can I interest you in an all-expenses-paid 32-day trip to Mammoth Cave, Kentucky, where we'll hang out in a cavern and try to adjust our bodies to a 28-hour day? The nearby hotel will take care of our gourmet meals, you can bring whatever books you'd like, I've got a deck of cards to play bridge, it'll be great."
49:58 Speaker 07 One deck of cards, 32 days.
50:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
50:01 Speaker 07 Cool.
50:02 Speaker 00 Well, that's all you need, really.
50:03 Speaker 07 Yeah, really.
50:04 Speaker 00 But bridge, just bridge?
50:05 Speaker 07 I don't even know how to play bridge.
50:06 Speaker 00 Me either. Two conditions, though: you've got to record your sleep movements and your temperature at regular intervals. Richardson said yes, I mean, who wouldn't? Like, I would do this, that sounds fun.
50:17 Speaker 07 It's also his advisor, and he's like, "Well, I can't say no."
50:21 Speaker 00 That's true.
50:22 Speaker 07 Yeah.
50:23 Speaker 00 I tried to do it with ticks, do you remember this?
50:24 Speaker 07 Nope.
50:25 Speaker 00 I was sampling in Panama and I tried to measure, see if there was like a diurnal pattern of tick abundance, and then the rainy season started at like 3 a.m. and I got rained out and I had to leave.
50:35 Speaker 07 And this is over.
50:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, it was exhausting.
50:38 Speaker 07 New experiment.
50:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, I never, I never did it again, though. Oh, well, opportunities for the future. But while the scientific conclusions drawn from this N of 2 experiment, just Kleitman and Richardson, they're a little vague, right? Richardson apparently readjusted to 28 hours, but Kleitman did not. It made quite an impact on the budding field of chronobiology, drawing the attention of journalists who sketched a story of scientific adventure, as well as researchers who wanted to try it for themselves. Like Michel Cifry, who spent two months in a cave in the Italian Alps in 1962, waking and sleeping when he felt like it. Ultimately, when he emerged, he was shocked to find that he had lost two weeks.
51:23 Speaker 00 He thought, "I'll just, it'll be exactly where I think," but no, he lost two weeks.
51:26 Speaker 07 Because he's too long.
51:27 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm. And this work helped to incite interest into the study of circadian rhythms. And by the early 1960s, the field of chronobiology was born, with one of its leaders, Franz Hallberg, introducing the term "circadian rhythm" in 1959.
51:42 Speaker 07 Love that.
51:43 Speaker 00 It seems so recent.
51:44 Speaker 07 Recent, I know, it is.
51:45 Speaker 00 Yeah. I mean, internal clock, I think, was at least from the 1800s.
51:48 Speaker 07 So it's just the term "circadian rhythm" that's more recent?
51:51 Speaker 00 Circadian rhythm.
51:52 Speaker 07 Okay.
51:53 Speaker 00 And since then, researchers examined the process of entrainment, which you described. And I was thinking about zeitgavers, again, apologies for the pronunciation, as kind of like, like right now, you're giving a talk, and you think, "Oh, I'm right on time, I'm doing great," and then someone at the back holds up like a five-minute warning, and you're like, "What?
52:10 Speaker 07 Whoops."
52:11 Speaker 00 "I'm only halfway through my presentation." I feel like that sign is a zeitgaver.
52:14 Speaker 07 Yeah, that's a good analogy, I like it.
52:17 Speaker 00 And researchers have examined the mechanistic basis of how these external signals are received by the hypothalamus, eyes, pineal gland, or by some other means. They've attempted to decipher the genetic basis of biological clocks, identifying clock genes, and observing how these genes synchronize across our body to orchestrate broad physiological and behavioral changes during a 24-hour period. They've done a lot.
52:42 Speaker 07 Yeah.
52:43 Speaker 00 A lot. And this research has been integral. To understanding what drives the rhythms of our life, why they're important, and what happens when they're disrupted. Which brings me to
52:55 Speaker 07 Dun dun dun.
52:56 Speaker 00 Shift work. Shift work has been around forever, or at least for thousands of years. Standing guard, keeping the fire lit, watching over your flock of sheep, caring for the sick or wounded. The military and certain trades have long required irregular hours, like shipbuilders who had to work with the tides, or rope makers. I found a quote by a rope maker from 1742. "We cannot make ropes when the sun shines. We begin at 8 o'clock at night and work till 8 in the morning. And sometimes we work all day if we can hold it." I don't know why. I tried to look into it, and I even asked, like, Blue Sky, and I got varied answers and some fun hypotheses. But if anyone knows or has an idea
53:39 Speaker 07 Why they have to work at night?
53:40 Speaker 00 Please reach out. Come find me. But until the late 1800s, shift work was a fairly uncommon occurrence. Then, let there be light. Specifically, electric light. In 1892, just three years after the invention of the light bulb, the first power plant in New York opened, supplying continuous power to those who could receive it. The effect on industry was immediate. Factories that had to shutter their doors shortly after the sunset or who used lanterns or gaslights for overnight work could now operate around the clock, bathed in the glow of artificial light. For the heads of industry, the benefits of around-the-clock operation were clear.
54:24 Speaker 00 Again, the word optimization comes to mind. Factories could be more efficient while maximizing production, and a 24-hour workday, broken down into shifts, became the new norm for many industries, even those that had not previously required continuous labor. Shift work was not just something to give them a leg up, but it was becoming necessary to survive the competition. It was apparent that industry was enjoying an economic boom from this increased productivity. But how were workers faring in this brave, new, well-lit world?
54:57 Speaker 07 Doing great, I'm sure.
54:58 Speaker 00 Doing wonderful. Interest in this question grew in earnest over the first couple decades of the 20th century. And a new concept term "industrial fatigue" was introduced to describe the exhaustion caused by overexertion, too-long working hours, and insufficient rest, often measured by a decline in productivity.
55:19 Speaker 07 It's all about productivity, Erin.
55:22 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, so, under this framework, human health was reimagined as or equated to the body's capacity for productivity. So, in other words, if you're sick, that means diminished output. If you're exhausted, that means more mistakes, which means diminished output. And this concern with worker health and productivity, especially when it came to industrial fatigue, led to the formation of committees, such as the Health of Munition Workers Committee in Great Britain, who sought to get a sense of the scope of the problem. One thing became clear: People working on night shift were especially prone to industrial fatigue. So I'm going to read you a quote from a 1918 report by the Health of Munition Workers Committee about night shift.
56:06 Speaker 00 "The objections to night shift may be shortly summarized as follows: Number one, it is uneconomical, owing to the higher cost of wages, lighting, and heating. Number two, supervision at night is not always so good as by day, owing to less effective lighting or to the employment of fewer or less experienced foremen. Number three, the inferiority of lighting may make work, and especially fine work, more difficult. Number four, the workers may be unable to obtain adequate sleep by day. This may be the result of the dislocation of the ordinary habits of life or of social causes, e.g. noises and disturbances, or the care of children. Workers are tempted to curtail their period of sleep through rising, to join the family
56:50 Speaker 00 midday meal, or to obtain some recreation and enjoyment. Number five, social intercourse, recreation, and amusement may be seriously interfered with. And number six, finally, it is not natural to turn the night into day and to deprive the body of the beneficial effects of sunlight." Not natural.
57:10 Speaker 07 Not natural.
57:11 Speaker 00 Not natural.
57:12 Speaker 07 They're not wrong.
57:13 Speaker 00 So as far back as 1918, people recognized the harm that night shift work could cause. But the next line in this report reveals the stark reality facing this kind of work. "Under existing conditions, night work at any rate for men and women is inevitable." And those existing conditions that are referenced in that happened to be World War I. And then they happened to be World War II. And then night shift work and shift work in general stopped being discussed as something that was an exception to the rule and slowly became the rule, a normal part of many industries. From transportation to hospitality, logistics to entertainment, round-the-clock work became a fact of life.
57:56 Speaker 00 Many countries introduced pieces of legislature that limited the harsh working conditions, especially like long and irregular hours, that had become so widespread during the late 18th and early 1900s. But shift work remained a staple of industry, growing in prevalence particularly through the mid 20th century. I can share a couple of old stats here if you'd like.
58:17 Speaker 07 Yes, please, I love stats.
58:18 Speaker 00 Okay, so these are from a 1981 symposium. "In France between 1957 and 1974, the percent of shift work across the workforce more than doubled from 10.3% to 22%."
58:31 Speaker 07 Wow.
58:32 Speaker 00 And in some industries, that percentage shot up to 50% and over.
58:35 Speaker 07 Okay.
58:36 Speaker 00 "In Great Britain, full-time night work was estimated to increase by 1% every year from the end of World War II to the late 1970s." Which 1% doesn't sound like much, but it adds up over time.
58:48 Speaker 07 Every single year, yeah, wow.
58:49 Speaker 00 The bottom line is that over the course of the 20th century, we've got more people than we ever have doing shift work. And accompanying this growth in shift work was heightened interest in its health effects on shift workers, as opposed to solely the effects that it had on accidents, injuries, or lost productivity. Partly driving this change in research interest was the growing field of chronobiology. While researchers were uncovering the physiological basis of the internal clocks that guide circadian rhythms, they were also exploring what could happen if or when those rhythms were disrupted.
59:26 Speaker 07 On purpose.
59:27 Speaker 00 Intentionally. And as you might expect, this research held great interest to both industry as well as the military. Can a person ever truly adjust and switch from diurnal to nocturnal?
59:40 Speaker 07 Spoilers? Not so much?
59:42 Speaker 00 Not so much, yeah. And if so, how long does that switch take? And how easy is it to reverse it?
59:49 Speaker 07 Right. Go back to normal.
59:50 Speaker 00 Right. Can you switch? Is it every two weeks? Is it every three weeks? Is it a month?
59:54 Speaker 07 Okay.
59:55 Speaker 00 Can it be done?
59:56 Speaker 07 Can it?
59:56 Speaker 00 Can it be done? How does shift work alter physiology of different systems in the short term? And what are some potential implications for the long term? By the 1980s and the 1990s, some of these long-term health effects of shift work were coming into focus. Digestion issues, which had long been recognized to be a part of shift work, cardiovascular disease, cancer, immune system issues, diabetes, mood disorders, and a host of social and lifestyle risk factors emerged as possible consequences of shift work, or more generally, a disrupted circadian rhythm and poor sleep. We have made great strides in our ability to evaluate the links between shift work,
1:00:37 Speaker 00 circadian rhythm, and health, from epidemiological, physiological, genetic, psychological, and sociological perspectives, all the perspectives. We've also come a long way towards understanding how we can control those risks in the workplace. But as everyone in this room, everyone listening, can attest, we've still got some ways to go to put what we've learned into practice for sustained improvement and prevention. We've recognized the negative effects of shift work for over 100 years, since it became a feature of our everyday lives. And there are some brilliant minds working on innovative solutions to address and reduce the impact of circadian rhythm disruptions at both individual and systemic levels.
1:01:21 Speaker 00 And we are so excited to have with us here today, one of those brilliant minds, Dr. Ian Dunican. Like Dr. Iliff, the provider of our firsthand account, Dr. Ian Dunican is also originally from Ireland, but moved to Perth where he completed his many degrees, including his PhD in sleep and performance, which he earned at the University of Western Australia. Dr. Dunican is the Director and Chief Advisor of Melius Consulting, a scientific consultancy undertaking research, consulting, and education. And he also hosts and produces the Sleep for Performance podcast. Fellow podcaster. On top of all of that, Dr. Dunican is also an adjunct senior research fellow at the University of Western Australia and is involved in numerous research projects related to sport, shift work, nutrition,
1:02:06 Speaker 00 safety, death, and psychology. So please join me in welcoming Dr. Dunican. Thanks so much for coming.
1:02:18 Speaker 07 We made this meme just for you.
1:02:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02:21 Speaker 06 It's the first time I ever heard my name and brilliant together, so we can retract that afterwards in the editing.
1:02:27 Speaker 00 Don't worry, we can cut.
1:02:29 Speaker 07 Thank you so much. We're really, really excited to chat with you. We're going to just pepper you with questions. Ready? So like Erin kind of has described already, we've known for a really long time that work that disrupts circadian rhythms can be pretty detrimental to human health. So if we look first from a systems perspective, what measures can organizations or companies take to help reduce the impact of shift work?
1:02:52 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's a good question. I think it's really important to take a systematic view. Many companies tend to just chase one thing and go, ooh, let's get technology. Let's look at rosters. So we always advocate a system view. And we have this paper that we published a couple of years ago in Safety and Health at Work, which has 14 elements, and it's very holistic. Some of those key elements often, obviously, include things like shifts and rosters, sleep disorders, which many people really don't focus on. I know you spoke about sleep apathy earlier on. There's over 70 recognized disorders by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine that we follow here in Australia. But typically, many companies just Administer a questionnaire like the.
1:03:32 Speaker 07 The.
1:03:32 Speaker 06 Airport sleeping. And I think that's an actual sleep disorder program when it's not. So we need to look more holistically there. Other components include educating our workforce and that's not just a few slides and induction. That's actually spending two to three hours, you know, like what you've done here today. In more detail about how to manage shift work at a personal level. Around sleep patterns, diet, nutrition, commuting to work if travel's involved as well. So these are just some of the elements that we would take in a system view as well. But another crucial aspect not to be overlooked is actually staffing. Because if we don't have enough people to do the job, we're just going to lead to more overtime. More stress on the individuals and more rework. And so it's very important at the first level that we have the staffing correct before we start trying to implement the system.
1:04:16 Speaker 06 And finally, on this point, you don't actually have to have a system that stands alone. That system could be integrated in your health, your safety or other sort of systems there in a business. So it doesn't have to be a standalone or a newly constructed system. It may exist in other ones as well.
1:04:31 Speaker 07 Okay, that makes sense.
1:04:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:04:33 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:04:34 Speaker 00 And so maybe you're lucky enough to work at one of these places that does incorporate a more holistic view of sleep and shift work. Or maybe you're not, but what can anyone do at an individual level to kind of reduce the negative impacts of shift work?
1:04:49 Speaker 06 Yeah, I think at the individual level, I think you've done a really good job today of highlighting some of the negative impacts. But what a lot of studies haven't done is looked at what is the benefit of some of the interventions? Or case control studies where people are doing something going forward. The first thing I would say to anybody undertaking shift work is keeping your own physical fitness and mental health in check is. Number one. So, you know, excessive alcohol consumption that we see, excessive nicotine, caffeine use that we see in shift workers. We need to bring that back into normal tolerable levels. When we start increasing our body weight, that's going to lead to things like sleep related breathing disorders. It's going to lead to more like generalized fatigue that you defined at the start as well. So it's really important that your own physical fitness and mental health and wellbeing is in check and in shape.
1:05:33 Speaker 06 And that's really key, I would say, for individuals. And also as well, when you are away undertaking shift work, whether it's here in Western Australia or elsewhere, like in the classic fly in, fly out. Is having a routine and that routine doesn't mean going to the pub every night and having drinks. That routine may involve some exercise, connecting with other people, family and friends back home as well. So it needs to be holistic in nature as well for the individual.
1:05:56 Speaker 07 Being healthy, you mean?
1:05:58 Speaker 06 Yes. Which is difficult when we're walking 12, 13 hour days. But you've got to make time. And I would say to people as well, don't think about going to the gym as a one or two hour exercise. Even 15 to 20 minutes of high intensity exercise can be really good for you.
1:06:09 Speaker 00 Right. And just having that routine, which is such a hard part to maintain, but it's so important.
1:06:14 Speaker 07 Especially if you're on those rotating shifts or things like that, but that makes a lot of sense. So a hot topic, hot button topic these days, why we made you this meme, is our screens, especially our personal devices, and especially the use of those at night. So I want to ask you, what do we actually know about how much these devices are disrupting our sleep or disrupting our circadian rhythms and contributing to things like fatigue? And how much of it is the light or the things that we're doing with our devices?
1:06:43 Speaker 06 So do you want the scientific answer or do you want the clickbait answer?
1:06:46 Speaker 07 I want your answer, that's what I want.
1:06:50 Speaker 06 Because I won't give you the clickbait answer. It's really interesting because we did discuss this a few weeks ago. However, over the last few days, there has been a bill introduced in Australia to ban social media.
1:06:58 Speaker 07 What?
1:06:59 Speaker 06 Yeah, so this was passed the other day, I believe. I'm not getting into politics, I'm not going, that's as far as I'll go. So if we look at electronic device use and its impact on sleep, there's two ways of looking at this. One is the subjective evidence. How do people report their feel with electronic devices? And two is the objective evidence. What's happening in laboratories with polysomnography? What's happening with actigraphy or wrist worn devices? The subjective stuff is saying, oh, this is really impacting my sleep. The objective stuff is saying, it's not. So the science and the data and the quantitative method actually is showing very little of what's out there. We're currently undertaking a systematic review and a meta-analysis. A few scientists are on that from around the world. Russell Foster, who you may know, who actually discovered the SCN, he's on that paper with
1:07:44 Speaker 06 us as well. And so what we're finding so far, self-reported stuff, very influenced, I think, by the media and the general population. I've ran two studies in athletes, no impact on to sleep. However, there's three mechanisms how electronic devices may be impacting sleep. One is the light emitting from these devices. That could be TV, iPad, social media, it could be anything, or gaming. Two, the nature of the stimulating activity. And many of us in this room do this. We get home, put the kids to bed, do our exercise, wherever it might be. Then we go, oh, a bit of me time. I put on Netflix, open up my laptop, do some emails. I'll check Instagram as well while I'm having a glass of wine and healthy dark chocolate. And it's always like stimulation plus alcohol plus caffeine. And then you wonder why you can't sleep.
1:08:28 Speaker 00 I wonder why.
1:08:29 Speaker 06 Well, I wonder why.
1:08:30 Speaker 07 Not a single explanation there.
1:08:31 Speaker 06 And as you've explained in your, in your review where you're on is in the, in the graph. Is when cortisol is high, melatonin can't be released. So if we're doing all this stimulating activity, we cannot release melatonin or it delays the time of melatonin. And but also as well, artificial light may have that impact, as we said. And the final thing is that we're replacing sleep time with other time.
1:08:51 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:08:52 Speaker 06 Classic example is I'll just watch one more and tonight Yellowstone is out as well.
1:08:57 Speaker 06 But the bad part about Yellowstone at the moment, which is also good, is there's not one more episode because it comes out weekly.
1:09:02 Speaker 00 That's the trick. That's why streaming services are really bad.
1:09:05 Speaker 07 Yeah. So that's what we can actually blame is Netflix.
1:09:08 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:09:08 Speaker 06 No, you can't blame Netflix, yeah. It's on Stan here in Australia anyway, so you can blame Netflix, not Stan. That's why I'm wearing my Orin Williams boots and belt today for Yellowstone. I was gonna wear a hat, but my wife said no.
1:09:22 Speaker 06 I recently bought an Isacobra. So it's, it's those three mechanisms, the light, the type of activity, and then replacing sleep time. But so far, we are not seeing a definitive link. Couple of weeks ago, we had the Australasian Sleep Association Conference in the Gold Coast. And even a massive study looking at body motion cameras with kids, no result, no impact on sleep.
1:09:41 Speaker 00 Wow.
1:09:42 Speaker 07 It's so interesting because all of the like recommendations are still like no screen time, one hour, two hours before bed. Even like all the sleep, you know, organizations still like recommend that blanket statement, which is so interesting.
1:09:54 Speaker 06 But it's not definitive. But I would say to people is if you're having trouble sleeping, shift work disorder, sleep onset insomnia, trouble winding down. Eliminate that activity before bed.
1:10:04 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:10:04 Speaker 06 Lessen that light. And just basically use that time to basically just wind down and calm down.
1:10:10 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:10:10 Speaker 06 Which probably leads in to the recommendations on light.
1:10:13 Speaker 07 Yep.
1:10:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:10:14 Speaker 06 This is something that we're really seeing now.
1:10:16 Speaker 07 Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. That makes a lot of sense.
1:10:18 Speaker 00 And so this may or may not be a question of personal interest, seeing as we just traveled across nine and 10 time zones.
1:10:26 Speaker 07 Four million time zones.
1:10:27 Speaker 00 This is what it feels like sometimes. But what can we do to minimize or escape the effects of jet lag? Like, are there any tips or tricks? Or are we all just doomed to be sleep deprived and brain fog and groggy when we cross more than a couple of time zones?
1:10:43 Speaker 06 Yeah, you really are, but you can't lessen that. You can't, you can, yeah, the answer is yes. You're gonna be impacted by jet lag. There's no escaping that. There is no biohack, regardless of who you listen to on a podcast. You cannot biohack out of jet lag. And then people go, oh, it happened years ago when people came to Australia. They came on a slow-moving ship that took six weeks, so they slowly adjusted. But now we have this rapid transmuryian travel, which leads to jet lag. So you can do some pre-adaptation, like with shift work, but a lot of people can't do that because they're trying to work before they go.
1:11:11 Speaker 07 Right.
1:11:11 Speaker 06 And then you've got to really kind of use rapid adaption when you get there. And going east and west will have different effects, like switching from days to nights or nights to days in shift work. And so there's many things you can do. The number one thing I would say is light. Light is key. So for you two here today, trying to get over jet lag, this is the worst environment you could be in. Nice and dark, nice and cool, artificial light, no zeitgerber's, no time givers. It's a bit like a casino. And that's what they do in a casino. They use all those things against you to keep you in there.
1:11:41 Speaker 07 So you have no idea what time it is.
1:11:43 Speaker 06 No idea what's going on. And now at 12:00 midnight, that we are now, we've got no idea what time it is. And so that's what's happening there as well. But with that, I would say for people trying to overcome jet lag is light and natural light is key. So today, I would recommend as much natural light as possible.
1:11:59 Speaker 07 Okay.
1:11:59 Speaker 06 That's the number one mechanism you can do. So don't get off the plane and go straight to the casino. Go outside, get some fresh air and get some movement.
1:12:06 Speaker 07 Oh, I love it. We have one last question for you. It seems like a very exciting time to be working in these fields, in chronobiology, in sleep science. What are you most excited about or most hopeful for in the future of this field of research?
1:12:20 Speaker 06 I think some of the most interesting research is coming out of Flinders University in Adelaide at the moment, and it's looking at light. Now, I'm separating the word "light" from social media.
1:12:28 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:12:29 Speaker 06 And I'm looking at the impact of light on our health, like you spoke about, artificial light, people working in nighttime and so on. Sean Kane, Andrew Phillips, Angus Byrne, some of those guys there are doing some really interesting work around the long-term impact of light, and they're using the UK Biobank data to show the impact on cardiovascular disease, mortality, all of these things as well. And as you said earlier on, in this research space, still lots to do, but we know that so far that less than 3% of people can fully adapt to permanent night shifts.
1:13:00 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:13:01 Speaker 06 And that's very, very few people.
1:13:03 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:13:04 Speaker 06 But most people think they can. So you cannot biohack your way out of this. There is no free ride, and you've really displayed that today.
1:13:10 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:13:11 Speaker 06 So what I would say is that the sort of the light and the science is really key going forward. And the final part is, I think, using individual sleep tracking metrics is really key for the future, because we have to individualize this. And we're starting to look at individualizing light as well, because people have different sensitivities to light.
1:13:28 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:13:29 Speaker 06 Some people can be in a brightly lit room, go straight to sleep, other people can't.
1:13:32 Speaker 07 Yeah.
1:13:33 Speaker 06 So looking at more an individual level of sleep and wake patterns and individual light sensitivity as well is the next phase, I think, we're going to get into.
1:13:38 Speaker 07 Ooh, I can't wait.
1:13:40 Speaker 00 Fascinating, I know. I have a million more questions, but I know that we do have to wrap this up. So thank you so much for sharing your expertise with us today. That was super fun.
1:13:49 Speaker 07 Yeah, we're really excited. If everyone here also got really stoked about this and wants to learn a lot more about circadian rhythms, about shift work, we have a very long list of the sources that we used to put together this episode.
1:14:01 Speaker 00 There's another page.
1:14:02 Speaker 07 There's a lot.
1:14:03 Speaker 00 Just come and find us. And I've got a ton of sources for this, but we always shout out just a couple that we want to specifically highlight. So two in particular. One is a book by Russell Foster and Leon Kreizman titled Circadian Rhythms: A Very Short Introduction, published in 2017. And on the history of shift work side of things, there was a great 1986 paper by Gordon et al. titled The Prevalence and Health Impact of Shift Work from the American Journal of Public Health.
1:14:30 Speaker 07 And then I also had a number of sources, a couple really great overview papers about circadian rhythm that I loved. One was from The Lancet 2022 by Meyer et al. titled Circadian Rhythms and Disorders of the Timing of Sleep. And that was part of a four-part series that was also really, really great. And then another one from the New England Journal of Medicine by Alada and Bass in 2021, Circadian Rhythms in Medicine. But we had a lot. We always post them on our website, thispodcastwillkillyou.com. Under the Episodes tab, you'll be able to find this list of all of our sources.
1:15:00 Speaker 06 Can I plug my book?
1:15:01 Speaker 07 I was gonna say, please.
1:15:02 Speaker 00 Of course, please. Yeah. And your session.
1:15:04 Speaker 06 I just released a book today for preorder.
1:15:06 Speaker 07 Oh.
1:15:06 Speaker 06 And it's called, thank you very much, it's a ghostwriter. And it's called A Guide for Sleep Health and Shift Work.
1:15:16 Speaker 07 Love it.
1:15:16 Speaker 06 And it's got over 240 references in it. And it's designed for people doing shift work, organizing sleep and shift work patterns. It's available for preorder. It's up on LinkedIn. It's on our website, Mila's Consulting.
1:15:26 Speaker 07 Fantastic.
1:15:27 Speaker 06 Please go over there and do it. And tomorrow, we have a fatigue management symposium from half past one to half past two. And we'll be delving more into this with five speakers in that session.
1:15:37 Speaker 07 Excellent. That's gonna be great.
1:15:39 Speaker 00 Thank you. Well, and a big thank you again to Dr. Iliff and also you, Dr. Dunnekin, for sharing experience and expertise with us. We really appreciate it.
1:15:47 Speaker 07 Yeah. And thank you again to Zach Bentley, Kelly Pipers, David Lowry, and everybody else here at AIA. Oh, I can't say it well. And I say the H wrong, I know.
1:15:58 Speaker 00 H.
1:15:58 Speaker 07 H. No? Thank you, everyone, for inviting us and for organizing this conference. We're really, really excited to be here.
1:16:07 Speaker 00 And we've got a couple more of our usual outro episode thank yous, which is thank you to Blood Mobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes. Thank you to Leona Scolacci and Tom Breyfogle for their amazing audio mixing. Thank you to everyone at Exactly Right, and a huge thank you to our amazing listeners, including everyone here today. Thank you, thank you, thank you. And until next time, wash your hands.
1:16:30 Speaker 07 You filthy animals. I've never... Send that to people in real life. Sorry.
1:17:12 Speaker 01 This is Jason Timp from Hoops Tonight with Jason Timp. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an off-road ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which can mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places. So, everyone on board?
1:17:45 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think so.
1:17:46 Speaker 01 You can't see it, but everyone in this room is nodding. They all agree the launch plan's perfect. But Julie has an idea how it can be even better. So she asks Copilot Cowork to help her overnight.
1:17:54 Speaker 04 Hey, Copilot. Gather the past three months of retail sales reports, surface key insights, and build a deck outlining a partner strategy by tomorrow morning.
1:18:06 Speaker 04 Morning, team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check Slide 4.
1:18:09 Speaker 01 Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. Breathe in and reset with Lincoln Rejuvenate, an available multi-sensory feature in the 2027 Lincoln Navigator.
1:18:21 Speaker 05 SUV. Experience the luxurious massage, visuals and sense to help you relax in the driver's seat. It's your time for a reset. Visit Lincoln.com to learn more. Lincoln Rejuvenate does not operate unless the vehicle is in park. When the vehicle is off or if any doors open, do not use the feature in a closed garage or in other enclosed areas. See owner's manual for important operating instructions. Lincoln and Navigator are trademarks of Ford or its affiliates. All rights reserved.
Previous Special Episode: Robert Alpert, Merle Eisenberg, Lee Mordechai & Diseased Cinema Next Ep 164 Rift Valley Fever: Ruminating on ruminants Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated