Skip to content

The problem with Suno and AI music

The Vergecast

31m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

David Pierce and Terrence O'Brien discuss the rise of AI music platforms like Suno and what they mean for the music industry, artists, and listeners. They explore why platforms are pushing generative music as a streaming destination rather than just a creation tool, and why users primarily use them to make genre-transfer covers or personal diary songs. The conversation highlights the threat this technology poses to the musical middle class, session musicians, and real human artists whose work gets buried under an avalanche of AI-generated content on social media and streaming services.

  • Streaming services like Deezer and Kobuz utilize systems to flag AI-generated content and keep it out of curated playlists. 13:30
  • Spotify and Apple Music approach AI music differently, with Spotify rolling out some artist protections while Apple offers optional labeling. 14:15
  • Generative AI music tools present an existential threat to the musical middle class and touring musicians who rely on session work. 19:13

Chapters

  1. 0:02
    Intro and Podcast Overview

    Hosts introduce the episode, announce the focus on AI music and Suno, and preview the upcoming discussion.

  2. 2:00
    Creative Authenticity vs. AI Production

    Debate over whether AI-generated music can provide genuine artistic connection or merely serve as a narcissistic exercise.

  3. 3:45
    Sunrise of AI Music Platforms

    The hosts explain what Suno is, its mission to democratize music creation, and how it works via prompts.

  4. 6:00
    Ethical and Environmental Concerns

    Discussion of the ethical implications of AI training data, environmental impact, and the broader societal effects of AI music proliferation.

  5. 14:01
    Industry Impact: Streaming and Copyright Issues

    Examination of how AI music floods streaming services, the challenges for real artists, and the role of platforms like Spotify and Apple Music in addressing or enabling the problem.

  6. 19:13
    Artist Livelihoods Under Threat

    Exploration of how AI tools like Suno threaten middle‑class musicians’ income by replacing studio time and session work.

  7. 21:42
    Case Study: AI Cover of Disney Song

    Hosts analyze a viral AI cover of “Eye to Eye,” discussing fan reactions, copyright concerns, and the broader implications for music discovery on TikTok.

  8. 30:11
    Closing Thoughts and Listener Engagement

    Hosts wrap up the episode, invite listeners to share their experiences with AI music, and provide contact information for feedback.

Highlights

  • 4:12

    Democratizing Access vs Making Coversinsight

    The guest explains that Suno's CEO pitches the platform as democratizing music creation by lowering barriers, while the reality on the ground is that people mostly use it to make genre-transfer covers.

  • 8:45

    Creating Personal Art and Empathydebate

    The host and guest debate whether making personal AI songs to process grief or breakups is valid art or an exercise in narcissism that lacks the human connection of traditional music.

  • 12:46

    Threat to the Musical Middle Classinsight

    The guest explains that generative AI tools like Suno bypass studio time and session musicians, directly impacting the livelihoods of working musicians and the industry middle class.

  • 22:35

    TikTok Viral AI Cover Argumentstory

    The host shares a TikTok example where a viral AI cover of a Disney song competes with a real band's cover, sparking fierce comment-section debates between human music supporters and AI defenders.

Quotes

  • “People don't enjoy making music.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:36
  • “Suno also seems to wanna be a streaming service.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:07
  • “It becomes this argument about human music versus AI music.”
    Unnamed speaker · 24:04
  • American Express Corporate 2:15–2:38
  • Midi 3:02–3:14
  • Michelob Ultra 17:46–18:08
  • LinkedIn 18:20–18:42

About this episode

AI-generated music is suddenly everywhere. On social media, music streaming services, and elsewhere, stuff made on Suno is becoming unavoidable. The Verge's Terrence O'Brien joins David to talk about where Suno came from, whether it can truly change the way we create and consume music, and how we can and should respond to AI music. We also have some thoughts on whether these songs might someday be bangers. Further reading: X admits its broken algorithm made the site feel like a ‘battleground’ | The Verge The Pixel colors might rule this year | The Verge Pixel Watch 5 leak shows off four different finishes | The Verge New York becomes the first state to enact a data center moratorium | The Verge Suno is a music copyright nightmare Suno leans into customization with v5.5 Nobody wants to tell me why they only listen to their own Suno slop Suno’s upgraded AI music generator is technically impressive, but still soulless Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed. We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
31:04

5,567 words · 9 speakers

Topics

  • Suno
  • Spotify
  • The Verge
  • Sora
  • The Vergecast
  • Deezer
  • Kobuz
  • Udio
  • Amazon
  • Meta

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated