Should You Wait for a Crash to Invest? (The Cost of Sitting in Cash)
Hosted by Andrew Giancola
- 53m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
In this episode of The Personal Finance Podcast, the host examines the common impulse to hold cash and wait for a market crash or pullback before investing. Through historical data from Charles Schwab, Citi Wealth, JP Morgan, and Vanguard, the host argues that trying to time the market is a losing battle. The research demonstrates that getting money invested immediately consistently outperforms sitting on the sidelines, even for investors who buy at the worst possible times or at all-time highs. Missing just a handful of the best market days can cut a portfolio in half, turning a decision to wait into a six-figure mistake. While cash is essential for emergencies, short-term goals, and planned expenses, holding long-term capital in cash out of fear of a downturn significantly damages long-term wealth accumulation.
- Never get caught trying to time the market because missing just a few strong days dramatically harms your total returns. 23:48
- Put your money to work immediately rather than waiting for a crash since historical studies show lump-sum investing beats dollar-cost averaging most of the time. 29:10
- Keep cash strictly for emergencies, planned spending, and short-term goals rather than as a speculative bet against market drops. 38:52
Chapters
- 0:00Episode Intro and Host Overview
Andrew Giancola introduces the podcast, the episode theme, and encourages listeners to engage via newsletter and ratings.
- 0:43Historical Evidence: Timing vs. Investing Immediately
He presents a Schwab study showing that even imperfect timing outperforms staying in cash, emphasizing the cost of missing market gains.
- 2:38Case Studies: 2020 COVID Crash and Beyond
He walks through three investor scenarios during the COVID crash to show how timing decisions affect outcomes.
- 5:22Three Options for Deploying Cash
He presents three strategies: invest immediately, dollar‑cost average over a set period, or wait indefinitely, and discusses the risks of each.
- 14:52The Cost of Waiting for Pullbacks
Using Citi Wealth data, Giancola illustrates how waiting for 5%, 10%, or 20% declines can tie up cash for months, eroding potential returns.
- 36:10When Cash Is Appropriate
Giancola outlines legitimate reasons to hold cash—debt payoff, emergency funds, and short‑term needs—while warning against speculative waiting.
- 46:03Immediate Investment Value
Explains the future value of investing immediately versus waiting.
- 46:48Five-Year Wait Cost
Highlights the drastic drop in portfolio value after five years.
- 48:00Key Takeaways Overview
Introduces the main lessons from the episode.
- 49:00Missing Strong Market Days
Explains how missing a few high-growth days can hurt returns.
- 49:37Long-Term Investing Mindset
Encourages focusing on asset allocation over perfect entry points.
- 50:59Master Money Academy Promotion
Promotes the host's investment education programs.
Highlights
- 5:26
Why Waiting Feels Smartinsight
People fear watching a large portfolio drop during a crash, and constant negative financial headlines fuel the anxiety that drives them into cash.
- 8:34
Charles Schwab Timing Studydata
A study comparing investors from 2005 to 2024 showed that even the investor with terrible timing ended up with three times the wealth of someone who stayed entirely in cash.
- 22:50
The Cost of Missing Best Daysdata
JP Morgan research shows that missing just the 10 best market days over a 20-year period cuts a portfolio's ending value by more than half.
- 23:44
The Long Wait for Pullbacksdata
Citi Wealth data shows that waiting for a 5%, 10%, or 20% decline means spending anywhere from 143 to 290 trading days sitting on the sidelines in cash.
- 28:34
Lump Sum Versus Spreading Outdata
Vanguard research reveals that investing a lump sum immediately outperforms spreading the investment out over time roughly 68 percent of the time.
- 34:29
Warren Buffett's Cash Strategyinsight
Warren Buffett holds cash because Berkshire Hathaway manages massive institutional capital, which is entirely different from an individual investor's strategy.
- 46:03
The Six-Figure Cost of Waitingdata
Delaying a $100,000 investment for three to five years costs an investor hundreds of thousands of dollars in lost compounding over a multi-decade horizon.
Quotes
“When I was young and I was a young investor, I thought every single year the market was at an all time high and there was going to be some sort of pullback at some given time.”
Andrew Giancola · 1:39 “There is a recession coming, but none of us have any idea when that's going to happen.”
Andrew Giancola · 2:34 “is waiting for a better entry price worth the potential returns that you miss while you're sitting on the sidelines?”
Andrew Giancola · 4:10 “And what we have shown on this podcast time and time again, is that market timing or trying to figure out what direction the market is going to go over the short run is a fool's errand.”
Andrew Giancola · 6:55 “If you stayed fully invested, you'd have $71,750 during that timeframe, about $10,000 invested through that timeframe, okay?”
Andrew Giancola · 23:08 “If you invest the money immediately, the value after 20 years is $466,096.”
Andrew Giancola · 46:03 “So you literally cost yourself $206,000 by waiting for three years.”
Andrew Giancola · 46:40 “The cost of waiting after five years is approximately $149,000 over the course of 20 years.”
Andrew Giancola · 47:04 “The stock market is going to crash again. One day, there's going to be a recession.”
Andrew Giancola · 49:54
Sponsored segments
- Master Money 0:19–0:44
- HostingR 12:15–13:03
- Whatnot 13:12–13:53
- Indeed 25:51–27:00
- Leesa 27:25–28:08
- Monarch 36:33–37:39
- PolicyGenius 37:56–38:52
- Master Money Academy 51:02–51:38
- McDonald's 53:11–53:24
About this episode
“I’m waiting for a pullback” is one of the most common things Andrew hears from investors, and this episode puts that instinct up against decades of data. He walks through research from Schwab, JP Morgan, Vanguard, Dimensional, and Citi, plus several case studies showing what actually happens to the person who sits in cash waiting for a better entry price. 👉 Want personalized help from Andrew? Join Master Money Academy at https://www.skool.com/mastermoneyacademy/about 👉 Join Andrew’s FREE Investing for Beginners Masterclass: https://event.webinarjam.com/q05p7/register/0o8z9io?webinar_id=21 👉 Live Call Registration Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeqIw5xncfn5tZbGG_U22iZ3BUmyHe9fPvBQaC1vW_x1D7bJA/viewform 👉 One-on-One Coaching Application Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/12UHo5Zmu1AyY_G4Gmbrcx9vThIZhxqFnaJ5dIihZL24/edit What You'll Learn in This Episode The five decisions you have to get right for market timing to actually work What the Schwab study found when comparing perfect timing, worst timing, and staying in cash How long investors historically waited for a 5%, 10%, or 20% pullback Why investing at all-time highs has produced competitive returns, not worse ones What missing just the ten best days does to a twenty-year portfolio Whether to invest a lump sum all at once or spread it out, according to Vanguard The legitimate reasons to hold cash, and the reasons that quietly cost you The price tag on waiting one, three, or five years before investing Start Here Join the community built to help you master your money, stay accountable, and reach financial freedom. 👉 Try Master Money Academy FREE for 7 days today! https://mastermoney.co/join/ 👉 Join Andrew’s FREE Investing for Beginners Masterclass https://event.webinarjam.com/q05p7/register/0o8z9io?webinar_id=21 👉 Join The Master Money Newsletter where you will become smarter with your money in 5 minutes or less per week Here! https://expert-hustler-605.ck.page/6aa7bb9a79 Partner Deals Hostinger → Build your website step by step at https://www.hostinger.com/ and use code PFP for 10% off Indeed → Get a $75 sponsored job credit at https://www.indeed.com/podcast Wayfair → Shop thousands of products for every style and budget at https://www.wayfair.com/ Leesa → Get up to 30% off mattresses plus an extra $50 off with promo code PFP at https://www.leesa.com/ Policygenius → Compare life insurance quotes for free at https://www.policygenius.com/ Monarch Money → The all-in-one financial tool + Get 50% Off at http://www.monarch.com/PFP DeleteMe → 20% off with code PFP https://joindeleteme.com/PFP20/ Resource/s Car Insurance https://secure.money.com/pr/gc43ce394da5 Best HYSA https://secure.money.com/pr/r453ecf4d190 Stock Brokerage Accounts https://secure.money.com/pr/v8d06f8de92c Best IRAs https://secure.money.com/pr/oe09b73d1952 Favorite Travel Credit Cards https://milevalue.com/best-credit-cards/?aff=mastermoney Studies Mentioned Schwab, Does Market Timing Work? https://www.schwab.com/learn/story/does-market-timing-work Citi Wealth Investment Lab, via TheStreet https://www.thestreet.com/investing/stocks/citis-data-could-change-how-you-invest-at-sp-500-highs Dimensional, Why a Stock Peak Isn’t a Cliff https://my.dimensional.com/chmedia/339626/source/why-a-stock-peak-isnt-a-cliff.pdf J. P. Morgan Guide to Retirement https://am.jpmorgan.com/us/en/asset-management/adv/insights/retirement-insights/guide-to-retirement/ Vanguard, Cost Averaging https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/dam/corp/research/pdf/cost_averaging_invest_now_or_temporarily_hold_your_cash.pdf Episode/s Mentioned The 1-3-6 Method For Building & Managing Your Emergency Fund https://youtu.be/rGdII_Z0hnw How to Never Worry About Money Again with Jesse Mecham https://youtu.be/_Zrin_NvjpY Watch Next Should You Cancel Whole Life Insurance? Investing After 50 & More https://youtu.be/pCU3H_xGR4Q The American Dream Now Costs $5.3 Million https://youtu.be/_p2aFDeMKTs What Happens if I Stop Investing for a Year? https://youtu.be/ihcTkAFwY00 18 SCARY Money Statistics in 2026! https://youtu.be/Jf8KjPwSTEA Do You Think You'll ACTUALLY Be Able to Retire? https://youtu.be/oT_mCCD9MpI Connect with Andrew Instagram → https://bit.ly/Skool-Instagram TikTok → https://bit.ly/Skool-TikTok Facebook → https://bit.ly/Skool-Facebook Podcast → https://bit.ly/Skool-Podcast Youtube → bit.ly/Skool-Youtube Newsletter → https://bit.ly/Skool-Newsletter Website → https://mastermoney.co X → https://x.com/mastermoneyco LinkedIn → https://www.linkedin.com/in/andrew-giancola-45027b340 Question for you: What percentage drop would it take before you actually hit buy? Name your number. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
10,462 words · 2 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Schwab
- Vanguard
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated