Eye Opening Encounters: The Moth Radio Hour

If you've been moved by a story this year, text 'GIVE25' to 78679 to make a donation to The Moth today. In this hour, stories of chance meetings, unexpected connections, and pleasant surprises—at Macy's, while camping, and in a graveyard. This episode is hosted by Moth Director Michelle Jalowski. The Moth Radio Hour is produced by The Moth and Jay Allison of Atlantic Public Media. Storytellers: Mandy Gardner learns an important lesson in a graveyard. Caroline Brennan learns a family secret. Bryan Kett attempts to recharge on a camping trip. Shania Russell comes to appreciate having a younger sibling. Connie Shin approaches a significant birthday. Podcast # 953

• 0:13Speaker 00

  This is The Moth Radio Hour. I'm your host, Michelle Jalowski. In this hour, stories of eye-opening encounters. I always feel like there's a special kind of magic that happens when a random encounter with a stranger, or a chance conversation, has the power to shift my whole perspective. It's so easy to live in an echo chamber, especially these days, and honestly, I love a reminder that I'm not always right, or that things can be different than they initially seemed to me. All the storytellers in this hour have the opportunity to shift their perspectives in ways big and small, and they take it. Our first story comes from one of our open-mic story slams in Asheville, where we partnered with Blue Ridge Public Radio.

• 0:56Speaker 00

  Live from the Gray Eagle in North Carolina, here's Mandy Gardner.

• 1:00Speaker 01

  So I'm walking through the cemetery, and I have been for quite some time. I just assumed that there would be a sign that would point me to where she lay. She was a Pulitzer Prize-winning poet, but I found signs that pointed the way to Eugene O'Neill, but no Anne Sexton. And I'd been walking around the cemetery for quite some time. When I finally found a little guard shack, it was actually a little visitor's center,

• 1:41Speaker 01

  but it was closed, because it was Sunday, and the cemetery was mostly shut down that day. But I walked around the outside of the building. I had traveled all the way to Boston from my home in Atlanta, and I really wanted to pay my respects, but I just couldn't find her. So I came upon the office, and I found a door that was propped open by a mop bucket.

• 2:09Speaker 01

  And I am not the kind of person who just breaks into places. I'd never done this before, but I'm staring at this mop bucket and I'm thinking about why I'm there. And why I'm there is because when I was in high school in the early 1990s in South Carolina, they didn't have a law that was the, you know, about not talking about gay people or the existence of queer or trans people. They just didn't. And the school board in my town actually banned the book The Grapes of Wrath because it took the name of the Lord in vain. So you can imagine, there were no queer stories told at all.

• 2:53Speaker 01

  So when I was 15 years old and starting to realize that this was my life, I thought it was a, I thought it was, it meant that I was gonna be lonely for the rest of my life and then probably hell awaited me on the other side of that because I had no other stories that told me anything different. So like many other queer and trans kids, I had to go looking for my own stories that would give me some sort of glimmer of what my future life might be like. And Anne Sexton, who was not queer, she was a married lady, but she wrote poems about lesbian desire, about love.

• 3:36Speaker 01

  She wrote a poem called "Song for a Lady" and put it in a book entitled "Love Poems." And that little poem, that little scratch of a poem was so beautiful and it gave me a little glimpse of intimacy, of actual happiness that I could aspire to one day. So yeah, in my early twenties, when I had the opportunity and the money, I went to Boston and I went to go visit her grave, but I could not find her. So yeah, I stepped over that mop bucket and I went inside that little office and I, luckily, no alarms went off and I found a guidebook and I stole it.

• 4:20Speaker 01

  And I ran outside and there was a map in there and it told me how to get there. So I get to the grave and I'm disappointed again because, well, she committed suicide in 1974, which was one year before I was born, and her husband had apparently, I mean, she was a confessional poet. She wrote about all kinds of taboo subjects. So, you know, he had not put a line of her poetry on her grave. It's her name and her date of birth and death, and that is it. I recited some of her poetry and smoked a cigarette as this kind of burnt offering

• 4:57Speaker 01

  to her, and then I was leaving. And just as I was leaving, an old sedan pulled up with four teenage boys inside of it, and I immediately got tense because I got bullied a lot by teenage boys, and that's just a reaction that I still have. But the driver, he jumped out of the car, which made me a little more alarmed. I thought I was about to, you know, get mugged or gay bashed. I wasn't sure which. But he just said, "Do you know the way to the Sacco and Van Zetti's grave? We're here for a class project."

• 5:36Speaker 01

  And I remembered that in this group, I was the thief. And I gave him the guidebook I had stolen in pennants.

• 5:47Speaker 01

  And then he said, "Who are you here to see?" And anticipating a blank stare in response, I said, "Ann Sexton?" And he said, "Ann Sexton? Is she here?" He turns to the boys in the car, "Hey, guys, you remember those Ann Sexton poems we read in English class? Ann Sexton. I fucking love her."

• 6:21Speaker 01

  And I remembered, one of my favorite lines of Anne Sexton's poetry is, "Live or die, just don't poison everything."

• 6:34Speaker 01

  And I left there, and I vowed to myself that I would always tell my story every opportunity that I got, because you never know whose life you might save, and you might even change the world.

• 6:56Speaker 00

  Mandy Gardner lives with her wife Bailey in Asheville, North Carolina. She's the Associate Director of Marketing at an impact investment firm, and she's proud to be a multi-story slam-winning teller who has competed in two Moth grand slams in Asheville.

• 7:12Speaker 00

  I asked Mandy if her relationship to teenage boys has changed in the intervening 24 years since this story took place. She told me she realized she wasn't afraid of teenage boys at all. She was afraid of bullies. She said, "And now I understand that bullies are not born, they are cultivated."

• 7:42Speaker 00

  Our next story comes from an open-mic story slam in Chicago, where we partner with public radio station WBEZ. Here's Caroline Brennan, live at the Moth.

• 7:59Speaker 02

  Growing up, my sisters and I would dare each other to run to the mailbox and maybe even raise the flag if we had the nerve to show we were there. And I know it doesn't sound that thrilling, but this was a no-go zone. Our mailbox was off limits to anyone but our dad, who was a career military officer. And I think, growing up, we just thought that was the norm, that only soldiers got the mail. Because our lives were dictated by rule and order and fear. And our dad was a very intimidating, towering figure. Which is why it really came out of nowhere when he was diagnosed with terminal cancer. And within three weeks, we were planning his funeral.

• 8:41Speaker 02

  So my four sisters and I were very fortunate enough to be able to go home to Austin, Texas, and be at his side and be able to say goodbye, which is a gift. And, um, and everything was just really new and unexpected. And so too was the revelation when our father told us from the hospice bed, all of his five girls around him, and all of us well into our 30s, that we had a brother. And he had a son in Germany, his son was German. And he had had his son, um, two years before he met my mom. And she knew about it before they got married. Of course, we looked right at her. And she, she knew, but, um, she, like him, had always kept it a secret.

• 9:23Speaker 02

  And so all I could think of, you know, we had always wanted a brother growing up. And my dad would be made fun of by his army buddies. And I would say, "Oh, Pat, you can only shoot pink. Look at all your girls." And, uh, so all I could think of was, I just have to meet him. I have to meet this guy. So, um, after the funeral, I learned that I was going to Germany for work. And so I reached out to him, to Michael. And I wrote him and I said, "I think I'm going to be in a town that's about three hours away if I train from you. Would you want to meet?" And he wrote back right away and he said, "Yes, uh, my wife and our son, who was an adult son, would love to meet you. Please stay the weekend with us." So I was dying. So we exchanged photos so we could find each other in the train station.

• 10:07Speaker 02

  And on the train ride, I was just looking at his photos. My eyes were just locked because he looked so familiar. It was just transfusing. And when I got to this train station, it was huge, an industrial city. It wasn't a cute quaint, you know, European station. It was massive, but I saw him right away. He was coming through the crowd, really, I was seeing my dad coming through the crowd and towards me. And he had this yellow rain parka and... We hugged and he said in a really thick German accent, "Welcome home." He said, "It's raining outside, but there is sunshine in my heart." And I saw this instant connection and he grabbed my bags and he walked with the same heavy gait as my dad and the same sloped shoulders, as his dad,

• 10:49Speaker 02

  and the same sloped shoulders and we went to his car and drove to his home. And at some point on the drive, he turned to me, we were both in the front seat, and he said, "I wrote you all those letters, all you girls." He said, "You never wrote back. Why?" And all I could think about was that mailbox that we could never touch. And I just said, "I am so sorry." I said, "I didn't know, we didn't know, I am just so sorry." And that whole weekend, I found myself apologizing for things I had no idea were happening and things I couldn't answer for. And over dinner the last night, he was telling me about when he learned who his real dad was. He grew up thinking his grandparents were his parents and he was 16.

• 11:33Speaker 02

  And he said, "You know, your dad, our dad and I started writing at that time." When he was 16 and he said, "I've kept all of dad's letters." He said, "Do you want to read them?" And I said, "Yes, of course I do." My dad was such a quiet man, I mean, a few words, he was only quiet or he was yelling. I mean, there was no in-between. So, the idea of my dad sitting down to handwrite letters to his secret son in Germany, it was like, "I would love to see these letters." And so, at the end of the night, as we were going up to the guest room, he handed me these binders, you know, he was a proper German. I mean, these things were so organized. So, they were in chronological order, starting like in the late 60s, early 70s. Each letter was in its own lamination, there were photos. And I was, it was like a "This is your life."

• 12:17Speaker 02

  It was like, "We're having twins," talking about me and my sister. "We're moving to Texas." And there are all of these family photos I had never seen before. You know, at some point in your life, you've seen every single childhood photo or family photo. I didn't even know, I didn't even know these photos existed. And at some point, it was like, the middle of the night, 3:00 in the morning, I started to feel that something was just off. And I was, because I was reading my dad's letters and then I would read Michael's reply and I'd flip it, read my dad's letter, Michael's reply. And at some point, I was thinking, "Well, how are Michael's letters here in this binder? They should be like in our garage in Austin, Texas." And so, the next morning, I asked Michael, I said, How do you have your own letters? I mean, shouldn't they be in the US? And he said, "Well, every time I wrote Dad,

• 13:02Speaker 02

  he would always put my letter back in his envelope and send it back to me." And he said, "I just always figured he didn't want them to be found." And I think he was right. And Michael never met our Dad. My Dad went to Germany at some point. They set a time to meet. Michael was ready. My Dad didn't show. I don't know why. I can't ask him. And my father was a wonderful father to my sisters and I, but I think in my gut, he was just afraid. And I've thought a lot about fear since meeting Michael and how it can just get in the way of connecting and of living your life. And when I left Michael's home, I had a couple of days in Berlin to walk around, and my head was just spinning. And I just kept thinking,

• 13:44Speaker 02

  "I never want fear to get in the way of living, especially in a city where people had torn down the walls to live." I just thought, "I can't let anything get in between having connection and relationships and the opportunity to just raise my flag and say, 'I am here.'" Thank you so much.

• 14:13Speaker 00

  Caroline Brennan grew up in a military family that eventually settled in Austin, Texas. And she has four sisters, including her twin. Now, she works with an international humanitarian organization where she embeds with local communities as they recover from emergencies and tell their stories to the world. After living in South Asia and East Africa and working across the Middle East, she is now based in America's Midwest. Since recording this story, Caroline and her sisters had another reunion with Michael and his family in Germany, where they discovered how much they have in common, including a shared sense of humor that translates even through language barriers. They're hoping to have a reunion with his extended family in the US soon.

• 15:05Speaker 00

  Do you have a story to tell us? You can pitch us your story by recording it right on our site, or call 877-799-MOTH. That's 877-799-6684. The best pitches are developed for Moth shows all around the world.

• 15:27Speaker 00

  Coming up next, a teacher wonders why he said yes to a student camping trip. And prom dress shopping takes a turn when The Moth Radio Hour continues.

• 15:42Speaker 03

  The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts.

• 15:50Speaker 04

  Today's episode is brought to you by Vinted. We've all got that designated chair or corner in the bedroom piled high with clothes we keep telling ourselves we'll definitely wear, but never actually do. My pile has reached critical mass, and it's past time for decisive action. Declutter or bust? Thankfully, I just learned about Vinted, a secondhand marketplace app that makes it easy to give your pre-loved fashion a second life and earn some extra cash in the process. Snapping photos and listing my pieces on Vinted can fit right into my afternoon routine without any hassle. The whole process is simple. Once an item sells, Vinted creates the prepaid shipping label for you, taking all the headache out of shipping things out. And there are no seller fees, so every bit of profit goes straight into your bank account

• 16:34Speaker 04

  instead of being eaten up by hidden costs. You can refresh your wardrobe and make room in your closet at the same time, an all-around win. Give your clothes a second life with Vinted. Download the Vinted app for free to start selling with no seller fees, so you keep everything you earn.

• 16:51Speaker 00

  You're listening to The Moth Radio Hour. I'm your host, Michelle Jelaski. In this hour, stories of eye-opening encounters. Our next story comes from Brian Kett, who shared it at an open-mic Story Slam in Denver, where we partner with public radio station KUNC. Here's Brian, live at The Moth.

• 17:12Speaker 05

  I used to teach high school science in Chicago. And at first, I was really just energized and optimistic about everything. And after a few years, I just got so burnt out. You know, I'm not really proud of that, but I was just, I never felt appreciated. No one ever thanked me for anything. I know that's not the point of education, but I was young. I was just running very low. I would buy lab materials for my classes with my own money. And then they would refuse to participate. And just say, "This is dumb, we're not doing that." And I would, I would try to make the curriculum really engaging, only for them just to call nucleic acids nucleic asses, which is pretty clever. And I would even host these after-school study sessions that they would ask for in preparation of a test. I would bring snacks, and then no one would show up.

• 17:57Speaker 05

  And then during the test, kids would raise their hands to ask ridiculous questions. A kid once asked me, this is true, once asked me, "How do you spell DNA?" And so, I was really just low, right? And I knew that I had to get away, I had to recharge. But I didn't have any money to take a trip anywhere. Spent it on lab supplies. And I told this to my coworker Shelby. And Shelby said, "Why don't you come camping with us this weekend? We're going to a state park in western Wisconsin, free trip." And I said, "I'm in, right? Time spent in the outdoors, nature, all that, this is gonna rejuvenate me." And Shelby said, "Great, we could use another chaperone." And I thought, "Well, what does that mean, Shelby?" And Shelby explained that she was taking the school's ecology club,

• 18:39Speaker 05

  which she ran, on a weekend-long camping trip, a field trip. And just for reference, the ecology club was comprised of like a dozen very intense teenagers, all of whom wore these, you've seen them, like the airbrushed animal t-shirts at all times. The pandas and the jaguars. And they did this unironically. And Shelby could kind of sense that this wasn't what I had in mind. And Shelby gave me a look. She gave me a look, it's a look that only Shelby can give. It's a very all-knowing look. And she said, "It'll really make a difference." And I was about to tell her, "I don't care." But a free trip was too good to pass up, so I said, "Okay, I'll go. But I'm not gonna help anyone. I'm gonna rejuvenate, this is my time." And she said, "That's fine."

• 19:24Speaker 05

  And so Friday, I got on a bus with like a dozen kids, many of whom are growing these very thin wispy mustaches. They were just unaware of. And about 10 minutes into the trip, they just started peppering me with questions. They would say, "Do you gamble a lot? What kind of tent do you have? Do you like animals? What's your favorite animal? Have you seen any interesting animals lately?" And it was just... It was so much, that I just said, "I'm sorry, I have to work now." And I just stared out the window for the next like... Four, five hours. Because traffic was horrible. So, we arrived at the campsite, it's pitch black. I said, "It's like 10pm." And I stick to my plan. I sit in my seat and I watch all these kids gather up their gear to go off the bus and start setting up their tents. And they all put on headlamps.

• 20:07Speaker 05

  Because of course, all these kids had headlamps. And I sat on the bus and I just watched them as they were really struggling. And I was feeling really good about my decision. Until a raindrop just hit the window. And I thought, "Okay, that's not the best. But this is gonna be fine." And a few minutes later, there were a few more raindrops. And I thought, "Okay, I'm still not gonna do anything. They should hurry." And surely thereafter, there was a little bit more rain. And I looked out, and all these kids were just kind of floundering. And I thought like, "What am I doing? Like, of course, I should go help, assist however I can." So, I got off the bus and I just started blindly sprinting from camper to camper, just helping them unfurl tent canvases and drive stakes into the ground and you get the frames together.

• 20:50Speaker 05

  And every time I got a kid's tent set up and they got inside to avoid the rain, to beat the rain, they did so without a thank you. And I set up like a dozen tents. And everyone got settled and everyone was cozy and warm. And then I went to the bus and I got my gear and I went to the far corner of the campsite. And right when I started setting up mine, the skies just opened up. And it was just torrential. And I was in the dark, I couldn't see a thing. And I was just reeling, okay? Because my hands were so wet and they were so cold. And I couldn't even like, get the tent frame together. And I just had a bit of a meltdown there by myself. I was so angry, I was angry at Shelby, I was angry at the kids, I was angry at the whole situation, with myself, for thinking that this would somehow like be restorative at all? Because I was cold and I was wet and I was tired.

• 21:34Speaker 05

  And I was like, less appreciated than ever. And as I was just like spinning out, out there in the corner by myself, in the dark, couldn't see a thing, suddenly, everything around me became illuminated. And I turned around to find a dozen kids, standing in the ring, smiling with their headlamps on. And I was just so taken aback, and they all just moved forward. And they all started working together to assemble my tents, and I just kind of watched this happen, and I looked over at Shelby, and Shelby said, this was all their idea. And so instead of, you know, staying warm and dry and everything, they had come to help, just, you know, the kindness of their hearts. And it served as such a turning point for me. It served as such an important reminder that, you know, it's not important about getting

• 22:19Speaker 05

  the thank you, that's not what matters. What matters is behaving in a way rooted in kindness and in service, regardless of the response, because you don't know how it's going to be received, right? And so that weekend, as we hiked, and we fished, and we cooked, and we laughed, we did all that, it was just so restorative. And I got a bit of my optimism back. And as we were loading up the bus on Sunday, Shelby looked at me, and she gave me this look, it's a look that only Shelby can give, maybe you've heard of it, it's an all-knowing look. And she said, "I told you so." And I said, "Told me what, Shelby?" And she said, "I told you it would make a difference." And she was absolutely right. Thanks.

• 23:04Speaker 00

  Brian Kett. Brian is a screenwriter and storyteller who splits his time between living in Los Angeles and thinking about Chicago. He likes mid-century design, fly fishing, crossword puzzles, and hearing from you. You can find out how to reach him at themoth.org. I asked Brian if he ever went on another camping trip with students again, and he said that he actually ended up going on this trip a couple of times. He said he still gets emails from former students who are now adults with families and careers of their own, who want to reconnect and share fond memories. And every time one of those emails shows up in his inbox, he is the one who is so very appreciative.

• 24:02Speaker 00

  Our next storyteller, Shania Russell, comes from the Moth's Education Program, which works with young people and educators to build community through storytelling. We met Shania in 2016, when she was at Bronx Academy of Letters High School, and she joined a Moth workshop. We loved her story, and asked if she'd like to tell it again with a little bit more direction and a few more minutes to expand it. Here's Shania, live at the Moth Ball.

• 24:31Speaker 06

  I didn't always want to be an older sister. I was a younger sister for a while. I have an older brother, and I really enjoyed the perks. But I have this vivid memory of me lying on the floor of our apartment. I'm coloring in a picture. It's vibrant, it's beautiful. I'm in the lines. I'm doing my best five-year-old drawing. I'm like Michelangelo. This is my Sistine Chapel. And I stand up to show the picture to my grandmother and my older brother. And just at that moment, the door opened, and my mother and my father walk in, and they're holding this little bundle. And everyone runs to the door to see the new baby, to see my baby sister.

• 25:16Speaker 06

  And I'm standing there with my Sistine Chapel, and no one's looking at me. And I'm like, oh, my God. This is going to be the rest of my life.

• 25:26Speaker 06

  But then this thing happens when your siblings get older, and it turns out they have personalities. And sometimes those personalities are pretty good. And they grow on you. And we spent summers together in Jamaica, making up stories, going on adventures. We read the same books. We didn't always watch the same movies, but I realized that I could bring my sister to the movies I liked and make my sister like those movies, if I tried. And even though my artistic career peaked with my five-year-old coloring, my sister turned out to be this incredible artist who could paint and draw and weave baskets and crochet blankets. And, OK, it was a little annoying,

• 26:10Speaker 06

  but it was still really cool. And just as I was realizing all this, I was graduating high school and I was moving a thousand miles away and I had this fear that I was losing my chance to be the older sister I knew I could be. I had this ridiculous fear that my sister would forget me, or worse, that I hadn't done anything worth remembering for my sister yet. But luckily around this time that I was graduating high school, my sister was graduating middle school. So middle school prom was coming up and my mom was working. And my mom was like, "Well, someone needs to go dress shopping with my sister."

• 26:52Speaker 06

  And I volunteered because I was like, "This is my chance. This is like our movie moment. I'm gonna find the perfect dress, the one that our mom would never pick because she doesn't have style and I do." And it's gonna blow my sister's mind and this is gonna be our big moment and she'll forever tell all her friends about this incredible moment with me. So I make it a big affair. We're at Macy's. We have like a hundred dollars. We're in the mall. And I'm like, "This is, this is gonna be it." And I'm running around and I'm grabbing dresses and I'm holding them up and I'm getting these like shrugs and these head shakes. And I'm like, "That's fine, I will not be thrown off.

• 27:36Speaker 06

  I'm not gonna buy the dress that gets a shrug or a head shake. I need to blow my sister's mind." So I'm running back and I'm grabbing more dresses, I'm holding them up, I'm getting shrugs, I'm getting head shakes, I'm running back, I'm getting more dresses. Around dress number fifteen, I'm realizing this isn't going so well. And I don't know what I'm doing wrong. Maybe I'm not as fashionable as I thought. But the Macy's isn't that big and we are running out of dresses. So I'm looking at my sister and I realize that my sister is looking across the aisle, not at the dresses, but at the suits and at the blazers. And I'm like, "Oh, shit. I have to, I'm doing the wrong thing."

• 28:18Speaker 06

  So I put down the dress I'm holding and I walk over and I'm like, "Do you want a suit?" And finally, I see this little glimmer in my sister's eyes and I get a nod, a nod finally. So...

• 28:33Speaker 06

  I'm thinking about it and I'm having a little dilemma because I know that our mom gave us money for a dress and our mom's expecting a dress and our mom is very traditional. And so if we don't go home with the dress, who knows what can of worms that'll open or what conversations we'll have to have. But this is still my big moment, so I get to thinking. And we run to the discount rack and we find this very simple plain dress that's like white at the top, black at the bottom. It kind of looks exactly like a suit. It almost like it was put here for us. And it costs like very little money. So I pick that up and I'm like, "How's this?" And I finally get a nod. And so then we run across the aisle to the suits and the blazers and now we're having fun.

• 29:18Speaker 06

  And we're trying on blazers and I'm like brushing off the shoulders and I'm giving all this advice that's like based on nothing where I'm like, "Oh, your shoulders can't look like that. They have to look like this." And I sound really smart, even though I'm not. And we find the perfect suit. We find the perfect blazer for... We find the perfect blazer. And then we aren't done yet because we need to accessorize. And so we start looking at pocket squares. We start looking at bow ties because my sister's really into bow ties, not regular ties. I don't know how to tie a bow tie, but I figure we'll figure that part out. So we find a bow tie that matches a handkerchief and they're like, it's they're like little blue dots. It's very decorative.

• 30:02Speaker 06

  It's very good pop of color. And we go to the register and I've been doing the math and we are a little over. But I'm in high school and I have my first debit card and I don't have a job, but I do have Christmas money. And I'm really excited to use my Christmas money. So I'm really excited when I get to pull out my wallet, pull out my debit card, slide it across, you know, like I'm in a movie. And it's like thirteen dollars. It's not that big a deal. Um.

• 30:29Speaker 06

  And so we leave and we're so excited and we go home and we're prepping for the big day. I'm watching a YouTube video on how to tie a bow tie. That is not how you tie a bow. They make it look so easy, but I didn't really figure it out, but I figured, you know, close enough. The big day comes. We have this plan where my sister goes in and then I'm like, oh no, they forgot the purse. And so I go in and I have my backpack on with the blazer and the bow tie and handkerchief. And so we're in the lobby of the like prom venue and we're putting the suit, we're putting the jacket over the dress that looks like a suit and I'm buttoning it and I'm tying the tie and I'm putting the handkerchief in. I'm not tying the tie super well. This isn't like our, this isn't like a perfect movie

• 31:13Speaker 06

  moment because the tie is crooked and that's not what a bow tie is supposed to look like. But for whatever reason, we are still having the time of our lives and I'm like beaming and he's flushed with joy and he's ready to run in. And I'm like, wait, no, I have to take pictures. So I step back and I'm snapping pictures. I'm kind of tearing up, but I'm still trying to be the cool sister. So I'm like, this is fine. And I'm like, we have to get some pictures with your friends. And then I realized I'm actually being the lame mom, so I have to stop. So I back up and I try not to cry and I watch my brother walk in. Thank you.

• 31:56Speaker 00

  Shania is a Bronx-born writer who says her love of storytelling emerged somewhere between The Very Hungry Caterpillar and Twilight. Since then, that passion has evolved from book reports and fanfiction to filmmaking and journalism. She's currently a news writer for Entertainment Weekly. I asked Shania what her relationship with her brother is like now, and she told me that her college fears didn't come true at all. Now, her brother is one of her best friends in the world, but he's way too cool and stylish to go shopping with her these days. She said it's probably time for him to return the favor and improve my sense of fashion.

• 32:35Speaker 00

  To see a photo of Shania and her brother and find out more about Shania and the other storytellers you heard in this hour, you can visit our website, themoth.org. While you're there, have you ever felt like you have a story you'd like to share? Did this hour of stories remind you of an eye-opening encounter of your own? If so, you can put just a story right on our site or call 877-799-MOTH. That's 877-799-MOTH.

• 33:06Speaker 00

  You can share these stories or others from The Moth archive and buy tickets to Moth storytelling events in your area through our website, themoth.org. There are Moth events year-round. Find a show near you and come out to tell a story. You can find us on social media, too. Just search for The Moth.

• 33:35Speaker 00

  Coming up next, a young woman goes on a long walk in search of answers when The Moth Radio Hour continues.

• 33:47Speaker 03

  The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts.

• 33:53Speaker 04

  Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it all starts with a great deal from your local Toyota dealer. Make a smart buy on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or get a Corolla sedan packed with the latest features, advanced tech, and head-turning style. Take a test drive in two of Toyota's most popular SUVs, the spacious, family-friendly Grand Highlander and adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid and plug-in hybrid models available across the lineup, plus efficient all-electrics like the BZ, BZ Woodland, and all-wheel-drive CHR, you can drive your way and skip the pump. And long after you leave the lot, your Toyota keeps delivering with legendary resale value, built on a reputation for quality and reliability. So when it's time for your next Toyota, you could trade in for more. From a great

• 34:38Speaker 04

  deal today to a great value tomorrow, a Toyota is right for you. Shop toyota.com for deals and details, or stop by your local Toyota dealer today. Toyota, let's go places.

• 34:51Speaker 00

  You're listening to The Moth Radio Hour from PRX. I'm Michelle Jelousky. Our next storyteller came to us through our community program, where we partner with local community organizations, cultural institutions, and nonprofits to teach storytelling. We first met Connie Shin at a workshop with I'll Go First, a New York-based nonprofit that uses storytelling to help people access mental health care. Over the past few years, she has told this story on Moth stages from Massachusetts to Oregon. Live at The Moth in Chicago, where we partner with public radio station WBEZ, here's Connie.

• 35:25Speaker 07

  It's 1991. I'm living in Baltimore with my mom and my dad. I'm this cute little kid with blunt bangs and I don't speak any English. Most days, I get dropped off at daycare, or I get left with my grandma, my dad's mom, because my parents, they work full-time between a laundromat and this restaurant that my dad just opened. The restaurant was called The Lunchbox.

• 36:08Speaker 07

  It was a cafeteria in downtown Baltimore, right across the street from the courthouse. I have vague memories of The Lunchbox. I've seen a lot of photos. There's this one photo of me, and in it, you can see that I'm running between the buffet stations. And right off to the side, you see my dad, and he's wearing green sweatpants, and he's grinning so big. And you can tell from this one photograph that I, as a toddler, very comfortable and at ease in this space. And you can tell from this one photograph that my dad was so proud of his place.

• 36:54Speaker 07

  On November 6, 1991, just a month after I turned three, two of my dad's teen-aged employees, along with two other people, robbed the lunchbox. And in the process of the robbery, one of them killed my dad.

• 37:13Speaker 07

  My dad's name was Myung Jin. He chose to go by Mike when he immigrated to the States when he was 25. And Mike was only 32 years old when he died.

• 37:28Speaker 07

  After my dad died, nobody talked about him. We never went to the graves. We didn't celebrate birthdays. We didn't note the passing of death anniversaries. Because my family and our community acted as if he never existed, I didn't grow up having the words to describe his absence. And it was weird growing up, knowing that there was this big thing missing in my life, but not having any language for it. I remember when I was a kid, my friends would eventually ask me, like, "Hey, where is your dad?" And I never knew what to say to them, so most times I just started to cry.

• 38:14Speaker 07

  Or other times, I would get angry at them for even asking such a thing, and I would say, "I don't have a dad." And that felt like a true statement to me, because I didn't have memories of my dad. I wanted to know things. I wish people said, "Wow, you look just like your dad. You smile like your dad. You run like your dad." But nobody ever said anything. So, I didn't say anything. And the silence went on for decades.

• 38:43Speaker 07

  But then in March of 2020, completely out of the blue, I received a phone call from the Baltimore City State Attorney's Office, informing me that the man who killed my dad was appealing his sentence, and that somebody in my family could write a victim impact statement and read it at his hearing.

• 39:06Speaker 07

  Also in 2020, I was turning thirty-two and it was messing with my head big time. I cannot wrap my head around the fact that I was turning the age my dad was when he died. I became fixated on this idea of turning thirty-two but completely dreading it. I was so obsessed with the number thirty-two that I had a friend tattoo it on me that year.

• 39:35Speaker 07

  Turning thirty-two just felt so symbolic. I mean, the same year I'm turning this age that my dad was when he died, I might meet the man who killed him. I knew I needed to do something big to acknowledge this birthday. So in October, on my actual birthday, I decided that I would walk the entire perimeter of Manhattan in one day because somebody told me it's actually thirty-two miles long. I wrote this essay and I sent it to all my friends and family explaining the significance of this birthday and I invited people to walk with me. I was floored by people's responses. My mom immediately went out and bought a pair of Hoka's and said she would walk with me.

• 40:22Speaker 07

  Some of my mom's siblings apologized to me for never talking about my dad. I had friends who, you know, didn't live in New York who said, "I'm gonna go on a thirty-two minute walk in honor of you and your dad." And I set up this tracker on Google Maps so that anyone, anywhere could see my path throughout the day.

• 40:43Speaker 07

  I started walking at seven AM from the base of Manhattan from South Ferry Station. And as I began to walk along the West Side, various people from my life started to show up. A roommate from grad school came and she walked with me for a few miles. Some cousins on my mom's side of the family came and they brought their three kids and we kicked a soccer ball through Battery Park.

• 41:07Speaker 07

  And as I continued to just cruise up the West Side Highway, more and more people started to show up. Even this guy that I recently matched with on Hinge came and walked with me for a few miles.

• 41:25Speaker 07

  And then my cousin Andrew showed up. Andrew is the son of my dad's younger brother. He's just a year younger than me, so he was almost two when my dad was killed. My uncle had told his kids that my dad had died in a car crash. And it wasn't until Andrew was in his twenties that he learned how my dad really died. I invited my uncle to do the walk, and I even finally asked him to tell me stories about my dad. And when I told him about the hearing, because I was just curious what he thought about it, all he said in an email was, "Don't say any of this to your grandma, and this guy needs to serve the remainder of his sentence."

• 42:08Speaker 07

  I wasn't surprised by his response, but it was hard to sit with, because I had started to feel differently that year. You know, in my mind, I was thinking, "My dad's been dead for nearly three decades. Why should this guy remain in prison?" And there were moments of the walk that felt equally mentally fatiguing. I remember as we were coming down Harlem River Drive, and I was thinking to myself, like, "What am I doing? Why did I tell all these people about my dad? Like, what am I trying to prove with this walk?" But even with moments of self-doubt, I couldn't stop walking.

• 42:49Speaker 07

  One, I'm a pretty competitive person, and too many people knew I was doing this walk, so I couldn't quit. And two, I was trying to make sense of my life through this walk. I had somehow linked in my mind that walking thirty-two miles would help me process my dad's death, as if every mile I walked, it would give me a year back where nobody talked about him. Doing this walk was my way of forcing the people in my life to acknowledge that he had existed. And in my mind, turning thirty-two felt like something that I could share with just my dad.

• 43:28Speaker 07

  I'd always wanted to do some sort of a legacy project in order to get to know my dad better, but I never knew what questions to ask, I didn't know what medium to use, so I chose to walk. I walked because I wanted to talk about my dad. I walked because I didn't know how to talk about my dad. And I walked because I had no idea how to write a victim impact statement. Like, what do you say about someone that you don't even know?

• 43:58Speaker 07

  And in the lead-up to the hearing and in writing this statement, it was really important for me to be able to answer two questions.

• 44:11Speaker 07

  Do I hate this person who killed my dad?

• 44:19Speaker 07

  Can I forgive the person who killed my dad?

• 44:25Speaker 07

  Is it possible within one's own soul to hate and forgive at the same time?

• 44:33Speaker 07

  And during this year, I had begun to learn just a little bit about transformative justice, and I realized that the answer to my dad's violent death is not more violence. That there's this collective responsibility that we all have to practice the things that we want to see change in this world.

• 44:54Speaker 07

  And this framework of transformative justice kind of aligned with a personal motto of mine, which is to ask myself, "What is a life well-lived?"

• 45:06Speaker 07

  Like, what did it mean for me as I was turning 32 to live a life well-lived?

• 45:14Speaker 07

  What did it mean for my dad who died at 32 to have lived a life well-lived?

• 45:22Speaker 07

  And now I couldn't help but wonder, what does it mean for this person who killed my dad to also have a life well-lived?

• 45:34Speaker 07

  The end of the walk, it got very cold, it was very dark. The people who were still walking with me, we were all kind of falling apart. One person sprained their ankle, we had moleskin for blisters. We're all hobbling towards that last mile. I'm so tired, I'm not even thinking about my dad. And in the end, we actually walked thirty-three point five miles because of construction.

• 45:58Speaker 07

  And at about ten PM, we reached the bottom of Manhattan. And some people were there to congratulate us, to celebrate my birthday.

• 46:08Speaker 07

  And the next morning, when I woke up, I remember feeling disappointed. I had thought that by doing this big, bold, brave thing, I would know myself better. I would feel closer to my dad. And through that process, I would have the words for this victim impact statement. But the walk didn't change anything.

• 46:30Speaker 07

  But now I realize that it was the start of me thinking about my life beyond thirty-two. Like, I've obviously surpassed my dad's age. And I've realized that planning a future for myself is its own form of a legacy. Like, I am my dad's legacy. My very aliveness is a testament to that legacy. Because every day, I get to live the life that he never got to.

• 46:58Speaker 07

  Couple of months after the walk, December twenty twenty, I did attend the hearing. And it was over Zoom. And there was no amount of walking or talking or thinking that could have prepared me for that experience.

• 47:12Speaker 07

  Nothing could have prepared me for the experience of being in my own home, logging onto Zoom, and just waiting for his face to appear.

• 47:21Speaker 07

  Nothing could have prepared me for the experience of hearing his voice and listening to him talk about the events that led him to kill my dad.

• 47:30Speaker 07

  Nothing could have prepared me for the experience of learning he has a daughter, and we are the same age, and we have both worked in education.

• 47:40Speaker 07

  And when his face finally did appear, I didn't know where to look. I remember thinking like, oh my God, can he see me?

• 47:51Speaker 07

  And when it was my turn, I read my statement directly to his face in his square, and I explained what it was like growing up without a father because of something he did when he was 21, and yet still believing that he should be released from prison.

• 48:06Speaker 07

  But the judge denied his appeal.

• 48:10Speaker 07

  But about a year after that, I wrote a second statement, this time to a parole board. And I explained that my feelings had not changed since the hearing, and I was still advocating that he be released from prison so that he can go home and explore what it is to live a life well-lived for him.

• 48:28Speaker 07

  And just last year, I received an online notification from the state of Maryland letting me know that he was released.

• 48:37Speaker 07

  And I think that all of this,

• 48:46Speaker 07

  this,

• 48:49Speaker 07

  I think that this honors my dad, and that is a legacy that I am very proud of. Thank you.

• 49:08Speaker 00

  Connie Shin lives in Brooklyn with her husband, aka the guy she met on Hinge.

• 49:14Speaker 00

  She loves to play euchre and do things that scare her, like telling a story at the Moth. I asked Connie how telling her story onstage has impacted her grieving process. She said, "I've learned that there is no roadmap or timeline to processing grief. I thought by doing this story that it would reach its conclusion and that the chapter would close, but I'm realizing the story keeps unfolding."

• 49:51Speaker 00

  Thank you to all the storytellers in this hour for sharing their stories of revelations and to you for listening. That's it for this episode of The Moth Radio Hour. We hope you'll join us next time, and that's the story from The Moth.

• 50:39Speaker 03

  This episode of The Moth Radio Hour was produced by me, Jay Allison, and Michelle Jalowski, who also hosted and directed the stories in the show. Co-producer is Vicky Merrick, associate producer Emily Couch. The rest of The Moth's leadership team includes Sarah Haberman, Christina Norman, Sarah Austin Jenness, Jennifer Hickson, Kate Tellers, Marina Cluce, Leigh Anne Gully, Suzanne Rust, Sarah Jane Johnson, and Patricia Uraina. Moth stories are true as remembered and affirmed by the storytellers. Our theme music is by The Drift. Other music in this hour from Quincy Jones, The Westerlys, Wolfpack, Duke Levine, and Keith Jarrett.

• 51:21Speaker 03

  We receive funding from the National Endowment for the Arts. The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. Special thanks to our friends at Odyssey, including executive producer Leah Reese Dennis. For more about our podcast, for information on pitching us your own story, and to learn all about The Moth, go to our website, themoth.org.