The Case Of
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
What’s it like prosecuting an accused murderer? Kristian and Stocky find out from someone who’s done it many times.
3,559 words · 5 speakers
ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
At the front of the room during Erin Patterson's trial are a bunch of people acting on behalf of the police and the community. And they want to put her behind bars for a very long time. They're the prosecution and in this episode, we're going to find out how they work. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
I'm Stephen Stockwell and this is Mushroom Case Daily.
Well, Stocky, as we've been talking about for months, the trial of Erin Patterson is a really, really big story. And we want to help people understand how that trial is going to work. So we've put together this short series looking at three key players in the trial. The defence team, the prosecution and the jury.
Yeah, and this episode's all about the prosecution. These are the people that are taking the evidence that's been collected and arguing that Erin Patterson should be found guilty of murder and the attempted murder charges that she's up against.
Well, we don't know exactly what's going on behind the scenes. We've spoken to Nick Pappas SC, a very experienced lawyer who knows all about what it's like to prosecute a big case.
I prosecute, I defend, I'm basically an all round criminal law barrister.
How many murder trials would you say you've sat in over the years?
Gee, it's a very hard one to put a number on, but many, many, many murder cases, including having to decide whether they were to proceed or not. And look, let's just say tens and tens of murder trials over the years.
That's decent.
Yeah, and that's why we wanted to spend some time with him. It's also handy that Nick's also been a defence barrister as well. And that's actually some of the work he's been doing in recent times. But as a prosecutor, Nick's work starts well before the trial, even before the pre-trial arguments. A prosecutor's got to get across loads of evidence and learn about the case. It's just a lot of prep work.
Yeah, it'd be these just like gigantic days, you know, like waking up in the middle of the night, thinking about what's going on and how you've got to run through that, working through pre-trial processes, figuring out what evidence, you know, will and won't be heard by the jury. And then I guess like after months and months of work, it is, it's time for the big dance.
Nick, obviously we're looking at the Aaron Patterson trial here and while you're not acting in that, could you perhaps put us in the shoes of whoever the prosecutor will be on the opening day of a trial like this where there's so much public interest, there will have been a lot of pre-trial that's dealt with, what will the prosecutor be feeling on the opening day of that trial?
Well, it's interesting, we don't know who the prosecutor is, I'm not talking about individuals, but there'd be a sense of apprehension, there'd be a sense of concern to ensure that what we say to the jury when we start the case is properly structured and correct and not too much and not too little, always focusing on the needs of justice. And so the apprehension is to ensure that we manage a fair trial. The fact that there's a glare of publicity, I think, doesn't make much difference, I think, to most of us, it certainly makes no difference to me, in that if I walk out and there's cameras outside or if there's journalists inside court, well, that's my workplace, I mean, that's just pretty much every day.
Pardon parcel.
Correct.
Often defendants don't give evidence in their own trials, but occasionally they do, and in a murder case, you could have an accused murderer taking the stand and as a prosecutor, you get the chance to cross-examine them. What's it like coming face to face with a killer?
Well, it's interesting, again, you've asked that question in a really, I won't say theatrical, but a really interesting way.
It's true though, isn't it?
Well, it's face to face, but it's your job, that's what you're there for, that's what you've trained for, that's what your reason, in terms of your professional existence is.
But on a human level, when you know what this person is accused of and...
Presumably you believe it because you're prosecuting it. Is there that element of I'm looking into the eyes of a killer and quizzing them here?
You're looking at someone who's the central player in a case where you've got to do your job so properly and so professionally that you don't want to let the system down. And personally, you want to make sure that the, I won't say the truth, because the truth is a garbled concept, but that the evidence is maintained to ensure that if there is a conviction to be had, it's had. In other words, you cross-examine the person, looking at them, knowing that they're the person who is accused of having done these things. And often you'll have plenty of evidence. There'll be CCTV or there'll be public statements or there'll be, you know, the record of interview.
There'll be all sorts of things that give you a real sense of what they've been accused of. But when you get a chance to ask them, there's a sense of heightened anticipation and adrenaline. And I won't say exhilaration, that's not the right word, but a sense of you're getting to the real nitty gritty of the case. At the same time, as the prosecutor, you don't want to ask a question that leads to a inappropriate
question being asked that might lead to, God forbid, discharge of the jury because you as the prosecutor have asked an improper question.
Or you went too far.
Correct. And so you've really got to be very, very careful in what you're doing. So, yes, you're looking at the eyes of a killer, in the sense of accused killer. But at the same time, there's so much else going on in your head that, like the duck, you're appearing to be reasonably calm about it and focused or even raising your voice or whatever you're doing in your cross-examination as the prosecutor. But underneath, your little legs are going at a million miles an hour because of the consequences of not doing your job correctly.
Are there moments you can think of from your experience as a prosecutor where, you know, there's been a witness who has said something or there's been evidence presented and your heart has just dropped?
Look, it's more common than you think. And there are times where the case can change quite dramatically when a witness says something that's unexpected. It shouldn't happen, but it does happen. And again, back to, the fact is, we're dealing with humans. Um, as the prosecutor, you should be in a position to say to yourself, well, okay, well, that's what that witness has said. Does that change my case so much? Is that an untruth? Is that somehow, um, uh, something which suggests this witness isn't prepared to tell the truth? And there's ways of dealing with it. So technically, you manage it. So you say, heart drops? Yeah, maybe that's the wrong description.
Maybe there's a sense of disappointment or a reaction to it, which leads you to then have to do something technical as a result of that. An application to cross-examine that witness as the prosecutor, because normally you're not allowed to do that. Um, uh, a reassessment of your case. If a witness drops something that happens to be fundamentally different to the case theory and how you have proceeded, then as a prosecutor, your obligation is to look at it and think about it. Have they just told the truth? If they say, no, I saw that it was Johnny who did it, not Fred, and you're prosecuting Fred, why have we just found that out today? The likelihood is because the witness is, is, is not telling the truth about Johnny,
but you can't just ignore that.
Are you crafting, though, your cross-examination with a view to leading them to a, a, a point where you'll, you'll, you'll nail them effectively at the end in front of the jury? Um, this is what we see in the movies, right? Where it happens.
Boy, can you come and help me? Cause I, I, I'm, I'm struggling to remember a case where I've nailed, uh, an accused witness. Um, look, it doesn't happen quite as simply as that, but we have to remember that these people were there and we weren't.
Have you ever got to the middle of a trial where you're arguing one side or the other and you've thought to yourself, geez, I don't really know if I believe this case that I'm arguing anymore?
Um, it, no, because I restrict my brain to not permit me to believe or not believe. My brain, uh, is completely, um, focused on me not being the decision maker. That's lucky. I mean, as I said before, I don't want to be a juror. And I'm not a judge making a decision on those facts.
But you're telling this jury that a certain person is either a criminal or they're innocent.
No, what I'm saying to a jury if I'm prosecuting it is that the evidence is sufficient to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. When I'm defending, I'm saying that the evidence isn't sufficient to prove them beyond reasonable doubt. You should have a doubt. What's a doubt? Well, that's a matter for the jury. I might have personal views that suggest to me that when I'm defending someone, this guy's going to get convicted. I might have that view. That's not my job. That's not my role and I'm not the decision maker. My job is to do my job because I want a society that's sufficiently confident that those who are accused of criminal conduct are only convicted and only go to jail if they are truly guilty. And if my guilty client gets off.
Quote unquote.
That's the cost to ensure that the innocent ones don't go to jail.
That's quite a noble way of looking at how it all works, really.
Yeah, I mean, I think you kind of have to approach it from that way, right? I mean, as journalists, we, you know, we have very high regard for the purpose of our work and it makes sense that lawyers, a similarly egotistical professional, would think of that in the same way.
Yeah, and I mean, look, it would help to keep some distance between yourself and the process. If you're going to do this job for a long time, I think it's probably something you have to do.
Absolutely, yeah. And I mean, the moment that Nick's kind of building to in a trial is just massive, right? Like, at this point, all the arguments are wrapping up and you just have to kind of sit and wait while the jury makes the decision. So kind of like, you know, thinking of this higher power or higher calling probably makes that a bit easier to manage. But I did still want to know what it was like as the kind of jury walks away.
Well, in almost every case I've ever done, when I sit down after my final address, within a couple of minutes, I think, oh. I should have said that. And that's often, you know, a frustration. And when the jury goes out at the end of it all, you do have a very critical review of your own performance and of the performance of the team. And so you might sit down and talk about it. You might like be just going to your shell and try and, you know, do something else to think about something else. In the past, of course, in the good old days, we'd go to the pub, you know.
Don't go to the pub anymore.
Oh, I don't think many people go to the pub anymore to sort of, you know, during the day anyway. I mean, it's just not the right thing to do. So there's a degree of introspection, there's a degree of self-analysis, there's a degree of anticipation. When you're for the defence, there's a high degree of anxiety and nervousness because you've been working with an individual for so long and their family and the idea that, you know, their hands, their fate is in the hands of the jurors and you don't know what the jury is thinking about is a really stressful process.
On that, when the jury walks in and they've got a verdict to deliver, what's going through your mind in that moment?
Well, as a defence counsel.
Oh, as a prosecutor.
Yeah, no, as a defence counsel, in contrast, I'm highly anxious and very concerned and my heart rate rises. And if I look at my Apple watch, I don't want to look at the numbers on there because it's pretty bad. But as a prosecutor, there's still a degree of anxiety, but personally for me, nowhere near the anxiety that I have as a defence counsel. At the end of the case, as a prosecutor, I'm happy and satisfied if I've done my job, which is not to cause any discharges of the jury because inappropriate evidence or questions are being asked.
I'm content if it's got past the end of the Crown case and it hasn't been discharged because there's insufficient evidence. And I'm happy if I've addressed the jury and put the case properly. In other words, if I've done my final address properly, compiled the evidence and presented an argument as to why the jury should convict. Now, I've convinced myself over forty years that that's my job and that my job is not to be concerned too much about the verdict. Because my job is not to seek a verdict, my job is to present the case to allow the jury to bring the verdict in. Now, of course, I'm interested in the verdict, of course I am. But my professional ethic and my professional approach is that the verdict has nothing to do with me.
But I don't like seeing people go to jail, maybe I'm just an old softie, I just, you know, deep down.
Even if they've done something terrible?
Oh, well, you know, I just, for some reason, maybe I should have been a priest or something, I just see everybody having something in them that's human. There's very few people I've been involved with in the law over the forty years who I would truly describe as evil. I have seen some and some attitude to them is quite different, but I'm glad I'm not on a jury. I'm glad I'm not a juror, never will be, because I'm disqualified. Because it's a big decision that juries make. And so as the prosecutor, I just want to make sure that whatever decision they make, it's the right decision.
One thing that we haven't touched on yet, but we'll get to now, is the families of victims are possibly pinning their hopes on you as the lead prosecutor or the prosecution team to secure justice for their loved one that may have died or may not be around or suffered some sort of crime against them. Does that sort of factor into your thinking as well, that these people are really relying on you?
It does. It factors into my thinking in a variety of ways. Firstly, thankful that there is a structure now which is a support service for the families and the victims. And secondly, acutely aware that the criminal law or the justice system is a blunt instrument and often doesn't give satisfaction to the families of a deceased. Any sentence doesn't bring back the deceased. No sentence is ever in true retributive terms adequate in people's minds. Some people see it differently, but most families find it very hard to think that their loved one was only worth 10 years or 15 years. And that's not what the system is doing. It's not putting a value on the life of the person that's died. It's applying quite different exercise in terms of sentencing.
But yes, as a prosecutor, yes, I do feel the pain and the pressure and the stress of the families and the victims' families very much.
Do you take that home with you as well, or is it something that you try to leave in the office when you go home for the night?
Clearly try and leave it behind and try and cope with it by debriefing with colleagues and so forth, but sometimes it breaks through. And I've been known a bit like a judge of the Supreme Court, the occasional tear wells in my eye during victim impact statements. And I'm open to accept that I'm just a human being and I don't ignore the victims in my mind, but they're the victims, I'm the professional, so I've just got to keep my stuff together and keep it, because they don't need to see me as a blithering mess, nor is it any good for me to suffer their stress too much. But I manage it by debriefing and talking to my colleagues and so forth. But it's a tough exercise, very tough exercise.
The jury's returned, they've delivered, you know, from acting in the sense of prosecutor, they've delivered a guilty verdict in that instance. What are you reflecting on in that moment? And then what do you go home and do that night or do when you leave court?
That's a really good question, because in the end, it's all about managing your work environment. And I switch off completely. As soon as the verdict's delivered, I do whatever's necessary in terms of talk to whoever I need to talk to. I'll come back to my room, I'll throw my robes off and I'll just leave. I don't want to think about it, I don't want to be involved in it.
I mean, yes, I'll get home and someone at home might say, you know, my partner will say, well, how'd you go? Yeah, it was a verdict of guilty. Oh, great. And I just won't respond to that because in the end, it's not, I mean, it's not something I want to be personally happy about in terms of the verdict. How'd you run the case? Oh, really well. I'm really happy with the way I led the evidence and managed the legal arguments. And my final address was a pièce de résistance. I mean, gee, it was good. So that's what I'm focusing on and I try and avoid being happy about verdicts. Having said that, you heard me say I try to avoid. There are occasionally verdicts which the case does get under my skin and I am very happy with.
It was super interesting to hear Nick's insights and it should be noted that for a criminal lawyer, getting to argue a case in the Supreme Court, especially if it's a big murder trial, that's probably the pinnacle of someone's career. So it's no mean feat and to get Nick's insight has been really valuable.
And it's, I find it really interesting how modest he is as he talks about it and how muted his reactions to the results are as well, given that it's such a huge achievement in someone's career for him to be, you know, so reflective and so thoughtful. I just, I don't know, I think I expected him to, you know, be a bit more, you know, boisterous, outgoing, celebratory in those moments, maybe.
I think it shows that all of these cases really have human beings at the heart of it and they're not characters in a TV show, they feel real emotions. Thank you to Nick Pappas for his time and expertise, talking us through what it's like being on the prosecution side.
If you want to get an idea of what it's like, you know, being part of the defence and working through that side or being a juror, check out some of the other episodes in our feed now. And if you've got any questions about this case or the process, click us an email at [email protected]. And of course, don't forget to sort yourself out with the ABC Listen app. You can track down Mushroom Case Daily on that. Make sure you follow us and that way you're not going to miss any updates.
Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, and Audio Studios manager, Monique Bowley. This episode was produced on the land of the Wurundjeri people.
You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated