The Case Of
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
Speaking up with your opinion may never be as important as when you’re deliberating with your fellow jurors.
4,414 words · 5 speakers
ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
If you live in Australia and you're listening to this podcast, the fate of Erin Patterson will rest in the hands of people just like you when her case gets to trial. A jury of her peers will decide if she's innocent or guilty. And today we'll find out what that process will be like for 12 people. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
And I'm Stephen Stockwell. This is Mushroom Case Daily.
So we've been looking at some of the key people who'll be in the courtroom during the trial of Erin Patterson. And there's probably none as important as the dozen people who'll make the call on her guilt or innocence. And that's the jury.
Yeah, these people are going to be ordinary Victorians selected from around Gippsland. So this is the area the trial is going to be held in Morewell. So they're going to be pulled from around that area. They're going to sit through the trial. They're going to listen to all the evidence and then they're going to return their verdict.
And what we really want to do is give people an insight into that process and what it's like to actually be sitting in the jury box. However, due to Australian laws, we're not really able to do that. Jurors aren't allowed to discuss the deliberations or the thought process that went into their crucial decisions. And that limitation even extends to the parties in the case. Even the accused murderer or the prosecution will never know the reasons that truly underpinned a jury's verdict. So because we couldn't talk to anyone in Australia, we caught up with someone who has served on a jury in the United States.
His name is Sven Berger.
I'm 44 years old. I live in Olympia, Washington. I was a software developer for most of my life, but now I work in the helping industry. I have, I have a wife, I have three dogs. So I think I'm pretty normal, dude.
Sven seems like a, a very normal dude. He's really lovely, actually.
Yeah, and we're talking to him because back in the late 2000s, when Sven was 28, he was on a jury for a murder trial.
Yeah, two guys had gone to a mini golf course. They had demanded money from the safe, just a couple of hundred dollars. And then they shot and killed the manager of that mini golf course that had opened it for them.
The trial was for the murder of Jonas Cherry. It was committed by two individuals, Paul Story and Mark Porter. And the trial I was involved with was for Paul Story.
And where were you living, working when you were called for that case?
I was in Fort Worth, Texas. I was working for a small medical education company. I had just bought a house. I was recently married. I've always kind of been into civic responsibility. I know that might sound kind of weird, but so when I got the jury summons, I was like, this is kind of interesting. This hasn't happened before. Let's check it out. I had a positive, positive impression going in.
Sven was actually pretty excited about this whole process. Like at the time, he had this real sense of civic purpose. So getting the letter calling for jury duty, you know, really kind of engaged him in that process. He'd watched a lot of Law and Order and was kind of interested in, you know, kind of checking that out.
Yeah.
But he really had no idea how much this was going to kind of affect his life. Like what he was going into was really pretty heavy. And, you know, he didn't know that because it started in this kind of like really procedural way during the selection process.
Take us through that selection process, Sven. Were you hauled into a big room full of strangers? Or what did it look like?
It was exactly like that, except most of the strangers were out in the hall and we were called into the big room one at a time to speak with counsel and the judge. And so, yeah, I mean, nobody was talking out there. I think everyone was either really bored or really nervous like me. And then when we got in there to speak with the lawyers, the defendant was in there at the time, which I guess is how they do it in Texas. And yeah, they just, they asked pretty straightforward questions. They were just a couple of weird little oddballs. And I think I passed muster. And afterwards, I was, I was kind of relieved because as I said before, I was looking forward to it. I wanted to be involved.
And when that jury panel was picked, can you tell us a little bit about who was in that jury? You said you were, you know, 28 year old, you know, young professional at the time. Who were some of the other people on the jury?
I don't know a lot of the details about the other folks, but I think I was the youngest person by probably seven or eight years.
It was mostly white people. I remember two African Americans, one Hispanic person. So it definitely, definitely skewed white. There was a, if I remember correctly, an even mix of men and women.
So you didn't talk much or chat about what you were doing and who you were through the process?
Honestly, no. We were given instructions not to talk too much during the, the breaks and to not discuss the case at all until it was time for deliberation at the end. And so I think most folks, because our breaks were never very long, it was just kind of like, well, sit around. There was a little bit of small talk. Listen to each other, but no, I didn't, I didn't really connect with anybody. It was, I don't know, it was kind of uncomfortable. Everyone seemed a little uneasy.
When the evidence started getting presented to the jury, what were some of the things that you were hearing and seeing?
There, there were a lot of disturbing photos. There was the testimony of like the, the fellow who, who found the deceased. He was the manager of the putt putt, which was a place you could do mini golf, ride a go-kart. And what happened was Paul and, and his partner were there before it opened, knocked on the door. They had worked there previously. So the manager knew them, let them in, then they robbed him and killed him. So, and then he was discovered by another employee sometime later. So we got a lot of firsthand stuff from him. There are numerous photos, a lot of physical evidence, you know, bullet cartridges, things like that.
Other evidence presented were that like he, someone took all the security tapes, except one, they missed one. And that was crucial to the case, as a matter of fact. And then there was a lot of like character testimony about like, there are folks saying, you know, asking that the sentence be the lighter side because of who he was. So that sort of thing. And then there were folks on the other side, not the deceased's parents, but the deceased's girlfriend, fiance, I believe. We mostly heard from her and she was devastated. She was rooting for the death penalty. But that's the kind of evidence we got. And some of it was, some, there was a lot of chain of custody stuff too. We spent several days talking with a sergeant who had this notebook like that.
And it was just like, they're just asking like, when did you receive this evidence? What did you do with it? Where has it been since then? Where is it now? And it was like that for like 200 pieces of evidence. It was so boring.
Yeah, they have to cross every single T and dot every I. I know you mentioned, Sven, that like there wasn't a great deal of discussion in the jury room, but surely I'm just imagining, you know, after you've heard a block of evidence for a couple of hours, you've gone back into the room and, and I mean, surely people need to blow off a bit of steam, right? After seeing some, some pretty harrowing stuff.
Yeah, that's definitely true. But to be perfectly honest, it was less than you might expect. Again, we had instructions from the judge not to discuss this stuff at all until the end. And so any discussion you might have heard were mostly folks playing like, whoa, that was quite a bit. Or, you know, I feel exhausted after all that. But no, we weren't really allowed to discuss any details and they stayed pretty close to that.
And how did you find viewing some of this confronting material? I mean, I'm imagining you saw, you know, pictures of deceased people or videos of a shooting happening. How did it make you feel to see that for real and knowing that that wasn't a piece of fiction?
Well, yeah, there was no video, but certainly the photographs, you know, they're just these high contrast flash images and, and yeah, they were, they were disturbing. It's, it's interesting because, you know, we see movies all the time that portray stuff like that or like the legal dramas, whatever. And so you think you'll be ready for it. But then when you actually see it in real life, it takes a moment to realize or for me to realize that this is, this is the real deal. You know, that's a picture of a, of a dead body. This guy, his family is here in the room. And, and once that starts sinking in, yeah, it feels very serious very quickly.
How compelling was the evidence that you were, you were hearing through the, through the course of the trial? Like, did you, did you believe it? Was it, you know, was it helping you make up your mind one way or the other as you were listening to it?
As far as the guilt is concerned, yeah, there was, it was no, no doubt at all. The defendant Paul, he confessed on film to officers numerous times, expanding his story. He never changed his story. It just, just added details to it. And so the question of guilt was non-existent.
One thing that some people will be asking, especially as, you know, outsiders who've never heard about this case.
Why did it even go to a trial itself? I mean, it sounded like he was clearly guilty and he confessed. Why was this case even put in front of a jury?
It was for sentencing. That's really all there was to it. I think some kind of trial kind of has to happen no matter what. I don't know that for capital punishment, you're allowed to do a summary judgment. I think a jury has to be there to see it because it's a really big deal. It's the biggest deal, you know. And so that's why it had to happen.
So Sven Story is fascinating, right? And just to clarify, his job here was deciding whether the defendant Paul Story deserved the death penalty or not. This is something that has to be done in the US when the prosecution is seeking the death penalty. But the whole thing is just really compelling. It's really interesting hearing him talk through all this stuff. But I'm wondering, Christian, whether or not it's fair to compare what he's dealing with with how a juror would experience this process in Australia?
Yeah, to a certain extent. I mean, the selection process does sound pretty similar. And also the fact that the jury sits in the room and hears all the evidence in the case, warts and all, views in many cases, graphic and confronting material, and hears evidence from people who've potentially been through some really harrowing stuff.
And I guess also sit through like a fair bit of really boring evidence too, like, you know, chain of custody stuff with evidence and all those bits and pieces.
Exactly. I mean, some of the big murder trials in Australia run for six weeks and the media might only show two or three days of that, which are the really compelling days. But a lot of it is pretty boring. And I've got to say, in my time covering the courts, I've seen the jury members go through the motions. That's for sure.
Thinking back to recent cases, I've seen jury members fall asleep. Um, I've seen um others who are clearly distracted or or not listening. And while jury members are very good at keeping a poker face and not showing their their emotions, there are certain times when something gets said in the courtroom and they just can't contain it. You know, you'll see a quizzical look or a look of disgust or sometimes despite the gravity of the situation, some evidence comes out that is genuinely funny and you see some of them trying to stifle the laughter, which is uh often quite an odd thing to think about when you, you know, reflect on why you're all there.
Totally. Yeah, it's such a such a big kind of heavy situation in so many senses. But there is always like those moments of humour as well. I mean, I think the thing that I find really interesting about Sven's experience is that, you know, he's being asked to decide the sentencing, which seems really like that's not something that happens here, right?
That's correct. I mean, in Australia, jurors are there to decide whether a person is innocent or guilty of the charges. They're not there to set the penalty for them. And in most cases, jury members are not even told what the maximum penalty is for an offence or what the sort of standard penalty is. So it's a question that they really never have to consider.
Yeah, and I mean, deciding whether or not someone is guilty or not is already just this huge burden for a juror, right? But deciding whether someone deserves the death penalty, that's just such a big ask. Like, the stakes couldn't really be any higher at that point. And so at this part of the trial with Sven sitting on it, he did not think that Paul's story deserved to be put to death. So I really wanted to know how the kind of decision-making process over the next little while went.
On the last day, we heard closing arguments. I think we might have heard closing arguments from one side the day before, then they finished up on on the day we were there or the last day. And then, yeah, the judge gave us some basic instructions. He told us what to think about, what not to think about, what we could do when we were in there if we needed to review evidence again, which honestly, we weren't allowed to review stuff or very much at all. And I'm really not sure why, if he thought it might change the outcome. And I'm still unclear about that. But then we got some brief instructions. We all went back to the deliberation room. And then, you know, it was kind of an uncomfortable moment of silence. And then the the person who was elected foreman at the beginning of the trial. Started a little discussion and it only took about an hour and a half, if I remember correctly.
So to put it in context, an hour and a half to decide a man's fate. What was that conversation like?
It was really stressful and I have some trouble with the total recall of that, but it there wasn't a ton of conversation. Basically, there was some opinion, everyone seemed to agree that the death penalty was the way to go. But there was still, we reviewed the evidence again with each other
and then voted essentially, and the whole process was pretty brief. And that's, that's when I had had the most problem because at that, at that point, I, I feel like I was misled. And there are some things that, like, so in Texas, if it has to be unanimous for the death penalty, but only one person needs to dissent for it to be life in prison. However, it is against the law for the jury to be instructed that way before deliberations. So none of us knew. I thought I had to convince 11 people the way I thought and I, I mean, I'm not, not proud of it, but I didn't have that in me.
Yeah. I mean, what were the personal dynamics in that room like? I'm imagining, you know, you've got a handful of people in that room. You've got all these different personalities, some much bigger than others. You know, what was it like in that room to, you know, to challenge or to speak up in those moments?
I was very, very depressed mood, certainly. And there, you know, the folks with the big personalities, it was very toned down by the end. I think everyone felt sort of the gravity of the situation. And since all the other jurors appeared to be in agreement.
Yeah, it felt, I mean, dangerous is the wrong word, but I didn't, I didn't feel comfortable at all discussing the way it was. Perhaps if someone had started the conversation before me, I could have joined in, but I, yeah, it was, it was a tough situation. I'm sorry. It's hard to talk about that a little bit.
No, it's a, it's a, yeah, it's a huge decision. It's a really challenging thing to, to discuss. What did you decide?
Well, we decided for the death penalty.
What was it like then walking back into that courtroom to deliver that judgment? Can you talk us through how that played out in the room?
So we came to the agreement, we voted, called the legal officer, Bailiff, I'm not sure what he's called, gave the decision, we were marched back out and it was very, very quiet. No one said anything at that point.
Were you able to look the defendant in the eye when that was handed down? How did you sort of feel?
I couldn't, no. The woman seated to my right began crying and I offered her my handkerchief and that was all I could do. And I felt like she did and I, no, I couldn't, I couldn't really look at Paul. I felt, I felt like, even then, I felt like maybe I wasn't making the right calls.
So we're seated, the judge asks the foreman if we've reached a verdict. He says, yes, he stands up, he delivers it, and then like less than a minute later, we're walking out the back door. We were given an option to either go out to meet the press or to leave and through the back way and everybody chose to just kind of slink out.
How did you deal with the rest of that day? Did you go home and talk to your partner about it or how did you deal with just the enormity of that situation?
My wife was, she was at, she was at school, she was a student at that time. And I, so I went to see my parents, they lived near me. And I had a few drinks with my dad and we talked about, I drank, I drank an awful lot back then, I don't drink anymore. But that was definitely, that was definitely part of it. We just discussed, I was relieved it was over. I felt, I felt a different weight after the fact, but the big one was gone. And I thought maybe this is something I could just, just a part of my life I could stop thinking about and move on from. Cause yeah, it was, it was a very heavy, heavy weight. It was, it was a burden that I was, that I was trying to release.
And my folks were really sympathetic, you know, a lot of hugs, pats on the back, that kind of thing.
This really affected Sven. We spoke to him on Zoom. I was looking at him as we were talking and as we were going through some of that, his retelling bits of this story, I could see him getting really uncomfortable, fidgeting a bit more, just like really slowing down in the retelling of it. And it was pretty close to actually sort of going, hey, look, do you need a moment to stop? But he, you know, sort of gathered himself and was happy to kind of keep going. But it really has had an impact on him. And, you know, as he mentioned, he started drinking as a way of, I guess, kind of dealing with this, which, you know, put a lot of pressure on his personal life. He's since moved cities and he's now quit drinking as well. But whilst Sven and his fellow jurors sentenced Paul's story to death, he hasn't been executed yet.
Yeah, that's right. I mean, in the years after that trial, which took place back in 2008, there's now been accusations that the prosecutors lied about the victims' families' intentions about wanting the death penalty imposed. And they've now come out and said they actually don't want Paul's story to be executed. And there's also questions about the defendant's IQ. And apparently, in the US, if it's considered too low, that could be a reason to spare them from the death penalty. Sven has signed an affidavit saying that if he'd known all those details at the time, he would have dissented.
There have been a few appeals around this case about the death penalty here, but nothing has changed. And Paul is still on death row, which, you know, kind of a decade and a half later, means that Sven still thinks about this a lot.
I do. I do. That's always going to be with me. I've been paying attention to Paul's appeal process. You know, there were some shenanigans in the courtroom that of course came up to a judge. And ultimately, it didn't work out for anything. So now, yeah, every once in a while, I'll check the Texas death row website to see if a date has been set for his execution. The first date that was set was my mom's birthday. And luckily, that was pushed back. But that was like, oh, my God. So yeah, no, I pay attention. I still pay attention. I don't feel good about it.
Hmm. So, man, as we're talking to you as part of a podcast that is looking at and following the trial of an accused murderer here in Australia.
What would your advice be to anyone that manned up on that jury or any jury for that matter?
I would like to tell people that this is one of the most important decisions you'll ever make for that person. And whichever way you believe, whichever way you feel, you need to speak up. If there's disagreement, you can't be quiet. It might be intimidating. It might be scary. There might be people who are shouting. But this is someone's entire life at stake. And I don't know anything about this case. I'm not trying to be sympathetic or otherwise. But they're not getting justice if you're not talking about it. And that's what we're all here to do, isn't it?
Hmm.
That's the whole process.
The way that Sven kind of puts that really kind of gives you some perspective on how big a decision a jury is making in something like this.
And just the lasting impact it has. And tying all of this back to the Patterson case. We're not talking about one alleged murder here. We're talking about three. So for whoever's enlisted onto this jury, it's going to be some pretty heavy and confronting material to consider. And also time consuming as well. I mean, I mentioned earlier, some of the big trials in Victoria tend to run for six weeks. So it is a big commitment. And while you're not allowed to talk about the case outside, surely it's got to be in your head. You've got to be thinking about it constantly. It is clearly a consuming factor of your life. And as Sven has explained,
it doesn't just end when you walk out the door. Sometimes it stays with you.
Yeah. I'd say a huge thank you to Sven Berger for sharing his experience with us for this episode.
Yeah, he hasn't shared his story too many times and it's obviously for a good reason. It's just tough to talk about this stuff.
Totally, totally. If you want to hear a bit more about the kind of key players in a murder trial, you can check out our other episodes on how the defence or the prosecution will be running their cases during this trial. They're in our feed at the moment. We also talk about the jury selection process in our one year on episode as well. So if you want a bit more info on this, you can you can jump into that too.
And if you've got any questions at all about this case or the process, flick us an email at [email protected].
And of course, make sure you sort yourself out with the ABC Listen app and follow Mushroom Case Daily so you don't miss any of our updates.
Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver, and producer, Stephen Stockwell.
Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson, and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, and audio studios manager, Monique Bowley. This episode was produced on the land of the Ruangtry people.
You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated