Skip to content

04 Jesse & Luke | Forensic evidence from the accused’s clean-up

The Case Of

Hosted by Stephen Stockwell

28m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode examines the detailed forensic and police evidence presented in the trial of former police officer Beau Lamar Condon, who is accused of murdering Jesse Baird and Luke Davies at a home in Paddington. Host Stephen Stockwell and legal affairs reporter Jamie McKinnon walk through the meticulous mapping of the crime scene, including blood spatter analysis using luminol testing, bullet holes discovered under floorboards and inside a bedroom door, and personal belongings recovered from a skip bin in Cronulla. The discussion also covers the defense cross-examination regarding DNA mixtures found on the accused officer's service firearm and the competing narratives presented by the Crown and the defense regarding how the killings unfolded.

  • Luminol is used as a presumptive testing tool that reacts to blood and certain cleaning products by producing a distinctive blue glow under special photography. 6:39
  • Police discovered a bullet hole in the kitchen floor, a fired cartridge on top of a kitchen cabinet, and a damaged bedroom door indicating a firearm was discharged. 4:11
  • DNA testing on the accused officer's service pistol revealed a mixture from at least three contributors where Luke Davies and the accused could not be excluded. 18:58
  • The defense has suggested that during a struggle, Luke Davies accidentally pulled the trigger and shot himself, which contrasts directly with the Crown's execution theory. 19:38

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Episode Introduction and Host Overview

    Stephen Stockwell opens the episode, setting the context and introducing the forensic focus of the case.

  2. 0:44
    Forensic Investigation Begins: Skip Bin Discovery

    Police uncover evidence in a skip bin at the Bowls Club, prompting deeper investigation.

  3. 1:55
    Forensic Officer Testimony: Luminol and Blood Evidence

    Jamie McKinnon explains how luminol reveals blood traces and the significance of the findings.

  4. 4:11
    Subfloor Evidence: Blood Stains and Bullet Holes

    Exploration of hidden blood stains and bullet holes beneath the floorboards of the house.

  5. 5:16
    Skip Bin Items and Police Response

    Details of items found in the skip bin and how police were alerted to the crime scene.

  6. 18:41
    DNA and Ballistics on Police Equipment

    DNA mixtures found on the police pistol and implications for the defense case.

  7. 22:14
    CCTV Audio and Video Evidence

    Discussion of the CCTV footage, audio of gunshots, and how it was introduced in court.

  8. 24:44
    Public Access to Exhibits and Media Release

    Explanation of how and when court exhibits are released to the public and media.

  9. 26:21
    Future Trial Developments and Next Steps

    Preview of upcoming cross-examinations and the direction of the trial moving forward.

Highlights

  • 3:08

    Skip Bin Discoverystory

    A groundskeeper at the Cronulla Bowls Club found blood-stained bedding, clothing, and identification cards belonging to Luke Davies in a skip bin, prompting the entire police investigation.

  • 6:39

    Luminol Testing Glowstrategy

    Senior Sergeant Bronwyn Lansley explained how luminol spray reveals a blue glow that helps investigators detect potential bloodstains, though certain cleaning products can trigger the same reaction.

  • 11:32

    Subfloor Blood Evidencedata

    Investigators found bloodstains, a bullet hole, and DNA matching Jesse Baird underneath the floorboards of the Paddington house.

  • 14:17

    Door Defect Repairstory

    Months after the shooting, police noticed a repaired defect on a bedroom door that, when stripped back, revealed stippling characteristics from a discharged firearm.

  • 18:58

    Gun DNA Resultsdata

    Defense counsel questioned forensic results from the service pistol, confirming mixed DNA profiles where neither the victim nor the accused could be excluded.

  • 19:38

    Competing Defense Narrativedebate

    The defense argues that a struggle occurred over the gun and Luke Davies accidentally shot himself, contradicting the Crown's allegation of an execution-style shooting.

Quotes

  • “It was the biggest fraud in Australian history.”
    Unnamed speaker · 0:16
  • “The forensic detail that we've seen here, Jamie, has been at times kind of graphic, but also at other times sort of deeply personal, right?”
    Stephen Stockwell · 1:55
  • “There were blood stains on a timber beam underneath the floor, a bullet hole in the kitchen floor, a fired gun cartridge above a kitchen cabinet and another hole in a bedroom door, which wasn't discovered until just two months before this trial.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:11
  • “The police are doing a review of the, I guess, the entire case, right? They've got a number of people involved in this.”
    Stephen Stockwell · 13:28

About this episode

From a skip bin at a Cronulla bowls club, to underneath the floorboards of Jesse Baird's Brown Street home: the forensic details of the police investigation into the alleged murders of Jesse and Luke have been laid out before the jury. Evidence of blood-stained belongings, DNA samples, a bullet hole, and a fired gun cartridge are all part of the Crown’s case about what allegedly happened inside the Paddington home. If you have any questions you’d like Jamie and Stocky to answer in future episodes, please email [email protected] mailto:[email protected]. Family and domestic violence support: If you need help, contact 1800 Respect https://1800respect.org.au/ national helpline on 1800 737 732. The Case Of is the follow-up to the hit podcast Mushroom Case Daily, and all episodes of that show will remain available in the back catalogue of The Case Of.

Transcript

0:00
28:00

5,260 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • ABC Listen
  • YouTube
  • Paddington
  • Mazda
  • Brown Street House
  • Cronulla
  • Bond Corporation
  • ABC Rewind
  • Sydney
  • Bowlem Arcondan's Tesla

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated