Skip to content

Episode 376

Sword and Scale

Hosted by Mike Boudet

1h 11m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In February 2025, police in Zanesville, Ohio, received a tip from a teenager claiming that an 80-year-old grandfather had died and his body was hidden in a shed. Investigators confronted the family living at the Summers Street home, including the grandfather's son David Jr., his wife Brittany Cole, and teenage granddaughter Nina. The family had repeatedly claimed that David Senior had moved away to live with relatives in Cincinnati or Columbus. However, police searched the property and discovered the 80-year-old's decomposing body wrapped in a mattress bag inside an outdoor shed. As detectives interviewed the household, conflicting timelines and elaborate lies began to unravel, revealing a dark cover-up involving financial motives, decaying remains left inside the home for weeks, and a confessed murder plot.

  • Authorities uncovered 80-year-old David Cole Sr.'s decomposing body wrapped in plastic inside a shed behind the family home after receiving a tip from a teenager. 19:04
  • Brittany Cole initially claimed her father-in-law had moved away, but investigators eventually extracted conflicting stories about when and how he died. 20:33
  • Surveillance footage from inside the home captured David Jr. discovering his father's decomposing body and expressing genuine shock over the condition of the remains. 40:12
  • Brittany eventually confessed during police interrogations to administering massive doses of Tylenol 3 and Z-Quil to the elderly man. 50:43

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction and Host Intro

    The host opens the episode, warning listeners of adult content and setting the stage for the story to follow.

  2. 2:00
    Initial Store Promotion and Transition to Murder Theme

    The host shifts from a promotional segment about free store items to a darker discussion about a murder case.

  3. 3:10
    Police Interview with Nina Bales Begins

    Detective Brian Ruff starts questioning teenage victim Nina about her missing grandfather, establishing the core mystery.

  4. 3:54
    Family Background and Grandfather’s Health Decline

    The transcript details the family’s living situation, the grandfather’s Parkinson’s, and conflicting accounts of his departure.

  5. 6:14
    Detective Ruff’s Interrogation of Brittany Cole

    Detective Ruff interrogates Brittany, revealing her shifting stories and the family's attempts to conceal the death.

  6. 16:00
    Timeline Reconstruction and Evidence Review

    Investigators piece together timelines, phone data, and video footage to understand the sequence of events leading to the death.

  7. 19:14
    Discovery of Grandfather’s Body in the Shed

    Police find the deceased grandfather in a shed, prompting deeper investigation into how he died and why he was hidden.

  8. 28:00
    Conclusion and Reflection on Family Dynamics

    The host wraps up the story, reflecting on the tragic family dynamics and the broader implications of the case.

  9. 54:49
    Financial Motive and Social Security Investigation

    The episode explores the family’s financial situation, suggesting a motive tied to the grandfather’s social security checks.

  10. 1:00:41
    Family Debate Over Grandpa’s Care

    The family discusses placing Grandpa into a facility and the events leading up to his death.

  11. 1:01:38
    Autopsy Reveals Natural Heart Attack

    The autopsy shows heart disease and a clot causing an acute myocardial infarction, confirming natural causes of death.

  12. 1:03:21
    Detective Ruff’s Suspicion and Evidence

    Detective Ruff remains skeptical despite the natural cause ruling, citing changing stories and video evidence that implicates Brittany and her son.

Highlights

  • 3:10

    Police Questioning Teenage Granddaughterstory

    Detective Brian Ruff questions 16-year-old Nina Bales at the Zanesville Police Department regarding the whereabouts of her missing grandfather, David Cole Sr.

  • 13:28

    Confronting Brittany About The Sheddebate

    Detectives question Brittany Cole about a 911 call reporting an 80-year-old grandfather's body hidden inside a backyard shed, a claim she initially expresses total confusion over.

  • 19:04

    Discovering The Body In Plasticstory

    Officers inspect a musty backyard shed and find an 80-year-old man wrapped in blankets and a large plastic mattress bag, exactly as the anonymous caller had described.

  • 40:12

    Surveillance Footage Captures Discoverydata

    Investigators review home security footage showing David Jr. opening his father's bedroom door, reacting with immediate horror and shock to the decomposing body inside.

  • 50:43

    Brittany Confesses To Overdosing Victiminsight

    Under intense questioning from detectives, Brittany breaks down and confesses to giving her father-in-law multiple doses of Tylenol 3 and Z-Quil.

  • 57:06

    Financial Motive And Spent Fundsdata

    Investigators reveal that the household had burned through $120,000 from the sale of a family farm and continued spending the deceased grandfather's social security checks.

  • 1:02:16

    Coroner Results And Heart Diseaseinsight

    The official autopsy reveals that David Senior suffered from severe heart disease with a blocked coronary artery, leading the coroner to rule the cause of death as a heart attack.

Quotes

  • “I went in there and first lights were off. It was like a fucking horror movie.”
    Unnamed speaker · 0:12
  • “Brittany said grandpa couldn't have left on his own.”
    Mike Boudet · 8:45
  • “If he had never moved out, then what had actually happened inside that house?”
    Mike Boudet · 19:40
  • “He died of natural causes. We were taking care of him and I thought my husband had taken care of it.”
    Unnamed speaker · 20:46
  • “The blood was screened for more than 95 commonly used drugs.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:01:19
  • “The official cause of death was an acute myocardial infraction.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:01:51
  • “Brittany had already confessed to first degree murder, after all.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:02:12
  • “Brittany showed absolutely no remorse.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:10:15
  • “He thought that because he was living with family, let alone family that provided health care, he would be in good hands.”
    Mike Boudet · 1:12:07
  • OnDeck 2:11–2:38
  • Dr. Teal 10:29–11:07
  • GSK 11:36–11:41
  • Dr. Teal 52:42–53:20
  • GSK 53:47–53:51
  • OnDeck 53:51–54:19
  • X Program by Truth Initiative 1:15:42–1:15:46

About this episode

When David Cole disappeared, the people closest to him seemed to know very little about where he had gone. But as detectives looked deeper into the home he shared with his son and daughter-in-law, Brittany, the stories they told began to fall apart. Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com

Transcript

0:00
1:11:32

10,898 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Tylenol
  • Cincinnati
  • Amazon
  • Disney
  • Dumbo ride
  • Agentic Enterprise

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated