Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Daniel Noah, a filmmaker and self-described hardcore skeptic, recounts a Ouija board session at the Stanley Hotel in Estes, Colorado. When his turn came on the planchette, it moved with a force he could not explain, spelling out "dad, mom, sorry" before devolving into repetitions of "swim" and "lake." The spirit identified herself as Ava, confirmed she had drowned in a lake, and directed the group to room 324 before vanishing. The next morning, the hotel's archive contained reports of two children in that room, and a local news story confirmed a child's drowning in a lake that no longer existed on the property.
Writer David Sloan investigates Robert the Doll in Key West, Florida. Through six boxes of Otto family archives, he establishes that the doll belonged to Gene Otto, a painter who became obsessed with it in his later years and was cruel to his wife Anne. Sloan discovers the doll was manufactured by the same German company that invented the teddy bear, and census records suggest a servant's child died in the house—possibly the spirit that entered the doll. The episode closes with Sloan baking Anne Otto's key lime pie recipe in the house's kitchen and feeling what he believes was her presence.
Planchette Moves With Unexplained Forcestory
Daniel describes how the planchette moved with force and precision despite no one gripping it, making him question whether a close friend was tricking the group.
Ava's Message on the Boardstory
The board spells out "dad, mom, sorry" before cycling through "swim" and "lake," identifying the spirit as a girl named Ava who drowned.
The Couple on the Landingstory
As Daniel and a friend ascend to room 324, a couple they have never met is sobbing on the landing, warning them not to come up because they saw a tiny figure.
Archive Confirms the Childrendata
The hotel archive for room 324 contains reports of a boy and a girl who would pull covers off beds and run around giggling, matching the Ouija board's message.
Camera Fires Without Looking at Dollstory
David tries to photograph Robert the Doll without asking permission; the camera refuses to fire, then fires three shots on its own without being pointed at the doll.
Teddy Bear Company Made the Dollinsight
Sloan's research reveals the doll was manufactured in Germany by the same company that invented the teddy bear, debunking the voodoo-servant legend.
Census Records Reveal a Dead Childinsight
Census data shows Emmeline Abbott, a servant's wife, had a child who died between 1900 and 1910, leading Sloan to believe that child's spirit entered the doll.
Baking Anne's Pie in Her Kitchenstory
After baking Anne Otto's key lime pie in the Artist's House kitchen, David hears a creak and a whoosh of lavender-scented air, which he takes as Anne's approval.
You know the most haunted places. The houses, the castles, the hotels. And you know the most haunted objects. The mirrors, the necklaces, the dolls. In this episode, we take you to the Stanley Hotel and introduce you to Robert the Doll.
4,970 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated