
#357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”
- 3h 57m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode features a conversation between the host and investigative podcaster Payne Lindsey, who shares the turbulent behind-the-scenes reality of creating Up and Vanished and Tenderfoot TV. Lindsey describes how he walked into cold cases with no police training or investigative background, using basic recording tools and social media to shake small-town trees and gather raw information. They discuss specific cases including Tara Grinstead in Georgia, Crystal Rysenger in Colorado, and Ashley Loring Heavy Runner on the Blackfeet Reservation in Montana, highlighting systemic failures, aggressive suspects, and confrontational face-to-face encounters.
Beyond true crime, the discussion delves into paranormal experiences, UFO phenomena, and a profound personal turning point that led Lindsey toward faith. Throughout the interview, Lindsey reflects on the enormous personal toll and moral weight of handling real-life investigations, the friction of dealing with local law enforcement and prideful state agencies, and his ongoing mission to give a voice to missing and murdered individuals.
- True crime podcasting often comes with complex ethical dilemmas and safety risks that go far beyond standard journalistic norms. 31:06
- When investigating cold cases in small communities, genuine information is rarely offered eagerly by people with real knowledge. 34:27
- Independent investigators often face resistance and defensiveness from state bureaus protecting their own investigative pride. 41:11
- Native American communities face disproportionate rates of missing persons cases compounded by complex, broken jurisdictional boundaries. 1:44:56
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Promotion and Host Intro
The episode opens with a promotional segment for ElevenReader followed by Shawn Ryan welcoming Payne Lindsey and setting the stage for the interview.
- 2:15Payne Lindsey’s Early Career and Podcast Genesis
Shawn and Payne discuss Payne’s beginnings as a freelance filmmaker, his lack of investigative background, and how a bet led him to start the Up and Vanished podcast.
- 5:00Choosing the Tara Grinstead Case
Payne explains why he selected Tara Grinstead’s cold case in Georgia as the first subject for his podcast, citing its mystery and his personal fascination with unsolved crimes.
- 12:00Interacting with Law Enforcement and the GBI
Payne recounts his interactions with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, including subpoenas, tips, and the tension between his independent work and official investigations.
- 38:26The Crawl Space Investigation and Media Attention
Payne describes the dramatic crawl‑space dig, the media coverage, and how the podcast’s revelations led to a press conference and a new suspect arrest.
- 53:31Confronting the Dukes and Ethical Dilemmas
The interview delves into Payne’s confrontation with the Duke brothers, the moral challenges of publishing sensitive information, and the impact on his personal safety.
- 1:01:09Continuing the Investigation and Future Outlook
Payne reflects on the ongoing nature of the case, the unresolved questions, and his commitment to pursuing justice despite obstacles.
- 1:02:01Graphic Details of Tara’s Murder
The host discusses the disturbing, graphic descriptions of Tara Grinstead’s remains shared by a podcast guest, highlighting the unsettling nature of the content.
- 1:04:02GBI’s Handling of the Case
The conversation turns to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation’s failures and the subsequent gag order, revealing the agency’s reluctance to admit mistakes.
- 1:04:38The Don Bradley Road Rage Incident
An anecdote about Don Bradley’s violent road rage incident illustrates broader issues of law enforcement’s pride and misidentification in criminal investigations.
- 1:16:00Podcast’s Role in Investigations
The host explains how the podcast has become an investigative tool, influencing law enforcement and uncovering new leads in cold cases.
- 1:25:20Crystal Rysenger’s Disappearance
The host recounts the mysterious disappearance of Crystal Rysenger in Crestone, Colorado, and his interactions with the suspect, Catfish John.
- 1:49:51Ashley Loring’s Missing Case
The discussion shifts to the disappearance of Ashley Loring in Montana, detailing the challenges of investigating missing Native American women.
- 2:04:07Alaska’s Florence Okpiluk Case
The host outlines the investigation into Florence Okpiluk’s disappearance in Nome, Alaska, focusing on the suspect Oregon John and the difficulties of locating him.
- 2:06:09Podcast Host’s Safety and Ethics
The host reflects on dangerous encounters with suspects, the ethical responsibilities of true‑crime journalism, and the importance of protecting listeners and families.
- 2:06:55Using a Fake Facebook Account
He details how he used a burner Facebook profile to initiate contact with the target, creating a believable backstory.
- 2:08:35In-Person Meeting in Alaska
The host and a friend travel to Alaska, set up a stakeout, and confront the target in a bar, revealing the target’s suspicions and the host’s deception.
- 2:10:35Deciding to Reveal Identity
After weighing risks, the host chooses to admit his true identity to the target, leading to a tense but honest conversation.
- 2:36:30Personal Haunted House Experiences
The host recounts eerie incidents in an old house, including unexplained sounds and electrical anomalies, illustrating his personal encounters with the paranormal.
- 2:41:33Podcast Intro and Ad
The episode opens with a brief introduction followed by a promotional ad for Shopify.
- 3:01:29Twitter Wars and Government Discrediting
The hosts discuss how Twitter battles and government actions fuel discrediting and the frustration of staying neutral.
- 3:03:05Congressional Hearing on Non-Human Biologics
They recall a congressional hearing about non-human biologics, reflecting on the hype and skepticism surrounding the topic.
- 3:05:14Debating Afterlife and Reincarnation
The conversation shifts to philosophical musings on death, afterlife, and reincarnation, with personal anecdotes.
- 3:28:31Personal Spiritual Encounters and UFO Mysteries
A deep dive into personal experiences with UFOs, angels, and spiritual revelations, blending religious and extraterrestrial themes.
- 3:35:42From Military Service to Advocacy for the Vulnerable
The hosts reflect on their military pasts and their commitment to protecting children and the vulnerable.
- 3:51:41Launching a Year-Round Investigation Platform
The hosts discuss the creation of a continuous investigative show to uncover missing persons cases and expose corruption.
- 3:56:46Unveiling New Evidence
The host reveals fresh material that could spark movement in unsolved cases.
- 3:57:20Unexpected Podcast Journey
He reflects on how the project evolved from a simple podcast to an investigative endeavor.
Highlights
- 4:21
Starting Up and Vanished Without Backgroundstory
The guest explains how he went from being a broke freelance filmmaker with zero investigative background to launching a proof-of-concept true crime podcast about the coldest case in Georgia.
- 14:47
Searching a Crawl Space for Evidencestory
After receiving a tip about a suspicious mound of dirt under a house, the guest searched a crawl space only to find the GBI searching the exact same spot shortly after.
- 16:46
Uncovering Clues in a Small Townstrategy
Starting with a call to his grandmother, the guest explains how simply asking questions in a town of 3,000 people quickly rattled nerves and prompted locals to start talking.
- 44:56
A Dubious Confession Leads to Arrestinsight
The guest details how an arrest was made after a drug-infused, incoherent confession, which ultimately unraveled during trial and left the community searching for the real perpetrator.
- 1:25:46
A Confrontation in North Carolinastory
While attempting to confront a person of interest in North Carolina, the guest experienced a volatile encounter involving threats and a physical swing with a motorcycle helmet.
- 1:47:40
The Crisis of Missing Indigenous Womendata
The host and guest discuss the staggering statistics surrounding missing and murdered native women, highlighting systemic indifference, lack of resources, and complicated jurisdictional handoffs.
- 2:14:07
Catfishing a Murder Suspect in Alaskastrategy
The guest recounts a high-stakes sting where he used a fake social media account to befriend an Alaskan murder suspect and eventually meet him face-to-face in a bar.
Quotes
“I was like, holy shit. I mean, that's more friends than I have on Facebook, so I'm doing something.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:24 “I had no investigative experience. All my experience came from documenting people.”
Unnamed speaker · 13:00 “The podcast was coming out every week and their case was getting a little messier because of it. Cause every week we would learn something new about Bo.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:08:23 “I have interviews that I have not ever put out that would make a whole hell of a lot more sense now. And there's dozens of them.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:11:04 “I think that it's kind of subconscious, but it's I've just realized that because I'm talking about real stuff, real sensitive things, that this is like someone's worst day of their life, their worst everything, a nightmare, right?”
Unnamed speaker · 1:13:33 “And I did something journalistically that I've never done before, which I was kind of at odds about, to be honest.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:10:35 “I was like, no more bullshit. I, I'd like to give you the platform to clear your name, if that's something that you can do or want to do.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:17:48 “I think the government shit is discrediting at this point.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:02:14 “I think the universe is infinite and never ends and it keeps expanding.”
Unnamed speaker · 3:10:34
Sponsored segments
- ElevenReader 0:00–1:58
- ZipRecruiter 18:13–19:02
- TheGlacierApp 21:04–21:24
- Tim Tebow Foundation 49:34–50:28
- Ethos 1:15:32–1:16:20
- Hexclad 1:36:16–1:37:32
- Gusto 2:02:41–2:03:38
- Shopify 2:40:06–2:41:27
About this episode
Payne Lindsey is a filmmaker, podcast host, and co-founder of Tenderfoot TV, best known for co-creating and hosting the true-crime podcast Up and Vanished. His investigation into the disappearance of Georgia teacher Tara Grinstead brought renewed attention to the long-unsolved case and launched his career in investigative podcasting. He also hosts Atlanta Monster and Radio Rental, and his work has expanded into television through Oxygen’s Up and Vanished series. Shawn Ryan Show Sponsors: Privacy Isn't Paranoia. It's Protection. Download Glacier - https://theglacierapp.com Try ZipRecruiter for FREE today at https://ziprecruiter.com/SRS to find the right people for your roles, seasonal or otherwise. Become a Defender today and donate to partner with the Tim Tebow Foundation to help rescue children. https://timtebowfoundation.org Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/SRS. Application times may vary. Rates may vary. Trustpilot rating as of 8/1/2026. Take advantage of HexClad’s Best Sale of the Year and GET UP TO 52% Off by going to https://hexclad.com/SRS #hexcladpartner Try Gusto today at https://gusto.com/SRS and get three months free when you run your first payroll. Start your free trial at https://shopify.com/srs Payne Lindsey Links: Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/paynelindsey X - https://x.com/paynelindsey Tenderfoot TV - https://tenderfoot.tv Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/tenderfoot.tv Youtube - https://www.youtube.com/@tenderfoottv Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
36,182 words · 7 speakers
Topics
- Alaska
- Up and Vanished
- GBI
- Nome
- Oregon
- Sedona
- Georgia Bureau of Investigation
- McDonald's
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated