Skip to content

460: Cruise Ship Murder, Child Predator Sting & 3-Year-Old Says “Mama Cut Papa” To Babysitter

SERIALOUSLY

Hosted by Annie Elise

42m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this episode of Serially, host Annie Elise and guest Amy Collette discuss several prominent true crime cases and updates. They cover the scheduling of Lindsay Clancy's upcoming retrial for March 29, 2027, following a mistrial where 11 of 12 jurors favored an insanity defense. The hosts also examine the re-arrest of Steven, who was previously given a controversial one-year sentence for sexually assaulting 18-year-old Michaela Settles, and the Galveston, Texas cruise ship murder where Susan Watford was strangled by her husband Jason Watford. Additional cases include a private child predator sting in New York involving Preston Purdy and an Orlando murder where a three-year-old child told her babysitter that her mother had cut her father.

  • Lindsay Clancy's second trial is scheduled to begin on March 29, 2027, after her first trial ended in an 11 to one mistrial. 9:48
  • Steven was re-arrested for a probation violation just four days after his release from a one-year county jail sentence. 16:40
  • Susan Watford was found dead in a cruise ship cabin after her husband strangled her following an argument at dinner. 21:06
  • Preston Purdy flew to New York and was arrested during a private child predator sting operation after planning horrific assaults. 32:21

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro & Sponsor Ads

    The episode opens with a brief introduction, followed by multiple sponsor advertisements for insurance, electronics, and retail deals.

  2. 2:20
    Host Introduces True‑Crime Focus

    Host Annie Elise welcomes listeners and previews the true‑crime cases to be discussed, including a cruise ship murder and a child‑predator sting.

  3. 6:32
    Lindsay Clancy Retrial Update

    Annie provides a detailed update on Lindsay Clancy’s second trial, including dates, charges, and the judge’s insistence on a March 29, 2027 trial.

  4. 28:04
    Wrap‑Up & Listener Engagement

    The hosts conclude the episode, encouraging listeners to share feedback, ask questions, and stay tuned for future updates on the discussed cases.

  5. 40:00
    Cruise Ship Murder Investigation

    The hosts discuss the murder of Susan Watford on the MSC Seaside, covering the timeline, evidence, and Jason Watford’s federal charges.

  6. 44:17
    Eugenio Martinez Murder Case

    The episode details the discovery of Eugenio Martinez’s body, the babysitter’s alleged self‑defense claim, and the ensuing murder charge against Isidra Hernandez.

  7. 47:27
    Three-Year-Old’s Confusing Statement

    The discussion opens with the child's remark about the babysitter, raising questions about interpretation and context.

  8. 48:12
    Exploring Self-Defense Possibility

    They speculate that the victim might have defended himself, leading to a bruise on the babysitter.

  9. 48:49
    Unplanned Nature of the Incident

    Hosts conclude that the event likely wasn’t premeditated, based on the chaotic scene.

  10. 49:34
    Sign-Off with Lighthearted Advice

    Hosts sign off with humorous warnings about divorce, kids, and cruises.

  11. 50:25
    JCPenney Black Friday Ad

    A commercial promoting JCPenney’s Black Friday deals is presented.

Highlights

  • 7:14

    Lindsay Clancy Retrial Date Setdata

    The host discusses the scheduling of Lindsay Clancy's second trial for March 29, 2027, and notes that defense attorneys believe prosecutors will pursue first-degree murder charges again based on their push for a jury trial.

  • 16:40

    Steven Re-arrested Days After Releasestory

    Steven, convicted of incest and furnishing alcohol to Michaela Settles, was re-arrested for a probation violation just four days after serving a six-month jail term.

  • 21:54

    Cruise Ship Cabin Murder Detailsinsight

    Investigators reviewed surveillance footage showing Jason and Susan Watford entering their cabin before Jason admitted to investigators that he strangled his wife for four to five minutes during an argument.

  • 24:15

    Prior Domestic Violence Historydata

    Jason Watford had a prior attempted first-degree murder conviction from 1996 and was arrested in September 2024 for assaulting Susan during an argument at their Texas home.

  • 29:53

    Predator Sting Confrontationstory

    Preston Purdy flew to New York to meet fictitious children in a private sting operation and made explicit, disturbing admissions about his intentions on a livestreamed confrontation.

  • 44:01

    Orlando Apartment Crime Scenestory

    Police investigating a man's body found in a trash bag outside an Orlando apartment complex traced blood and evidence to a residence 800 feet away belonging to Eugenio Martinez and Isidra Hernandez.

Quotes

  • “Police say a three-year-old girl told her babysitter that her mama had cut her pop-up.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:04
  • “He said, he could pretty much guarantee that at least some of what he had planned, particularly involving the eight year old girl, would have happened.”
    Annie Elise · 30:24
  • “She eventually admitted that he had died during an argument between the two of them, but she insisted that she had actually acted in self-defense.”
    Unnamed speaker · 45:38
  • “I don't think a three-year-old would interpret that as mama was cutting papa.”
    Annie Elise · 47:41
  • “I know. It is a wild, wild case.”
    Annie Elise · 49:25
  • “Don't kill people. Just get a divorce. Stay away from kids.”
    Annie Elise · 49:34
  • JCPenney 34:37–36:07
  • Sandisk 49:56–50:29
  • JCPenney 50:25–50:37

About this episode

Join Annie as she breaks down what’s happening in true crime this week.

Transcript

0:00
42:58

9,547 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • True Crime
  • Legal Updates
  • Cruise Ship Murder
  • Child Protection
  • Domestic Violence
  • Criminal Trials

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated