
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode examines the state of scientific research and public health in the United States following the Democratic midterm victories and the ongoing tenure of the Trump administration. Host Wendy Zukerman and guest Max Kozlov discuss the tangible impacts of federal budget cuts, institutionalized grant screening, and the rise of political appointees overseeing health agencies like the NIH. While researchers and newly elected lawmakers are celebrating a potential political shift, the guest explains that systemic changes, executive vetoes, and ongoing agency policies mean the scientific establishment remains under pressure. The conversation also explores how AI data centers and local electricity concerns became a surprising flashpoint for voters during the election cycle.
- Expect continued political screening on federal research grants despite congressional funding stability. 8:57
- Anticipate intense congressional hearings and oversight regarding federal vaccine policies and health agency leadership. 22:30
- Recognize that local voter resistance to data centers was driven largely by everyday affordability and electricity costs. 10:16
Chapters
- 0:01Opening and Context of the War on Science
Wendy Zukerman introduces the episode, highlighting the recent celebration of midterm results and the ongoing attacks on science during the Trump administration.
- 0:37Impact of Trump Administration on Science Funding
The hosts discuss the firing of scientists, dismantling of US aid, and the broad cuts to science funding under Trump.
- 1:11Measles Resurgence and Vaccine Skepticism
The conversation turns to the rise in measles cases and the role of RFK Jr. in undermining vaccine confidence.
- 1:45Election Results and the Rise of Science‑Loving Politicians
Wendy notes the Democratic victories and the influx of scientists and healthcare professionals into Congress, raising hopes for science policy.
- 6:00Interview with Max Kozlov on Post‑Midterm Science Outlook
Max Kozlov shares his perspective on how the election may change the science landscape and the lingering influence of Trump.
- 9:12Measles Outbreak and Funding Redirection to AI
The discussion covers the current measles crisis and the shift of federal funds toward artificial intelligence initiatives.
- 16:45AI, Data Centers, and the Election’s Tech Debate
The episode examines how data center construction became a pivotal issue in the election, reflecting broader concerns about tech influence and local impacts.
- 21:00Closing Reflections and Oddball Questions
The hosts wrap up with sponsor segments and playful questions, ending on a hopeful note for science’s recovery.
- 21:36Future of Science Policy Under Democratic Control
Wendy and Max analyze the challenges Democrats face in reversing Trump’s policies, including veto power and filibuster hurdles.
Highlights
- 8:57
Institutionalized Grant Screening Processinsight
The guest explains that grant approvals now face an additional layer of political screening by agency leadership and RFK Jr.'s office to align with administration priorities.
- 9:18
Rebranding AI in Grant Applicationsstory
The guest humorously notes that following an executive order, researchers now have to use the term superintelligence instead of artificial intelligence in applications.
- 10:16
Science in the Electioninsight
The guest notes how Senate candidates openly campaigned against public health figures and made science a massive part of their political platforms.
- 10:16
Data Center Local Pushbackdata
Data centers became a major local flashpoint across the country, with over forty ballot measures attempting to restrict their construction due to noise and water concerns.
- 10:16
Voter Concern on AI Data Centersdata
An NBC exit poll revealed that fifty-six percent of surveyed voters considered AI and data centers to be a major or crucial factor in their vote.
- 22:30
Limitations of Congressional Powerstrategy
The guest details why Democrats cannot easily reverse administration policies due to presidential veto power and the sixty-vote threshold required by the filibuster.
Quotes
“People were literally in labs doing the research and were told, "Get out of here. Pencils down, get out, don't cure cancer."”
Unnamed speaker · 0:52 “The money hasn't all gone to the research that scientists have said, "This is the stuff that we want to fund, this is the most impactful, rigorous stuff."”
Unnamed speaker · 7:50 “I think RFK is near the top of the list of administration officials that Democrats have been vocal about potentially impeaching.”
Unnamed speaker · 11:10 “An NBC exit poll found that 56% of voters that they surveyed considered AI and data centers to be a major or crucial factor in their vote.”
Wendy Zukerman · 17:13
Sponsored segments
- Base44 20:40–20:54
- Samsung Galaxy Tab S12 Ultra 26:11–26:52
About this episode
A whole bunch of scientists and doctors won in the U. S. midterm elections, which has got some nerds really excited. They’re wondering: Could this turn things around for U. S. science, which has been hit by cuts and restrictions from the Trump administration?? We talk to journalist Max Kozlov from Nature to find out whether it’s time for a nerd party in the U. S. A. — or if it might be too soon to pop the champagne. Find our transcript here: https://tinyurl.com/ScienceVsWarOnScience In this episode, we cover: (00:00) A blue wave … and a nerd wave? (02:33) What’s happened with science under Trump (09:32) What science stuff did voters care about? (11:54) Abdul El-Sayed adapted some MAHA language (14:35) Data centers lost at the polls (20:19) Are scientists celebrating too soon? (28:17) Oddball questions with Max This episode was produced by Wendy Zukerman, with help from Michelle Dang, Ekedi Fausther-Keeys and Rose Rimler. We’re edited by Blythe Terrell. Wendy Zukerman is the executive producer. Video editing and sound by Bobby Lord. Music written by Bumi Hidaka, Peter Leonard, Emma Munger and Bobby Lord. Thanks to Humdinger Studios in Melbourne and Podville Media in Washington, DC. Science Vs is a Spotify Studios Original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us and tap the bell for episode notifications. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
5,173 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- AI
- NIH
- NSF
- SI
- Compute campuses
- Nature
- Science Versus
- CDC
- NOAA
- Department of Health and Human Services
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated