Skip to content

Another Law Struck Down By Supreme Court

The Real Estate Espresso Podcast

7m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode examines a Washington State Supreme Court decision that struck down Initiative 2066, a voter-approved measure regarding natural gas and energy choice. The host explains that the court based its ruling on the state constitution's single-subject rule, introducing key concepts like vertical and horizontal rational unity. While ostensibly about natural gas, the ruling creates significant implications for real estate investors who rely on complex omnibus legislation touching zoning, building codes, and taxes. Because forty-three state constitutions contain similar single-subject requirements, this decision provides legal precedent that could impact legislation and development underwriting nationwide.

  • State constitutions often contain single-subject rules that require provisions in a law to have rational unity. 0:57
  • Omnibus legislation can be completely invalidated if unrelated provisions fail the vertical and horizontal rational unity test. 2:45
  • Real estate investors must assess regulatory risk and consider whether an entire statute could be thrown out due to one problematic provision. 5:31
  • Forty-three states have single-subject constitutional requirements, meaning Washington State's legal reasoning could influence rulings nationwide. 6:10

Highlights

  • 0:23

    Supreme Court Strikes Down Initiativedata

    The Washington State Supreme Court struck down Initiative 2066, an initiative approved by voters in 2024 regarding natural gas access.

  • 1:03

    The Single Subject Constitutional Ruleinsight

    Article 2, Section 19 of the Washington State Constitution prohibits bills from embracing more than one subject to prevent log-rolling.

  • 2:40

    Rational Unity Requirementsstrategy

    The court emphasizes that legislation must have vertical rational unity with the overall subject and horizontal unity where provisions relate meaningfully to each other.

  • 3:42

    Historical Precedent for Large Billsinsight

    Large omnibus bills can survive constitutional challenges if all provisions are components of a comprehensive effort to address a single identifiable problem.

  • 5:02

    Refusal of Separabilitystory

    The court refused to apply the separability clause, choosing instead to throw out the entire statute because they could not know which parts voters wanted.

  • 6:10

    National Implications Across Statesinsight

    With forty-three state constitutions containing similar single-subject requirements, attorneys elsewhere can cite this Washington ruling as persuasive precedent.

  • 6:21

    Federal Legislation Exceptiondata

    Unlike state laws, the US Constitution lacks a single-subject restriction, which is why federal legislation can span thousands of pages.

Quotes

  • “No bill shall embrace more than one subject, and that shall be expressed in the title.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:03
  • “The court concluded that these provisions had sufficiently different regulatory purposes that they constituted multiple subjects.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:15
  • “The Washington Supreme Court refused to do that in this case. The judges concluded that they could not know which parts voters would have approved and which ones they wouldn't have.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:02
  • “For real estate investors, that distinction is important because our industry sits at the intersection of a huge number of regulatory regimes.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:20

About this episode

On today’s show we’re going to talk about a Washington Supreme Court decision that, on the surface, is about natural gas. But I think the much more interesting story is what this ruling could mean for the way laws are written, and by extension, for real estate investors trying to understand the rules under which they are making long-term investment decisions. The case is called Climate Solutions versus State of Washington. On September 17, the Washington Supreme Court struck down Initiative 2066, a ballot initiative that Washington voters had approved in 2024. The initiative was broadly aimed at protecting access to natural gas and limiting government policies that would discourage its use. But the court did not strike it down because of the merits of natural gas policy. It struck it down because of the way the initiative was constructed. Washington’s Constitution contains a remarkably simple sentence. Article II, Section 19 says: “No bill shall embrace more than one subject, and that shall be expressed in the title.” Historically, courts have allowed fairly broad legislation. A bill dealing with transportation, for example, can obviously contain provisions governing roads, transit, bridges and funding. But the Washington court emphasized that it is not enough for every provision merely to relate to some enormously broad title. There must be what the court calls vertical rational unity — the provisions have to relate to the overall subject of the legislation. But there must also be horizontal rational unity. In other words, the provisions need to relate meaningfully to each other. 43 states have similar single subject provisions in their constitution. So this is not just a Washington issue. This ruling will likely be cited in other jurisdictions. ------------ **Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com http://www.victorjm.com/](http://www.victorjm.com http://www.victorjm.com/) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso%5D(http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [[email protected] mailto:[email protected]](mailto:[email protected] mailto:[email protected]) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com http://www.ystreetcapital.com/](http://www.ystreetcapital.com http://www.ystreetcapital.com/) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) http://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital%5D(https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)

Transcript

0:00
7:22

1,247 words · 1 speaker

Topics

  • Washington State
  • Washington State Supreme Court
  • Building Industry Association of Washington
  • Washington State Constitution
  • Washington Decarbonization Act

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated