Skip to content

Film Fights With Friends - Season 2 / Episode 11 | Remake Round Table

RAGE Works Network-All Shows

1h 36m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode of Film Fights with Friends features a roundtable discussion with returning guests Hugh Fitzgerald and Becca V T about the best, worst, and untouchable remakes in cinema history. The hosts and guests debate what constitutes a true remake versus a reimagining or a separate adaptation of a novel, evaluating high-profile films like Dune, Roadhouse, Man on Fire, The Thing, Wonka, Point Break, Rollerball, and King Kong. Alongside the film debate, the participants explore how nostalgic attachment to childhood viewing, differing camera work styles, and adherence to source material shape audience receptions of remakes.

Throughout the conversation, the speakers analyze specific technical choices, such as Peter Jackson's extended runtime in King Kong versus the stop-motion efficiency of the 1933 original, and John Carpenter's updates to 1951's The Thing. They examine why certain classics like The Princess Bride, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, and Jaws should never be touched by Hollywood remakes. The episode offers a mix of film trivia, behind-the-scenes stunt history involving legendary performer Tom Steele, and passionate cinematic opinions from industry insiders.

  • A great remake should honor the original story's emotional core while making you want to revisit the classic. 21:02
  • Be cautious when evaluating remakes, as childhood nostalgia heavily influences whether we view a new version as successful. 53:20
  • Films that are deeply embedded in culture, such as The Princess Bride and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, should never be remade. 51:15

Chapters

  1. 0:09
    Show Intro and Guest Announcement

    Hosts Paul and Stephen introduce the episode, announce returning guests Hugh Fitzgerald and Becca V T, and outline the remake discussion theme.

  2. 0:47
    Bonus Question Teaser

    Paul hints at a surprise question about a film that should never be remade, setting up audience anticipation.

  3. 3:12
    Production Pitch and LA Logistics

    Stephen discusses a new project pitch, the challenges of shooting in LA versus New York, and the creative agency’s role.

  4. 9:00
    Fan Engagement and Sponsorship

    Hosts promote listener interaction, Patreon support, and sponsor Stunt Contact, encouraging audience participation and support.

  5. 13:49
    Wrap‑Up and Call to Action

    The episode concludes with a recap, a reminder of the surprise question, and a final push for listener support and engagement.

  6. 14:34
    Remake Round Table Intro

    The episode officially brings in Hugh and Becca, re‑introducing them and setting the stage for the remake debate.

  7. 17:19
    Positive Remake Picks

    Hugh, Becca, and Paul share their favorite remakes—Dune, Roadhouse, and Man on Fire—explaining why each stands out.

  8. 21:14
    Remake Criteria Debate

    The panel discusses what makes a good remake, emphasizing honoring the original, nostalgic impact, and emotional resonance.

  9. 49:39
    Negative Remake Picks

    The hosts reveal their least favorite remakes—Red Dawn, The Thing, and Wonka—detailing why each failed to meet expectations.

  10. 51:54
    Gene Wilder’s Legendary Forward Roll

    The hosts discuss Gene Wilder’s insistence on performing a forward roll in a film role and the behind‑the‑scenes story.

  11. 53:20
    Remakes and Childhood Memories

    They explore how nostalgia for original films influences opinions on remakes and the emotional impact on younger viewers.

  12. 54:32
    The Cancellation of Duster

    The group reflects on why the show Duster was canceled, citing its target demographic and era of viewers.

Highlights

  • 10:14

    Archery with Feetstory

    The hosts highlight the impressive social media content of Arissa Kelly, a performer known for doing handstand scorpion poses and shooting a bow and arrow with her feet.

  • 27:28

    Roadhouse Camp and Cleaver Actioninsight

    Becca V T defends the Roadhouse remake as a fun, clever, and raucous take that successfully updates an eighties camp classic for modern audiences.

  • 36:35

    Man on Fire Dual Endingsinsight

    Paul Veraci champions Tony Scott's Man on Fire as a brilliant remake of the Scott Glenn film, noting how both versions offer entirely different, powerful conclusions based on the same source material.

  • 37:42

    Dune as a Masterpiece Remakeinsight

    Hugh Fitzgerald argues that Denis Villeneuve's Dune is a stellar remake because it returns the focus to the human element and Paul Atreides's hero journey.

  • 44:36

    The Thing and Practical Stuntsdata

    Stephen Koepfer discusses John Carpenter's The Thing as a brilliant remake of the 1951 original, comparing their shared history of epic full-body fire burn stunts performed by veterans like Tom Steele.

  • 58:18

    Pioneering Female Directorsinsight

    The panel praises Kathryn Bigelow's directorial achievements from Point Break to Zero Dark Thirty, emphasizing her confidence and talent in a male-dominated industry.

  • 1:01:25

    Rollerball Remake Disappointmentdebate

    Paul Veraci lambasts the 2002 Rollerball remake starring Chris Klein, arguing that it stripped away the intellectual AI and corporate corruption themes of Norman Jewison's 1977 original.

  • 1:24:24

    Aspect Ratio and Modern Aestheticsinsight

    Paul Veraci explains why certain modern remakes and prequels fail to capture the feel of older films due to changes in film rates, aspect ratios, and overly shiny digital aesthetics.

Quotes

  • “Well, and, and to be fair to the middle entity, the creative agency that we're talking to, they weren't aware of, of the desire to shoot in LA.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:05
  • “And if you have a stunt sequence that you would like to submit, because they do have best stunt performance, the winner of that category will be on the show.”
    Unnamed speaker · 7:06
  • “A great remake makes you want to watch the original in the most nostalgic best way possible.”
    Unnamed speaker · 21:02
  • “Those little things to me are what remake, or what, what can make a remake fucking great.”
    Unnamed speaker · 39:21
  • “They brought in gospel music. They brought in all this other stuff, but kept the story the same, just changed the setting.”
    Unnamed speaker · 40:45
  • “That was shit. Can we, we can agree that was shit. Taking a, a beautiful story and by a legend like Wilder that it was written for.”
    Unnamed speaker · 51:54
  • “Because he said it set up the entire story of who Wilder was.”
    Unnamed speaker · 52:46
  • “I don't know what, what this was. So that was one that I really stood out to me.”
    Unnamed speaker · 51:45
  • “If you ever sat in traffic, you felt a little bit of that movie inside of you.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:33:26
  • [email protected] 2:34–2:51
  • Patreon 7:32–7:40
  • Stunt Contact 8:05–9:05
  • Patreon 1:36:44–1:36:52

About this episode

Returning guests Becca GT (S1 Ep1) and Hugh Fitzgerald (S1 Ep4) join Paul and Steve and rip into what some of our favorite and worst remakes are! What constitutes a remake? Can a television show truly be a remake of a film? Can a film accurately remake a TV show? Is a reboot a remake? Is a spin-off a remake? What films should never be remade? Join us and find out what these industry insiders really think about some of the movies you love (or hate)! MENTIONS: Becca on Film Fights With Friends: https://youtu.be/tt5vGQn-vko?si=xFcghMoOJhLa3O33 Hugh on Film Fights With Friends: https://youtu.be/8Pn3GZWBuQM?si=RIABsu1bOY-NUTCX Dune (2021) Trailer: https://youtu.be/n9xhJrPXop4?si=O7LS2ajUqq5kECkF Dune (1984) Trailer: https://youtu.be/hzUlXEyvJeA?si=r0aLEvVzo8_a8322 Willy Wonka & The Chocolate Factory (1971) Trailer: https://youtu.be/2WKPKnggJqk?si=XCuEwtv73S8YqZvK Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005) Trailer: https://youtu.be/OFVGCUIXJls?si=4PeaCgmvVNuqspFn Road House (1989) Trailer: https://youtu.be/oByMeAfwARs?si=r0M5BcM0XmhhEsHo Road House (2024) Trailer: https://youtu.be/Y0ZsLudtfjI?si=Hx5OJfoHqAqdS3Je Rollerball (1975) Trailer: https://youtu.be/yku2CXuKKiU?si=xEZRUxdzzBgFYiFh Rollerball (2002) Trailer: https://youtu.be/uFWFEoK9Yz8?si=iqgylyRXCJi1C2zg Point Break (1991) Trailer: https://youtu.be/ZgHPumVN4Fo?si=bPYF3Xz_WZ_uvknH Point Break (2015) Trailer: https://youtu.be/ncvFAm4kYCo?si=zOtmrz0kLijIpSX1 Man on Fire (1987) Trailer: https://youtu.be/AERYCHIx184?si=iq2QCNEP9bps2gA6 Man on Fire (2004) Trailer: https://youtu.be/ALKCTuH79iE?si=OwWNFvcXAVVvtF8I King Kong (1933) Trailer: https://youtu.be/PbrikL8IjXM?si=MCsnUdVdVoXhIo2e King Kong (2005) Trailer: https://youtu.be/V00s34PFHVo?si=Pa6B4PPGc1YbxjWp King Kong vs T-Rex (1933): https://youtu.be/yvD3X3RcK3Y?si=hlJuAU3S7QoEcDVi King Kong: The Practical Effects Wonder: https://youtu.be/w4sFn3Qiw9g?si=zEd9t_y4bRXaJjjR Thing From Another World Fire Burn (1951): https://youtu.be/kl-Y8ZkUenk?si=Zxj7fsRdhVMDArFW The Thing (1982) Trailer: https://youtu.be/5ftmr17M-a4?si=OpWUVNtbuwls4fj9 The Thing From Another World (1951) Trailer: https://youtu.be/EpqtGCzASAo?si=EqQXF-FUmhclQIwP Red Dawn (1984) Trailer: https://youtu.be/HZJMZapC8NQ?si=rOtEOKe4Kh3HnWlE Red Dawn (2012) Trailer: https://youtu.be/nGoe7BdGdlg?si=90pbTPYz-1d6ldtZ TAMMFF Film Freeway: https://filmfreeway.com/TAMMFF FILM FIGHTS WITH FRIENDS Do you listen to our show as an audio podcast? Give video a try. Subscribe to our YouTube for the video version with awesome behind the scenes pics and video! https://www.youtube.com/@FilmFightsFriendsPod?sub_confirmation=1 Dig the show? Consider supporting our Patreon. There are some cool perks! http://patreon.com/FilmFightsFriendsPodcast Join our e-mail list! Hit us up here: [email protected] Instagram: http://instagram.com/FilmFightsFriendsPod http://instagram.com/FightsWithFriendsPod Facebook: http://facebook.com/FilmFightsFriendsPod mailto:facebook.com/@FightsWithFriendsPod Steve’s Instagram: http://Instagram.com/sambosteve http://instagram.com/sambosteve Steve’s IMDB: http://imdb.me/stephenkoepfer Paul’s Instagram: http://Instagram.com/KravMagaChef http://instagram.com/KravMagaChef Paul’s IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm8062990/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1 Breakfall Studios’ Instagram: http://Instagram.com/breakfallstunts http://instagram.com/breakfallstunts SPONSORS Stunt Contact https://stuntcontact.com/ Stunt Access https://stuntaccess.com/ PRODUCERS Executive Producers: Stephen Koepfer Paul Varacchi Produced by: Press Record Studios -Matthew Kaplowitz -Richard Butler -Andrea Levine http://www.pressrecordstudios.com Video Editor Matthew Kaplowitz Original music by: Ahrue Luster Brought to you by Breakfall Studios ®Film Fights With Friends LLC

Transcript

0:00
1:36:56

17,136 words · 4 speakers

Topics

  • The Thing
  • The Thing (1982)
  • Shogun
  • Dune
  • The Thing from Another World
  • Man on Fire
  • Esquire magazine
  • New York City
  • The Thing (2011)
  • Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated