What Labour’s Capital Gains Tax Would Actually Cost You
- 17m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode examines the potential impact of Labour's proposed 28% capital gains tax on residential and commercial property investors in New Zealand. The host Stephen Knight and the guest Andrew Nichol analyze a hypothetical 10-year property holding to calculate tax liabilities, examining how deductions like acquisition costs, sales expenses, and accumulated losses alter the net tax paid. They also evaluate strategic adjustments investors might make, such as shifting towards yield-focused properties, purchasing more properties to offset reduced gains, or holding properties across generations to utilize inheritance exemptions.
- Investors can choose to rely on the government ratable value or obtain a registered valuation to set a tax baseline when the policy starts. 6:02
- Accumulated losses and transaction costs can significantly reduce the effective capital gains tax liability below the nominal 28% rate. 2:58
- Inherited properties are exempt from the proposed capital gains tax, creating strong incentives for intergenerational holding. 1:23
- Meeting specific long-term wealth goals under a capital gains tax regime may require purchasing approximately 40 percent more property. 8:18
Chapters
- 0:08Podcast Introduction and Episode Overview
Hosts introduce the show and outline the discussion about Labour’s proposed capital gains tax.
- 0:59Explaining the 28% Flat Capital Gains Tax
Hosts break down the basic mechanics, exemptions, and start date of the new tax.
- 1:42Calculating Tax on Future Gains and Deductions
Illustrates how future gains are taxed and how acquisition costs and losses can reduce the taxable amount.
- 6:48Valuation Strategies and Council Rate Trade‑Offs
Discusses using registered valuations to lower tax liability and the cost of higher council rates.
- 9:12Strategic Property Acquisition Under the New Tax
Explores how the tax might shift preferences toward yield properties and affect long‑term investment plans.
- 13:19Adjusting Wealth‑Building Tactics and Intergenerational Planning
Considers holding properties longer, using reverse mortgages, and inheritance strategies to avoid tax.
- 14:55Effects on Flippers, Developers, and Market Dynamics
Examines whether the tax benefits or burdens flippers and developers under the bright‑line test.
- 15:50Historical Context and Political Landscape
Hosts reflect on the repeated proposals for capital gains tax and the political frequency of such debates.
- 16:55Episode Wrap‑Up and Call to Action
Hosts summarize key points, encourage listeners to subscribe, and preview future episodes.
Highlights
- 0:59
Proposed 28% Flat Tax Ratedata
The proposed capital gains tax introduces a flat 28% rate on residential and commercial property profits starting in July 2027. Family homes, farms, and inherited properties are exempt from the tax, and gains are only taxed from the policy's implementation date forward.
- 1:42
A property purchased for $700,000 that appreciates by 5% annually over 10 years yields a $440,000 capital gain. At a 28% tax rate, the resulting bill to the IRD would be $123,000, leaving the investor with $316,000.
- 5:00
Deductions Reduce Effective Taxstrategy
While Labour's initial policy document omits certain deductions like sales costs and accumulated losses, including them changes the numbers. In a modeled scenario incorporating losses and transaction expenses, the actual tax paid drops from $123,000 to $78,000.
- 5:57
Valuation Baseline Incentivesinsight
Because past gains are exempt, property owners have a strong incentive to secure a high registered valuation on the day the legislation starts to minimize future taxable gains. However, a higher ratable value can also lead to increased annual council rates.
- 8:18
Buying More Property To Compensatestrategy
If capital gains are taxed, investors aiming for specific wealth targets may need to increase their portfolio size by about 40 percent. For instance, an investor needing three properties would require roughly 4.2 properties to bridge the same wealth gap.
- 9:39
Growth Versus Yield Propertiesdata
Comparing growth properties and yield properties over a 15-year horizon shows that growth properties still earn significantly more total profit even after paying the capital gains tax, though their outsized advantage is reduced.
- 12:56
Intergenerational Wealth Strategiesstrategy
Since inherited properties are exempt from the tax, aging parents and their children may use intergenerational financial support so the parents can avoid selling properties and triggering the tax liability before death.
Quotes
“So if you look at how much you'd actually pay, right, let's say that you bought a $700,000 property, you purchased it like the day the capital gains tax comes in. So all of your future gains are going to be taxed, right?”
Unnamed speaker · 1:42 “It does exclude things like improvements and acquisition costs. So that's the thing that Labour have actually released about an eight page document, having some of the details about the policy.”
Unnamed speaker · 2:58 “So if the capital gains are now taxed, does that change the maths? Does it make yield properties more attractive?”
Unnamed speaker · 9:30 “If you sell it now, you're going to pay 250 grand worth of tax. Actually, I'd rather just maybe even borrow against my house, give you the money so you can live your life.”
Unnamed speaker · 13:29
About this episode
Labour wants a 28% tax on the profit when you sell an investment property. So we built a spreadsheet ... not to argue whether it’s fair, just to answer one question. If you buy a property, what does the bill actually look like? In this episode, Ed and Andrew run the numbers on a 28% CGT in plain English. You’ll learn: What actually happens if Labour’s capital gains tax comes in The bill you’d actually receive, and can you legally minimise itHow it changes which property you buyThe lesson? A CGT wouldn’t kill the maths, but it changes the game most for anyone planning to switch from growth to yield at retirement. Let us know your thoughts by leaving us a voice message on the Property Academy Hotline https://www.speakpipe.com/PropertyAcademy For more from Opes Partners: https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upStay ahead of the NZ property market https://www.opespartners.co.nz/private-property-sign-up?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=promo&utm_campaign=pp_signupInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript
3,509 words · 2 speakers
Topics
- Opes Partners
- New Zealand
- Heartland Bank
- Auckland
- Wealth Plan
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated