Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast The Aussie Tax Trap That Could Hit Kiwi Property Investors⎟Ep. 2449 About this episode Australia is overhauling investor tax rules ... and some Kiwi property owners could get caught in the crossfire.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down Australia’s proposed changes to capital gains tax and negative gearing, including why some investors could end up paying significantly more tax… even on New Zealand properties.
You’ll learn:
How Australia just doubled it’s capital gains tax The fish-hooks that mean you could pay this extra tax … even if your’re a kiwi Could this spread to New ZealandTax rules don’t stop at borders. If you live, work, or plan to move overseas, your property strategy can quickly become more complicated than most investors realise ... especially when governments start changing the rules.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how Australia just doubled its capital gains tax and what it means for Kiwi investors, the fish hooks that mean you could pay this extra tax even if you're a Kiwi, and could this spread to New Zealand? Now, Australia has just made the biggest changes to property investor taxes in 30 years, but what's really changed? Well, the Australians are getting rid of both negative gearing and increasing their capital gains tax. Now, even if you've never bought an investment property in Australia, these changes still matter. Now, let's talk about what's changing, Andrew.
0:57 Speaker 00 Start with the capital gains tax because the Australians had quite a unique way of taxing your capital gains.
1:06 Speaker 01 They've had a capital gains tax and the way it works is if you hold a property for more than 12 months and then you sell it, then you pay the normal tax rate that you pay, your income tax rate on half of the gain. So say you sold a property and made 200 grand, then half of that, $100,000, that's going to be at your tax rate. Now, your tax rate could be 47%. So if that's the case, you're going to pay $47,000 on your $200,000 profit, which means the effective rate that you're paying on that profit is 23.5%. Now, there are two new rules from the 1st of July 27. First, there is no 50% discount. You're going to pay tax on the whole profit, not half of it, the whole profit.
1:50 Speaker 01 But the interesting thing is it's inflation adjusted. So I'll talk to you about how that works in a second, but the second new rule is that there's a new minimum of 30% tax rate on all capital gains.
2:04 Speaker 00 So basically, if your tax rate on your income was lower than that, you know, let's say it was 20%, well- Well, you'd still pay a minimum of thirty percent. So even if you're a low income earner, you could pay an outsized amount of your income on this capital gains tax. Now, interestingly, this only applies to new purchases after July twenty twenty seven. So you could still be buying up a storm of Australian property up until that date, because anything before that is still under the old rules. And I think that's why when I've been scrolling on my Instagram, looking at my favourite Australian financial creators, there's this wonderful trend at the moment where people are posting photos with Anthony Albanese,
2:46 Speaker 00 the Prime Minister of Australia, announcing that he's their new business partner, because he's going to take potentially, call it half the gains, without taking any of the risk. So the Australian government's going to effectively be your new business partner. But that inflation indexation is really interesting in terms of how it works. So an adverse example before, you sold a property for seven hundred K that you bought for five hundred K. You paid forty seven grand. Now, under the new rules, let's say that you bought a property, again for five hundred K, you sold it five years later for seven hundred K. But over those five years, there'd been an average of two and a half percent inflation per year. So the way the new rules will work is the tax department would say,
3:31 Speaker 00 if the property went up in value with inflation, it would be worth five hundred and sixty six grand. So the real increase, the increase above inflation is seven hundred K minus the five hundred and sixty seven grand. And that gets you to a hundred and thirty four thousand dollars. And they would then say, okay, you are going to pay tax, in this example, at forty seven percent, on that hundred and thirty four thousand dollar gain, which is about sixty three grand. So your effective tax rate has gone from twenty three percent to thirty two percent. So it's gone up by about fifty percent in this example.
4:09 Speaker 01 So I think I need to pay more.
4:11 Speaker 00 Yes, so you pay more tax because your whole gain is taxable. So rather than half your, your gain not being taxable. They're saying the small proportion of any gain that is base of inflation, that's not taxable. It's quite funny when politicians change the rules like this. And it does obscure what's really happening because there's a lot, lot of moving parts in terms of what how much comes from inflation. But in this example, the investor would pay about an extra eight to nine percentage points worth of tax.
4:43 Speaker 01 And will it be the actual inflation rate year on year?
4:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, the inflation rate from when you bought to when you sold.
4:49 Speaker 01 God, that's going to be quite complicated. Accountants are going to have a lot more billable hours.
4:55 Speaker 00 Now, the other thing that we were just talking off the air about is the capital gains changes is not just for property. This isn't just targeted towards investment properties. This is businesses, this is shares, this is holiday homes, right?
5:08 Speaker 01 Hmm. And I know that there's a big push now. I've seen Nicola Willis, our finance minister, on a few interviews, talking to business owners over in Australia or people that are about to start businesses. Saying come and do it in New Zealand. We don't have a capital gains tax. And we've got the government that's trying to limit the amount of red tape and allow people to be innovative. So there might be a bit of a shift in, in the business community.
5:31 Speaker 00 The other thing is that in some cases, this rule could actually be beneficial and mean that you pay less tax. So let's say you bought an asset, and this is a property podcast, so you bought a property. You held it for five years and let's say inflation averaged at five percent and your property went up in value by five percent. You could then sell it and not pay any capital gains tax at all because house prices didn't outpace inflation in that example. But you would still get the benefit of having leverage on your property. So there is a scenario where you could theoretically make some good gains and pay less tax. But let's talk about the negative gearing changes well.
6:12 Speaker 01 So the way it works in Australia is if you make a hundred K from your salary and you've got a rental property that you're making a 10 K loss on, and that could be a paper loss, not just a cash flow loss, the tax department says, okay, you, we're going to treat this as if you only made 90,000 from your salary because we're going to deduct that loss from your income. So they give you the tax back on that 10 K chunk of your salary. So your tax refund could be kind of $3,000. Now, the new rules from the 1st of July 27, negative gearing for existing property is gone. So they're getting the same, they're getting the same rules that we have here in New Zealand and have had for a number of years. Now, there's one exception. New builds still get full negative
6:55 Speaker 01 gearing. And they also get the old rules on the capital gains tax. So, so the government is trying to incentivize adding stock to the market rather than buying existing stock. Exactly the same as what we do here in New Zealand with DTIs and LVR restrictions.
7:10 Speaker 00 And interestingly enough, if you own a property in Australia and you bought it, say, two years ago, you still get to use the old negative gearing rule. So there's going to be a bit of a two-tiered system. Now, Andrew, most listeners to this show aren't Australian property investors. They might just be a Kiwi living in the great town of Hawata, thinking about growing a property portfolio. So why should Kiwis even listen to this?
7:37 Speaker 01 Now, the way Australia's going to do this is they tax their residence on their worldwide income and gains. So if a Kiwi moves to Australia for work and they become an Australian tax resident, their New Zealand rental property is also subject to the new Australian rules on the New Zealand property. So it doesn't matter that you own a rental property in Auckland, it's treated with the same Australian tax rules. And this could be a trap because the Australian tax department, they don't care where the property is, they care where the owner is and where they're domiciled from a tax residency standpoint. So you could end up paying these capital gains tax even though you're a Kiwi.
8:16 Speaker 00 And there was a really interesting example that we were just talking about this week, about a Kiwi who He's living in Australia, thinking about buying a property back over here. And then they pulled the brakes on that purchase. Walk us through what happened.
8:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, so a Kiwi couple who had already moved to Australia and they're living there. They had a new build property under contract with one of our team here. And confirmation was coming up. They were doing their due diligence. They walked into an Australian tax accountant, thought we'd better get the advice around this tax side of things. They walked in very optimistic and they walked out and cancelled that contract. And the reason they did that was because they're now going to be paying capital gains tax on that New Zealand property as if it was owned in Australia because they're captured by that Australian rule.
9:01 Speaker 00 And the other thing that's quite fascinating is even if they purchased a property in New Zealand, held it for a couple of years, then moved back to New Zealand. According to their tax accountant, that would be considered deemed disposal when they leave Australia. Which basically means that when they decide to move back here, then the Australian tax department would say, well, that's as if, or we're going to treat it as if you've sold that property. And you need to pay the capital gains tax as if you have sold the property, despite the fact that you have in fact not sold the property.
9:36 Speaker 01 So what you're saying is they move back to New Zealand and want to carry on earning that property for another 20 years. They've got to pay the capital gains tax even though they still own it. How do they pay that money?
9:46 Speaker 00 Well, in that case, you'd either have to borrow it, pay it in cash, or sell the property. Now, this is where it's very important that you actually check with an accountant because it does depend on the visa you're on. Because my understanding is that exit tax situation likely doesn't apply to Kiwis on a special category visa, which is the standard New Zealand visa that that most of us honor in Australia, which is considered a temporary visa. But just check with an Australian accountant if you are purchasing a property like in New Zealand and you're living over there, or you're making any sort of investments if you're living in Australia. Because you don't want to invest thinking that you're not caught by these rules and then find out 10 years later that you actually are. So I'm not sure the exact fees that that couple were on.
10:32 Speaker 00 But the advice that they got was that these rules would apply to them. Now, there might also be some lessons for Kiwis who are currently in New Zealand and are thinking about moving to Australia.
10:42 Speaker 01 I think the number one thing, like you said before, is talking to an accountant because you want to find out what applies to you specifically. But the other thing is that new builds across the Tasman are going to have more advantages compared to older properties from a tax perspective. So here in New Zealand, we do have those benefits like lower deposits and easier to get the funding because the debt to income ratio rules don't apply. Aussies, they haven't had those same advantages. I think there was some advantages from state to state on with the stamp duties. But now they're going to actually have quite a clear distinction around some of the more significant tax rules.
11:19 Speaker 00 Now, one other thing that I've been thinking about with the the two tier system in terms of this capital gains tax is that there will likely be a lock-in effect. Just walk everyone through how that works.
11:32 Speaker 01 So Australian investors who already own established rentals are now incentivised to hold on to those properties because the moment they sell and buy something else, they lose that grandfathering benefit and they face the new capital gains tax on any properties purchased post 27. Now, the result is that, okay, I'm going to hold on to these properties and I'm not going to buy something else. I'm just going to sit on what I've got at the moment. Now you have less supply going into the second-hand market.
12:02 Speaker 00 And a good example is let's say you owned a property and you were trying to transfer like from a growth to a yield strategy. Typically, you'd say, well, I don't need that property anymore, the growth property. Let me sell that, release that to the market. I'll go buy something that suits my needs. But now you might not do that and you might hold on to that property that might not suit what your strategy now usually would be, which would be going towards something that's high yielding, but you decide to continue holding on to it to avoid that tax. That is typically what we see when capital gains taxes like this get introduced because people are not dumb. They decide to work within the rules, making the the ration. Decision for them, which just means that it's not what they would usually do in the past,
12:46 Speaker 00 right? Taxes change the incentives.
12:48 Speaker 01 I think this is pretty significant. I cannot believe, maybe it's my algorithm, but I've just been absolutely blasted with things on TikTok and Instagram around this kind of thing. So it must be seriously bothering people. So it'll be interesting to see whether or not this changes after the next election. When's that? Do you know?
13:03 Speaker 00 2028 is when they're expecting to have the next one. So after this new policy comes in, we'll see if the Liberal Party comes out and tries to argue against this or say that they'll repeal it. The other thing with this policy is that I don't think it will mean that people move away from property and decide to invest more in shares or decide to invest more in growing a business because all assets are taxed the same way under this proposal. This isn't an anti-property policy. It is more a revenue generating policy for the Australian Government. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how Australia just doubled its capital gains tax and what it means for Kiwi investors, the fish hooks that mean you could pay this
13:47 Speaker 00 extra tax even if you're a Kiwi, and whether this could spread to New Zealand. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. It really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:04 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Nine.
14:07 Speaker 01 I'm the Gomil.
14:08 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, taxes and insights to help you get the most after you see on the property market. Until next time.
Previous Can Landlords Still Say No To Pets?⎟Ep. 2448 Next OCR Holds – But Interest Rates Could Still Rise⎟Ep. 2450 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated