Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Can Landlords Still Say No To Pets?⎟Ep. 2448 About this episode A landlord said no to a tenant’s Labrador. The Tenancy Tribunal said yes.
In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack the first major Tenancy Tribunal ruling under New Zealand’s new pet laws – including what counts as a “reasonable refusal,” why the landlord lost, and what this means for rental property owners going forward. You’ll learn:
Why landlords can no longer simply say “no pets” by default The conditions the Tribunal imposed before allowing the dog What arguments are – and aren’t – likely to hold up at Tribunal Main lesson? The rules around pets have fundamentally changed. Landlords can still refuse animals in some situations… but they now need clear, evidence-based reasons that would stand up under scrutiny.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn whether landlords can still say no to pets. The first case from the tenancy tribunal about this new controversial law and the case where a landlord had to let a tenant keep what will become quite a big dog. Now, these new pet rules have been in since December 2025 and landlords can't say no to pets anymore without a valid reason or a reasonable reason. And we said back when this law first came in that we'd need to see some cases at the tenancy tribunal to see how that's enforced, to understand what a good enough reason for
0:57 Speaker 00 saying no to a pet is. Well, we've got this first case now and what happened, Andrew?
1:03 Speaker 01 So the tenant asked the landlord if they could have a puppy and it was a Labrador, so a decent sized dog. Now, they were renting a unit on the top floor of a three storey building and it had a large deck and a section at the back that they shared with other units. And the landlord said, yeah, no, I don't think that's going to be the good fit. And the tenant said, no, I'm off to the tribunal. The tribunal sided with the tenant and the pet was actually approved, but it did come with other conditions, but I was pretty surprised about that.
1:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, because if landlords refuse a pet, as I said, they must give a reason. That reason must be reasonable. This case is trying to say, well, what does reasonable actually mean? So does this mean that tenants get a free pass for pets?
1:48 Speaker 01 Well, before the law came in, the landlord could just say, no, I don't want pets in my property, so that's my hard and fast rule. But after the law changed, the default has flipped. The starting answer is now yes. And if the landlord doesn't want to have a pet there, they have to give reasonable reason as to why the answer would be no.
2:06 Speaker 00 So just come back to this Labrador for a second, because I would understand what really happened.
2:11 Speaker 01 So the landlord said, in my mind, and I'm just reading this, so I can't see the place, but it sounds like the property isn't really suitable for a big dog like this, and that's what the landlord said. Now, that's because, you know, it was a small upstairs flat with no outdoor access. Labradors, they're big dogs. But the tenancy tribunal said, well, yeah, those are fear concerns, but they can actually be mitigated.
2:34 Speaker 00 And if we look at some of those conditions, the tenant said that, well, maybe there could be a trial period, or maybe they could get support from their neighbour who was willing to chip in and make sure that they could look after the dog. And the tenancy tribunal said that an unfenced or small property can still be suitable for a small, well behaved or house-trained dog. And while Labradors can grow big, it's a small puppy at the moment. The other thing they said is, okay, we understand that your property is quite close to your neighbours, and they might get a bit effed off if the dog keeps on barking. But actually, what you need to do as a landlord and property manager is do an assessment
3:17 Speaker 00 of the actual property, the neighbourhood, and of the specific dog and its breed, how well-trained the dog is, and if it's actually going to bark, rather than say, I've got these general concerns about dogs, you've got to assess the specific dog. So the property manager came back and said, okay, well, we're really worried that the dog's going to disturb the neighbours, that there's going to be a risk of damage to the deck, because often the dog's going to be outside on the deck, and there's a bit of a safety risk, because the dog could slip through the railings of the deck, it could easily squeeze through it, and it doesn't have a secure exercise or toilet area. The tribunal came back and said, but that could be addressed with reasonable conditions,
4:00 Speaker 00 so a pet bond, or what if the tenants pay for some mats on the outdoor deck, or put up a protective barrier around the deck railing to make sure the dog doesn't fall through the gaps there. Maybe the dog always has to be supervised when it's in the communal bank. Yard and the carpet, perhaps that needs to be cleaned professionally and flea treated at the end of the tenancy. Now, these are a lot of, a lot of conditions, but the tenant has signed up for it. And so I think the lesson here is if you're a landlord and get these kinds of requests, this is the level of detail you've got to go into in terms of offering reasonable conditions. So rather than saying, I want to say no, it's almost like, what would I need in order to be able to say yes?
4:45 Speaker 00 And actually, I know our team has a case in front of the tribunal. We expecting to get a decision next week. What is happening here?
4:54 Speaker 01 So in this instance, the property that we're talking about that's being rented is a two bedroom townhouse with a small garden, like 20 square metres. Now, the pet being requested is a large breed dog. Now, the landlord wants to say no because in their mind, the dog is too big for the property and they're worried about noise and damage and disruption to the neighbours. Now, it's going to the tribunal next week and we'll possibly report back on what happens. But judging by the one that we've just used as an example, I'm wondering whether or not this is going to be approved.
5:27 Speaker 00 Well, the approach that we've tried to take at Opus Property Management is to walk that fine line, that balance line between tenants and landlords. So there's a number of cases where tenants have requested pets, the landlords have wanted to say no. We've had to say to the landlords, actually, under these new laws, the reasons that you're given wouldn't stand up at the tenancy tribunal. So take the pet bond, let's work on some reasonable conditions because you kind of have to say yes now because the law's changed. But in this instance, we believe we've actually got quite a strong case because the dog is quite a large dog. There isn't that big of a space in the backyard. We didn't believe that there were reasonable conditions we could put in place to make the property suitable.
6:10 Speaker 00 And just keep in mind as well that if there is a residence association or body corporate that bans pets or bans dogs in your property or, or in the, the area, then that overrides this law as well. So I wonder whether this. Going to be an incentive. Oh, you're going to say that too.
6:29 Speaker 01 Just about to say that. I guarantee you might start to see a lot of landlords who sit on body corporates. Saying, well, why don't we actually put some restrictions in here because maybe it's not them necessarily that it's affecting. But they might have, um, your dogs barking next door and they might not want to put off tenants. But that will probably be something we see more of. I wonder what happens if that's done retrospectively, right? So say I've got a unit in a development. I think, oh, those neighbours are being a bit pesty with that, that dog. We vote to have no pets anymore. Does that person have to then get rid of the pet? Cause that would be pretty sad for that owner, right? But similarly, like the comment around, you know, with the Labrador example, once the Labrador is there, like there is no
7:12 Speaker 01 trial period with a pet. Once you've had the pet and you've, you know, decided you love it, you can't just take it away from someone six months later.
7:20 Speaker 00 Well, I agree with you in practice. Let's come back to theory for a moment. When I was talking to Tiffany, who runs our property management team, she was saying that if you give consent to a tenant to have a pet and that you find that it is a nuisance or it is causing damage. You can revoke the consent with a reason. So even if you have accepted a pet at the start, it doesn't mean you're necessarily stuck with a pet for the next two years. Now that might be what the laws technically say, but I'm a bit sceptical, Andrew, and think, well, if you have approved a pet for two years, then you go to the tenancy tribunal. The tribunal might say, oh no.
8:00 Speaker 00 Now there's an emotional connection between the pet and the owner and the tenant can't possibly consider giving up their emotional support dog. And it's a bit like the, the case I remember we talked about where before these rules came into effect, there was a tenant who got a pet. It was a dog. The landlord said, no dogs, no dogs. They decided to get it anyway. After six months, they go to tribunal, the landlord's trying to say there are no pets, that's on the tenancy agreement. But now the kids of the tenant has formed an emotional connection to the dog and the dog's allowed to stay with conditions. And that's just to say that landlords don't have as much control around pets as they perhaps once did. Having said that, here's what I want to get your take on, right?
8:45 Speaker 00 So I've got a property and the tenant has two cats in it, which is probably totally suitable, right? So that's fine. And then they wanted to get a third cat. I just thought, how many cats are suitable for a two bedroom property?
8:59 Speaker 01 I mean, you know, my, my position on cats is more the merrier.
9:03 Speaker 00 Oh, you're just a crazy cat lady.
9:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. I'm basically a couple of years off just being a recluse with a bunch of cats. But I do think that, you know, often when you see people with three or more cats, they're probably the type of people that will allow kind of more, more damage to happen. Like that is an absolute generalisation. But anywhere that I've been to where people have got more than three or more cats, it smells like cat piss. And just quickly, you know, the things that are not going to be considered reasonable for refusing a pet are things like, I don't like dogs. Now that's me. I don't like dogs as much as I like cats. But my personal preference doesn't make a lick of difference to the law. Another one that people might want to consider is if you've just settled a brand new property
9:47 Speaker 01 and you think, well, it's brand new, the carpet's new, that's also tough luck. That's why you can take a pet bond now. And also past experiences, I remember one of our property advisers, Ben King, went to go and rent a property in Kashmir. He already had a cat and the landlord, who's actually a well-known landlord from Christchurch, said, absolutely not. I had a bad experience with a cat 13 years ago. No cats ever. You can have something else, but never having a cat. So that doesn't stand up either.
10:17 Speaker 00 And if you're a landlord, try to work out what to do with all of these pets. Or you want to talk to someone about it. You might like to get in touch with our team at Opus Property Management. If you Google Opus Property Management, it'll be the first thing that comes up. If you click the big orange button, you can request a free rental appraisal and book in a chat with our team. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned can landlords still say no to pets? The first case from the Tennessee tribunal about this controversial law and the case where a landlord had to let a tenant keep a dog. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
10:56 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
10:59 Speaker 01 How do you like them?
10:59 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the use on the property market. Until next time.
Previous Should NZ Have a Capital Gains Tax?⎟Ep. 2447 Next The Aussie Tax Trap That Could Hit Kiwi Property Investors⎟Ep. 2449 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated