Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Sell It or Rent It? The 3-Step Framework for Making the Right Choice⎥Ep. 2254 About this episode You’ve built equity in your first home, so should you sell it or keep it as a rental when you upgrade? In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down one of the biggest questions homeowners face, revealing when keeping your home as an investment makes sense … and when it’s a trap in disguise. You’ll learn:How to tell if your home would make a good investment propertyThe mistake that makes investors think their rental is profitable (when it’s not)How to compare your current home to other potential investmentsEd and Andrew show why the best decision isn’t always the obvious one, and how running the numbers properly can mean the difference between a solid investment and a financial drain. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Dye.
0:12 Speaker 01 I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, should you keep your own home as a rental property? How to tell if your current home would actually make a good investment property? And the mistakes that investors make time and time again that you'll want to avoid. And this is such a classic situation that Kiwis often find themselves in, especially if your house price has gone up or your house value has gone up since you purchased it. So you bought your first home and you've paid off some of the mortgage. It's gone up in value and now you're thinking, oh, maybe when we buy our next property, maybe we could just keep the one we're currently living in, our first home as a rental property. Now, what do you think about this, Andrew?
0:57 Speaker 00 Is it a good idea?
0:59 Speaker 01 Well, it definitely depends, which I know is a terrible answer, but we'll tell you what it depends on. It depends on whether or not that property is a good rental property. So you've got to ask yourself, well, would I actually go out and buy this property as a rental property? Or am I just doing it for convenience? And I get why people get a bit misled in their head around the numbers. Like if you've bought your first home and it's gone up in value and you've paid off some of the mortgage. So you've got a whole lot of equity in it. When you look at the numbers, you think, okay, the rent would cover that mortgage because the mortgage is so small. And people think, oh, I don't want to pay a real estate agent, I'll just keep it.
1:32 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I suppose the other thing is the convenience of saying, well, we've been thinking for a while about getting an investment property. If we just keep this one, well, then we've got an investment property. And we know that it's an okay house because we've been living in it. So maybe it's going to be okay. But I do think the mistake that people make is exactly what you just said. As they look at that house, they say, the mortgage is 300K because we've paid it down. The rent's going to be 600 bucks a week. Well, well, the rent's going to cover the mortgage, it's going to pay for itself. It looks cash flow positive, but it's only because you're looking at it with the current mortgage today. And then the other mistake they make is Then they go buy their new house, they take out a massive mortgage against this new house that they're going to live in.
2:16 Speaker 00 And then they've got this massive personal mortgage that is costing them so much. Meanwhile, the rental is almost debt free and that can just give the the wrong impression, right? And now, why is that just such a a catch to watch out for?
2:30 Speaker 01 Well, it the cash flow might look good, but that's not because it's a great investment property. It's just because the mortgage is tiny, but the overall portfolio with that kind of structure is pretty weak because you've got this massive personal mortgage. And then a tiny mortgage on the investment property.
2:44 Speaker 00 And that can do a couple of things. Number one is your personal mortgage is not tax deductible. So typically, the most efficient structure from a tax perspective is to have a small personal mortgage. And a large investment mortgage, assuming that you want to have that amount of debt. You know, for instance, if you've got eight hundred thousand dollars worth of mortgages in total. You will pay less tax if those mortgages are against the investment properties rather than your personal own home. But because people often do this, keep their own home as a rental and then go buy a different house. We often see that people make that mistake. They've got this mammoth personal mortgage.
3:26 Speaker 00 But then the rental looks like it's covering itself, but actually it's just very inefficient. And I'll give you some examples of what this actually looks like. So I've been looking at it, Andrew, as if we were living in Christchurch. And we already own our own home.
3:41 Speaker 01 Is this you and me now?
3:42 Speaker 00 This has been you.
3:43 Speaker 01 Okay.
3:43 Speaker 00 We own, we own our own home and I've basically run the numbers already. So let's say that you own this property, which is in Christchurch, it's three bedrooms, one bath. So pretty standard house that you might own as like a first home buyer. It's in the suburb of Midahoe, which is, I mean, how would you describe that as a suburb since you've been living in Christchurch forever?
4:06 Speaker 01 Fairly kind of middle class suburb.
4:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, sweet. So good, good kind of first home buyer sort of house. I reckon it's worth about six hundred and forty five grand now. And let's say you bought it ten years ago when house prices were way cheaper, right? So let's call it that you've got a two hundred and fifty thousand dollar mortgage on that and you're paying that off over twenty years. Now, if you turn that into a rental property, hey, you might get six hundred bucks a week on that. Do you think that's pretty fair?
4:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, that seems reasonable.
4:35 Speaker 00 Okay, so you've got a four and a half percent gross yield. But if you logged into Opus Plus and ran the numbers, it'd look pretty good. You'd be saying, man, that rent is covering all of the mortgage costs. So you'd be getting about twenty eight grand, twenty nine grand worth of rent per year. And then on top of that, your mortgage is only costing about eighteen, nineteen thousand dollars per year. So you're thinking, God, that's pretty good. I've got to top up some of the, the like rates, bills and insurance costs just a little bit. But it might cost you sixty six bucks per week. And of course, you're paying down the debt over time. So you might think, okay, that looks pretty good. But what you've got to factor in is that if you keep having that property
5:18 Speaker 00 with that small mortgage, two hundred and fifty thousand dollars, when you want to upgrade to get into a better school zone to go buy this property, which is currently for sale in Christchurch, two hundred and twenty three Memorial Avenue, which costs just over a million bucks. If you're taking out a massive mortgage on that property, you've now got a million dollar mortgage on your own home that you're also paying off. And that's going to cost you fourteen hundred bucks a week to pay the mortgage on that as well as the rates and insurance. And so when you add it all up, the rental property might be making some okay cash flow. But your overall portfolio across those two properties is now costing you. Once you factor in the rates and the mortgages and the insurance and your rental income,
6:03 Speaker 00 it's costing you fourteen hundred and eighty three dollars per week. What do you think about that, Andrew?
6:08 Speaker 01 Quite a lot of money. And when you're paying that just out of your own personal income, that would be a bit of a stretch for most people, I think.
6:15 Speaker 00 And so what we're really trying to get you to think about is not just what the cash flow. Looks like on the investment property that you're going to keep. But what does it look like across your whole portfolio? Now, one of the things that I'd really encourage you to consider is, well, if you sold that property, your current home, and then you bought the house that you want to live in, in the better school zone and bought a different investment property, what would that look like as an investment? Because if you decide to sell and buy something else, you can set up the mortgage in a different way, right?
6:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, so what you'd probably do in that case is if you're buying a property specifically as a rental property, you're probably going to borrow a hundred percent of the money to do that using the no cash needed method. So you borrow your deposit against your house and the balance of it against the rental property. You probably split bank as well in that case. And because it's an investment property loan that you're taking out, generally speaking, you'd put that on interest only as well. So your cash flow is a little bit better and you can focus on paying down your mortgage.
7:14 Speaker 00 Now, if you were to do that though, and say, okay, let's sell the property we currently live in. Let's have a smaller personal mortgage on the new house we're going to live in, our upgraded house. And we bought a different investment property. What does that do to our cash flow? Well, rather than costing us fourteen hundred and eighty-three dollars per week, if we bought a different property that was, you know, maybe, maybe a little bit cheaper, but still investment grade, your cash flow might be about four hundred and fifty dollars a week better off. So I reckon in this situation, it might cost you eleven hundred and twenty-seven dollars per week. That's because you might have a better mortgage structure and actually be able to buy a slightly higher yielding property as well.
7:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I think that's a really important exercise to go through because I think what people don't do is consider what the alternative is and what the opportunity cost of keeping that property is. And again, like, you know, you might love living in that property and think, yeah, it's gone up in value, so it's a great investment. If you weren't going to go and buy it, if you didn't own it, then maybe you just get rid of it. And yeah, you still got to factor in the agent's fees and the timing of that. But you always want to think about investments, about getting the best return on your money.
8:24 Speaker 00 And then even if we look at the return on investment, and I am in Opus Plus kind of running these numbers. If I look at the return on investment that spat out in Opus Plus, if I kept that Kavan Place property, the first home buying property, the one that in the scenario we live in, Andrew. The return on investment is 187% over the next 15 years. Whereas if I went and leveraged up and bought this other property, you know, a different investment property that I've chucked in and run the numbers on, it's looking at about 277%, which basically means for every dollar I have to invest into the first home property, 15 years later, for every dollar I put in, I'm getting about a
9:06 Speaker 00 dollar eighty seven cents back. Whereas for this other property, for every dollar I put in, I'm getting two dollars and seventy seven cents back. So just from a straight return on investment standpoint, looks to be a little bit better. But one thing that we talked about right at the start is should you turn your own home into a rental when you upgrade? Or should you not do that? We always say, well, it kind of depends and you've got to run your numbers. Now, in the past, it's always been very difficult to run your numbers in a robust way, which is the reason why we created Opus Plus, which is our free property investment app to run these numbers for you. Now, if somebody wanted to do this exercise at home, what are the steps that they should take?
9:47 Speaker 01 So number one is go and log into your Opus Plus account. And if you haven't got this, it's free to set up. It's our property investment app that you can just log in either on your phone or online and start by adding your property in there. And then you can run a different scenario. And when you run a scenario based on that property being a rental, treat it as if you mortgage the property at the full value of it. So in that case that he was talking about before, the value 650, imagine it had a debt of 650 because if you end up keeping that property, you're going to want to structure it so that the maximum debt is against your rental property rather than your owner occupier property. Now, once you've done all that, you've got all the numbers in there, you've got the result of that property being mortgaged to the max and, and having the rental income coming in and
10:32 Speaker 01 all your costs go out, then compare it to something else. Go and find something else, be it Trade Me or another investment property and enter in those details and then put them side by side. There's a great compare properties tool in Opus Plus. We can put them both out and it will give you the main points side by side. And then you can say, yeah, those numbers are good. Or actually, this isn't actually a great investment. It was a great home for us, but it's kind of served its purpose now.
10:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, and in terms of the scenarios that I was running before, in terms of, okay, what would happen if you kept it versus buying something else? You could create a couple of scenarios for the upgraded home you're actually gonna live in. So the upgraded owner occupier. So you say, okay, what does it look like if we borrow all of the money to buy that property? And what does it look like if we sold the home we currently live in? Took the money and put it into the new house that we want to live in? And then in the dashboard, all we've been doing throughout this podcast is say, okay, well, what happens if we buy the new house with a big mortgage and keep the current home we live in? Versus if we buy this house with a smaller mortgage and buy a different investment property instead? And so it's just a way to run these numbers because these are quite complex, right?
11:43 Speaker 00 And they are quite difficult. Because New Zealand's so small, nobody had bothered to create this app. So if you haven't checked out Opus Plus, I highly recommend jumping in there and creating these different scenarios. Just so that you are able to run these in quite a robust way. Now, if you are going to turn your property into a rental, there are a couple of things that you wanna think about. So for example, my sister, she's got her own home. She decided that she was gonna turn it into a rental property because her and her partner had the opportunity to go and work on a farm for a bit where a house was provided. Now, one of the things you've got to watch out for is the healthy home standards. So I know it cost them a couple of grand to upgrade that property to become healthy homes compliant.
12:25 Speaker 00 Now, that might mean you've got to get a heat pump in the lounge. That might mean that you've got to get a healthy homes assessor in who then says, okay, there are a few drafts coming in from the garage into the lounge. And so therefore you need to put some stuff in to stop those drafts coming in. In fact, there are five healthy home standards that you've got to meet. And so you wanna say, well, where are we falling down and what would we need to upgrade the home for? And that can cost a couple of grand. You're also gonna wanna think about whether you wanna change the ownership structure, moving it into a trust or company so that if you take out a larger mortgage, that's actually kosher from the IRD's perspective. And then you'll also wanna think about some of the quirks of your property. Because you know how sometimes when you live in a property, there are little quirks that you just live with?
13:09 Speaker 01 You know how to, you know how to get the window open if you just jiggle it this way.
13:15 Speaker 00 Whereas you might want to fix that before a tenant moves in. And because of all of that, that's why in reality, it can sometimes make more sense to just sell that property, pay the real estate agent fee and buy a higher yielding investment property instead. But what are the main lessons here for you, Andrew?
13:32 Speaker 01 I think that the main thing is, don't just assume that the property that you live in, because it's gone up in value, that it's going to make a great investment and focus on the numbers. But when you're doing the numbers, when you're actually running the numbers and analysing through Opus Plus or however you're going to do it, do it as if you're fully leveraged, as if you had a 100% debt on that property. So that way you can compare everything, you can compare apples with apples when you're looking at other alternatives. Now, if you're comparing your property as a rental property and the debt's really low, and you're looking at another property with 100% debt, the numbers are just going to be skewed. So you want to make sure you're consistent with your assumptions. Don't just look at the surface level cash flow, because again, sometimes, once you've
14:15 Speaker 01 actually analysed this property, it might be that the best outcome, sell that property, reinvest the money. Because I see situations all the time where people, if they just sold their old property, paid off their personal debt and reinvested any extra cash that's left over, they'd end up in a way better position.
14:31 Speaker 00 And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned should you keep your own home as a rental, how to tell if your current home would be a good investment, and some of the mistakes investors really need to avoid. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get that message out to more people.
14:52 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Atknight.
14:55 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Dickle.
14:56 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, hacks and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous Downsizing Your Home: Smart Retirement Plan or Risky Bet?⎥Ep. 2252 Next The New Law That Will Change Renting in New Zealand⎥Ep. 2255 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated