Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Downsizing Your Home: Smart Retirement Plan or Risky Bet?⎥Ep. 2252 About this episode Many Kiwis plan to sell the family home and buy something smaller to fund retirement. But does downsizing still work in 2025, or is it another myth about ageing gracefully? In this episode, Ed and Andrew explore when downsizing pays off and when it leaves you short. You’ll learn:3 reasons downsizing fails and 4 times it actually worksHow timing (before 72) can make or break your planWhy some retirees walk away with less than $200k after sellingWhether you’re dreaming of a smaller home or wondering if you’ve left it too late, this episode shows what it really takes to retire comfortably in New Zealand. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seb McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Jekyll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn, can you still use downsizing to pay for your retirement? The three times that downsizing fails, but the four times that it still works? And why some Kiwis just won't get as much money as they think? And the reason I wanted to talk about this is that retiring comfortably in New Zealand can cost almost a million dollars or more for a couple. If you want a pretty comfortable lifestyle, living in one of the major cities. But the average Kiwi actually spends more money than they earn and never end up saving enough. And that's why, you know, a lot of Kiwis do plan. But there is one source of wealth that a lot of Kiwis have, which is the money or the equity
0:58 Speaker 00 within their own homes, which is why you might be planning to downsize to fund your retirement. Now, Andrew, what is downsizing and how does it work?
1:06 Speaker 01 So as couples have children and they, you know, want a bit more space at home, they tend to get bigger houses and in your 40s, that might be the kind of time you do it. Then you get into your later parts of your work life and your kids have left home. Maybe you don't need as much space and you think, okay, well, maybe we don't need this big house anymore. So we're going to downsize. You sell your family home, let's say you sell that for 900,000. You buy a smaller house because it's just you and your partner now. So you buy that for 600,000. Now you've got 300,000 left over. You put that in the bank and that's towards your million dollars that you need for retirement. Now, it kind of makes sense because most New Zealanders, we've got a whole bunch of money tied up in our own home. But having been a financial advisor for the last 20 years, it's often not that simple.
1:50 Speaker 01 And the numbers don't work out quite as glossy as people imagine.
1:53 Speaker 00 So let's talk about when it doesn't work as well as you'd think it would be. What are the three times it doesn't work out quite as you'd expect?
2:00 Speaker 01 I think the biggest thing is the sales cost. People forget about the fact that it costs to sell a house. And by the time you factor in a real estate agent, a lawyer, maybe some repairs and maintenance, some marketing, it all kind of chips away at the amount you're going to get. So the example I gave you before, that $900,000 house, let's say you sell it to buy that $600,000 house. And you're thinking, I'm going to have $300,000. Okay. Well, let's think about the fact that. We normally say it costs you about five percent to sell a property. Five percent of the home value. So on that nine hundred thousand dollar property, that's forty five thousand dollars that you're gonna take out. So now, take the forty five thousand off the nine hundred thousand. Once I've bought my new property, that's only two hundred and fifty five thousand dollars left over.
2:43 Speaker 01 Minus anything that I spend on the new property. So one thing that I always see is that people end up spending a little bit extra on some new furniture or some new appliances, that kind of thing. And actually, according to research, only one in ten older sellers are left with more than two hundred thousand after all their costs have been absorbed.
3:02 Speaker 00 So for about ninety percent of people, even if you do downsize, you're gonna get less than two hundred K. Now that, yeah, hundred and fifty, hundred and sixty K, if that's what you get, that can still be a meaningful part of your retirement. But if we're aiming for a million bucks in the bank so you can retire well, according to Massa University's research as a couple, then actually it's gonna cover less than twenty percent of that money that you need. And I know the second thing that you sometimes see is that people buy a smaller house, but the smaller house doesn't have that much of a smaller price.
3:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, all of the time I see people say, okay, well, I've got, I've got this house now. It's a big old house. I'm gonna sell that and buy something, you know, lower maintenance. Well, they end up spending more money on that lower maintenance property, even though it's smaller, it might cost them the same amount or even in some cases more. The other thing that I see quite often is people might have kids around the country. And so I'm working with someone right now and they're, they're living in Auckland right now. They've got a big old house. They're gonna sell that, buy an apartment in Auckland. But they also wanna get something in Queenstown so that they can go between the two cities and see both sets of kids. Now, as a result, they're gonna end up with probably actually having to chip money in rather than downsizing and ending up with money left over.
4:15 Speaker 00 Well, it's funny, I was actually talking to a couple who live in St. Heliers. And they've got kind of. I'm gonna say like the average house in St Heliers, which is worth a couple of million bucks. Cause St Heliers is a really nice suburb. Now, if they wanna sell that and buy a smaller and they wanna, they wanna newer house. Because they want something that is less maintenance, a bit, bit warmer, a bit nicer. Even if they buy a smaller house, it's gonna cost basically the same amount of money. So even if they downsize in terms of the space of the property. Because they wanna build a quality house, it's gonna cost them roughly the same amount of money. But what's the third reason that sometimes downsizing doesn't work as well as you think?
4:54 Speaker 01 I think that's when people kind of hold off actually doing it. They don't do it quick enough. Or actually, they may never move. So moving isn't just a financial decision. Yep, the, the money left over, that's a financial decision. But you tend to have quite an emotional tie to a property that you've lived in and raised your kids in. And so as a result, people kick the can down the road quite a lot. In fact, I'm actually working with some people right now. Who they need as much money as they can get. And one of the suggestions I made to them is, are you gonna downsize at some stage? Their house is worth like three or four million dollars in Auckland. They're gonna, they're gonna very valuable house. Now, the only problem is, she is very emotionally tied to this property. And so whilst they know it's the right economic thing to do, because they need the money.
5:38 Speaker 01 They are gonna have a real challenge getting on the same page of when they're going to sell that property.
5:44 Speaker 00 And that's cause what, they would have raised their kids in there, they had all their family Christmases there. They've had so many memories. Oh, don't you remember when little Daisy was three years old? And she took her first steps? Is that when kids take their first steps, Andrew?
5:55 Speaker 01 I have no idea. And then, and also remember they've spent all this money on renovations. So they've made it the house of their dreams. And now they, they feel like they wanna enjoy the house of their dreams for as long as possible.
6:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I saw one study that said if you don't downsize by the age of seventy two. You basically don't do it. Because then you're at the stage where, oh, I'm too old to move. I can't be bothered moving. And then the only time you actually downsize is when either you financially must now do it. And you're in a bit of a tougher position. Or when you've got some health complications and now you're off to a retirement village. So the studies show us, if you're gonna do it, you need to do it in the first. Early couple of years of retirement when you're well enough and able enough to actually do that.
6:37 Speaker 01 Imagine moving house at seventy two, it's bad enough now.
6:40 Speaker 00 Oh, my back's bad enough to pick up the chest of drawers. Come on, Andy.
6:45 Speaker 01 Hold.
6:46 Speaker 00 Not a chance. Use your back. No, not that much of your back. And the other thing you've got to just consider is that if you are planning to downsize to fund your retirement and then you never end up doing it, you are going to have to live on less money than you otherwise would. You won't be able to live the same retirement lifestyle that you would actually otherwise do. But there are some times that downsizing can work because I don't want to say that, hey, this never works because it does for some people. You know, what are kind of the four times where you see it really works?
7:19 Speaker 01 Our first one is if you've got low debt or mortgage free. So if you're free and clear of your mortgage, you've paid that off during your work life. Then you're more likely to have more wealth when you downsize. So let's say you take a million dollar property this time and you sell it, pay your real estate agents, your lawyers. You end up buying that six hundred thousand dollar property. If you've got no mortgage, you could be left with three hundred and fifty thousand dollars. But if you have a two hundred thousand dollar mortgage still on your house, well, that erodes pretty quickly and you're only left with one fifty. So lower debt or no debt, that's really going to help you out.
7:50 Speaker 00 But similarly, downsizing could help you clear your mortgage if you've still got a small one left. The other one is if your house is really, really, really expensive, you know, and that way you can step down, buy a cheaper property. I'll give you an example. I know somebody, this example's going to shock you, but this person's very wealthy. They've got a fifteen million dollar house in Auckland. It is very, very expensive. And part of their retirement plan is to sell it and move to a five million dollar house. Now, if you move to a five million dollar house, that is still a very, very, very, very, very nice house, like top one percent in New Zealand type of house. But for them, that is some genuine downsizing because it's going to free up millions and millions of dollars. Now, if you sell a million dollar house and buy an eight hundred thousand dollar house, there's not as much of a difference.
8:35 Speaker 00 So you're not going to come away with as much left over once all the fees are paid. Now, I'm not suggesting that the solution. As we all go buy fifteen million dollar houses, pay down the mortgage and move to five million dollar houses. But I'm just using that as an example of some real genuine downsizing. If you sell a two million dollar house and buy a one million dollar house, if you're in the position to be lucky enough to have that option, you know, that's some genuine downsizing. And I suppose another example of genuine downsizing is kind of the third time it works.
9:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, which is when you move location. So we see this all the time, particularly places like Auckland. If you're in a really high value area and you're going to sell your property and move to a similar property, but in a different, more affordable location like Tauranga, often you'll see that that will be a good way of ending up with money. Now, what you don't want to have happen is like one of my clients at the moment, they're thinking about moving from Auckland to Queenstown. Again, if you do that, you're probably going to spend the same money or even more. You're not going to end up with cash left over. But if you go to Tauranga, Nelson, one of those smaller regions that are more affordable, you could even get like for like without having to spend like for like.
9:39 Speaker 00 I mean, Tauranga is not that much more affordable than Auckland. It's more affordable, but like it's still pretty expensive.
9:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:45 Speaker 00 But sometimes what I've seen is people move from like New Plymouth to Tikiwiti. Now, Tikiwiti is a very, very small town in the Waikato where houses are very, very cheap. Like if you sold an expensive property in New Plymouth and moved to Tikiwiti, you'd still have the nicest house and a million bucks left over.
10:02 Speaker 01 I don't know if many people are moving from that to that though, are they, do you think? But then, of course, the other thing to remember is if you've set up all your, your life in an area like Auckland, you know, your restaurants and bars that you like to go to, you've got all your friends and family there. All of a sudden, moving to the middle of nowhere must be pretty depressing.
10:18 Speaker 00 Well, that's the trade off, right? And if you don't want to have to downsize to that degree, you invest more so that you don't have to and you can stay in the place that you know and love. But I suppose the fourth time it really works is if you do downsize before you hit that age of seventy two. Because as I said, if you stay in your home after you hit seventy two, you are much less likely to move at all because it is just psychologically harder to move. Now, in terms of, well, if I do downsize, how much can I live off? And there, we did a podcast years ago. Which I think was fantastic about the rules of thumb of if you have a lump of money in your bank account, how much can you spend and basically not run out of that money until
11:03 Speaker 00 you die? So there are two potential rules of thumb. One is for every hundred thousand dollars you've got in your bank account, you can spend four thousand dollars a year and you can adjust that for inflation. So as the cost of things go up, you can keep on spending the equivalent of four grand a year. Now you need to invest that money, it can't just be lying in your account, but that's the rule of four percent. So let's say you downsize and you come away with three hundred thousand dollars, you'd be able to draw twelve thousand dollars a year pretty comfortably from that and effectively not run out. Though of course you should listen to that podcast, it comes from a fantastic report by the Society of Actuaries, which are the numbers dudes of New Zealand. However, if you don't care about your spending, keeping up with inflation and you want to spend
11:45 Speaker 00 a little bit more when you're young, you can use the rule of six percent. So for every hundred thousand dollars you've got in your bank account, if you invest that, you can draw six thousand dollars a year. So if you downsize, you come away with three hundred thousand dollars, then you could spend eighteen thousand dollars a year to top up your superannuation. You of course talk to a financial advisor about setting this up, but those are some broad rules of thumb you can use. But Andrew, if we just take a step back, who is downsizing the right choice for and how much can you count on it?
12:15 Speaker 01 So typically if I'm building a wealth plan for an investor, I won't include downsizing unless there's an extreme situation like they've got a really, really valuable property, like, you know, some of the Auckland properties of investors I work with, they could be worth close to ten million dollars. In that case, often I might do that. I might include some amount or a conservative amount. Generally speaking, I don't like to rely on it for all of the reasons that we've just discussed, because people have these grand ideas of downsizing and that don't end up happening, unless of course, they kind of have no other choice. But it's come up recently just in conversation with people because I have got a lot of investors who are either really near retirement or at least one of them is. And because they
12:56 Speaker 01 haven't done a lot of investing so far, it's kind of, it's a necessity. So we are factoring it in, but generally speaking, I like to not worry about it.
13:04 Speaker 00 I think downsizing can be a real psychological crutch. So if you haven't invested and you're 50 years old, and this isn't to beat you up, but like if, if somebody said to you, what's your retirement plan? And the only asset you've really got is your home and you're paying off that mortgage diligently. Obviously your first reaction is going to be, well, I'll just sell the house and I'll buy something cheaper. Because that's your current source of wealth. But you also just want to be realistic about whether that is actually going to happen. And how much money you can get out now. In some cases, you absolutely can. In other cases, it's not going to be as realistic. But over the last 15 minutes, you've learned whether you can still use downsizing to pay for your retirement. The three times that downsizing doesn't work, the four times it does. And why some Kiwis just won't get as much money as they think. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast.
13:49 Speaker 00 Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:58 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. I'm Michael. We're going to be back again to work with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the property market. Until next time.
Previous When Property Investing Doesn’t Work: The $500k Lesson⎥Ep. 2251 Next Sell It or Rent It? The 3-Step Framework for Making the Right Choice⎥Ep. 2254 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated