Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast I Made $100,000 From This One Property Deal (Case Study)⎥Ep. 2124 About this episode Strahan McIntosh didn’t set out to become a property investor. But after teaming up with his brother, surviving cowboy tradies, and getting caught in a cyclone, he’s now built a purposeful portfolio across 4 different regions. In this Case Study Sunday episode, Strahan shares his story – from Palmy to Christchurch to Hawke’s Bay – and the deal that made him $100,000. You’ll hear:How Strahan and his brother made $100k each from a single property saleThe $4,700-a-month blowout that nearly derailed his financesWhy Cyclone Gabrielle forced the government to buy him outCheck out our Property Investment NZ guides to start or grow your own investment journey. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Upus Partners. I'm your host, Seaweed Knight. I'm Andrew Nichol. And this is a show that helps Kiwi investors go from zero to five properties. So you could be financially free, even if your tradie goes to you mid renovation. Now stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn how Stran invested in four cities in just nine years. How he and his brother made a hundred grand each on a single property deal. And the renovation blowout that cost him almost an extra five grand a month in those surprise costs. And we are so grateful that Stran is joining us for another Case Study Sunday. Stran is a real listener of the show, just like you guys who are walking your dogs or running on your treadmill. Stran, welcome along to the show.
0:53 Speaker 00 Thanks for having me, guys. And tell us about the very first property you invested in. Where was it and what happened? Yeah, so I moved back home from my first stint in Christchurch to Pums North and was looking around, trying to get back out of the family home as I was a bit older. And the market was pretty tough back then for first home buyers, but ended up looking at a house close to Palmer Boys High in the city centre itself. I looked at it on a Tuesday, had an offer on Thursday and had it under contract on Saturday before the first open home. This is your first property? Yeah, that was my first property. I knew I had to move fast if I wanted it. And the first open home was really interesting.
1:37 Speaker 00 I had a lot of extended family come through and obviously the real estate agent was in conversations with a lot of people and a lot of groups coming through the house. And unfortunately she had to say that it was under offer before at that first open home. So she probably missed a beat there, but I was extremely happy. So how did you convince the seller?
1:56 Speaker 00 To sign a contract with you before they've even marketed it or had lots of people through it. I'm not too sure. I think they were under a little bit of time pressure. They were moving away and they must have thought, oh, if we just get this under contract around the figure we want, then we'll be happy and they can move on with their lives. So I didn't have to do a lot of convincing and there was a little bit of negotiation, but not, not a lot. What sort of prices were you paying back then? I believe I got the property for two nine five. What year was that? Twenty sixteen. Twenty sixteen, a three hundred thousand dollar property. God, what it'd be worth today? Yeah, so just sold it recently, actually, in March approximately, sold for about mid fives.
2:39 Speaker 00 Mid fives. And how much money did you spend on it in that time that you owned it? Uh, I didn't spend a lot. I was gonna do a renovation, as we'll talk about, but ended up not doing it. And by the time I went to sell it, it was, it was definitely a lot more rundown than I remembered. So had to do a little bit towards the back end just to get it ready to sell, but I wouldn't have spent much at all, maybe ten K. So just trying to figure out, okay, if you sold it for mid five, let's just call it five fifty. So you made two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. How much cash did you put in deposit and also top ups over that period of time to make that two fifty? Yeah, trying to remember, I think it was, it would have been twenty percent, I believe, as a deposit. So sixty K? Um, yeah, and, you know, I think as we talk a lot about the, the bank of mum and dad helped out there as well as some savings.
3:24 Speaker 00 And then I paid principal and interest for, uh, would have been five years or so before I went to interest only. So, yeah, I, I wouldn't, wouldn't be sure of the numbers, but I guess not much in terms of maintenance and upkeep. I tried to keep my costs really low. So even if you put in, say, another, let's say forty thousand dollars, which would be quite a high amount because you're paying down principal, but of course you're getting that. Back when you sell the property, forty thousand, you put in a hundred and you make two fifty when you sell and your principal payments back. It's great. And Stran, one of the things I'm really interested in is you ended up using that first property to buy a second house with your brother. Talk to us about that. Yeah, so I, I think the interest rate changed. I remember this clearly and, and
4:08 Speaker 00 the, the personal banker I had, which they don't really exist anymore, emailed me and said, hey, your interest rate's changing. Do you want to keep your payments the same on principal and interest? And I said, sure, just a little bit easier. So I think I was paying down more than what I needed to. And then the property value increased. So I went to the bank to try and get some money out for renovation. I got about sixty thousand out. And then I started applying for, for other jobs and, and seeing what was around. And I ended up moving down to Christchurch. And I remember having a conversation with my older brother saying, hey, I'm gonna probably use that, that money I got out for renovation to actually just put a deposit on another house and buy down there. I didn't want to be paying someone else's mortgage. And he kind of just turned around and
4:51 Speaker 00 said, oh, at that stage, he owned his own home too. And he said, oh, well, why don't we just go in together? So I ended up doing all the, the looking and visits down in Christchurch. The first time he physically saw the property, he was helping me move my stuff in. So myself and my partner at the time moved in and we got some flatmates. He paid his half of the mortgage and I covered everything else. So when you're doing a deal like this, where you've got essentially your brother, who's just an investor, but you've got the benefit of living in the property, how do you figure out who pays what so that it's fair? I think I ended up just going to him and, and saying, it'll be on me to make sure that we've got enough to cover most of the mortgage. And then I think he pitched in for
5:34 Speaker 00 rates, insurance and those types of things from memory. And I just figured, you know, if, if it's a positive cash flow, then, then we would have some in the, in the bank in case we didn't have a flatmate in there for a while. So I probably took most of the risk, but having his deposit was, was massive. Okay, that's really interesting. I know that along the way, Stran, you had a couple of cowboy contractors and rogue tradies. Talk to us about those situations. Yeah, so I think it was it was during COVID, I believe. And we had my partner and I, Max, we had a dog together and our flatmate had one as well. And we wanted to take the fence down, it was pretty rundown, and build another one.
6:15 Speaker 00 And that was when, and I don't know if you guys remember, but there was a big shortage in fence paling or wood in general in the construction industry. And so one of my ex-partner's friends was trying to go out on their own and took the fence down. And then realised he couldn't actually get some material for it for a reasonable price to put another one up. And it was going to cost an exorbitant rate. So I was pretty furious at the time because it was pretty unsafe, I guess, for the dogs. And what I ended up doing was I worked in rugby at the time at a club down in Christchurch, Maristalbion. And I ended up getting one of the players to come and help out and step in, who was probably a little bit more reliable.
6:53 Speaker 00 So you got a rugby player to put up the fence because your friend who was running a fencing business had removed the fence before he could get the palings to put up the new fence. Yeah, the rugby guy was, you know, qualified builder and things like that. Gotcha. And this other guy was just like a handyman trying to move into the space, doing, you know, landscaping and small odd jobs around that kind of thing. But yeah, it was a it was an experience. And so what did you end up doing with that property? Do you still own that property now? No, so I I moved up to Hawks Bay in twenty one. And I guess this is the the part where, you know, if I take all the risk, I can make some of the calls. And I rung up my brother and said, look, I've just accepted a job in Hawks Bay. We're selling the house. He didn't get a lot of say. I said, I'm I'm moving up in this timeframe and we're gonna we're gonna auction it off.
7:36 Speaker 00 So we auctioned it off. It would have been June or so, July, maybe a little bit later of of twenty one, from memory. And yeah, we we both did pretty well from it. When you say pretty well, how well did you do? So we got about a hundred thousand dollars each, which my brother was pretty happy about. It helped to renovate the inside of his property back in Palmerston North. I ended up having to half my profit. I broke up with my partner then, but ended up taking that, the profit I did have and reinvesting it in land up in Hawks Bay. So your situation, I hear this quite a bit. People get into a partnership because someone has something that the other person needs. In your case, you needed an extra deposit.
8:19 Speaker 00 So you get into this investment together and then someone's plans change. And as a result, you want to sell the property probably a little bit earlier than maybe your brother wanted to. Cause if you still own that today, it might be worth more money. How did you two manage to decide that that was the right thing? It sounds like you were driving it, but was there any animosity and or has your brother looked back and gone, we should have kept that property. You're an idiot. No, I think we're generally pretty lucky with the timing that I think it'd be worth around the same as what we sold it for back then. He was in the midst of his renovation, so I think it worked out well for him too. So again, yeah, really lucky with the timing. But I think regardless, with myself taking the majority of the risk and majority of the
9:00 Speaker 00 the payments for back for the mortgage and things like that, I kind of felt like I was in a position to say, it's not working for me anymore. Let's sell up and whatever happens, happens. He definitely wanted more at the auction than I did. Yes. So that was a little bit of negotiation internally between us. And this is a really good example. I mean, we're talking about how Stran invested in four cities within nine years. We're only two properties in and off the first property from Palmy, he made quarter of a million dollars out of that property. The second one, after only owning it for a couple of years, we're talking about you and your brother took out six figures, a hundred grand each. We're up to $350,000. I mean, it's so interesting that some people are kind of anti-property investment. And then you look at how a regular person, if I'm allowed to call you a regular person, Stran, I hope you don't mind by that.
9:44 Speaker 00 But we're talking about making over a third of a million dollars in property over the last nine odd years. How else is any normal person going to make 330 grand or 350 grand? Yeah, no clue. And I think you see all those memes around, you know, um, maybe still in the in the womb, saying I should have invested back then and, you know, as soon as you could. But, um, yeah, I was just really lucky to have the ability to get into the property space as soon as I could in 2016. And so you've gone all over the show. We've been Palmy, we've Talked about Christchurch at this point in your life here in the Hawks Bay. You ended up in a tiny little town called, oh wait, I'm gonna need a couple of tries at this. Tongo Oyo. Yeah, Tongo Oyo. So I, I was living in Napier at the time.
10:29 Speaker 00 I purchased land in Tongo Oyo with the view to build on it eventually. I remember driving out often to mow the, mow the grass and listen to you guys on the way out. There was approximately 20 minute drive, so that worked really well. And beautiful weather always as it is in Hawks Bay. It was right next to the beach, so the dream was, you know, a beach house. Already had like a, a city house back in Palmy back home. Thought I would, I'd go that, that route. Yeah, it was probably not the best investment I made, considering that it was bringing in no income. And it was just bare land, but the dream was, the dream was there. And initially there were some challenges with the Iwi to do with the, uh, treatment of the wastewater.
11:10 Speaker 00 So it was on hold for a while, which didn't really bother me because I didn't have the, the money to build just yet. Anyway, I was just kind of land banking it for a while. And what made you decide to buy there? Was it just purely because you wanted the beach house? Or were you thinking about this as an investment as well? I think by then I was trying to be a lot smarter with my decisions. I, I knew the house prices were really high back into 21. And I didn't want to, um, just kind of make a sideways move. So yeah, that's why I thought land would probably be better than buying an existing home or a new build. As I said, it was probably more of an emotional decision at the same time with, with a nice view out to the beach and, and a more isolated community, I guess, as you say. Yep.
11:54 Speaker 00 And then the cyclone came along, the Hawks Bay Cyclone, Cyclone Gabrielle. How did that impact you? Yeah, so I remember getting woken up early. We, we all had the day off knowing there was bad weather coming. And, and my flatmates were saying that we needed to get out of the house and, and, and go. Cause the, the stock bank had broken in Taridale, which is where we lived. I didn't believe them. I thought it was a joke, but luckily we got out of there. And post cyclone, I didn't think there was much impact on, on the land out at Tongo Oyo, especially my land. There was some silt and things there, but. It didn't really have much of an impact, though as time went on, we got put in a category two, I believe, two B, which meant that something along the lines of that the community, you know,
12:37 Speaker 00 it's safe to live, we need to put stock banks up and things like this and make it safer in case of another flood, but that cost was going to come on the the landowners, which could have been pretty hefty. And there were a few properties that were totally flooded. And there were some landowners that were out there during the flood, which would have been pretty dangerous and very unsafe. So as a collective, we fought that categorisation and ended up moving to a category C eventually and getting red zoned. Okay, so you get red zoned. And now that's with EQC. And so they're going to give you a payout? Have you been paid out for the property? Yeah, so I believe it was half council and half half EQC with the payout. We had to fight
13:19 Speaker 00 for that for a long time. Obviously, a massive process in terms of valuation of the of the land and all the hoops you need to jump through, but ended up getting paid out. It would have been February or March twenty twenty four. Okay, so about a year ago. And all this process, are you representing yourself or do you have to engage a lawyer for this? Through the land sale, you obviously get a lawyer through. But in terms of getting feedback back to the council and our thoughts, it was as a personal approach. We had a Facebook page kind of discussing our options as a group. I think there was thirty eight or so different lots on on the subdivision. And so, yeah, we kind of got together and said collectively,
14:02 Speaker 00 if we have one voice, it may be a little bit more powerful. There are still some individuals who actually live out there, who wanted to keep the land. So there was a little bit of, not a huge lot of us that that wanted to stay. But I guess for my case, ending up selling was back to the council or the government was probably the best place we landed. And after all that, you moved back to Auckland and kept investing for a lot of people after Your property flooded out and having it red zoned, you might be sworn off property. What ended up happening once you went back to Auckland? Yeah, so I moved up to Auckland for a job from Hawks Bay and the property settled while I was in Auckland. And I flew home to see family and do that, that stuff.
14:46 Speaker 00 And actually went to an open home over the weekend while I was down there. And just, I guess through educating myself and listening to podcasts and reading up on, I guess, property development or investing. I saw potential in this property down in Palmerston North. I had to pay out and thought, why not go in again? So purchased a property in Hokofuru in Palmerston North. It was a four bedroom, three living room situation for about mid sixes. And I decided that I would split the property in two and create two units and two streams of income. And I know there were some issues with the building consent and resource consent that blew the timeline out. Talk to us about that.
15:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, so engaged with the builder after settlement and went in and started kind of taking things down and walls and cleaning up the property. But hadn't got building consent or resource consent for, for the kind of, all the extra work we're looking to get done. And Palmerston City Council, just the timeline on those processes just keep going. So if they're not happy with something, they've got 20 days to look through the material. They'll come back after 20 days to ask you for more information. You provide it to them and the 20 days starts again. So through that process, it probably took us, we started in July. It probably took us till December to get building consent and resource consent.
16:08 Speaker 00 And that meant that, you know, we couldn't move on the actual renovation part, which meant that I had the first house in Palmerston North. And then the second one while I was renovating. And yeah, it was pretty tough financially. So let me get this straight. Now you've got a bunch of mortgages that you're paying and you've got no income stream coming in. I think I remember reading in your notes, it was like almost $5,000 a month in mortgage payments. How the hell did you manage? Yeah, I think it was close to a million dollars worth of mortgage, which was quite scary when you logged into the bank. I had income coming from. From the first house, not a lot, which was part of the decision making to purchase the the second property in Palmerston North and and try and maximize the cash flow or the the income coming through.
16:49 Speaker 00 I had luckily some emergency funds when I took the second mortgage out. I got some money in kind from the from the bank. So chewed through that really quickly and just had to juggle a lot of my expenses and keep my expenses really low, but it was tough. And what it led to was the sale of the first property that I had in in Palmerston North to try and pay it all off. Not only did the timeline blow out, but I think the scope of works blew out as well. Which meant that I I needed to get more money to to pay the builder and for the renovations. And that makes sense, right? How are you gonna? You can't really get tenants in if you're applying for building consent and resource consent. Cause you'd have to kick them out in three months or whatever the consents come through anyway, because you're going to start renovating it.
17:32 Speaker 00 And last question for you, Sran, you said in your email to me that you're starting to become a bit more of a purposeful investor. What does that mean for you? Yeah, I guess from when I moved away from Palmerston North and had the home back back there. I had friends of the family living there for a while and and friends. So I didn't have a property manager at the time, just leaned on my family. And I guess what I figured out after a little while is that's no longer, you know, my home, it's it's an investment. And I moved to interest only, which made a lot more sense for me financially. And now with this new property in in Palmerston North, splitting it in two and and increasing the the income just made sense and and it was trying to continue my journey in in property, continue learning.
18:17 Speaker 00 It's it was a massive mission to to do the renovation a lot more than what I should have bitten off probably, but yeah, just those decisions, I think, have been really good for me going forward. Yeah. And I just think it's so awesome that you've decided to come on. I know you've been listening to the show for almost four years now, which we're very grateful for. But the most awesome thing about Case Study Sunday is it's real people who are investing in real properties and are also tuning into the show because that shows everybody else that this community that we're building isn't just people who talk about property. Or talk about investing, it's people who are actually doing it. And so the reason we are so passionate, Andrew and I, about Case Study Sunday is that Case Study Sunday isn't just for us and putting out a nice show, it's for you guys as well to share your stories.
19:01 Speaker 00 And so I want you to send me an email, [email protected] and come on to the show, come on for Case Study Sunday, share your stories, because just like Stran's story will inspire some of you today, your story, even though you might not think of it, that could be very inspirational for other people too. They might relate to some of the challenges you've had. So send me an email, I want to get you on, because over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how Stran invested in four cities over nine years, how he and his brother both made a hundred grand each on a single property deal, and the renovation blowout that cost him almost an extra five grand a month in surprise costs. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast, really does help us get the message out to more people.
19:48 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast, I'm your host, Tim Atkine. And I'm Andrew Nicoll. We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and science to help you get the most out of the selling property market. Until next time.
Previous Growth vs. Yield: 5 Questions that Decide Which to Invest In⎥Ep. 2123 Next Property Investing Is Risky When You Don't Use THIS⎥Ep. 2125 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated