Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Growth vs. Yield: 5 Questions that Decide Which to Invest In⎥Ep. 2123 About this episode Every property investor eventually asks this question: “Should I buy for capital growth or yield?” In this episode, we walk through 5 critical questions that will help you make that decision – based on your age, goals, budget, and existing portfolio. Listen in as we compare real examples of investors who prioritise growth and others who focus on cashflow … and how to tell which path is right for you. Which investors are better suited to capital growth vs yieldHow your age and retirement goals affect your investment strategyWhy the number of properties you already own changes your next stepAnd here's the self-assessment tool where you can find out what's the right fit for you. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obers Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the five questions you need to answer before deciding your property investment strategy. Who should care more about growth and the investors who should care more about yield and how to figure out what's right for you. And I'll tell you why I want to talk about this, Andrew, is one of the most important decisions that a property investor needs to make is whether they start investing in growth properties, which tend to increase in value faster, but don't have quite as good a yield, or whether you should go for yield properties which have a better rental return, but don't increase in value as fast. And so we've talked to death about this, I feel at least, on podcasts and webinars and YouTube videos.
0:59 Speaker 00 But I was coming out of the gym the other day. I know you're about to fall off your chair. You're all thinking, does Ed really go to the gym? Yes, I just got tubby because I was trying to, I was trying to build muscle and I got a lot of fat in the process. But I was walking out of the gym and this young guy on the desk says, Ed. I'm like, hello. And he says, oh, I was watching your webinar the other night. I was like, great. He's like, I want to invest in property. I'm like, great. How old are you? He's like, I'm 24. I've got a prayer approval for, for a good amount of money too. And I want to invest with my dad, but we don't know whether we should go for growth or yield. Now, Andrew, what would be your initial take on that? If, if somebody stops you while you're coming out of the gym, even though you work out
1:42 Speaker 00 at home, but you're walking, you're walking out of this imaginary gym, somebody stops you, the 24 years old, the situation I've outlined, what would usually be your take?
1:50 Speaker 01 It's two things, Ed. Now, because he's young, I'd absolutely say you need to buy for capital growth. Like that's what will make you wealthy. You don't need the income now, you need the wealth in the future. The interesting part though, as you mentioned with his dad, his dad might be at a completely different stage of life. He might want income now. And so therefore maybe the dad needs to be buying something more high yielding. But assuming that his dad might be 50, yeah, he'd probably go growth as well.
2:14 Speaker 00 And I always thought that was kind of quite obvious what the answer would be. But there are so many people who ask this question that I'm like, ah, we need to recap this. We've come up with five questions and we've actually built you guys a quiz where you can go and answer these questions online. And it will give you a sense of what might be the right fit for you. And I think the first question you've got to ask is, how old are you? Or what kind of life stage are you in? So are you just starting out in life like this 24 year old? Honestly, that that sounds almost quite condescending, Andrew. That that 24 year old just starting out in life, it wasn't that long ago that we were 20. Well, it was a bit, it was a bit long ago that you were 24.
2:52 Speaker 01 Hang on, just calm down.
2:54 Speaker 00 But are you just starting out? Have you been working for a while, say you're kind of 40s, 50s? Or have you got less than 10 years from retirement? Now, this is really important because a 30 year old or somebody who's been working for a while would typically tend to go for growth. If they really care about those long term gains, we're building wealth for the future. If you've got less than 10 years to retirement, that's generally where you'd start thinking more about yield. Because the thought process will be, how am I going to use these properties in order to live off? And one of my favorite examples of this is we were once advising, I think she was about 60 years old, five years away from retirement. Earned a really good income.
3:37 Speaker 00 Now, for her, the right strategy wasn't buy a property, hold it for 15 years, wait for the property value to increase. It was, well, actually, you're so close to retirement. The strategy is buy a high yielding property. Let's smash down the mortgage because you don't currently have a mortgage. And for the first couple of years in retirement, she was going to keep working in her job, in her office job. And she's going to take the superannuation and aggressively pay down that mortgage. So by the time she was 67, she could retire and this property would generate her a good, good income. Whereas if you're younger, you probably wouldn't, wouldn't go down that route. So that's question number one. What's question number two?
4:17 Speaker 01 How many investments you've already got? And the reason this is important is if you've got no investment properties right now, you probably want to start with a growth property. And I often think about it like this, growth will make you the most money over the long term. And if something changes in your life and you only ever buy one property, you probably want it to be growth. And by buying your first property as a growth property, a house or a townhouse, you're generally speaking, you're going to see faster capital growth. And therefore you're going to be able to leverage sooner to buy that additional property. Now, if you've already got three, four, five properties, maybe at that stage you might look at your portfolio and say, okay, this portfolio is costing me quite a bit to top it up because I've bought high growth properties and don't get as good yield.
5:02 Speaker 01 Maybe then you look to supplement those top ups with a high yielding property. Now, just bear in mind, if you buy a high yielding property today with today's interest rates, using the no cash needed method, you're probably going to be topping that one up as well. But as interest rates come down and rents go up, eventually that might provide an income to help balance out the cash flow on the high growth properties.
5:23 Speaker 00 Okay, so the first one's about how old you are, how far away you are from your goal. Second question's really about how many properties do you currently have? The third question is what matters more to you? Is it building wealth for the future? Getting a passive income in the future or retirement income in the future? Or having some sort of passive income now? Now, if your objective is more the long term, that's when you're going to go for a growth property because a property that's going up in value by five or six percent per year on average is going to get you better long-term compounding gains than something that's going up by, say, three and a half percent per year, which is what would typically forecast your property might go up in value by?
6:07 Speaker 00 But if you're thinking about short term income now and assuming you've got, you're putting some money into this property, cash deposit, so that your mortgage isn't really, really, really high, that's where you might decide to go for a yield property. And we've got to talk about this example a little more, probably next week. But I had a really interesting email, actually, we both got this email from a listener who said, and this is a bit morbid, so we won't dwell on this too much. We'll discuss more in detail next week, but it was a listener who said, hey, look, I'm Maori, my wife is Maori, and I look at the stats and I know for a fact that Maori people unfortunately don't tend to live as long and so typically have fewer years in retirement on average, those are the stats, those are the facts.
6:52 Speaker 00 And it's very sad. And because of that, this guy was saying, retirement isn't as much of a driver for me and my wife because we don't know how long our retirement's going to last. We're more interested in living today. And so based on that, if you're less concerned about the long term retirement and you're thinking more about today, well, that's where you might legitimately say, maybe we'll go for yield. What's question number four?
7:18 Speaker 01 Number four is going back to the cash flow and what kind of top up can you actually afford? So again, if you're using the no cash needed method like most people do when they invest, so you're going to borrow a hundred percent to buy the property. Generally speaking, you're going to have to top that rent up to cover all the costs. Now, growth properties, because they get higher capital growth, tend to get lower yield. And so therefore your top up tends to be a little bit higher, particularly in those early days. Like if you're buying a property today, it's a bit more painful than it is in a few years' time as the interest rates start to ease and your rent goes up. A yield property, on the other hand, that tends to get better income. And so therefore your top up tends to be a little bit less. So depending on what side of the camp you fall under, how much you can afford to top up
8:01 Speaker 01 might depend if you're going to buy a higher yielding property, a lesser top up, or a higher growth property, but a more of a top up. And just to give you a bit of a guide today, and this is very much just a finger in the air, your top up for a high growth property at the moment might be somewhere between hundred and fifty to three hundred dollars a week on average roughly. If you're buying a higher yielding property, it might be somewhere between fifty dollars a week and a hundred dollars a week, just as a rough guide.
8:28 Speaker 00 The last question is if you sold everything today, you cashed up everything except your main home that you live in, sold all of your assets, could you afford to buy a property without a mortgage? Now, if the answer is yes, then you might go for a yield property. If the answer is no, then you might still be in a growth phase. And the reason I like this question is it's very simple. It's very easy to say yes or no to it. But the reason we ask this is a lot of the strategies that we're talking about on the show, like the golden goose or the nest egg. And if you don't know what those are, there are some great podcasts for you to dive into. But when we're thinking about the golden goose, the strategy is that at the point that we want to stop working,
9:13 Speaker 00 at the point that we want to live off the rental income from our properties, the strategy is typically we buy a high yield property, no mortgage or low mortgage, and that's how you live off the rental returns. Now, if you can't do that today, then perhaps you're still in growth mode. Perhaps you're still what we call running the race. There are so many terms that we're talking about, Andrew, that we've talked about on the show, like nest egg, golden goose. By the way, guys, if you ever are like, what is that word that Ed and Andrew are talking about? We have just launched a glossary on our website where, because we're the first people to do 2000 episodes on property in New Zealand, we've had to come up with all of these terms to describe these different strategies that we often talk about on the show.
9:58 Speaker 00 We've created a glossary on our website where we explain what each of these terms mean. If you're ever like, what's the no cash needed method? What's a high yielding property?
10:06 Speaker 01 Just when you mentioned that, I thought it was quite interesting. I logged into someone's Opus Plus the other day to walk through a new wealth plan for them. And I saw that they had named their mortgage Mortgage Buster. I thought how great that was.
10:19 Speaker 00 Oh, that's, that's another, to be honest, I know I've gone off on a major tangent here, Andrew. Mortgage Buster is actually one of the terms that I stole from a mutual friend of ours, Brad Parsonson.
10:33 Speaker 01 That's the only good idea he's had.
10:36 Speaker 00 But he, he once called it the mortgage buster. And I thought it sounded like a water slide from the Waiwera Hot Pools up north of Auckland, which unfortunately now closed. And I thought, what a great name for a mortgage strategy. Do you know what, I, gosh, this is a tangent now, but we're under time, so it's all good. So then I started Googling water slide names. So that I could take the water slide names and turn them into like property investment strategy names.
11:03 Speaker 01 So what other ones did you come up with?
11:05 Speaker 00 Well, none of them were particularly good.
11:06 Speaker 01 Right.
11:07 Speaker 00 But, but one of this.
11:07 Speaker 01 I can't, I couldn't think of anything complete opposite. Like that is obscene.
11:13 Speaker 00 No, because, because one of the slides at the Waiwera Hot Pools was the gut buster. I remember that, the gut buster. I thought, oh, well, that's mortgage buster. So what else could there be? So anyway, where was I? Where was I?
11:28 Speaker 01 Yield and growth.
11:29 Speaker 00 Oh, that's, oh, yes, growth and yield, yes. So that question, kid, is if you sold everything except your main home today, could you afford to buy a property without a mortgage? If the answer is yes, then you might be at the stage where you are ready to transition into crossing the finish line and stop going to work. So yield could be appropriate. If the answer is no, you could still be running the race, could still be in growth mode. So Andrew, as I said, we've created a tool on our website, Little Quiz. Answer these five questions and it will tell you which one you might like to go for. And the really cool thing is over 3,484 people have taken this since we've launched it.
12:10 Speaker 00 So let's go through it, answering these questions like that 24 year old that we talked about at the start. So question number one, what life stage are you in? Starting out, been working for a while or less than 10 years from retirement.
12:22 Speaker 01 So starting out.
12:23 Speaker 00 And what's more important, building wealth for the future or getting a passive income now?
12:28 Speaker 01 So I would encourage him to build wealth for the future.
12:31 Speaker 00 Okay. And how many investment properties did he own today? Zero to one, two to three or four or more?
12:36 Speaker 01 So zero?
12:37 Speaker 00 And could you afford to put a top up into your property towards the investment property?
12:42 Speaker 01 We'll assume he can.
12:43 Speaker 00 And if you say, actually, do you know what? He was working a couple of jobs because I, he told me what his pre-approval was and I looked at him.
12:50 Speaker 01 You were surprised.
12:51 Speaker 00 And I said, this must be your second job. And he's like, yeah, yeah, yeah, this is my second job. I was like, yeah, because that's a solid pre-approval, just working out of the math, what somebody in that industry might get paid. So, I mean, good, good on him. And last question, if you sold everything today, except your main home, could you afford to buy a property without a mortgage?
13:09 Speaker 01 No.
13:10 Speaker 00 Okay, so based on that, you don't even have to put in your email address. This quiz would suggest that growth properties are probably the right fit for him. But for you guys listening to this, I'll drop the link to this down in the, the description so that you're able to go and get this. Or if you, you just don't Google, to be honest, if you Google Opes Partners Growth versus Yield Quiz, it'll be the first thing that comes up. And I should say as well, this is our view on growth versus yield and how you figure out the answer. If you listen, of course, to a different property commentator, you might get a slightly different answer around what they think the right answer would be. But you're listening to our show, so you get our opinion. So, over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the five questions you need to answer before choosing your property investment strategy, the sort of investors who should care more about growth and those who should care about yield,
13:54 Speaker 00 and how to figure out what is right for you. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:09 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight.
14:12 Speaker 01 And I'm your host, Nick.
14:13 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here in tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous The Real Reason You Don't Feel Rich: The Compounding Click⎥Ep. 2122 Next I Made $100,000 From This One Property Deal (Case Study)⎥Ep. 2124 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated