Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Nearly four years into investigating the 1993 death of her mother, Lori, the host receives a response from Joey, the brother of Lori's ex-husband, Scary Harry. During a tense video call, Joey claims to have witnessed Thomas Kelly, the host's biological father, murder Lori after an altercation involving an old pregnancy and domestic abuse. As Joey details bizarre crime scene elements like scattered bread and a marble statue, his narrative shifts repeatedly, mixing up timelines and involving claims of severe PTSD. Later, after consulting a detective and confronting Joey via message, the host discovers that Joey admits he was not actually there and was merely repeating rumors, leaving the investigation back at square one.
- Authorities and friends can confirm when details provided by an unreliable witness contradict known facts and police records. 42:55
- Witnesses who initially claim direct involvement in a crime may later admit they inserted themselves into the story. 43:49
- A second autopsy and pending DNA testing on hair and bone samples can take many months to yield results. 2:19
- Police witness statements from the original investigation noted unusual details like bread and hair tufts at the scene. 21:13
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Intro and Host Background
The host introduces the episode, her role, and the podcast’s purpose.
- 0:51Joey’s Unexpected Video Call
Joey reaches out after a year, offering a video call to share crucial information.
- 2:08Setting the Scene: Awaiting Autopsy Results
The host explains her anticipation for the second autopsy and the context of Joey’s call.
- 3:53Exploring Joey’s Family Connections
The host probes Joey’s knowledge of her mother’s ex-husband and his brother, setting up potential suspects.
- 6:19Conflicting Stories About the Murder
Joey alternates between claiming Thomas killed her and describing a different scenario, confusing the host.
- 28:13Police Report Details and Discrepancies
The host discusses evidence from the 1993 police report that clashes with Joey’s narrative.
- 41:06Revisiting Witness Accounts and DNA Tests
The host reflects on past witnesses, new DNA testing hopes, and the detective’s skepticism.
- 43:13Confronting Joey About Lies and Motives
The host confronts Joey over inconsistencies, questioning why he fabricated the story.
- 45:11Future Investigations and Autopsy Awaiting
The host outlines next steps: awaiting new autopsy results and potential DNA evidence to clarify the case.
Highlights
- 1:00
A Threatening Warninginsight
Joey warns the host on a video call that testifying against him could result in someone dying.
- 5:30
Staircase Allegationstory
Joey claims that Scary Harry kicked Lori down a set of stairs when she was drunk, causing a miscarriage.
- 17:39
Claiming to Cover the Killerstrategy
Joey explains that Thomas brought him along as a witness to cover his back in case neighbors intervened.
- 23:50
A Clump of Hairdata
Joey claims a clump of light brown hair found near the front door belonged to him after he ripped it from Thomas's head.
- 43:43
Retracting the Confessioninsight
Joey sends a message admitting he was not there and apologizes for adding himself into the mix.
Quotes
“If I tell you, and if it goes to court, then you will have to go up and testify against me. And if that happens, one of us is gonna die.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:00 “I just wanted to apologize to you for me not acting sooner to what I could have stopped.”
Unnamed speaker · 15:44 “I think about those message exchanges and our video call for weeks, turning them over and over in my head.”
Unnamed speaker · 44:50 “In December of 2023, I've been waiting 10 months for the new autopsy results to come back.”
Unnamed speaker · 45:11
Sponsored segments
- Audible 0:00–0:17
- Audible 19:19–20:49
About this episode
An associate of Lauren’s biological father confesses to being present when her mom was murdered. But can he believed? See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
7,220 words · 6 speakers
Topics
- Ayr Media
- Toluca Pictures
- MGM Television
- Apple Podcasts
- Facebook video call
- Killer Psyche
- Who Killed Daphne
- The First Wife
- Apple Podcasts app
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated