Skip to content

Bernhard Goetz

Morbid

Hosted by Ash Kelley

43m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode of Morbid explores the life and actions of Bernhard Goetz, widely known as the subway vigilante, who shot four teenagers on a New York City subway train in December 1984. The host details Goetz's isolated upbringing, his troubled relationship with an abusive father, and his later trauma after suffering two muggings in a deteriorating New York City. The hosts examine the starkly polarized public reaction to the shooting, where many fed-up New Yorkers viewed Goetz as a hero fighting urban decay, while others saw a racially motivated act of violence against minority youth. Ultimately, the discussion unpacks the legal fallout, the civil suits, and the complex societal tensions surrounding crime, self-defense, and vigilantism in 1980s America.

  • Bernhard Goetz purchased a Smith & Wesson revolver in Florida after being denied a concealed carry license in New York following two muggings. 22:43
  • On December 22, 1984, Goetz shot four teenagers on a New York subway train after one of them asked him for five dollars. 23:17
  • Goetz admitted in his police confession that he wanted to kill and maim the teenagers and would have kept shooting if he had more bullets. 24:51
  • After a high-profile trial in 1987, a jury acquitted Goetz of attempted murder and assault, finding him guilty only of possessing an unlicensed firearm. 43:50

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Ads

    The episode opens with a brief introduction, followed by a series of commercial breaks and a comedic anecdote about stepping in a pile of shit.

  2. 1:34
    Ash and Elena Introduce Morbid

    Hosts Ash and Elena welcome listeners to Morbid and tease their upcoming discussion of Bernie Goetz.

  3. 4:40
    New York City Life and Personal Anecdotes

    Ash shares a humorous story about stepping in a pile of shit in Brooklyn, detailing the aftermath and social media reaction.

  4. 7:46
    Transition to Bernie Goetz

    The hosts shift focus from personal stories to the main topic: the infamous subway vigilante Bernie Goetz.

  5. 12:24
    Education, Career, and Personal Struggles

    Bernie's college years, early career setbacks, marriage, and eventual return to New York to start his electronics business.

  6. 20:36
    Mugging Incidents and Rising Tensions

    Bernie's repeated mugging experiences and the failure of law enforcement to protect him, fueling his sense of injustice.

  7. 23:12
    The 1984 Subway Shooting

    A narrative of the events aboard the 14th Street subway car, including Bernie's decision to shoot, the victims, and the immediate aftermath.

  8. 33:00
    Aftermath, Civil Cases, and Legacy

    Bernie's later life, civil lawsuits, activism, and the enduring debate over his legacy and the broader implications for gun culture.

  9. 43:35
    Legal Proceedings and Public Reaction

    The chapter covers the investigation, trial, convictions, and the polarized public and media response to Bernie's actions.

  10. 48:04
    Jellyfish Reversion Discussion

    Hosts debate the biology of jellyfish reverting to polyps and the innate nature of this process.

  11. 50:04
    JCPenney Black Friday Ad

    A commercial break promoting JCPenney's Black Friday deals and holiday savings.

Highlights

  • 4:45

    A Rough New York Tripstory

    The host recounts an eventful trip to New York City where she accidentally stepped in questionable waste, got it on her purse, and had to wash her hands in a rain puddle.

  • 9:35

    A Disturbing Childhooddata

    The host details how Goetz's father was convicted of molesting teenage boys when Goetz was twelve years old, casting a heavy shadow over the family.

  • 24:42

    The Confession Detailsinsight

    In his taped confession, Goetz expressed a chilling desire to kill and torture the teenagers, stating he only stopped because he ran out of bullets.

  • 29:01

    Public Sympathy for the Shooterinsight

    Despite shooting four people on a crowded train, police tip lines were flooded with callers expressing sympathy for Goetz amid widespread frustration with rising crime.

  • 42:04

    Grand Jury Indictmentsstrategy

    After an initial grand jury only indicted Goetz for illegal firearm possession, a second grand jury added attempted murder and assault charges.

  • 42:57

    Flight Into the Tunnelsstory

    After shooting the four teenagers, Goetz calmly spoke to the train conductor before forcing open the doors and disappearing into the dark subway tracks.

  • 45:20

    Civil Lawsuit and Damagesdata

    Darrell KB, left paralyzed and brain-damaged from the shooting, won a civil judgment against Goetz, requiring Goetz to surrender ten percent of his income.

Quotes

  • “He was a good student. He graduated with a bachelor's degree in nineteen sixty-nine and he got a job right out of college.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:34
  • “The conductor approached him cautiously and was like, "Are you a police officer? Like, what happened here?"”
    Unnamed speaker · 26:07
  • “The public reaction to the shooting was decidedly different from that of law enforcement and city officials.”
    Unnamed speaker · 29:01
  • “He told the officer, and this is a quote, now you cannot understand this.”
    Unnamed speaker · 32:06
  • “Keep it as weird as a fucking jellyfish that can revert to a polyp, not the ones that kill people.”
    Unnamed speaker · 48:25
  • State Farm 0:33–0:54
  • JCPenney 1:04–1:31
  • BetterHelp 17:52–19:03
  • Southern New Hampshire University 18:53–19:27
  • JCPenney 19:28–19:56
  • SimpliSafe 33:16–34:27
  • American HomeShield 34:34–35:05
  • JCPenney 35:08–35:35
  • JCPenney 35:41–35:54
  • JCPenney 50:04–50:17
  • Old Spice 50:24–51:01

About this episode

On the afternoon of December 22, 1984, thirty-seven-year-old Bernhard Goetz boarded the Manhattan subway at the 14th Street station, bound for home. At one point during the train ride, one of a group of young Black boys approached Goetz and asked him for money, to which Goetz responded by pulling out a handgun and shooting at the group of teenagers, striking three of them. After the shooting had stopped, a witness testified that Goetz stood over one the boys and said, “You don’t look so bad. Here’s another,” then shot the boy a second time. After evading police for several days, Goetz was arrested and claimed he’d shot the teenagers in self-defense after they tried to rob him. To many residents of New York, who were fed up with the high crime rates and deteriorating landscape of the city, Goetz became a kind of folk hero who took it upon himself to do the job the New York Police Department seemed unable to do. But to many others, particularly the city’s Black community, Goetz’s actions were symbolic of the every day racism and unequal justice people of color had experience every day in New York.

Transcript

0:00
43:51

9,250 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Vigilantism
  • Subway Shooting
  • Crime in New York
  • Legal Trials
  • Self-Defense
  • Urban Decay

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated