Skip to content

At The Money: Is Technology Price Gouging Consumers?

Masters in Business

Hosted by Barry Ritholtz

25m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Host Barry Ritholtz and guest Lindsay Owens examine how modern technology, algorithms, and corporate surveillance have fundamentally altered pricing and consumer power. Moving beyond traditional inflation drivers like tariffs and supply chain issues, the discussion details how companies use sophisticated yield management software, dynamic pricing, and data collection to engineer prices and extract maximum value from buyers. From real estate software artificially inflating rents to hidden algorithms altering grocery and airline costs, the conversation explores the darker side of digital commerce and the erosion of transparent market competition.

Throughout the episode, the guest outlines specific examples of high-tech price coordination, including the RealPage rental algorithm case and Instacart's dynamic pricing experiments on grocery shoppers. They debunk the corporate Robin Hood defense of charging different prices based on income, arguing instead that surveillance pricing ultimately squeezes all consumers regardless of wealth. Ultimately, the episode serves as a warning that e-commerce promises of transparency have been replaced by opaque, coercive systems designed to capture every last dollar from wallets.

  • Landlords using revenue management software can participate in coordinated pricing schemes that artificially inflate rental markets. 8:05
  • Corporate pricing is increasingly driven by extensive surveillance and the collection of detailed consumer data. 17:31
  • Dynamic pricing experiments by delivery apps can result in shoppers paying significantly different amounts for identical items. 22:26
  • The primary goal of surveillance pricing is to extract maximum consumer surplus rather than engage in fair Robin Hood redistribution. 24:15

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Host Overview

    The episode opens with a brief introduction of the host and the show’s focus before transitioning to the main topic.

  2. 2:11
    Defining Modern Price Gouging

    The host introduces the concept of price gouging and explains how technology has amplified it.

  3. 8:00
    Dynamic Pricing in Retail and Grocery

    The conversation shifts to how retailers use dynamic pricing and electronic shelf labels to charge consumers differently based on data.

  4. 8:58
    RealPage YieldStar and Rent Collusion

    Owens explains how RealPage’s YieldStar software facilitated price‑fixing among landlords, leading to a federal investigation.

  5. 18:00
    Potential Good Uses of Pricing Technology

    Owens offers examples of how electronic shelf labels and other tech could reduce food waste and help consumers.

  6. 22:53
    Instacart’s Secret Pricing Experiment

    Owens details the study that revealed Instacart charged shoppers up to 23% more for the same items, sparking regulatory backlash.

  7. 23:44
    Corporate Spin vs. Reality of Surveillance Pricing

    The host and guest debate whether companies truly benefit some customers or simply squeeze everyone more efficiently.

  8. 26:44
    Future of AI Shopping Assistants

    The discussion turns to the promise and peril of AI agents that could either help or exploit consumers in e‑commerce.

Highlights

  • 3:33

    Pricing as Engineered Scienceinsight

    The guest explains how pricing has evolved from simple cost-plus formulas into a highly engineered science utilizing physicists, pricing consultants, and AI companies to squeeze consumers.

  • 8:05

    RealPage and Rental Floorsstory

    The RealPage YieldStar algorithm allowed thousands of landlords to coordinate rents and establish hard floors that prevented prices from dropping, leading to Department of Justice scrutiny.

  • 11:59

    Concentration Drives High Pricesdata

    With 75 percent of industries more concentrated than a generation ago, shrinking competition creates the ideal petri dish for nefarious pricing technologies.

  • 16:12

    Walmart and Product Patentsstory

    A Walmart patent filing from 2023 described technology that could change the price of mayonnaise based on whether a customer already had tuna fish in their shopping cart.

  • 19:52

    Delta Air Lines and AIstory

    Delta partnered with an AI pricing startup called Fetcher to hike airfares, expanding its usage from one percent of fares to twenty percent after seeing revenue boosts.

  • 21:28

    Instacart Dynamic Pricing Experimentdata

    An investigation involving secret shoppers revealed that Instacart charged different customers up to 23 percent more for identical grocery items at the exact same store.

  • 24:09

    Debunking Corporate Robin Hoodinsight

    The guest argues that charging higher-income shoppers more does not genuinely help lower-income buyers, but rather allows companies to capture all available consumer surplus.

Quotes

  • “Price gouging isn't anything new. It's been going on for forever, but the technology that allows faster, more subtle, and more hidden price gouging to take place is what's new.”
    Barry Ritholtz · 3:09
  • “RealPage is super interesting because what it represents is sort of an exponential shift in what's possible for price fixing and collusion.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:44
  • “They were talking about new technologies, dynamic pricing and electronic shelf labels in the grocery store, at the drive‑thru line.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:35
  • “Instacart was charging some shoppers different amounts than other shoppers. And those differences were as high as 23%.”
    Unnamed speaker · 22:26
  • “I call this the corporate Robin Hood theory of surveillance pricing. Steal from the rich to give to the poor.”
    Unnamed speaker · 24:09
  • Edward Jones 27:21–27:52
  • Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business American Express Card 27:33–28:28
  • MasterCard 28:28–28:58
  • Cincinnati Insurance 29:15–29:33

About this episode

Lots of forces are driving prices higher. But what about Artificial Intelligence, Algos, Surveillance Capitalism, and other technologies we all use every day? Might they be sending prices higher? Lindsay Owens is CEO of the Groundwork Collaborative, a DC-based economic think tank and author of a new bestseller, “Gouged: The End of a Fair Price—and What That Means for Your Wallet.” Each week, “At the Money” discusses an important topic in money management. From portfolio construction to taxes and cutting down on fees, join Barry Ritholtz to learn the best ways to put your money to work. See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
25:43

4,524 words · 10 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • RealPage
  • Fetcher
  • ChatGPT
  • Instacart
  • Walmart
  • YieldStar
  • Comcast Business
  • Meta
  • Delta Air Lines
  • Muse

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated