Skip to content

"The Show Must Go OFF" (w/ Laura Benanti)

Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang

1h 28m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang welcome actor and performer Laura Benanti to the podcast to discuss her touring show Nobody Cares, her iconic stage career, and the realities of navigating the theater and comedy worlds. The conversation explores Broadway casting trends, touring life, dramatic moments in famous musicals, and shared culturaltouchstones from Into the Woods to reality television. Benanti shares behind-the-scenes stories from her extensive career, including working with legendary figures like Stephen Sondheim and Patti LuPone, and opens up about transitioning into stand-up comedy and embracing a new artistic phase.

Throughout the episode, the hosts and guest trade sharp theatrical anecdotes, debate the challenges of eight-show-a-week performance schedules, and share humorous stories about awkward encounters and fandom. With characteristic wit and deep affection for the performing arts, Benanti reflects on her early inspirations, the pressures of trying to be cool, and finding joy through humor and community. The episode balances reverence for theatrical icons with unvarnished comedy, making it an essential listen for fans of theater, pop culture, and sharp comedic commentary.

  • Splitting performance roles or limited runs can protect actors from physical burnout and injuries sustained during rigorous Broadway schedules. 18:38
  • Accepting your own comedic and theatrical eccentricities leads to greater artistic freedom and personal happiness. 40:31
  • Recovering people-pleasers must recognize that constantly trying to make everyone else happy often means lying to someone. 43:30
  • Seeking out kind collaborators and surrounding yourself with supportive colleagues creates a sustainable and joyful creative environment. 1:01:14

Chapters

  1. 0:00
  2. 6:03
    Transition to Main Guest Introduction

    Matt and Bowen shift focus to welcoming Laura Benanti and setting the stage for her interview.

  3. 8:43
    The Challenges of Touring and Scheduling

    Hosts and Benanti talk about the logistics of touring, travel mishaps, and balancing personal life with performance demands.

  4. 13:07
    Industry Insights: Broadway vs. TV

    Benanti reflects on the differences between stage and screen, the evolving roles for actors, and her thoughts on future projects.

  5. 36:00
    Closing Reflections and Takeaways

    The episode wraps up with final thoughts on culture, career, and the importance of staying true to oneself.

  6. 40:44
    Personal Growth and Self‑Discovery

    Benanti opens up about her early struggles, self‑sabotage, and the journey toward authenticity and confidence.

  7. 44:33
    Show Intro and Sponsor Ads

    Hosts open the episode, introduce guests, and deliver a series of sponsor advertisements.

  8. 45:55
    Writing Process and Authentic Humor

    Discussion of the guest’s long‑standing writing habit, how humor is crafted, and the importance of staying true to one’s voice.

  9. 50:15
    Multiple Sponsor Ad Reads

    Hosts deliver a sequence of ads for Vive Healthcare, Prep Wisdom, Depop, Hotels.com, and Sniffy's Cruising Confessions.

  10. 53:53
    Into the Woods Nostalgia

    The group reminisces about the original production of Into the Woods and the guest’s high‑school memories of the show.

  11. 56:00
    Broadway Experiences and Colleagues

    The conversation turns to various Broadway productions, notable performers, and the guest’s personal relationships within the theater community.

  12. 1:14:08
    Personal Life, Family, and Drinking

    Hosts and guest discuss family dynamics, drinking habits, and the challenges of balancing performance with personal life.

Highlights

  • 2:36

    First Maria von Trappinsight

    The hosts introduce Laura Benanti as the first Maria von Trapp to appear on the podcast, celebrating her storied Broadway career and recent successes.

  • 11:57

    Not Actually Italianinsight

    Benanti reveals a surprising family secret, explaining that her original last name is Vidnovic and she is actually Slavic by birth.

  • 11:58

    Sicily Volcanic Eruptionstory

    The hosts recount their travel disaster when their flight to Sicily was canceled due to a volcanic eruption, leading to a discussion of Benanti's family winery.

  • 19:16

    Breaking Bones on Stagedata

    Benanti recounts severe physical injuries sustained while performing on Broadway, including breaking her neck during Into the Woods at age twenty-one.

  • 23:34

    Gypsy Rose Lee's Sonstory

    Benanti shares an emotional backstage encounter with Gypsy Rose Lee's son after her performance, realizing it was a once-in-a-lifetime experience.

  • 38:14

    1991 Into the Woodsstory

    Benanti reveals that the 1991 PBS broadcast of Into the Woods was the definitive cultural moment that inspired her to pursue musical theater.

  • 57:40

    Sondheim's Birthday Tributestory

    Benanti describes being invited by Stephen Sondheim to sing one of his earliest songs at a birthday celebration.

Quotes

  • “I am Benanti by love, which is what they say.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:31
  • “I am Italian by love.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:31
  • “I don't have any, like, sort of shared Slavic culture.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:35
  • “I think people go to Broadway to, like, legitimize themselves, which is interesting to me.”
    Unnamed speaker · 14:01
  • “But going into more like, of a comedy space at 47 years old, like, that is also hard, where I feel like, I, in some ways, I'm walking into something where I feel like, okay, maybe I don't belong here.”
    Unnamed speaker · 45:02
  • “There's like, I don't say this as like, a dig at the culture, but I don't think there is such a thing as like, belonging in comedy.”
    Unnamed speaker · 45:41
  • “I'm not just like Claudia in Nine, singing it in the crack key.”
    Unnamed speaker · 46:38
  • “I wrote a lot of very serious stuff, which makes me laugh now.”
    Unnamed speaker · 47:32
  • “I just want us to really restrain and rein it in before it gets out of control.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:31:41
  • Healthy Sexual 0:39–0:54
  • Spam 24:04–25:17
  • getprepwisdom.com 25:57–27:59
  • ViiV Healthcare 50:12–50:56
  • Depop 51:02–52:14
  • Hotels.com 52:17–53:33
  • Healthy Sexual 53:39–53:43
  • ViiV Healthcare 1:14:44–1:15:24
  • Depop 1:15:34–1:16:53
  • Hotels.com 1:16:57–1:18:04
  • Healthy Sexual 1:18:27–1:18:34
  • Matt Rogers 1:39:48–1:40:07
  • ViiV Healthcare 1:40:20–1:40:42
  • cars.com 1:41:05–1:41:33
  • Virgin Voyages 1:42:16–1:42:56

About this episode

The unreal Laura Benanti joins Matt + Bowen for a lil' Las Cultch that is performed in exactly the CORRECT key! That means the first ever Maria Von Trapp is in the studio! As well as the first Gypsy Rose Lee, the first Melania Trump, the first Eliza Doolittle and the SECOND Claudia from Nine! The three all come together, forming a trine, to ask... what is the POINT of vacation? What does it mean to be Italian, not by blood, but by love? What is the backstage etiquette when your friend is in a show that is awful? When is it just too many mugs in the cupboard? Also, the story of Tita Papa, the Italian Santa Claus who sleeps with your wife, how Laura broke her neck committing onstage, and what it was like to experience Sleep No More alongside a terrified Patti LuPone. All this, the impact of the Into The Woods PBS pro-shot, liking musicals but loving Sondheim, hosting the Jimmy Awards, No Hard Feelings, "comedic embarrassment" and realizing that your vagina may but be The Portal To Greatness. You gotta head over to www.nobodycaresisacomedy.com https://nam04.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.nobodycaresisacomedy.com%2F&data=05%7C02%7CAnnaHossnieh%40iheartmedia.com%7C25828e576d8e458c612308df128b5662%7C122a527e5b714eba878d9810b495b9e3%7C0%7C0%7C639250061844551341%7CUnknown%7CTWFpbGZsb3d8eyJFbXB0eU1hcGkiOnRydWUsIlYiOiIwLjAuMDAwMCIsIlAiOiJXaW4zMiIsIkFOIjoiTWFpbCIsIldUIjoyfQ%3D%3D%7C0%7C%7C%7C&sdata=chtH4KNwspWBat7PMXr1C7OY4z5e1Z%2B72827N%2B3HzE4%3D&reserved=0 and get tickets to see NOBODY CARES, Laura's new stand up show. She's brilliant in every way. Just like you<3 See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
1:28:03

20,756 words · 5 speakers

Topics

  • Mugs
  • The Jimmy Awards 2018
  • Wicked
  • Sniffy's Cruising Confessions
  • Ars Nova
  • Dollywood
  • Seth Meyers mugs
  • M&Ms Caramel
  • OnlyFans
  • iHeart Radio app

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated