Pod Insights If You're Listening There Will Be Mud (again) About this episode That's right, we're talking soil again. Is there a field of Ukranian chernozem soil sitting in rural New South Wales? Producer Pat joins Matt to finally find an answer.
Plus, rumours of a chernozem black market… is it true, or just a dirty lie?
Thanks to the New South Wales Soil Knowledge Network!
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:09 Speaker 01 Hi, it's Sam Hawley from ABC News Daily, the podcast that brings you one big story affecting your world each weekday in just 15 minutes. Lawmaking in regulating hate speech is difficult because you have to balance freedom of speech, but then you need to draw the line at genuinely harmful speech, which is something I've been arguing for for decades. Join me for ABC News Daily. Find it on the ABC Listen app.
0:36 Speaker 02 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabikal and Gadigal people.
0:47 Speaker 02 G'day, Matt Bevan here. This is If You're Listening. When I first managed to dedicate a whole episode to the black soil of Ukraine known as Chernosy, we all kind of thought it was a one and done kind of deal. It turns out we were wrong. First, we covered how precious this fertile soil is and how it's shaped Russia's invasion of Ukraine through the swampy, impassable barriers of mud it creates. And then we discovered this very curious claim online that there's a patch of this precious Chernosy soil right in our own backyard in the tiny rural town of Nimittabel in southern New South Wales. So does Australia have its
1:30 Speaker 02 own Chernosy? I'm joined by Pat Sunderland, one of the new producers on our team who has been playing a long game of stuck in the mud, trying to put this matter to rest.
1:46 Speaker 02 G'day, Pat. How's it going?
1:48 Speaker 03 Hello, Matt. Pleasure to be here. And it feels no more appropriate for my first episode than to be diving into this long saga.
1:56 Speaker 02 I know, I know. Look, you're our newest addition to the If You're Listening team, and we've decided to start you off by looking at the most obscure story that we can possibly think of.
2:08 Speaker 03 It's all, it's all part of the hazing ritual. I'll get paddled after this, of course.
2:11 Speaker 02 That's right. Yes, yes. That's a paddling. And yes, you'll have to go down the line with the paddles. The question you've got to ask yourself is, is this a hazing ritual or are you on probation somehow? You know, if you don't nail this. I don't think you can go wrong with mud. How can it not be interesting? It turns out, it turns out, but it's far more interesting than anyone could ever possibly have expected.
2:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, the, where we're left off last time, I was catching up on the full story of it all. And we were kind of left with this strange claim about Nimitabell, that it has the only patch of true chernism in Australia, in this small, tiny town. The last you heard of it, we had listeners, the hydrogeologist Anna Gibson emailed in saying that the soils around New South Wales are not classified as chernism, it's not quite right. But you also played a little bit of Leah Moore, the geologist who specifically works in the area, who had a different perspective, just to refresh everyone's memory, I've got it here.
3:08 Speaker 00 There are some near Nimitabell, but only in very localised areas, in low-lying parts of the landscape. They are present, but they're not very extensive.
3:17 Speaker 03 So, yeah, she kind of thought that they were there, you could say that they were there, but, you know, hardly a, a, a big patch.
3:25 Speaker 02 If I recall correctly, it was, it was basically, she was basically saying there were puddles of it.
3:30 Speaker 03 Yes, yeah, yeah.
3:32 Speaker 02 Basically, there would be low-lying areas that would gather a lot of water, and those were the only parts of the Munero region that had enough water in them to form this particular type of soil, because it needs a lot of water. So, it, there would be little, down the bottom of little gullies and valleys, little patches of chernism.
3:51 Speaker 03 Yeah.
3:51 Speaker 02 Uh, that was, that was her theory.
3:54 Speaker 03 So I sort of left with the dilemma of, well, this person seems to know a lot more than me about soil, they're probably right. But then another person, the other hydrogeologist, Anna, also seems to know a lot more about me than this sort of thing, but had a very different opinion. So I was kind of trying to figure out how to best get a ruling on this, basically. Uh, go, go to, go to the dirt umpire, is, uh, was what I had to do.
4:16 Speaker 02 Yes, that's what you want. So who is the dirt umpire? Tell me, tell me about who is the dirt umpire?
4:19 Speaker 03 Well, I encountered the New South Wales Soil Knowledge Network. Now, this is a group, of, we all know, the NSW SKN. I mean, they, these are a group of retired or semi-retired soil specialists, they may be scientists, they may have worked in landcare or in Government departments are looking at the right use of soil and how to revive soil and things like that. I knew I had settled on the right people when going on to their sort of landing webpage. They had this great video called Why is Soil Important? Which has sort of been the kind of larger question, I feel, of these episodes. And I'll just, I'll play a little bit of it, just so you can hear the passion that they have.
5:03 Speaker 04 Well, without that top 10, 15 centimetres of soil, we wouldn't have any food. We wouldn't have any fibre. We wouldn't have any fuel. We wouldn't have fresh water.
5:14 Speaker 02 Well, soils are the cradle, are the penance here for all of our issues, really. I mean, it's an all-important, all-encompassing issue, the management of soils.
5:24 Speaker 03 I mean, it makes you tear up a little bit, doesn't it?
5:26 Speaker 02 It does.
5:27 Speaker 03 I mean, that's.
5:27 Speaker 02 It's so mysterious, really, because, you know, I, I've been this year dealing with a dead patch of dirt around. Well, we had to do a bit of landscaping in our, in our backyard. Well, it was actually a sewage disaster. That had to be solved with the use of a digger. And the digger had to come in and remove, you know, large areas of the ground and then put it all back. And I've been trying to figure out why the grass won't grow back over it. And I'm, and I'm just going, it possibly has something to do with soil. But I don't, I don't really know what soil is or, or, or why it's important. And, and, and how I turn what, what I currently have as dirt into soil. And I feel like these are the guys who would, who would know about this.
6:11 Speaker 02 They seem, they seem into this kind of thing.
6:13 Speaker 03 It's gone from a journey of, oh, isn't it funny that people know so much about this? To why don't I know more about this?
6:21 Speaker 02 I know.
6:21 Speaker 03 It's a fundamental building block of the entire world that we live in.
6:26 Speaker 03 But so these guys got in touch with me, I reached out to their, to their website and they could not have been more helpful. A ton of guys, I can name it, John Laurie, John Lees, Peter Fogarty, Peter Walker, Brian Jenkins, Ian Packer, a number which were in these videos. They sent me pictures of trips they had taken to Ukraine in the 2000s, looking at the.
6:47 Speaker 02 They're all standing there in Ukraine, visiting the dirt.
6:51 Speaker 03 Yes, literally. They must have been telling their family like, oh yeah, we're going to Eastern Europe. Oh yeah. Well, I'm going to Ukraine. Oh, well, just to look at the soil.
7:00 Speaker 02 Oh, you're there to see the sights? Are you there to see Kyiv? You know, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I'm there to stand there and look directly down underneath my feet.
7:09 Speaker 03 Uh, it also may not shock you to know that when I got in touch with them to say, "Hey, uh, so the long story short, I work in this podcast." They were fully on top of the debate that had happened so far. They said, "Oh, yes, no, we know about this. We've, we've been hearing about this old, the old Nimitabell stuff again."
7:24 Speaker 02 We've been expecting.
7:27 Speaker 03 Please come in.
7:28 Speaker 02 Did they, you know, were they, were they facing the wall in a high-backed chair and they swiveled around and they went, "Ah, of that time you came here."
7:35 Speaker 03 Stroking just a small lump of dirt on their lap, you know?
7:41 Speaker 03 A piece of clay.
7:44 Speaker 03 "No, Mr. Bond, I expect you to dig." Uh, so.
7:48 Speaker 03 So they, uh, these guys put me onto this resource, long story short, called E-Spade, which is a New South Wales government thing that anyone can access. You can go on and Google it right now. And essentially what it's done is it gets a Google map of the state and just overlays it with any number of filters of soil type, soil landscape, et cetera, et cetera, and soil reports. So you can literally look at all these filed reports for every single little inch of the state. And they've catalogued it, usually most of them from the 90s or the 2000s, of these in-depth diagrams of every type of soil. And if you look a little further, I found almost immediately this diagram. So I want you to, uh, to look down at that little, um, sort of slope diagram that I put in the, in the notes there.
8:32 Speaker 02 Oh, yes, yes, yes. So we have, uh, a, a schematic cross-section. "Manoroo soil landscape illustrating the occurrence and relationship of the dominant soil materials." Well, we've got chocolate soils up the top. And then a little bit lower, we've got chernosums.
8:50 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
8:51 Speaker 02 And then down the bottom, right where, uh, Lea Moore said they would be, at the very bottom of the valley in this diagram, black chernosum.
8:58 Speaker 03 Exactly. Black chernosum. So, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, that diagram clearly lists chernosums in both the brown, black and classic forms around the slopes of the manoroo soil landscape. Now, that does include the area around Nimitabell. So that was, so I, I thought, great.
9:15 Speaker 02 We've, we've finally proven that, that a single line in a very obscure Wikipedia article was accurate. And it's only taken us six months.
9:24 Speaker 03 But I'm glad you brought us back to that, that line in the Wikipedia article because... I have many caveats here. Don't we love caveats in a discussion like this? That claim on Wikipedia cites that Nimminabel has the only true chernosum soil in Australia. So there's two sort of extra claims there. Firstly, that there is no other chernosum soil in Australia. And two, that Nimminabel has whatever true chernosum is. So the idea that, oh, there's this, you know, there's this black stuff that you can call chernosum.
9:56 Speaker 02 Knockoff chernosum.
9:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, this is the home brand stuff.
9:59 Speaker 02 T-moo chernosum.
10:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, so let's start with the, with the first claim. Is there other chernosum in Australia? So I do no thinking of my own. I go back to the Soil Knowledge Network people and they gave me a little tip. Rather than citing through the soil profiles of the entire state, they brought me to Wellington, New South Wales, not to be confused with Wellington, New Zealand, which is yet another small town right outside of Dubbo, um, sort of near the Bell River. And sure enough, I have another diagram there in the listing in that soil profile. Now, this one, there's a few things now.
10:33 Speaker 02 No, chernosums.
10:34 Speaker 03 Exactly. Prairie soils, whatever that is, and chernosums. So already, and, and then there were suggestions of other parts. A lot of agricultural areas, basically New South Wales, have some patch of what can often be referred to as chernosum. So already, I'm sorry, Nimminabel, as moments after placing the crown on your head, I am pulling the crown away and giving you a sort of smaller half-crown, a shared silver medal, so to speak.
11:02 Speaker 02 It's just everywhere. It's everywhere.
11:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's, you can't go for a walk in the country without tripping over. Uh, it's getting your boots stuck, you know, in a wet patch of chernosum.
11:10 Speaker 02 Into it, yeah.
11:11 Speaker 03 Now, the other question is, what is true chernosum? Because, and, and, and more to the point, why were there these disagreements between these other geological experts of whether or not there is or isn't chernosum? And this is where we get into a very interesting and, and exciting tangent about how the classification of soil types work. Because this is something I, I did not know about, which is, if you look at animals or plants or most things, there's a scientific taxonomy which is. Consistent, the whole world round, you know, we we refer to species in the same way that American scientists do and they, you know.
11:47 Speaker 02 Well, well, we try.
11:49 Speaker 03 Yes, yes.
11:50 Speaker 02 I mean, this is how you end up with five different names of a Brontosaurus. Different scientists discover similar things and then decide that either they are the same thing as this other scientist discovered, or they're a different thing and give them a new name, but in fact they are the same.
12:05 Speaker 03 But at the end of the day, they all follow the kingdom phylum order genus system. You know what I mean? There may be disagreements about where to put, in which box to put them, but the boxes are all the same.
12:17 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, yes.
12:18 Speaker 03 And again, going back to we don't seem to care enough about soil in this world, there is no system like this for soil. There's a, there's a world reference base that the UN and international science bodies will sometimes use, but every country has their own completely different system. They may be closely related. A lot of European countries or American, Canada have similar systems, but they all have different systems. And that is because it doesn't really make a lot of sense for, say, Australia or Greenland to be using the same soil classification system because 99% of the soil in Greenland is going to be of a certain chemical makeup and 99% of the soil in Australia is going to be of a certain chemical or mineral makeup.
12:56 Speaker 02 My understanding is that Greenland is mainly H2O in its frozen state.
13:00 Speaker 03 Yes, there's no soil in Greenland, terrible example. I pick one of the few countries on earth that does not have soil, basically. But you see my larger point.
13:09 Speaker 02 I do, yeah.
13:10 Speaker 03 So Australia's current soil classification system has only been around since about 1996 or so. It's relatively new. I've, I've added there a massive poster showing all the main, this is the highest level of soil classification. You've got things like anthroposols, which are man-made soils, dermosols, ferrosols, et cetera, et cetera.
13:33 Speaker 02 Yeah.
13:33 Speaker 03 And so the issue, and really the heart of what the disagreement has been about all along, is that we don't have a word for chernisms really anymore. And the early 90s, when those soil profiles that you were looking at, those diagrams, when they were being made, a kind of wet fertile soil with a lot of organics in it would be basically considered, well, we'd call it a chernism because it's close enough, it's similar enough in those kind of broad strokes.
13:58 Speaker 02 I've seen, I've seen, I've been to Ukraine. Those guys went to Ukraine, they saw that, they came back, they were in Nimitz Bell, they went, that looks pretty much the same as what I saw in Ukraine.
14:06 Speaker 03 Exactly. So, so what now we would refer to as chernism is something, is the much less catchy eutrophic black dermisol is basically what...
14:15 Speaker 02 I hate that.
14:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's terrible, it's terrible. And that's essentially what the most modern Australian soil classification would refer to it at. So, bringing back to that disagreement between our listener Anna and the geologist, Dr. Leah Moore. Anna Gibson, in her email, made reference to, I'll just check with one of my colleagues, that colleague that she checked with was Dr. Leah Moore. So, it came back to, we were all on the same page.
14:41 Speaker 02 You're a boar, we're all, we're all...
14:42 Speaker 03 Eating our own tail.
14:43 Speaker 02 Sneaking its own tail, yeah.
14:45 Speaker 03 And so essentially, at the end of the day, not to rag on Nimitz Bell and their Wikipedia editors once again, but the idea of a true, and just to make sure I'm getting the pronunciation perfectly right here, I will say that the idea of a true... Chernism. Is not quite as Dr. Leah Moore there, thank you Dr. Leah Moore. The idea of a true chernism doesn't really make any sense because we don't use the term in Australia anymore. So the idea that one would be considered chernism but isn't actually, or the other would be a true chernism, unless they literally grabbed a bucket from Ukraine and brought it over here, it, it doesn't really add up in the most modern soil sense. And I'm excited for all the actual experts to email in and tell me why I'm wrong on that. But that does seem to be where the modern science lies.
15:27 Speaker 03 To wrap up, yeah, how do you feel, Matt, at the end of this very long road where we've reached such a, in some would say unsatisfying conclusion, but how do you feel?
15:37 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, I mean, we've, we've basically come all the way to, well, technically, it's impossible for there to be Chernosim in Australia because we don't have a definition of that.
15:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:47 Speaker 02 I had, you know, images of myself, you know, on a giant dirt chair, on a, on a float, going down the main street of Nimitz Bell during their, obviously their annual Ukrainian Dirt Festival, being handed the key of the, the keys to the city by the, by the mayor, that kind of thing, and none of that's gonna happen now.
16:08 Speaker 03 Well, you've been saved the Wicker Man style ritual at the end where they sink you in a giant pool of Chertism to become part of the next, the next harvest. So you've saved yourself that fate at the very least.
16:23 Speaker 02 So is this the end of the, of the, of the Chertism story for us?
16:28 Speaker 03 I do have, it's not the end of the Chertism story in general, because-
16:32 Speaker 02 Of course not.
16:33 Speaker 03 Rabbit holds lead to rabbit holds lead to tangents. I did find this-
16:36 Speaker 02 Particularly in such fertile soil.
16:37 Speaker 03 Exactly. I did find this interesting sort of side story about the black market of the black soil, the theft of Ukrainian soil. This is a story that has been a part of Ukrainian sort of culture and history for a little while now. One thing I kept encountering through my research is this story that back in World War II, the Nazis, when they occupied Ukraine, were, were stealing, literally digging up-
17:03 Speaker 02 What?
17:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, entire trains packed with Chernosim and shipping them back to Germany. This is a story that I saw on very dodgy looking news articles. I saw it in YouTube comments on videos about Ukraine. I've got a comment here, "My wife is Ukrainian and told me her grandparents told her the Germans took truckloads of the black soil to Germany." Now, all this stuff is generally considered to be Soviet propaganda, not actually true. The logistics of war, especially at that time, were hard enough without having to move entire train tracks full of soil back to Germany. But it has been- A sort of persistent anxiety and nervousness in Ukraine and not for no reason.
17:44 Speaker 02 What have you done, Pat? You've opened up a new fascinating.
17:47 Speaker 03 I know.
17:48 Speaker 02 Oh, my goodness.
17:49 Speaker 03 It's it's a this is a very troubling thing, but to to kind of give the broad beats of it all. From nineteen ninety two in Ukraine, there was a full moratorium on the sale of Ukrainian farmland. So this soil that was so incredibly appealing and is so fertile. There was so much interest in foreign investment into this soil, but it was not allowed in Ukrainian law. There was a full moratorium against it.
18:11 Speaker 02 The new government of Ukraine.
18:12 Speaker 03 Exactly. So in that absence, a very lucrative black market popped up.
18:18 Speaker 02 Black market indeed. Ha ha.
18:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. I've got a quote here from the former Ukrainian Foreign Minister. I'm not going to attempt to say his name, but his first name is Boris, speaking back in two thousand and nine. And this is what he had to say.
18:30 Speaker 05 There is no secret that although there is a legislative ban on buying the land, the land is being sold. By the time when this, you know, moratorium will be lifted, I'm afraid that there will be no land left.
18:46 Speaker 03 So this was a sort of open secret in Ukraine that illicit sale of farmland and of this Chernism soil was taking place, according to the NGO Green Front. The kind of modus operandi was soil was dug up, loaded into trucks and shipped away.
19:03 Speaker 02 A soil heist.
19:04 Speaker 03 Yes, exactly, a sort of lands eleven, if you will.
19:11 Speaker 03 And then it doesn't make any sense. By that logic, it would have been good called casinos eleven, but don't worry about that.
19:18 Speaker 03 The resulting land that was dug up was then.
19:22 Speaker 02 That's almost good by she. That's very close, Pat. That's very good.
19:27 Speaker 03 So the resulting land that was that was kind of stolen was then used as an illegal landfill. They would fill up the hole that they dug with just rubbish that was illegally dumped. So it was sort of a crime on two fronts, but also two lots of profit to be made. Now, this market grew by twenty eleven. It was worth approximately nine hundred million dollars supposedly until in twenty. 2021, the ban on farmland was lifted. This was part of the kind of ongoing liberalisation of Ukrainian markets. It was part of the conditions of getting a lot of IMF funding.
19:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
19:58 Speaker 03 The issue then became a sort of repeat of this original rumour. After the kickoff of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, there are now rumours once again. Papers like Ukraine's Mirror of the Week are claiming that Russian supermarkets have begun to sell bags of stolen chernosy.
20:17 Speaker 02 What?
20:18 Speaker 03 That they're putting up advertisements showing a big newspaper out of a giant bag of dirt with a big 50 cent or whatever the equivalent Russian currency is stamped on the side. So the question is, is this true? Is this part of the Russian degradation of the land and part of the ongoing war? Or is it another sort of rumour of the fog of war and online misinformation? And we won't really know the truth, much like these Nazis supposedly selling off trainloads of dirt. Will we not know the truth for years?
20:48 Speaker 02 Oh, well, you've opened another can of worms, Pat. I mean, I now need to know whether or not there has ever been stolen chernosy. The fact that there is this repeating, recurrent rumour that foreigners are coming in to steal our soil is fascinating. And the fact that it returns in times of war is such a fascinating, fascinating idea. We're going to have to return to chernosy back in black, you might say. Pat, fascinating story. Well done. You've passed the test.
21:22 Speaker 03 One more month added to my sentence.
21:25 Speaker 02 Plus one. Yes, plus one month. You're going to have to come back with something equally interesting in a month. Very good. Thank you very much.
21:31 Speaker 03 Thank you.
21:39 Speaker 02 Thanks, Pat. We'll be back on Thursday, looking at the turmoil sparked by the latest release of Epstein files and what it can tell us about the current state of American society. I'll see you then.
Previous Stephen Miller: Edgelord in Chief Next How Epstein and QAnon blew up the justice system Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated