Pod Insights If You're Listening How Epstein and QAnon blew up the justice system About this episode When news first broke of a billionaire sex offender with a private island… the story didn’t erupt through traditional media — instead it circulated through online message boards like 4chan. What began as internet trolling and fragmented rumour became fuel for something much bigger.
The Epstein case fed directly into the rise of QAnon, a conspiracy movement built on the belief that a hidden elite was operating above the law. Now, after years of pressure and public obsession, millions of Epstein-related documents have been released by the U. S. government.
The Epstein Files have exposed networks, associations, and uncomfortable truths. But instead of restoring trust in institutions, they’ve underscored how fragile that trust has become.
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 3,753 words · 30 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 Corbyn middle mass here. The Ashes were awesome, but they are over. The good news is the cricket keeps rolling as the focus shifts to the T20 World Cup. Australia is trying to climb back to the top, India is looking all powerful and England is trying to turn Ashes shame into T20 glory. And did we mention the backroom power struggles? The ABC Cricket Podcast is dropping every Monday and Friday as former opener Ed Cowan joins me to pull apart the juiciest storylines in the game. Search for ABC Cricket Podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
0:37 Speaker 02 This podcast was produced on the lands of the Uwabikal and Gadigal people. Most world changing photographs are of moments of high drama.
0:46 Speaker 03 Only one brave protester dared resist the tanks.
0:49 Speaker 02 There's the Tank Man in Tiananmen Square.
0:52 Speaker 03 As onlookers cheered, the tanks tried again to move and were halted by their lone tormentor.
0:57 Speaker 02 There's the Napalm Girl in Vietnam. The occupants are flushed out, but it's not the Vietcong. And there's this.
1:04 Speaker 04 This picture was taken by American soldiers on duty inside Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad.
1:11 Speaker 02 The prisoner, hooded, standing on a box with wires attached to his hands.
1:15 Speaker 04 He was told that if he fell from the box, he'd be electrocuted.
1:19 Speaker 02 But I'd argue that a photograph of three smiling people taken in London in 2001 belongs on that list too. The photo was allegedly taken by Jeffrey Epstein. The three people smiling in it are Epstein's partner, Ghislaine Maxwell, Prince Andrew, the Duke of York, and a 17-year-old then known as Virginia Roberts.
1:43 Speaker 05 There's Ghislaine Maxwell, there's The Flash, that's me at 17, and that's Prince Andrew with his chubby fingers.
1:50 Speaker 02 Virginia told 60 Minutes on Channel 9 about the day that photo was taken.
1:55 Speaker 05 The photo was taken off of one of my small, yellow Kodak, the old disposable photos before we all had iPhones. So it was taken off of that.
2:03 Speaker 02 She developed the photo when she returned home to Florida and then took it with her when she moved to Australia in 2005. For six years, the one and only copy of this photo sat in an envelope on her bookcase at her home. Right up until she showed it to a reporter from the UK tabloid, The Daily Mail. The reporter had contacted her, asking if she had anything she might like to say about Jeffrey Epstein. It turns out, she did. Virginia Roberts, by then known as Virginia Giuffre, had been one of several women who had filed civil lawsuits against Epstein and had been paid $500,000 by him in a confidential settlement. But that wasn't the only thing The Daily Mail was interested in.
2:48 Speaker 02 They were interested in her relationship with Prince Andrew.
2:53 Speaker 02 Giuffre was the first person to publicly link Andrew with Epstein, a guy so obscure that, at the time, we weren't quite sure how to pronounce his name.
3:03 Speaker 06 In question are his links with Jeffrey Epstein, a US financier who's served time in jail for soliciting an underage girl for prostitution.
3:11 Speaker 02 It's odd to realise this in hindsight, but really, it was in this moment that the story went from being a curious, local, florid story about a creepy billionaire, to a global scandal, propelled by the royal mad, British tabloid press.
3:27 Speaker 06 Prince Andrew admits staying at Epstein's New York house in December was unwise.
3:32 Speaker 02 And without that photo, I don't think we'd have reached the position that we now find ourselves in. It was the first crack in the dam that has now led to a catastrophic burst.
3:44 Speaker 07 Millions more documents relating to the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein were released by the US Department of Justice.
3:50 Speaker 02 The tiny leak that started with that photograph in 2011 has become an unstoppable wall of water and debris, sweeping through reputations that we once thought were untouchable.
4:03 Speaker 07 The story the files tell is one of base corruption that stains all it touches.
4:08 Speaker 02 It seems that almost nobody is safe.
4:10 Speaker 08 There were holiday snaps of former President Bill Clinton and Epstein released, and messages from Elon Musk, asking for an invite to Epstein's wildest party.
4:21 Speaker 02 But to me, this wave of destruction is a sign of something deeply broken.
4:34 Speaker 02 Modern society relies on the idea that there are systems that will hold people to account for wrongdoing. But trust in that system has disintegrated to the degree that many people feel like mob rule is the only option. The courts, media and government have failed, so it's time for torches and pitchforks. But how did it get this bad? I'm Matt Bevan, and this is If You're Listening. So this photo, the world first saw it in 2011, when it was published alongside Virginia Giuffre's sexual assault allegations against Andrew Maxwell and Epstein.
5:19 Speaker 02 But after its release, five years went by and nothing really seemed to happen. Prince Andrew now has to live with an allegation he's denied while he continues his work as a senior royal. There was no sign of any criminal investigation into the allegations. Thankfully, Russian state media was here to help.
5:36 Speaker 09 We begin with a story of sex slaves, underage girls, a billionaire, murder, a prince, and at least one former US president.
5:46 Speaker 02 Ben Swan, a conspiracy theorist with TV host Good Looks, was on the Russian payroll and all over this story.
5:53 Speaker 09 There have been more than 40 women who have come forward with claims that Epstein not only abused them, but shared them with his famous and powerful friends.
6:02 Speaker 02 It's important to note here that even when this story was rumbling around in 2015, most people had no idea who Jeffrey Epstein was. Even Alex Jones, the conspiracy theorist from Infowars, seemed not to have ever heard of him.
6:16 Speaker 10 The allegation names multimillionaire financier Jeffrey Espin, Epstein, who was also convicted of soliciting sex with underage girl.
6:25 Speaker 02 But Jones, Swan et al. weren't interested in Espin, or whatever his name is, they were interested in those famous and powerful friends.
6:33 Speaker 09 What has been the biggest scandal in the UK since World War II has now come to the US, and it may involve former President Bill Clinton.
6:41 Speaker 02 This story bounced around conservative conspiracy websites throughout 2015 and 16.
6:46 Speaker 11 Go to conservativewell.com.
6:50 Speaker 11 And this story is there and you can verify it.
6:53 Speaker 02 But when you do actually go and try and verify it, you quickly find yourself following links to the online message board 4chan. If you haven't heard of 4chan before, consider yourself lucky. It's essentially just an unregulated website where anyone can post anything anonymously.
7:10 Speaker 12 It's very much like a Facebook group, except everyone's anonymous. There's no names.
7:15 Speaker 02 As a result, the website hosts everything from memes and edgy political takes to death threats and child abuse material that largely goes unchecked.
7:25 Speaker 13 The site has featured menacing material in the past, often difficult to trace.
7:30 Speaker 02 But a large part of the culture on 4chan was about pulling pranks and seeing who falls for it. In short, trolling. Think of 4chan as the spiritual home of trolling. Which reminds me, have you seen this video of my cat?
7:52 Speaker 02 If you've ever been rickrolled, well, even if you haven't before, you have now, that joke was born on 4chan. Not everything there is malicious. Sometimes people post classified documents there.
8:05 Speaker 00 The secret document from the Defence Intelligence Organisation was posted on a file-sharing site known as 4chan.
8:12 Speaker 02 And sometimes they just make up fake secret information just to see how the police and media is going to react. It's difficult to tell on there unless you're a very heavy user what's real and what's just being done for the lols.
8:26 Speaker 14 I don't think that I trust the general public's ability to identify fake news, real news, anything like that.
8:37 Speaker 02 A story, for instance, about a billionaire pedophile with connections to the royal family and the Clintons and a private island is just the type of fake news that would be made up for lols on 4chan. But in 2016, that exact story happened to be real news and the right-wing corners of the internet went bananas for it.
8:57 Speaker 11 This is huge. This is huge in that we...
9:02 Speaker 11 Appear to have an entire government that is involved in a child sex trafficking ring.
9:12 Speaker 10 Who knows if this is true, but my gosh, Paul, just the firestorm of pedophile news.
9:17 Speaker 11 Why the mainstream media isn't reporting this, I do not know, but this is huge.
9:23 Speaker 02 What the mainstream media was mostly reporting on in 2016 was the fact that giant batches of emails from inside Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign were being leaked online. Thousands and thousands of them. Folks on 4chan started combing through them to see what they could find, and then they started mixing what they found with the stuff about Epstein.
9:46 Speaker 02 And it quickly created this.
9:49 Speaker 10 Pizza Gate is real. Only question is, what exactly is it?
9:53 Speaker 02 Someone on 4chan posted a totally unsourced list of possible words inside the campaign emails that may have a more sinister double meaning, like pizza referring to underage girls. It was entirely nonsense, almost certainly just made up to see if anyone would be stupid enough to buy it. And it turns out that there really were people out there who were that stupid.
10:17 Speaker 10 This story that's been the biggest thing on the internet for several weeks, Pizza Gate, as it's called, is a rabbit hole that is horrifying to go down.
10:25 Speaker 02 It jumped from 4chan to conspiracy boards across America.
10:29 Speaker 15 A news site published a story alleging that Hillary Clinton and her campaign chairman John Podesta were running a child sex ring out of the Comet Ping Pong Pizza Restaurant in Washington DC.
10:41 Speaker 02 There were so many conspiracy theorists that were so obsessed with this story that I wouldn't have been surprised if there was like a red string, thumbtack and corkboard shortage at the time.
10:51 Speaker 10 What the hell is this? And you start reading it, there's thousands and thousands and thousands, and you know you're reading something real bad.
11:00 Speaker 02 When asked for evidence that the Clintons had anything to do with child sex trafficking, people referred to stories about Jeffrey Epstein, that photograph of Andrew, Ghislaine and Virginia taken on a disposal camera in 2001. That was proof, surely, of an elite pedophilic cabal, at least to your average internet user. And the fact that no one was being prosecuted for these alleged crimes was just further proof to those conspiracy theorists that it was an elaborate government cover-up. Next thing you know...
11:35 Speaker 15 The 28-year-old man finally went to the restaurant armed with an assault rifle, a revolver and a shotgun to find and rescue the children. He fired several shots into the restaurant before police arrested him.
11:48 Speaker 09 He reportedly told police that he wanted to self-investigate a conspiracy theory linking that store to a pedophile ring and to Hillary Clinton.
11:57 Speaker 02 Pizza Gate was a comparatively small conspiracy, a single slice compared to the extra-large supreme pizza it would eventually become. Users on 4chan watched on as the Pizza Gate chaos unfolded and soon came up with a fun new way of trolling people.
12:16 Speaker 16 Someone started posting as a secret insider in the US government.
12:20 Speaker 02 Virtually nonsensical posts started popping up on 4chan, signed by a single mysterious letter.
12:26 Speaker 16 Calling themselves Q as a reference to the Q-level security clearance.
12:30 Speaker 02 The posts, which came to be known as Q-drops, were largely stream-of-conscious nonsense. But eventually they started making predictions about things that would happen in the US government.
12:42 Speaker 16 Saying that Hillary Clinton would be arrested the next day, which obviously did not happen.
12:46 Speaker 02 What was the reason for this apparent arrest, which did not happen? Well, Q claimed...
12:51 Speaker 17 The United States government was secretly being run by a cabal of Satan-worshipping, cannibalistic child predators who were running a global sex trafficking ring and were hell-bent on undermining Donald Trump while he was in office.
13:08 Speaker 02 The Q-drops were full of references to Jeffrey Epstein. The existence of an elite child sex predator, a real one, gave an air of legitimacy to the claims, even though the rest of what Q was saying was total nonsense. But as those 4chan users suspected, people bought it.
13:28 Speaker 18 The QAnon conspiracy theory has taken off around the world. The bizarre ideology has attracted millions of believers worldwide.
13:38 Speaker 02 These posts, which started as an elaborate joke, or a troll really, grew into something bigger than anyone on 4chan could have imagined. Since 2016, QAnon followers have been entangled in everything, from a significant uptick in vaccine skepticism, to the attack on the US Capitol on January 6th, and even forcing the release of the Epstein files. It's hard to believe that it pretty much all started because of a single photo taken on a disposable camera in a London apartment in 2001.
14:17 Speaker 02 Now, that's a neat little story, isn't it? A way of viewing what's happened as an inevitable chain of cause and effect. The photo was a crack in the dam. People chipped away at it, and it grew and grew until the dam broke.
14:39 Speaker 02 But I've been thinking a lot about cause and effect lately. I think the dam metaphor is missing a piece. We might know where the beginning of this story was and where it's ended up. But the key question is, who neglected this dam so much that a single crack, left unaddressed, led to the entire dam bursting?
15:03 Speaker 02 How was the infrastructure so fragile? How did the American and British governments, and even the British monarchy, end up in the flood zone? Well, I think the key to understanding it is in the cultural climate of mid-2010s America. So let's wind back the clock a bit.
15:24 Speaker 02 Quick quiz question. Which movie won Best Picture at the Oscars in February 2016? The real surprise of the night was the winner of Best Picture. Any guesses? Well, here's Morgan Freeman at the ceremony. And the Oscar goes to...
15:42 Speaker 02 Spotlight.
15:47 Speaker 02 Spotlight was a movie about uncovering a massive institutional cover-up of child sex abuse. It was about reporters on the Boston Globe's special Spotlight investigative journalism team who painstakingly exposed the Catholic Church's efforts to protect pedophile priests by moving them around the country rather than reporting them to authorities. It came in the midst of a rash of movies about hero journalists and whistleblowers uncovering institutional corruption. There's this notion of the heroic whistleblower meeting with the heroic journalist in a dark parking lot or on a park bench.
16:27 Speaker 02 They hand over a binder of top-secret files which expose the corruption that's rotten right to the core. And look, that does happen in real life. There are historical examples like Deep Throat and Edward Snowden. In 2017, there were a lot of people leaking from inside the Trump administration.
16:48 Speaker 19 A so-called resistance inside the Trump administration to thwart parts of his agenda and his worst inclinations.
16:55 Speaker 02 The idea of an anonymous informant is such a cultural trope that The Simpsons parodied it back in the 90s.
17:02 Speaker 20 I can't tell you who I am, but I worked on the campaign.
17:08 Speaker 21 Hey, Mr. Smithers! Well, you might as well give me a ride home now.
17:13 Speaker 02 But in all those cases, both real and fictional, the key thing is that the person who's receiving the information from the mysterious informant is actually equipped to deal with it. They are journalists, lawyers, detectives, prosecutors, inspectors, or perhaps most capable of all, Lisa Simpson.
17:34 Speaker 22 I don't think Bob won that election legally. I can't believe a convicted felon would get so many votes and another convicted felon would get so few.
17:42 Speaker 02 The Watergate scandal in the Nixon administration wasn't uncovered by an anonymous guy altruistically leaving a trail of breadcrumbs for the public to follow. It was a dude who was upset that he'd been passed over for the job. Of FBI director leaking to newspaper reporters.
18:00 Speaker 23 Deep throat urged Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein to follow the money. And they did, all the way to the White House.
18:06 Speaker 02 Similarly, in Spotlight, brave victims and disgruntled lawyers told their stories to journalists who meticulously checked the facts before reporting on them.
18:16 Speaker 20 I had 20 priests in Boston alone, but I couldn't go after them without the press. So I sent you guys a list of names.
18:29 Speaker 02 The study of knowledge and how we decide what's true is called epistemology. In a functioning society, people trust the professionals, the lawyers, the journalists and the government to expose the truth. And that's because these professionals know how to fact check information, how to corroborate evidence, how to avoid defaming people, how to protect the identities of victims and deal with very sensitive material in a professional way. Once all the information has been verified by the people trained to understand it, the story is then published to be read by the public. When things are working as they should, the public is the audience, not the investigator.
19:12 Speaker 02 This is called an epistemic system, a structured method used by institutions to validate and organise knowledge. The epistemic system is the dam that controls the river of information, storing water, treating it and releasing it when needed.
19:38 Speaker 02 The way the Epstein saga has been brought about, not really by trained professionals, but ultimately by a whole lot of very angry people on the internet, is an indication that the epistemic dam is collapsing.
19:51 Speaker 02 For 20 years, some within the system have certainly tried to shine a light on this story, to use the power they had to hold people like Jeffrey Epstein to account. Reporters like Julie Kay Brown at the Miami Herald, for instance, tried to give victims a voice but struggled against a rot inside the justice system.
20:13 Speaker 24 This is the kind of corruption that isn't necessarily on the books as a crime, but it's corruption of the entire system that when you have a wealthy man such as Epstein be able to use his money and his influence to manipulate the system the way he did.
20:32 Speaker 02 British journalists tried to get answers out of the royal family but were met with denials and silence. Eventually, consistent campaigning from journalists and victims led to a reopening of the investigation, which led to Epstein's arrest in 2019. Unfortunately, the US government was too incompetent to keep him alive. Victims had to be content with seeing his accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell, behind bars. From that point, it seemed as far as the judiciary and the government was concerned, that was the end of the matter. Justice officials from both the Biden and Trump administrations said there was not enough
21:13 Speaker 02 evidence contained in the files collected during the investigation into Jeffrey Epstein to prosecute anybody else. They also said they had no evidence that Epstein ran a blackmail operation or was an intelligence agent for anyone.
21:28 Speaker 25 But I don't understand why the Jeffrey Epstein case would be of interest to anybody. It's pretty boring stuff. It's sorted, but it's boring. And I don't understand why it keeps going.
21:40 Speaker 02 So, case closed, I guess? Or at least, in a functioning system, that would be the end of it. But clearly, this is not a functioning system. This whole saga keeps going because nobody believes anything anyone in power says about it. Trust in the American epistemic system has eroded to the degree that a large section of the public spent a great deal of time and energy demanding that all of the Epstein files be released so that they can investigate the situation themselves.
22:10 Speaker 26 Nothing should be off limits in the search for truth. You're either on the predator's side or you're not.
22:16 Speaker 02 We've arrived at a point where the systems meant to protect people have failed so badly that millions of people now feel emboldened to tear everything open themselves. And we're seeing this happen in real time. The government has been bombarded with freedom of information requests for documents it could not legally release. But now, nearly 20 years after Epstein was first arrested, the government has given up trying to satisfy public suspicion. We've officially reached a point of no return and the dam has completely burst.
22:53 Speaker 02 They've declared that clearly, nothing they say will satisfy people. So they've released everything that they're allowed to release.
23:00 Speaker 27 Three million pages, 180,000 images, 2,000 videos made public, further exposing Jeffrey Epstein's web of crime and influence.
23:10 Speaker 28 They include serious claims about other alleged accomplices in his notorious crimes.
23:18 Speaker 02 That's where we are now. The files are out there, in all their horror. But we shouldn't have ever had to see these files. This is not how the system is meant to work. Everyone Epstein corresponded with for the last two decades of his life is now finding their lives put under a microscope. Some may deserve it, some may not. And worst of all, photo evidence has been released without context and names of victims have been left unredacted, exposing them to even more harm. The justice system has rules to avoid this kind of thing, but the justice system has crumbled under its own weight. It's given way to mob justice.
24:02 Speaker 02 Online, we're already seeing the revival of the pizza gate conspiracy theory. Our old friend Ben Swan is out there stirring it up.
24:09 Speaker 29 Epstein is pizza gate. But the other reality is time to accept pizza gate is much more and much bigger than just Jeffrey Epstein.
24:22 Speaker 02 It's not just pizza that people are interpreting as a code word, but grape soda, ice cream, frozen white tuna and jerky. People going crazy, think they found a code word for human meat? And now we're all doing our own investigations and coming to our own conclusions. We have to, because we're sure not going to trust anyone else's take on this story.
24:51 Speaker 02 If You're Listening is written by me, Matt Bevan. It's produced by Dare Shepherd and Pat Sunderland. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon. Look, this thing obviously feels quite big and upsetting and confusing. If you've got questions about the Epstein files, send them to us at ifyou'[email protected] and we'll try and find some answers. Send them in text form, or even better, record a voice note and email that to us. IfYou'[email protected] This story obviously won't be disappearing anytime soon. We'll be back on Tuesday. I'll see you then.
Previous There Will Be Mud (again) Next The time an astronaut said they weren't coming back Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated