Skip to content

How traders allegedly gamed CAS

Finshots Daily

9m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the downsides of the newly introduced closing auction session mechanism in the Indian stock markets and examines a case where it was allegedly manipulated. Market regulator SEBI recently pulled up Kopthal Mauritius Investment Limited and Manci Share and Stock Broking for allegedly gaming the Sensex closing price to boost profits on their option contracts. The discussion details how Kopthal used massive buy orders to spike the index before canceling them, while Manci played the opposite game to lower the index and profit from put options. The episode evaluates why this happened, noting that the closing auction relies on a single window with fewer participants, and discusses potential safeguards used by global exchanges such as order freezes and randomized closing times.

  • Regulators can deter market manipulation in closing auctions by following global exchanges that enforce no-cancellation windows or randomized closing times. 7:33
  • Traders can influence closing auction prices by flooding the order book with large orders and canceling them before execution. 6:05
  • Closing auction mechanisms can suffer from low participation rates compared to traditional volume-weighted average price systems. 9:30

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Host Transition Announcement

    Shashank announces stepping back and introduces new host Saad while thanking listeners.

  2. 1:01
    Episode Focus Introduction

    The episode’s main topic—downsides of the closing auction session (CAS)—is introduced.

  3. 1:38
    CAS Mechanism Overview

    Explanation of how the new CAS system works and its intended purpose.

  4. 3:42
    Kopthal’s Aggressive Buying Tactics

    Kopthal flooded the market with large buy orders to push the index up.

  5. 4:49
    Manci’s Spoofing and Cancellation Strategy

    Manci placed sell orders to lower the index and then canceled them to profit from options.

  6. 6:25
    CAS Vulnerabilities Highlighted

    Discussion of how CAS’s design allows manipulation through order cancellations and limited participation.

  7. 7:53
    India’s Current Safeguard Measures

    Overview of India’s existing no‑cancellation windows and random cutoff times for CAS.

  8. 9:39
    Conclusion and Listener Engagement

    Closing remarks, thanks, and invitation for feedback from listeners.

Highlights

  • 1:54

    SEBI Pulls Up Two Companiesdata

    SEBI pulled up Kopthal Mauritius Investment Limited and Manci Share and Stock Broking for allegedly manipulating the Sensex closing price during the closing auction session and minting 3.68 crore rupees.

  • 3:49

    Aggressive Buying Spikes Indexstory

    During the first two seconds of the auction, Kopthal placed 32 large buy orders worth 66 crore rupees, accounting for 99 percent of buy orders and instantly pushing the indicative Sensex level up by 362 points.

  • 4:35

    Playing the Opposite Gamestory

    Manci placed sell orders worth 145 crore rupees across eight Sensex stocks to keep the index artificially lower for five minutes, helping it exit put options at a profit.

  • 6:42

    The Spoof and Pull Tacticinsight

    Traders flood the order book with large buy or sell orders to move the indicative price, canceling most of them afterward without ever intending to trade.

  • 7:33

    Global Exchange Safeguardsstrategy

    Exchanges like the NYSE use a ten-minute freeze before the close, while Thailand and Hong Kong use randomized closing times to prevent manipulation.

  • 9:08

    Participation Drop in Auctionsdata

    Early data from Bernstein shows that trading in the final window accounts for just 1.6 to 2.3 percent of daily NSE turnover, down from 10 percent under the old system.

Quotes

  • “Unlike the old Vwap method, which averaged thousands of trades over 30 minutes, a call auction's single closing price can be heavily influenced by just one or two large participants if genuine competing orders are scarce.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:00
  • “CAS currently allows traders to cancel orders almost until the end of the order entry period.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:25
  • “The NYSE, for example, has a freeze 10 minutes before the close.”
    Unnamed speaker · 6:54
  • “Early data according to Bernstein suggests that trading in the final window currently accounts for just 1.6 to 2.3% of daily NSE turnover compared with 10% under the old Vwap system.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:08
  • “So, perhaps the solution is to extend the no cancellation rule to limit orders too, at least during the final few minutes before the random cutoff.”
    Unnamed speaker · 8:12
  • Team Dito 1:08–1:35

About this episode

In today’s episode on 21st August 2026, we talk about the downsides of CAS (Closing Auction Session) and explore whether Indian stock markets can keep manipulation at bay. Sign up for FREE insurance masterclass by Ditto https://ditto.sh/2cgegs

Transcript

0:00
9:53

1,665 words · 1 speaker

Topics

  • CAS
  • SEBI
  • Finshots Daily
  • SET
  • Vwap
  • Mauritius
  • Kopthal Mauritius Investment Limited
  • Manci Share and Stock Broking
  • JP Morgan Chase
  • NYSE

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated