Pod Insights Decoder Booking CEO Glenn Fogel wants you to take out your travel frustrations on AI chatbots About this episode Today, I’m talking with Glenn Fogel, the CEO of Booking Holdings, which owns a large portfolio of familiar travel brands: OpenTable, Kayak, and Priceline, as well as its largest subsidiary, Booking.com. This episode is pure Decoder bait all the way through — from Booking’s structure, to competition with hotels and airlines increasingly going direct to consumer, even to how European regulation affects competition with Google. Oh, and of course, how Booking is incorporating AI; Glenn has some fascinating thoughts there.
Glenn really got into it with me — there’s a lot going on in this space, and it’s interesting because there are so many players and so much competition across so many of the layers, even among Booking’s own subsidiaries. I think we probably could have gone twice as long.
Links:
The oral history of travel’s greatest acquisition | Skift
Long-term travel looks like a strong growth industry, says Booking’s Glenn Fogel | CNBC
Ryanair wins screen-scraping case against Booking.com | Airways
Aggregation Theory | Stratechery
A Call for Embracing AI—But With a ‘Human Touch’ | Time
Booking.com launches new AI Trip Planner | Booking
Priceline releases new AI platform and ‘Penny’ chatbot | Skift
Transcript: https://www.theverge.com/e/23976178
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Amanda Rose Smith. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 14,734 words · 9 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Companies shouldn't have to choose between speed and control. Amex Corporate connects cards with flexible spending controls and real-time visibility to help teams adapt faster. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:24 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
0:33 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:41 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:55 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neil Ipe-Tel, editor in chief with Virgin. Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking with Glenn Fogel, the CEO of Booking Holdings, which owns a large portfolio of very familiar travel brands, including OpenTable, Kayak, and Priceline, as well as Booking.com, the company's biggest subsidiary, which is hugely popular in Europe. I gotta tell you, this episode is pure Decoder bait all the way through, from booking structure to competition with hotels and airlines, increasingly going direct to consumer, even to how European regulation affects competition with Google. And it's really interesting, because there are so many players and so much competition for every piece of the puzzle. On top of that, Booking is a really big company. It's bigger than you might think. It has slowly and steadily absorbed many
1:40 Speaker 03 of its rivals over the years, starting with Priceline's purchase of Booking.com in the mid-2000s and ramping up with big buys like Kayak for $1.8 billion in 2013. You'll also hear Glenn say Booking is expanding beyond simply flights and hotels into experiences. That's why it has OpenTable, and he's thinking about other ideas as well. But even still, Booking.com itself accounts for 90% of the company's total profits. So I wanted to know how Glenn thinks about organizing resources across the company, especially since he's also the CEO of Booking.com. You see what I'm saying? Decoder bait. We also really got into why a company like Booking.com exists in the first place. It's basically an online travel agent. It doesn't own any hotels or run any airlines.
2:24 Speaker 03 And anyone who's part of a hotel or airline reward program here in the United States has probably noticed those companies are working really hard to cut out the middlemen and get you to book directly with them. Some airlines, for example, now only let you earn rewards miles if you book directly. I thought I understood that trend. Companies want a direct relationship with their customers. But Glenn's view is that it's actually an outlier. You'll hear him say that even the biggest travel chains in the world, your Marriott's and your Hyatt's, benefit from online travel managers like Booking because the world is so big and complicated. From where he sits, these hotels don't necessarily want to operate customer service in 100 languages or take dozens of different payment methods. And that's the service Booking is offering. Glenn was also surprisingly open with me
3:07 Speaker 03 about regulation. Booking.com is based in Amsterdam, and Europe's big new tech law, the Digital Markets Act, classifies it as a gatekeeper, just like Apple or Google. As you might expect, Glenn's not thrilled about that. But at the same time, it means competition with Google might be on a more level playing field. And I wanted to know how that might play out. Of course, it wouldn't be a decoder in 2024 unless we talked about AI. And Glenn is definitely bullish on AI over the long term, especially in customer service. That thing where you call customer service because you specifically want to talk to a person? Glenn thinks you might not need that so much in the future, in part because the AI won't care if you're really mad at it. You'll see what I mean. Like I said, this episode is pure decoder bait from start to finish. We probably could have gone twice as long.
3:50 Speaker 03 Okay, Booking Holdings CEO Glenn Fogel. Here we go.
4:05 Speaker 03 Glenn Fogel, you're the CEO and President of Booking Holdings. Welcome to Decoder.
4:09 Speaker 04 Well, thanks for having me.
4:11 Speaker 03 Booking is a big company. It's a complicated company. It owns a lot of brands that people know, maybe some brands people don't know. Can you quickly just describe what Booking Holdings is?
4:19 Speaker 04 It can be confusing, especially depending on where you live. If you live in the US, you may know, I hope you know booking.com, but you may know better Kayak. Or you may know OpenTable, or you may know Priceline. And if you're in Asia, you may know Agoda. And if you're in Europe, you definitely know booking.com. So a number of different brands, a lot of people are surprised by how big booking.com is versus the other brands. So booking.com is probably about 90% approximately rounding off of the total amount of profits come out of booking.com. And people are surprised, say, wait a minute, you mean OpenTable, Priceline, Kayak altogether?
4:58 Speaker 04 And then the other ones are about 10% and say, yeah, but it is a very big company. So even companies like Priceline, Kayak, OpenTable are very big companies too. It's just booking.com is much bigger.
5:09 Speaker 03 And that's almost entirely in Europe, you're saying, booking.com?
5:12 Speaker 04 No, no, no, we're very, very global. As I say, I hope a lot of people in the US, I think a lot of people in the US know booking.com and throughout the world. You know, we operate very global. The only places where we would have trouble filling your travel needs would be places that we're not allowed to operate because of either US or EU law.
5:30 Speaker 03 Booking is a company was formed with a lot of rollups, right? You're describing a lot of brands that started as independent companies like Priceline and Kayak and others. How does that work now? I mean, you bought them? Are they standalone companies? Are they all part of one company? What's the structure?
5:45 Speaker 04 Because you used the word rollup. I used to be an investment banker. And a rollup by definition really means take a lot of companies and merging them together into one company and reducing costs. That is not the way we did it. I've been at the company now since 2000. I've been here a long time. I helped do all the deals. So when we bought a company in, all of them were very small when we bought them. And one of the key things to get entrepreneurs to come and stay with us to us to create an independent management style. So the people who had started these companies would want to continue to do what they're doing so well. You had to give them the sense that they still had some stake in how things were going to be done. Now, over time, there's certainly been bringing together best ideas, communicating, how are things working?
6:30 Speaker 04 What's working here? Make sure you pass that information to other areas. And of course, there are some centralized services too that you do. But overall, we still like to try and drive down to the lowest level. It's not just at the brand level, but all the way down. Try and give as much authority and ability to make decisions as far down the chain as we can do.
6:48 Speaker 03 You mentioned the idea that you're going to help people with all of their travel needs, basically wherever they are. Is that how you think of the company as a service organization for travel? Are you bigger than that? Or do you have ambitions to expand beyond it? I mean, there's a lot happening in travel that I want to talk about, but I'm curious for just kind of the big picture.
7:03 Speaker 04 Travel is an enormous opportunity for us. It's hard to say how big is the total addressable market, depends on who you ask, maybe three trillion. Now, last year, we are by far the biggest company in the global space. Where our market cap was, you know, you're running $130 billion. That's very big. You look for the next biggest, and that'd be Airbnb. And they're in, you know, maybe around below 100 in the 90s. And the next one down, Marriott, you know, 70s. So we are very big, but there's still tremendous opportunity in travel per se. And let's face it, travel's still not done as well as we all would like it to do. So there's great opportunities for us to make it better.
7:44 Speaker 03 One thing that's interesting about Booking or any of your subsidiary brands, people know, you don't actually operate the travel experiences, right? You're not running hotels, you're not renting the cars. I'm assuming you don't run restaurants. I don't, everybody secretly has a cafe that want to run. My dream in life is to run a restaurant. So that's why I asked that way. But the travel industry is like a lot of paperwork. Fundamentally, is that how you think about you're automating the sort of process of getting a flight, booking a hotel, getting a restaurant reservation?
8:11 Speaker 04 Yeah. So, you know, it's interesting how you mentioned it because true, we do not operate hotels. We don't operate the actual planes. We, as you say, we don't operate a restaurant. But here's, here's the thing and one of, one of the issues though is how can you make it better? Given the fact that we're not going to provide the ultimate service that a person is actually spending their money for. And really that comes into a bit of, let's call it instead of paper, let's call it information. And this is something I've seen and looked upon over many, many years is how much really what we're just trying to do is organize information. Being able to provide the information in an easier way for people to make decisions. And then help execute those decisions in a better, faster way. That's really what we're doing here. And that's the service we're providing.
8:55 Speaker 04 Is making easier for people to discover, to learn about what they want to do, then to actually make their reservations, then make sure it gets done the right way. Make sure we're getting great value to them, making sure they're getting the best prices. And then God forbid, anything goes wrong and travel, sad to say, it's true. Sometimes things do go wrong. And then being available to help them quickly. That's really what we're providing. We're an agent to the traveler.
9:21 Speaker 03 When you say you're an agent to the traveler, that sounds like you're saying you're a travel agent, which is an industry that got wiped away, disintermediated completely by the internet. Is that coming back as people get out of the pandemic? They start spending money on travel?
9:32 Speaker 04 No. Well, first of all, a lot of people call us an online travel agent. That's the word a lot of you use. But the truth is that the human travel agent has been a declining population for a very long time. And I'll tell you the things that we're working on right now in AI and things of that nature, I suspect it's going to continue to decline. As we create the virtual travel agents, we use all the skills we have in AI, all the new things are coming out, particularly in generative AI. And try and recreate what was once upon a time where the only way you could do travel was speaking to a human being.
10:08 Speaker 03 One of the reasons I ask it that way, and it sounds like we're going to talk about AI, which comes up on almost every episode of the show lately, is that the promise of a human travel agent, or one of the concierge services, maybe a premium credit card will offer, is that they will know the right people at the airlines, or the hotel, or whatever, to solve your problem quickly, right? You'll just call your travel agent and they will do it for you. A website, or an AI chatbot, and some other interface, they won't have those capabilities. They will just have whatever capabilities the underlying APIs will give them. Is that a gap that you have to get through to kind of bring the travel agent experience back?
10:44 Speaker 04 Well, I think the way you phrase that may not be the way I would look at it. So when you say that there's a concierge who will be able to accomplish something better than someone like us could do, really what you're, what's really undergoing here is that if someone, this concierge person, that person has a very high volume and very high value to a supplier. So the supplier may then give that concierge agent more benefits in terms of helping cure problems faster. Well, we, there's no, there's no difference. We're doing it too with our best customers. Don't forget, an airline or hotel cares a lot more about the volume we provide to them than any single agent possibly. Again, you
11:26 Speaker 04 know, we did $151 billion a travel last year. $151 billion. That's a heck of a lot of travel. We have a lot of relationships. So the issue for us, though, is how do we distinguish, does someone who does more business with us, do we give them a higher level of service? Do we separate out and categorize customers? I think all businesses are always looking to try to take care of their best customers in a better way. That's just the nature of why you're trying to attract them and keep them.
11:56 Speaker 03 That actually brings me to kind of a big question about online booking services, like the ones you operate across the board.
12:04 Speaker 03 Do you want to own that customer relationship? You know, if you go to the airlines or you go to the restaurants or whoever, they would love to own the customer relationship. Delta does not want me to book with another airline. They certainly don't want me to book on Delta through you. They want me in their portal. Is that something that you find attention with? Is that something you've already worked through and it's a solved problem? That you want the customer relationship?
12:25 Speaker 04 So here's the thing, I like the way you ended with relation, customer relationship as opposed to ownership. I don't believe in owning customers. I think that's, I think it's a terrible phrase and I don't believe in that. I believe you want to provide a great service that that customer always wants to use you versus a competitor. And whether that competitor is another online travel agent or another portal like a bank that offers up travel services or even the supplier direct. You always want to provide a better service so they use you instead of somebody else. And how do you do that? That is at the basis, giving more value to that customer. Now, one of the benefits we have over anybody else is we get the ability to have a lot more data than any individual.
13:09 Speaker 04 So as I point out, you know, we do more travel business than any individual travel supplier does. In addition, we get to see the traveler across many different verticals. So while an airline may know a lot of habits about that person in terms of their flight, things they like to do, how they like to do their flights, they don't know a lot about their hotel preferences. They don't know a lot about their ground preferences. They certainly don't know about what they like to do when they get to wherever they're visiting. We have all of those verticals and that goes into a whole idea of what we call our connected trip. It's really stitching together all elements of a trip so that we can provide the great services. And as people use our services, we learn more about what they really prefer.
13:51 Speaker 04 We're able to personalize and provide better services to them. So they then feel a need, a desire to come back to us.
13:58 Speaker 03 I want to ask you a very simple, maybe dumb branding question. The site's called Booking.com. Priceline is obviously famous for name your own price for a flight when it started. Kayak, I think, started as a multiple flight search booking system. Those are all pretty flight centric. The idea that you're going to sell a full service experience, you're going to know the customer pretty well. Say, here's a bunch of experiences, buy this trip, push one button. Are you getting take up on that? Are people buying into that? Or are you still kind of stuck with what people already think of as the brands?
14:29 Speaker 04 So the first thing is, we are by far a hotel accommodation. Hotels are homes, all parts of accommodations. By far, flights is a very small part of the business compared with things. You're right, you're correct that Priceline 20 something years ago did start as a flight only. But very quickly hotels became bigger at Priceline. As I mentioned, Booking.com, our biggest company, it's only been doing flights for a few years. So for its 20 something years, it was an accommodation only business. So let's, you know, flights is the smaller or a much smaller part. But we are seeing people are beginning to pick up this idea of doing attractions and doing what to do there. And it is something that we are growing. We just started that a couple of years ago.
15:13 Speaker 04 So it's relatively early, but it definitely is something that when I am deciding, you know, and nobody decides, I'm going to go to a place, I'm just going to stay in the home or the hotel. You go because you want to do stuff. And one of the great things is that our customer acquisition costs are relatively low since we already have them going somewhere.
15:33 Speaker 03 This, I think, brings me into the decoder questions. You've mentioned a lot of brands people know and how they've changed. Priceline has changed from flights to hotels. Booking started with hotels and is going into flights. You've got other ones. How do you structure it so they either are competitive or cooperate? How is the company actually structured right now?
15:50 Speaker 04 You always want to make sure that you don't have cannibalization. You try and make it so that you're not actually fighting against each other. You're trying to compete against the outside. So obviously we have to set it up so that we call it with certain ground rules, how companies are going to compete, what areas you want to concentrate, asset allocation, capital allocation, how are you going to do it? And we do that through a, we have a group management board that I lead, where I bring together the leaders of the individual brands. I happen to also be the CEO of the largest subsidiary, Booking.com. So while I also run the Top the Booking Holdings, I'm all CEO of Booking.com. But it does create, require some coordination because you do not, what you don't want to do is waste
16:32 Speaker 04 time, energy, effort, money on doing things that are duplicative and things that you don't think are incremental benefit.
16:38 Speaker 03 Are you more of a divisional structure or more of a functional structure? Are each of your brands independent with overlapping capabilities?
16:45 Speaker 04 They are formerly separate companies. They do, they have their own CFOs, their own CEOs. They do operate as separate entities, but we do try and bring them together for coordination. And of course, the holdings company has a responsibility to enforce certain things that are standard that you have to have, just something that's almost privacy or say something like security. These are things that you want to enforce across the entire organization at once.
17:11 Speaker 03 Do you enforce those competitive overlaps? Do you say to kayak that they shouldn't get too much in the Priceline's lane?
17:18 Speaker 04 Well, kayak actually being very different, being a meta, they actually go across a little bit. A better example would be Priceline, Agoda and Booking. And making sure that we are concentrating the areas you want to concentrate. What we don't want to do is have somebody try and take business away from another brand and end up in a case where all we're doing is giving away money to somebody else because they were overpaid for marketing, let's say, in the area.
17:46 Speaker 03 Do you, do you think of those core functions like marketing or more specifically, technology as things that you share? Cause that's a pretty big cost across any sort of web property or service property like you run and having duplicative tech stacks is often the biggest cost.
18:03 Speaker 04 Yeah, the tech stacks are very different and they built up differently. So just for example, at the very beginning, you had Priceline and Agoda have what's known as a merchant model, in which case people would pay upfront for their reservations. Booking.com started off in a different way where they took no money upfront. You paid, for example, at the hotel. And then booking.com got paid a commission after you left. Very different structures and the way things are built up. Now, of course, we want to try and do things where we can actually get some synergies. We want to do something. So for example, procurement. Procurement is done across the entire organization. But of course, there can be different needs.
18:47 Speaker 04 So you want to try and get volume, scale, benefits. But at the end of the time, you say, look, we're not going to try and do this one size fits all because there are different needs. And that comes on a case by case basis.
18:59 Speaker 03 You've mentioned you've been there for 20 years or so. You've watched the company grow this way. You're now the CEO. What's the benefit of being structured this way? Because most CEOs come on here and they say, we brought things together. We did a bunch of synergies. We've stopped paying for multiple engineers building in different tech stacks. What's the value of having duplicated functions and divisions like this as opposed to kind of mashing it all together?
19:22 Speaker 04 As you know, CEO of booking.com, as CEO of the group, I always want to be careful and make sure what I'm doing is best for the entire organization, not just good for booking.com. And when we do do things that are, may appear to be duplicative, you want to say, well, what is the cost of standardization? What is the delay? How much are you going to slow things down while you're putting everything together onto just say, one platform? Is that really going to give the benefit? On the other hand, though, as I mentioned earlier about driving things down to the lowest levels of the organization, letting people just run hard with what they are doing. It gives, I think, a benefit overall. Okay, it's worked so far, but as you mature,
20:04 Speaker 04 as growth slows, as it always does over time, as you get bigger and bigger, it's just law of large numbers. It's harder to grow at 50% when you're a much bigger company than it is when you're a smaller company. Then you start looking at that. Are there better ways to do it in a way that will save money by standardization across the entire organization? But again, this is on the very nuance that we have to be careful not to slow the company down just for the sake of coming up with everybody doing it the same way.
20:33 Speaker 03 Do you feel, obviously you're speaking to me from the Netherlands now. Booking is headquartered there. You know, in the American market right now, the margin pressure on every company is out of control. And you do see companies getting smaller and consolidating their teams. Even the biggest tech companies had rounds and rounds of layoffs and they're eliminating things that seemed like a lark or maybe just your interest rate ideas that they had. Do you feel that pressure in Europe? Is that, do you think the market is different for you?
21:00 Speaker 04 Well, really, I think global, always global. We don't think individual markets, of course, we're reporting, we're talking about which areas are. We are a global company operating, you know, I don't remember the exact number, it's over 200 countries and areas around the world. So we're always looking, you know, we have the benefit of diversification and since one area may not be doing as well as another area, you get a benefit when the other area's doing better. But look, there's always pressure, whether economies are going fantastic or you're in a recession, either way, you're always under pressure because you have competitors who are trying to come up with better ways to do it. So you're always looking at your costs. You're always trying to make sure you're doing things in the best way and trying to save money. But you have to always be thinking, am I doing it in the right way?
21:43 Speaker 04 And am I doing it, I'm saving money, so I'm doing something good in the short term, but that's going to cost us a lot more in the long run.
21:52 Speaker 03 We need to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
22:02 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline. That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
22:12 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
22:19 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
22:33 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
23:03 Speaker 06 Low energy, unfocused, foggy, you might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body with a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors. Great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade hydrates better than water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
23:36 Speaker 03 We're back with Booking Holdings and Booking.com CEO Glenn Fogel to talk about the competitive landscape of the online travel industry, which has been consolidating aggressively for decades. I want to talk about that competitive pressure because it feels like in your business in particular, it comes from a lot of different places as opposed to just pad up competitors. But let me come back to that in a little bit. How big is Booking now? Have you been growing out of the pandemic or about the same size, you hold steady?
24:01 Speaker 04 We are far above where we were in 2019 before we went into the pandemic. Yes, I mentioned $151 billion of travel. That is a very large number. In the $130 billion of market capitalization, these are enormous numbers for most companies, but it's compared to the scale of the opportunity because travel is so big. That shows that we have a lot of growth still to have.
24:28 Speaker 03 How many people is the company now?
24:31 Speaker 04 Approximately round off, call it 25,000 employees.
24:34 Speaker 03 And how is that allocated? Is it mostly, is that mostly at Booking.com? Is that across the company?
24:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, more at Booking.com than the other ones is given the nature of the size of the different companies, but there are thousands in every one of them and spread throughout the world.
24:50 Speaker 03 And do each of those have their own structures or are all the structures kind of harmonized?
24:55 Speaker 04 Well, when you say structures, what do you, well, help me out. What do you mean when you say structure?
24:58 Speaker 03 I will, I will once again pick on Priceline and Kayak, which are the ones that I use, but you could pick any of them. Do they have their own product teams, their own design teams? And are those, are those structured the same way at each one? Or are they allowed to have different structures?
25:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, they're totally different structures within them. And of course, they are separate companies. They all have their own design, their own technology, you know, their own CTOs, their own chief product. Every single one is a separate company.
25:25 Speaker 03 So that part that you were talking about, about pushing things to the lowest level when it's necessary. How do you make those decisions? Do you, do you say, okay, we see what's happening at Booking. That's a good piece of core called AI technology. We want to bring that everywhere. When does that happen? Is that a meeting? Do you just send an email? Do you fire off a text?
25:41 Speaker 04 No, it's, there are different meetings. We call them sometimes steerco's across brand stuff. So for example, AI is a good example of this. We're having different groups have meetings across brands to ensure that all the companies are learning what, what's working in one, what's working in another. A lot of the opportunity right now for a lot of companies is increasing productivity through generative AI stuff. So we want to make sure, well, what's working here? What are you using for your co-pilot in your tech space? Which one are you using? Oh, how's that working? What kind of numbers are you seeing out of that? Oh, we should try that one too, or we should do this one because this is working for us. That's the type of thing. But in terms of the day-to-day stuff, you really go down deep.
26:24 Speaker 04 You keep the, you ask the question about how we make decisions. It's, we are a very data-driven company and most companies say that and everybody goes by, you know, that old, old saying that, you know, in God, we trust everybody else bring data. But we really live it and we've lived it for a very, very long time. You know, we were one of the first companies back in the early parts of this century to have, A B testing was our mantra, really. A lot of people weren't doing that. You know, a lot of people are doing stuff where it was the old style on the highest paid person's opinion. We never believed in that. We always believed like, show us the data because digital commerce is really one of the greatest experimental bench tables you could ever play with. And you can see right away, if I do this, what happens? If I do that, what happens?
27:10 Speaker 04 And we've been very fortunate and that's really how we came from. Really nothing to be the size that we are is by continuing to look at what is actual real in terms of data versus just what is somebody's opinion.
27:22 Speaker 03 That information sharing you're talking about at most companies is pretty unstructured, but the way booking is structured, where you've got these different companies, different teams, it seems like you probably need some sort of structured communication to make sure information is flowing between all these groups. Is that something you've organized or is that something that just happens organically?
27:41 Speaker 04 Well, a lot of it happens organically, but for important things, we'll set up steer codes. So we want to make sure that we do have actual centralized place for information to share. Or as I say, this group management board where I am sitting with the leads of my other companies and we are able to share, set up an agenda, what do we want to discuss, what are the important elements to do that. And then at the very top, when we're putting together our planning for the next coming new years is really getting the input from all the brands, all that in the very top I can see. And then we can add further adjustments to what is going to be the total plan for everybody.
28:18 Speaker 03 A steer co is a steering committee. That's my guess.
28:22 Speaker 04 Yes, correct. Correct. Steering committee. Right.
28:24 Speaker 03 And then how big are those committees? Do you decide, okay, we need an AI steering committee? And you just like pick a leader? How big do those committees get?
28:30 Speaker 04 It depends on the size and which one it is. It can all depend or just a few to a large one. By the way, since larger ones go slower than bigger, the smaller ones, just by the nature of the number of people who want to contribute. But we will set it up when there's an issue, an element or something where it's cross-brand and we want to make sure that we're getting good communications going across.
28:51 Speaker 03 I'm really interested in this because so many of the companies I talk to are functional companies where the CEO controls product and marketing and divisional structures are just more complicated. But it sounds like what you're saying is you get more speed, you're doing more testing with the customer. Is there a world in which you see, okay, we've gotten really big in order to make the big step change with AI or something, I need to do some more top-down leadership?
29:16 Speaker 04 I'm wary of ever having anything too centralized. I think you look at a lot of successful organizations that work much better because they're taking advantage of all the people's great ideas, all the people's abilities. And when you have, uh, look, it's funny, we hear stories and say, Apple got under jobs. And he was really, you know, the story is always of him sort of like the single heroic leader. But I'll tell you, I had never worked there and I don't know what it was like, you know, back in the day, but I bet there were a lot of smart people, there were a lot of good ideas and helping make sure those great products came out.
29:54 Speaker 03 They are no longer shy about saying they were there and had helped those products come out, I will tell you.
29:59 Speaker 04 Well, there you go.
30:00 Speaker 03 We'll use Apple or, uh, we just had Rivian on the show. Rivian is a super functional organization, right? The entire product operation reports to RJ, the CEO. You're saying you, you, you see some value in spreading things out.
30:12 Speaker 04 Oh, definitely. Well, I was just saying diversification is a great thing, too. You end up in this mono thinking where if you're one person, one idea, one, and this is the way it's going to be, that person is not willing to accept other people and be willing to, hey, maybe I'm not the smartest person in this particular thing. And having multiple brands doing multiple different things, I can think of a whole bunch of different things that came out of one of the brands or another one that was really absolutely fantastic. And of course, the other areas picked it up, say, we're going to do that too, because it's going to help us all.
30:44 Speaker 03 So this brings me to the other decoder question, which you already previewed a little bit. How do you make decisions? What's your framework of making decisions? And I think importantly here, is your framework different for your role as the CEO of booking.com versus the CEO of Booking Holdings?
30:58 Speaker 04 Well, um, obviously defer a lot of stuff to the brands, to those CEOs who are in charge of those companies. And more and more important for me is making sure, understand why they're making the decisions. And of course, at the end of the day, their responsibility is their numbers and hitting their, what they have said they're going to produce or what they're going to create. At booking.com, I'm the one who's responding to that. So I guess I had a conversation myself about that. But the thing is, at the end of the day, and I say it's how do we make decisions? We make decisions, like I said, on data, but also what's really important to me is listening, is really listening. And just because I have the title of CEO, doesn't mean I know everything. In fact, I don't know most things. In fact, I depend. My biggest, my biggest decision is really making
31:41 Speaker 04 sure that I'm hiring the right people, the best people. And even there, I'm using other people to help me make that decision because there's no one person who knows everything, of course. But actually, most people only know a lot about one simple, one single area, and they have to really accept their other people have a better understanding of other areas. You have to depend on them to make those decisions. I'm doing that all the time. Yes, I'll ask questions, and I'll listen to the answer and see how confident that that person is speaking, that person really knows what they're saying, and that they're, and it makes sense what they're saying. But at the end of the day, you really have to depend on the team. You know, look at your best sports teams, right? Best sports teams, because they're great players. The coach helps lead the team, but the coach doesn't play. The
32:26 Speaker 04 coach never goes on the court and scores the baskets, right? Coach never goes in soccer and kicks those, those shots. Yeah, coach never throws the, isn't the quarterback throwing the ball? The coach is setting up a structure and hiring great talent and making sure that great talent then goes out and execute to their best.
32:47 Speaker 03 Again, do you think about that differently for how you manage booking.com versus managing the CEOs of the other companies in the holding group? Because you're probably competing for talent across the board.
32:58 Speaker 04 Um, yeah, but it's not that, that doesn't come up much at all. It really doesn't. And yes, and we, really what I want to do more of, and we've done some, but I want to do even more, is the cross fertilization of people, having people move from one of the companies to the other ones. We have not done as much of that as I would like. We'll do more of that in the future. I think it's really giving people new opportunities and different opportunities. That'd be an important thing, I think, for a lot of people. Plus, I think people also enjoy new challenges and coming up with a new thing.
33:29 Speaker 03 I think I understand that company, like I said, almost every CEO I talk to runs a functional company. So I was very excited to talk to somebody in a divisional structure. But let's talk about the travel industry for a minute here. A lot has changed. You've been there almost 20, 25 years.
33:43 Speaker 04 25 years almost, yeah.
33:44 Speaker 03 You've been there almost 25 years. I think it's safe to say that there have been many radical revolutions in travel in that time. There was the pandemic. It went away. It's come roaring back. You've seen things like the rise of these premium credit cards. You've seen things like the rise of loyalty programs. And lately, I think you see the rise of influencers in social media, just really making things happen. Like, everyone went to Greece this summer, from what I can tell, and that's just like a social media phenomenon. What's the thing right now that's driving the most in the travel? Is it just pent up post-COVID demand? Is it something else?
34:16 Speaker 04 See, one of the benefits of having been in the business for almost a quarter of a century directly, and before that I was a business banker, and my clients were airlines, so I had more time doing that, too. So I've had a good look at this industry. Here's the great thing about it is that, in the long run, travel always grows slightly better than GDP. Okay, that's a global number, talking global now, okay? Now, there's going to be some volatility. And when you have something like pandemic, or the Great Recession of 2008 and 2009, and things there, or even earlier, the dot-com implosion recessions, the early part of this century.
34:55 Speaker 04 You always have these issues of, will it come back? And it always does. And that's the great thing. So I know there are going to be some soft times. There are going to be some great times. Like, when we came out of pandemic, there was that revenge travel surge. This is fantastic. But the truth is, I know that that couldn't possibly last, because in the end, we're going to end up in a long-term run where travel goes slightly better than GDP. Now, on top of that, our job is to get a bigger share of that. And we have benefits of scale and capabilities that enable us to do that.
35:28 Speaker 03 That scale is really interesting, right? You mentioned earlier, you have the ability to negotiate favorable rates or favorable treatments from some of the airlines or hotels that you work with. Those companies want to be direct to consumer, right? The airlines in particular, the hotels, maybe not as much. They're getting theirs.
35:45 Speaker 04 Look, nobody likes to pay for marketing. Nobody wants to pay for distribution. Everybody would like customers to come through them directly and no cost. That's what everybody would like. That's not the way the world works and marketing is a very important part. Distribution is a very part, part about how you sell stuff. But the desire to sell direct is, is always been there and always will be there.
36:09 Speaker 03 So do you go to those partners and say, look, we know you want to go direct, but the law of the world is you have to pay for marketing? Or do you say, we're going to bring you more customers and this rate is worth it?
36:18 Speaker 04 Oh, absolutely. We are, you gotta give added value. No one is going to use your service, no matter what it is, unless the person thinks they're going to get value. And the value to provide is incremental customers that they could not have gotten their own way, or they wouldn't have gotten as cheaply as they got it from us. So let's give an example here. Let's say you're a small hotel in Switzerland. How are you possibly going to get Chinese travelers? What are you, you're marketing Chinese? You speak Chinese? We do 44 languages, right? How you can do the customer service? You're going to have your customer service people do Chinese customer service? I don't think so. So there's so many different, how about payments? Let's do that one to do one too.
37:01 Speaker 04 Small Swiss hotel, do they take Alipay? Probably not. Did he WeChat pay? Probably not. We'll take the money from the customer in China. We'll put euros into the bank account of a Swiss hotel. Well, well, because Switzerland doesn't use the euro. So we'll put in Swiss francs for that. But that's the thing. That's the thing. You have to think about that, all the different ways things are done. So no hotel goes out and makes its own electricity. Why? Because it's cheaper to get the electricity from the utility, right? Well, we provide customers that they would not be able to get, or if they could, it would cost a lot more than us providing for them.
37:36 Speaker 03 So the small hotel in Switzerland is a great example, right? Everyone wants a small hotel in Switzerland to succeed. I assume, I'm guessing no one is rooting against the small hotel in Switzerland.
37:46 Speaker 04 Sure, the big hotels are rooting against the small hotel.
37:48 Speaker 03 It's the big hotels that are the kind of the problem, right? Like the, the American travelers probably looking for brands that they recognize. They might be looking for the Hiltons or the Marriott's. Or you think they're all, I get, but what I'm getting at is basically, are you selling a more boutique experience? Or are you selling the cheapest experience?
38:03 Speaker 04 We're doing neither. What we're doing is providing what the customer wants. The customer wants a marriage, wants a health, whatsoever. We have great relations with Hilton, every single international chain. We are a big supplier customers to them. If the person wants a small boutique, we can provide that. They want a home. You know, a lot of people don't, Americans generally don't realize how big our home business is. Our home business is approximately two thirds the size of Airbnb's, and that's just our home business. Now, what people also don't know is that, you know, we've been growing very rapidly and expanding. The reason they don't know is because in the U.S., we're not as big in the homeless area as we are in other parts of the world.
38:44 Speaker 04 But if you want a home, we can provide you with a home too. So really, the end of the day is what does the customer want? That's what our job is to provide them what they want, or provide them the value so they can get it better from us than they could otherwise. Because, let's face it, Kenny, as I say, what we're doing is an information transaction. And going out and getting information is very, very inexpensive nowadays. Another way to say that is we're just, the customer is just one click away from somebody else.
39:13 Speaker 03 Right, and usually those clicks are to the Hyatts and the Marriott's of the world.
39:17 Speaker 04 Well, why do you say that?
39:19 Speaker 03 Because those companies are big enough to do the marketing. They can probably figure out how to accept WeChat payments. They are inherently international. They can convert the money into Swiss francs and probably do some Forex leveraging and arbitrage, right? Like, they're big enough to compete with you on the services that you say you're providing.
39:34 Speaker 04 Actually, they're not actually. See, that's the thing.
39:37 Speaker 03 Oh, interesting.
39:37 Speaker 04 Even the biggest. We, and I won't say who, we've had some of the largest changes in the world come and ask us to provide certain types of services. Because we can do it better than that. I mean, think about, think about the technology basis.
39:49 Speaker 03 Well, now, I have to, give me a hint. Don't, maybe I don't have to say who, but give me a hint.
39:53 Speaker 04 No.
39:55 Speaker 03 I tried.
39:56 Speaker 04 Here's the thing. Think about the technology difference. Thousands, look, thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands of people are coming up or doing engineering stuff to create a better way to do travel in our companies. Most companies have nowhere near, and the people they do have have to spend. A lot of their time making sure that their own just basic, you know, bread and butter technology stuff is working fine. So we can provide these types of services to other suppliers in a way that's cheaper and better than they could do on their own.
40:28 Speaker 03 Do you see that tension in the industry that eventually people are being, becoming a supplier of hotel rooms to your platform? And that might be commodifying them.
40:36 Speaker 04 Well, of course, there's always the fear. Look, again, nobody ends up wanting to end up beholden to somebody else. Let's use a different example. How many times do we hear people complain about Google? And they say, I hate this. I have to spend all that money with Google to get a customer. If only they would come to me directly and spend, or I hate being beholden to Google. That's no different than anything else. Look, everybody wants to be able to make sure that their customers come to them and they don't want to pay for how they're going to get there. But the nature of competition is such is if somebody doesn't put money into Google, they're going to lose out on business. If somebody doesn't want to work with us, that's perfectly their reasonable thing. But if I can provide incremental value to them,
41:19 Speaker 04 they will generally want to do business with us.
41:24 Speaker 03 We need to take another quick break. We'll be right back.
41:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
41:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
41:52 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
42:05 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
42:36 Speaker 06 Low energy, unfocused, foggy, you might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body with a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors. Great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade hydrates better than water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
43:08 Speaker 03 We're back with Booking Holdings CEO Glenn Fogel to dive into the Google comparison and how regulatory measures like the Digital Markets Act are affecting his company. You previewed the next question perfectly because I was going to ask about Google. The comparison to Google here is right there. A bunch of media companies, for example, don't want to be suppliers to Google. They want a direct relationship, but the search engine is what creates demand. You've talked a lot about generating demand, about matching the customer with the small hotel in France. That's a search product. Is that how you think about the core value? Is this is a search product and it's going to curate the results for you?
43:41 Speaker 04 That's one element, but there's so many things. You know, we go all the way the other way. One of the worst things for people on travel is a problem. And if you're not there to solve that problem, if they booked it with you, but you don't solve for them, they're never coming back to you. So one of the great things you provide to a customer is assurance that if something goes wrong, you'll be there to help fix it for them and they won't be out on their own trying to fix it. That's a real value. No search engine does that. That's a big difference. And in fact, one of the reasons people say, and I don't know, I've never gotten this from Google, but a lot of people say, you know what reasons Google does not go further into the actual transaction? They don't want to deal with that actual messy, messy part of customer service. Now, that may be true or not.
44:25 Speaker 04 Certainly, I can understand why somebody, it's a hard thing to do well, but once you do do it well, you have an advantage.
44:33 Speaker 03 One of the other interesting parts of the comparison to Google is where the results come from. Right now, I think a lot of people are reevaluating the sort of deal Google gets, which is to index all the websites and then show the results. And then AI has made it so that Google might read the results for you. There's just some recalibration about where Google gets its results on, what it's around, allowed to scrape, and in particular, what the AI companies are allowed to scrape. You run a search engine. Literally today, as we're speaking, Booking lost a case against Ryanair, which had accused Booking.com of scraping the website and then overcharging fares. Is that just the way it goes? Do you have to be able to go look at everything and you feel like you should be able to look at everything? Or do you need deals with airlines, hotels for API access?
45:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, the Ryanair case had nothing to do with scraping. So if you read the actual case, it had to deal with a 1980s law that dealt with whether or not somebody can access information using a password. And did that create a problem for the user? It dealt with things of hacking back in the 80s. What's interesting in that case, though, while we're not pleased with the way it came out, and if you saw the amount of damages, $5,000, literally $5,000, I mean, really, I mean, unbelievable. Here's the thing is, I like the idea that people should be able to get information as cheaply as possible. But I
46:01 Speaker 04 also understand the issue that people have ownership of proprietary information they have created. They should not be forced to share it. But if I do put something out to the public, then I have essentially given it out to everyone that anybody should be able to use it. It's an interesting question. You know, this whole generative AI thing is going to be a very interesting case, because as we've seen some of these cases come around, the training models, the training sets for these models is, well, should somebody have gotten paid for training that information for the model or not? And I don't know how these court cases are going to come out. I certainly am as interested as the next person in what these type of cases are going to result in.
46:44 Speaker 03 As it happens, I know that 1980s law that you're talking about pretty well, it's the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. It's the law that says you can't access a computer system without Permission, and if you do, it is very messy. The history of the CFA is not cut and dry, and certainly it does not always get applied well. But the core idea of it, which is you need permission to access a computer, even if it's on the internet. Well, the court just ruled against you, right? The Ryanair published its prices and you got them somehow. Is that something you need to structure or systematize across the board? Like, are you paying for API access to your various hotel and flight partners?
47:19 Speaker 04 You don't pay for API access, but what's interesting in your case is you say, yes, that was the first. That was the jury decision. Fortunately, we're not done yet. We'll be appealing this, so it's not over till it's over on that one.
47:36 Speaker 03 Well, I look forward to that appeal. Again, the CFA is messy. For the listener, we can fall down a long rabbit hole in the CFA, which we'll avoid for now. But I promise it's messy if you want to look into it. There's other kind of issues here, especially in the comparison to Google. For example, in Europe, the Digital Markets Act was just passed. Called Meta, Google, and Apple gatekeepers. And at classifiedbooking.com is a gatekeeper too, right? You're in the same category as the big players in the internet because you own the demand. In the parlance of my friend Ben Thompson, you're the aggregator, right? And because you can control and send demand, you have a lot of power in the market. Do you see that kind of regulation as having a meaningful impact on your business?
48:15 Speaker 04 Here's the thing. While we certainly were not pleased with being called a gatekeeper in what is one of the most competitive industries in the world. The idea that we have such a, as the regulators alleged, that we have a dominant position. And I'm like, well, do you feel that you don't have another way to get travel? I mean, really? But that's the way it is. That's the way it is. Okay, so we have to follow the rules and we are following the rules and we are doing all the things necessary for that. And I don't see it as being a huge issue for us at this time. But I do see on principle, it's unfortunately going to, you know, something that I've said several times.
48:59 Speaker 04 I don't think this was the Optimal solution they were searching for. You know, it's interesting about regulations. I'm in favor of regulations in general. You can't have, like, uh, yeah, let's go back to sports. Sure. You can't have a sports game without rules, right? I mean, let's go, soccer is an easy one. That's your rule. That you can't pick up the ball, because if you can pick up the ball and run with it, then it's not soccer anymore. Then it's something else, right? So that's okay. So the thing on my, on regulations though, is I want the rules to be the same for everyone. I don't like it when certain companies are governed one way, other companies are governed another way. That gives a bias for one versus the other. I don't see really need.
49:39 Speaker 04 Now, sometimes it seems that we have to do that because this company is so large and actually has a monopoly position. And I say, okay, now I understand. That kind of makes sense. But then we look at ourselves and we're not, oh, a monopoly? You're kidding me? Even more so, which is sometimes regulations really don't, don't, they're, they're set up for a reason. That's a good reason, but it doesn't work so well in practice. I'll give you an example that right now there's a shortage of pilots, commercial pilots. A lot retired during the pandemic and the world needs more pilots. So in parts of the world, there is a regulation that no matter what, if you're 65 years old, you can no longer be a commercial pilot. Now, the idea is what? Well, we want to have safety. We want to have aviation safety.
50:22 Speaker 04 And then you take that, well, we don't want pilots who are too old to fly. And then they just came up with 65. But here's the thing, there's somebody, uh, one day after they're 65, suddenly they no longer are able to fly. And the day before they were able to fly, that doesn't make a lot of sense when you think about it. There are probably a lot of 65 year olds who actually can do their job fine and that your health is perfect and fine. And so maybe the rule should be something that actually talks about capabilities and health and really make it so we want safety first, absolutely. But maybe just having an arbitrary 65, which was put together probably diagnosed how many decades ago? When maybe 65 year olds really shouldn't be flying. It just, it just seems strange to me that, and that's a rule that's not good.
51:04 Speaker 04 So what we want is regulations that actually are effective of achieving what their goal is, not coming up with something that is a proxy for it and ends up actually making things worse in terms of when you start segregating out different companies in different areas. And we'll see. Of course, politics plays a big role in a lot of this.
51:23 Speaker 03 Oh, we're going to get to politics in a second, but let me flip the DMA conversation on its head for one second. Obviously, the DMA applies to Google. There are companies here in this country that are thrilled about the DMA that would love something like DMA to come. Yelp is the company I'm thinking of.
51:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, sure.
51:38 Speaker 03 Is Google being under the DMA and having to open up its search results, or at least not being able to favor itself so much? Will that help Booking.com or Booking, any of your companies?
51:47 Speaker 04 We'll see, we'll see the, you know, it just happened in terms of the lock him to effect not that long ago. And then the companies have six months after being named a gatekeeper to make certain changes. And then the EU regulators have a chance then to examine it. We'll see, it's very early to know how these rules are going to play out.
52:08 Speaker 03 What changes do you think you're going to have to make?
52:10 Speaker 04 There are certain requirements in terms of sharing information. Um, I can go through a whole list of the DMA, but again, what I'm saying is I don't think it's going to change your business hugely. I'll give you an example that it changes. So one of the things that we have in, in the past, we've said to hotels, for example, we'd say, look, here's the deal. We'd love to do business with you. We'll translate all your content. We will give you lots of advice and what photos to put in. We will make sure that you can try and get customers from all over the world and provide incremental demand. And we're not going to ask for any money at all right now. We'll do all that for you and we'll spend a fortune in marketing. So you'll get more customers.
52:53 Speaker 04 The one thing is though, the one thing is though, if you do get a customer, we'd like you to pay a commission. So there's no risk and you know, you'll get almost all the money yourself, just a little bit of a commission. The one other thing though, is what would be really bad for us is if you are priced below the price you give to us. Well, what will happen is people will use us to figure out which hotel they want. And then they'll just click over to you and get a cheaper price. And that in the end, we won't then get the commission because they booked it with you, et cetera. So we'd like you to, that was called parity. And the DMA says, Can't have that parity. And we're like, really? Okay. Well, in, in some countries, we didn't have that.
53:36 Speaker 04 So now what's happening though is because other countries, we'd already dropped that parity. We saw there wasn't much of a change actually in the business. But one of the things we'll do is we'll have to continue to give more benefit to our customers. So they still have a reason to book with us. And now, of course, we can match the price at a hotel, you know, lowers the price. Well, then we can lower the price too. We'll do that. Or we'll provide more services and more things so they continue to use us. And in the end of the day, maybe this is good for actually society, more competition. I don't know. It is what it is. It's a rule. We're following it. And I still believe though, in the end, the best thing is provide a better way to do travel. And that's how you win in the long run.
54:17 Speaker 03 I gotta tell you, I, I, I know there's a long history of arguments about price parity, especially in Europe where you operate. The way you describe it, it doesn't sound bad, right? Like you might pay a higher price on your property, but you know that you have to earn that money.
54:31 Speaker 04 Well, and you never know, we may just lower the price ourselves, you know, while they may give us a price. And, you know, we have X percentage of commission. Maybe we take some of the money out of our own pockets. So we make sure that the customer still gets the same price. We'll figure it out as we go along. But I definitely believe that you have to provide better value. If you don't, why is anybody going to use you?
54:50 Speaker 03 It just broadly step back out of, out of your role as CEO of these companies. You talked about needing rules and make sure, make sure the game is fair. Doesn't that seem like the right outcome? That the companies are under more pressure to deliver more value?
55:03 Speaker 04 It could work out that way. It could be something that way. I think the way we were doing it though, was a very good way to do it. Because the only, yeah, the way this is called, by the way, narrow parity. We've only had narrow parity. We weren't saying that they couldn't have lower prices with other websites and other competitors that were just saying like, if we're going to have a partnership with you, with hotels, we'd really like it to be that people don't use our service and do everything, then just jump over to you frictionless, see the go over and get cheaper. But okay, look, this is the rule. This is the law. It'll be this way.
55:36 Speaker 03 You mentioned politics and talking about regulation versus politics, but it is election season in the United States. Booking Holdings is a holding company. It's a company formed of acquisitions. Right now, under the Biden administration, acquisitions are somewhat disfavored. It's hard to get them through. Although I will say, Microsoft was able to buy Activision, which is a pretty big acquisition that occurred under the Biden administration. But it's generally harder to get them through. Are you looking at, okay, we got to make more acquisitions. I hope that climate changes. Because around the world, in Europe, the United States, these big kind of deals are disfavored in favor of more competitors.
56:11 Speaker 04 Well, I think you're right that there definitely has been a trend over the last few years in Europe, in the US, and in other parts of the world that has changed what used to be thought of as something that was a good idea of allowing mergers and acquisitions to enable better services to the customers. To now be, wait a minute, maybe it's squashing our competition. Look, it all comes down to the individual cases. And what we don't want to do is enable monopolies to continue to entrench their monopoly power. On the other hand, what we don't want to do is destroy what is a very important part of the entire tech ecosystem,
56:53 Speaker 04 which is enabling people to create new businesses, get venture capital money to form these companies, become somewhat successful, but recognize that you need an exit. And very, very, very few companies ever become of a type that can become an IPO. So the general way people are able to get their investment out is through the sale of that company. And by lowering the ability of big companies to buy these startups, smaller companies, et cetera, enable this whole cycle of capital being allocated to new ideas, creating new service, new product. Then it'd be bought by a larger company, and that money flows back to the venture world and creates new companies.
57:38 Speaker 04 That whole cycle is being disrupted, can be disrupted. Buy this idea of, well, we're not going to allow profitable big companies to buy anything. That's a bad idea. And I think it's naive of some people to believe that there'll be no consequences to this.
57:53 Speaker 03 Have there been any acquisitions that you haven't done because you were chilled by the regulations?
57:59 Speaker 04 Well, go the other way. We were in a, we were blocked, literally blocked by the EU from buying a relatively small flight travel service. It's called E-traveli in Sweden. We wanted to buy it, two billion, which relatively small size compared to the size of our capital. And also, what's interesting is a very competitive market. There's no shortage of ways to buy an airline ticket in Europe or anywhere, okay? But here's the thing, they said, "Well, if you buy that, that's going to increase your ability to sell hotels." A little true. There's some benefit to it, of course, and I can't deny that. And the regular said, "It'll increase your share by one to two percent." That was their opinion, that was their decision, right? And therefore, you shouldn't be able to buy, you're not going to be able to buy that.
58:44 Speaker 04 Now, my, my answer to that is that makes very little sense, given a lot of our competitors have both flights and hotels. And by us buying this flight company would enable us to make a much better flight service with our capital, with our technology, with what we know how to do. We'd make it even better for the consumers, and we'd provide more competition to the flight business. Well, we're appealing that one, too. So, we'll see. Come back in a few years, I'll let you know how it worked out.
59:13 Speaker 03 Again, you've got two CEO roles. How much of your time do you spend on these kinds of issues? The regulatory issues? And how has that changed?
59:20 Speaker 04 Well, it never used to be any time at all back in the day. I mean, back in the day, this never came up. And now it starts to come up. One's the fact of us being bigger, one's part of it, because you, as you point out, the world has changed a little bit, and it does take time. And it's, it's thinking these things through and dealing with lawyers, people who are public affairs field. We never had a public affairs department until relatively recently. And our legal department's expanded a great deal. Part of the problem is, though, is that we prefer to spend that money on hiring engineers and create better services. Unfortunately, when we have to spend a lot more money, not just with hiring lawyers, but hiring outside counsel, etc.
1:00:02 Speaker 04 That's money that can't be used to make better products and services for society.
1:00:07 Speaker 03 Come on, Glenn, you're creating jobs. You know, there's public affairs people, they need to eat, too.
1:00:11 Speaker 04 Well, I agree. I get, they do, they do. But, you know, but the thing is, though, I'd rather have that money on engineers to make better products.
1:00:20 Speaker 03 No, I've, I've heard that argument before. I was, I was joking about the other thing, but I... You know, I used to be a lawyer. Every now and again, I gotta, I gotta defend my people a little bit.
1:00:28 Speaker 04 Hey, hey, I, I, I have a law degree. I'm a member, I'm a member of the New York State Bar. Nothing against lawyers. I'm just saying that in terms of, you know, hey, look, in the end of the day, we do need lawyers and we do need rules and our society is better off because we actually live by the rule of law.
1:00:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:00:46 Speaker 04 Those societies are better and I'm in favor of that. I would just like to have smart laws.
1:00:51 Speaker 03 Taylor Swift has been on to where she's conquered the entire world now. I believe she's actually the president of the United States in secret. That's my conspiracy theory. Um, in the United States, the experience of buying a Taylor Swift ticket was basically horrible. And there's a long, we did an entire episode on, on the antitrust law changes in the eighties that led to Ticketmaster that led to literally congressional hearings about Taylor Swift and Ticketmaster. In Europe, it's very different, right? I, I have friends who have flown to Europe and it's cheaper to buy a ticket to a Taylor Swift show and a flight and a hotel than it was in the markets that we have here in the United States. That's crazy. Do you see that regulatory difference as being better? Right? Because the, the market for all of those things is more regulated, more constrained.
1:01:34 Speaker 03 And it seems like everyone's happier, like everyone's still making money and the consumers are happy.
1:01:38 Speaker 04 Well, let me say this first. I'm not an expert in the Taylor Swift economics. I understand there there is actually a course at one of the top business schools. I think they was looking at a case about the Taylor Swift economy. And I, I, your point about people flying to Europe, I, I do know of somebody who flew to Brazil for the Taylor Swift and did end up being cheaper flying to Brazil, going to the concert there, coming back than it would have been to buy a similar seat, you know, seats in the, in the New York, uh, I think it was New York. I know where it was in the U.S. Here's the thing though, I don't know that it's because of any changes in regulations about ticket selling or monopoly. I have no idea how much, and I can't speak to that.
1:02:19 Speaker 04 I can say though, that certainly we agree, everybody, no one, no one's in favor of monopoly. Nobody, I, I, I've never met any economist who would say that's better for society to have monopolies. So I, I say that now I have to think back. Of course, there are some natural monopoly type things that people think it's a but you know, we're on the same page on that. I'm not sure that Europe's any better in this at all though. And I certainly can tell you that I'll give you a lots of example in Europe where unfortunately, this goes back to politics, where the protection of certain vested interests are much worse in Europe than they are in the US. So it depends on which industry, which thing you want to talk about. But you and I, we're on the same page, though, that we want to create an environment, an economic
1:03:02 Speaker 04 system that provides the best value to the society. And one of the ways to do that is to make sure there is fair competition.
1:03:11 Speaker 03 Let's end on the AI piece, which you mentioned several times, is an investment every company is making. The idea that I have a problem when I travel and I can just speak in natural language to an assistant that will help me solve that problem is very powerful. I understand why you would be investing in that. There's a lot of steps between here and there. So let me just ask the first foundational question. Do you think the AI systems we have today can actually do the things you want them to do? Because that seems like the most open question of all.
1:03:41 Speaker 04 Well, they can do some of the things we want them to do, and they're doing them right now. I mean, I like the fact that when I get on a plane, I feel fairly safe because all the automated AI type systems in that plane work pretty darn well, and it flies pretty well. That's a good thing. But in terms of something which you think would be less complicated would be some sort of generative AI customer service.
1:04:06 Speaker 03 Specifically, that's what I mean. A customer-facing LLM system. Can it do it? Because it doesn't, I don't, the proof isn't there yet to me.
1:04:13 Speaker 04 No, it can do simple things. So you can, let's say, I'll give you a good example. OpenTable right now is working with an AI company and its restaurant partners. And if you want to make a change to your reservation, if it is one of the reservations, one of the restaurants that has signed up for this, you will get that answer exactly. You can do it just like that with a human-like voice talking to you. Say, I need to add a person to this reservation, or I need to cancel this reservation or something. And that's in freeing up the duties responsibilities of the host. If you'd called the restaurant and wanted to tell them to change it, instead I talk to a human,
1:04:54 Speaker 04 the machine, the AI, the AI is doing it for them. That's a good use case. That shows it can be done. Now, lots of little ones, but the complicated ones were nowhere near that. And that's unfortunate because we do need it badly. I mean, look at what just happened the last couple of days. Where, you know, the things go down and people are upset and their customer service numbers go off the chart. Then you have to try and figure out, okay, how are we going to fix this? And it requires a lot of humans to do it as opposed to the AI. Something will be there though, just not sure when.
1:05:27 Speaker 03 That when is really important, right? A company like Booking that needs to operate massive, scalable customer support phone lines or chatbots. You are the target customer for the Open AIs and the Googles and the Microsofts of the world. Like when I talk to them, they imagine you. And all of their investment and their current market caps are predicated on their products being sold to you in a way that works. So I think it's important to note, like you're not ready to make that investment in their tech yet because you don't think it works.
1:05:59 Speaker 04 Well, no, no, we are making huge investments because you won't be able to create these without, without working on it to make it out. I'm just saying we're not there yet. But we are getting some things there. Some of our customer service stuff is already going through that we're able to do simpler things with that. And I imagine the rate of advancement is going so rapidly. I maybe it'll be sooner than I think we'll actually be able to achieve some of these things, but it's very complicated stuff. Being able to, for example, if you have a flight that is delayed. Being able to have an AI agent go through all the permutations, kind of what the right things are.
1:06:39 Speaker 04 And all the other parts of the trip, because a trip is a chain of many different things. First, you have to get from your home to the airport and the plane takes you to the place. Then you have to get from the airport to your accommodations. Then when you get to the accommodations, maybe you had dinner reservation, many linked parts. And then you're, imagine that generative AI, human-like agent will be able to deal with all these things and all these possibilities. Tomorrow is not, is not real, but in the not so distant future, yeah, I think we'll get there. It's just going to take some time.
1:07:16 Speaker 03 When you think about that time and then your investment, what's the horizon on that investment having to pay off?
1:07:22 Speaker 04 Look, it pays off when you start getting the simple things done, which we're already doing right away, because that means that I won't have to hire as many new customer agents to handle as the volume increases. We won't have to increase the number of CS agents at the same rate because the simpler cases will be handled by these AI customer agents. And at some point, gradually, gradually, gradually, it'll get better and better and we'll need fewer and fewer. And it'll be something that I think will be better for the customer because I don't know anybody who ever enjoyed waiting on hold to speak to someone to fix the problem. One of the wonders of doing an AI agent is that they'll be in a whole time, right?
1:08:07 Speaker 04 Right to the machine. That'll be a great thing. And by the way, the AI agent is never going to get angry back at the customer. Sometimes customers get really angry, which just justifiably sometimes, and they may say things that would upset the agent. And the agent may then yell back if it's a human. The machine is never going to yell back. It's always going to be nice and it's never going to come with a bad attitude, could have had a, you know, fight with its spouse in the morning. It won't come really tired because it stayed out too late the night before. I tell you, there are a lot of benefits to having an AI agent versus a human, and I hope we'll get there.
1:08:44 Speaker 03 I'm excited for the stories of people trying to jailbreak the AI agents and make them get angry with them because it, people are people. That's what they do. They encounter these chatbots and it's their first instinct is to break them in that way.
1:08:55 Speaker 04 Fortunately, most people aren't like that.
1:08:58 Speaker 03 But some are. It's a great effect and it's very fun. What AI company are you working with right now? Is it OpenAI? Are you with Google?
1:09:04 Speaker 04 We work with everyone you've probably ever heard of and probably some you may not have. We're always talking, we may not have signed a contract, but we're always discussing possibilities. Look, again, We meet a lot of advances, but I believe we are still in the very, very early stages of what the possibilities are down the road. And I'll bet there's some of the companies that are going to come, the big winners have been invented yet.
1:09:27 Speaker 03 You've obviously thought about this through the macro level. Do you think that the kind of needs that you will have in the future for customer service will support the valuations and investments the big AI companies are putting forward right now? There's a paper from Goldman that came out that said this math doesn't make any sense at all. Do you, you're in it, you're the customer. Do you think there's enough demand for those valuations?
1:09:49 Speaker 04 We're one customer. There are many customers that are many uses. I'll say, I'll say this, it's very difficult to predict the, you know, the future and make predictions, especially about the future. And I, I really say that many times people have thought of the limits on the possibilities and they've been proven wrong. And the idea in the 1960s, if somebody told you, you're going to have a thing in your pocket, you know, 50 years, that's going to have more computer power than what we're using to try and get to the moon. And you're going to be able to talk to anybody on the earth, you know, you'll be able to send video and like real video. How many people would have believed that was possible? I bet not many.
1:10:29 Speaker 04 The same way, I bet that people in the 1890s could never envision that in 30 years, there'll be these manned machines in the air flying around. Right? Just so many things. I think we limit ourselves sometimes to the possibilities. So in terms of valuation, I'm not going to try and make a guess about, you know, is it a bubble or not? I do know in the 2000s, there are a lot of people who said, the internet's a fad. And there are people, and you know, it didn't quite work, work out that way.
1:10:56 Speaker 03 Glenn, you've given us so much time. This has been a great conversation. What's next for booking? What's next for travel, do you think?
1:11:03 Speaker 04 What's next is, is remembering these truisms. People will always want to travel. One of the first things people do when they go from poverty to lower middle class is take a trip. People will always want to see new places. Our job is to make it easier for everybody. How we do that is we use technology. We'll use this technology, we'll make it easier and there are more people to to enjoy travel. One of the things will be is we'll have to really think about how do we handle the issue of too much travel? How do we handle the issues of certain parts of the world being the favorite place that everybody wants to go, which suddenly makes that place not such a great
1:11:45 Speaker 04 place to go. And we're seeing that even now, we're seeing that in Venice, we're seeing that in Amsterdam, we're seeing that in Barcelona. And the question is, how will we come up with what the fair way is so that we can best decide on how we handle all the different stakeholders in travel? Because it's not just the suppliers, it's not just the travelers, and not just people like us who are helping to arrange it all. It's the people living in these neighborhoods in sustainability, what about the environment? So we have a lot of things to think about as travel continues to increase in popularity, which it will, we'll have to think about those consequences, and hopefully think long enough ahead that we can come up with the smart ways to handle it in a fair way.
1:12:27 Speaker 03 Amazing. Well, Glenn, thank you so much for being on the show. This is great.
1:12:30 Speaker 04 Well, thank you so much for having me.
1:12:36 Speaker 03 I'd like to thank Glenn for taking the time to join Decoder, and thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. If you'd like to let us know what you thought about this episode, or really anything at all, drop us a line. You can email us at [email protected] . We really do read all the emails. You can also hit me up directly on Threads, I'm at reckless1280. We also have a TikTok, for as long as there's a TikTok, check it out, it's at DecoderPod, it's a lot of fun. And boy, have some of those videos popped off lately. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Our producers are Kate Cox, Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Amanda Rose Smith. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
1:13:21 Speaker 07 Looking for a simple way to thank your clients or recognize employees for a job well done? A Starbucks Card is more than a gift. It's a pick-me-up, a break in their day, and a reminder that you appreciate them. Whether you're shopping for digital or physical cards in bulk, Starbucks Cards are the perfect gift to brighten anyone's day. Share the joy of coffee and connection when you give the gift of Starbucks. Shop Starbucks Cards in Bulk now at StarbucksCardB2B.com.
1:13:48 Speaker 08 Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes. A 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from DoorDash, and Best Buy. You'll then play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag!
1:14:06 Speaker 03 No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. Age 18+. See PlayatMcD.com for rules and PlayatMcD.com/amoe for info and playing without purchase by mail by November 2. Chance card game ends November 8. Game ends November 22, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro.
Previous AI has a climate problem — but so does all of tech Next DOJ antitrust chief is ‘overjoyed’ after Google monopoly verdict Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated