Skip to content

Spiritual but not Religious, from No Small Endeavor

The Daily Stoic | Wondery+

47m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode of No Small Endeavor, hosted by Lee C. Camp and featured as a sneak peek on The Daily Stoic, presents a conversation with author Belle Tindall Riley about her book, The Sacred Ache. The guest and host explore why people in a modern, secular, and disenchanted age continue to experience a deep sense of longing and restlessness, which Riley observed firsthand in the Healing Field at the Glastonbury Festival. They discuss how the promises of prosperity, autonomy, and technology have failed to deliver, leaving society grappling with perma-crises like loneliness, anxiety, and a meaning crisis. The discussion examines how individuals increasingly turn to mainstream spiritual practices like manifesting, tarot, and witchcraft to fill this void, and evaluates the tension between expressive individualism and the desire for external wisdom. This episode is worth listening to for its thoughtful unpacking of why human beings remain faith-filled creatures and how modern spiritual consumerism often mirrors the very individualism people are trying to escape.

  • Recognize that human restlessness and spiritual longing are designs rather than defects. 18:17
  • Be cautious of spiritual practices or worldviews that always give you what you want. 25:35
  • Examine whether your spirituality simply serves your self-absorption instead of enlarging your attention beyond yourself. 42:36
  • Maintain relationships, traditions, or practices that are allowed to lovingly resist and tell you no. 25:51

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Episode Introduction and Show Overview

    Ryan Holiday introduces the No Small Endeavor sneak peek and explains the podcast’s focus on living a good life.

  2. 0:43
    Disenchanted Age and the Iron Cage

    Lee Camp discusses Max Weber’s disenchantment thesis and the modern struggle against rationalization.

  3. 6:04
    Critique of Re-enchantment and Spiritual Consumerism

    Belle critiques the tendency to re-enchant the world through consumerist spiritual practices and warns against losing authenticity.

  4. 20:02
    Manifesting as a Spiritual Practice

    Belle outlines the mechanics of manifesting, its appeal, and the tension between personal agency and divine collaboration.

  5. 30:32
    Tarot, WitchTok, and Consumer Spirituality

    The conversation turns to tarot card reading, the rise of WitchTok, and how these practices reflect a commodified search for meaning.

  6. 46:54
    Closing Reflections and Next Episodes

    The hosts wrap up the first part of the series, summarizing key insights and previewing upcoming interviews.

Highlights

  • 6:11

    Glastonbury's Healing Fieldstory

    The guest describes her surprise at finding a massive, 24/7 marketplace of spiritual options called the Healing Field at the Glastonbury Festival, where people readily queue for tarot readings instead of attending headlining musical acts.

  • 11:02

    The Failure of the Secular Promiseinsight

    The guest argues that after running the experiment of secular modernity for long enough, society is more anxious, tired, and lonely than ever, proving that material prosperity and autonomy have not come up with the goods.

  • 13:35

    Childhood Shame and New Atheismstory

    The guest shares a vivid childhood memory from primary school where she instinctively lied about her family going to church, attributing it to the cultural air of the New Atheism movement led by books like The God Delusion.

  • 20:02

    The Mechanics of Manifestingstrategy

    The guest breaks down the practice of manifesting, explaining how it combines visualization with the law of attraction and the belief that the capital-U universe will collaborate to bring your desires to pass.

  • 33:12

    Outsourcing Therapy to Tarotinsight

    The guest highlights a trend where people, particularly women, are giving up traditional therapy and turning to tarot card readers because they no longer trust themselves to be the sole narrators of their own stories.

  • 40:43

    Consumerism Hijacking Spiritualityinsight

    The guest warns that when secularism recedes and people become spiritually open, consumerism and individualism often channel that openness, turning spirituality into just another product for sale.

Quotes

  • “The fate of our times is characterized by rationalization and intellectualization, and above all, by the disenchantment of the world.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:10
  • “I think there is a great deal in common between fundamentalist atheism and fundamentalist religion.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:18
  • “You just don't have to look very far to see, like, when we're all that we've got, we're not enough.”
    Unnamed speaker · 12:05
  • “You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and so our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you.”
    Unnamed speaker · 17:52

About this episode

Here's a sneak peek of an episode from the podcast No Small Endeavor, hosted by Lee C. Camp. Living well is a lifelong practice, and No Small Endeavor gives you the tools and perspectives to keep refining that process. Lee talks with world-class thinkers, psychologists, authors, and philosophers about what it really takes to live a good life—not in theory, but in practice. In his latest series, Lee explores the human ache that secularism can't explain, and the new spiritualities that may not be able to fill it. He travels around the world, talking to guests on both sides of the war between science and religion. Like Belle Tindall-Riley, a biblical scholar from rural Wales who grew up lying to her classmates about going to church. In this episode, Belle explains why she reads practices like manifesting, tarot, crystals, and WitchTok for the true longing underneath. She examines the limits of a spirituality that always tells you you're doing just fine. You'll come away asking questions of your own spirituality: does it ever tell me no? Hear the rest of the series at https://link.mgln.ai/ https://link.mgln.ai/dailystoicdailystoic https://link.mgln.ai/dailystoic Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

0:00
47:36

8,140 words · 6 speakers

Topics

  • The Ache
  • No Small Endeavor
  • Oxford
  • UK
  • The Sacred Ache
  • Healing Field
  • Tarot cards
  • WitchTok
  • The God Delusion
  • Glastonbury Festival

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated