Pod Insights Criminal Raynella, Part 2 Quotes “The prosecution argued that Raynella had drugged David on the morning he died, and that she had fired one shot aimed at David, but that she had missed.” Unnamed speaker · 5:23 · Share this quote IM8 0:00–0:26 Helix 0:34–1:52 Quince 15:51–18:02 Mint Mobile 26:08–27:39 ARCA Wealth 27:17–28:49 About this episode In 2009, Raynella Dossett Leath stood trial for the murder of her second husband. Meanwhile, prosecutors investigated the death of her first husband. But then, something unusual happened. “I have covered hundreds of trials, and I have never seen what occurred on the final day of Raynella's trial.”
Say hello on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, invitations to virtual events, special merch deals, and more.
We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery.
Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop.
Episode transcripts are posted on our website.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from IM8. IM8's Daily Ultimate Essentials contains 16 supplements in one drink. They sent me some to try, and I like drinking it in the morning before breakfast. Go to IM8health.com/criminal right now and use code CRIMINAL for a free welcome kit, five free travel sachets, plus 10% off your order. That's code CRIMINAL at IM8health.com/criminal. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Support for Criminal comes from Helix. If you're looking for a new mattress, consider Helix. Helix can custom build a mattress based on your sleep needs.
0:44 Speaker 00 Just take the two-minute Helix Sleep Quiz. You can try your Helix mattress for 365 nights and easily return it if you decide it's not right for you. One of our producers has a Helix mattress, and she said the quiz about sleeping habits was really helpful. It helped her find a mattress that was particularly good for someone who sleeps on their stomach. Go to helixsleep.com/criminal for up to 30% off. That's helixsleep.com/criminal for up to 30% off. Helixsleep.com/criminal. Hi, it's Phoebe, coming to you from the road. I'm out on tour right now with our brand-new live show called Don't Worry. It's an evening of stories about my own life and family.
1:29 Speaker 00 You'll hear from people like my sister and my father, who I interviewed for the show. You know, isn't it everyone's great dream to have someone sit you down and say, "Tell me about your life"?
1:40 Speaker 01 Depends on the life.
1:44 Speaker 00 We've got tour dates all over the country coming up soon. You can find them all and get your tickets at thisiscriminal.com/live.
1:56 Speaker 00 This episode is the second part of a two-part story. If you haven't heard the first part, you may want to go back and listen to that first.
2:06 Speaker 00 This episode contains descriptions of suicide. Please use discretion.
2:15 Speaker 00 On March 2, 2009, Raynella Dossit Leath arrived at Knox County Criminal Court in Knoxville, Tennessee. She was accused of murdering her second husband, barber David Leath. He'd been killed by a shot to his forehead.
2:33 Speaker 00 The courtroom was full of cameras and journalists. The trial was being covered by local and national media. Twelve jurors had been selected from a pool of about 500 people. The case was presided over by a longtime Tennessee judge, Richard Baumgartner. At jury selection, he'd asked the potential jurors if they'd heard about the case, or if they knew David and Raynella personally. Several people were sent home.
3:05 Speaker 00 The prosecution argued that Raynella Dossett Leath had fired three shots, that the second one had killed her husband, and that she had staged the scene to look like a suicide.
3:18 Speaker 00 But Raynella's defense team said David Leath had died by suicide. They said it was actually possible that David could have fired all three shots himself.
3:29 Speaker 01 There was a lot of assumptions being made.
3:32 Speaker 00 Joshua Hedrick, one of Raynella's defense attorneys, says investigators had jumped to conclusions about what a suicide should look like.
3:42 Speaker 01 People talk a lot about what's a suicide and what's not, and the reality is that there's not a correct way to do it. Here's a man in bed with a gunshot wound, and it seemed to them suspicious that there were multiple gunshots.
4:02 Speaker 00 The defense explained that David and Raynella had been seeing a doctor in the period leading up to David's death. They had talked to the doctor about David's mental state. He was sometimes forgetful, emotional, and angry, and didn't seem like himself. The doctor suspected early-onset dementia.
4:23 Speaker 01 He had accelerating problems with his memory, with his emotional state. He was having trouble with life.
4:33 Speaker 00 At trial, Raynella's youngest daughter, who'd been a senior in high school when David died, took the stand. She was upset and explained that she had been close with David, and that he hadn't been himself in the months before his death. He often wasn't getting out of bed in the morning, and she thought he seemed depressed and confused.
4:56 Speaker 00 David's daughter said she disagreed. She said he had seemed normal in the weeks leading up to his death.
5:04 Speaker 00 The medical examiner had found drugs, including painkillers and an antidepressant, in David's system. He didn't have a prescription for them.
5:15 Speaker 00 Experts who testified at trial disagreed about how much the drugs would have affected him.
5:23 Speaker 00 The prosecution argued that Raynella had drugged David on the morning he died, and that she had fired one shot aimed at David, but that she had missed.
5:34 Speaker 02 The prosecution argued that first shot startles him, and he is just barely starting to raise up when the second shot kills him.
5:46 Speaker 00 Jamie Satterfield covered Raynella's case for the Knoxville News Sentinel.
5:51 Speaker 02 And then he just collapsed, and his hand goes down onto the mattress.
5:58 Speaker 00 They argued that Raynella could have fired the third shot to get gunshot residue on David's hands.
6:07 Speaker 00 The prosecution called a firearms expert to testify about the gun. It was an old .38 caliber Colt revolver.
6:16 Speaker 00 On the stand, he began explaining how the revolver worked.
6:21 Speaker 02 Because this is a revolver, it's a .38 special, what happens, you know, we see on TV, and somebody's got the semi-automatic, and the casings go flying when you fire it. With a revolver, those casings stay in the gun.
6:36 Speaker 00 When investigators opened the gun, they saw that there were two different brands of bullets inside.
6:41 Speaker 01 Some of them were Remington, and some of them were Winchester. And you can tell the difference in the bullet.
6:50 Speaker 00 The Remington bullets were silver, and the Winchester bullets were brass-colored.
6:56 Speaker 00 Investigators said when they looked inside the gun, they could tell the order of the three shots that had been fired that morning. The last shot that had been fired was a brass-colored Winchester bullet.
7:09 Speaker 01 The bullet that was recovered from David Leath was a Remington, and the bullet that was recovered from the wall was a Remington.
7:19 Speaker 00 The third and last bullet, the Winchester bullet, had gone into the mattress.
7:26 Speaker 00 David Leath would have already been hit with one of the Remington bullets by the time the Winchester bullet had been fired. The medical examiner said he would have been killed instantly. He couldn't have fired the third shot.
7:42 Speaker 00 Raynella's defense brought an expert, who said that death spasms could have caused David Leath to pull the trigger a third time after he'd been hit.
7:51 Speaker 02 Raynella's defense really centered on this notion that this was a suicide. The secondary defense was, if you think that it's not a suicide, if you think it's a murder, well, they can't prove Raynella did it. She has an alibi.
8:11 Speaker 00 On the morning David Leath died, Raynella's daughter, who was a senior in high school, had left the house around 8:15 a.m.
8:20 Speaker 00 Raynella said she left the house not long after that to go visit David's mother in the hospital. A nurse at the hospital said she ran into her around 9 that morning.
8:32 Speaker 02 You know, the prosecution noted that the window for time of death was such that Raynella could have killed David, cleaned up the scene and herself, and still gotten out. They pulled in people to testify about the fact that she never visited David's mother in the hospital, how unusual that was, and how she made sure she was seen. So the prosecution argued that Raynella seemed to be staging an alibi.
9:09 Speaker 00 The prosecution argued that Raynella had killed David, then repositioned him and the gun to make it look like a suicide. They argued that she then cleaned herself up and threw her clothes in the washing machine.
9:25 Speaker 00 Hours later, when police arrived at the house, the dryer was running.
9:31 Speaker 00 And Jamie Satterfield says the prosecution really focused on the breakfast tray found next to David's bed.
9:38 Speaker 02 Raynella's story is that she lays this tray of food on the table next to the bed, and that's the last thing she did when she walked out. There was no blood on any of that food, that tray, and it was so close to the bed, it was almost impossible that there would not be blood spatter on it. So they really hammered that.
10:06 Speaker 00 Jamie Satterfield says the prosecution argued that Raynella had to have brought the tray of food into the bedroom after shooting David. But Raynella's defense said she wouldn't have had time to do all the things the prosecution said she had done before leaving for the hospital. The nurse, who testified to running into Raynella at 9:00 AM, also explained that the area of the hospital where she worked was a 10-minute walk from the parking lot. Raynella would have had very little time in the house alone after her daughter left for school before getting in her car.
10:48 Speaker 00 What did the prosecution think Raynella's motive was?
10:52 Speaker 02 What they tried to argue was that the marriage was not doing well, that Raynella is the type of person, that when she got tired of David and this marriage, that she decided to kill him.
11:09 Speaker 01 It's kind of hard to imagine a motive.
11:14 Speaker 00 Raynella's defense attorney, Joshua Hedrick.
11:17 Speaker 01 Raynella had a comfortable life. They were living in Raynella's house that she had inherited from her late first husband. They didn't have financial difficulties. It's hard to imagine how this benefits Raynella. If she was unhappy with him, she'd just divorce him.
11:34 Speaker 00 After closing arguments, the 12-person jury started deliberating. But the next day, they sent a note to the judge, saying they couldn't reach an agreement.
11:46 Speaker 02 It was an 11 to 1 vote to convict, but there was one holdout. And after some polling by the judge, the jury foreman said that they were hopelessly deadlocked.
12:02 Speaker 00 The jury foreman explained that they couldn't agree on whether they could convict Raynella Dossett Leith on circumstantial evidence alone. The judge declared a mistrial. The jury hadn't heard about the death of Raynella's first husband. Prosecutors were told by the judge they couldn't bring it up. And there was something else the jury didn't hear about. Something that had happened three years after her first husband, Ed Dossett, died, when Raynella got a call from a man named Steve Walker.
12:35 Speaker 02 And Steve Walker had some startling news for Raynella. What Steve Walker told Raynella was that he and his wife were in the process of being divorced, and that through that divorce action, he had learned that his wife, who had worked for Ed Dossett, had an affair with Ed, and that the child, the son, that Steve Walker had raised as his own, was actually Ed's child. And Steve said to Raynella that he just thought she ought to know.
13:19 Speaker 02 You know, Steve was processing this himself, and I think he was looking for a kindred spirit.
13:27 Speaker 00 A little later, Raynella reached out to Steve and told him she had found some papers in the barn at her farm that she thought had something to do with the boy, Ed's son. She asked Steve to come back to her house to take a look. She picked him up at the auto shop where Steve worked, and they got in her car. When they drove up to the barn, Steve, says Raynella, pointed out the hilltop on her property where Ed Dossett was buried. Steve and Raynella got to the barn and got out of the car.
14:02 Speaker 02 And they're talking, they're standing there talking about this discovery, and Raynella points over to a bucket in the corner of the barn there and says, "Those papers are in that bucket." When Steve turns and starts to walk toward that bucket, Raynella pulled out a gun.
14:27 Speaker 00 I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal. We'll be right back. To listen without ads, join Criminal+.
14:49 Speaker 03 Everyone, it's time to wake up.
14:52 Speaker 04 Five more minutes.
14:53 Speaker 03 We've been sleeping long enough, hitting snooze on the fact that we're still stuck with the old way to phone plan.
14:59 Speaker 05 It's Saturday.
15:01 Speaker 03 Yes, it's old and cuckoo, just like that phone plan you have.
15:05 Speaker 05 Okay.
15:06 Speaker 03 I know, it makes no sense. So rise and shine. It's time for a whole new way to phone plan. T-Mix from T-Mobile, where you pick what's in your plan, like streaming, travel, or gaming, and then change those picks too, because there's been a change in plans.
15:22 Speaker 05 Okay, we're awake. And T-Mix sounds great.
15:27 Speaker 03 Good, because I'm all out of alarm sounds. There's been a change in plans. Introducing T-Mix from T-Mobile. Pick what you want, change what you want, included in your plan on America's best network.
15:38 Speaker 06 Number of picks varies by plan and lines on account. Account or pick changes may impact existing device and other promotions. Best mobile network in the U.S. based on analysis by Ookla's Speed Test Intelligence data 18/20/26. Visit t-mobile.com/picks.
15:51 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from Quince. Brass candlestick holders, 14-carat gold earrings, and chef-grade cookware. These are all gifts you can buy from Quince. This holiday season, Quince makes gift giving simple. From premium clothing to high-quality goods, Quince has something for everyone. And the best part is that everything at Quince is priced 50% to 80% less than similar brands. They work directly with factories and cut out the middlemen, so you can have luxury-quality pieces without the luxury price tag. I've tried a lot of Quince pieces myself, and I like the quality of the items I've received. Quince offers lots of different kinds of products that I think would make great gifts,
16:35 Speaker 00 like a carry-on suitcase or a decorative marble bowl. Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the U.K. too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was Criminal. It's the best way to support the show. Steve Walker says he made it out of the barn after Raynella Dossett Leith fired a shot at him, and he ran across the fields. Raynella's property was big, and there were no houses nearby.
17:15 Speaker 00 He says Raynella followed him with her gun and fired at him again. Then Steve tripped over a barbed wire fence and fell. He says he closed his eyes. Raynella pulled the trigger, but the gun didn't go off. Either the weapon had jammed, or she was out of bullets.
17:34 Speaker 02 And he was able to climb up in this culvert, essentially in hide, and when she couldn't fire the gun, she gave up and apparently went back to the farm. He stayed in that culvert, afraid to move, no idea why. This woman is shooting at him, convinced that she is going to kill him, but eventually he works up the nerve to come out of the culvert, ends up, you know, running to someone's house and is able to call 911.
18:14 Speaker 00 When she was questioned by police, Raynella denied Steve's version of events.
18:19 Speaker 02 What she claimed was that as they're walking to the barn, Ed's buried out there near the barn, and she claims that Steve, and I'm going to use the words that she used, she claimed that Steve pissed on Ed's grave and left. Steve vehemently denies that.
18:45 Speaker 00 Raynella said she'd only shot into the ground to scare Steve off. But she was charged with attempted murder. Steve Walker said he never really understood why Raynella attacked him. He only had theories.
18:59 Speaker 02 Some believe, including Steve Walker, that her thought was that she would kill Steve and take that son. Now, that's not rational. You've still got a mama in the mix, but that's what Steve believes.
19:18 Speaker 00 Raynella's 11-year-old son had died the year before in a car accident.
19:24 Speaker 00 Jamie Satterfield says years later, Steve Walker was still struggling after what had happened.
19:31 Speaker 02 He was terrified. He said he still, if he hears a car, he lives out in the country too. But you know, if he hears a car or there's a vehicle he doesn't recognize, he gets nervous to this day. He believes that had that gun not jammed or whatever happened to it, he would be dead.
19:53 Speaker 00 Eventually, Raynella Dossett Leath took a plea deal. Instead of attempted murder, she pled guilty to assault.
20:00 Speaker 02 That is a felony. But then, because she had no criminal record, the judge allowed her to erase this conviction from her record after a period of time. So if you went today and were searching for those records, you're not going to find them.
20:18 Speaker 00 By the time Raynella Dossett Leath was facing her second trial for the murder of David Leath, her record was clean. But prosecutors were looking into the death of her first husband, Ed Dossett, who in 1992 had been sick with cancer. When Raynella said he'd been trampled to death by his cattle.
20:41 Speaker 02 There was very little investigation done in Ed's death. Once, the medical examiner signed off on the autopsy, saying that this was an accidental death. There really was nothing done. Ed was buried and people just moved on.
21:00 Speaker 00 But now, about 15 years later, prosecutors asked a medical examiner to take a new look at Ed Dossett's death. She looked at his toxicology report, which hadn't come back by the time his death had been declared an accident by a former medical examiner.
21:18 Speaker 02 And she concluded that the injuries from the cattle would not have killed him.
21:26 Speaker 00 Instead, it was a lethal dose of morphine. The medical examiner said the morphine levels in his system were, quote, "so extraordinarily high, it is unlikely that any human could function or continue to live." But when he died, Ed Dossett had had a morphine pump implant. It helped him manage the pain from his terminal cancer. It was possible the implant could have broken and leaked, inundating his body with morphine. Prosecutors wanted to know more.
22:02 Speaker 02 So the prosecutor sought to exhume his body.
22:08 Speaker 00 Their first request to have Ed's body exhumed was denied by the judge. Prosecutors kept trying. But by the time Raynella's second trial for the death of David Leath began, they still weren't allowed to mention her first husband. Jamie Satterfield says neither side brought new evidence.
22:29 Speaker 02 It was very much a duplicate of the first trial. But the prosecution was a little smarter. In the first trial, they'd gotten a preview of the defense's strategy. And they now knew their weaknesses and they were able to shore those up. And you know, in the first trial, we learned that the jury, although it was deadlocked, it was deadlocked 11 to 1 to convict. So the prosecution only really needed to pick up, you know, one vote.
23:00 Speaker 00 At the end of the second trial, the jury deliberated for two days. When they came back, they found Raynella Dossett Leath guilty of murdering David Leath. And what was the reaction in the courtroom when the jury in the second trial said Raynella was guilty?
23:19 Speaker 02 When the jury came back and declared Raynella guilty, she was visibly upset, as were her daughters and her supporters. So there were a lot of tears on that side of the courtroom. And you had David Leath's camp, who believed that they'd finally gotten some justice. And this case has been that way. It's very polarizing because you have folks that are in Raynella's camp and they believe in her and they'll always believe in her. And then you have folks who think that she is a black widow.
24:00 Speaker 00 Raynella Dossett Leath was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 51 years. She was 61. At this point, prosecutors had charged her with the murder of her first husband. And they had tried to have his body exhumed four times, each time their request had been denied. But now that she was in prison for life for the murder of her second husband, they decided to drop the case. What happened to her after she was found guilty?
24:36 Speaker 02 You know, she did well in prison. She did a Bible study classes for some of the ladies there at the women's prison where she was placed. And she had a little nickname in prison, Mama Ray. It didn't surprise me at all that she gets to prison and she starts running the place. That's consistent with what I know about her personality. But I will say this, her daughters, they remained loyal to their mother. And they were heartbroken. And they did everything that they could to try to raise money and try to attack this conviction.
25:20 Speaker 02 And while Raynella was in prison, something fairly extraordinary happened.
25:28 Speaker 00 Jamie Satterfield heard that something was going on with the judge, who had presided over both of Raynella's trials and had sentenced her to life in prison.
25:38 Speaker 02 It turned out that he had been buying and using drugs and that he was pretty much stoned half the time that he's on the bench, if not all the time.
25:55 Speaker 00 We'll be right back.
26:08 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from Mint Mobile. For just $15 a month, Mint Mobile offers high-speed 5G data and unlimited talk and text. And switching to Mint Mobile has never been easier. You can sign up online and you can even keep your current phone and number. We have a friend who's tried Mint Mobile. He says the sign-up process was easy and he kept both his phone and his old number when he signed up. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com/Phoebe. That's mintmobile.com/Phoebe. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at mintmobile.com/Phoebe. Limited time offer. Upfront payment of $45 for three months,
26:53 Speaker 00 $90 for six months, or $180 for 12-month plan required, 15 per month equivalent, taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies. See mintmobile.com.
27:17 Speaker 00 Support for Criminal comes from ARCA Wealth. If you don't want to manage the people who are managing your money, ARCA Wealth can help. It's a wealth management tool built for real-life complexity, like tax planning, RSUs and options, accounts that are scattered across different banks, a business sale or retirement. One advisor coordinates all of it. ARCA remembers the tax deadline. It knows when your equity vests and when your life actually changes. A new job, an inheritance, an exit. They're already on it, not waiting for you to notice first. Right now, Criminal listeners can book a complimentary financial planning call with an ARCA advisor at arcawealth.com/criminal.
28:00 Speaker 00 That's A-R-C-A wealth.com/criminal. Every ARCA Wealth advisor is a fiduciary, legally and ethically bound to act in your best interest. ARCA Wealth is fee-only, so what you pay is transparent. For important disclosures, please visit arcawealth.com. This segment is a paid endorsement for ARCA Wealth. I'm not a client and have an incentive to endorse ARCA Wealth.
28:29 Speaker 00 Richard Baumgartner, who presided over both of Raynella Dossit Leith's trials, had been a Tennessee criminal court judge for 20 years.
28:39 Speaker 01 Judge Baumgartner was, for a very long time, a very good judge.
28:42 Speaker 00 Attorney Joshua Hedrick.
28:44 Speaker 01 I tried a lot of cases in front of Judge Baumgartner, and he gave good trials, and I had a lot of respect for him.
28:51 Speaker 00 But in 2011, an investigation showed that the judge had become addicted to painkillers after a medical issue. A woman, who was part of a court program he had started to help drug users get treatment and jobs, said she'd come to him, asking for help finding work. Then he had asked her to buy opioids for him. It became a regular thing, and later, they started having sex.
29:20 Speaker 00 The investigation found that during his last two years on the bench, the judge had been buying pills and having sex in his court chambers during court recess. Some people said he sometimes appeared to be asleep during trials.
29:35 Speaker 02 And you can imagine that the minute that that headline broke—I broke that headline, by the way.
29:41 Speaker 00 Jamie Satterfield.
29:43 Speaker 02 But the minute that that news became public, Raynella's new defense team—she had a new defense team at that point—they seized on that very promptly.
29:54 Speaker 00 Did you feel like you had a good chance of being granted a new trial for Raynella after this all came out?
30:03 Speaker 01 We thought that we had an OK chance.
30:07 Speaker 00 Joshua Hedrick and his team also said they'd found a new witness, a paramedic, who said he had seen a police officer at the scene hold the revolver, while he heard another officer say the weapon had been secured.
30:22 Speaker 01 It would have been standard practice to at least render the pistol safe or at a safe distance before letting the paramedics in. And it would not have been unexpected for the responding officer to see the firearm lying on the bed and, almost as if by instinct, clear it, empty it of ammunition so that it can't hurt anybody on accident while we're working on the scene. But in doing so, could have disrupted the original order.
30:54 Speaker 00 Raynella's defense team said there was a chance the bullet casings had been moved around, so the order of them didn't prove anything.
31:05 Speaker 00 A Tennessee judge, Paul Summers, granted them a third trial. After about six years in prison, Raynella got out on bond to stand trial again.
31:17 Speaker 00 How was she feeling about this third trial? Was she optimistic?
31:22 Speaker 01 Raynella was optimistic the entire time I knew her. She had sort of a calm confidence about her. She was convinced that this will all be over soon. We just have to explain what happened.
31:36 Speaker 02 And so, a third trial was set for May of 2017.
31:42 Speaker 00 That's a lot of trials.
31:46 Speaker 02 You know what's funny is if you sat through all three trials, you could almost quote— you know, I can almost quote things that witnesses were going to say.
31:58 Speaker 00 A jury of 16 people were in the courtroom. At jury selection, Raynella's defense tried to have anyone eliminated who had followed the press coverage of the case, or heard Raynella described as a "black widow," a term they said was loaded and all over the news. Headlines said things like "Knoxville's Black Widow Granted Retrial in Death of Second Husband," "New Trial Date Set for Knox County Black Widow," and "New Witness Speaks in Black Widow Case."
32:33 Speaker 00 But the judge allowed people to sit on the jury even though they'd heard about the case.
32:40 Speaker 00 During the trial, Raynella's defense team set up David and Raynella's bed in the courtroom, including the nightstands from their bedroom and the mattress. It was covered in clear plastic, but the bloodstains were still visible.
32:56 Speaker 00 Joshua Hedrick got on the bed to demonstrate how each shot could have been fired by David Leith. The prosecution also demonstrated their version of events, with one prosecutor playing the part of David Leith and the other playing the part of Raynella, shooting him in bed.
33:17 Speaker 00 After about a week of testimony, both sides were getting ready to present closing arguments to the jury of 16 people.
33:25 Speaker 02 I have covered hundreds of trials in my 33 years, hundreds, and I've never seen what occurred on the final day of Raynella's third trial.
33:40 Speaker 02 We have the jury, they're in the box, they're ready for closing arguments, and they're ready to receive this case.
33:49 Speaker 00 And then, the defense team made what's called a motion for a judgment of acquittal. It's a chance for the defense to argue that the prosecutor's case is so weak that it shouldn't even go to the jury. The judge should just throw it out.
34:05 Speaker 01 Every lawyer makes it in every case, and you typically make that motion first when the state rests. They say the state rests, and the court asks if you have a motion, and the defense lawyer stands up and moves for a judgment of acquittal. And it gets denied, and we go on with the next phase, and it's sort of pro forma.
34:26 Speaker 00 Joshua Hedrick says defense lawyers make the motion, knowing that it'll most likely be denied. The prosecution's case is already strong enough to have gone to trial. But sometimes it's necessary to preserve certain arguments for a later appeal.
34:44 Speaker 00 But this time, after Joshua Hedrick made the motion, the judge said they'd be taking a break, and he sent everybody out of the room.
34:56 Speaker 00 A few minutes later, when the judge came back, he started going back over the facts of the case.
35:02 Speaker 01 And I remember thinking to myself, this is going on a long time. And I don't know why, just deny the motion so we can charge the jury. I don't know why we're still making findings of fact.
35:17 Speaker 01 And I looked over at a co-counsel, Rebecca Legrand, and she sort of had an unusual look on her face. And I could tell that she was thinking essentially the same thing. What's happening? What's going on?
35:32 Speaker 02 Raynella was there, seated at the defense table, and she had her head down. And the judge starts talking. And he says he believes that the prosecution has proven that this was murder, that it was not suicide. He was convinced of that. And you could see Raynella kind of drop her head a little more.
35:59 Speaker 02 But then he says what he does not believe is that the prosecution has proven that Raynella did it.
36:11 Speaker 02 And that they spent all their—he actually criticized them, said they spent all their time focused on proving it was murder and not proving that it was Raynella. And he said that he was dismissing the case and releasing the jury. And Raynella popped her head up, and she had, you know, some tears in her eyes, a big old smile on her face. Her daughters, of course, were ecstatic. Everybody in the courtroom was shocked. I was shocked. I couldn't breathe for a minute.
36:48 Speaker 01 My first thought was, is that appealable? Can they appeal that? And so, everyone around me is reacting. And I turned to Rebecca, and I said, is that appealable? And she says, I don't know. And, you know, the news was there, and everybody was there. Everybody wanted a statement. And you have a moment. When you're in trial, there's so much adrenaline, and you're running on so much adrenaline, and that floor just—the bottom just drops out of you when you're done. We went back to the office, and we weren't really sure what to do from there. We just went back to the office to find out if the state had grounds to appeal that, if there was anything else that could be done.
37:29 Speaker 00 But that was it. There was nothing more the state could do. Raynella Dossett Leith was free. There would be no more trials.
37:39 Speaker 02 A lot of people were upset at this decision. Just from a legal standpoint, there were people in the legal community that were really questioning why Judge Summers would take this extraordinary action when the case is ready for the jury. And it's really a jury call, right? He's saying it was murder.
38:06 Speaker 02 The question was, did Raynella or not? Shouldn't the jury decide that?
38:11 Speaker 00 It was later reported that, at a hearing before the trial had started, the judge, Paul Summers, had let both sides know that he knew Raynella Dossett Leith personally. He'd gone to law school with her first husband, Ed Dossett. He'd been to his funeral. He asked the prosecutors if they still felt he could be impartial. They'd said yes. Now, some people said that was a mistake.
38:40 Speaker 00 One later, a reporter asked the judge if he granted the motion to, quote, "finally end this case." The judge answered yes.
38:49 Speaker 00 How did the jury members feel about not getting to deliberate?
38:53 Speaker 02 I had jurors who called me to complain. They were upset. They didn't quite understand it. Nobody did in the beginning. But, you know, the ones that I talked to, they were ready to convict her.
39:08 Speaker 00 At the end of the trial, Raynella went back to her farm.
39:13 Speaker 01 I think that she had sort of a happy existence. I think she had exactly what she wanted. She had her family, and she had some goats and some friends around, mostly her grandchildren. Her grandchildren were most of her world.
39:31 Speaker 00 Raynella Dossett Leith died in April of 2026. She was 77.
39:38 Speaker 00 There are a lot of people who think that she did it.
39:43 Speaker 01 Well, you can't blame them. The news media certainly had her guilty from day one. In the media, she'd been portrayed, she was the Black Widow, right? And it was always the Black Widow this, the Black Widow that.
40:00 Speaker 00 Are people still talking about this case in Knox County?
40:05 Speaker 02 You know how like Beyonce, the one name Cher, right? Raynella is that way in Knox County.
40:13 Speaker 02 All you have to say is Raynella. And people immediately think Black Widow.
40:19 Speaker 02 A Black Widow who got away with it.
40:33 Speaker 00 Criminal is created by Lauren Spoor and me. Nidia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susannah Roberson, Jackie Sajiko, Lily Clark, and Lena Silson. This episode was fact-checked by Katie Sederborg. Special thanks to Jerry Price.
40:54 Speaker 00 Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti. Julianne Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. And you can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com/newsletter.
41:10 Speaker 00 We hope you'll consider supporting our work by joining our membership program, Criminal Plus. You can listen to Criminal, This is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery without any ads. Plus, you'll get bonus episodes. These are special episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spoor, talking about everything from how we make our episodes, to the crime stories that caught our attention that week, to things we've been enjoying lately. To learn more, go to patreon.com/criminal. More on Facebook at This is Criminal, and Instagram and TikTok at criminal_podcast. More also on YouTube at youtube.com/criminalpodcast.
41:48 Speaker 00 Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal.
42:20 Speaker 03 Hear that? That's the sound of busy. To a restaurant, all that shouting and banging might as well be a symphony. It means the long days and longer nights are paying off. Sure, it's noisy, but there's a worse sound. This, not busy. Busy means business, which is why Toast gives restaurants the tools and tech they need to help them perform under pressure. Sounds pretty good, right? Toast, built for busy.
Topics Criminal Knox County T-Mix Knoxville Tennessee Toast Vox Media Podcast Network .38 caliber Colt revolver .38 special Previous Raynella, Part 1 Page updated November 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated