Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores the less-discussed side of meditation, examining adverse effects that can range from insomnia and hyperarousal to psychosis. Through personal accounts from practitioners like Sue, who experienced severe dissociation from a breathwork app, and Jane, who suffered psychotic episodes during intensive Zen retreats, the program investigates who is most at risk. Researchers like Dr. Willoughby Britton and Associate Professor Nicholas Van Dam explain that overachievers and people with a history of trauma or mental health issues are particularly vulnerable. Additionally, Professor Willem Kuyckens discusses findings from the Myriad Trial, revealing that mandatory school mindfulness programs showed no overall mental health benefits and even slightly worsened outcomes for students with pre-existing issues. The discussion calls for greater transparency, better screening, and informed consent in meditation practices rather than treating mindfulness as a universal panacea.
The episode opens with the host Sana Khadar introducing the podcast and the focus on meditation’s adverse effects.
Sana and Fiona Pepper explain what constitutes meditation sickness and the prevalence of adverse experiences.
Guests share real-life accounts of distress from meditation apps and retreats, illustrating the spectrum of symptoms.
The conversation turns to the Cheetah House program that helps meditators in distress and its client demographics.
Practical advice is offered on how to spot distress during meditation and steps to take if it occurs.
The episode reviews the large-scale trial testing mindfulness programs in schools and its surprising lack of benefit.
Experts weigh the positive mental health outcomes of meditation against the potential harms and discuss informed consent.
High Rate of Adverse Effectsdata
Dr. Willoughby Britton notes that meditation-related adverse effects impact half of all meditators, with one in ten experiencing long-term impairment or distress.
Severe Dissociation From An Appstory
Sue describes a terrifying experience of ego dissolution and reality shattering while using a 17-minute breathwork app alone at home.
Demographics Seeking Supportinsight
Dr. Willoughby Britton explains that Cheetah House sees diverse demographics, including young males drawn to macho mindfulness alongside middle-aged women.
Overachievers Are Vulnerableinsight
Data from the Varieties of Contemplative Experience Study showed that 75 percent of those experiencing adverse effects had graduate degrees and were extreme rule-followers.
Bad Advice To Keep Meditatingstrategy
Experts warn against the common advice to simply keep meditating through psychological distress, noting that severe reactions require stopping and seeking help.
Professor Willem Kuyckens shares findings from a major trial across 84 schools showing no positive signal on student mental health from mandatory mindfulness classes.
Meditation As A Potent Toolinsight
Associate Professor Nicholas Van Dam argues that meditation is powerful enough to cause pronounced effects, which means it can work in either helpful or harmful ways.
“Meditation-related adverse effects occur in half of all meditators, and one in”
“10 will experience a meditation-related adverse effect that lasts more than a month or is”
“Cheetah House is a support service designed to cater specifically for meditators in distress”
“75% of them had graduate degrees and like JDs, MDs, PhDs, like, you know, were CEOs of, of major companies”
“On each of our main outcomes, there was absolutely no effect on the young people's mental health or social, emotional functioning or wellbeing, no signal whatsoever”
Meditation sickness, meditation-related adverse effects or meditators in distress – you probably haven't heard these terms, even if you do meditate. Yet research finds adverse effects occur in half of all meditators. For one in 10, it impairs their functioning or lasts more than a month. Experts say many people can benefit from meditation, but it can also come with harms. Today, the second episode of a two-part special on the research into those harms and the personal stories of those who've experienced them. You can hear part one of the series here https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/when-meditation-goes-wrong-part-one/107016730. Guests: Willoughby BrittonAssociate Professor, Brown University Medical School; Director of the Clinical and Affective Neuroscience Lab Nicholas Van DamAssociate Professor, Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences; Director of the Contemplative Studies Center at the University of Melbourne Willem KuykenProfessor of Mindfulness and Psychological Science, University of Oxford Jane ReedExperienced adverse effects from meditation and the author of First Telling SueExperienced adverse effects from meditation Credits: Presenter: Sana QadarReporter/Producer: Fiona PepperSenior Producer: James BullenProducer: Rose KerrExtra info: Defining and measuring meditation-related adverse effects in mindfulness-based programs https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8845498/The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5443484/Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of universal school-based mindfulness training compared with normal school provision in reducing risk of mental health problems and promoting well-being in adolescence: the MYRIAD cluster randomised controlled trial https://mentalhealth.bmj.com/content/25/3/99Cheetah House https://www.cheetahhouse.org/To explore more great episodes from the award-winning psychology podcast All in the Mind with host Sana Qadar, download the ABC Listen app (Australia) or search 'ABC All in the Mind podcast' wherever you get your podcasts. There you'll find more episodes on mental health, trauma, attachment theory, wellness hacks, and family relationships. You'll also hear interviews with experts like Esther Perel, Billy Garvey and Ethan Kross. All in the Mind is created for ABC's Radio National by specialist journalists and reporters at the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
4,620 words · 6 speakers
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated