Pod Insights All In The Mind The promise and perils of manifesting About this episode If you could manifest anything into your life, what would it be? A perfect partner, your dream house, winning the lottery?
Manifesting promises a limitless potential of dreams to achieve — through methods like vision boards and affirmations.
But does manifesting actually help us realise our goals? Is it harmless fun? Healthy positive thinking? Or can manifestation lead the brain down some dark alleys that you might not expect?
In this episode we mention another episode called Visualisation and values — goal setting like a winner https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/visualisation-values-goal-setting-choice-point/102525774. It's part two of our two part series on the athlete's mindset. Part one is called A winning mindset — how top athletes think https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/winning-mindset-how-top-athletes-think/102499952.
This episode was first broadcast in March 2024.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 01 Hey, Sana here. This episode is one from our archives. Considering many of us are probably looking at New Year's resolutions and setting fresh goals, we thought it was a good time to take another look at the promise and peril of manifesting.
0:24 Speaker 01 It's 2006. Australian TV producer Rhonda Byrne has just published a book called The Secret, based on our earlier film with the same name.
0:33 Speaker 02 This secret gives you everything you want.
0:35 Speaker 01 And it's about to become a global phenomenon.
0:38 Speaker 02 You can have, do or be anything.
0:41 Speaker 01 Oprah gets on board, it becomes a New York Times bestseller, and more than 35 million copies are eventually sold, making it one of the best-selling self-help books ever. So what is The Secret?
0:55 Speaker 03 The idea that basically if you put out to this higher power a desire, a wish, a feeling, a thought, that the universe, like a magnet, will hear that and then draw those things towards you in your life in this kind of real cosmic way. So that's the first thing. The second thing is that you can harness that power.
1:17 Speaker 01 The Secret isn't the first book to push this kind of idea. It's just the newest edition in the manifesting canon, but it brings the concept to a whole new generation. And now, if you fast forward to present day, social media has turbocharged all of that.
1:32 Speaker 04 Here's how to manifest something effortlessly.
1:34 Speaker 05 This technique is to manifest a text message instantly.
1:37 Speaker 06 Many times I've proven to myself that I can literally manifest money out of thin air.
1:41 Speaker 05 Believe that you can and will manifest it and surprise, it works every single time.
1:48 Speaker 01 This is All in the Mind. I'm Sana Qadar. There are more than 160 million views for manifesting content on TikTok alone. It's huge. And the enduring appeal of these kinds of ideas is understandable because life can be really hard sometimes. Why wouldn't you want to believe that you can manifest the man of your dreams, or a million dollars, or whatever else? It just seems really cool to like be able to.
2:13 Speaker 05 To control what's going to happen.
2:16 Speaker 03 It's seductive to feel like you have some kind of spiritual way of getting rich.
2:24 Speaker 01 And part of the appeal has to be the fact that some of the elements of manifesting are grounded in some evidence, like there is research to back up the power of positive thinking, or how visualizing can help you achieve your goals. But we're going to dig a bit deeper into those kernels of truth, because manifesting isn't always harmless wishful thinking.
2:45 Speaker 03 We found that manifestors were more likely to have been bankrupt.
2:49 Speaker 01 And how much more likely were they to have been bankrupt?
2:51 Speaker 03 Forty percent more likely.
2:53 Speaker 01 Wow.
2:55 Speaker 01 Today, the promise and peril of manifesting, and an alternative that's actually got some evidence behind it.
3:10 Speaker 01 The first issue with manifesting is the very term itself. It's kind of a wishy-washy, catch-all term, because it can be a byword for both goal-setting or wishful thinking.
3:21 Speaker 02 When people talk about manifesting, you know, some people mean this and other people mean that.
3:26 Speaker 05 It's almost like used as a bit of a joke of like, oh, I just need to like manifest myself this or manifest myself that.
3:32 Speaker 01 And there seems to be so many ways to do it.
3:35 Speaker 05 So a lot of people I know like to make vision boards.
3:37 Speaker 01 This is Alice, a 28-year-old from Perth who sees a lot of this content online.
3:42 Speaker 05 And I think that's one pretty cool way of manifesting, because then you've got that visual thing to focus on.
3:48 Speaker 01 And visualizing is a key element to a lot of manifesting claims. Really visualize that ideal life, those things that you want to manifest. But Alice is also skeptical of a lot of the claims out there.
4:01 Speaker 05 A lot of people like sort of tapping their face as they say mantras, or using crystals.
4:08 Speaker 01 And the other thing you'll notice, if you watch a lot of this content, is there are so many techniques for writing goals down. Here's just one example. It's called the 369 method, and it involves writing down your goal three times in the morning, six times in the afternoon, and nine times at night. So Nikola Tesla believed that the numbers 369 had a
4:27 Speaker 03 Powerful impact energetically when it comes to manifesting what you want. They're little rituals, right? It really depends on what you believe about those things, you know? If you believe that, hey, I'm gonna try these things if they, if they make me feel better, that's, that's great. But I would say though, like what, I, I think it's just about thinking, okay, so what am I gonna believe if this doesn't happen for me?
4:49 Speaker 01 This is Lucas Dixon. He's a researcher and teacher at the University of Queensland Business School, and he studies the success industry, which includes gurus and influencers and the kinds of beliefs their advice encourages.
5:01 Speaker 03 You know, why is it so specific? That's what I wanna know. Why the three, the six and the nine?
5:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, I wanna know that too.
5:06 Speaker 03 Now, if that's the case, this is what I think to myself, it's awesome. That's something you can study. You can do a study on that. You've just given me an awesome, very specific technique. Where's the research on it? When people do this, are they more likely to achieve their goals than people are not? And let's be honest, there's not the research for it.
5:23 Speaker 01 I double-checked and he's right. The three, six, nine method doesn't have any actual research behind it, just a lot of claims. And yet, search hashtag three, six, nine method on TikTok and you'll find that alone has thirty-five million views.
5:39 Speaker 03 I don't know how, how this kinda stuff just proliferates.
5:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:44 Speaker 03 I know it's been called all sorts of different things in the TikTok world now, like it was some kinda method or this thing or that thing.
5:50 Speaker 01 There's also like new variations of sort of the term like adopted for Gen Z, like hashtag lucky girl syndrome and hashtag delulu.
5:59 Speaker 03 Ah.
5:59 Speaker 01 So a bit of delusional thinking. That one's kind of winking a little bit at some of the ridiculous edges of this kind of thinking.
6:05 Speaker 03 Great, so you know more about that. I'm just an old sticker, right? But again, it's like, if you take it lightly, like I said, it's not that big a deal.
6:14 Speaker 01 But many people don't just take it lightly. For a time, Lucas took it very seriously. Before becoming an academic, he worked in the music industry for many years. And he hit a point where he found himself feeling burnt out.
6:28 Speaker 03 And I was feeling like I was drifting and I wanted a new, a new change. And I thought I wanted to make a difference in the world, help people. And I trained as a counselor and a hypnotherapist. And I guess I did get more into it in that phase when you're around other people that are also really believing in the power of the mind. And it depends on who you speak to, right? Sometimes it's like a very, almost quasi-religious thing. Sometimes it's not. Sometimes people say it's just, you know, your unconscious mind. Like if you say positive things to yourself, it'll just grow something inside of you that will just keep you on your path. And what happened was that people would come in and I would be like their last chance.
7:09 Speaker 03 You know, people with terminal cancer or chronic pain or addiction. And, you know, at the back of their minds, I could tell it was like, could, could the power of my mind cure or heal this? And so I began to realize how serious or consequential the next thing that I said to these people could be.
7:31 Speaker 01 The real turning point for Lucas was this one particular meeting he had with his training supervisor, who made a comment to a fellow trainee about their cancer returning.
7:41 Speaker 03 And the supervisor, who I knew was a very strident believer in the power of positive thinking in the mind. And just, I knew they were quite extreme in that belief. And she, the supervisor, just blurted out without a thought, "Oh, you just keep popping those things out, don't you?"
7:58 Speaker 01 As in thinking that woman gave herself cancer by not thinking positively enough?
8:03 Speaker 03 Yeah, that she was either not thinking positively enough or that she was, there must be something that's created this inside your mind. So maybe negative thoughts you don't even know about, maybe beliefs that you're holding, you know, in your body. And I just realized that this supervisor was sitting with clients every day with that kind of attitude. And I just imagined the damage that that could do. That's how I realized that this is not, that there is definitely a line here. And if you cross that line, it can be really dangerous.
8:38 Speaker 01 But how do you assess where exactly that line is? Because as I mentioned, the thing that makes manifesting tricky is that parts of it are grounded in evidence-based techniques, like affirmations, positive thinking, visualizing. But it's also true that the evidence isn't so straightforward. Take, for example, the power of positive thinking.
8:58 Speaker 03 The power of optimism and hope is well-known. There are famous examples. There are therapies built around it, like logotherapy, which was something that Viktor Frankl, who wrote Man's Search for Meaning, being in the concentration camps, I think he was in Auschwitz, and how important it was for him to make some kind of positive meaning out of his life each day. And it was obviously more complex than what I'm just saying. But basically, the idea that you can be resilient through hard times is something I think that we've established is important. Reframing situations is important.
9:36 Speaker 01 So positive thinking doesn't mean you ignore life's problems. It means you approach the bad stuff in a more positive and productive way. And there's research linking that kind of thinking to longer lifespans and better physical health, better mental health, better wellbeing overall. But when it comes to actual behaviour change, positive thinking can also backfire.
9:58 Speaker 06 You might think that if you want to change your behaviour towards fulfilling your wishes, positive thinking does the trick. Well, it does the trick in terms of that it puts you momentarily in a good mood.
10:12 Speaker 01 This is Gabrielle Otian. She's a professor of psychology at New York University, and she researches motivation and how the way that people think about the future can affect their behaviour.
10:22 Speaker 06 It also does the trick that you can mentally explore all the possibilities of the future. But when it comes to actually implementing these possibilities, then positive thinking in terms of daydreaming and fantasy... Is actually an impediment. So we find, for example, that the more positively people fantasize about success in a weight reduction program they had enrolled in, the fewer pounds they shed three months later, one year later, two years later. Or take students, the more positively they fantasized about success in an exam, the worse they did.
11:07 Speaker 01 That's so disappointing.
11:08 Speaker 06 It is so disappointing.
11:12 Speaker 01 It's also so counterintuitive. Like, why would thinking positively about the future hamper a person's ability to reach their goals? To find out, Gabrielle and her team did some experimental research, where they made some people fantasize about the future in a positive way.
11:28 Speaker 06 And in the other groups, we induced negative fantasies, or irrelevant thoughts, or factual thoughts, or no thoughts.
11:35 Speaker 01 And what she found is that people in the positive fantasy group felt they had already accomplished their goal.
11:42 Speaker 06 They were already there. And what did they do? They relaxed. And you can measure that by reduced blood pressure. Or you can just ask people, how energized do you feel with respect to implementing your fantasies? So they feel relaxed after feeling already accomplished. So what does this positive fantasy do? It relaxes people, it zaps the energy.
12:10 Speaker 01 That is the opposite of what manifestors claim.
12:13 Speaker 04 So by setting it and forgetting it, that's how you get into that energy of it is done. And your manifestation has to show up.
12:20 Speaker 01 For them, positive thoughts are positive energy that you put out there in the universe, and that's what you're going to attract back.
12:26 Speaker 03 This is where it starts to get sensitive. And I, I think it's because it really ties into people's worldviews and their, their spiritual beliefs.
12:35 Speaker 01 Lucas wanted to investigate this worldview. And he wanted to learn more about the psychology of people who believe you can really manifest an outcome just by focusing on a goal and thinking about it and writing it down, visualizing it, saying affirmations, whatever it is. That the universe will pick up on that energy and deliver the outcome you desire.
12:54 Speaker 03 People tend to talk about manifestation in different ways. But what we had to do when we were designing a way of measuring the degree to which people believe it is think about what are the things that unify people who believe in manifestation? What are the main things that are there in most people? And it tends to be these two things. It tends to be the belief in what I called cosmic collaboration. So the idea that it's not just you and your mind. It's you, your mind, and this other entity. So it's sometimes called the universe, the cosmic consciousness, God, some people might call it. Or even like in, say, if you read the book The Secret,
13:34 Speaker 03 you'll see like quantum, this idea of quantum physics that is quite out there. The idea that basically if you put out to this higher power, a desire, a wish, that the universe, like a magnet, will then draw those things towards you in your life in this kind of real cosmic way. So that's the first thing. The second thing is that you can harness that power. So it's not just the idea of doing positive affirmations or doing visualizations, but it's the belief that those things get you into a state of receiving, and then the universe rearranges things for you.
14:14 Speaker 01 Lucas and his colleagues surveyed just over a thousand people. And here's what they found out about the real world outcomes for those who believe strongly in these ideas.
14:24 Speaker 03 So on the positive side, people who believe in manifestation tend to rate themselves as more hopeful, more optimistic. They've got higher aspirations in life, to be wealthy, to be rich, to have a better family life, relationships. On the negative side, that doesn't seem to translate into objective measures of success insofar as success, say, is income. They don't tend to have higher income than anyone who doesn't believe in manifestation, don't tend to have higher education attainment or things like that. So it doesn't seem to translate into giving people an edge over others in that case.
15:04 Speaker 01 This series of studies, which were published in 2023, Lucas also wanted to know whether believing in manifesting affected a person's appetite for financial risk. And it did. Big manifestors were more likely to believe in get-rich-quick schemes and to invest in things like cryptocurrency.
15:20 Speaker 03 Which is a fairly volatile type of financial investment.
15:23 Speaker 01 But the most troubling and headline-worthy finding was that people who believed highly in the power of manifesting were more likely to have been bankrupt.
15:33 Speaker 03 We just asked people, have you been bankrupt in the past? They knew that what they were going to say was confidential. And they said, yes, currently I'm bankrupt. Yes, in the past, or no, that they haven't been. And so as people score higher on the manifestation scale, they're about 40% more likely to have been bankrupt.
15:51 Speaker 01 That's pretty huge. That feels like a really big indictment of the power of manifesting.
15:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I'm looking forward to talking about why that might be. Although we didn't look at why that might be in these set of studies, I think we've got some ideas about what that might be and what we could look at in the future.
16:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, tell me about that. Like, is it because they're more willing to take risks?
16:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, partly. So the idea that you're kind of protected or you've got this edge through manifestation, that there's no real limits to what you can achieve. So this is one of the beliefs that you see really come back in a lot of the literature on manifestation, right? That there's really no limits. It really doesn't matter if you're asking for a million dollars or you're asking for $100. It's all about how in alignment with that belief you really are.
16:40 Speaker 03 But there's a couple of other things that I think are involved here. So one is the idea of confirmation bias. And it's the idea that you're more likely to believe evidence that supports what you already believe. And you're more likely to require less evidence to confirm that belief. Whereas on the other side of things, when someone says something that sort of bumps up against what you believe, you require more evidence to sort of change your beliefs of things. Now, when it comes to manifestation, this comes out in that you're told that you really have to focus on all of the wins, not the misses, not the misses, the hits.
17:22 Speaker 03 So for example, you hear about people, like Jim Carrey. He's got this famous speech, I think he's speaking to Harvard alumni or someone like that, where he's saying, listen, I wrote a cheque to myself for $10 million. And it was sitting there for years and it said, for services rendered, it's a cheque and I just manifested that. One day, 10 years later, I got that exact cheque. And the thing is with that is we, again, yes, that might confirm what we kind of hope or believe, but we're not actually thinking about all of the people that have also written cheques. And that hasn't happened for.
18:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, right.
18:03 Speaker 03 Okay, and when you add those into the equation, then it's much more likely that you'll write a cheque and nothing will happen.
18:11 Speaker 03 You know, so that's one issue. But then another issue, I think, and it's sort of related, is positive thinking. If it's the thing that causes success and failure, then what happens when you're in debt? Now, if you believe in manifestation, you've created that. Like if you really believe, right? So it's your negative thinking, a limiting belief, a lack. So you better start to think more positively about that. Otherwise, you're just gonna keep creating more and more of that, you know? And so the problem is, now you're not focusing on the debt and what you need to do to be able to alleviate that. You're only focusing on the positives. And sure, that might mean that you take some positive actions,
18:53 Speaker 03 but sometimes you need to put your attention on things that are uncomfortable.
19:01 Speaker 01 How do you recommend people manifest effectively then? Like, how can they understand where to draw the line between positive thinking? And the, you know, benefits that can come from that and delusional thinking?
19:14 Speaker 03 I think you need to think about, like, why are we calling it manifesting? Is it just because it's a trendy term? Or like, what is it? Manifesting, the word, to me at least, means that something just comes into existence. And I don't think that's the right way, really, to think about most big goals in life. Like, I consult with, with small businesses and solo entrepreneurs sometimes. I work with them to try to marry the, the head and the heart and the idea of your head in the clouds and your feet firmly planted on the ground. It is about balancing that, right? We need to set big goals, we need to be creative, we need to find something that we're passionate about. But we also need to ground that in.
19:57 Speaker 03 So for example, if you're going ahead in your business, just thinking, wow, I love what I do. This is awesome. But what about, are you good at it? Are you competent at it? That's the, that's, that's something that in this world of the success industry, we're just told, it's just because you don't believe in yourself enough. And sometimes, when you don't feel confident, and I know this is uncomfortable, sometimes it's because you're not competent at that thing, right?
20:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that's so funny and so interesting. You know, if you're not confident, perhaps you're not competent? Because that is so not a message we hear in our culture these days anymore. It is very much, you know, try harder, think more positively, you can make it happen. If you're not confident, fool yourself into confidence, kind of thing. We don't really hear the message where maybe you should just accept that that thing isn't for you.
20:50 Speaker 03 It's either accept that it's not for you or what can you actually do about it? You can actually learn and get better, right? And maybe it will be for you in another year. I mean, that's kind of what it was for me. It's like I was really into research and understanding things. I had no skills to be able to do that until I went to university and spent eight years, you know, learning how to do it. And I feel much better for it. It's a real sense of self-esteem rather than sort of painting over with a positive affirmation.
21:16 Speaker 01 And so is an alternative, like what are some alternatives to manifesting them? Like, is goal setting a way to go?
21:23 Speaker 03 I mean, I think that's what we're, yeah, that's what people think about. I think when they think about goal setting is it's, it's putting yourself into a positive space and thinking about things. So Gabrielle Otian's probably the researcher that's done the most on something that's, I guess, as close to manifestation as you can get. And that's the idea that visualization is an important part. So thinking big about, about the future, it is an important part. People that set bigger goals, they tend to achieve bigger goals, right? But that's not enough.
21:53 Speaker 06 Manifesting, you know, gives us paradise on earth.
21:58 Speaker 01 So what is psychology professor Gabrielle Otian's alternative to manifesting? Well, it's got a slightly strange name. It's called WOOP, W O O P. But it's based on her two decades of research on motivation. And it harnesses the best of what manifesting has to offer, like the goal setting and visualizing, as Lucas just mentioned, but it also converts that to action.
22:19 Speaker 06 If we manifest, then we just say to ourselves that this will come, it will come, it will come. We fantasize about it, but that makes us passive. So WOOP stands for wish, outcome, obstacle and plan.
22:38 Speaker 01 Here's a brief overview of how it works. Step one is selecting a wish.
22:43 Speaker 06 That is dear to your heart, but at the same time, it's also feasible for you, but still a little challenging.
22:50 Speaker 01 Step two is to think about what would be the best outcome if you fulfill that wish.
22:55 Speaker 06 How would I feel? And you find that best outcome, that best feeling, and you summarize it in few words. And then you imagine that best outcome and you really vividly imagine it.
23:10 Speaker 01 Then this is where you change gears. Instead of staying in that positive imagining, you now think about what stands in your way and you plan for those obstacles.
23:18 Speaker 06 And that obstacle. Needs to be in you because what is in you, you can control, you can change. And finding this inner obstacle is the critical step
23:29 Speaker 01 Hmm.
23:30 Speaker 06 In mental control. And by finding that obstacle, you understand that you're not there yet. You haven't fulfilled yourself that wish. So that gives you the energy to overcome that obstacle. And that's the reason why it is so important to not stay alone in the future like with manifesting, but kind of link the future to the obstacle of reality.
23:58 Speaker 01 The other thing that makes Whoop different to manifesting is that you can walk away from your goal. That's not considered a failure to manifest properly or more accurately, a failure to whoop properly.
24:09 Speaker 06 It might be that you feel this obstacle is too costly for me. Or you might say, maybe it's the wrong time point. Now, for example, when you have an exam next day, you might not sort of fulfill the wish of doing two hours of exercise. Or if the obstacle is really such that you cannot overcome it, you can let go from the wish and then invest your energy in other wishes which are more promising.
24:38 Speaker 01 That's really interesting because yeah, there's a huge dose of realism in Whoop, which feels a little bit at odds with like the American idea of like, you know, you can be anything and you can do anything. You just have to set your sights to the sky and the sky is the limit. Do you find people struggle to accept something like Whoop? Because there's this, you know, dominant idea of what it means to reach for goals and set goals?
25:04 Speaker 06 Yes, we do find Whoop is much more difficult to to bring to people than positive thinking. In a way, Whoop frees you up. I mean, it it makes you really free because you can understand, ah, this is what I want and this is what I can do. And this is what is probably outside of my possibilities. And that's from you know, because then you can accept it.
25:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's making me think for people who are inclined to think the sky is the limit for their ambition, what they probably aren't considering is the sky is the limit for their disappointments as well.
25:45 Speaker 06 Exactly.
25:48 Speaker 01 Gabrielle has studied the efficacy of WHOOP and specifically its mental contrasting element in a number of scenarios.
25:55 Speaker 06 The academic domain, the personal domain, the health domain.
25:59 Speaker 01 And she's also investigated the mechanisms underlying why it works.
26:04 Speaker 06 What mental contrasting does is it triggers non-conscious processes that then influence the behavior change. So it connects the future with the obstacle of reality and the obstacle of reality with the behavior to overcome the obstacle. So when I then consciously think about the future, these processes are triggered, then make for the behavior change.
26:33 Speaker 01 So there are evidence-based methods and options out there for people who are goal-oriented and want to think big about the future. And if you're a big listener of All in the Mind, some of the concepts Gabrielle covered might sound familiar. We talked about mental contrasting in another episode titled "Visualization and Values: Goal Setting Like a Winner." And if you want to find out more, you can find that episode by Googling the name plus "All in the Mind" or scrolling back in your podcast feed.
27:02 Speaker 01 Now, if you're still not convinced that manifesting isn't necessarily the best way to go about achieving your goals, here's what Lucas has to say about how you can parse through the content you see online.
27:14 Speaker 03 When you're listening to someone talking about manifestation, you might want to think, what are they getting from this? You know, if they're selling a course or, you know, they're selling you something, perhaps they've got a vested interest in having you believe that they can show you how to do this.
27:33 Speaker 01 This is where I should mention that WHOOP is free. You don't have to pay to use it or implement it. You can learn it on your own.
27:39 Speaker 03 The other thing is that any belief system, I don't care what it is, that requires you to have faith and the idea that if you are skeptical about it, if that is seen as something that's detrimental in your group or you're just being negative, it's not. Not going to be effective to you, I would be wary of those things because I think that what any kind of tightly knit group, polarised group, extremist group has is they they shut down any dissent.
28:09 Speaker 01 Hmm.
28:10 Speaker 03 And so it's, you know, try to just notice if you're getting shut down with your critical thinking, if people are trying to stop you from thinking skeptically and reality based about things. Because I think, yeah, that can be an entryway into that extreme.
28:31 Speaker 01 That is Lucas Dixon, researcher and teacher at the Business School at the University of Queensland. And you also heard from Gabrielle Otien, professor of psychology at New York University. Thanks to producer Rose Kerr. This episode was written and presented by me, Sana Qadar. And finally, thank you for listening. I'll catch you next time.
Previous "Scarier than killer robots": why your brain isn't ready for AI Next Age of rage: the psychology behind our moral outrage Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated