Pod Insights All In The Mind Age of rage: the psychology behind our moral outrage About this episode Politics, war, abortion, gun control — why do some topics make us so outraged?
One theory is that our preoccupation with preventing harm is to blame.
So today, we examine how humans developed morality, why we differ in what we consider right and wrong, and how that drives us to moral outrage.
And after all of that, we'll find out how to have better conversations with people you disagree with (even if you're feeling outraged).
If you want to hear more about that, check out The skills supercommunicators use, which you can learn too https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/allinthemind/skills-supercommunicators-science-you-can-learn/103430306.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen. Podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:07 Speaker 01 There is just something about youth that makes you think you're invincible. Kurt Gray was a pretty typical teenager in that he thought he was invincible, especially behind the wheel of a car. So when he and some friends were running late to the movies one night, he hit the gas.
0:25 Speaker 02 So it had just rained and I had gotten my driver's licence not long ago. And it was dark, so I was rushing up the road. I wasn't paying a lot of attention because the music was blasting and we were talking about high school gossip. And I was just about to blow by the exit when a friend over the back shouted over the din, "You're gonna miss it. Turn left, turn left." And so I immediately turned left reflexively. I didn't look at my blind spot.
0:52 Speaker 01 That's too bad because in his blind spot was a brand new Mercedes Benz.
0:58 Speaker 02 I hear it, see it, obviously, you know, we start squealing and spinning and eventually we stop. There's steam coming up from the road, the orange sodium lights. And there's no one around, just the two of us cars. And I unroll my window to apologize. And the guy gets out of the car, he's looking so angry and he points to me and says, "You're fucking dead. I'm gonna kill you." You know, I freeze and then I do what seemed to make sense and I slam on the accelerator.
1:33 Speaker 01 Kurt starts driving in a blind panic. He doesn't really know where he's going and he ends up driving into a strip mall parking lot where he's cornered.
1:41 Speaker 02 He gets out of the car, menacingly walks over to us. And I locked the door at the last second and I unroll my window a little bit to apologize. And then he reaches into my window as I'm apologizing, he's trying to unlock the door. I'm slapping his hand away while apologizing. It's like a very awkward thing to do.
1:59 Speaker 01 This is terrifying and comedic now with distance.
2:03 Speaker 02 Exactly, with distance. Eventually, my friend in the backseat, she holds up a cellphone, which was still rare at the time. And she says, "If you don't stop, I'll call the cops." He stops and says, "Yeah, you call the cops and I'll tell them what you did."
2:19 Speaker 01 Now, this comment confused Kurt, and it incensed him because, yes, of course, it was wrong that Kurt had nearly smashed into the guy, that he could have killed him. But now Kurt felt like he was the victim, with this guy cornering him and threatening him.
2:36 Speaker 02 So this comment was so strange to me because to me, it was obvious that I was the victim. He was literally slapping me around, literally threatening to kill me. And yet, he says that the cops would be on his side, right? That he feels righteous. And I realized, you know, through time, through my research especially, I realized that we both felt convinced that we were the victims in that situation. And that feeling of threat of harm gave us the moral conviction that we were right.
3:07 Speaker 01 Kurt Gray is all grown up now, and he's a professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where he directs the Center for the Science of Moral Understanding. He's also, hopefully, a better driver. But the fact that both he and the Mercedes driver thought they were the bigger victims, that they were most harmed, Kurt says that explains the crux of why we get stuck in all kinds of heated arguments, on everything from abortion to, yes, road rage.
3:38 Speaker 02 It's so self-evident to us that our moral convictions are true, right? Your opinion on immigration, or abortion, or taxes. But then someone else can have exactly the opposite opinion and also think that they are absolutely true.
3:52 Speaker 01 Kurt explores all of this in his new book called Outraged: Why We Fight About Morality in Politics and How to Find Common Ground. So today, we're digging into the psychology behind our moral outrage. I'm Sana Qadar. This is All in the Mind.
4:17 Speaker 01 It certainly feels like we're more outraged than ever before, thanks to social media. But as we know, feelings aren't necessarily fact. So is this true?
4:27 Speaker 02 Scientists haven't tracked feelings of outrage, per se, but lots of other indicators do suggest that we are more outraged and more polarized than ever. As you point out, social media, a big contributor. And also, I think another driver of this is that increasingly, because we're so divided with different media streams, different media diets, we now tend to have different core assumptions about what causes harm, about what creates suffering, and who the victim is in situations. So almost every hot button issue that you can think
5:05 Speaker 02 about, illegal immigration, abortion, these are ultimately arguments about who is most vulnerable to suffering, and whose suffering are we really obligated to prevent. And so, with abortion, for instance, there's a debate about, is it the fetus that really needs protecting? Or is it pregnant women, women searching for reproductive rights? And so, we've got this really intense trade-off here, and both sides are ultimately concerned about protecting someone from harm. But conservatives make a really different kind of base assumption about fetuses than liberals, which is that a fetus is like a baby and can suffer harm.
5:50 Speaker 02 And so, it's just one example of how your assumptions about who can suffer, maybe you get it from your pastor, from the news, right? Those things change your moral convictions.
6:04 Speaker 01 But disagreements over political, sometimes moral, issues have become so heated, in the States especially, that two nationally representative surveys, conducted by researchers at Louisiana State University and the University of Maryland, found about 15% of self-identifying Republicans and 20% of self-identifying Democrats think the country would be better off if members of the opposing party just died.
6:34 Speaker 01 Which is incredible to me. And I don't think that vibe would be similar here in Australia. I think that's particularly American. But psychologically and evolutionarily, how have we gotten to this point, though?
6:47 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, it's a good question. If you think back in the in the midst of time, I mean, this question really gets at who we are as a human being. And it starts with a misconception, I think, which is that human beings are apex predators. And we have been incredible apex predators for maybe 100,000 years, maybe a little more. It turns out, though, that for the vast scope of our evolution, we were not apex predators. We were terrified primates hiding from the real predators like saber-toothed cats or giant eagles. And so we're kind of hardwired to be on guard for threats. And so, you know, fast forward a little bit, right? The way we stayed safe from these predators is we lived in groups.
7:32 Speaker 02 You know, we like banded together, built walls, stayed on the lookout for each other.
7:36 Speaker 01 But then we faced another threat, which was other people. Other people could steal from us, or they could murder us.
7:43 Speaker 02 And so we needed a tool to keep us safe from other people harming us. And if other people harmed us, we needed a way to get outraged enough to kick them out of our group, to punish them.
7:54 Speaker 01 And that tool is morality. We developed stringent ideas about right and wrong. And if someone did something wrong, something immoral, outrage would be one punishment. And Kurt says this moral sense in our minds compels us to cooperate and not harm others and to get angry when other people might harm us or vulnerable members of society.
8:17 Speaker 02 And so that's a force that kind of like keeps us together as a society. But I should add, it only applies to people within our group. And if there's another group out there, well, they could be a threat too. And so this feeling of righteousness, well, we can also use that to harm those who might attack us, those with different beliefs. And so there's this tension with morality, right? We're trying to protect ourselves from harm, but we're also willing to harm the villains we see out there in the world.
8:43 Speaker 01 Kurt says the problem is that these days, the threats we face are less obvious.
8:49 Speaker 02 So no longer are we threatened by saber-toothed cats. And no longer are we really threatened by murder from other people in our tribes or cities. I mean, there's still crime, but people are much more afraid of crime than I think is rational. There are studies showing that people who live in inner cities where there's lots of crime, they fear crime just as much as people who live in the suburbs where there's almost no crime. So something's weird in our minds, which is that no matter how safe we are, we still fear violence in the same way. And so what that means is, if there's no obvious threats, no obvious violence around us, we begin to see as threatening
9:32 Speaker 02 more benign or ambiguous threats.
9:36 Speaker 01 It's why arguments on social media, on everything from your favorite celebrity to more significant issues like abortion, can inspire such vitriol and rage. And it goes some way to explaining what could possibly lead so many Republicans and Democrats to say the world would be better off if their political opponents were dead.
9:59 Speaker 01 But if this is our evolutionary programming, then is there any hope of overcoming this pattern? Well, Kurt thinks there is. And step one in that process is to acknowledge that harm and a concern with preventing harm is what all our arguments over moral issues, over what counts as right or wrong, boil down to. That's what they're ultimately about. But you might be wondering why that is step one. And before I can explain that further, I need to actually backtrack on what I've just said. Because this idea that harm is at the core of all our moral arguments, it's actually not what all psychologists who study morality think. Allow me to detour for a moment
10:44 Speaker 01 into a somewhat academic, but also relevant to our everyday lives debate.
10:52 Speaker 02 So everyone in moral psychology, scientists, believe that harm is important for our moral convictions. We are all motivated to avoid physical and emotional suffering. Some other psychologists, namely Jonathan Haidt.
11:07 Speaker 01 You might recognize the name. That's the guy who wrote The Anxious Generation and the book The Coddling of the American Mind.
11:14 Speaker 02 Some other psychologists believe that the moral mind is carved up into other little mechanisms. He calls them foundations. And the idea there is that some people, especially conservatives, have a richer moral sense because they have more moral foundations.
11:32 Speaker 01 Meaning they care not just about harm and fairness, but also things like loyalty and authority and purity. Whereas progressives are primarily concerned with questions of harm and fairness.
11:45 Speaker 02 And so this theory, I think, is not only bad for discourse because it says conservatives have a bigger, better morality than liberals. It's also, I think, scientifically not supported. So it is the case that conservatives are more likely to care about the opinion of church leaders or to care about premarital sex as a purity. But progressives also care about purity, like hot yoga, juice cleanses, right? Those are kind of liberal purity concerns. Liberals are concerned about listening to civil rights leaders as authorities. There's really no difference in these kind of like values. And really where there's no difference
12:27 Speaker 02 is in the fact that liberals and conservatives are all ultimately grounding their moral convictions in concerns about harm. And so we've run so many studies that show that no matter what value you're talking about, no matter what moral key word you bring up, right? Industriousness, punctuality, compassion, bravery. But it turns out that how much you care about those values, this kind of core moral convictions, is connected to how much you see them as connected to harm. And so at the end of the day, if you kind of dig deep down, it's harm underneath whatever seems to be lying on top.
13:05 Speaker 01 And so, does that have any effect day to day on our lives? Or is this purely like an academic debate?
13:11 Speaker 02 I think it does have an effect. And that's because if you think that there is some moral basis that you can't understand, so the argument is, look, maybe conservatives have a sense of purity and liberals don't. And so they can never understand each other. There's some unbridgeable chasm between the morals of the left and the right. On the other hand, if it's the case that we all share a common currency in our moral minds, then we can always find a way to understand someone on the other side if we can understand the harms they see. And I think that's a powerful way of bridging these chasms that have been created from
13:55 Speaker 02 social media, from political outrage.
14:02 Speaker 01 You're listening to All in the Mind. I'm Sana Qadar. Kurt Gray is a professor of psychology at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and he's the author of Outraged: Why We Fight About Morality in Politics and How to Find Common Ground. So Kurt argues, and his research suggests, that everyone is ultimately worried about the same thing: harm. But their ideas of what causes the most harm and who is most vulnerable, that's what differs, based on personal politics, religion, culture, life experience, all kinds of things. The problem is, there are a few factors that often cloud our ability to grasp this.
14:44 Speaker 01 One is our tendency to engage in something called moral typecasting.
14:54 Speaker 02 Just as we typecast actors into enduring moral roles, so if you run into Daniel Radcliffe, you don't think Daniel Radcliffe, right? You think Harry Potter. So too do we typecast people into moral roles. We tend to see people as either villains or victims, but not both. And the Reason for this is that within a typical moral act or immoral deed like abuse, there's one person who's the abuser, one person who's the victim, and they're not the same person. And so we kind of like project this either or villain or victim mindset out onto the world when we make sense of the behavior of other people.
15:33 Speaker 01 But not all situations are quite so clear cut. In fact, many of the conflicts we face are way more complex.
15:40 Speaker 02 What typecasting means is that we strip others of their complexity and simplify them as either you're a hundred percent a victim, it's not your fault, you did nothing wrong, or a hundred percent a villain and say, you can't suffer and you're only to blame. And you see these perceptions entrench and incite conflict because your side feels like the victim, I didn't do anything wrong. You know, you started it, right? And they feel the same thing, makes it really hard to have conversations.
16:10 Speaker 01 This kind of dynamic has been observed in all kinds of intergroup conflicts, from Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda, to Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland, to Israel and Palestine.
16:23 Speaker 02 I mean, any longstanding conflict, there's always legitimate actions, big or small, that involve villainy and there's victimhood. But what you can do, and this is often called competitive victimhood, you compete to be the ultimate victim.
16:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:39 Speaker 02 Because if you're the victim, you're not to blame, right? Because typecasting means victims are not villains. So no matter what side you're on, both sides have this tendency to really simplify the world and say, well, we're the victims and you're the villains.
16:53 Speaker 01 And how do we bust through that inclination? How do we move past that quirk of our psychology?
16:59 Speaker 02 So one way to move past this is just to go a little bit off of a hundred percent, zero percent. Like maybe I'm 99% victim and you're 1% victim. But now I've kind of understood and recognized that you are at least a little bit victimized and now we can have conversations. And this isn't just in geopolitical conflict, but also conflicts between spouses, between coworkers. So many times in relationships, you think, wow, this person's doing all these terrible things. They're the villain and I'm just the victim. And they think the same thing. And the way you come together is you say, well, I still want to have a relationship with you. Now I recognize that I was kind of the villain a little bit
17:43 Speaker 02 and you're kind of the victim. And once someone feels validated, then they can better have conversations because now no one is cast as just evil and no one likes to be seen as just evil.
18:02 Speaker 01 Kurt has some more specific advice as well on how you can go about talking with someone you disagree with productively.
18:10 Speaker 02 One, you can just ask yourself, what harms do they see? Because we often don't think that the other side's trying to protect themselves or anything, right? We think they're trying to burn it all down. And people have a misconception about what best creates respect in conversations about politics. And so we asked hundreds of Americans, imagine you're having a political conversation with someone on the other side. What would make you respect them? The majority of people said, facts. I would respect when someone just gave me the facts without any editorializing. And so we said, okay, great. Here are the facts.
18:53 Speaker 02 And they say, well, not those facts. Those are not real facts. Right? Those are fake facts. So we, you know, different media ecosystems, different facts. And so not only do we not agree on the facts, but it turns out facts are not really relevant to questions of morality because those things we feel in our gut and those things are about harm. But it turns out the most powerful way to bridge divides is through storytelling. And, you know, as a journalist, I think this is probably obvious to you, but not obvious to a lot of people, right?
19:27 Speaker 01 Why we lead everything with a story. Absolutely. Yeah.
19:30 Speaker 02 Exactly. Right. The car chase story. Exactly. You know, we evolved telling stories around the campfire even now if you sit around the dining room table. You're not like, well, you know, if you think about the distribution of beliefs on this particular issue, you know, never. You think here's a story and that's what's interesting. And so when it comes to morality, we respect those who tell us stories to back up their beliefs, especially when those stories are grounded in experiences of harm.
20:01 Speaker 01 This isn't just Kurt's opinion. It's what research from his lab has found across several studies. And let me just give you one example. So in one study, they would have a researcher grab two passerby's on the university campus and raise the topic of gun control with these two people. Now, one of these people would be a random and the other would actually be a research assistant, someone who was in on the study. And whatever the random person thought about gun control, the assistant would take the opposing view.
20:35 Speaker 02 They were often pro-gun control. And then our accomplice always took the opposing opinion. And she started out real strong. She says, you believe in gun control? I can't believe that. Anyone who thinks that is un-American, right? Like those are fighting words. We wanted to get people feeling a little angry. And then she followed up with the reason she believed that people should have more guns. And she either said, look, here's a specific statistic. I forget the statistic now, but she's like, here's a statistic about how many people use guns to protect themselves every year. Or here's a story. When I was a kid, my mom used a gun to defend herself from a human invader.
21:16 Speaker 01 Right.
21:16 Speaker 02 Then we recorded those conversations. We had a team of research assistants rate them for respectfulness. And it turns out that using stories led to more respect from the other person and also led her to be seen as more rational. And that's interesting, right?
21:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:33 Speaker 02 Because we usually think of the other side as stupid, as irrational. But. If you ground your political views and experiences of harm, even if we disagree with those views, we can understand the desire to protect yourself.
21:47 Speaker 01 And yeah, you can't tell her that event didn't happen, i.e. those facts aren't real. That's her story. That's harder to kind of fight against, and that taps into your personal empathy, I suppose.
21:58 Speaker 02 Exactly, and that's a great point. So in other studies, we found that personal experiences seem more true. And I'm a scientist. I still think facts are important. They're just not what you should lead with when you're about to start a conversation with someone who disagrees with you.
22:16 Speaker 01 And if you don't have a personal story of harm, how do you engage in that conversation in a way that still, yeah, maintains that respect and empathy?
22:25 Speaker 02 Right, so not everyone has compelling stories of harm, but we all are motivated to protect ourselves. And so I think you need to let the human shine through the kind of political division. In the book, I talk about three steps you can do that are all, I'm not going to say easy, but are at least straightforward for having more respectful conversations. So the three steps are: connect, invite, validate. Connect, C, invite, I, V, validate, F, Civ. And it's the beginning of more civil conversations. So that's how you can remember. And so connecting is just talking to the person as if they're a person. You know, it shouldn't be hard, but sometimes it is. And so the way you can kind of connect with someone
23:10 Speaker 02 as a person is to ask them questions.
23:13 Speaker 01 Specifically, deep questions, which are questions that get at a person's values, beliefs, and experiences. We covered deep questions in a whole lot more detail in an episode last year on super communicators, which was super popular. And so if you want to learn more about deep questions, we'll link to that episode in our show notes.
23:33 Speaker 02 So that's the first step. Connect as human beings. Get at someone's hopes and fears and worries. Second, invite. Everyone likes being invited to a party. No one likes being demanded to attend a party. It's the same with sharing political views. If you want to know how someone's thinking, say, "I know you voted differently than me in the last election, and I'm trying to understand why. I'd really love to hear about it if you'd feel comfortable enough to share it." That's really different than, "How could you vote for that person? Tell me." And then the third step, the V and C I V is validate. So once someone musters up the courage, right? And it's hard to share your beliefs, especially when you're worried someone might argue against you.
24:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:15 Speaker 02 Is to validate them. This doesn't mean agreeing with them, doesn't mean giving up your moral convictions. It means doing something like saying, thanks. I appreciate you sharing that. And if I'm listening correctly, I think this is what you're saying. And so that's a conversation now, right?
24:31 Speaker 01 Hmm.
24:31 Speaker 02 And now they won't feel so threatened if maybe you challenge them.
24:35 Speaker 01 Hmm.
24:35 Speaker 02 And I actually have a story of having a conversation like this in a, in an Uber.
24:40 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
24:41 Speaker 02 So I'm taking Uber to the airport. As soon as we close the door, the driver asks what I do. I tell him I study morality and politics. And then he basically says, oh, boy, here we go. I have a really unique political view. I am a Christian nationalist, but not the typical Christian nationalist.
25:00 Speaker 01 Okay. What does that mean?
25:02 Speaker 02 You know, yeah, exactly. What does that mean? And that's a good question. And that's the question that I ask, right? I say, I don't know many Christian nationalists. I don't know even what the typical one thinks. And so I'd be interested to hear how your views are maybe different from that typical Christian nationalist. And so for 20 minutes, he tells me about his views and, you know, he's a little libertarian, you know? But he believes that this is how society should be structured and how the family should work. You know, we go through it all.
25:31 Speaker 01 Yep.
25:31 Speaker 02 And it's clear I'm interested. I'm trying to understand. I connect, so I invite, I validate. And then here's the interesting thing. As we're pulling into the airport, we start talking about abortion.
25:43 Speaker 01 Hmm.
25:43 Speaker 02 You know, keep it contentious. And he says, you know, I just think anyone who's pro-choice seems like they support concentration camps.
25:53 Speaker 01 Oh, my gosh.
25:53 Speaker 02 As far as I'm concerned. Yeah, right. So there's this old adage that if you have a conversation about morality long enough, especially on the internet, someone gets compared to Hitler.
26:02 Speaker 01 Right.
26:02 Speaker 02 And, you know, so it happened. And what I did then was push back.
26:08 Speaker 02 I said, look, if if we're gonna have a reasonable conversation about politics, about morality, you can't go comparing half the country to the Nazis.
26:18 Speaker 01 Right.
26:19 Speaker 02 Like, that's not how they are, and it's just not an acceptable thing to do in conversation. And he said, I completely agree. I'm sorry, I'll take a step back.
26:27 Speaker 01 Wow.
26:28 Speaker 02 I didn't mean it like that. It's just hard to express my my views and, you know, I just said that.
26:33 Speaker 01 That is fascinating.
26:34 Speaker 02 Right, for the next minute, you know, we kind of kept on talking, but the reason we could do that is because I tried to understand, it was a good faith effort to understand his views and connect. And and now we can kind of be like, well, let's have a civil conversation, right? But I couldn't have challenged him initially, right? It took this kind of this connection.
26:54 Speaker 01 That would have just evolved into defensiveness and sort of, yeah, not great stuff.
26:58 Speaker 02 Right, exactly, right, because he knew that I didn't think he was a terrible human being, right? He knew that I knew he was concerned about protecting his family in a different way than I thought would be the best way to protect your family and society, but he knew I respected him and then the conversation could go better.
27:14 Speaker 02 But I think a challenge to these conversations is, right, because we're so entrenched in our political party, progressives and conservatives, right? We feel like even trying to understand is somehow like betraying our side. Like, if you just are seeking to understand the other side, you're somehow betraying the cause. But I think it's not true. I mean, you know, I talk about this stuff a lot, and many people are suspicious, they are like, both sides is them. And I'm like, no, you can hold fast to your convictions, but if you want to effect change, if you want to advance your goals, you need to understand the people who are opposed to those goals, and you need to build coalitions. So even just from a pragmatic perspective, you need to understand them.
27:58 Speaker 02 And from a democracy perspective, democracy flourishes when there's distinct ideas, and you need to understand what could be interesting and what section of them could be true to kind of navigate the messiness of our modern life.
28:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I guess if you don't do that, you kind of are stuck in metaphorical trench warfare forever.
28:17 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly, exactly.
28:22 Speaker 01 That is Kurt Gray, professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and author of Outrage: Why We Fight About Morality in Politics and How to Find Common Ground. That's it for All in the Mind this week. Thanks to producers Rose Kerr and senior producer James Bullen, as well as sound engineer Roy Huberman. I'm Sana Qadar. Thanks for listening. I'll catch you next week.
Previous The promise and perils of manifesting Next 'My brain snapped': Harry's sudden psychosis Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated