Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Were the Princes in the Tower murdered? About this episode It's one of history's greatest mysteries - 'what happened to the Princes in the Tower?' In 1483, young Edward V and his brother Richard were awaiting Edward's coronation. But next thing we know, they vanished and their uncle Richard III has taken the throne. So what happened?
Eleanor Janega guides Anthony through this episode, with a special guest appearance by Eleanor's 'Gone Medieval' co-host Matt Lewis! 'Gone Medieval' is History Hit's medieval history podcast. Check it out if you want to find out more!
Edited by Hannah Feodorov and Anna Brant. Research by Phoebe Joyce. Produced by Freddy Chick.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 12,097 words · 4 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers, now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries, and I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Antony and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:53 Speaker 01 Two boys are on their way to bed in the Tower of London. They hold hands as they make their way up a spiral staircase. A sound makes them jump and look back together in fright, but nothing is there. Not yet. And yet, they have been stalked by growing unease in recent weeks, have felt the walls closing in, the windows darkening. These two boys, these princes of England, are in trouble. Very soon, they will have vanished into the tower's stone walls. Their clothes, their belongings, everything will disappear without a trace.
1:32 Speaker 01 This is history's greatest cold case. What happened to the two princes who disappeared in the tower? The 12-year-old Edward V and his nine-year-old brother, Richard of York, were taken to the Tower of London to await Edward's coronation after his father's death. Next thing, the princes are gone. Just disappeared. And their uncle, Richard, is suddenly crowned King Richard III in their place. But did Richard kill them? Did somebody else? Did they flee and live long lives abroad and then return to England for vengeance? For centuries, historians have fiercely debated their fate. Today, here on After Dark, we will solve the mystery of what happened to the princes in
2:16 Speaker 01 the Tower.
2:43 Speaker 01 Hello there and welcome back to After Dark. I'm Anthony.
2:46 Speaker 02 And I'm Eleanor.
2:48 Speaker 01 And today, we are going to be solving, yes, solving Eleanor, we're going to be solving one of medieval history's biggest myths or controversies or debates. And well, first of all, I'm going to let you describe what it is we're going to be solving. But this, we have people in different camps on this particular episode, people even on the History Hit team in different camps. And we're gonna, it's obviously, we're hosting this, but you're also going to hear from our brilliant colleague, Matt Lewis.
3:19 Speaker 02 That's right.
3:20 Speaker 01 Who is also your co-host on Gone Medieval. And Phoebe, who is our researcher on After Dark. Phoebe is, has also had some stakes in this. She works at the Tower of London, when she's not researching for us. So we're going to be hearing a few different opinions and viewpoints on this. And then we'll, we will make the definitive conclusion. You don't need to look any further for your, for your, your outcome on this particular mystery. Tell us what the mystery is, Eleanor.
3:44 Speaker 02 Okay. Today, we are talking about the princes in the Tower.
3:48 Speaker 01 Dun, dun, dun.
3:50 Speaker 02 And now, I, I hear you cry in your soul, Anthony.
3:56 Speaker 01 Yes, go on.
3:57 Speaker 02 Which princes in which tower?
3:59 Speaker 01 Well, now, I'm gonna say this as well. Am I being pedantic here? Am I, am I missing something? This could be very me, actually, now that I'm saying this out loud for the first time. There weren't princes in the tower, technically. Well, potentially. There was a king and a prince.
4:15 Speaker 02 That's correct.
4:16 Speaker 01 So whoever, the Victorians, right?
4:19 Speaker 02 Yeah. Yeah. Listen, it's sentimentality is what that is, you know? And fundamentally, if you call them the princes in the tower, then like the entire thing, it's just like you're agreeing that he oughtn't to have been king. That's my point.
4:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:33 Speaker 02 That's my point.
4:34 Speaker 01 Right. We're gonna, we're gonna delve into all of this, but do answer your own question because which princes, which tower?
4:40 Speaker 02 Okay, so you've already slightly answered the question because our wonderful researcher, Phoebe, works at the Tower of London. We're talking about the Tower of London.
4:47 Speaker 01 Right. Oh, yeah.
4:49 Speaker 02 You love her. I love her.
4:50 Speaker 01 I've given that away already.
4:51 Speaker 02 Wow, listen, we simply love to see her. She has been around for quite some time. By the time we approach princes getting into her, she was originally built by William the Conqueror when he arrived in London, because it turns out people didn't really like the Normans had just taken over.
5:09 Speaker 01 They bolt hold themselves in, in safety.
5:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, basically. So it's like you have to have a big castle so that you can go out and take on any rebellious townspeople as and when, and also intimidate them a little bit.
5:21 Speaker 01 Sure.
5:22 Speaker 02 And at various points in its life, it is a palace where the kings do live. But by the time we are creeping up to the end of the medieval period, it's more like a jail.
5:33 Speaker 01 Because we're right on the verge of Tudorland here, right?
5:35 Speaker 02 That is right. So we are just getting into the early modern period. A lot of other castles have been built in the meantime that are more luxurious, more comfortable. When the king is in London, he's usually staying in houses as opposed to in the tower because by this point in time, it's not so much of a worry that the angles will rise against him. You know, these sorts of things. And you use it more for high-profile captives ordinarily. It's not like a prison for like Bob who stole a sheep.
6:07 Speaker 01 He needs to leave those sheep alone. And actually, you know, they don't come much more high profile than the heir to the throne.
6:15 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:15 Speaker 01 And the spare.
6:16 Speaker 02 That's right. And that's who we're dealing with here. So we've got technically Edward V.
6:21 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:21 Speaker 02 Edward's.
6:22 Speaker 01 Not a prince if you, if you follow the line of inherited monarchy.
6:26 Speaker 02 Exactly. So he's 12, right? And he's there with his little brother and his little brother is Richard of York who is nine.
6:33 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:34 Speaker 02 And what has happened at this point is their dad, who was Edward IV, dies.
6:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:42 Speaker 02 He dies in April 1483. He is 40 years old, which is not a good innings.
6:47 Speaker 01 No, even people have this misconception, right? There's like, well, they lived to be 23. That was great for the day. That's not really how that was working.
6:55 Speaker 02 No, in average age, I hasten to remind everyone, the way that you get average age is you take all the ages. Yeah. And you put them together and then you divide by it. And at this point in time, and indeed up until we invent vaccines, infant mortality, so everybody, everybody usually dies, you get 50% of all children die before the age of two.
7:19 Speaker 01 So this is dragging.
7:20 Speaker 02 So drags it right down. So it drags it right down. So people tend to live usually into their 60s, oftentimes further.
7:28 Speaker 01 Yes. Yeah. And you will hear people in their 80s, in their 90s.
7:31 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah.
7:32 Speaker 01 It's, it's not usual to be living into your 90s in the late medieval, early modern period, but it's not unheard of at the same time.
7:38 Speaker 02 Yeah, everybody knows somebody.
7:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
7:40 Speaker 02 It's not that word. So 40, that's not a good innings.
7:42 Speaker 01 Being cut short. Yeah.
7:43 Speaker 02 Yeah. So like, that's unfortunate because this creates a power vacuum, right? Just in the way that 40 is not a good innings. 12 isn't a great age for a king.
7:55 Speaker 01 To be reigning. No.
7:56 Speaker 02 No.
7:56 Speaker 01 So we're gonna need some form then, based on my bit of knowledge about the early modern kingship. We're gonna need some form of a protectorate, I'm imagining.
8:05 Speaker 02 Yes, that's right.
8:05 Speaker 01 Okay.
8:06 Speaker 02 And so into that gap steps their beloved uncle, Richard.
8:12 Speaker 01 Who we will know probably best as Richard III.
8:16 Speaker 02 That is right.
8:17 Speaker 01 Okay. My Richards get a bit shaky sometimes, but yes.
8:20 Speaker 02 And he's like, my lovely lads, my two little nephews, what better place to keep you both?
8:28 Speaker 01 Safe.
8:28 Speaker 02 Safe.
8:29 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
8:30 Speaker 02 Before the inevitable coronation of Edward V, but in.
8:36 Speaker 02 The Tower of London.
8:38 Speaker 01 And we.
8:39 Speaker 02 Like, it's so for real.
8:41 Speaker 01 But of course, they're 12, so they're gonna be like, okay. But here's the thing, if in, I think this is really important to remember, right? Because we've spoken about this, they're not both princes. In this line of succession business, Edward, Edward V now, has automatically, the moment his father took his last breath and his heart stopped beating, even without the coronation, he has become the king. But there is a solemnization.
9:07 Speaker 02 Correct.
9:07 Speaker 01 That has to come with that through the coronation. So in order to make that official, the oils have to be placed on him in strategic places and all the kind of thing. So yes, he has passed one threshold of kingship, but the wholly, the divine element of this kingship has not yet occurred. When Richard says, we're going to the tower, boys.
9:28 Speaker 02 Exactly. And I know now that seems very silly to us, but it is very serious to them at the time. You have to have the anointing, you have to have God recognize it, or it hasn't happened.
9:40 Speaker 01 It's not real, yeah.
9:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. So we do need this coronation to take place. So originally, this coronation is meant to take place on the 4th of May.
9:49 Speaker 01 Okay.
9:49 Speaker 02 1483.
9:50 Speaker 01 When does dad die?
9:52 Speaker 02 Dad died in April, right?
9:54 Speaker 01 Oh, that's quick.
9:56 Speaker 02 Yeah.
9:56 Speaker 01 Very quick turnaround.
9:57 Speaker 02 It should be. It's ordinary to do that because you need a king.
10:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you need it to be solemnized.
10:02 Speaker 02 It's like, you just gotta like.
10:03 Speaker 01 We're going.
10:04 Speaker 02 You have to, the thing about monarchy is that it has to perpetuate itself, lest vacuums occur, right? So you need to say who is going to be in charge.
10:16 Speaker 01 Yep.
10:17 Speaker 02 England is a unique place in that the king is always getting killed and all kinds of weird things are happening. That usually doesn't happen in other countries, but England is just wild.
10:25 Speaker 01 Yeah.
10:25 Speaker 02 Like that. So, listen, this is a country that has lived through the anarchy. This is a country that has very recently gone through some civil wars. You know, there's been some light takeovers by certain queens and things like that. So we do see basically the line of succession get messed with occasionally. So it's very, very important in an English context to get this done as quickly as possible. So we're supposed to have it on the 4th of May. And then Richard is like. Listen.
10:54 Speaker 01 May, sh may.
10:56 Speaker 02 What about like, I don't know, I'm just feeling really good about like, the 22nd of June.
11:00 Speaker 01 Oh, okay.
11:01 Speaker 02 The 20th, what about the 22nd of June, guys?
11:03 Speaker 01 We're near, we're on the verge of better weather.
11:06 Speaker 02 Listen.
11:07 Speaker 01 The goal is gonna look shinier.
11:08 Speaker 02 We'll have a garden party. It's gonna be great. But then it's funny, because then like, that just doesn't happen.
11:15 Speaker 01 No, perfect. Good.
11:16 Speaker 02 It's wild that that doesn't happen. And instead, Richard III is crowned king in July.
11:24 Speaker 02 And ouais, le prince.
11:26 Speaker 01 Well, well, and such is the age old question, but now we have this, this man who was not next in line. But, but I do think that's really important, what you're saying about the, the idea that this line of inheritance that is supposed to be unfolding for the last few iterations, hasn't necessarily gone how it should have gone anyway.
11:51 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:51 Speaker 01 So in some ways, we're in usual territory, despite the fact that in the long span, it's quite unusual that this is happening.
11:58 Speaker 02 Oh, absolutely. I mean, it is unusual anywhere else in Europe. Anywhere else in Europe, everyone would be like, what are you talking about? In England, it's like, yeah, I don't know, things got really crazy for a while, and we made some different decisions. Now, usually, military force is involved.
12:15 Speaker 01 Yes.
12:15 Speaker 02 In that.
12:16 Speaker 01 Yes.
12:16 Speaker 02 But I hasten to add that, for example, with the anarchy, when we have a disputed king, essentially, he gets there, Stephen gets there by just getting crowned first.
12:27 Speaker 01 Stephen's back.
12:28 Speaker 02 Stephen's back, back again. Oh my god. Oh, cut that out. Don't let anyone know I'm making Eminem references in the Air Bar World 2026. Okay, all right.
12:37 Speaker 01 My, my seven year old nephew loves Eminem, by the way.
12:40 Speaker 02 Oh, God bless.
12:40 Speaker 01 It's really strange.
12:41 Speaker 02 Listen, the kids, you know, the, the aunts are back.
12:44 Speaker 01 I don't know how that has happened.
12:47 Speaker 02 You've seen the little rice jeans. It's happening.
12:49 Speaker 01 I have, yes.
12:50 Speaker 02 It's happening. But, so when Stephen gets to be king, it's because he got the coronation first. And ultimately, two things can be true. You're supposed to become king if you're the eldest son of a king.
13:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
13:02 Speaker 02 And you're alive. That's true.
13:03 Speaker 01 Yep.
13:03 Speaker 02 But also, whoever gets there first wins.
13:06 Speaker 01 Because God has designed that that person, even if it's not the bloodline, God has said, it's him.
13:12 Speaker 02 Yep.
13:13 Speaker 01 And it's very often a hymn, mostly a hymn.
13:15 Speaker 02 I'm gonna be so for real with you. That is correct. Yeah, like, so, you know. It's weird for anywhere else, but not so much for England, right?
13:23 Speaker 01 Right. So we have Ricky two. No, he's Ricky three.
13:27 Speaker 02 Pretty Ricky.
13:30 Speaker 01 Keep it in, it doesn't matter. We have Ricky three on, not Rocky three, Ricky three.
13:35 Speaker 02 That's right.
13:36 Speaker 01 On the throne and he has weaseled his way in there. All the Ricardians will be very sad that I used the word weaseled. I'm sorry, but you know, I'm just using it for narrative effect. So, so that's one of the people that is now in place. What has happened to the other two co-stars, our former king slash prince?
13:57 Speaker 02 Wow.
13:58 Speaker 01 End of episode. Thank you for watching.
14:00 Speaker 02 Basically, like where, where are they? Where's the kids?
14:04 Speaker 01 Where are they right now?
14:04 Speaker 02 We don't know.
14:06 Speaker 01 They should be in the tower.
14:07 Speaker 02 They should be in the tower. Last anybody heard, they were in the tower. Yeah. The last time they are seen.
14:14 Speaker 01 Okay.
14:15 Speaker 02 Is in the kind of late spring of 1480.
14:18 Speaker 01 Okay.
14:19 Speaker 02 Okay.
14:20 Speaker 01 Now, is anybody asking where they are?
14:22 Speaker 02 Yes.
14:22 Speaker 01 Oh, good.
14:23 Speaker 02 Some people are like, hey, where's like, where did, where'd those kids go?
14:27 Speaker 01 Do you remember those two?
14:28 Speaker 02 Where, where, where did those guys go?
14:30 Speaker 01 Do you know if you see Edward and your man? What's the other fellow's name?
14:33 Speaker 02 And, you know, we're still asking this question. A lot of people are still looking into this. There's a lot of ongoing investigation. Of course, my darling Matt Lewis, my co-host, has for History Hit done a really great episode that is called The Survival of the Princes in the Tower. You've got Philippa Langley, very famously heading up the Missing Princes project. You've got people around the shop looking for them.
14:56 Speaker 01 Still looking for them now, like in really active terms.
15:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. You know, people are sometimes digging up skeletons in the tower. You know, there are debates about whether or not some bones that we think might be the princes should be DNA tested. You know, it's, this is a hot topic.
15:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, still. And it's, it's a Channel 4 documentary. If, if we were able to do this one, that's going to be more cameras are going to be on that.
15:19 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
15:20 Speaker 01 You know, if, if, if that DNA testing ever happens, you can be sure there's a documentary crew that's, that's going to be there watching it.
15:26 Speaker 02 Completely.
15:27 Speaker 01 You have, it's a tragic tale. Right? It's like children have died or if you don't believe they have, maybe they haven't. But but in terms of that haunting, they need to be dead to haunt. So in that strain of thinking, they're there and they're children and it's all very tragic. And so tragedy manifests itself in haunting and, you know, it makes sense in that in that context. But do we know anything about those final? Well, they've disappeared. Sure. Okay, we can say that with confidence. But what were they doing before they disappeared? How were their lives unfolding? Were they being treated as as was Edward being treated as the heir at that point? What's the story? Do we know?
16:10 Speaker 02 So kind of. But the the trouble that we have with this entire story is there are camps.
16:16 Speaker 01 Okay.
16:17 Speaker 02 On either side that feel incredibly strongly about this. And also, a lot of what we tend to hear happens afterwards. So it'll be people who are reporting at a remove of decades. And oftentimes, also, the way people talk about this is in a particularly politicized context. So the way that most people come to know the story or anything about Richard III is usually via Shakespeare.
16:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. They'll they'll have an insight through that, right? Yeah.
16:48 Speaker 02 And Shakespeare, obviously, is writing for the Tudor court very specifically. And so he's writing plays that are going to delight the Tudors and what justifies them being on the throne. But the fact that Richard III was a very naughty man indeed, and he deserved to be overthrown.
17:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
17:02 Speaker 02 Essentially. So we do have ideas about what was going on at the time, but they mostly sort of come from.
17:11 Speaker 01 Later Tudor propaganda type sources.
17:14 Speaker 02 Exactly.
17:15 Speaker 01 Would you say, I know this is a small bit of a tangent, but I think it's probably worth exploring. Would you say that one of the reasons this particular story or history persists is because of Shakespeare's intervention? I mean, you know, it's compelling in itself, but then it has this a version of it includes stage life with this. And then it's Shakespeare. So it's a pretty big deal.
17:37 Speaker 02 I think so.
17:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:38 Speaker 02 I think that we really can't discount. Count that. And I think that also, you know, we've got him to blame for the way that people just want to kiss and make out with the tutors all the time too.
17:46 Speaker 01 Yes.
17:47 Speaker 02 Or like some of the most uniquely awful people in history. It really has to be said. And so there, there is this kind of reification and lionization of the tutors from this period that is directly linked to Shakespeare. And now like, I'm like, love Shakespeare, hate the tutors symbol S.
18:04 Speaker 01 Do you know what? I'm not even a big fan of Shakespeare anymore.
18:06 Speaker 02 Wow.
18:07 Speaker 01 I used to be, I used to be, but I'll tell you what happens to me after a while. If somebody, I'm like this in the 18th century with Horace Walpole, for instance. If somebody gets all the headlines from a particular era, I really, my brain just starts to sideline them a little bit.
18:20 Speaker 02 Okay. So you're like a Marlow guy now.
18:21 Speaker 01 Where I'm at. Yeah. Like I, just because it's like the underdog is a little bit more appealing or the lesser known.
18:27 Speaker 02 You're just trying to be cool. What about 12 night, dog?
18:30 Speaker 01 What about 12 night? If I was trying to be cool, is this what would be happening in my life?
18:34 Speaker 02 Yeah. Like, listen, yeah, all the cool kids.
18:36 Speaker 01 I've gone all the wrong ways about this.
18:38 Speaker 02 Yes. No, I love it.
18:40 Speaker 01 I have a, a, a description here from an Italian diplomat called Manici. Am I saying that right?
18:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
18:47 Speaker 01 Manici. Sure. Why not? And it is about the disappearance of the prince's in the tower. And he is saying, and these are his translated words, obviously. The two princes were shut up in the Tower of London. Again, this is aft, this is retrospectively applied. And day by day began to be seen more rarely behind the bars and windows. Is that a, is that a dubious description?
19:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm suspicious of that. Just the bars and windows thing. Anyway. And until at length, they ceased to appear altogether. Now there's probably elements of truth there, right? Already there is a suspicion that they have been done away with. The elder prince slash almost king, as I have learned from those who knew him, was afraid that he would be murdered and kept repeating his confession daily, thinking death was at hand. I mean, it's very evocative. These, that's a 12 year old boy you're talking about there.
19:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:39 Speaker 01 And you're, you're, you're pulling on heartstrings because the, a scared child is, is, is a, you know, that's.
19:46 Speaker 02 Like, we're not monsters, right?
19:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
19:48 Speaker 02 Okay. So what I would say here is. It isn't weird. First of all, it's not weird that the princes are in the tower. You usually go to the tower when you are getting ready for your coronation.
19:59 Speaker 01 Right.
19:59 Speaker 02 Right? Like, listen, this is what the Normans do. You go and you are very particularly saying that you are a part of this unbroken succession of kings, even if it's very much like it's done been broken a couple of times already. But you go to the tower first, you prep, and then you go over to Westminster Abbey. There's a big procession through London. You go to Westminster Abbey, say the magic words, bada bing bada boom, you're the king.
20:21 Speaker 01 And the magic words are bada bing bada boom.
20:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, that is.
20:23 Speaker 01 Right? From what I remember.
20:25 Speaker 02 And God goes, and then, and then you're done.
20:27 Speaker 01 He's our guy.
20:28 Speaker 02 Fantastic. But it is weird that this whole thing just becomes like very truncated. You know, it's like, well, where are the princes? They are being kept very particularly in a tower at the time, which is called the Garden Tower.
20:43 Speaker 01 That sounds nice.
20:43 Speaker 02 That looks over the White Tower. We call it the Bloody Tower now.
20:48 Speaker 01 And is it because of this that we call it the Bloody Tower?
20:50 Speaker 02 Partially. This is also where like a lot of condemned people
20:54 Speaker 01 Right.
20:54 Speaker 02 will then be sent. Not that the princes are condemned in any formal sense.
20:58 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:59 Speaker 02 And it's saying.
21:00 Speaker 01 Is it, is it true to say at this point, because we know that there was decent accommodation at the tower for a higher class, you know, I'm not saying like not overly luxurious, but it was okay.
21:11 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was fine.
21:12 Speaker 01 Is it the same at this moment in time?
21:13 Speaker 02 Listen, probably the Garden Tower is nicer than what most people in London are living in.
21:18 Speaker 01 There you go. See, yeah, yeah. It's not a palace, but we're good.
21:21 Speaker 02 It'll be fine. It's got a roof.
21:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:23 Speaker 02 There's a fireplace.
21:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:25 Speaker 02 You'll be, yeah, it's okay.
21:26 Speaker 01 You've got some food coming into you here and there. I also have the very famous, of course, image that is way, way, way later, 1878.
21:35 Speaker 02 Oh, the Victorians, they love it.
21:37 Speaker 01 The Victorians. Look at that hair. That is very Hoxton hair now, isn't it?
21:42 Speaker 02 I love their little black outfit.
21:44 Speaker 01 I know. So do I. Is that supposed to symbolize mourning? I'm sure it is.
21:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, it is. It's like, because their dad just died.
21:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
21:49 Speaker 02 Like, that's the other thing to keep in mind. Like, it's gotta be like, you know, again, this is a 12 year old, right? And, and your dad just died.
21:57 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
21:57 Speaker 02 And now.
22:00 Speaker 02 It is alleged that you're also in fear for your life.
22:03 Speaker 01 Yes.
22:04 Speaker 02 That's a lot for a kid.
22:05 Speaker 01 And he has a lovely bevel.
22:07 Speaker 02 I know.
22:07 Speaker 01 On that step and the lovely blowout hairdo.
22:13 Speaker 02 I know, I wish.
22:14 Speaker 01 And they're holding hands and they're kind of, I mean, they're where they absolutely probably never would have been, which is, these are the two boys, obviously, we're talking about. They are, they're standing on a stairway that's curving up into an unseen. Now, it's very reminiscent of what you would find in that kind of a structure, but the boys are not hanging out on that staircase.
22:31 Speaker 02 No, listen to me also, if you go and you visit the Bloody Tower now, which everyone should do, oh, I just love the Tower of London. But the staircase is really tiny, you know, like.
22:42 Speaker 01 It looks quite big there. Yeah, yeah.
22:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, like, granted, this is like tall people problems, but every time I go up those staircases, I have to like, put my hand on them so I don't bonk my noggin.
22:51 Speaker 01 How tall are you?
22:52 Speaker 02 Six one.
22:53 Speaker 01 You're taller than me. I'm six. Same height as Jesus. That's what my granddad used to say.
22:57 Speaker 02 Just, you know, listen to me. That's how we make a minkel, Kenny. All right?
23:01 Speaker 01 Actually, people are quite short, Kenny generally.
23:03 Speaker 02 But like, but in my family it's not.
23:04 Speaker 01 My family, yeah.
23:17 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
24:00 Speaker 03 Land of Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
24:54 Speaker 01 Right, so we don't know what happened to them, but people have theories. And so now we're moving into the theories part of what happened to these two little boys.
25:03 Speaker 01 The first one, it was Richard who done it.
25:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, grow up.
25:08 Speaker 01 No, you're saying no.
25:09 Speaker 02 Listen to me, this is a busy man.
25:12 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:13 Speaker 02 He's got things to do.
25:15 Speaker 01 Can I just ask, when they say that it was Richard who done it, do they literally mean Richard's own hand?
25:19 Speaker 02 Like, a lot of people say that. Yeah, like there will be like things where it's like, oh yeah, he went in there and he knifed them or he smothered them or whatever. And what are you... Kings barely like, they don't know how to cook.
25:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:34 Speaker 02 Gee, like kings don't know how to do anything for themselves. And granted, he's not a king, but he was a duke. You know, this is not an individual who is used to getting his hands dirty.
25:43 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:44 Speaker 02 And I mean, I suppose within this, you could say, well, he really wants to do away with the princes. Okay, like I can see, I can see that. And like, this is like the best way to keep it down.
25:54 Speaker 01 Yeah.
25:56 Speaker 02 Also, by the time you've done away with them, who care?
25:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, like, does it really? And actually, in some ways, the fact that it was done at the hand of the king, who is now on the throne, kind of legitimizes you being there, despite the fact that it's quite gruesome and everything. But such is the struggle for a throne, I suppose, if you were to look at it. I mean, again, that's, I'm just using that as an argument, because this is obviously a 12 year old boy that we're talking about. And even in the context of, you know, childhood is not exactly understood in the same ways as we understand childhood today. But the 12 year old boy is still seen in terms of being a child, right? That's why they would have needed a protector in order to, if that, if he had been crowned. So we have then this idea that Richard killed him. You've hinted at this
26:42 Speaker 01 already, but let's drill down into it a little bit more. Why? Why is that a useful theory to be out there?
26:49 Speaker 02 Well, it explains why Richard becomes king, which is really weird. There's, there's absolutely no reason that he should have become king, really. Now, also, we have this theory crop up, kind of almost right away. So we have a narrative written by a guy called Thomas More.
27:05 Speaker 01 Oh, I've heard of him.
27:06 Speaker 02 You may have heard of him. You may have heard of him.
27:08 Speaker 01 Now we're into the Tudors.
27:09 Speaker 02 But he writes a history of Richard III in the 16th century. So it's like from 1513 to 1518. And he's like, Richard killed those kids.
27:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
27:21 Speaker 02 And that's where it's, it's spoken aloud. So we have the Italian going, I'm really worried about these kids. They're looking really scared and we're seeing less and less of them. That certainly is true, right? But the first person to ever kind of speak it forth into the world is Thomas More.
27:37 Speaker 01 Oh, I didn't know that. Here's, he's the first person to put those, those, in England, right? To put those bits together to go, here's your complete narrative that you might have been missing some of the details, but actually I can fill in the blanks.
27:50 Speaker 02 Yeah, because the rest of it is kind of gossip.
27:53 Speaker 01 Sure.
27:53 Speaker 02 So we've heard from the Italian, it's also true that the Spanish are gossiping about this. So Diego de Vara, he is the Spanish ambassador to the English crown and he writes back in 1486 and he's like, yeah, Richard killed those kids.
28:08 Speaker 01 Okay.
28:08 Speaker 02 Right? Like, so people are gossiping.
28:11 Speaker 01 And 1486 is important, right? Because by, this is me delving back into my mind a little bit now. 1485 is the start of the Tudors on the throne, am I right? So, so it's still starting to link this idea of that murder by Richard to the Tudors for the Tudors benefit. It's still within that timeframe, even though it's quite quick after their disappearance and after Richard comes to the throne. It's still, i- i- if we're using that as a, as a timeframe, we're now into the Tudors.
28:38 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. And listen, this is when it gets all twisted. Because you've got Shakespeare, we've already talked about it. During this, like much is made of the fact that Richard III, according to them, is a hunchback.
28:48 Speaker 01 Yes.
28:48 Speaker 02 We do know that he had a spinal problem.
28:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
28:50 Speaker 02 When we found his body, that, that, that checks out, but it's like, not all of that. And you got to understand that for medieval and early modern people, you bring up things like this in order to discredit people, to say that they're evil. There's this idea that beauty means that one is aligned with God.
29:08 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
29:09 Speaker 02 Right? So like, you know, anyone who is like beautiful, it's because God just loves them.
29:12 Speaker 01 It's a perfection thing.
29:13 Speaker 02 Exactly.
29:14 Speaker 01 I mean, we still have it today in some ways. We don't link it to God so much, but
29:17 Speaker 02 Yeah.
29:18 Speaker 01 it does equal.
29:18 Speaker 02 Virtue.
29:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
29:20 Speaker 02 Right? So there's this idea that like, he is uniquely unvirtuous by dint of having a spinal problem. And because that is socially how things work at the time, that's kind of believable.
29:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. It feeds into their belief system. And I, you've pointed this out a couple of times when we've been lingering in the medieval era while you've been in, Eleanor, and I really love this, about how easy it is for us to dismiss those things as, well, that's clearly bullshit. Or that, that, God, how horrendous is that? And this doesn't, this, this goes against everything we know and our values. But in terms of their value system. We cannot underestimate how much sense that would have made for them. And I think that's, that's important for us to bear in mind.
30:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, it is really one of those things where it's difficult that, you know, we can't see air because it surrounds us, right? It's very difficult to understand that you're within a culture. When you're within it, you think that's just how things are.
30:14 Speaker 01 Yes.
30:14 Speaker 02 Right?
30:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, we're not questioning this at this particular moment.
30:17 Speaker 02 Exactly.
30:18 Speaker 01 I have, not only does he say that Richard is responsible, Thomas More I'm talking about here, not only does he say that Richard is responsible, he actually gives a description of the murder. So where he's gotten this from now, God, we have names. I'm just saying them. Okay, I'll read it out and you can tell us how much to ignore.
30:33 Speaker 02 Okay.
30:35 Speaker 01 Miles Forrest and John Dighton?
30:38 Speaker 02 I'm assuming.
30:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, sure. D I G H T O N.
30:42 Speaker 02 Listen, don't ask me how to pronounce English names. I have no idea.
30:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm Irish. We all have excuses. "About midnight, the silly children, oh, the silly children lying in their beds came into the prince's chamber and suddenly bundled them up among the bedclothes, berapped and entangled them, pinning them down by force into the feather bed and pressing pillows hard onto their mouths, that within a while, smooded and stifled," I presume that's some kind of relation to smothered, right? Yeah. "their breath failing, they gave up to God their innocent souls into the joys of heaven, leaving to the tormentors their bodies dead in the bed." Hmm. Drama.
31:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, very dramatic.
31:28 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:28 Speaker 02 Very dramatic and also like somewhat believable. So within this, we've got like on Richard's orders, right? And also it's been alleged, the reason we have kind of like names, right?
31:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:41 Speaker 02 That like some people eventually confess to killing this. So interesting point here, right? Like we've got these named names in Thomas More.
31:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm surprised to see this.
31:53 Speaker 02 We got this Miles Forrest, we got this John Dighton, but we've got another guy, completely different guy, Sir James Tyrrell, and he's like, yo. I killed a couple. Some princes may have been murdered.
32:04 Speaker 01 By, under his instruction?
32:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, basically. Yeah. So that-
32:10 Speaker 01 When is that? Do we know when that confession happens? Is it during the Tudors again?
32:14 Speaker 02 Bingo. Yeah. So it's like, again, this is just sort of like, it's all shaping up the way the Tudors need it to shape up. You know, and like, quite why one would confess, like perhaps under some duress.
32:29 Speaker 01 Hmm. Hmm. Yes, yes. Or to just gain favor, to align themselves more closely with Henry VII, like all of the above. But it's there. We have a, we do actually have a confession then.
32:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, we do. And I think that it is interesting and worth considering because there is one.
32:51 Speaker 01 We can never know necessarily.
32:52 Speaker 02 We don't know how exactly or why, you know, like there are reasons that people do things. Could he just be literally in terror for his immortal soul? Yeah.
33:02 Speaker 01 Yes.
33:03 Speaker 02 Hundred percent.
33:03 Speaker 01 It's just as legit as anything else, right?
33:05 Speaker 02 And like literally, the way that you're supposed to deal with things, if you've murdered someone, one of the big things that priests will say to you, if you want like any chance of absolution, is that you have to confess. You have to like confess and take on whatever it is you're going to have to face, right?
33:22 Speaker 01 And is it him that names Miles Forrest and John Dighton?
33:25 Speaker 02 This is an interesting one because yeah, he's the one who points the finger. So this is the exact opposite of who will rid me of this meddling priest, right? This is like, hey, Miles and John, what's happening, guys? Can I get you to do some light regicide?
33:44 Speaker 02 So yeah, like he's naming names. This is how we get these.
33:47 Speaker 01 Okay. I mean, it's something in a, in a, in a piece of history that we feel like we have nothing. It's something at the very least. And as you say, it's worth kind of considering. I'm gonna, I'm gonna move on to the next theory, theory two. And that is apparently that somebody else killed them. Who? And might that somebody else be Eleanor? And why?
34:07 Speaker 02 Okay. So one of the big names that we get in this is Margaret Beaufort. Okay. Big one, big one. So she's Henry VII's mom.
34:17 Speaker 01 She is.
34:17 Speaker 02 And the idea here is that maybe she wanted people to not like Richard.
34:24 Speaker 01 Yes, well, yeah.
34:26 Speaker 02 Because like
34:27 Speaker 01 It benefits the Tudors.
34:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. It's like she's trying to make this claim for like this obscure branch of the family, like from Wales.
34:35 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yes.
34:35 Speaker 02 Please calm down, you know, like, and she's trying to be like, oh, I think.
34:40 Speaker 01 This is her exact voice.
34:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. That's what she sounded like.
34:45 Speaker 02 So like, so basically, the idea here is that somebody else has done it to make Richard III look bad.
34:52 Speaker 01 Right.
34:54 Speaker 02 So that everyone will go, damn, bro, you sure did kill your nephews.
34:58 Speaker 01 Oh, okay.
34:59 Speaker 02 Right. And so like, now, here's the thing about it. We don't have any evidence from the time.
35:05 Speaker 01 For this.
35:06 Speaker 02 For this. No, this is just like a vibe. This is a vibe. And it's partially a vibe based off of Philippa Gregory's fiction.
35:15 Speaker 01 Right. So this is, so then that that must mean it's relatively recently taken on real legs. Then I'm sure there was probably snippets of it around because potentially those rumors informed Philippa when she was researching and writing that piece of fiction. But now it's taken a bit more mainstream, maybe, or.
35:31 Speaker 02 Yeah. Listen, I love it. It's quite modern. It's like a women in men's fields.
35:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
35:37 Speaker 02 Like women can murder princes, too.
35:39 Speaker 01 We call it the girl bossification of history.
35:41 Speaker 02 That's right. That's right. Yeah, exactly. So, you know, like this, we, this is a very new theory.
35:47 Speaker 01 Okay.
35:48 Speaker 02 It's kind of fun.
35:49 Speaker 01 Okay, I'm gonna come out and say I don't buy it.
35:52 Speaker 02 I know.
35:53 Speaker 01 That first one, I'm a bit like, okay, there's stuff there, like that, that there's either a murder committed on, on Richard's orders, not by him, not at his hand. But there's something in that. Okay, so we have Margaret. I'm not buying that. So we can conclusively rule her out.
36:09 Speaker 02 Okay, so exactly. And how do you feel about the Duke of Buckingham?
36:13 Speaker 01 I am only very familiar with the 17th century and onward Duke of Buckingham.
36:18 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. Well, okay, so this one in particular is Henry Stafford. Okay, again, he's, yep, got some relations to the throne, pretty distant. He had been aligned with Richard, okay. But then he does like a light coup against him in October 1483. And he decides that he's going over to Henry VII's claim to the throne instead, right? So the girls are fighting.
36:46 Speaker 01 Hmm, as they always are at this period of time.
36:49 Speaker 02 So the question is, did he?
36:54 Speaker 02 Turn on Richard.
36:57 Speaker 01 To frame him.
36:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, like, could he have killed the princes for Richard?
37:01 Speaker 01 Oh, for him.
37:02 Speaker 02 And then be like, oh, yeah, like, actually, it was like him, right? Like, maybe he was, maybe he was trying to do a metalsome priest.
37:12 Speaker 02 That's what we're calling it here.
37:14 Speaker 01 I, um, is it what, how, did you, did you confess?
37:19 Speaker 02 No, I mean, well, I mean, the thing is, like, he gets killed in November fourteen eighty-three because of the whole coup thing.
37:27 Speaker 01 Buckingham does?
37:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
37:29 Speaker 01 Unfortunately, so, okay, so he's not, he doesn't even.
37:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, like, so, I mean, so it's kind of like a nice one to pin it on because it's like, well, he did anyway.
37:37 Speaker 01 That's exactly where my suspicion is coming from.
37:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's like, and they're like, oh, yeah, like, woo, I bet that he did it.
37:42 Speaker 01 Okay.
37:43 Speaker 02 Because then it's like, well, you can't even be mad at me.
37:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
37:45 Speaker 02 Because, like, I already killed that guy, right?
37:47 Speaker 01 Can't question that. You can't look into, okay.
37:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, and like, he is also kind of like a very distant relative of Margaret Burford. So like, maybe there's like a whole, maybe it's a whole thing.
37:57 Speaker 01 Okay.
37:58 Speaker 02 Could be.
37:59 Speaker 01 Links into it, it did, you know, I'm, again, I, I think it's a little, I'm gonna, no, we can rule that out conclusively, put one of those stamp pictures over this and say, this credited not happening.
38:13 Speaker 02 Like a name, name, names, someone else prob, prob's not, okay.
38:17 Speaker 01 Okay, now we're on to theory number three, and this is, this is where our good friend Matt Lewis comes in. We're gonna hear from Matt in just a second. It'll like you're right back at Gone Medieval. But this theory is the no one did it theory, and that they weren't murdered at all.
38:35 Speaker 03 Hi, Eleanor. I hope you're enjoying a moment away from the Gone Medieval dungeon. I can see you've got the devastatingly handsome, incredibly witty, and incalculably wise Lord Antony there with you. I've almost finished my purchase of a hundred copies of Queer Georgians. Just waiting for Antony's verdict on this question, really. Can I sum up my position on the princes in the tower in a couple of minutes? No, I cannot, but here goes. I think both survived Richard III's reign and challenged Henry VII for his crown. He cast them as Lambert Sinell and Perkin Warbeck, and we've fallen for his lies ever since. There's plenty of evidence to at least suggest their continued existence beyond 1485. There's no actual evidence of deaths, at least from 1483 to 1485.
39:20 Speaker 03 There's a bit of hearsay and some gossip, but that's not admissible evidence, as anyone who starred brilliantly in a crime drama will tell you. If Richard was going to kill them, he had to tell everyone they were dead to prevent them from being a threat to his throne. Otherwise, he killed them for no gain at all. In the 1490s, crowned heads of Europe recognised the younger of the princes in the tower as the rightful king of England. We more often call him Perkin Warbeck, but the point here is that I don't believe kings would say you can pass off a common boy as a king. It would tarnish their own sacred majesty and open the door for someone to do exactly the same thing to them. No gain would be worth that risk.
40:04 Speaker 03 Much of our image of them is affected by romantic Victorian portraits of them, looking off in different directions, wondering when the murderer is due. "Is he late yet, Edward?", asks young Richard. Even the dog gets in on the act for crying out loud. There's plenty more to think about, but my time is just about up. Antony, take good care of the Queen of Gone Medieval. I have every faith that you'll reach the correct decision. Now, do I hit buy on these books or not?
40:35 Speaker 01 Lightbulb blackmail. That is the most compelling argument.
40:40 Speaker 01 Listen. The amount of references he got in there, he must have been on my Wikipedia page. He got crime dramas, queer Georgians, not to mention personal flattery. My man can research. I fall for it, and that's every single time. That's my boy. I will say this, there was one particular point which he said that I went, "Oh, that's interesting. That deserves a little bit of a discussion between you and I here." It's kind of, we're gonna have to pick this up with Matt as well, just for balance, to get Matt in to talk about this. The idea that if Richard had been involved, and even if it wasn't out of his own hands, but had been involved in the disposal of the true heir...
41:22 Speaker 01 That actually might benefit him to let people know that he was dead. Is how do you think that stacks up?
41:30 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, I think that that is an interesting point, but fundamentally, he also just doesn't ever offer an explanation. He's just like, damn, that's crazy. Anyway, I'm the king now. Like, there's never any discussion about like where the princes are, right? So
41:45 Speaker 01 Does he ever say anything after?
41:47 Speaker 02 He's just like, wow, that's crazy. Where'd those guys go?
41:50 Speaker 01 To know, I used to know.
41:52 Speaker 02 Well, I guess if no one's around, if no one wants to be a king, I guess I'll be the king, I guess.
42:00 Speaker 01 One of the things I found really compelling, so I'm gonna have to give it the same weight in this. In the earlier thing is we suddenly got names. We had the, the, the people who potentially killed the princes in the tower in theory one. It's a lot of Ts. Now we have more names that Matt mentioned there. We have Lambert Simnel and Perkin Warbeck. So, so these are people we can trace in the archive.
42:23 Speaker 02 Yep.
42:23 Speaker 01 Why, why are they not? Or, or, well, why in your mind are they not the princes in the tower?
42:31 Speaker 02 Well, listen, Perkin Warbeck, he's like, hey, what's up? It's your boy, Richard of York.
42:36 Speaker 01 That's right. So he's pretending to be the younger fellow.
42:38 Speaker 02 Yeah. And he's like, hello, it's me. Um, it, thanks very much. Like,
42:42 Speaker 01 Do they turn up together or separately?
42:43 Speaker 02 No, separately, separately. Um, and they, so they come to, they come back to England through different routes. Sometimes through Ireland, sometimes over from the Frenchlands. And he comes in and he claims that he is Richard of York, which I think is an interesting one. I think it's interesting that he's
42:58 Speaker 01 The younger one.
42:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, that he's the younger one and not.
43:01 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:01 Speaker 02 So that's quite interesting. Then we also have Lambert Simnel, um, and he is specifically connected to an uprising in 1487. He doesn't say he's Edward the fifth.
43:11 Speaker 01 Okay.
43:12 Speaker 02 He's, he's not coming here and saying, hey, what, it's your boy, it's Edward the fifth. I'm here to become the king. I'm the king.
43:19 Speaker 01 So what's he doing then?
43:20 Speaker 02 What, what, listen, who doesn't enjoy a light uprising?
43:23 Speaker 01 So it is, it is some form of a coup uprising type situation, well, an attempt at, at that. But, but he's not. So who says he's Edward the fifth then?
43:33 Speaker 02 Matt.
43:35 Speaker 02 Which, I mean, that's compelling. I'm compelled, right?
43:37 Speaker 01 But at the time, was anyone saying it?
43:39 Speaker 02 Eh, no.
43:40 Speaker 01 Oh, what?
43:41 Speaker 02 Yeah. So it's like, this is kind of like something that we're coming up with now.
43:44 Speaker 01 Oh.
43:44 Speaker 02 And so some historians now argue that he wouldn't have had the backing that he had were he not.
43:51 Speaker 01 Didn't have that.
43:51 Speaker 02 Exactly.
43:52 Speaker 01 But we don't have somebody at the time saying, your man there that came in, that's actually Edward. So he's not saying it himself. Nobody at the time is saying it. This is something that historians, and I can see why, I can see what you're saying.
44:03 Speaker 02 Because it's a fairly successful uprising.
44:05 Speaker 01 And, yeah, and he has the support. And who is this person? It is a nobody. But what's also interesting is that it's happening in 1487. So it's not a direct challenge to Richard at all.
44:20 Speaker 02 No, it's a, this is a challenge against the Tudors. So, yeah, I think that there is this big differentiation here between Perk and Warbeck, who's like, tis I, Richard.
44:29 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:30 Speaker 02 Right? And Lambert Simnel, where now we're thinking maybe there might have been something behind it just because he was able to generate a certain amount of action. But also fundamentally, people don't like them Tudors.
44:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:43 Speaker 02 So, you know, it's kind of like fun to poke at them.
44:45 Speaker 01 I still think, though, no, well, yeah, I still think that if Lambert Simnel, the second one, had been Edward, that we would have something contemporary go, even if it was in a way of explain, like written down to say, of course, yes, he's calling himself Lambert Simnel, but we all know in Gloucestershire that this is the actual Edward the Fifth or whatever. I mean, it's odd. It's odd that there's this random man showing up being like, uprising, let's go. Yeah, weird, but it doesn't necessarily spell the return of a missing king to me.
45:23 Speaker 02 And like, also, let us be so for real. Of course, like, there's some random uprisings. Who the hell is Henry VII? Seems like you could just have an uprising.
45:32 Speaker 01 We've had a whole generation of random uprisings.
45:33 Speaker 02 Yeah.
45:34 Speaker 01 In this, prior to the 1480s.
45:36 Speaker 02 Like, why not, why not, like, one for the people?
45:38 Speaker 01 It's just another one.
45:39 Speaker 02 I'm like, oh, so you think that regular peasants can't have an uprising? Come on. I love peasant uprisings.
45:59 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt, and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
46:54 Speaker 01 Isn't there something as well about the prince's mother sending his sisters to Richard?
47:03 Speaker 02 Yeah, and so this is like a good question. It's like, why would she do that if she thought he'd killed her sons?
47:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is what, yeah, yeah, yeah. And this is, so this is, feeds into the idea that they must have survived because she would never have sent. But I guess it's true, two things can be true at the same time.
47:21 Speaker 02 Well, it's like, listen, the girls aren't gonna, like, let's be so for real. We are here in the 15th century, girls can't inherit the throne.
47:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, so worse, and actually what she's doing potentially is ensuring their safety by putting them into the centre of power.
47:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, everybody look at them. It's like, also, the worst has already happened, right? Like, here's my daughters, they're over there. There isn't really the same threat to their lives. This isn't, you know, three monarchs later when we have Mary, right? You know, this is, you don't really let women inherit the throne of England yet, yet.
47:56 Speaker 01 So the danger's just not the same.
47:57 Speaker 02 It's just not the same. And is it weird? Yeah, but court's weird.
48:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, of course.
48:03 Speaker 02 Right, like, yeah, it's like, I mean, the, the whole thing is a nest of vipers one way or another. The best that you can say about any king is that they're dead, right? Like, these are not nice people.
48:12 Speaker 01 It is psychotic.
48:12 Speaker 02 Yeah, it is. It's really dangerous.
48:14 Speaker 01 There's a psychosis in, in the idea of a court.
48:16 Speaker 02 The most dangerous place that you can ever be is at court.
48:19 Speaker 01 Yes, absolutely.
48:20 Speaker 02 So, you know.
48:21 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so it would make sense, even if she did think or know that, that, again, that's actually now that, now that we're having this conversation, it's a very modern take to go, say she even did suspect that Richard had, had some way played a part in killing her boys. It wouldn't be that weird for her to go, well, let's make sure that doesn't happen to the rest of the surviving part of the family and that we still have a place in this new reign. And so, girls, off you go. You're gonna, you're going to be our family representatives there now. And it also then adds legitimacy to Richard and it's, it shows that there's this, this peacefulness that is between the families, et cetera, et cetera.
48:58 Speaker 02 Exactly. And more to the point, like with this also, it's saying, I'm not a threat.
49:04 Speaker 01 Yeah.
49:04 Speaker 02 Like, I'm not gonna blow your spot up. I'm not, I'm not doing anything. Just please be nice to the girls. Can you get them some advantageous marriages?
49:10 Speaker 01 Yes.
49:11 Speaker 02 Like, no, no threats over here.
49:13 Speaker 01 We're good, yeah.
49:14 Speaker 02 You know, so there's multiple ways you can read that.
49:16 Speaker 01 Right. Final, this isn't really, well, it is a theory, but it's, it's potentially some evidence, but it is a theory as well. There have been two sets of skeletons, am I correct? Two sets of skeletons found in or around the tower. Some people believe one or the other are the skeletons of the princes in the tower. Discuss.
49:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, okay. So, the first set of skeletons we find, um, come from 1647. They're rebuilding a staircase in the White Tower, and they find a wooden chest 10 feet underground, and it's got- Two skeletons of children that are clearly, clearly children.
50:00 Speaker 01 Okay.
50:00 Speaker 02 Right. Now, come to understand, please, though, this is, this is something to understand. Like, yeah, that's maybe a bit weird. This is also happening during the reign of Charles II. Right. So we have the restoration of the monarchy.
50:11 Speaker 01 We're back on the throne. Yeah.
50:12 Speaker 02 And he's very seriously hoping to be like, ooh, prestige, prestige. Like, isn't it important to have a king? Wouldn't we all agree? You need a tiny spaniel. You need a king.
50:23 Speaker 01 You do lovely black long locks.
50:24 Speaker 02 Yeah, you need to have all of these things, right? And so he, too much, kind of like pomp and circumstance, says these are the princes and they are interred at Westminster Abbey, which is the traditional resting place of many monarchs.
50:40 Speaker 01 I see.
50:40 Speaker 02 Right? So, you know, like, Lizzie Wan is in there, et cetera, et cetera.
50:45 Speaker 01 So he gives them, so, okay, just let's recap on that, just so I have the timeline correct. Did you say 16, they were discovered first in 16?
50:53 Speaker 02 Forty seven.
50:53 Speaker 01 Forty seven. So even before Charles I is beheaded.
50:57 Speaker 02 Yeah.
50:57 Speaker 01 In forty nine, they're discovered, but they kind of just mingle around there while the Republic and the Civil War is all happening.
51:04 Speaker 02 Listen, we had better things to do.
51:06 Speaker 01 Yes, than worry about these two.
51:07 Speaker 02 We were busy doing witch hunts. We were like, we were sliding castles. There was all sorts of things.
51:13 Speaker 01 Knocking Ireland pieces.
51:14 Speaker 02 Listen.
51:15 Speaker 01 Okay, lots going on. As you say, then, Charles II comes back. There is this restoration of the monarchy. They are restored with no new hindrances on their powers, but we have started to see the push forward of Parliament in a new way. And the birth of, in some ways, modern party politics starts to emerge at this time. But in order to still shore up this idea of monarchy, you're saying that what, what he does is, yes, those are the two boys, and now we're gonna infuse them with the regal dignity that they were denied in birth. And it gives me an excuse to have some pomp and circumstance again to.
51:53 Speaker 02 And, oh, aren't I a nice guy? Like, I'm worried about, like, oh, these ancestors. Like, I have, like, these sensitivities, right? It's a nice little bit of propaganda and it costs him nothing.
52:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:06 Speaker 02 Right? Like, for the price of a tomb, you can get all of this.
52:09 Speaker 01 And you can say what you want, because in those days, you're not gonna be looking for DNA. Nobody's gonna be like, and it adds up narratively. It makes sense. We found the skeleton of two children down some stairs in the tower.
52:20 Speaker 02 Voila.
52:20 Speaker 01 Who else could it be?
52:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly.
52:22 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:22 Speaker 02 Yeah. So in 1933, we took another squiz at the bones.
52:26 Speaker 01 Yes.
52:27 Speaker 02 And we seem they're like from around the correct age.
52:30 Speaker 01 Oh, they are.
52:31 Speaker 02 Or so, yeah.
52:31 Speaker 01 So there has been testing done on the, on those ones?
52:33 Speaker 02 Well, the 1933 testing, you know what I'm saying? You know, so like.
52:39 Speaker 01 Somebody smelled them and we're like.
52:40 Speaker 02 And they're like, yeah, it seems like, like. And we haven't done any DNA analysis on them.
52:45 Speaker 01 On the, that set of bones, nothing?
52:47 Speaker 02 No. So it's just kind of like, you know, vibes.
52:49 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:49 Speaker 02 Right place, right time. Charles II said so, you know, whatever.
52:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
52:53 Speaker 02 Yeah.
52:54 Speaker 01 Okay.
52:55 Speaker 02 Now, here's the thing. We got another set of bones.
52:57 Speaker 01 Right. Now, I have been confused around this because yes, there is another set of bones. When are these found?
53:02 Speaker 02 These are found in 1789.
53:05 Speaker 01 Oh, another revolutionary year.
53:07 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
53:08 Speaker 01 Okay.
53:08 Speaker 02 And these are.
53:09 Speaker 01 God, is there just loads of bones of kids hanging around the Tower of London?
53:12 Speaker 02 Listen, these are not from the Tower of London.
53:15 Speaker 01 Oh, where are these?
53:15 Speaker 02 These are from St. George's Chapel in Windsor, which is where Lizzie too is buried.
53:20 Speaker 01 Yes.
53:21 Speaker 02 Yeah.
53:22 Speaker 01 Okay. So they're there.
53:23 Speaker 02 Hmm.
53:24 Speaker 01 So they're saying they were transported or they were moved.
53:26 Speaker 02 Whereas like, that's kind of like, it's, it is one of like the familial resting spots. You know, that is the sort of place that you might go put some bones.
53:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
53:34 Speaker 02 You know, if you're feeling guilty.
53:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, yes.
53:38 Speaker 02 If you're feeling bad about the, you know, yeah.
53:42 Speaker 01 Okay.
53:43 Speaker 02 Yeah. So like that is, that's a place, that's a place. And these are found because like some workmen are doing a job and they accidentally break Edward the Fourth's tomb. And they're like, why are there two coffins of unidentified children in here?
53:56 Speaker 01 Oh, wait, they were in with their dad? Oh, okay. Didn't realize this.
54:02 Speaker 02 That's weird, right?
54:03 Speaker 01 So there's two unidentified, I don't know if they would have been able to tell that they were boys at that particular moment in time.
54:10 Speaker 02 But we got, we got two little skeletons of kids in with Edward the Fourth.
54:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's weird.
54:15 Speaker 02 It's weird.
54:15 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:16 Speaker 02 A little bit weird. Strange.
54:17 Speaker 01 And what do we, do we know anything about that? Was there a confusion?
54:20 Speaker 02 The royal family don't want you to like, think about it. They're like, please, could you just leave these skeletons alone? You're being weird. This is weird.
54:27 Speaker 01 So there's note on those two particular ones?
54:29 Speaker 02 Mm hmm. Mm hmm. So like, this is, the point is like, we're still kind of debating this. And the thing that is sort of like keeping us from doing that is the modern royal family. I would argue correctly is like, Jesus Christ, like leave these remains alone.
54:44 Speaker 01 Yeah.
54:45 Speaker 02 Right? Like for the sake of a mystery, could we just like not?
54:50 Speaker 02 Let these skeletons rest in peace. Right. And so that's where we're at. So maybe there are bodies.
54:57 Speaker 01 Charles William, unlike Eleanor, I am willing to to be part of this testing process because I'm a nosey, nosey person.
55:09 Speaker 02 Anthony's like, do it for the plot.
55:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm like, okay, I get the ethics and I really do. And I get it. You are right. I will admit defeat. I will also admit an insatiable curiosity around trying to know something. But no, I get what you're saying. And you, as I say, you are, you are right. You are on the right side of this. That's compelling to me, though.
55:29 Speaker 02 It's compelled me, though.
55:30 Speaker 01 I was a little bit compelled when you're talking about the two that were found in the tower, but now I'm more.
55:34 Speaker 02 I'm more compelled by those ones.
55:36 Speaker 01 Are you?
55:36 Speaker 02 The ones in the tower, because the tower, it's like all sorts of people were living there.
55:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:42 Speaker 02 For hundreds upon hundreds of years.
55:44 Speaker 01 And loads of people were killed there.
55:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. And it's like, it's weird or like, like, who are these kids buried in with their dad? It's odd.
55:50 Speaker 01 I think I know the answer to this now.
55:52 Speaker 02 Oh.
55:52 Speaker 01 I think I've solved it.
55:53 Speaker 02 Oh, well, okay. So do you want to hear my take?
55:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
55:57 Speaker 02 Okay, look, I don't exactly know, but one thing I do know is them kids dead.
56:02 Speaker 01 Yeah.
56:03 Speaker 02 Okay. And part of what makes me say this, at the very least, is even the version of this where we accept that Perkin Warbeck and Lambert Semnol are the princes.
56:15 Speaker 01 Sure.
56:17 Speaker 02 Involves the boys being smuggled out of the tower in the middle of the night by well wishers.
56:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
56:24 Speaker 02 Okay, here's my thing. When I babysit my nieces and nephews.
56:29 Speaker 01 You've tried to escape with them.
56:31 Speaker 02 No, no one is like, damn, we better get those kids away from Eleanor right now because I fear for their lives. Why? Like, if everything is just like completely copacetic and like completely above board in the Tower of London right now, why are we smuggling kids out of there, homie? Hmm. Like, why do, why do we even need?
56:52 Speaker 01 To think.
56:52 Speaker 02 To do that.
56:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
56:54 Speaker 02 If everything's fine.
56:55 Speaker 01 Oh, that's a good point.
56:56 Speaker 02 This is a key piece of evidence. Like, okay.
56:58 Speaker 01 And very. Almost basic.
57:01 Speaker 02 Yeah.
57:01 Speaker 01 In a good way, I mean.
57:02 Speaker 02 No one, but like, no one talks about that. So it's like, so, you know.
57:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:07 Speaker 02 So why, like smuggling them from what if everything is fine?
57:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:10 Speaker 02 If everything is fine and these kids grew up to be, you know, like leaders of varying rebellions, et cetera, et cetera, why are we smuggling? Like you would just be like, okay, yeah, there they are. And, and also like in to Matt's point about like, what would the kings of Europe have to gain from this? Well, in the first place, they're the kings of Europe, they are the kings of England. They're like kings of England, that's like.
57:32 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:32 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, that's a king. Like they pick a new king every five minutes over there. Like they're like, he's not talking about me.
57:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:39 Speaker 02 Right? Like, and then also a big bunch of the people who are kind of supporting the pretenders. So for example, Perkin Warbeck, he has support from the Dukes of Burgundy, the Duchess's aunt. And the Duchess is like, oh yeah, for real, that's my nephew. She hasn't seen him since he was like three.
57:55 Speaker 01 Okay.
57:55 Speaker 02 You know, and she's also like the richest woman in Europe and people don't like the tutors.
58:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:01 Speaker 02 They don't like the tutors. So it's kind of like, yeah, like it's like, I've got money for that. Like go annoy the tutors. Like that'll be, this is gonna be funny. Let's see what they do. Right? It's just rich people's stuff. It's like rich people's sports.
58:11 Speaker 01 Sure, sure.
58:12 Speaker 02 She's not a queen.
58:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:14 Speaker 02 It actually doesn't call anything into question.
58:16 Speaker 01 But equally, she, she, maybe she sees, look, I'm total conjecture on my part, but like, you say she's not a queen and she's not. And so she's like, yeah, I got the money to do this. But I wonder if she's like, well, if we can put them, put that guy on the throne then, but then if we get some actually legit rich blood in there, we can, we can.
58:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, like then they're beholden to you and that's all.
58:36 Speaker 01 Yeah.
58:37 Speaker 02 Quite fine. I don't know who killed these kids or if they simply died. I think that also like one way I would think about it is perhaps they simply died of neglect.
58:49 Speaker 01 That they just didn't survive the tower.
58:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, they just didn't survive the tower. Maybe they just weren't treated particularly well. This is a common way that royal people die when they are under custody.
59:00 Speaker 01 Oh.
59:01 Speaker 02 Right? Oftentimes they're not out and out murdered. They just die.
59:06 Speaker 01 It just happens.
59:06 Speaker 02 They just die because they're just not being treated very well. These are young kids in an incredibly stressful situation. Their father has just died. Apparently they're going around saying they're in fear for their life. It's the bloody 15th century. If they get a bad cold, they're just gonna fall over and die.
59:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:24 Speaker 02 I actually just think they're not treated particularly well.
59:27 Speaker 01 Okay.
59:28 Speaker 02 That's kind of like my personal pet one. I don't know that anyone went in there and smothered anyone. But I think those kids are dead.
59:39 Speaker 01 I'm gonna agree with you. I'm so sorry, Matt.
59:41 Speaker 02 Matt, you're so wonderful.
59:43 Speaker 01 Now you only need to, now you only need to buy 50 coffees of Queer George.
59:48 Speaker 01 I, I, I agree with you. And you know what has, there are two children in a tomb with Edward the fourth. I think that's what it has to come down to. And one of the reasons why I'm buying into your theory there of whether, whether or not they were killed per se, as opposed to just died, would make sense in that their bodies were somewhat honored by placing them in the tomb with their father. And, and even if they were killed, it's still an honoring of their status, their position, but still going, yeah, I see what you could have been, but I'm gonna, say they were murdered. I am, that has to be them, doesn't it?
1:00:33 Speaker 01 I mean, I don't know, but.
1:00:34 Speaker 02 To me, it seems compelling, right? To me, it seems compelling. And like, listen, I want to be clear. I'm not one of these people who is like, and Richard the third is a really horrible man, bad man, like, let's do all of that. And this is more particularly because I think that all kings are bad. A cap with a K. And I think that fundamentally, the position of royalty is a violent one.
1:00:59 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:00:59 Speaker 02 That is, that is a result of a monopoly on violence. And all kings are terrible people.
1:01:09 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:01:09 Speaker 02 All kings murder dozens, scores of people, whether it's in warfare, or that guy stole a sheep, or you know, what have you. I don't find. The prince is more compelling than any of those ordinary people that we will never hear from.
1:01:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:01:27 Speaker 02 So even were these kids killed, I don't think that makes him necessarily a worse king than anybody else. You know, there are terrible monarchs all over Europe who are doing absolutely abysmal things constantly, and we don't bring it up. And it is, as Matt pointed out, a result of this ridiculous kind of Tudor and Victorian sentimentality that we dwell on the story the way we do. In many ways, I feel about Richard III the same way that I feel about King Stephen. He got there first.
1:01:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, sure, sure.
1:02:00 Speaker 02 And that makes him the king.
1:02:01 Speaker 01 That's the name of the game.
1:02:02 Speaker 02 Exactly.
1:02:03 Speaker 01 Didn't make it to the altar, didn't get the sacrificial, well, not sacrificial, didn't get the consecrational oils or whatever. So it's, yeah, I see, it's a way to be king.
1:02:16 Speaker 02 Yep.
1:02:16 Speaker 01 It's a legitimate way to be king, what he does, what Richard III, well, or if he does, if he does, yeah, sure, exactly. If he does that.
1:02:24 Speaker 02 I don't know, like, I think the only way we're really gonna get closure on this would be if we do DNA analysis on either of these skeletons and it comes up conclusively to be them. Otherwise, there isn't a way to solve this. And I also think that, like, as historians, we have to become comfortable with that. You know, we don't get to have an answer to everything.
1:02:42 Speaker 01 No, we have to meet these stories and histories where they are. They don't need to work for us. Still, though, Charles and William, if you want to.
1:02:50 Speaker 02 Listen.
1:02:51 Speaker 01 Send me a WhatsApp.
1:02:53 Speaker 02 Get at us.
1:02:54 Speaker 01 I'm not a medievalist.
1:02:55 Speaker 02 Sound off in the comments. Can we come over? I just wanna talk.
1:02:59 Speaker 01 I feel like Catherine and I would get on. Now, listen, I think do away with the monarchy. I don't understand it. I'm Irish, obviously, and I do think it's a form of psychosis that monarchy is. That said, I do feel like I get on with Catherine. She has lovely gowns.
1:03:13 Speaker 02 She has really nice gowns, doesn't she?
1:03:15 Speaker 01 I bet you she's good crack. And I know she might not seem in. The work, but I bet you she's good crack. And I feel like I could bring the crack out in her a little bit more.
1:03:23 Speaker 02 Hmm, hmm.
1:03:25 Speaker 01 Like. Based on nothing.
1:03:26 Speaker 02 Okay, come down pub.
1:03:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. That's what I mean. And like, just like, let's sack them all off and we won't go there.
1:03:33 Speaker 02 Listen.
1:03:34 Speaker 01 Go over to the west of Ireland for a while. Just, you know, we don't need to, we don't need to bring all the entourage and everything. I mean, you probably do for your safety, but you'll be grand. It just, I don't know. I don't know. It's, it's, but nonetheless, they remain a compelling institution. Here we are, 2026, and they are headline news still in the same way that this is happening in the 15th century. And so, you know, we're having a lot of conversations right now, and my second book feeds into this, but we have a lot of conversations right now about the survival of the monarchy. I see no clues, despite any personal republican leanings that I might have. I see no clues right now and this day, the 27th of February that we're recording this, 2026, that the institution
1:04:15 Speaker 01 of monarchy is in any real danger. I think we are on the verge of seeing what will look on the surface of it like radical reform in the next generation. But there will be a king after Charles. William will be king unless something, you know, totally unforeseen or catastrophic happens. I don't see it going anywhere.
1:04:37 Speaker 02 I don't think that like any of the current princes are getting knocked off. No.
1:04:41 Speaker 01 No. And if they do, you know where it comes.
1:04:46 Speaker 01 Right. That does solve that one then. People can stop talking about this now.
1:04:50 Speaker 02 Listen, you know, we're fine. We're done.
1:04:52 Speaker 01 Do you wish they would as a medievalist? Are you a bit like, oh, I'm done with that one?
1:04:56 Speaker 02 Well, I guess my thing about it is I don't get it because again, I don't care about kings.
1:05:00 Speaker 01 Okay.
1:05:01 Speaker 02 I like regular people. I think Lambert Seminole is more interesting if he isn't a prince.
1:05:05 Speaker 01 Sure. Well, I mean, that is insane.
1:05:09 Speaker 02 That's my take.
1:05:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:05:11 Speaker 02 So, yeah, like, I mean, I'm, I'm much more interested in everyday people. Again, a cab with a K. All kings are bastards. I don't want to know about them or care about them. And I don't feel the need to.
1:05:24 Speaker 01 Stick up for them because They don't need anyone to stick up for them. They're fine. They're fine. They're absolutely okay. Right. On that, we will leave you to it. Thank you for joining us for this world changing discussion. The medieval You're welcome. The medieval field is now our piece that this mystery has been solved. Those boys are in that tomb with their dad. If you've enjoyed this episode, you could go and actually watch the conversation on YouTube. We have our YouTube channel. Go over there. You can come and see me on my social media channel, Anthony Delaney History. Eleanor, where can they find you? Dr. Eleanor Yanaga. So you can hang out with us there. Leave us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts on both Gone Medieval and After Dark,
1:06:07 Speaker 01 because it helps people find us and discover us and hear more problem solving escapades that we take part in. Write to us at [email protected] . Particularly, do you guys do this Gone Medieval in case Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, you can, you can get us at [email protected] . I see a pattern. It's crazy, isn't it? It's like we work for the same production company. If you have any subjects, topics that you would like us to cover, then you can get in touch on either one of those there. And we will have our producers go through them. They look at them and we talk about them as well. So they may well make it to air. I will let you go. Thank you. Have a good day. Have a good night. Enjoy your workout. Enjoy your day at work, whatever it is you're doing. And we'll see you again soon.
Previous The Human Cost of Fame Next Dark Side of the Celts: Wicker Men and Trophy Heads Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated