Pod Insights After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal Dark Side of the Celts: Wicker Men and Trophy Heads About this episode The Ancient Celts: feared in battle, guided by Druids, and bound together by ritual.
Long before Rome pushed north, Celtic peoples ruled forests, hilltops, and river valleys. But in this episode we'll be discussing the darker aspects of this ancient civilisation...
We are very lucky to be joined by Professor Ronald Hutton as our guest. Ronald is a returning fan favourite having been on numerous episodes of After Dark, including the Origins of Halloween and the Execution of Charles I.
This episode was edited by Hannah Feodorov. Produced by Tomos Delargy. The senior producer was Freddy Chick.
You can now watch After Dark on Youtube! www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit http://www.youtube.com/@afterdarkhistoryhit
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.
You can take part in our listener surveyhere https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/6FFT7MK.
All music from Epidemic Sounds.
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal is a History Hit podcast.
Voting is now open for the Listener's Choice Award at this year's Podcast Awards. Click to place your vote on the Spotify mobile app: https://open.spotify.com/s/xhg6PJa
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello After Darkers, now brace yourselves for a public service announcement.
0:04 Speaker 01 History Hit, the production company behind After Dark, also makes documentaries, and I'm talking beautifully shot, fantastically told, immersive histories on screen. There's hundreds and hundreds available to watch right now, online at historyhit.com, with a new release each week.
0:20 Speaker 00 There's a lot to digest there, but guys, take a deep breath because there is more. Antony and I have made two new History Hit TV documentaries. I have recently made one about London's most notorious haunting, the Cock Lane Ghost, based on my new book Hoax, that is releasing for Halloween.
0:36 Speaker 01 And I've got one following that, about the Great Irish Famine, which is coming soon.
0:41 Speaker 00 To see what's on offer and to subscribe, visit historyhit.com/subscribe to start exploring the past.
0:54 Speaker 01 The ancient Celts, a patchwork of tribes that spread across Europe, feared in battle, guided by Druids and bound together by ritual. Long before Rome pushed north, Celtic peoples ruled forests, hilltops and river valleys. They built fortified settlements, forged weapons of iron and lived in a world where warfare and worship were inseparable. To the Celts, power was not political, it was spiritual.
1:46 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to After Dark. I'm Antony and, as you may have noticed, I am Maddieless and have been for the last few episodes and will be for a short time to come yet because she is trekking in the Andes on discovery missions that will change the world. But until then, you have me and a plethora of incredible guests to navigate the historical terrain that we're about to discover today. And in this episode, we will be talking about... About the dark side of the Celts, the rituals, the violence and the dangers that shaped these ancient societies. And who would we rather have to help us navigate that particular terrain than Professor Ronald Hutton? Who is, of course, a returning guest and a fan favourite.
2:27 Speaker 01 And Professor Hutton is at the University of Bristol and specialises in early modern Britain, British folklore, pre-Christian religion and modern paganism. Professor Hutton, welcome back to After Dark.
2:41 Speaker 02 Thank you very much. I am a bit of a plethora. It's delightful to be one.
2:46 Speaker 01 It is. This is a really interesting one for me, right? Because we're going to be talking about the Celts. And somebody had the nerve to say about middle aged Celts earlier. And I don't know if I quite fit that category just yet, but we're not too far from it. Yeah, yeah, just about. But this is something culturally that that we in Ireland grow up with. This idea of our Celtic, you know, DNA, our background. It is something that we we carry with us. But actually, I often wonder if we know what we're really carrying with us and actually how much Celt we are. So that's part of what we're going to to get into today. But the first question I want to ask you is the most broad question.
3:28 Speaker 01 So we can start from a very broad vantage point. And that is, who were the ancient Celts?
3:36 Speaker 02 Anthony Mochi, be a Celt.
3:39 Speaker 01 I will.
3:40 Speaker 02 Be bold, be brave, be confident as a Celt. The problem is that the term Celtic was used by the mid 20th century for three different things, which only overlap. They weren't the same and they came from different periods. There's an ethnic connotation in that the Greeks and Romans used the word Celts vaguely for people living north of the Alps. But they couldn't quite agree on who up there were Celts. The only thing they seem to have agreed upon is that anybody from what's now the British Isles were not Celts. There's also a term used for language groups, the Celtic languages, which was coined
4:23 Speaker 02 by Welshmen at the end of the 17th century. And finally, it's used for a style of curvy lupi art.
4:31 Speaker 01 Yes.
4:32 Speaker 02 And that's
4:33 Speaker 01 Tattoos.
4:34 Speaker 02 That's a 19th century coinage.
4:38 Speaker 01 So there's this, there's layers of what to be a Celt and what, what has Celtic links means. You spoke there about the kind of geographical elements. You talked about there being a kind of a religious or a decorative element to it as well, all of these things. But am I right in saying that today where we find claims of Celtic ancestry is mainly in Ireland, obviously Wales, in Scotland, and then in the Cornish people and the Manx people as well. And then in Brittany, right? Is that the main geographical location of where people are claiming Celtic descent today?
5:20 Speaker 02 You've collected the lot of Celts in that
5:24 Speaker 01 A collection of Celts.
5:25 Speaker 02 Yes. Some people would admit the, the people of North West Spain, the Gallicians, to the family, but they themselves are dubious about their identity in this regard. Archetypically, after about 30 years of recent argument between academics, we can reach something like a new consensus that the term Celtic can be applied resolutely to peoples who speak what we call the Celtic languages. And they are exactly the people who think of themselves and be thought of as Celts in the modern world. And they have a continuous
6:06 Speaker 02 identity of such and history from the Middle Ages onwards, from the early Middle Ages. The big problem is that largely, I say largely, there are some holdouts against this, but they tend not to be in Britain, or indeed even in Ireland. But the holdouts are against the revision of a cultural package that got put together in the minds of academics in the early 20th century. It is not older than that. There'd still be people alive when the package was ditched, who were born when it was taking shape.
6:46 Speaker 02 And this is to see a unified ethnic group, the Celts, around two thousand, three thousand years ago, stretching across Europe from Ireland, Turkey, and taking in the whole of what's now France and Southern Journey, Austria, and other lands on the way, including northern Italy.
7:10 Speaker 02 And they were seen as having common languages, common art style, common culture.
7:17 Speaker 02 This, this has been abandoned.
7:19 Speaker 01 Right.
7:19 Speaker 02 It really doesn't hang together. You can see, if you like, a kind of rainbow, a spectrum of cultures stretching across that area before the Romans conquered most of it. But it's not a unified ethnic and linguistic group, or even a cultural group. So, on the whole, we've tended to scrap the term Celts for that.
7:47 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:47 Speaker 02 And people still speak of Celtic art, but we now realise that a lot of other art at the time is displaying the same features.
7:56 Speaker 01 Right.
7:57 Speaker 02 And therefore, there is absolutely no doubt that the term Celtic is appropriate for a group of languages, simply because it's been used for so long. And it's a precise definition. And then it can embody the tremendous cultural identity and gifts to the world of the Celtic-speaking peoples since the early Middle Ages, often under acute pressure from other peoples, Germanic or Romance-speaking peoples, above all the British and the French. And their ability to preserve their identity as themselves through such a history, which
8:39 Speaker 02 at very best is one of relentless cultural pressure, and at the very worst is one of horrific persecution in places and times approaching genocide. So, the Celts of the present day can wear their Celticity with pride.
8:56 Speaker 01 Celticity, that's right.
8:57 Speaker 02 And have in a good one and a half millennia of continuous existence and identity behind them. The problem is only if you try and stretch across most of Europe over two thousand years ago.
9:12 Speaker 01 Now, you talked about this idea of persistence and the Celtic people overcoming, persisting, enduring despite some of these incursions that have happened over, over different millennia. One of the things that I want to feed into here then is, is whether or not the, one of the ways in which this survival has endured is because of a stereotype that is linked to cultures of violence when we hear about the Celts. I can conjure up an image in my head of somebody with wild hair, half painted, blue face and, you know,
9:51 Speaker 01 almost naked, charging at a group of far more civilized invaders. How real is that when we talk about Celtic peoples? Let's say in the, in the Atlantic Archipelago or the former British Isles.
10:05 Speaker 02 The stereotype of the Celt in modern times is not really linked to violence so much as unruliness. After all, the kind of violence disposed of by the Roman legions was sensational, acute, catastrophic, that they could slaughter people in huge numbers. But they marched in step, they were mechanically equipped. And so they look far more akin to modern industrial warfare than the primeval. So by contrast, we see the, the peoples whom the Romans and Greeks described as Celts, which is a kind of short term for anybody
10:49 Speaker 02 whom they haven't yet conquered, living north of the Alps, is they are emotional, ungoverned, unruly, can't even comb their hair, paint themselves odd colours, run into battle naked. We can unpack, you know, all of those particular labels. It's a, it's a, it's an ethnic stereotype.
11:13 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:14 Speaker 02 Produced by hostile peoples. But it gets a new lease of life under the Victorians. And I'll, I'll especially finger Matthew Arnold here, who was so brilliant at getting everybody to believe it, that he was actually trying to get the Victorian.
11:35 Speaker 02 English and Scots, Lowland Scots, to take the Celtic-speaking peoples and their descendants seriously, not to disparage them.
11:43 Speaker 01 Right.
11:43 Speaker 02 By saying it's a partnership of peoples. And what the English and the Lowland Scots, the Germanic peoples, remember Lowland Scots speak a Germanic language, squats, breed squats. Is they're good at maths, sciences, building, rationality, structured government, taxation, welfare. And what the Celts are, who are kind of unreasonable, undisciplined, unorganisable, is they're really, really good at art and literature. They live with their emotions, they live close to nature, they reconnect the urbanised, industrialised, Germanic peoples with their natural roots and their imaginative life.
12:28 Speaker 02 Without them, the Germanic peoples would die imaginatively, creatively. So the moody, emotional, creative Celt is absolutely essential to civilisation in the British family of peoples. But of course, it does mean they can't rule themselves.
12:47 Speaker 01 Funny that, isn't it?
12:49 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, there has to be a payoff here for a Brit.
12:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, I'm suddenly feeling more moody, dramatic, artistic Celt is suddenly feeling far more my lane of Celticism than potentially any kind of warrior Celticism.
13:03 Speaker 02 I, by the way, am half Slav.
13:06 Speaker 01 Ah.
13:07 Speaker 02 And the Germanic peoples have actually parodied the Slavs in just the same way, you know, emotional, undisciplined, can't rule themselves, that sort of thing.
13:16 Speaker 01 Oh, that's so interesting. Yeah, it's that they can't be trusted with their own, with the outcome of their own civilizations.
13:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, but aren't they wonderful?
13:24 Speaker 01 But they're lovely, they're great for a poem. Tell me this then, in this melee of different things coming together to form these peoples, depending on where we're encountering them, there is one thing that I have encountered again and again, which is, I'm not sure how realistic this was across Celtic peoples or whether it was very specific to Wales, I think. This idea of the cult of the severed head, or actually possibly more specifically the skull, is that really something that we see preserved archaeologically?
14:02 Speaker 02 The question of the cult of the severed head in Iron Age North West Europe is a vexed one. Because on the one hand, the idea of it comes very specifically from one rather wonderful person, somebody who was not actually an academic, but who was a foundationally great scholar. And that's Anne Ross, who wrote this breathtakingly good book, Pagan Celtic Britain. It was good for its time, which was the 60s, the late 60s. And it was she who had the idea that the Celts, which in her day were still believed
14:45 Speaker 02 to be a confederacy of peoples all related, stretching across Europe, had a cult of the head severed or otherwise.
14:58 Speaker 02 And this is still possible because heads are important in Celtic art. And you do find skulls preserved in various ritual structures from the Iron Age.
15:15 Speaker 02 But you also find long bones, thigh and arm bones, preserved in the same context. It isn't just skulls. And Anne was particularly keen on a particularly large collection of stone heads, carved stone heads, which are found over England and in bits of Wales, and which were dated vaguely to the Iron Age at that time. Problem there is they are now, most of them, conclusively dated to the 16th, 17th centuries. Although they may have had a ritual function then in being protective. On the other hand, they also had a humorous function.
16:00 Speaker 02 For example, quite a number of them have a hole drilled in the corner or the centre of the mouth. And back in Ann's day, it was thought this was for libations of mead or beer to feed the deity of whom this was an image. And we're now pretty sure that these were receptacles for clay pipes.
16:21 Speaker 01 Perfect.
16:22 Speaker 02 And people would then throw balls to try and knock the pipe out. So an awful edifice of belief bites the dust.
16:30 Speaker 01 Yes, yes.
16:30 Speaker 02 With the redating. The remaining heads, most of them are simply undated. They may be Iron Age, but they may not be. So we're left with the skulls and the bones. And because there are bones as well as skulls in a lot of Iron Age deposits, it's not a particular cult of the head. But also heads remain pretty common. And this could be because there was something sacred about them, the repository of wisdom, of life. Or it could be simply that some peoples in northwestern Europe collected them as trophies.
17:07 Speaker 02 And we do have a literary source, Posidonius, a Greek traveller who turned what's now France, it was then Gaul. A few hundred years before the Christian common era. And he said that over the southern two thirds of what's now France. The tribes would collect the heads of their unsuccessful enemies and preserve them in vats of oil. And they'd bring them out at dinner parties to display to their guests, you know, like family china or.
17:41 Speaker 01 Games night.
17:41 Speaker 02 Yes, that's exactly right. But we don't know which is which, whether there's any sacred significance, or this is because of headhunting. There is a display, an intimidation factor here, as well as pride and family heirlooms of deceased enemies. When a hillfort at Breeden Hill, which is the hill that sticks out of the area of the M5 between Tewksbury and Worcester on the right-hand side, there's a fort on there from the Iron Age, and it had timber gates which crashed in flames about 100 years before
18:22 Speaker 02 the Common Era, carrying with them the severed heads who'd been stuck on the pointed tops of the gate timbers.
18:29 Speaker 01 Right.
18:29 Speaker 02 Which is fairly clearly a kind of welcome to would-be enemies, showing what's going to happen to them.
18:45 Speaker 01 Terry Cottle died by suicide, but his heart lived on, transplanted into Sonny Graham. Years later, Sonny died the exact same way, same heart, same fate. But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. Sonny also married Terry's widow. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff, this is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. New episodes are available Mondays, and Apple TV subscribers get special early access to the entire season. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
19:27 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt, and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to Conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hits. There are new episodes every week.
20:23 Speaker 01 It's interesting, isn't it? Because as you're describing that, Ronald, it really strikes me, you know, that heads are being displayed, as you're hinting there, in the all throughout the early modern period in very similar ways, in that kind of deterrent, or this is an example of what might happen to you. And we never really say, in that case, oh, they had the cult of the severed head. But it's that idea that because we don't necessarily know, or because there are some gaps to fill in, that we've slightly mythologized some of that practice in terms of what they might have been doing. So I find that really interesting. But speaking of mythologies that are coming into these
21:03 Speaker 01 peoples and these cultures, Druids. How are Druids Celts? Is this a sect within Celticism? Is this a totally separate group of people? What is the intersection and what's the relationship between Celticism or the Celtic people and Druids?
21:24 Speaker 02 The Druids are a point at which the ancient idea of Celts and the sustained and respectable idea of Celts as people speaking Celtic languages and having cultures that evolved since the Middle Ages, they come into one here. Because Druid is simply the term used by people speaking Celtic languages for a specialist in religion and/or magic.
21:54 Speaker 01 I see.
21:54 Speaker 02 But it's very broadly defined. So in the Roman descriptions of pre-Roman Gaul, well, that's now France, which the Romans conquered. The Druids are a highly trained and organised supra-tribal priesthood, who take twenty years of education and have a common meeting altogether in the centre of Gaul, irrespective of their tribes, and are regarded as very powerful and very wise. We don't know if any of this is true. It all comes from one commentator, Caesar, or possibly from some unknown person finishing Caesar's book after Caesar got knifed.
22:38 Speaker 02 Whereas in medieval Irish literature, Druid is simply a term for anybody who's working magic. Now, there are full-time magicians, who are therefore full-time Druids, and they're very important. But anybody who works magic seems to become a Druid at the time at which they're working magic. The rest of the time, they're a blacksmith, or a poet, or a king, or something else. So it's a lot more porous. And I think it's quite important not to impose Caesar's, or pseudo Caesar's, possibly bogus picture of an Iron Age Gaelic, Gaulish society
23:19 Speaker 02 upon Ireland, or vice versa, not to mix the two together in one big melting pot and produce a composite picture of Druids that may never have existed across the whole Celtic world.
23:32 Speaker 01 And do we know what types of practice, or what types of magic they are engaging in? Is this land-based? Is this seasonal-based? Is it something that they're trying to control the area around them? Is it healing? Is it all of the above? Are we left with any proof as to what they're doing there?
23:53 Speaker 02 The record is disappointingly barren of actual records of Druid rituals or spells. In fact, the main one we have is from the destruction of Dardagus Hostel, which is one of the most stunning Irish medieval stories. And it's a write called the Tarvish, the Bull Dream, which describes- How they they say a man, but we take this as being a druid. Because the context, when you want to get a vision, in this case to choose the next king. Uh, you sacrifice or just kill a white bull.
24:33 Speaker 02 And then you get the man concerned to gorge upon a kind of Irish stew. Uh, without the potatoes of the meat. And having bloated himself, uh, then go to sleep on the hide of the bull. And he will then have a dream and that dream will be prophetic to identify the new king. Uh, it all sounds very convincing, being medieval Irish literature, we have no idea. Whether this is an authentic memory of a Druidic ritual, which it might well be. Or whether it's just a bright idea on the part of the fillet, the olive. Uh, the bard who was composing that particular tale.
25:15 Speaker 01 It's tantalizing in a way because I remember those stories. Growing up about the the lying and the the remnants of the bull and that they were definitely around just as kind of oral tradition. But we were definitely talking around those topics in school. Another thing that I recognize from the Druid. Uh, practice is this idea of, I, uh, when I saw this, I went, that can't be right. But the idea of the wicker man and what is potentially happening there and and it's. This large, well, supposedly this large wicker statue in which. The Druids would sacrifice humans and animals for burning now.
26:00 Speaker 01 This is coming from somebody you've already warned us about Ronald, which is of course Julius Caesar or somebody adjacent to him. And and in that it says, there were figures of vast size, the limbs of which formed of ossiers. They fill with living men, which being set on fire, the men perish, enveloped in the flames. And he frames the ritual as within broader sacrificial belief, saying Gauls.
26:27 Speaker 01 Think that unless the life of a man be offered for the life of a man, the mind of the immortal gods cannot be rendered propitious. So how skeptical should we be of this particular, this particular description that's left to us by Julius Caesar or Caesar adjacent?
26:47 Speaker 02 We can be pretty skeptical about the ancient descriptions of the Wiccan man. And we can also trace a complete and straightforward descent from Julius Caesar, or at least Caesar's book, and Christopher Lee and Drag
27:07 Speaker 02 in the nineteen seventies movie.
27:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
27:11 Speaker 02 Caesar actually conquered Gaul, so he would have encountered its native peoples in their pre-Roman condition and been pretty reliable. But the description of the Wiccan man, as we call it, in Caesar's description of Gaul is in a self-contained section that doesn't sound like the style of the rest of the book.
27:36 Speaker 01 Hmm.
27:37 Speaker 02 And actually, what Caesar says in the rest of the book is sometimes contradicted by this passage and vice versa. So it looks like an insertion. And we know that Caesar never actually finished the book, the Gallic War. It was completed after his death by another writer who hadn't accompanied Caesar to Gaul. And so there's a possibility that the writer concerned decided to liven up Caesar's narrative by inserting this description of Gaul based upon less reliable sources. So what looks like an eyewitness account of a culture may be nothing of the kind.
28:20 Speaker 02 And there are later references to human sacrifices conducted by Druids, one of which includes the the Wiccan man motif. In writers a bit later, Dioldras Siculus Strabo, they're Greek writers who never went near Gaul. And indeed, the description of the wicker man may have been taken from Caesar. Or pseudo Caesar. So the evidence is distinctly suspect. But it not only was taken as gospel by everybody who was impressed by the Romans, which was practically everybody in Europe until the 20th century, or even the late 20th century.
29:06 Speaker 02 But also by Christians, to whom the idea of pagan priests as being dyed to the elbows in human sacrifice was a traditional motif.
29:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
29:20 Speaker 02 And that's why the wicker man became very popular, became very popular in particular because of one bestseller, which was A History of Britain, produced by a lawyer called Islet Sams, who's pretty well forgotten now, in the 1670s. And the great thing about it was it was illustrated. Really great pictures. And one of the pictures was of the wicker man. And every time you see a picture of the wicker man now on a tea towel, I have one, or reproduced in books, and as you see it in the film, The Wicker Man, it's taken from this illustration to Islet Sam's book.
30:03 Speaker 02 So, you know, a picture, it says, is worth a thousand words, and certainly in impact, this particular picture proves that truth.
30:13 Speaker 01 Well, I have an image that was a perfect segue into this part for me, Ronald, because I've got a picture of an 18th century illustration from A Tour in Wales, written by Thomas Pennant. And without a doubt, this is also influenced by your late 17th century image that you're talking about. And I'll just describe it here for listeners, and we'll put this on the YouTube and on social media as well. But we have a very giant figure with a very human face, actually, very, very human face, probably, what, five times the size of the other humans, well, not others, because this isn't a human, but the humans depicted in this image. And it is gigantic. It is, it is probably about four or five people, an arm is about four or five people
30:58 Speaker 01 wide, and the body looks like.
31:02 Speaker 01 A cage, for all intents and purposes. Obviously, we know it's made from wicker, or we're being told in this image that it is. And it is stuffed, and that's the only word I can use, really. Stuffed with people, squirming, wriggling, there's arms and legs protruding from the cage that they're held in. Then down on the bottom, there is a man who looks like he is trying to run away as quickly as he possibly can, because he is setting light to the right hand foot, which of course then will engulf the whole thing. And then looking on, we have scantily clad women, we have religious figures, someone
31:41 Speaker 01 who looks quite druidic, actually. And it is a very arresting, very arresting image, but it's interesting how long and how deep these ideas go. But it also speaks to this idea that you talked about at the top, Ronald, about the brutality that other civilizations almost insisted that the Celts and the Druids had to have had, and that, you know, we are more civilized than this, we would never do this. It's rather, it's pretty gruesome.
32:20 Speaker 02 Does the illustration, which you've just described, have in one of the two feet a trapdoor still open with somebody being stuffed in?
32:29 Speaker 01 Yes.
32:30 Speaker 02 You're looking at Islet Sam's illustration.
32:33 Speaker 01 Right, this is where it's coming from. Yes, there's a little ladder up into the, into a door that's still open, where people have just gone in. Yeah, absolutely, they're being fed into it to meet their darkened doom. Let's talk a little bit about the Irish-Celtic tradition then, specifically.
32:54 Speaker 01 Because I want to talk about the fact that this is somewhat different than the Celtic tradition in mainland Britain, because the Romans never invade Ireland and it's also then some of these traditions are encapsulated in the Tuatadi, which is written in approximately the 11th century, but has much, much older oral storytelling roots. I want to turn to Morrigan specifically, a potentially dark figure. Can you explain to us who she is for people who may not know?
33:26 Speaker 02 I'll explain with delight who the Morrigan is. We're friends.
33:31 Speaker 01 We are.
33:31 Speaker 02 We have a relationship, she and I.
33:33 Speaker 01 Yeah.
33:35 Speaker 02 She is the very best known, especially at the present day, of the Irish war goddesses. But there are quite a number of them. In fact, there are over 40 names in the tales, although we can relax a bit because only five of them are named regularly. And indeed, only one more is named more than once. The others have names that are well-known to experts in medieval Irish literature, where they appear as frequently as the Morrigan. But they tend to be forgotten now by the public, because the Morrigan has other dimensions
34:19 Speaker 02 that the other war goddesses lack. Because all the other war goddesses do is incite slaughter, prophecy slaughter, and enjoy slaughter. They start trouble as well as really enjoying it. Whereas the Morrigan does more things than that. She is a prophetess of great things in general, including the good times, the bad times, and the end of the world. She is amorous. She mates with the Dachter, the good god, and enjoys it so much. They've already met. This is a date. She's ready for him when he turns up. And she enjoys it so
35:03 Speaker 02 much that, inspired by this, she then goes off and murders the king of an opposing army in order to give the people of the Dachter, who are also her own people, but kind of more important, the Dachter, the ability to win a major battle. And also, she propositions the Ulster hero par excellence, Cuthrin, Cuthrin being a brat, a moody late adolescent.
35:30 Speaker 01 With a hurley.
35:31 Speaker 02 Yes, with a sideline in homicide.
35:34 Speaker 01 Yes.
35:35 Speaker 02 No, actually, a central profession in homicide, rudely rejects her. Cuthrin rudely rejects most propositions.
35:43 Speaker 01 Yes.
35:44 Speaker 02 And she then attempts to get vengeance by killing him, and he beats her off. But she also looks after people. She helps a druid win his sweetheart in one minor story. In other stories, she actually gets married to the Dachter. They settle down in the Bruna Boina, and they have a family. It all sounds quite domestic. You have medieval place names like the Morrigan's Half.
36:16 Speaker 01 Yeah.
36:17 Speaker 02 And the Morrigan's Cooking Pot. You know, the Morrigan at Home.
36:20 Speaker 01 Yes, yeah, yeah. What is that? Yeah.
36:23 Speaker 02 Yes. And she gives luck to people. She gives them victory.
36:28 Speaker 01 I think that's how I would know her most. That's what her legacy is to me mostly, is a luck thing, yeah.
36:34 Speaker 02 Yes. So if you want to strip it down to its essentials. Really, what most of the other war goddesses do, what all of the other war goddesses do, is mostly spread panic.
36:45 Speaker 01 Yes.
36:45 Speaker 02 They make a hundred warriors die of fright by flying above their camp and screaming at night. They enjoy watching people suffer and die, whereas the Morrigan gives the opposite panic, least instead, or maybe as well, which is the riastra, the battle frenzy, when warriors lose their fear completely and give themselves up to combat. Now, this is not unique. I think she's a, the extreme northwestern corner. Yeah, the, not a, northwestern corner, of a complex of similar goddesses.
37:25 Speaker 01 Right.
37:25 Speaker 02 Who are found across Europe. The Norse one is Freya. The Roman one is Venus. The Greek one, not so much on the war side, but it's there, is Aphrodite. But spectacularly, Inanna, alias Ishtar, in the Near East. And probably Anatastati, Ashtat, in Syria. What they all do is, rather counterintuitively to any modern hippie, they combine a sponsorship of war with a sponsorship of love.
38:00 Speaker 01 Yes.
38:00 Speaker 02 And sex. And although nobody ever spells out why, everyone just knew, so nobody explained it. There is a similarity, because both combat, which in those days is really single combat, all over the battlefield, and lovemaking are a dramatic engagement of bodies, which engage with vital fluids, and in which people lose themselves.
38:26 Speaker 01 Yes.
38:27 Speaker 02 They lose reason, they lose control. And so they may come from the same source, the ecstasy of sex and of the passion of love.
38:53 Speaker 03 Land a Viking longship on island shores, scramble over the dunes of ancient Egypt, and avoid the Poisoner's Cup in Renaissance Florence. Each week on Echoes of History, we uncover the epic stories that inspire Assassin's Creed. We're stepping into feudal Japan in our special series Chasing Shadows, where samurai warlords and shinobi spies teach us the tactics and skills needed not only to survive, but to conquer. Whether you're preparing for Assassin's Creed: Shadows or fascinated by history and great stories, listen to Echoes of History, a Ubisoft podcast brought to you by History Hit. There are new episodes every week.
39:47 Speaker 01 This is one of the ways in which we still hear about the Morrigan, I suppose, is because of the ways in which I'm talking about the Romans never conquered Ireland and so therefore certain things endure in different ways. But just to balance that out, Ronald, I wonder what the impact of Roman conquest is on the culture outside of Ireland? How immediate is that felt? That Roman presence felt?
40:16 Speaker 02 The Roman presence takes time to seep into a culture, but the Romans have got a lot of that.
40:24 Speaker 02 Hundreds of years. And you can see it in the archaeology. And it still presents us with a moral problem in Britain at the present day. Because for the first 200 years of Roman Britain, once you get away from the towns and the forts into the countryside, which is where 98% of people live, it's an Iron Age culture. You don't have anything Roman about at all. People are now being taxed and they're produce and they're disarmed, but they're just doing what they've done for a thousand years in the same way. When you come to the third or fourth centuries, particularly
41:05 Speaker 02 the fourth, it's changed. On the typical farmstead, you'll find Roman pottery, Roman utensils and Roman money. I mean, like, small denomination copper coins, but they're all there. So even the rural Brits have got thoroughly Romanised.
41:22 Speaker 01 Yes.
41:23 Speaker 02 And that, of course, at the present day, provides what would be a dilemma for novelists, playwrights, artists, if the two ever met from the, say, the different bits of Roman Britain. Because if you're looking at the first century, then the Romans are the villainous invaders. It's Carac Tarkas. Above all, it's Boudicca, you know, the kind of o'er-British feminist, who are the figures with whom we sympathise. And the Romans are jackbooting their way onto our shores and building horrible new towns with dead straight new roads between them. Any protester would recognise a target there. And establishing
42:07 Speaker 02 a uniform tyranny. In the words of the Scotsman Calgarcus, who may or may not, and which may or may not have been invented by a Roman, the Romans created a desert and called it peace. But flip on 300 years, or 400 years, and it's Roman Britain, which is the civilised, Christian, safe, familiar area. It's the Anglo Saxons, who are the verminous, harsute, heathen warriors, coming over to rape and pillage and destroy and enslave. And it's characters like Arthur.
42:47 Speaker 02 Who are, and Aurelius and Euther Pendragon, who are the defenders of Britain.
42:53 Speaker 02 The sympathetic figures. It's a, it's a schizophrenia in our attitudes, the Romans, which reflects a reality of a non-Romanised and thoroughly Romanised Roman Britain.
43:06 Speaker 01 That's interesting. Do you think that legacy of a Romanised Britain then is more with us in everyday life today than potentially the Celtic Britain that we've been talking about? Or do you think we have a strange mashup of the two things side by side here? How, because sometimes I think it's way more blatant in Ireland and Scotland. And even when we're talking about language and that's going through such a huge revival in Ireland. Anyway, I can't speak to Scotland, but I think it might be the same. But the language is really making a comeback as we try to re-establish 100-plus years now after Ireland was, was,
43:46 Speaker 01 it was no longer part of the British Empire. The language is now finding its feet again as it did at the end of the 19th century. Is it the Roman-ness that distinguishes Englishness from the current ideas of Englishness from those earlier Celtic iterations? Or is it just because history's difficult, right? And it all melds together. But, but how present, I suppose, is what I'm asking. How present is the Roman influence even today?
44:14 Speaker 02 History is difficult, but we should share its challenges. In one sense, Ireland is Romanised at the present day. Because if you walk through the streets of Dublin, you're looking at classical buildings, the Roman style. You're looking at columns on which national heroes stand. You're looking at sculptures of mythical beings or historic beings, Mother Liffey, Anna Liffey. Uh, and people who are commemorated, this, this is a Roman style.
44:50 Speaker 01 Yeah.
44:50 Speaker 02 And indeed, yeah, every time Ireland, or indeed anywhere in Europe goes urban, it Romanizes.
44:55 Speaker 01 Yes.
44:56 Speaker 02 So we're all Romans in that sense. Uh, but Celticity is at the heart of Irishness. And the more of it there is, and the more attractive Ireland, Gallic Scotland, Wales, Cornwall, Brittany, become to everybody else. You know, Gorma, Llama, Huggatt, yeah, you're doing a grand job.
45:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, I can't take personal, um, I can't take personal responsibility. I do love a rule, as it so happens. But this idea of, of the unruly Celt, there is something to be said for it, right?
45:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, a lot of the British and the Germanic peoples of Europe are Celts when they're on holiday.
45:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, around a pool when they want to get the, uh, the lounger closest to the pool. Yeah. Suddenly they, they embrace their Celtic past. It's an interesting one, Ronald. It's, it's interesting how these things bleed through and how the mythology goes on to inform what is either factual or what we want to believe. I was reading somewhere, no, I was watching somewhere recently that there was this idea that Celtic Ireland was a utopia for women, for instance. And there was this great historian online going, that really wasn't the case because they were trying to compare the idea of, of pre-colonized Ireland being this liberal, incredible place. But, but the, the research she had done just didn't bear that, that out,
46:18 Speaker 01 that it actually was quite an oppressive place for women even then. And, and so I just wonder, as a way to depart from this, to what extent, in terms of that unruliness that we're talking about, to what extent does dream making, and we spoke about this when we talked about prehistoric Britain as well, but does dream making fill in some of these gaps of Celticism? And actually, how appropriate is that in terms of what we do know about Celtic tradition?
46:51 Speaker 02 There is a particular magic, and I'm choosing the word deliberately, about medieval Celtic literature. It goes to places and it does things which other medieval literatures don't. Although there are there are overlaps, you know, the French romances of the 12th century are full of glittering glamorous magical human-like but non-human beings called fae who correspond pretty well completely to Arthur D. Dunan in the Irish literature at the same age. But I'm taking a punt here because I don't think anybody has articulated this before.
47:35 Speaker 02 But I would go further than people have done hitherto to suggest that the Irish and Welsh, and therefore possibly the Celtic cultures, have a different attitude to magic. That if you look at the literatures, it's kind of a neutral force which deities use in Ireland and humans can use, and it's totally respectable for them to do it. And if they use it in a hostile way, then it's up to their opponents to deploy it against them. So you'll get your druids to curse each other if it's a political matter. Otherwise, in a private matter, you curse back.
48:20 Speaker 02 Whereas the other peoples of Europe, and it's pretty much a sellout, the Greeks, the Romans, the Germans, the Scandinavians, have an intense suspicion of magic as something furtive, antisocial, suspect, cheating. It's used by the bad guys.
48:39 Speaker 01 Yes.
48:39 Speaker 02 In stories. In Ireland, it's not. It's used by good and bad guys. And really, it's all morally equivalent. It's just that it is used by villainous characters. It's used for bad purposes. And I think that is a genuine difference. And it's not just the Celtic-speaking peoples.
49:00 Speaker 02 As we define them now, it's the Egyptians. I don't think there's any connection between the two, but in Egypt likewise, magic was seen as a neutral force, heka, which kept the world going. And gods use it every day to be divine. It's how they operate the cosmos. But humans can learn it too. And if they're really, really good, they become gods.
49:23 Speaker 01 Wow.
49:24 Speaker 02 And if you want to hex somebody, you just do it. And if you feel you're being hexed, you either hex back or you go to a professional in the temple to do the hexing for you. There's no such thing as witchcraft in ancient Egypt, to find in the negative sense. And there's not much of it in the Celtic speaking peoples either, which is why when the notorious witch hunts of the early modern period, 16th, 17th centuries, come along, they're almost missing from all the Celtic speaking areas.
49:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, we don't have them in the same way in Ireland at all.
50:03 Speaker 02 You have them in Ireland among Scottish and English settler communities.
50:07 Speaker 01 Yes, yeah.
50:09 Speaker 02 And you have them in Wales, in the more English influenced areas, but hardly what it's in its five executions.
50:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
50:18 Speaker 02 Not all of which may be carried out in the whole of early modern Wales. The Isle of Man is the same. They have one execution that horrifies them so much, they never try it again. And the witch trials are pretty well missing from the vast area of Highlands and Western Isles, Scotland. But in the Northern Isles, which are geographically about the same, and very close to the Highlands, you have a Norse culture, Scandinavian settlement, and they're appalling the intense areas for witch hunting, just like Norway, Denmark.
50:56 Speaker 02 Sweden.
50:57 Speaker 01 You're finding them there.
50:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
50:59 Speaker 01 Well, I am off to reconnect with my Celtic magic roots for the afternoon. Well, I'm not, I'm away to give a talk, actually, it's far less glamorous than that. But either way, that's been so interesting in terms of how we are framing national identities today, Ronald, and thank you for bringing some of those points to After Dark. We have a few other episodes that you may remember that we had Ronald on, and that, of course, was Histories from the Early Modern Period, when we're talking about the execution of Charles I. We also spoke to Ronald about the origins of Halloween and the history that, as we can see, they're tying in to some of the things we talked about today. So if you haven't listened to those episodes, do go back through the back catalogue,
51:41 Speaker 01 listen to them and learn about those different parts of history as well. Thank you, as ever, for joining us on YouTube or on the podcast. And you can get in touch with us, of course, as ever, on After Dark by sending an email to [email protected] , where you can, of course, suggest a topic for a future episode. So do send those in, we do look at them and we do start to try and work them into the programme as we can. Thank you for listening and until next time, happy listening.
Previous Were the Princes in the Tower murdered? Next Britain's First Ghost Hunt Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated